Popcorn

Popcorn was an excellent exploration of anxiety and OCD as experienced by a young middle school boy. It follows him over the course of one day, and includes some funny cartoons - which I found illustrated the way that anxiety feels in a fun and yet informative manner. As someone who doesn't have anxiety, I felt that this book enabled me to experience the range of emotions, from nerves to a full blown panic attack through the protagonists eyes.

Erin

Portland Readers

This is a test review.

Mackenzie Test

CILIP Test 1

Popcorn was an amazing book to read. It had many funny moments whilst also having some moments that were a lot less funny. I really enjoyed the different cartoons scattered around the book. This is a great read as it can be relatable for people with or even without anxiety at some parts. I also think that the analogy of anxiety being like popcorn was really smart and fitting.

Sofia

Portland Readers

I enjoyed reading this book. The plot was great and there was some funny aspects in the book. The characters were well written and I liked the illustration's. I would recommend this book to people who have anxiety/ocd.

Alexa

Portland Readers

the book is good and its still intresting and kind of funny way to learn about anxiety in a fun was and also learn how diffrent people deal with it

Rosemine

Portland Readers

I think it was an okay book but I found it a bit boring and I wanted to be able to quiz* on it so it wasn't good for me. *Accelerated Reader Quiz

Emma

Redhill Reviewers

We both enjoyed the book a lot. It was very nice and fresh to hear from someones perspective about the struggles of someone with anxiety and the doodles and drawings really helped. Rob Harrell is a very funny and descriptive writer and kept us engaged throughout. Andrew, I'm sure is a character that a lot of people can relate to but he made all the characters loveable (apart from the bully, and in Andrew's perspective G) but they were all very unique. We also found it funny how a nurse has a junk food stash, and how his 2 favourite 'teachers' like each other and how Mr Kellerman also has it. Overall a very enjoyable read from both of us. Would reccomend!

Tara Rose and Evritt

Portland Readers

This was a very good book. It kept you engaged the entire time, and left you wanting to know what would happen next. The storyline was relatable and realistic, so you could empathise with Andrew. It was a very good reading level for me, and I found the illustrations very funny and interesting. I would definitely recommend this book to friends. Truly an enjoyable read.

Will

Portland Readers

It was a really good book about a kid with anxiety who's Grandma goes missing and has to face his biggest fear on photo day as well.

Kennedy

Redhill Reviewers

There's a wonderful hopeful tone throughout the novel alongside a sympathetic and authentic representation of panic attacks. Accessible and affecting throughout, this is a romp of read set across a single day.

Mahnoor

Reading Wizards

Popcorn is a book about a boy called Andrew who lives with his mum and his Grandma who has Alzheimer's. Andrew struggles with anxiety, being bullied and feeling different to other people. At home he knows his mum is finding it hard to care for his grandma and hold down a job. While at school he has an incident with a rough bully who hurts him. He has a friend called Jonesy who wants him to stick up for himself but he doesn't feel able to as he often thinks it will make things worse. Andrew has OCD which means he likes everything to be clean and tidy and he sometimes has to do things many times to reassure himself. Andrew describes his anxiety through a popcorn kernel getting hotter and hotter. The author uses illustration which looks like Andrew's doodles to show how he's feeling. I found this book hard to read, especially the parts where Andrew is being attacked by his bully as he doesn't seem to be able to get himself out of the situation. The book seems like it should be a comedy book by looking at the illustrations but the words and feelings Andrew describes are not funny and were difficult to read. The author is excellent at describing anxiety and it makes you want to help Andrew and hope he finds a way through his struggles. Because Andrew is aware that his mum is also finding life difficult, he doesn't want to burden her with his troubles and so you feel like he is alone with his problems. He also doesn't have his grandma to talk to anymore as she often doesn't remember who he is and it's sad reading about how much he misses the old her. Before I read this book, I had a good understanding of what Alzheimer's was but I now have a better understanding of what it must feel like to lose someone and the love they had for you, even when you're standing in front of them. I enjoyed most aspects of the book but I did find it uncomfortable as I struggle with anxiety around school and found myself worrying about how I might feel in that situation.

Orla

Page Wanderers

The book can be an uncomfortable read for those not used to it. An overall fabulous read that really shows what anxiety is like for young people. I was really there with the narrator experiencing his struggles for myself and it's not often that you get a happy ending for these books so i'm glad one existed.

Emma

Townley Book Club

Popcorn was an amazing read! It was funny, yet relatable. If you were experiencing anxiety, it would be a comfort to know others are going through the the same thing. I love the popcorn scale, but when I first choose the book, the title confused me! I liked the drawings but they could make people feel self conscious about having panic attaks.

Annabel

Esher High

Popcorn is a novel which deeply focuses on anxiety in the daily life of a person. This is presented through the perspective of a boy at middle school who lives with anxiety, especially on his school photo day. Throughout the story, he describes his scale for indicating his mental stability as a ‘kernel scale’ where the more unstable he is mentally, the closer he is for his kernel to pop. In the novel, he attempts to control his kernel while encountering unfortunate situations regarding relationships as well as his anxiety during the school day. I recommend the novel towards students who are year 7 or higher as the book contains serious and complex topics regarding anxiety, however with additions of comical elements for a bit of post-script information for readers to further understand Andrew’s situation. This also helps readers to understand what Andrew’s emotion is when anxiety makes things difficult for him, which might be challenging for years under the recommendation. In conclusion, I personally believe that this novel challenged a unique way of describing anxiety in daily life, and I would highly suggest others to read the book.

Kota

The Lotus Readers

Popcorn is a truly unique book, if not slightly stressful. Its crammed full of wonderful science, a not so wonderful bully, and one very bad day. It's unusual to find a book were the main character has anxiety, and the author portrays it spectacularly in this book.

Ben

TBGS READERS

Popcorn was a super engaging, fast-paced book which is filled with comedy and real-life emotions, targeted at younger readers to relate to and enjoy. Although I wouldn’t recommend it to most adults or teenagers, I do think it’s a must read for younger beginner readers wanting to start reading books, especially ones about people’s life and experiences. 4/5.

Dexter

Horsham BOok HUNTers

'Popcorn' is a book that may seem to me a harmless comic at first, until you read into it and it displays its true colours as a book about anxiety and panic attacks. Although it may sound like a stressful topic, they way it is depicted (in the Anxiety Files for instance, Andrew's personal collection of discussing his state of mind) commits to an almost graphic novel-like style that presents it in a way that can be seen as juvenile or fun, balancing the heavy topics. Its depiction of a panic attack is most definitely the highlight of the book, drawing the most attention as the climax of the story and fitting that role perfectly. I am sure many can relate to Andrew's struggles throughout the book, as the author took inspiration from real disorders and that allows people with those disorders to connect with the anxious persona, bringing this cartoon character out of the page.

Santiago

Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

Popcorn was a great book. Whilst it was a bit childish in my opinion it explained anxiety and other mental health issues in a really clear and understandable way. The story follows Andrew on school picture day, when he wants to get the perfect photo, whilst still having to deal with bullies, science experiments and home issues. Written in the form of Andrews journal, the book was filled with small cartoony- images and short chapters- making it easily accessible. Overall, I would give it 3 stars.

Emily

HAEC Books and Biscuits Carnegie Shadowers

This book is very relatable as i am also not a fan of school photos. This book was overall very good and i feel that this should be a book used in the curriculum so kids/teens dont feel alone.

Blue Cover

HAEC Books and Biscuits Carnegie Shadowers

I did not finish this book as I thought the theme was a bit weird I get it if you have anxiety and all but I don't so I don't find this book very relatable. It's got a good idea but I just didn't enjoy it. Some people say (about random books) "I just couldn't put it down!" But I couldn't pick it up. I thought that the pictures were a bit overused. Overall, this book is the worst one I've read. No offence Rob. Sorry!

claudia and poppy

Cottingham High School

Popcorn was an easy read because of the pictures and it was easy to understand 8/10

connor

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

When I read this book I felt that the story was too short. I did not like how the whole story was only set over one day. I thought that I didn’t really know the characters very well and I would have preferred if there was a bit more of a build up in the plot. My favourite character was by far Jonesy, I liked her calm attitude and how she always helps Andrew. When she said that she only played basketball for fun it gave me a sense that she is very calm and laid back. I did not really like Andrew although throughout the book the author tries to make the reader feel bad for him. I felt that his overreactions were a bit over the top and that if I was in his position I wouldn’t have cared about some of the things that he was really worried about. I think this book should be aimed at children going through anxiety.

Nathen

The Perse Carnegians

The book popcorn by Rob Harrell was an entertaining book about a teen ager who has just joined middle school in america who has anxiety and ocd there are everyday issues that the average person will go through day to day school life there were illustrations so then you don't have to rely on your imagination only because you may forget what they look like i would recommend it to young teen agers it also shows what its like to have a panic attack while i have never had one it looks not good. on a scale from one to a ten i would rate this book about a 6 out of ten its a good book.

Bradley

Glossopdale Readers

Popcorn is a great book for readers aged 8–10 because it is both humorous and friendly, making it enjoyable and easy to follow. The story uses lighthearted jokes and amusing situations to keep young readers entertained while still being appropriate for their age group. Importantly, the book contains no swear words or other bad language, making it a safe and suitable choice for children. In addition, it includes many funny and wholesome scenes that help create a positive and engaging reading experience. Overall, Popcorn is a good, age-appropriate book that can encourage younger readers to develop a love of reading. My feelings for the book are that it is very positive and entertaining to read.

Jack

The Lotus Readers

I loved this book. I simply just couldn't put it down! It is a wonderful mix of comedy and fun and seriousness. It is perfect for teaching young individuals (and old ones too!) about anxiety, stress, panic attacks and way more. Overall, I think this is my favourite Carnegie so far.

Hamzah S

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed reading Popcorn, and to be honest I thought I wasn’t going to enjoy this book at first. I like how it shows what having anxiety actually looks like and that in the end it’ll be okay. I think that the thing that threw me off at first was most likely the pacing of the first few chapters but after reading more of the book it got better. I think my 2 favourite characters in this book are the Nurse, because of how funny yet kind she was, and the main character Andrew, because of how well his character is written. This book also covers heavy topics such as Alzheimer, bottling up emotions and divorce. Overall, I would really recommend this book if you want a funny yet reassuring read, then “Popcorn” is for you.

Ala

Bassingbourn Readers

Popcorn is a book about a child with anxiety and trying to stay spotless for a school photo. It also follows his worries for his grandma who has Alzheimer’s and when she disappears. When a bully ruins his collar he finds an unusual friend in the school nurse who helps him.

owen

The Fitzharrys Shadows

Popcorn is now one of my favourite books from the carnegie. I like how it represents anxiety . I like all the characters and their own backgrounds. One of my favourite parts is using popcorn to represent anxiety. 10/10

William S

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book was very very good. I could not stop reading it for about a week. What I really enjoyed about this book was how well the main character (Andrew) is portrayed to make the reader feel bad for him, especially in the way how life just feels so unfair at times like when his new shirt got ripped by the horrible school bully Gene. One thing that I didn’t find very clear though was if Andrew had a neurological disability or if he was just a very anxious kid. I think the author could of had a bit where he was diognosed if that was the case because it left the reader pondering a lot. In the end it is good to see that Andrew over comes his fear and just gets the picture even though he looks like an utter rag doll. The illustrations are a great addition to the book (they made me laugh quite a few times!) overall it was a really good book.

Sam

Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

Pop Corn is about a boy called Andrew and how he copes with his anxiety. It was very good and fun to read by using cartoon/Illustrations to show his feelings

Xavier

Central Teen Reading Group

Popcorn was quite an interesting book. It deeply shows how a boy with anxiety can have his life quite easily ruined without the correct conditions. His mum wants a good yearbook picture from him and his 'kernel of worry' keeps getting hotter and hotter till it finally pops. I enjoyed this book for a few reasons, it was well described, detailed and it showed genuine ways people deal with anxiety and not just make it up along the way, and I do think that it is quite irregular that someone's day can be that bad. I did enjoy it and I also like how Rob Harrell wrote a book on his own anxiety. 8/10.

Sebastian H

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed this book. Popcorn has really educated me further about anxiety and panic attacks and in my opinion, has fully captured the vision of what it feels like to have an attack. I've had a really good time reading this, and it doesn't feel like I'm reading a lot either because I get to see pictures every now and then! it's a real breather from other books with only text. I love the actual pictures as well, I love the style being rough and panicky, and also the anxiety files are really creative! Overall, this was an amazing read and Popcorn has succeeded past my expectations, as I picked up the book not expecting a lot. I largely recommend to all audiences, especially children so that we can teach them mental health. This was a beautiful way of spreading awareness about what children feel when they're anxious. It's really common for people to feel alone in mental health, and educating others how it really isn't as bad as our minds perceive it is something I love personally. Loved it!

Melisa

The SBSJs

Ghostlines: Ghostlines by Katya Balen was a heartwarming, beautiful book. It was all about adapting to change and how you shouldn't be afraid to try new things. This book celebrates friendship and community, but it also has a sense of resilience. The writing style really made me feel like I was there with Tilda and Albie. I loved this book because of its closeness between characters, the way people can rely on each other. It was wonderful to find the secrets of Ayrie and to follow Tilda through the wonders of the island and her troubles with her brother. Overall, Ghostlines was an amazing book that said a lot about not being afraid to be an outsider and that you should always attempt new things.

Zainab

ParkLrc

The book “Popcorn” by Rob Harrell is a funny yet interesting story which would show you a complete new vision. The main character is called Andrew Yaeger and has social anxiety. He has a school picture that day, so he wants to keep his shirt as clean as possible. The social anxiety setting makes the book really attractive as you read it through. The author gives us easy-to-understand examples of Andrew’s swirling social-anxiety mind. Throughout the book, there are some problems that would ruin his clean shirt. For example, science experiments and nose bleeding in PE. The author represents how Andrew overcomes the problems really well. He first gets social anxiety swirls, but he overcomes them. Overall, this book is really worth reading since it is a positive book that develops growing up and overcoming the problems, which can inspire moving on.

Kei

The Lotus Readers

Popcorn by Rob Harrell was a book about the main character, Andrew, overcoming his extreme anxiety. The main storyline follows Andrew’s day at school, where he takes his school photo. At the start of the story, he desperately tries to protect his new shirt which his mom bought from him, and felt overwhelming anxiety every time it was ruined. However, by the end of the story, he learns how to control his anxiety and go through his complexities by forcing himself to face the situation, or imagining the best scenario that can happen. Throughout reading the story, I was surprised by the fast change of the protagonist, and how he manages to face his phobia, which is clearly a challenge for anybody. Overall, I enjoyed Popcorn, since it was easy to understand the storyline, and also had numerous comedic scenes.

Jayden

The Lotus Readers

Popcorn is about a boy who has anxiety and a grandmother with Alzheimer's. I think that one of the purposes of this book is to bring awareness to mental health issues. I think that someone who would enjoy reading this book would be someone who likes to read graphic novels. I think this because the way the book is formatted reminds me of that. For example, there are many pictures on the pages that show what's happening at that point in the story. It also can be a funny book at times with a few jokes throughout the story which could be another thing that they have in common. In my opinion, the story would be best read at 11 and up because even though the reading level is not too high the content of the book is mature and deals with things such as panic attacks, premature grief and abandonment.

lily

The Lotus Readers

Andrew hoped that he would have a perfect day for school photograph day. However, things go wrong. First, he gets his shirt collar ripped by a bully after not letting him cheat in a maths test, then he gets a bad cut on his nose while playing basketball. After that, he gets his shirt completely stained from a ketchup rocket mixed with baking soda. Andrew was dealing with anxiety all this time, and he could have panic attacks. It was getting closer and closer... can he prevent it from happening? I really enjoyed this book because it talked about people like Andrew who dealt with problems similar to his and it gives me a new perspective about people like him. My favourite character was his art teacher because he was funny, calm and kind. Finally I would recommend this book to people who want to learn about everyday problems that may occur to anyone.

Ibsan

The Perse Carnegians

I found this book really extended my understanding of anxiety as I knew little about it before I read the book and it had a decent plot although I did get a bit confused as I though it lasted more than one day. So was then surprised when I realised. I enjoyed reading it.

Zoë

Skipton Shadows

So it was good at the whole anxiety and stress thing, like everything is going wrong spiraling BUT just being me myself and I. I'm not entirely keen on the story line it just kept on lingering and droning on and on. Watching someone have a bad day is way more exhausting than actually fun to read you know, bit more childish than I'm used to tbh. Would recommend to a younger audience struggling with anxiety or OCD in general Overall a 5.6/10

Insiya

Teen Book Club

I thought the book was quite interesting from a perspective of a child being bullied and all the bad events that happened to him are quite dramatic and it leads to one thing worse throughout the day. I definitely would never have picked this book for myself, but I thought it was an interesting book on how some children like Andrew Yeger handle mental health.

Summer

Tractors

I love how the author included lots of real life coping strategies and situations and especially drawings. My rating is 9.3 and a definite recommendation for 7-12 .

Ava

Dunraven Carnegie

Popcorn is a really good book . I enjoyed how it is really a story of the author when he was young . It also appealed to me as i hadn't really heard of social anxiety before and now i feel like i understand it a bit more. It was also good as it only was set in one day yet so many twists and turns happened. 9/10.

Sandy

Dunraven Carnegie

The blurb was captivating and initially sounded more childish than the book's content itself, the cover did not evoke anything to me; it seemed like the standard middle-grade fiction cover. It took me 3 days to read the book. It followed a young boy as he went about his school picture day; he is a victim of mishap and worries, making his day feel to be turbulent - eventually leading to an anxiety attack where his peers and teachers help him. The main themes covered are anxiety, emotional honesty, humour, friendship and bullying. I think this appeals to 9-12 year olds, the book is not specifically gendered which is a strength of the format. As the themes can be quite topical it may be hard for a younger audience to understand the euphemism of popcorn as anxiety however I would find that anyone over the age of 12 would find the plot itself too immature. I liked how the boy noticed his mother's struggles as well as spoke about his grandmother’s Alzheimer's, this created a realistic lens to themes that are cmmonly ignored in children’s literature yet are things that children notice in real life. Them being written down as a part of the plot makes the book feel more insightful. The ending was comical and served as a nice moment. I did not like the sequence of events, the book felt oversaturated with plots that became too fast-paced and played on too many stereotypes, this prevented Harrell from exploring one theme in depth and creating something meaningful from it. I would rate this book a 7/10. I would recommend it to other readers and I think it deserves a Carnegie medal.

Faye

Gibraltar Carnegie Scholars

I really enjoyed Popcorn! It was funny, engaging with its entertaining illustrations but also went through important themes like living with people who have Alzheimer's disease and dealing with anxiety. One of the things I liked about the book was that the book was basically the authors story of living with anxiety except twisted and made into a funny novel! One thing I might improve about the book is the fact that all these things happen in one day, and the whole day is very stretched out. But on the other hand, that is the plot of the book! Overall, this was a great read!

Jana

The Perse Carnegians

To me this book is really good, as it focuses on a boy named Andrew, who has is managing his anxiety and is trying to get through the school day while trying to get a nice school photo for his mum to make her happy. And it can help children with anxiety too.

Louise

St Angela’s Reading Angels

Popcorn was a fantastic read! I found Andrew as character so interesting in the way his mind worked and his thought processes. It was nice to be able to connect and understand how he felt having anxiety and how hard he found it at times, but then what he did to overcome those struggles. I really liked how Rob Harrell helped readers to vision exactly how Andrew felt with pictures and phrases at times, like the "Popcorn Meter". I really enjoyed this book!

Lara

Tractors

I like how this book has a clear representation of anxiety, and the panic attack part was certainly interesting to read. I find it a little unrealistic though on how some of the characters act.

Freya

Winchmore School Carnegie Group 2025/26

Pop Corn is an engaging book that showcases different viewpoints to younger readers with a fun and humorous story line. It educates on conditions like Alzheimer’s, OCD and anxiety in an intriguing way while subtly giving advice on ways to cope along with the list of helpful sites at the end. The life of a teenager had me more interested in how life can be so different for two people who are thought to be similar. I enjoyed the intensity and description in this book which helped me wholly understand each action and event. I have never read a book like this before and it made me realise how interesting a different viewpoint can be.

Meerab

Carnegie Shadow Judges MEAC

I would give this book a 4/5. It is set over the course of one school day and is about a boy who suffers from anxiety. I liked Popcorn because, instead of being all action, action, like many books, it focuses on some very real world problems that we don’t always think about. I also like how instead of trying to describe what anxiety feels like, it uses the ‘popcorn analogy’ and the ‘popping scale’, which helped me to understand what anxiety might feel like.

Jack

TBGS READERS

Popcorn is a side splitting book full of emotional honesty and hilarious mishaps throughout the book it is very relatable for people who have a lot of anxiety. I consider this a very good read.

Alessandro

MTS Northwood

Popcorn is a fun and emotional story that blends humour with some serious topics. It follows Andrew and his friends as they deal with a tough situation, showing how people act when things get stressful. The book also looks at how quickly things can go wrong and how misunderstandings can affect what people think. Andrew was my favourite character because he seemed real and easy to relate to. He makes mistakes and has a hard time with some decisions, which made him believable. I liked seeing how he tried to handle everything going on. My favourite scene is when he talks to his therapist. It feels honest and easy to understand, which is why I liked it so much. The story kept me guessing because I wasn’t always sure what would happen next. The tension builds gradually, which makes it more thrilling to read. There were parts that made me laugh, but there were also sad moments that added to the story's emotional impact. Overall, Popcorn is a fantastic book that is both entertaining and suspenseful. It encourages reflection on how people treat one another and how situations can change rapidly. I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys stories that are both exciting and meaningful.

Izzy

Vista Academy Littleport

What makes this book stand out is its brilliant honesty. Instead of being overly clinical, Harrell uses the "popcorn" metaphor to perfectly describe that bubbling, frantic feeling of a looming panic attack. It’s a story that tells kids (and adults) that having a brain that works a little differently doesn't make you "broken"—it just means you’re navigating a louder world. It's amazing!

Farwa

Reading Wizards

Really wild and funny while balancing emotional problems. I loved this book. The way it is written almost like a diary entry enhances it for me. 10/10!

Abigail

SWA Readers

I loved this book, solid 10/10. Why? All the themes were great and I related to Andrew's anxiety. The OCD is really well represented, and helped me learn more about it. 10/10

Hen

SWA Readers

I would give this book a 4 out of 10 as I didn't really like this book. Although there are a few themes present, I didn't enjoy it as it stayed on things for way too long which I didn't like. I didn't like that the whole book is set in one day as the pace is really slow. I also think that there should be more themes present within the book as it heavily focuses on anxiety and panic attacks.

Daniel

Tenbury Page Turners 26

I really enjoyed the book it is really funny , my favourite character is Andrew as he is the main character it is his school photo day and he is really nervous because he want a good picture for his mum but he isnt having the best day.

Aisha

Check ‘Em Out @ OSCA

The idea was good but i personally did not enjoy since i think it is more childish and i couldnt finish it. I also found some pictures not enjoyable, overall 4/10

Melissa

GreatB00ks

Popcorn wasn't the most enjoyable book, with the character's only real struggle within the story being at the very end. Some of the ways in which his anxiety is described is interesting, and the writing style was playful. It felt almost too fictional, even for a fiction book, with the events being over the top, feeling forced. The idea for this book, a boy struggling with anxiety, is interesting, but the execution of the idea was the main flaw of the book. Andrew is a good character template, but I felt that his anxiety was as deep as his personality went, with no exploration of his other characteristics. Overall, I wish this book was the same themes, but with a more developed plot.

Oliver R

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I enjoyed this book a lot more than the other books but I have a few issues with it. I'm personally not a big fan of having the book set in just 1 day but I do understand why it happened as it's trying to say about all the bad things that happened in that day all building up to when his "kernel popped" and I did enjoy the ending. I liked the authors other books like Wink which I enjoyed reading but he always gives the main character anxiety and a female best friend for some reason. I enjoyed this book and i give it a 8/10

Elliott.H

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Popcorn I really enjoyed this book! I thought it was very well written and engaging and was definitely one of my favourites I have read so far. I really learnt to connect with the main character, Andrew, and definitely felt extremely sorry for him more than I would like to say. I thought it was a very good idea of the author (Rob Harrell) to integrate the real world ideas and truths of anxiety and mental health, as it made you think more about it but you didn’t really realise it was written to explore subjects like these instead of just a fun book that could be enjoyed by many which I thought made it even better as a book. I would recommend it to people age ranged 7-14. The plot line follows Andrew on his journey through school picture day where everything seems to go wrong, integrating bits of other plot lines ie his therapy sessions, until eventually at the end where he finally gets his school photo. It is very well written and I loved reading it, overall an amazing book.

Naomi

Helkats & Hardbacks

Personally, I didn't enjoy reading Popcorn, mainly because of the tone of the book. I felt it was more suited for younger readers to make them more aware about anxiety. I also didn't really like how anxiety was the main point of the book, with little in-depth plot, and how it was constantly to referred to. I also found that some of the many problems/hurdles Andrew has to overcome are unrealistic - especially since they all occur in one day. The analogy of a popcorn kernel was a nice one to make readers understand though. Overall, I found it too focussed on anxiety, and thought it could have emphasised Andrew's and Jonesy's friendship a bit more. 6/10.

Aashaz Z.

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book was great. The end was so relieving and well-written. I was on the edge of my seat the whole time. It gave me a deeper understanding of people who suffer from anxiety and panic attacks. This book had some great aspects and a happy ending. I loved POPCORN by Rob Harrell.

Wesley

The SGS Book Bandits

I really liked this book in comparison to the other ones! I felt it was more relatable to me as a reader and it was funny. Overall, I connected with the book which is really all I want from reading. I rate it 7/10.

Amalia

Elms Shadowing 2026

I enjoyed this book. I liked the way the action all took place across one day in the life of Andrew, a boy suffering from anxiety. It is school photo day, so he is trying very hard not to get messy, but over the day various accidents involving a basketball, ketchup, a bully and a rogue science experiment conspire to make him increasingly unpresentable. The physical mess seems to represent his mental state as the day goes on. Andrew is caught between these pressures at school and the ones in his home life. His grandma with Alzheimer’s has gone missing and his mum isn’t responding to his calls. Andrew uses “the popcorn scale” to describe his anxiety levels, which I thought was a clever way to show the build up of pressure and its effect on the anxiety sufferer. The writer uses humour to explore quite a heavy subject matter, making it clear that it can happen to anyone.

Magnus

The Perse Carnegians

Popcorn follows the story of Andrew Yaeger, a seventh-grader who struggles with anxiety. I enjoyed this book and thought the way such a serious topic could be included in a funny book was very smart as it provides younger audiences an introduction to topics so common yet so serious.

Libby

Vista Academy Littleport

Didn't like this book either. The selection of books this year seems to be very limited, three of the four books I have so far read are set at a school, where the protagonist in question is subject to bullying, and has problems they want to hide from the outside world. (I realize this is turning into a commentary on the current state of YA/children's publishing, I'll get to 'Popcorn' in a moment.) Many books published nowadays, seem to follow the same, or similar, agenda. Where has the fun, the magic gone from books? These books often follow the trend of mental health (eg Popcorn) which I absolutely think has been over-done as of late. And of course I understand the importance of awareness around mental health, but we only need it rammed down our throats, not all the way out the other end. Now for the actual book, I thought it was okay, but also wasn't great either. As hinted at earlier, I believe the plot to be a systematic failure at being original. The storyline was almost identical to any other recently written book of its age group, never deviating from the rules the institution has set and expects an author to follow. I did however, think that it brought attention to a different issue that usual, OCD. This one I hadn't yet seen in a novel, and I thought that Harrell depicted it quite well. Everything else was same-same though. I also thought that some of the illustrations looked as if they were from the 'Bob's Burgers' cartoon. Take that as a condemnation, or a compliment, as and when you wish. Would not read again.

Rory

KES Readers

This book follows Andrew through his school picture day where he deals with bullies, spilt juice and a basketball. Despite his struggles, Andrew still tries to look perfect for his mother! This book was not my favourite out of all the Carnegie books but I still enjoyed it. I would recommend this book to children in year 4+.

Lukshmi

CSGS Page Turners 26

I liked Popcorn because it is funny at times and also I feel like readers with anxiety and OCD would relate to it. The novel also has images that helped me understand the story a bit more though I feel like the plot was a bit predictable. Overall this book was good. I would rate it a solid 3/5.

Clara

Euro Champs

I like Popcorn because it helped me understand how people with anxiety live

Tamera

Dunraven

The story follows seventh-grader Andrew Yaeger through a single, disastrous school photo day. Andrew is a perfectionist who struggles with severe anxiety and OCD. He is determined to look perfect for his mother, but the world seems to conspire against him through bullies, exploding science experiments, and spilled juice

lamar m

Lionheart2026

This book is awesome! The way that Rob Harrell has thought of a way to get people to have a laugh and experience some heavy topics is fantastic. It definitely proves that anybody can be anxious on any level and be able to get help.

Oskar

St Kaths

This book is about Andrew, who struggles with anxiety and this is the story of one day in his life. This book wasn't my favourite (sorry!) but it was very humorous and pretty funny, as well as being informative about how anxiety feels and how to deal with it as best you can. I would give this book 2.5 out of 5 stars.

Edith

Montsaye Shadow Readers

Overall I think popcorn is a good well rounded book and readers can really relate to it . In my opinion I found at the beginning it was a bit dry and overwhelmed you with description It had a good story line if it could be improved I would say the writer could have made it more exiting at the start to draw the reader in. I would rate the book 4 stars out of 5.

Bella

Stratton shadowers

What a day- poor Andrew! Well written and set out. It was great that the overall theme was accepting- your condition (anxiety) and help from others. Aimed at 9+ which if fitted. It was alright.

Debbie

Ousedale Olney

I have read Pop Corn by Rob Harrell. I found this book not very gripping and there wasn't any form of character development in the story.However, I did enjoy the fact that it is all in one day and not in a long period of time. This is overall a good book.

Elyes

4Shadowers

The representation of anxiety was very well done with a good mix of narrative and illustrations. It showed a great plotline with the resolution being incredibly heart warming.

Rachel

LSST Library Shadowers

Popcorn by Rob Harrell follows Andrew, who needs to make it through school picture day whilst suffering from anxiety. I really enjoyed his character, who displays the troubles of problems like anxiety, but also how to overcome them. This book describes anxiety like a popcorn kernel, where multiple events at school and at home cause it to pop: " A rogue ketchup rocket, a bully and a building sense of impending doom." Overall this was quite a simple read; it was not too hard to follow, although I felt it was not serious enough at some points when displaying problems such as anxiety and Alzheimer's. I would recommend this to an overall younger audience, especially those facing challenges such as anxiety. I would rate this book a 4/10 for future readers.

Oliver

The Fitzharrys Shadows

'Popcorn' follows a boy called Andrew, who is suffering from anxiety. The book takes place on a single day. Multiple incidents gradually build up to him experiencing his greatest fear, which is a panic attack in school. At this point, black blotches start to appear on the pages, highlighting panic. Eventually, the book leads to a happy ending. This book is easy to read, and people with anxiety may empathise with Andrew and his struggles. Overall, this book wasn’t bad, and I liked it a bit. The novel has illustrations to help with the tone. I would rate 'Popcorn' a solid 8/10; it's not bad and something some people can relate to.

Aiden

The Lotus Readers

Popcorn is a lively and memorable story that turns one disastrous school day into something both hilarious and meaningful. Andrew only wants to get through Picture Day, but every problem makes his anxiety grow stronger, until it becomes impossible to ignore. I liked how the book shows that worries are not always visible from the outside, and that even funny situations can hide real fear and pressure. The mix of humour, chaos, and honest emotion makes Andrew feel believable and easy to care about. This is an enjoyable and important read that encourages kindness, understanding, and the courage to accept help.

Yasmine

4Shadowers

The book Popcorn is about how a young boy named Andrew is dealing with anxiety and is set when he is having the worst day ever. His grandmother, bullying and much more all surround him, while he is just trying to stay tidy for his picture. I like this book because it feels somewhat relatable, as going through high/secondary school can be tough and you might get anxious along the way. I think the writer made it easy to sympathise with Andrew, as the detail going into his feelings is so incredibly intricate. I enjoy how the title 'Popcorn' relates to Andrew himself and how the book is like his own journal, but also a story in a way. I would definitely recommend this book to readers my age because it is a good reminder that other people are anxious and we are all going through the same situation.

Suheyla

Chiswick Carnegie

It was a very fast paced book, probably too much so. I think that the real life coping tips was a good touch. The ending was enjoyable. Overall, a decent read.

Mark

Bassingbourn Readers

I think that Popcorn was an amazing book because I thought that some of the references to real life were very relatable, especially the feeling of anxiety but not that extreme. I liked the use of a popcorn kernel in hot oil to symbolize the feeling of growing anxiety. I really liked it at the end when Andrew gained confidence and stood up to Gene. I think that was an amazing end to the story. It also made a much more lighthearted ending after the panic attack, which was quite nerve-racking. I also really liked the ending with the photo where his glasses were completely wrecked.

Sam

The Perse Carnegians

I really enjoyed reading popcorn because Rob Harrell has made it very funny but also emotional as Andrew has anxiety and describes it as popcorn ! it did make me laugh reading it but I was also made me feel sad for him its a very good book and would recommend it to my friends.🍿┏(＾0＾)┛

Florence✧･ﾟ:* *:･ﾟ✧

Lionheart2026

Popcorn by Rob Harrell is an interesting book in the day of life as someone who is quite emotional and suffers from anxiety in school. The genre is quite similar to Diary Of A Wimpy Kid by Jeff Kinney, as it involves a sense of humour and mixes in school life. It also has some illustrations and is overall a fairly quick read.

Ethan

Carnegivores

The book "Popcorn" by Rob Harrell is a funny story with illustrations. It follows a boy named Andrew who struggles with anxiety and OCD. The plot details his day, including science experiments, school photos, and dealing with a bully. Andrew’s anxiety increases as the day goes on. I enjoyed the easy reading level and the fact that the story is set over one day, with interludes showing Andrew at his therapist. However, I found the plot predictable and unexciting, I probably wouldn’t have read it if it hadn’t been on the Carnegie list, as it’s not something I would usually pick. However what I thought the book did well is illustrate anxiety and OCD from a child’s point of view. It reveals how Andrew thinks and how his mind thinks, which I found quite interesting . The book has a light and silly tone, but without the illustrations and writing style it wouldn’t feel as cheerful. The plot was quite quick and changed throughout scenes frequently, the main character was likeable and interesting however the side characters weren’t really memorable. Overall I enjoyed this book but the plot wasn’t that interesting .

Constance

Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

I really think this is beautiful and funny story - the bit with the ketchup bottle was hilarious. I liked how the main character kept messing up - it was so random. The only part of the story I didn't enjoy was the character of the bully (I am not sure if the character was really needed, but I understand why they were there). Overall, I thought the book was amazing and I would recommend it to others. ***** (5 stars).

Ayaan

Rockwood Reads

I didn't think that Popcorn would be good since it is for younger readers but it suprised me with how funny it is and the reality of it.

Marwa

Dunraven

It's a good book because it shows a person going through anxiety showing the challenges of it all through the book.

Gilbert

Kingdown Wilts

Popcorn by Rob Harrell is a very funny and interesting book that explores the themes of anxiety, accepting help and support and being resilient in everyday life. I especially like this book because it contain many different characters that all help Andrew so it shows to all of us that there is always help. I would recommend this book to readers ages 12-15 and give it a rating of 7.5/10.

Hisham

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The book was interesting and funny, and I liked the little illustrations. I also liked the fact that it was written in the first person; it really helped you feel what the character was feeling.

Anna

Inkscape Critics

Popcorn: The book Popcorn by Rob Harry made me realize what anxiety can be like. It can be (as described in the book) like a popcorn kernel you can cook it and cook it but at some point it will pop. But you don’t have to deal with the anxiety or pop corn kernel alone. Like in the book Andrew seeks help from his school counsellor, friends and family and he finds it and they make him understand that you don’t have to do it alone or care about what others think about you and you should just be yourself. Overall this book was making a better understanding of facing anxiety and it could probably help future people who read it.

Zach

Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

I like how this book can help people understand how someone with anxiety can struggle everyday. I thought the author relating Andrew’s anxiety to popcorn-popping was very clever, but the storyline was very far fetched. I also found it quite boring in parts, but I think younger readers would really enjoy this book.

Anya

Shelf Indulgence by JCG

This book was a decent read for me though not my favourite. The style of the book was quite childish which I normally would enjoy but the actual writing felt too serious for the tone I had set in my head for this book. However, I appreciate how this book related with real life experiences and everyday thing which definitely made me feel like everything was real and actually happening. Overall this book was not too bad and it had its moments through the pages

Lakshake

HGS Book Club

I really enjoyed reading this book! I found it really interesting how clearly the book explains what anxiety is like because it may be difficult for people without it to understand what challenges there are to overcome. I loved how alongside this important theme, there was still plenty of humour involved! So far, this book is definitely one of my favourites!

Anna

CSGS Page Turners 26

I believe that this is a great read as it is about a young boy called Andrew and you go on a journey through his day however his only 1 goal is to keep clean for the school photo for the end of the day. However, there is a science experiment gone wrong a rogue ketchup rocket a bully and a building sense of impending doom. You also encounter Andrew's life at home with his grandma who has alzheimer and him having OCD. I would recommend this to you as it is fast-paced, funny and you never know what is going to happen next

Charlie

Bookwizards

I really enjoyed the style of this book, it was very relatable and funny but there were also moments when it was harder for Andrew. I loved this book and would definitely recommend it.

Arabella

Epsomian Shortlist Shadowers

I find this really hard to say but i could not finish this book. I think that it was mainly aimed at younger children.The writing was very immature and i feel like lots wasn't explained and the alzheimers was quite disregarded. But i think if you are a younger audience who struggles with anxiety this is for you .

Emmy

GreatB00ks

I hated this book. He went into no detail about the fact the main character's gran has Altzhimers. The whole book was written in a very childish way and there was next to no deatail about anything throughout the book. However, there were some acpects that i believe some younger readers may potentially enjoy. The consepts were put into language that young readers would be able to understand and would not be freaked out. Overall, i would not recogmend this book to people unless they enjoy kids books kr were a young reader themslve.

Phoebe

GreatB00ks

I enjoyed reading this book and thought that it was nicely written but the story was not enjoyable and was incredibly far fetched and that took away from the story. The writing was good but the story let it down with too many themes and its outlandishness. 5.5/10

Henry D

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I read Popcorn, it’s about a boy called Andrew who has anxiety and things throughout the day make him feel worse such as the school picture day and his granny having dementia and constantly forgetting his name he suspects she’s getting worse. I really liked the book because it had morals while also being a child friendly book containing emotions, and overcoming difficult events. It was a good read but slightly easy and it had very few words which I didn’t already know. The book also has this thing called the kernel scale which added a sense of excitement and drama to the book making the reader want to read on and find out what happens in the end. Right before the photo shoot he has a panic attack and a teacher comes and helps him. This is another moral of friendship and perseverance which makes you feel better.

Freddie

Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

I very much enjoyed this book as I felt like it was an accurate description of the hardship of school on top of anxiety. It has a very easy story to follow along with and it is perfect for younger readers but also for older readers to understand the theme that younger audiences may not realize. Overall, a good book with themes such as anxiety, panic attacks, humour, emotional honesty, friendship and bullying.

Freida

Thomas Tallis Reads

I think Popcorn by Rob Harrell is a really good book because it is both funny and a bit sad at the same time. It is about a boy called Andrew who has a really bad day at school and struggles with anxiety. Some parts made me laugh, but other parts made me feel sorry for him. I liked how the book shows what anxiety feels like in a way that is easy to understand. The drawings also make it more fun to read and help show his thoughts. Andrew is a very relatable character because he worries about things that lots of people worry about. Overall, I would recommend this book to other people my age because it is interesting, funny, and also teaches you about mental health.

Dinu

Rainbeau Readers

Wow!! This book is stunning. As a fellow anxious person myself, I really empathised with Andrew and felt his incredible need to tap his fingers on surfaces. As soon as I picked up this book, I felt a strong urge to simply not put it down. The words intertwined in my heart and this book will forever leave a place there. The use of the vocab was extraordinary and gripping. The pictures made me laugh! This book really digs deep on anxiety and OCD. As funny as this book is, the therapy lessons that Andrew has, gives a real life example on how many people are struggling. I know that there have been people struggling with Anxiety for ages now, and they are comforted knowing that people are also struggling with similar struggles too!! This is a truly great book, I would 100% recommend this book to others who are struggling internally, as panic attacks are terrifying and this book gives a real inside to anxiety, bulling and OCD. Fab book, Rob!!

Georgie

Brookie Reads

Popcorn was a good book about a boy whose anxiety through the day gets worse and loads of bad things happen to him, a chemistry explosion, a ripped collar and many more. 7/10

Max

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Popcorn was a very creative book that reflected on the topic of anxiety. The main character of the book had severe anxiety and imagined himself as a kernel that started off well but when he got more anxiety the kernel got hotter and hotter until it popped. It also covers the topic of kindness; when the main character, Andrew, gets a panic attack in the middle of an art class because his grandma has disappeared his friend, Aisha, helps with finding her. I really enjoyed this book because it was based on a real-life scenario but it also was a very original way to look at it.

Sotiris

The Perse Carnegians

I thought that this book was very original and the ending was well written. I did find the book quite slow at times, especially as the whole book was about 1 school day. I thought the overall book had a good message and I think the ending made up for the rest of the story.

Nadia

St Kaths

Popcorn: Popcorn is an amazing book with not one but two enemies (even if one is inside of the protagonist Andrew). Andrew’s anxiety takes over when several pressures appear all at once and a typical day at school goes from a stroll in the park to a race in the Olympics. To add to his stresses his beloved grandma ‘G’ goes missing and constant bullying ensues. There is some good suspense and light hearted humour involving ketchup rockets and crystal explosions. All of this created a great tension in the story for me. It helped me understand the internal impact of anxiety and how people experience things differently. I really loved this book and it is perfect for suspense lovers like me. 8/10.

Avery

TPS Carnegie Collective

I think Popcorn by Rob Harrell is a very good book because it felt like I was in school. The main theme in this book is friendship. The plot builds curiosity as it develops. The characters are interesting and engaging. They make the reader care what is happening. The style of the writing suits the story and the themes extremely well. The important idea that this book explores is anxiety. It helps readers understand different experiences or viewpoints. 7.5/10.

Kamran

Booky Wookies

It is Andrew's picture day and he has had a haircut and a new shirt, his mum wants him to have a good picture. Then G, his grandma, goes missing, stressing him out even more. To make it worse Gene decides to beat Andrew up because he won't let Gene cheat on a test. He has a panic attack in class. Will he find G? It is a good, light-hearted way to talk about OCD. I enjoyed it because it showed what other people are experiencing, when you are only worrying about yourself.

Ava

Montsaye Shadow Readers

The book Pop Corn is a powerful book. It starts by a boy doubting himself in the mirror and how as he kind of grows he starts to see someone and it gains his confidence.. In my opinion the book is fabulous and has a heartwarming touch towards the end. I would definitely recommend this book to my friends because it's something different. I would give this book 3 stars because it wasn’t the sort of book I’d usually read.

charlie H

Glossopdale Readers

I thought the way the book tackled anxiety was a great perspective on things. However I do have one problem. The fact that so much happened to the main protagonist in the same day does make the book feel unrealistic in some ways but equally it had a decent plot. Definitely portrays its message but could have had more plot development. 6/10

Ben P

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Pros: - This book was easy to read and I liked how anxiety was a motif throughout the book. - I liked how the therapy sessions were a change of setting Cons: - I don't think this book is my genre, however if I was younger I may enjoy it more - I would not usually go for this book however the plot was really good. -> I would like to have seen a bit more plot development Rating : 3 / 5

Zayna

Mansell Library Reviewers

I thought that the book was very enjoyable, and shows how many other people might have to cope with anxiety. There was also a strong impact when he had the panic attack, also showing how many people feel when they have one. I would give this book a 9 out of 10 as it had me hooked in throughout the whole story.

Rhiyan

The WH shadowers

Anxiety...!!! The most difficult thing to describe when you are going through it but WOW what a wonderful representation of it!! The amount of emotion this book made me feel for Andrew was impressive. The irony...the things that made me sympathise with Andrew were not always the things that caused him anxiety, such as the fight. I enjoyed the 'no frills' element to the writing which would make this accessible to young readers and also give them the sense that these feelings of anxiety are felt by others and that they should be accepted. Thoroughly enjoyed the humour and the character dynamics.

Fiona

The Carnegie Coast Readers

it was an amazing book! I loved the amazing realistic twist. This would be an amazing book for people to relate. Rob Harrell I hope your book gets a win!

Chloe

SHS Book Club

Although Popcorn was fun and included illustrations, it explored anxiety and bullying which adds some depth. However, I didn’t really understand if the plot of making sure Andrew’s, the main character’s, photo for picture day was perfect was very clear. Nonetheless, the events that took place in his day were quite dramatic and kept you wanting to read more. I found how Andrew described anxiety as a corn kernel heating up to popcorn quite interesting, and his ‘Anxiety Files’ were another intriguing way of him expressing his mental health in a “funny-ish” way, as he said himself. I liked the character profiles at the start of some of the chapters, too, as it gave a picture of the people described which was helpful. I did enjoy lots of this book, but I feel like the plot wasn’t very strong and how his shirt kept getting ruined a bit repetitive, so I rate Popcorn a 6/10.

Mae

Helkats & Hardbacks

This book was really good as it was following the life of a boy with anxiety. It shows that many people you wouldn't expect to have anxiety have it and it shows that you can control your anxiety, for example, Mr Kellerman, a very jolly man who, surprisingly, had anxiety, which was a surprise to Andrew after he and Mr Kellerman were talking after Andrew's panic attack.

akmal

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I found this book very insightful into the world of people with anxiety. I found the book interesting yet a little slow paced as it was written so it took part in just one day and it was perhaps overly descriptive in certain places but other than that I quite enjoyed this book would definitely recommend to people struggling with Anxiety or OCD.

Rowan

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really liked Popcorn because of the plot. Andrew Yaeger is a 7th grader that has anxiety and OCD starts his day badly by getting bullied but it made me smile when his teacher who also has anxiety helped him out as well as his classmates supporting him. My favourite part of this book has to be the ending where they had picture day because he just stops worrying about himself and puts on a smile for the camera. I also enjoyed the part where his friend help Andrew with his anxiety problems and I think she impacted Andrew a lot and without her it would be hard for him. And these parts of the book make me enjoy reading Popcorn and I would read it again.

Gabriel

Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

I loved Popcorn! From the humor to the description it was all amazing! One of my favourite parts of the book had to be the panic attacks and how well they were described. I felt like I was really in school with Andrew! I have never read a book that is all in one day and I think the author Rob Harrell did a great job. This was a great book! 9/10! And the illustrations were also fun.

Celine

The Maynard School

I disliked this book for the most part. The plot was boring, repetitive and didn't pique my interest. I usually love reading books similar to this, but this one was just not meant for me. However, I did like one thing - his panic attack. It was written amazingly, with feelings and pressures that people in real life would understand and relate to. How one seemingly tiny thing can just tip your glass. Although the writing style didn't appeal to me, I'm sure it would to others.

rida

HGS Book Club

Popcorn is a book about anxiety but I would really not recommend it for two reasons. 1. It is very repetitive the same anxiety over and over again with next to no change. 2. If you read the blurb it practically tells you all of the so called 'exciting' parts of the book so you already know what is happening. I would give this book a 3/10.

seb

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I enjoyed Popcorn, especially with it's representation of OCD, anxiety and other things similar to that. It also felt fairly accurate to how some school days can go, specifically with the overall tone.

Sophie

KECHG Shadowers

I really enjoyed the style of this book, it was very relatable and funny but there were also moments when it was harder for Andrew. I loved this book and would definitely recommend it.

Arabella

Epsomians

I found Popcorn to be very weak (there seems to be a repeating pattern here). One of the main reasons why I disliked Popcorn was because it was so unbelievably predictable, I realised from the very start what was going to happen and I was not excited to read it from there. The plot was boring and thin. The characters - or lack thereof - had no distinct impact and the main character - Andrew - was the worst, being the most bland person of them all. Another reason why I severely disliked this book was the fact that it is, once again, aimed at a far younger audience. How are these books reaching the shortlist? The illustrations here were pointless other than to make the book look larger, when in reality it only took about an hour to read. To be honest the book being short was probably the only good thing about it. Actually, I lie, I quite liked the representation of Andrew's anxiety as a popcorn kernel in a pan of oil as it helped me to visualise how it might feel to have anxiety. It's clear Popcorn is trying to show people with/without anxiety how to cope/how to help when in a situation like this but I thought it was presented poorly and didn't carry much meaning. Especially the final chapter when he is talking to the bully and they 'resolve' their issues when in reality he would've been punched in the face. Overall, Popcorn was weak because of a thin plot, bad characters and a failed attempt at showing awareness about anxiety. Plot:3/10 Characters:2/10 Setting:3/10 Style:4/10 Total:12/40

Sevan

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Popcorn tells the story of a boy named Andrew Yaeger who has anxiety problems and whose grandmother named G suffers from Alzheimer’s. Andrew’s main mission throughout the book is to get a good school photo for his mum without anything going badly, but all sorts of things go amiss, from a violent bully to science experiments gone wrong and a full-on panic attack. I found one of the most interesting things in the book is the “Anxiety Files” that make understanding the problems of anxiety and how to deal with them much easier. There are also drawings in the book that visualise his anxiety, for example, the sliding “Kernel Scale” which shows his anxiety levels as a kernel of popcorn from chillin’(fine) to poppin’(panic attack); and Tense Kid, who is a human expression of Andrew’s anxiety. I felt that I could relate to Andrew because, like many people, I sometimes suffer from anxiety. I felt reassured at the end of the book when Andrew, with his art teacher’s help, manages to control his anxiety. I understood that if he could deal with his anxiety, other people could too.

Theo

Forest Hill Library

I think that Popcorn is a good book for people with Anxiety. Popcorn is about a boy called Andrew who has anxiety and he goes to middle school. It’s photo day and Andrew is really anxious because he wants a good photo but throughout the book there are some things that ruin his appearance. I liked how it mentioned certain characters and kept on mentioning them throughout the book and assigns different roles to them. I also liked how it explored themes of bullying, anxiety, panic and friendship. I also really liked how they put pictures of teachers on each chapter so readers knew what they looked like before reading about them. Overall, this is a great book about overcoming anxiety.

Leopold

The Perse Carnegians

Popcorn is a book that I felt I could relate to in so many different ways. The author's way of describing anxiety is really accurate and as I watched Andrew get closer and closer to popping I felt like the world was against this boy, but he made it through. I always thought anxiety made you weak but this book showed me that in a lot of ways it makes you stronger. I think this is an incredible read and put a whole new spin on the meaning of anxiety. I would recommend it to people around the age of 11.

Bea

FGCS Bibliophiles 2026

I loved this book it is a fast paced book all about a young boy with anxiety and working through his worries. the main character is called Andrew Yaeger and his grandmother has a bad disease that makes her wonder off. His best friend helps him a lot. My favourite part of the book was when he stood up to the bully. It was also a very quick and fun read. It is suitable for everyone I loved it. Overall I'd give it a 9 stars out of 10.

Jacob

Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

I thought this was a good book, but not the best. It included many relatable elements that reflect a child’s life, but with a twist—focusing on anxiety. It presents an everyday story in a unique and slightly different way. I think this book is great for younger readers with a big sense of humour, as it will make you laugh your butt off.

Olivia

Rainbeau Readers

Popcorn is a funny, heartfelt book about an anxious seventh grader who survives a school picture day with anxiety and OCD. I really enjoyed it.

Senuli

Folkestone Academy Readers

I like how it addressed anxiety, stress and how those can get in the way. I loved how funny it was as well as the illustrations and the final result of the picture, which was a mess.

Connor F

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

It was okay at best. I thought that the plot was fine but the execution was not. I thought that the ending with the bully was not as satisfying as it could have been. Overall nothing special. 4/10

Aiden

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really like this book because there's a number of techniques about getting brought up and they are mentioned through out the story. This is also a great book because it's funny and explains a lot about anxiety.

Erin

Folkestone Academy Readers

Popcorn by Rob Harrell is a story about anxiety, told in a comical, lighthearted way. It is set in a regular middle school and follows Andrew Yaeger as he navigates an increasingly disastrous day, his anxiety (or his “popcorn kernel”, as he calls it) getting closer and closer to “popping”! In the end, he does have a panic attack. But he comes out of the ordeal, in one piece, and learning that he is not alone in his struggles, and that people are always here to help. Issues with a bully are also resolved, and all in all, the book leaves nothing hanging or unfinished. The book balances emotion and humour well, and the representation of anxiety seems authentic enough, without getting too dark or painful. Characters seem consistent, and the book retains a cartoonish element throughout (in writing style as well as illustrations). The ending was realistic and positive. The story didn’t seem overly clichéd, but nor was it especially thrilling. In my opinion, it was a good book but the emotional depth and originality/element of surprise was not enough for my personal taste. I think it’s suitable for all ages, but best perhaps for under-12s. To conclude, this was a well-written book, but more suitable for fans of comedy and lighthearted reads than those of books high in emotional depth, fantastical elements and/or thrilling plots.

yuding

The Perse Carnegians

I’m not sure what to say about Popcorn. I did like the idea of trying to stay neat for the school photo, the one thing that it literally impossible for every school child, but…I mean, it didn’t really hook my interest. I think some people might’ve liked it, but it honestly wasn’t my taste. One thing Rob Harrell could do if he was going back through the book, is to make a bit more action, or find something at some point that livens up the book, something that the main character normally wouldn’t dare to do.

Sherlin

Crypt Bookworms

Throughout the book, Andrews's anxiety is represented as a popcorn kernel being put under pressure until it pops-I found this metaphor really interesting. The book explained a lot to me about what it really feels like to have mental health like this. This book was an extremely interesting as I had never read a book from the mental health category awareness before. I liked how the Author managed to weave so much drama in one day at school and I can empathize with Andrew over how it must have felt.​

theo

Beacon Thursday Book Club

I thought Popcorn was a brilliant and very original idea and especially liked the pressure building and then 'Popping.' However, in my opinion it is slightly too drawn out and in between the catastrophes there is lots of awkward small talk and it feels like a drawn out and boring read in some places. Furthermore the ending is sweet and wholesome but I think it wasn't very credible. However apart from these points, overall it is a good book portraying a relatable state of mind for a lot of people.

Oliver

Tenbury Page Turners 26

Popcorn by Rob Harrell is a book about anxiety and coping with it. It is about a boy named Andrew who has serious anxiety problems and has to go through the school day with out having a panic attack. I liked this book as it probably makes people more aware of people with anxiety and how to help them. 7/10

Sylvan C

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

It's a good book I like it because I like how it is written and the front cover is very cool so I really like it for those reasons thanks for letting me read a cool book.[:

Charlie

Kingdown Wilts

I think this is a good book where a boy starts a new school and its picture day at school and MOTHER wants HIM to start picture day looking nice. Overall I liked the book and think its a very good read.

esa

Carnegie Shadow Judges MEAC

This is an interesting story that walks through the struggles of anxiety for a young boy attending school. The problems he faces may be present in everyday life for students. I enjoyed reading this book because of the author's use of links for everyday life. I would have enjoyed more if some facts were not repeated further and we knew more about the main character's past incidents or achievements. Some illustrations were eye-catching and helped to show what was happening.

Zaydan

Carnegie Shadow Judges MEAC

This is a book about a boy called Andrew Yaegar. I personally don't like this book. I think it didn't focus enough on the actual story line and despite the entire book being only one day I don't feel like there was enough detail. The author just kept going on and on about feelings and anxieties which I know is the point of the book but I think it got very repetitive and wasn't very interesting. Overall 4/10.

Musa

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Popcorn was a really thrilling book, and I really enjoyed reading this. It explained anxiety really well and I like the references to a popcorn kernel. I think it was a really great story and I liked how Andrew had to conquer many, many difficult challenges, especially for him, but I loved it when he found people who supported him and talked to him. I found Jonesy and her obsession with sea life humorous, but also relatable since I really love the aquatic world as well. I definitely learned a lot from this book, and it was an extremely fun story to read.

Raine

Rainbeau Readers

I found Popcorn an enthralling read, it focused on anxiety and the effect it has on a person’s day to day life. However, the plot also proved that even if you have anxiety or are struggling with worries, then good things will always follow. Popcorn is a humorous book, which has great imagery and an intriguing story line. Overall, I rate the book a 9/10, as I felt like it could be based over a few days rather than one. Being based over one day, I felt like it was confusing, for the days felt longer than they actually were.

Evie

Sherwood Shortlist Squad

This book was fun to read. I liked how the author took us on a journey of the main character for that very day, and how it goes very very wrong. Generally, it is a really nice book, and I thoroughly enjoyed it!

Amelia

Weald of Kent Grammar (Sevenoaks)

I personally don't like this book. I think it didn't focus enough on the actual story line and despite the entire book being only one day I don't feel like there was enough detail. The author just kept going on and on about feelings and anxieties which I know is the point of the book but I think it got very repetitive and wasn't very interesting. Overall 4/10

Toby

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Though I really enjoyed this book, I felt that maybe it is better suited to younger readers (I am in Year 8). having said that, I really liked how the protagonist sees his anxiety as a 'popcorn kernel' which pops when his levels of stress build up. His grandma has dementia, and one of the stressful events for him is when she runs away. I found this easy to relate to as I have experienced the same thing with my grandma. This book explores real-life situations and serious topics in a light, refreshing and memorable way.

Indi

Shelf Indulgence by JCG

Popcorn follows the story of a boy with anxiety throughout a school day, which gets worse and worse. This book utilises emotive language effectively to allow the reader to really get in empathise with Andrew. However, it is slightly repetitive and extremely predictable so therefore not very entertaining as a whole.

Arnold

TBGS READERS

The stuff that I liked. It was a fun action-packed book with lots of twists and turns. The saying “the world is against you” is what this book is. Once I picked this book up, I could not put it down. This book got my heart racing. It’s supper book and quite relatable. The comparison of anxiety to a popcorn kernel is funny and light-hearted. The illustrated comics are silly and have lots of comedy in them. The stuff that I did not like. The chapter numbers have parts in them sometimes with symbols others with words and numbers. Conclusion It’s a kind of sad but overall, it’s a really good book. It is one I would recommend to my friends.

Logan

Chapter Chats

I loved the book Popcorn. Its detailing on Alzheimer’s disease and anxiety is described well and (though from books I already knew a little about Alzheimer’s disease) really made me reconsider panic attacks and anxiety. I loved the relashionships and characters most especially the freindship between Jonsey and Andrew. It also makes you think about how lucky some people have it compared to others. The book was amazing and thought provoking and really makes you laugh out loud at everything. It’s filled with funny sad angry and regretful moments. Amazing thought provoking and literary gold. I would definitely recommend this to a friend.

Drupta

HGS Book Club

I thought this book was really good and enjoyable. It was quite a short easy read for me so I would definitely say it is suitable for 8+ but it is still a really good book and I feel like it describes anxiety really well helping many people understand what it is really like.

Arya

Rainbeau Readers

Popcorn is a very interesting book about Andrew Yaeger that seems to be a light-hearted, fun read whilst blending in the struggles of anxiety. The author made it much easier to understand what it must feel like and makes it relatable for the reader. The fact that the book is one progressive day is really powerful and allows the author to really go into fine details. The book also blends humour and there were many times where I almost laughed out loud. Overall, Popcorn was a unique insight and was a brilliant read.

Isabel

NDHS Book Group

I found this book very informative in the way that it showed how the day in the life of someone with anxiety is when they are having a rough day. It also embodies the main theme of anxiety and overcoming in a nice story, where many things are happening and the main character, Andrew, has to deal with it. I also found it imaginative where there are 'half' chapters which give new information and reflect on Andrew's therapist visits; I did not always enjoy this aspect of the book since it breaks the flow of an exciting chapter. Overall, I would recommend this book to teenagers, because the book seems relatable and informative.

Buddhan

The Perse Carnegians

This theme of this novel is anxiety in middle school. The whole book was based on this theme and in my opinion, it would have been more realistic if there had been a couple of other themes because anxiety isn’t the only feeling a person experiences. Also the author did not develop the central character enough; the reader didn't get to see his personality, his traits or any of his passions and interests. Another negative criticism is that the climax was almost instantly introduced. I would still give the book a 3 out of 5 because some bits of it made me laugh and others were quite thought-provoking and overall it was a fun and enjoyable read.

Willows

Shelf Indulgence by JCG

This book was very good! Being a reader of Diary of a Wimpy Kid a few years ago, it brought me back and it felt like that style of book with the odd picture, which was very funny. There was lots of content which I could relate to, especially with anxiety and school photos. I really liked the character of Andrew and it’s kind of funny to see it getting worse… and worse… and worse. I also loved the message I got from the book; it doesn’t matter how you look in a photo, as long as you are happy :)

Isla

Ousedale Shadow Chasers

Popcorn follows Andrew, a Year 7 student who deals with anxiety and OCD. The whole story takes place during one chaotic school picture day. Andrew just wants a normal photo, but everything goes wrong — his clothes get messed up, he has trouble with classmates, and he worries about his grandmother, who has Alzheimer’s. As the day gets more stressful, his anxiety builds, which he describes like popcorn heating up in his chest. The book mixes humour and seriousness which is quite nice. 8/10 👌

Edison

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I liked Popcorn Although I thought that it was aimed more at younger kids, I could still somewhat relate to the character and I thought comparing anxiety to popcorn was a nice way to describe it. I liked the illustrations through the book as I thought they helped you understand how Andrew was feeling. I thought that Andrew having his Grandma have Alzheimers was a good addition as it helped show how he felt with her moving in and all of the challenges of having a relative with Alzheimers. I thought the story built up to the ending well and was quite unrealistic but felt real at the same time. I would recommend this book to people aged 8+ as it shows how anxiety feels for people really well while still being fun for a younger audience. Overall I enjoyed this book and would give it 7/10.

Robin.O

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The story follows Andrew Yaeger, a boy who struggles with anxiety and OCD well that’s my guess . It all happens over one chaotic school day .It’s picture day, which is really important to him because he wants a nice photo for his mum. At the start, Andrew is already worried, and things quickly go wrong. A bully targets him called Gene the mean, his clothes get ruined, including the new nice shirt his mum got him and embarrassing accidents keep happening (like getting hit in the face and messy spills from a ketchup rocket ). Each problem makes his anxiety build upclike a kernel of popcorn heating up,from chiilin to popping which is how he describes his panic. Things get much worse when he hears that his grandmother, G who has Alzheimer’s, has gone missing. This pushes his anxiety to the limit, and eventually he has a panic attack at school, which is his biggest fear. After this, his teachers and friends help him calm down and support him. His grandmother is found safe, and Andrew realises that even though the day went terribly, he got through it. By the end, he feels more confident and accepts that it’s okay to need help. I think that the storyline of the book was quite fast and the book on the whole is fascinating to see what people feel with problems like this normal people take for granted. It’s a nice and easy read which can be read by younger and older people because understanding mental problems for adults and just the pictures and the understandability for kids. I think this is a great book but annoys me a bit because of how much exaggeration is used.

Toby

Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

POP CORN review - Rupert 4 stars overall This book started off by introducing characters well, such as Jonesy and Gene (The Mean). It made me think of possible scenarios that would happen later in the book. The pace of the story started slow, like most books, but it got more intense throughout the book. A build-up was very clear, even showing a popcorn anxiety meter (lower was chill, higher was popping!) that increased when situations were rough. The world was believable, as it was a first-person story of a boy called Andrew with anxiety having a picture day in school, however some of the parts of this book seem unrealistic. I would give the PLOT of the book 3 stars. I have already mentioned the plot loosely earlier in this review, but I found that shifts through scenes were hard to follow, for example, one chapter Andrew is at school, the next he's at therapy and the next he's back at the same school day. The end does satisfy me, as Andrew meets someone who also had anxiety and that person manages to calm Andrew down. The themes would go into comedy since it made me laugh a lot while also being [a word for dealing with stress]. The characters were all different and equally good, and I found myself getting annoyed at one of the bad people! This must've been on purpose and it did emotionally sway me in some areas. I would not re-read this book but it was enjoyable (books I re-read must be top-tier).

Rupert

Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

At first I was confused about what popcorn had to do with the book, but then it became clear when the author gave us an insight into how Andrew deals with and explains stressful situations: he visualises a kernel of corn, slowly getting closer to popping. This was a really interesting way to show how anxiety manifests in people; and the illustrations really helped show how Andrew is feeling. It was also interesting to see how Andrew's attitude to the school pictures changes throughout the day, as at first he is really anxious and wants everything to be perfect, but gradually he becomes more accepting that he can't control the outcome and becomes more relaxed.

Philippa

Shelf Indulgence by JCG

At first I was sceptical, but I actually really enjoyed it, I really like the characters!

Emma

Dunraven

It was a very nice book because I enjoyed how the author laid it down in the text, like the character was writing talking to the reader like they were talking to us . When I saw the name I didn't feel like this book was a nice book but when I carried on reading I under stood the meaning of the name and how the book refer to someone's life [for real] .

Marissa

Book Lovers Unite!

POP CORN by Rob Harrel is a very funny but it also has quite serious moments .It is about a boy called Andrew who has social anxiety and feels really embarrassed about his school picture.But Andrews bully Gene Phillips is a rich kid who makes Andrews kid dreadful as Andrew lives with his grandma and his mum who This book teaches you how school can be when people judge based on how you look and this is why I would recommend this book to people our age because it shows what can actually happen and that you need to treat people with empathy.

Abhinoor

Xenial Readers of Rushey Mead 2026

This book is about a boy named Andrew Yeager who suffers with anxiety in his everyday life. His symptoms include having panic attacks, having to tap with his fingers for a certain amount of time e.t.c. He goes to school on picture day certain everything will go well with everything organised well to make the picture perfect. However as his day goes on, his day seems to get worse adding the level onto his popcorn anxiety scale, which he uses to make sure the one thing doesn't happen in school;him having a panic attack. I think that children aged 11-14 should read this book because it may be relatable to some people who also suffer with anxiety and also this book has comedy in it to make the reader understand anxiety .

Jiya

Xenial Readers of Rushey Mead 2026

"Popcorn" by Rob Harrell is a heartwarming and humorous graphic novel that centers on the life of Ethan, a shy and artistic middle schooler who is terrified of public speaking; The story beautifully captures the anxieties and triumphs of adolescence as Ethan and his friends embark his fear and step out of his comfort zone. The narrative is filled with vulnerable characters, laugh-out-loud-moments, and touching scenes that highlights the power of friendship and self-discovery. Harrell`s vibrant illustration perfectly complement the engaging story, making "Popcorn" a delightful read for anyone who has ever felt the pressure of putting themselves out there

Ayush

Xenial Readers of Rushey Mead 2026

The book Popcorn follows the story of a boy named Andrew,who struggles anxiety in school. the book is set on a chaotic school picture day . Andrew has to face a series of tense events such as facing a school bully , a science experiment gone wrong and news of his grandma being lost . the book tackles themes of OCD and anxiety management and accepting advice and support from others . I personally thought this book was not too bad but i would recommend this to someone who needs help with anxiety in a fun way

Praneel

Xenial Readers of Rushey Mead 2026

What I liked most about Popcorn is how it tackles the 'internal noise' we all feel sometimes. It’s a brave book because it uses humor to talk about things that are usually hard to explain, like fear and pressure. The story shows that being brave isn't about not being scared, it's about how you handle it.

Lojine

Lionheart2026

Although I don't normally enjoy reading this type of book, it was a surprising adventure to read. It was very comedic and I personally loved the little illustrations you treat yourself on every few pages (drawn by the author, as well!). As well as that, I think that the author's aims in writing this book are very impactful, informing people about anxiety, panic attacks and how to deal with them. I really loved Jonesy and Andrew's friendship because, despite their differences, they continue to push through and talk after fights. The plot moves quite slowly. I did get second-hand embarrassment from some scenes, but I think that just adds to the interest, doesn't it? Overall a nice read and I would recommend to childen around the age of twelve or to those who tend to stress and worry a lot.

Erin

The Tiffin Girls’ Shadows

This book has been a hugely fun read! Most of it was relatable to me and I liked how Jonesy (best friend) always got Andrew's back, even when the worst happens. The illustrations clearly showed how Andrew felt throughout his dreadful day. I would recommend this to others and I rate it 9/10.

Teni

Carmel Shadowers

Popcorn is a truly heartwarming and informative book, going deep into truly what anxiety feels like and what it can lead to. Every character is unique and interesting, and the story still contained a lot of humour. I also thought the illustrations added a lot to the plot, because we could experience anxiety visually, as well as from Rob Harrell's own words.

Jude

Carnegivores

Popcorn is about Andrew's ( a boy with anxiety ) day and how everything goes wrong in it. In this day Andrew's grandma (who has Alzheimer's ) goes missing and he gets hit in the face with a basketball and lots more. Towards the end of the book this all leads to a panic attack. This book was good because it showed how we don't know what's happening to someone or what there thinking and how it all lead to a good ending.

Samuel H

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

At first, I wasn't sure if I would like this book but as I kept reading I became invested into Andrew's story. Living in a single parent household, G having alzheimer's, Gene and obviously his anxiety. I appreciate how Rob Harrel used his own experiences to make Andrew's behaviour more realistic and eye opening in a way. The part when Andrew had his panic attack was probably my favourite part not because I liked seeing him suffer but because I sympathised with him so much. I could feel my own breath become shallow like his and my heart rate faster and it felt like I was on this roller coaster of emotions with him. Even though this book deals with quite sad topics, the frequent jokes, comics and parts when Andrew seems to break the fourth wall and talk to the reader lightens the mood. Overall, I enjoyed this book and would give it a SOLID 3.99 out of 5. It's ONE of the better books in this shortlist but I'm not sure if it has that extra wow factor to bring it to the top. The only reason it didnt get four+ stars is because the mc was younger than me and usually I prefer if the mc is either the same age or slightly older than me, which might seem a bit random or dumb but i can't help it. I like how the book takes place on one day and seeing how has bad day just gets worse and worse.

Emaan

Carnegie Shadow Judges MEAC

Over the last week I was reading the book Popcorn. The plot followed a boy call Andrew and his day at school on picture day, you see Andrew has anxiety as he makes it through the day the popping scale get closer and closer to the end. All he wants is a good photo for his mum, though that becomes increasingly harder throughout the day as he get bullied, bad news about his grandma and exploded on by a school experiment gone wrong. The main characters are Andrew, Jonesy (Andrew's best friend), and his Grandma. I would say that the style of the book is humorous and cartoonish as we see 'The Anxiety Files' describe how Andrew feels all through the book. The theme of the book mostly centres around OCD, anxiety and how stressful a normal day at school can be. Overall I think that Popcorn is a great book for anyone who struggles with OCD/anxiety or if you just want a fun read.

Edie

Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

Popcorn shows Andrews day at school and the challenges he faces and overcomes . I think it was a good book and showed a good representation of anxiety especially at school . I liked the rhythm of the book as it kept me reading and I enjoyed the pictures and little comics throughout. The characters were also good and overall I would give this book 4/5 stars.

Holly

Vista Academy Littleport

I loved the book, it allowed readers to easily immerse themselves in the book and it shows the struggle in school with anxiety and OCD. I loved how it wasn’t unrealistic and not everyone will be accommodating to others' disabilities. What I also liked in the book was that the characters helped him get through his panic attacks. What I also thought was good in the book was the idea of a scale with a popcorn kernel that pops when Andrew has a panic attack. It allows readers to learn what small things could trigger a panic attack and how they could be more accommodating, This book relates to a lot of people, even if they do not have anxiety or OCD. Everyone can relate to feeling overwhelmed and fear of being judged by others. This is what makes the book so good, it allows readers to have an emotional connection to the book.

Junaid

Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

"Popcorn" by Rob Harrell is a great read. In the perspective of Andrew Yaeger, a boy who suffers with anxiety, you begin to see what life is like when you have anxiety. The style of the artwork and drawings make the book seem a bit childish. The book partly makes up for it in the well thought out incidents that happen throughout the book. Overall, a good read. 7/10

Elliott

Hope Valley Literati

'Popcorn' is an excellent book. It shows the feeling of anxiety very well and things just go from bad to worse. It is very funny and also not preachy as I was worried it might be from the blurb. I deeply enjoyed it. As someone who gets quite anxious, I felt it showed the feeling of anxiety very well and shows readers - especially younger ones - strategies and other information in a non text book style. Nor did it feel like a book your parents might buy for you that you open the first chapter, find it too preachy or textbook like, then put on a shelf to never be read again. 9/10 book would recommend to anyone who gets anxious.

Grace

KES Readers

I like this book because the story revolves around topics such as anxiety and dementia. While, this book IS fictional, it feels real and gives you a good understanding on what anxiety can be like. If you like this book, I’d suggest you read “Goldfish Boy”

ZakH

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

After I finished reading this book, it was like breathing a gulp of air. Everything that happened in the book was very quick and unexpected and it was a relief when the book slowed down to a steadier pace towards the end. Although it was quick and fast-paced, it was quite relatable to my own everyday school-life, such as rogue basketballs and failed science experiments. Overall, this was a great book-8/10-but I think it would have more effect on the reader if the story was stretched across multiple days, because since this book is about school, it’s quite unrealistic and would feel less constricted if the story was stretched along even just two days. I think that at the end, Andrew Yaeger was very brave to take the school photo, considering his incredibly gloomy day, his lost Grandmother, his panic attacks and his new shirt being messed up, he showed that he truly learnt at the end of the book by braving the school photo. This also shows that even with disabilities, you can still overcome anything. I think the moral of this story is to never give up and stay positive.

Felix

The Perse Carnegians

I really liked this book because people commonly think that things like OCD is just a quirky label that you can use to feel special and unique when you like to have your desk organised, but it’s actually a lot more than that, and this book shows how awful it can really be when you suffer from it.

Lorin

Carnegivores

it was very emotional but not relatable for me as it was about someone with anxiety who had a bad day. However, the book was good and it reminds me that after every dark night there is a bright day coming up.

Gracious

Baxter Booklighters

I thought that this book was bursting with humour and plot twists whilst also having a serious but interesting message incorporated in the story. I think that the author has written this book very well and I am keen to read more books by him.

Pyrros

NDHS Book Group

I think that popcorn is a relatable book for kids around my age, and it really emphasises the stress around looking nice and presentable for a photo that will be your identity for a whole academic year. Overall its a really nice book and i would recommend it to people who like reading relatable books.

Emma

9y4

I think this book explains anxiety perfectly and just stress specifically from school in general. Can’t wait to finish reading it.

Sage

Lit Legends of Swavesey

When I first saw popcorn, I thought that I wouldn't like it as it isn't the type of book that I normally read. However upon reading it I found it was actually really good and quite enjoyable. I found that the topic was very relatable as lots of people like trying to look good and smart for school picture day. My favourite part was when he was with the nurse and the art teacher. I would recommend this to ages 10-14 as it is a bit young. Overall, I would rate this book a 6.7/10 as it has got a good plot but it isn't really my cup of tea.

Amelia M

Skipton Shadows

I liked this book and I enjoyed the story

Anna

FGCS Bibliophiles 2026

I find Popcorn a very interesting read because of the deep topic of anxiety and how you’re not alone in the world and there are people who understand you and want to help.

Luke

Waddesdon Shadowers 26

Popcorn by Rob Harrell is one of those books that makes you laugh—until it suddenly doesn’t. It takes on a lot: anxiety, OCD, bullying, family pressure, and a grandmother living with Alzheimer’s disease—which hit especially hard, as Alzheimer’s is close to my heart. And yet, it never feels overwhelming. Instead, it holds you there, balancing humour and heaviness in a way that feels real. The portrayal of anxiety is painfully accurate—the slow build, the spiralling thoughts, the sense that everything is about to “pop.” The kernel metaphor works brilliantly. What stands out too is how naturally coping strategies are woven into the story—no preaching, just quiet, useful support. Andrew is easy to root for because he keeps trying, even when everything is going wrong. His friendships feel genuine, and the thread with his grandma is handled with such tenderness—no drama, just that quiet, recognisable grief. This book really understands children as whole people dealing with big things. It’s funny, honest, and deeply kind. One I’d hand to any student who feels things a little too much.

Mrs Ward

BCS Book Squad

Popcorn is a fantastic novel in which we see what life is like to have anxiety through the eyes of a young boy. It is crazy, moving, exciting and explores themes such as friendship, family and ordinary things people with anxiety really struggle with. I really enjoyed this book because I got to see the world through someone else’s eyes- which assisted me on how to help others who are coping with a similar situation. I would wholeheartedly recommend this book to everyone. -Molly.

Molly

Chiswick Carnegie

Popcorn is about a boy called Andrew who lives with his Grandma G, who used to work at his school. At his school picture day, he is determined for everything to be perfect for his grandma. However, Andrew has anxiety, which makes it harder for him to cope when the day inevitably starts going wrong. I enjoyed Popcorn because I think it was well-written and funny and it made it easier to understand topics that might otherwise be quite difficult to talk about, such as anxiety and Alzheimers.

Alexandra

Chiswick Carnegie

I really enjoyed popcorn as it is a really good book. At first I was a little unsure but I really enjoyed it. It displays a character with anxiety and their struggles at school picture day. It has a deeper theme of accepting issues, bullying and mental health issues and how it affects peoples lives. I would recommend this book.

Carolina

SCD Pageturners

i liked the book because i liked the part about anxiety was my Favourite part 10/10

Jaxon

SCD Pageturners

This is a great book with emotions that are strong and hard to manage. It is about a boy struggling with his anxiety, describing it as a popcorn kernel. He's trying to suppress panic attacks and manage family problems in this story. I would award it 4 stars, out of 5!

Elspeth

Montsaye Shadow Readers

Popcorn by Rob Harrell is a funny but also quite emotional book. It follows a boy called Andrew who goes through a very stressful situation, and the story shows how he deals with it. The book is easy to read and understand, and it explains anxiety in a clear and realistic way. Even though it talks about something serious, there are lots of funny moments that make it enjoyable and not too heavy. The illustrations add extra detail and help show what Andrew is feeling, which makes the story more engaging. Overall, Popcorn is a really good mix of humour and serious ideas. It’s an enjoyable read that also helps you understand important feelings.

Iqra

Skipton Shadows

Popcorn is a really good book for age 9+.As the story says everyone has anxiety things happen also children and young teens. The story is close to our real life which is really thoughtful when we are reading it. And it actually gives a lot of suggestion when we are feeling anxiety, which is really good book for me.However, I found out some of the things that the character is anxiety about is actually a bit boring for me, probably because I had already experienced it and I have solved the problem by myself. But it’s a good book for someone that need some suggestion and don’t know how to see the anxiety.If I would score the book out of 10, I will give it 7. And I will absolutely recommend this book to some of my friends and also my brother or some of my cousin who don’t clearly know what is anxiety and how to solve these problems if they are experiencing it.

Christine

Lit Legends of Swavesey

I think this book is totally amazing. It has helped me understand the theme of anxiety through the use of humor and comic-like drawings making it easier for people to understand hard topics like anxiety. It rushes into events without really building up and I think this is really effective. It is well written and quite emotional making it a really catchy read. It also touches upon another hard topic of alzheimers with humor making it so more people can understand the disease. Overall this book helped me understand hard topics and was a really good read.

Rose

Skipton Shadows

I really liked Popcorn as the book was full of excitement and comedy, but my favorite thing about the book was its originality. You don’t come across books everyday where someone is anxious and is going to have to take school photo. This also makes the reader understand that everyone gets anxious. From this book we were reminded that it is important not to laugh at people as sometimes people can be upset even if they don’t show it. What I also really liked about the book is its comedy. I find it really funny when Kendrick’s ketchup rocket hit Andrew in the head and when Gene puts too many of the crystals in Andrew’s science experiment I just felt like everything went wrong for Andrew. All in all I really recommend this book for people of age of 9 to 13, as it is an easy enjoyable read, and not to challenging to understand.

Christopher

4Shadowers

I read Popcorn from Rob Harley and really appreciated this book: it is the story of a boy, named Andrew, suffering from anxiety, and of his catastrophic day at school. The reasons that I loved this book are that the author managed to make this novel both funny and touching. The author Rob Halley also made great illustrations to go with the story which makes it be even more hilarious and entertaining.

Marc

4Shadowers

I really liked the book pop corn for various reasons.First of all I thought that this book was very captivating and easy to read .In addition i absolutely adored the art work that reflected the main characters anxious personality.Lastly this book was very funny but quite sad at the same time , for example what i thought was quite sad was that the main character’s grandmother has Alzheimer and that the main character’s father abandoned him .Overall i really enjoyed this book i'd give a 10/10👍👌

Matheo

4Shadowers

I love reading, but some books just don't click with me -but not this book. As soon as I started reading, I knew that I was going to love it. This book was so well written and the illustrations really well placed in the book and showed what was going on perfectly. The book was written in Andrew's (the main character) perspective, which really helps you feel what the character is feeling. Andrew describes anxiety in a very interesting way which really makes it easier to understand and it makes it a lot nicer to read because even if you haven't been through it, you can understand it.

Eva

The Shady Bookhounds

Popcorn was an intersesting read for me as it showed the experiences of a young person having anxiety. I enjoyed it as i have not read many books like this. It was also important how the book included a family member with dementia. It was nice to see how the boy coped with his experiences.

Jennifer

GreatB00ks

Popcorn is an amazing book. It is very emotional and funny at the same time. At times, it is also very relatable. The book "Wonder" is a very similar book just even better.

Mendy

Belsize Stories

Gripping, very realistic, but I don't like the topic it's dealing with but it's well written. Good for 10-12 year olds

Yishai

Belsize Stories

I have awarded this book 3.5 out of 5, overall. It is about a boy called Andrew, who suffers from anxiety and in the story it is picture day. He is wearing his new shirt which he can't get dirty. But the world is out to get him today. There's a bully, a ketchup rocket and many other problems.

Olivia

Montsaye Shadow Readers

All Andrew needs is a good school photo to bring back for his mum but today it is like the world is against him. The school bully hates his guts; his new shirt is ruined. There is a rogue ketchup bottle and a science experiment gone wrong. When things can’t get worse, his worst nightmare comes true. Andrew’s anxiety is described as a kernel and the kernel is being heated until it is so hot it pops into popcorn. My favourite character is Jonesy (Andrew’s best friend) because even after their fight, she was still loyal the whole way through. I would recommend this book to people whose family suffer from Alzheimer’s or people who have anxiety.

Ailsa

Vista Academy Littleport

I really liked reading this book, Popcorn is written in a really engaging way and succeeds in capturing the readers interest. This book also deals with the difficult topic of anxiety in a way that is understandable for the target audience and gives an insight on what its like to be a teen living with anxiety. The small illustrations help make the book even more engaging. I particularly liked the story line of this book (the day of the main character keeps on going wrong with obstacles in his way throughout the day) as its a very nice, short read that anyone could enjoy.

Basia

Thomas Tallis Reads

I liked how the book gets the struggles of anxiety and panic attacks really clearly. Also I enjoyed the comparison of the stages of panic compared to a kernel all the way to popcorn. One thing that I would've liked in this book was more adventure, so maybe when G is lost when Andrew is in school, Andrew escapes and tries to find his grandma. Overall I enjoyed the book, though.

Henrique

Elms Shadowing 2026

I found this book quite enjoyable but there were a few moments that I found confusing. I think it really raised my awareness to people with OCD and other mental anxiety struggles though I thought the comedic side was a bit lackluster. I think the story was very interesting and different to other books in the genre, and I think the storyline was really well thought out. Overall, I think it was a very nice book and was enjoyable to read but I expected more comedic success for a book that heavily relies on that.

Teddy

Elms Shadowing 2026

I liked Popcorn because it is about a boy called Andrew who can't cope with anxiety and there are really fun pictures to illustrate the words. I would recommend this book for ages 9+, and for people who like books about anxiety. It is also quite funny and Andrew has lots of accidents during the day, such as standing up to bullies and has mishaps in P.E.

Sara Malka

Hasmonean Pages

This book is about a boy named Andrew who has anxiety and is trying to get through his photo day, which is very important to him. However there is the school bully who is trying his best to stop Andrew from making his perfect photo. The main character is Andrew. I wasn’t very keen on his character but I thought he was very determined. My favourite character was Jonesy because she is very bubbly. I really liked this book and I loved all the illustrations.

Evie

HHS 2026

This book is about a boy called Andrew who suffers from anxiety. On the picture day his mum buys him a new top to look good but then over the course of the day disaster happened. It was full of little doodles, which at first I struggled to follow but I ended up actually enjoying them. The book was all about anxiety and his levels were shown on a 'popcorn metre', his levels went up significantly across the day. Overall this book was surprisingly enjoyable and has helped me to understand what different people might be going through and never judge someone.

Conor D

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I thought that the book was interesting and comedic. It taught me lots about anxiety that I didn't know before. I think that Popcorn was a worthy winner and I would like to see more books like it. More people (old and young) need to learn more about anxiety; this book is a good first step into the impact of anxiety. G (the grandma) also has dementia, this book can also help you learn about dementia. A great read.

Wilbur

NDHS Book Group

Popcorn is a great book for explaining anxiety and I especially love how it shows and lets the reader keep track of the characters anxiety levels during the book. I also like how it mentions that you can supress anxiety and the fact it mentions that bullying leads to anxiety.

Arthur

The Fitzharrys Shadows

I think Popcorn by Rob Harrell was a very good book; I liked how the story unfolded and how almost everyone can relate to the main character. The story is about how life has it's ups and downs and is sometimes stressful and that you need to just overcome the obstacles as there will be brighter days; It also includes tips on how to handle stress and anxiety.

Eleanor

Bassingbourn Readers

Popcorn is the story of Andrew who suffers from anxiety. Andrew compares himself and his anxiety to a kernel of corn in oil and shows this in a sort of anxiety graph with at the end the kernel popping. Today is picture day and he is stressing about keeping his shirt clean. Andrew’s day goes completely crazy with his grandma going missing, a bully destroying his shirt, some much hated ketchup sprayed at him and an explosive science experiment. How muck heat can his kernel take before popping? I loved this book because it is full of humour and is also a book anyone of any age can red and enjoy. There are also drawings and caricatures in the book to illustrate the most funny and awkward moments.

Sibylle

4Shadowers

Popcorn was a short book that took on quite impactful and prevalent topics. I felt the writing style, pictures and overall tone were aimed towards a younger audience and how to introduce them to the concept of anxiety. However, I felt that even though it was written for a younger audience anyone could read this book and finish it with an idea about how anxiety can make you feel. Overall, a good book which conveyed its ideas in a clear and concise way that was easy to understand.

Benjamin R

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Popcorn follows the story of a boy called Andrew Yaeger on his school's photo day. He suffers with anxiety and school is a daily challenge for him. Andrew refers his levels of anxiety to a popcorn kernel, it "pops" when he experiences an anxiety attack. All he wants is a nice picture for his mum, but as the day goes on, that option starts to disappear. In my opinion, this book did not resonate with me as much as other books I have read. However it does share Rob Harrell's interpretation of anxiety which could relate to lots of other people.

Jacob

Larkmead

Popcorn is a novel which deals with Andrew, an ordinary student who must face several hardships on his first day of school. I enjoyed this book, because it draws us, in its way, into a tumultuous and intense atmosphere while putting forwards serious -or even light issues- such as anxiety or Alzheimer disease through the story of a secondary school student; this enables us to feel closer to the main character who faces these different problems in his everyday life. Moreover, it was written in a rather concise way, which is, I believe, convenient. However, the author’s writing style did not seem appealing to me: I found the book quite boring. It lacks liveliness which contributed to that tiresome feeling I had while reading it. Additionally, this novel lacked varieties of focalizations in the different chapters, such as the bully’s, for instance, which could be relevant. Furthermore, I also think this is too stereotyped; it is ALWAYS the “nerd boy” getting bullied and bearing all the world’s problems (poverty, anxiety, the KETCHUP?, the bullying, he’s bad at sport and sciences, and so on and so forth…). Finally, the main character did not appear great to me. Indeed, the author made him too “different”; why not introduce a lambda character who gets bullied? This, would appear more realistic- I could not relate at all while reading the story. The character barely has friends, there is lots of blood and violence, and he is STILL at school. They don’t do anything about the bully… In short, I think this story is a bit exaggerated- perhaps it is due to cultural differences between France and the UK ? It feels like I am watching TV. Overall, I did enjoy reading it for the Carnegie contest, yet, there were several elements which did bother me.

Zoe

4Shadowers

The Author did a really good job at portraying anxiety in this book. At one point, the main character, Andrew, suffers from a panic attack due to all the pressure of needing to look good for the school photos being taken (but everything messing his appearance up, which also stresses him out because he's a massive germaphobe and potentially suffers from OCD), his grandmother - who has alzheimers disease - going on a "Walk", which meant she basically went missing for a while, and his best friend and him having a mild fall-out, and I especially liked that segment for the use of stains/ink blots being printed on the page further exagerrating how the panic attack felt to him. It reads a little like Diary Of A Wimpy Kid in the sense that it uses tons of pictures to add to the story, which does admitedly feel a tiny bit childish for me (I'm not quite the target audience, ha, ha) but overall it is a nice read! At the end there's also been placed some resources like books and websites to help kids understand/cope with anxiety and relatives suffering from Alzheimer's, which I feel is a nice touch. Popcorn explores a ton of different topics and many are executed in an understandable way. It's a nice book and I'd reccomend it lots!

Klaudia

Ousedale Shadow Chasers

‘Popcorn’ by Rob Harrell is revolved around Andrew and the growing ‘kernel’ in his stomach. Picture Day has arrived and Andrew desperately wants to take a good picture for his mum. The book follows Andrew as he navigates through the day, with disasters happening left and right, and his anxiety growing. This book represents a lot of deep themes, including OCD, bullying and panic attacks. I especially liked the clever way Rob Harrell used to portray anxiety, with the ‘kernel’ in Andrew’s stomach and the way it grew closer to popping every time something dreadful happened. The representation of the themes in this book is immensely accurate: how panic attacks feel, the coping strategies and how challenging it can be to deal with Alzheimer’s. Despite these deep themes, the book manages to be funny and entertaining. The combination of the humour and mature themes balance the story really well and I would recommend this book to anyone who likes to read about deep themes in a relatable and funny way.

Hailey

Helkats & Hardbacks

Popcorn is a novel about Andrew Yaeger, who has anxiety and a grandmother who has Alzheimer's. He has to take a school photo and keep himself clean enough for it, whilst fending off a panic attack. I found the plot interesting but the language was very simple. As a result, I would reccomend this book to a younger audience. Overall, this book just didn't interest me. 7/10

Elijah

Vista Academy Littleport

Popcorn was such a new and different read for me as I have never read something that is about anxiety and ocd disorders before. I feel really grateful that I have read Popcorn because it has helped bring awareness to me of how people with anxiety disorders may feel and how I can help them and be a kind and supportive friend in the future. Furthermore, I really enjoyed the formatting of the book and how it was written in a first person perspective so that I could experience all of Andrew's emotions throughout his journey alongside him and it felt like a really intimate experience. Also, I think that the anxiety journals and the popcorn anxiety meter were such smart ways to showcase Andrew's thoughts and feelings and express what it is like to have anxiety in an interesting and fun yet still educational manner. Overall, I really bonded with Andrew's character throughout the novel and I think that Popcorn is a very special, quirky, funny and informative must-read for everyone because it will help us to support people, especially children and teenagers, with anxiety disorders in the right way and learn to understand a bit more about what they go through. I really enjoyed Popcorn and I also loved the bright, graphic cover that encouraged me to read the book in the first place!

Aliana

The Maynard School

I read Pop Corn by Rob Harrel. The book follows a young boy named Andrew who suffers from anxiety. Through comic book style illustrations and writing the writer plunges the reader into his day and struggles.  The main problem I found with the book was its weak plot, minimal charachter developement and childish story. Throughout the book, we learn little about the protagonist, which makes it difficult to feel connected to him. Furthermore, the plot is basic and infantile and leaves the reader feeling like the story is rushed. Another problem I found with the book was the way the writer seems to be writing a guidebook to panic attacks with the techniques and suggestions for handling having one, supporting someone who is having one or supporting someone who just had one. This textbook approach to writing that seems to be taking over from what used to be entertaining creates a rising sense that for a book to be recompensed it must have one or many didactic messages. For me personally as a reader this makes me feel a deepening sense of dissapointment at the turner that children's litterature is taking as it moves further and further way from the epic sagas like Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings towards lessons in kindness, sex education or mental health. Though these topics are no doubt important, they go against the principles of fiction in which you dive into a fantastical paralel universe. In conclusion, although Pop Corn does present an important topic, its lack an engaging storyline, character development and a developed and intricate plot. While its aim in educating children about panic attacks and anxiety is valid, the result is a dull and repetitive story similar to a guidebook far, far, far away from the epic chronicles that used to be litterature.

Felix

4Shadowers

I absolutely loved reading Popcorn! This was such an amazing book and I loved how it portrays anxiety, and gave me a better understanding of it. It also gave off the "Diary of a Wimpy Kid" vibe. This book was light as well, even when showing large descriptions of the situation. However, because of these descriptions I didn't really think it was necessary to use comic-like pictures, but if it helps both the reader and author, then it doesn't really matter. Overall, I loved this book and it helped me understand anxiety a lot more!

Afreen

Skipton Shadows

I expected this book to be a lot better than it was, and I will say I am a little disappointed by it. I didn't expect there to be pictures, and, again, I feel as if this book is aimed at children younger than me. However, I learned a lot about Alzheimer's Disease while reading this book (a topic I am quite new to) and that was a concept I felt was elaborated on enough.

Clara

Bassingbourn Readers

Pop Corn is an easy-to-read book set over one day from the first person perspective of a boy, named Andrew, who deals with anxiety. Andrew wears his new shirt to picture day, determined it will go great! He could not be more wrong. First, the shirt’s collar gets ruined, then he gets a pretty bad nosebleed, then he’s found out his grandmother is missing, he’s then involved in a science explosion, and finishes the day off with a panic attack. The events are funny, but the reader feels sympathy for Andrew, especially through the tension and skill of the writing. It shows that anxiety is a real issue, and helps people with it to understand and deal with it.

Kirsty

Vista Academy Littleport

I really enjoyed Popcorn my favourite part is when Andrew came back inside during lunch and a ketchup bottle came flying down into his face. Even though it wasn't funny for Andrew I think it was because that ketchup bottle could have landed anywhere else but it had to land on his face. During this book I felt really bad for Andrew because he was having bad luck this whole day and it had to be picture day as well. My favourite character has to be Dr Cain because she has helped Andrew a lot with his anxiety and I just love how she wears her fluffy socks during work no shoes just fluffy socks. My least favourite moment of this book is when Gene (has Andrew would say "Gene the mean") ripped up Andrew's new shirt for picture day. I would recommend this book for people who love hilarious scenes but also for people who likes a little but of awkward moments.

Natalia

Vista Academy Littleport

I felt this book was filled with character. The doodles were very funny and the content was very deep and emotional. I myself don't have anxiety but I can imagine that someone who does would find this book more relatable than me. I still enjoyed this book though.

Thomas

Forest Hill Library

I absolutely loved this book! A beautiful exploration of anxiety that was truly organic and authentic, and is aimed at an age group who may not have had much exposure to mental health education. It takes the classic school comedy tropes and totally flips them to offer an accessible and empathetic reflection on anxiety in children. I normally find illustrations somewhat unnecessary in books, but loved them here as they were a story in themselves; they did not just describe the story, they added to it. I’ve genuinely got nothing bad to say about this book - I’m only sad that I’m above the target audience!

Eve

St Kaths

Popcorn. It is interesting to read and a good book as it basically says "It's fine to not be embarassed about things that are different about you than the general public." (Or atleast, that's my interpretation of it...) But, personally, the book feels like reading a book from "Diary of A Wimpy Kid", which isn't a bad thing, but it was a bit more childish for me. Overall, good book with a coherent plot, but seemingly intended for a slightly younger reading age.

Namish

4Shadowers

Popcorn was an interesting book! I really liked how it talked about anxiety, OCD and germophobia without sounding preachy and textbook-like. It was an interesting mix of a graphic novel and a book– and I really liked the analogy of a kernel of corn getting hotter as things go wrong throughout the day. However, I did find that it would have been better suited to a younger audience as I didn't find it challenging at all. The storyline also seemed very busy and didn't really allow that much space for characters to develop– all of the events happening in the space of one day seemed rather implausible. Overall, I would recommend it to a younger child– but the descriptions of anxiety and OCD were very well written.

Jackie

The Perse Carnegians

I found Popcorn an enjoyable read, as I felt drawn to the characters, and could relate to them. I loved the humour in this story as it lightened what could be quite a dark and depressing book. Although this story was dealing with some very challenging issues- for example OCD and severe anxieties- it portrayed them really accurately as something we can’t get rid of but can help, and also the extreme challenge of living with Alzheimer’s. I liked the writing style as well, and would recommend this book highly. However, I have also read Rob Harrel’s other book (Wink) and I did prefer it to this one, because I felt it had a better and slightly less complex storyline. Overall, I would reccomend this book for 10+ and rate it 4/5 stars.

Lottie

Beacon Thursday Book Club

An interesting read that perfectly enraptures the feeling of the gradual buildup. Slowly leading to the moment where you *POP*. However, I felt that some events seemed a bit too out of place in the story, though the tension in the book a much more exciting read.

Alisha (O)

LSST Library Shadowers

Popcorn is a book about Andrew Yaeger, a child who suffers with anxiety. He has had to give up his bedroom for a grandmother with Alzheimer's, had his father abandon him and now it's picture day, and when everything goes wrong, can Andrew make it through the day? I like Popcorn because it juggles funny with issues that people are facing right now, in real life. My favourite character was Jonesy because she is really kind and forgiving. I would recommend this book who anyone who likes humour. My favourite part of the story was the exchange between Andrew and Nurse F after an incident in the gymnasium because it showed how kind and funny Nurse F was.

Catelyn P

Vista Academy Littleport

Pop corn is an amazing book about a boy (Andrew) struggling with anxiety issues and a panic attack at school is his worst nightmare. This book shows his rollercoaster of emotions on school picture day. Andrews worries and anxieties are described and illustrated very well. The author Rob Harrell wrote Popcorn in Andrews first person perspective wich helps you really feel just what he does ( he being Andrew ). The book relates to what Rob Harrell went through, since he had anxiety as a kid as well. I really recommend this book to students that like realistic books and books about school drama.

Arietty

The Shady Bookhounds

This hit me in that very specific way where I’m laughing… and then suddenly not. Because Popcorn by Rob Harrell is doing something quite difficult, and making it look easy. On paper? This is a lot. Anxiety. OCD. Bullying. Poverty sitting quietly in the background. A grandma slipping away piece by piece with Alzheimer’s. A parent stretched thin to breaking point. And a kid just trying, desperately, to hold it all together on picture day of all days. It should feel heavy. It doesn’t. Or rather, it does. But not in a way that crushes you. It holds you there instead. The anxiety in this book is… painfully accurate. That slow build. That tightening. The way small things don’t stay small. The way your brain turns on you, quietly at first, then all at once. The “kernel” metaphor? It’s perfect. Because you can feel it. Heating. Pressurising. That inevitable pop hanging over everything. And what I really appreciated, this isn’t just representation for the sake of it. It’s useful. Genuinely. There are coping strategies threaded through the story so naturally you almost don’t notice you’re learning them. No preaching. No textbook tone. Just: this is how it feels. this is what might help. And yet, this book is funny. Actually funny. Not forced. Not awkward “we need comic relief here.” The kind of humour that sits right next to distress because that’s exactly how real life works. You can be on the edge of a panic attack… and still notice something ridiculous. You can be overwhelmed… and still laugh. That balance is so hard to get right. Harrell nails it. But what stayed with me most? The tenderness. Andrew is so easy to root for. Not because he’s exceptional. Because he’s trying. Even when everything is going wrong, and it really, really is, he keeps trying. The friendships feel real. Messy in small ways, but fundamentally kind. Supportive without turning into some perfect, unrealistic safety net. And his grandma… that thread hurt. Quietly. No melodrama. Just that slow, recognisable grief of someone fading while still being there. This book understands children. Not as problems to fix. Not as “issues” to explore. But as whole people navigating things that are often far too big for them. And somehow, it makes space for all of it. The panic. The fear. The love. The absurdity. All in one school day. It shouldn’t work. But it really, really does. This is one of those books I’d press into a student’s hands without overexplaining it. Especially the ones who feel everything a little too loudly. 5★

Mrs Naden

Lostock High Readers

I really enjoyed this book, which is filled with humour, pathos and a realistic depiction of anxiety. Set over the course of one day, it was a roller coaster ride. Despite everything going wrong that could go wrong, the supporting characters helped Andrew get through.

Caroline

Central Teen Reading Group

‘Popcorn’ by Rob Harrell is a book which explores themes such as friendship, mental health and bullying. It follows Andrew as he struggles with his anxiety on school picture day, and all of the problems he encounters on the way. I would recommend ‘Popcorn’ for anyone who enjoys school stories with humour.

Isolde

HHS 2026

I really like this book, it managed to feel funny and amusing aswell as relatable and comforting! The story had a deep meaning and message that was carried by a series of bad things happening to the character in his journey to get the perfect school picture. I did enjoy it however it did feel a little basic at times. All in all a really nice book that tackled mature themes in a easy to understand way and made me smile!

Agnes

Lit Legends of Swavesey

This book really represents anxiety well. I wouldn't know about how it represents OCD, as I don't have it, but it gave me a good understanding of what it is and how its like to have it. The descriptions of panic attacks are really accurate and I love how everything seemed to go wrong in his day, because that happens to me! amazing book :)

Anika

Norwich High Bookworms

This book is about Andrew. He lives with his mum and Grandma who he nicknames G. Andrew has anxiety and has a hard time at school with the school bully Gene. However, the school photo day is finally here and all Andrew wants is for his anxiety to disappear, for him to be germ-free and for him have a successful school photo. But when trouble and commotion visit Andrew, will he be able to succeed the school photo in the end? The main character in this book is Andrew. I really liked his character as he has gone and is going through a lot but continues pushing and never gives up. My favourite characters in this book would have to be the Nurse and Andrew’s art teacher. I thought they were both extremely supportive and kind. I really enjoyed this book. I thought it had a good combination of the humour and real life aspects to it, so it taught you a valuable lesson but also in an understanding and down to-earth way. I would definitely recommend it.

Priya

HHS 2026

I did not enjoy this book as I found the story really boring because I thought the story was very uninteresting. I would recommend it to young kids or people who wish to learn the basics of anxiety but not for people who want a fairly interesting story. One good thing about it was that it seemed to show the challenge of Alzheimer correctly.

Hasan

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I loved the book as well as the story line. Every thing about the book is brilliant. So emersive and made me want to keep reading even after it finished.The illustrations were beautifully done. Loved it!

Hollie

St Kaths

I loved this book, it gave a lot of laughter also this book included some of the real difficulties like anxiety and OCD. What I liked most was that it was middle - school themed.

Adidev

The Fitzharrys Shadows

At first I wasn't sure - I thought that this might be another 'tick box' exercise, but I was quickly won over by how sensitively the author addressed a range of topics. Not only did he give a really accessible description of what it feels like to have a panic attack, he spoke with sincerity about the realities of living with someone with Alzheimer's Disease. This made me really warm to his character, Andrew. I also appreciated him showing that not all teachers are ogres - there are goodun's out there who care for the student beyond their grades. Thank you!

Mrs Webb

Vista Academy Littleport

Popcorn was an interesting book to say the least. It dealt with adult problems in a way that younger readers like us can understand. Many people don't know what a panic attack feels or just plain old anxiety. Now despite these adult issue being explained. This book was most certainly a read for younger children with the concepts not being explained fully and in their full form. I personally enjoyed the book but also felt a little disappointed with the short read time with it taking me just an hour to read in total. Overall 7/10

sam w

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

In Popcorn, a young boy in Year Seven, Andrew Yaeger goes through a messy day on the most important part of the year, Picture Day. Andrew talks about his grandmother ( dubbed G ), his hot - tempered dad ( who left Andrew and Andrew's mother). He also talks about his three visits to his therapist, Dr Cain. She helps him talk about his struggles and even the author, Rob Harrel, includes some breathing techniques that Andrew learns from the Doctor. His BFF Jonesy, School Nurse Finnegan, Art teacher Mr Kellerman and Principal Mr Espinosa comfort Andrew throughout the day.

Rafa

Chiswick Carnegie

I really enjoyed Pop Corn because I found it interesting to see the world through the eyes of someone with anxiety. It is written from the perspective of a young boy called Andrew, who struggles with anxiety. It is picture day at his school and his mum and grandma want him to look the best he can however he has a very unfortunate day leading him to get a school photo that looked quite different from what he expected. I love how crazy his day ends up being and I found it fascinating to see how his day affects his anxiety. It is a great book and I highly recommend it to all but specifically to people who enjoy seeing the world from a different perspective.

Hattie

Chiswick Carnegie

This book is very interesting and funny. I love how Andrew only just wanted to take a picture but then the day turned upside down. It was honestly hilarious! I couldn't get my nose of the book.

Morgan

St Cath’s Shadowing

Popcorn was a great book about anxiety. It was full of little doodles, which are first I struggled to follow but I ended up actually enjoying. The plot was pretty basic but although I don't really get the actual popcorn one, some of the analogies were really good. I wish I had read this book a couple of years ago. I quite liked the ending but found it weird that the author decided to squish all those events into one day rather than having it over a longer amount of time. This book opened my awareness of anxiety.

Aidan

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The book Popcorn is a very relatable book that holds a much bigger meaning and could help people struggling with OCD, anxiety, panic attacks etc mixed with a tad of humour. Andrew uses a kernel of popcorn as a representation of his anxiety growth. Overall I really liked this book and found it fascinating.

Poppy

HHS 2026

As soon as I heard I could read this book I got so exited. I knew I would like it just from the front cover and I really love the artwork. As I started to read it was amazing and I love how it's based around my age, (year 7) so its very relatable. It did make me panic at some times but overall I loved it and I would read it again.

Scarlett

The Shady Bookhounds

Andrew is a boy who has anxiety and needs to take a school photo when life decided to give him a hard time. I like it and give it 8/10

Tejas

The SGS Book Bandits

In Popcorn it is about a boy called Andrew who has really bad anxiety. It is his photo day at school but he is worried that his photo might not be perfect because he has to survive a full day at school with his luck he'll be lucky to get out alive. It contains illustrations of his anxiety levels on his popcorn meter. I would recommend this book for the younger population because it might not be as interesting or griping for adults. Overall i would rate this book a 7.99/10 because at the start I was struggling to get into it but as time passed I got more and more interesting.

Ayaan N

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

What a lovely book. It explains anxiety in a way that is understandable even to those who do not suffer from it. I was moved by the depth of this book and I had a few laughs along the way. All in all, most enjoyable.

Mrs Muller

Folkestone Academy Readers

Amazing idea and I found it hard to stop reading because I felt like the main character relates to me just that they show it more. I also liked how it had many links to how people with OCD or neurodiversity might struggle in the real world. Overall, I saw it as an extraordinary book that is easy to follow and really engrosses the reader.

Henry

St Kaths

This book is about anxiety and relating it to popping a popcorn kernel. This book is a little young for me so I would recommend this for 8 year olds. This is a 3 out of 5.

cody w

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Poor Andrew - what a disastrous day! It was really useful to learn how it feels to be anxious and how we can help our friends who are struggling with this. Despite all the terrible things that happen, this is still a very entertaining story. Top marks to the author!

Bibliophile

Angmering Book Lovers 4 Life

I found this book quite enjoyable and it had an interesting plot, however it was quite an easy read. It was interesting because it was about anxiety, and it showed some real coping methods, but also showed the harsh reality that people can't always get the help they need to cope with problems, and even worse - when they start getting the help, it has to be cut short. It was not the best book I've ever read, but not the worst, so I rate this book 6/10.

Edward M

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed this book because when I started reading I really didn’t want to put it down. It is about a boy (Andrew) who is just trying to get a good school photo for his mum who is starting at a new job. They live with their grandma who suffers from Alzheimer’s while Andrew suffers from anxiety. But his picture day turns out to be really quite the day . . .

Erica

Folkestone Academy Readers

Good consistent plot, in a simple way spreads awareness of anxiety and how people who experience it may feel. They also explain the way people feel during a panic attack and gives some examples of grounding techniques. While also addressing the fact many things can build up into a panic attack and to not fear if it does happen as there are many people to support you.

Julia

Reepham Reads

How can one day at school go so wrong for just one person? While Andrew's friends can laugh off or accept what occurs (see Kendrick's canteen ketchup incident) he finds it difficult and the anxiety levels rack up till the corn of his brain is literally popping. My opinion of Andrew changed throughout the book as the sources of his anxiety come to light and the worry that he will turn out like his absent father Dan, a fastidious yet angry person. The support Andrew receives from his friends and school staff is phenomenal and he finds a kindred spirit in Mr Kellerman the art teacher. Loved the apt illustrations too. This book should be in school wellbeing and learning support settings as well as the Library.

Mrs P

Cake a Book Club

A deep meaning behind a colourful cover, this book is so perfectly written that it shines a little light inside you. It is such a sweet book with a deep meaning which is almost like the perfect blend: not too sweet, not too sour.

Charlotte

St Kaths

An amazing piece of writing considering the metaphorical idea of popcorn to the harsh reality faced by many due to anxiety - causing more struggles in their personal lives. By writing this exemplary book alongside the use of imagery, it encapsulates the core purpose of accepting anxiety and working around it to make your life better. However I feel like the book could have been longer to explore a more expanded idea - where it would develop into a future rather than a short glimpse of time.

Kaleb

Folkestone Academy Readers

I really like this book and i can totally relate to all of the things that happen to the boy in this book highly recommended

saharsh

Carmel Shadowers

I really liked this book! I found it really humorous and heartfelt, and it gave a really important insight into what anxiety can do to a person, and how Alzheimer's can affect your life. The cartoons inside the book helped me imagine what the characters looked like. I look forward to seeing which book wins the Carnegies!

Miguel M.C

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Stunning book with an amazing story line all BASED IN ONE DAY a true masterpiece of the best ocd main character book ever well done

Neave

Carmel Shadowers

I loved this book! It covered very emotional and serious themes while also being funny in it's own way. It is about a boy who only wants a perfect school picture for his mum but his day ends up going horribly wrong.

Amelia

SHHS shadows

Popcorn by Rob Harrell is a really interesting book that talks about anxiety and how to overcome it. As Andrew goes through his day, readers watch him move up the popping scale (getting more anxious) until he’s about to burst. Popcorn helps the reader understand what it is like to have anxiety and how friends can always make you feel better. If you like books with funny and real elements this is the perfect book to read. I really enjoyed this book because of the catastrophes and humour.

Annabelle

The Fitzharrys Shadows

An enticing book about anxiety and the stresses faced by school and personal environments. With the incredible metaphor of popcorn, the book acts as a reminder of individuals who struggle with anxiety. As a shorter book, it allows younger readers to understand themselves, as well as understand the experiences for others who struggled. Otherwise, it's been a highly successful book as far.

Kaleb

Folkestone Academy Readers

Popcorn is a book about a middle school boy in America facing challenges including anxiety, a grandma with Alzheimer's and a bully. It describes his emotions, thoughts and tells us how he is really feeling about the problems he faces. Rob Harrel starts the book by introducing us to Andrew Yaeger; a boy struggling with anxiety, Susan; Andrew’s hard working mother intent on not losing her brand new job, and his grandma called G who has had Alzheimer's for a year and a half. These characters face various problems throughout the book like financial difficulties. G often forgets who Andrew and his mum are and Andrew has to sleep in the kitchen because G sleeps in his room. The day the book describes is school photo day and Andrew is trying to keep as neat as possible for his mum. Unfortunately, after a bully rips the collar off his shirt, he gets hit in the face with a basketball and a science experiment explodes in his face, Andrew doesn’t think the day can get any worse. That’s when he gets a call saying that G has gone missing. The book focuses on Andrew’s difficulties with anxiety and how he accepts help from the adults around him. This is a theme that many children will relate to today. I really enjoyed this book because it tackles important themes in a relatable way. It made me laugh and cry at different times. I also liked the layout of the book where some pages would be handwritten extracts from his diary. I would recommend this book to anyone 10 or over who likes to be challenged by what they read but in an enjoyable way.

Greta

Helkats & Hardbacks

I really enjoyed this book, 'Popcorn'. It is a funny, relatable story and really good if you have known someone in the same or similar state to the boy in the book. It is about a boy who has anxiety attacks, ADHD and autism. He has 'picture day' one day, his mum has a very important interview and his grandma, who is the most precious thing to him, is at home with care. The day takes a horrible turn.

Samuel

Brentwood Carnegies

This is an interesting book about a kid who has really high anxiety. I find this really interesting as it shows that even if they look fine they may be in pain or stressed on the inside. it also has a bit of humour and when there is humour it always ends up making it worse for Andrew (this kid with anxiety) as it stresses him out. His grandma goes missing, a science experiment explodes in his face, there's a ketchup rocket and a bully. How could this day be worse? A panic attack.

henry

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed the book. The comparison to a popcorn kernel was quite fitting because it allows the reader to really understand how close Andrew is to having a panic attack and also how is he feeling. The illustrations helped because they added to our understanding of how anxiety feels in quite a comical way.

Zeven

Rainbeau Readers

Popcorn was an excellent book because at first Andrew was terrified to get a panic attack at school but at the end of the book he got one and then he learned to cope with it. And he learned his favourite teacher had panic attacks too, but he learned to control it and accept it as a part of his life.

Maulik Linesh

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The story follows Andrew Yaeger, a seventh-grader who is just trying to survive the gauntlet of School Photo Day. For Andrew, this isn't just about a bad haircut; he’s dealing with severe anxiety and OCD. He visualizes his worry as a popcorn kernel in his stomach. Throughout the day, as things go wrong—a bully, a science experiment disaster, and the terrifying news that his grandmother (who has Alzheimer's) has gone missing—the heat under that kernel keeps rising. Andrew’s biggest fear is "popping": having a full-blown panic attack in front of everyone.

Patrick J

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Andrew is a boy who lives with his grandma and his mum, his mum is struggling to earn money with her job. Andrew is boy with severe anxiety and OCD in his life, his best friend Jonesy is very good at basketball and athletic. For Andrew, it's his photo-day and he cares a lot about it as his mum really wants to see how it turns out. He gets hit by a basketball and gets a bad eye and he has to deal with gene the school bully. Gene punches him in the stomach and in chemistry, Gene puts a chemical in his test tube and it explodes over him, his shirt is ruined and his grandma has gone missing. In art, Andrew has a panic attack and punches his favourite teacher. In the end, he calms down and his grandma is found. I really liked this book because its really funny to me. I recommend this book to year 7s

mahiru

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed reading "Popcorn" because I thought it was a very accessible way of describing anxiety to younger students. I think Y7 and above would enjoy this book which describes anxiety as feeling like popcorn kernels cooking. I also found this book genuinely funny in places - often YA fiction which includes humour can be unfunny. One thing to note is that anxiety is experienced differently by different people.

Mrs Copley

Kellett Carnegie Shadowing 2026

POPCORN is a book about Andrew Yaeger, a seventh grade boy, who struggles with anxiety. It is picture day and the book follows his journey through a day in which almost everything that could go wrong, did go wrong. This book highlights problems that someone with anxiety and OCD has and what they might do to manage that. One of these is an analogy of a piece of popcorn "chillin' out in the bag" on a scale to an overwhelming pressure and popping. One thing that I would improve about this book is building on the ending as I feel that it was too rushed and some problems that Andrew was worrying about, though they were solved, weren't fully explained. Overall: 4 out of 5

Felix C

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Honestly, I have quite enjoyed the book. Especially when all the bad things happen. The author seems to highlight that Andrew has anxiety but makes humour out of it as well. He definitely has tried to prove that having anxiety is hard and the problems it causes. Focussing on the session with Dr Clio, we learn that it may not be only the big things but also the small things that cause a problem. Anyway this is the summary of the story: Andrew is a kid getting ready for picture day and trying to take the best one he can for his mom. However, it seems like life is going against him with all the problems, like the basketball incident, a science experiment gone wrong and his bully. The rage he experienced we knew was like a kernel on a scale. For him, a panic attack is when you pop and mainly he is in the middle between uncooked and popcorn. We were able to understand that he was germaphobic when Danny sneezes on Andrew, when a person breathes on him and when he wants to clean desks and arm rests because who knew who could be sitting there. The end of the story is when Andrew is in complete shambles and his photo ends up looking horrendous. I recommend this book to whoever wants to learn more about stressed and anxious people, but not in a really scientific way. If you want humour and wanting to understand problems people have, I would go for this book. I rate this 8/10

Ihsan K

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

POP CORN is a great book to read for you to understand how people with anxiety see the world, and how they feel in certain places. It’s a book about a boy who has anxiety and has to overcome many challenges e.g he has a grandma who is known for wandering around and one day she was just gone, but they later find her safe and sound. When you get further into the book you can see how much his anxiety has grown and how worried he can get. I would recommend this book to Year 7, and maybe Year 8.

Darcy

Brentwood Carnegies

This book was really good . As someone who has experienced what a panic attack feels like I personally think that the author really captured the emotions and feelings .

Sahaana

Denbigh Carnegie Book Club