The Carnegies

The Boy I Love is a beautiful story of two young gay men fighting in World War One. The main character, Stephen is returning to war for the second time as a Lieutenant after losing his boyfriend Michael in his first experience. On the train, he meets a guy named Danny who he is rude to and then deeply regrets how he treated Danny. So, while Stephen tries to make it up to Danny the two grow closer and endure the pain of war together. Stephen and Danny must keep their relationship secret as no one accepts the LGBTQ+ society and they cannot express their true feelings towards each other without being rejected and seen as disgraceful even from their own parents. As the story goes on, the two learn more about each other and the connection between them becomes even stronger. The book explores the different routines and practices performed by the military and also discusses the hierarchal society. This is shown when the main leaders and captains are very bossy and ignorant of those with a lower status. The officers are far more privileged and they force others to do long and difficult work while they relax. Overall this book includes the unfair hierarchy, the poor treatment of gay men and the toughness of war. It was absolutely amazing and intrigued me to discover even more about war, earning my vote. I recommend this book for ages 12-13+.

Rita
FGCS Bibliophiles 2026

Rowan
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Normally, I'm a really huge fan of historical fiction, especially during the world wars, and despite it being an extremely well-written book and incredibly historically accurate, I just found it quite hard to continue this book. I really enjoyed the plot, and the idea of Danny and Stephen's relationship, as homosexuality is a topic that is not often discussed that far back in time. Personally, I think that I'm not a huge fan of action and fighting in books, which is probably why I struggled to keep reading (entirely on me), but the parts that established and continued the plot I thoroughly enjoyed! From a written standard, I thought that both Danny and Stephen were very likeable characters, but my favourite character was Captain Jackson. This was because he was a very honourable, intelligent, and warm character, someone who you could rely on, whilst being a strong commander, treating all his men with respect. Finally, although many people were not huge fans of the ending, I thought it was quite refreshing to have a book where (SPOILER) neither of the leads were killed, and despite not quite getting a happily ever after, still could love each other at the end. Though it was not quite my cup of tea, I do think 'The Boy I Love' would be worthy of winning the prize, and would very much deserve it.

Kate
St George’s Dragon Readers

The boy I love was a book made in heaven for me. My favourite period in history is WWII and I love a gay romance book! I cheered the boys on from the start. I found the fact that Stephen’s trauma caused him to try and protect Danny extremely touching. I did think that the toad and the snake could have been mentioned a bit more with their real names as it confused me further through the book as to whose nickname was whose. The book showed just how hard it was to be gay in those times but how people still manged to find love. I think it raises awareness to an issue and shows how lucky we are to live in society that (mainly) accepts us for who we are. The characters were very well thought through and had amazingly deep backstories that were dropped in bit by bit to explain things, like how Danny didn't want to shoot the man and purposely missed.

Nina
The Perse Carnegians

Theo duP
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book is about a guy called Neon who is supposed to be in bed with his girlfriend aria. Itys keeps rewinding all the way to when they both first met and saw each other for the first time and fell in love. One part of this book I really like is at the start when he’s freaking out hiding in the bathroom. I like how the writer writes about it and the description.

Summer
Vista Academy Littleport

This book is about a nineteen year old boy called Stephen who is returning to fight after an injury. He meets a new recruit called Danny he is smart and talented. They both are finding it very unfair as the summer ticks down to the battle of the Somme. Will their great relationship save them. One of my favourite parts of this book is the first time they see each other and fall in love with each other.

Summer
Vista Academy Littleport

I really enjoyed some aspects of the book; the historical setting was immersive and engaging, and worked well as a vehicle to explore the themes of the book. Although the book focused on a historical time period, I didn’t feel disconnected from the characters or plot, and the overall messages of acceptance are still very much applicable and relevant today. I sometimes found the writing style somewhat heavy handed, and I thought some parts were overly explanatory, which could make the book feel a little awkward at times. There were also some characters and relationships that could have been developed further if the book was slightly longer. Although the book seemed to be written for a younger audience, the subject matter was a little heavier than you would expect, which distracted me at times, but overall I think this is a useful book for it’s representation of LGBTQ+ people, particularly in historical contexts, and it is definitely a good book for kids to read to raise awareness about and normalise these themes.

Tara
JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

The boy I love is a stunning standalone by William Hussey. It starts with the struggling Stephan, who is still mourning the loss of his best friend-and Lover – Micheal, who has recently died at war. But everything starts to change once Stephan meets Danny, cool, charismatic, and totally unprepared for the war that he has chosen to fight. Stephan decides to follow the unexpected tug of determination that tells him to protect Danny. But the feeling he starts to discover, may be even more dangerous than even the war at hand.

Lottie
JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

Beautiful book, I loved the bit when Stephen was drawing as I like art myself. He was my favourite character because of his talents and kindness. I enjoyed the LGBTQ+ romance aspect as it is meaningful and important to our society

Emily
Sale High Readers

The novel brings out the waste of war, and the strength and hope that love can bring. The book’s title and it's eye catching cover show that the relationship of Stephen and Danny will be central to the story but it is also a thoroughly researched, powerful depiction of trench-life. It's a thought provoking read for young people today about how people who were forced to live, work and fight together, of the deep bonds that grew from those experiences, and of the daily dangers that they were forced to endure. The ending could be read as maybe a bit realistic as Danny would have been unlikely to survive but it leaves on a message of hope.

Julie
Tenbury Page Turners 26

Lieutenant Stephen Wraxall, aged 19, is back to action after injury during World War One. There he meets Private Danny McCormick, a young lad who just joined. Stephen immediately gets Danny to be his servant-soldier. Eventually these two form a strong, steady friendship, but it turns into something more deep, and forbidden back then. But then Stephen and Danny were forced to fight in the Battle of the Somme by their corrupt leaders. I enjoyed this book a lot because it was touching and contained some action-filled scenes (and possibly funny!) such as some of the lads getting punished just for taking pictures using a camera, which was forbidden back then. My favourite character would be Danny because he was funny, easy-going (although sometimes on the serious side!) and reliable to Stephen throughout the war. Finally, I would recommend this book to anyone who is looking for a good read and would like to learn a bit more about World War One.

Ibsan
The Perse Carnegians

This was a historically accurate book which combines the power of a war story, where the characters experienced the brutalities of war, as well as a love story between two boys. The main characters, Stephen and Danny, embark on a journey into the trenches, and on the way they realise the cruel facts of war as they fall in love. In my opinion, this was a very touching and real story about world war one. I found many of the characters believable and interesting, even the annoying Captain Beddowes. Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this book, however I would only recommend to older audiences- about 12 years old.

Bowen
The Perse Carnegians

What a fabulous book! Really interesting topic explored in a tender and insightful way. I loved the juxtaposition of the harsh reality of war and the beauty and excitement of the romance. I didn’t know which way it would go towards the end … and then the ending was excellent and very clever. Lovely to see more Historical Fiction on the shortlist – my favourite genre.

Miss Heath
Bassingbourn Readers

A heartwarming story that shows an accurate representation of the hardships of WW1 and strongly supports the LGBTQ+ community in a beautiful, accurate story.

felicity
Waddesdon Shadowers 26

The boy I love was a book made in heaven for me. My favourite period in history is WWII and I love a gay romance! I cheered the boys on from the start. I found the fact that Stephen’s trauma caused him to try and protect Danny extremely touching. I did think that the toad and the snake could have been mentioned a bit more with their real names as it confused me further through the book as to who was who. The book showed just how hard it was to be gay on those times but how people still manged to find love. I think it raises awareness to an issue and shows how lucky we are to live in society that (mainly) accepts us for who we are.

Nina
The Perse Carnegians

Personally, I thought the book "The Boy I Love" was a beautiful novel, diving into the taboos of World War i - for men being gay - and the gradual progression of the deep relationship between Stephen and Danny. Throughout the book, we see the development of the war (and moreover the Somme) but staying true to the main key factor in the book - a romance. In many respects, it reminded me of many books I have heard before (such as Morpurgo's "War Horse" among many), but what excited me the most in the novel was the combination of Danny and Stephen's love to each other, drastically contrasted to the calamity and hate shown in the Second World War. I think the novel really hones down on those in the war that have either been misrepresented in culture or simply disregarded; William Hussey truly puts a light on these beautiful individuals, giving them the respect they deserve, through every page, sentence and word. I'm excited what Hussey will be able to produce to us a few years down the line!

Ryan
The Perse Carnegians

I find this book very romantic and therefore rate this book a 3.5/5 because ->it is supposed to be a war book but it is too much about them to have anything about war ->it felt very artificial like it had an ai backbone style even though I know it is not ->The storyline could've been a bit clearer in my personal opinion ->I feel like there could of had been a bit more about the tunnels and how they figured it out ->The book could have been tweaked in a few places to be a bit clearer ->Overall, this was a good read

Arya
The Perse Carnegians

The boy I love is a book harder to read than the others. Depicted in WW1, Stephen is sent back to Britain with an injury where he meets Danny, a new guy. It was hard to read at first but became easier as the book goes on. Stephen doesn’t even realise he likes Danny until about halfway through and there is a lot of things trying to stop them being together. For example, the war and strict captains and colonels makes it very hard for them to be together. Stephen thinks his life is going to be miserable because the effect war had on him but seeing Danny makes him feel non-ghostly, like he’s more alive again.

William
The Perse Carnegians

I really enjoyed The Boy I love as it was a very interesting and sometimes very exciting book. It was set in World War 1, and it showed how homophobic people were in that time and how hard it was for gay people as they were constantly having to hide their sexualities for a fear of being prosecuted as well as persecuted. It was also a sad and tragic tale as many of the soldiers were killed and Lieutenant Wraxall had flashbacks of that young German soldier who he killed. This book also showed that on either side of a conflict there are good people who do not wish to be at war but would much rather be at home with their families.

Alex
The Perse Carnegians

I really enjoyed the boy I love as it was a heartwarming tale of love and perseverance on the face of prejudice and pain of loss and grief due to the terrible conditions and horrors of the first world war.I really like the emotional bond between Danny and Stephen and feel like even though they are not necessarily always together now their relationship will survive.I also really liked the backstory of Danny and his theatrical life and the kindness of his aunt. Overall, I loved this story and the ending just slightly heartbreaking.

Elsie
The Perse Carnegians

The boy I love: This is an impactful and historical book about a same-sex relationship in the battlefield of world war one. Moreover, it tells a story of what it was like back then to be part of the LGBTQIA+ community, and the realistic, horrifying experience that soldiers had to go through.

Isabel
Rainbeau Readers

'The Boy I Love' is a touching and thought-provoking story about the lives of gay men during the First World War. I think the author did a fantastic job of portraying a gay relationship without any stereotypes. I also really enjoyed the blend of accurate historical fiction and romance, and how seamlessly the two themes intertwined along the events of the book. Overall, 'The Boy I Love' was excellent– and I look forward to reading more of William Hussey's work in the future!

Ayanna
LC Best Books

This book is incredible and a book that tears out your heart then puts it back together in the best way possible. I love this book

Nancy G
SDG Reads

I kind of enjoyed this book as I struggled reading the text as it was really small. The story was really interesting and enjoyable. I would rate this book 4/5 stars.

Matilda
Kingdown Wilts

I really like the boy I love because it touches on the LGBTQ+ community (specifically gays) in a time where it was punishable by death. I also like it because of how good the characters are. I feel like every character was very thought out and not made up as you go. Most of the characters have a backstory, like Danny, he was adopted by his aunt after his mother's death and was brought up around performance life from then on. I really like how the author touches on how these types of backstories change someone.

Alessandra
Kingdown Wilts

When I first picked up The Boy I Love, I was expecting a dreary read, one I would have to read quickly to just get through it. Others I know had told me it was good, but I read all the time, and believed it would not be as good as the (many) books I read for pleasure, which are generally ya romantasy and sci-fi/ dystopian. However, this immediately delighted me. Not only is it a riveting, emotional love story, it is a wonderfully descriptive World War 1 story. Having read a lot of historical books, including a good few from Michael Morpurgo, most are about World War 2, or other events in history. Honestly, I believe that the first world war is often overlooked in history lessons and such, and this was absolutely eye-opening. Its two intertwining plots kept me in my seat and brought me close to tears. I absolutely love this book, and would 100% vote for this in the awards. William Hussey has written an outstanding book. The emotions contained in this book are incredible. The way the author has included the lost stories of soldiers are heart-rending and I believe that this part of history is really important in the way we live today. The companionship between the soldiers, and the bond between Danny and Steven have echoed the relationships that exist in the world today. This book has even changed the way I view myself, as I can now see my sexuality in a positive light and helped me to be proud of who I am. Don't be afraid to be different.

Rose
Kingdown Wilts

I really enjoyed reading The Boy I Love because there is a lot of good descriprion and an inspiring and emotional story. It's first person perspective from Second Lieutenant Stephen Wraxhall, returning from a blighty (time away from the front due to injury). He meets Private Danny McCormick on the train and it escalates from there, I just think the romance moves too quickly, especially for 1916. Stephen has a small feeling and then on the train to the front, suddenly thinks 'I imagine kissing him' and 'It takes all my willpower to keep facing forwards'. I was also disappointed in the end, because it was all going so well and then suddenly a shell landed at Stephen's feet and it all ended so abruptly. Other than that, it was overall a great book full of emotion. We need more historical fiction books like this, to raise awareness of people like Stephen and Danny, and even Alan Turing, who helped Britain to WWII and got no thanks, he was only thrown in prison.

Kirsty
Vista Academy Littleport

The Boy I Love was a good book, and it was written in a way that meant you could have sympathy for the characters. I particularly liked the way that the book went into detail about the fighting in the Somme, and it covered some themes that are quite important - how LGBTQ+ people were treated, for example. It made me glad that society is not generally like that any more. It also made me think about what it must have been like watching your friends die in a muddy field in a foreign country. At the end, I was sent into a moral dilemma, as when Beddows got his 'karma' (if such a thing exists), I thought 'Do I laugh, does he deserve it? But a death isn't funny - but then it is only a book...'. I would give this book a 9/10.

Edward M
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The Boy I Love is a great historic novel about gay soldiers in the first world war and the trials and tribulations they face. The story follows a young lieutenant and how he falls in love with a member of his platoon and the consequences this causes. It is a lovely heart felt story that i would recommend to readers over the age of 14. I would give this book 5 stars out of 5.

Isla
Weald of Kent Grammar (Sevenoaks)

The boy I love was a very interesting book about the war. I also liked how it showed how people would really be treated as a gay person in WW1. It wasn't just accepted as normal back then and was seen as a terrible thing.

Milly
Tenbury Page Turners 26

The Boy I Love is a sweet book with a nice love story, but it gets a little too repetitive after a while. The main characters are really cute together, but they seem to have the exact same problem over and over again. Because they keep arguing about the same things, it feels like the story just goes in circles instead of moving forward. It is a bit sad because you really want them to be happy, but the book just feels a little too long when nothing new happens. I think it is a good book if you like soft romance, but it can get a tiny bit boring if you want a lot of surprises.

Arsene Lupin
College Francais Love Books !

I really liked the boy I love! First of all it covered some very deep and meaningful themes, both LGBTQ+ and the horror and loss of war, and I felt it explored both themes really well! It also brought my attention to something I hadn't really considered, those from the LGBTQ+ community in the past/ in the war and the abuse they faced. The overall story was really good and interesting, and I really felt engaged with the story, and Stephen and Danny as characters. Overall, I thought it was a really interesting, unique and enjoyable book!

Edward L
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I enjoyed "The boy I love" at the start of the book as it showed the start of the love between Stephen and Danny. Unfortunately, I wasn't as intrigued to read the book nearer the end. I was surprised to enjoy the theme of world war I in it though as I do like to learn about that topic. Overall, I would rate it a 3.5/5 stars.

alice
Lost in Pages

The Boy I Love is a very heartfelt and important book for society today. It gives a side to WW1 that not many people know of. Also, It deals with the theme of LGBTQ+ which there are not enough books talking about. It gives young people that are LGBTQ+ positive role models to look up to in Stephen and Danny. It also shows that at the time the book was set, there was intense prejudice and discrimination against LGBTQ+ people so it shows the challenges that people had to overcome back then to find their place in society.

Harry
Bookwizards

8/10 The waste of war, and the strength and hope that love can bring. 1916: Stephen is only 19 but he’s already had a lifetime’s-worth of life-changing experiences in the trenches of the First World War. Now he’s heading back from England, back from injury, back to the Western Front, to lead a group of men as they prepare for the upcoming Somme Offensive. It’s obvious that Stephen is going to find it mentally tough to do his duty after the traumas he’s experienced, but he finds himself warming to a young recruit (even younger than Stephen!), Danny McCormick. Danny's enthusiasm and good humour are infectious, and, unlike Stephen, Danny is not ashamed of expressing his flamboyant personality in front of higher-ups who would view any hint of homosexuality as a crime. Cautiously, their relationship develops and becomes a respite from the horrors surrounding them. The book’s title (the title of a popular music hall song of the time) and its cover, put the relationship of Stephen and Danny in the foreground, but ‘The Boy I Love’ is also a meticulously researched, powerful evocation of trench-life, of the people who were forced to live, work and fight together, of the deep bonds that grew from those experiences, and of the daily dangers that they were forced to endure. We know that the worst day in the history of the British Army, the Battle of the Somme, is shortly to come. Nearly 20,000 British soldiers will die. The connection between Danny and Stephen means that there is positivity, and hope, in the darkness.

Mr Hodgson
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Though this isn’t a genre I typically read, I really enjoyed The Boy I Love. Danny and Stephen's relationship was sweet, and I found both of them to be interesting and likeable characters. Their romance takes place during World War I, a time when homosexuality was forbidden, and I think the story did a wonderful job at showing their struggles. Also, the writing was gorgeous and vivid, which I loved. However, I wished the ending had been a little longer; it felt a bit rushed, and I would have liked a few more details. Overall, this was a great book that I would definitely recommend to others. Four stars :)

Quinn
College Francais Love Books !

While reading The Boy I Love, I almost fell into some sort of spell. For the first 100 or so pages, I was exceptionally tired of the story. In retrospect, it truly helped me build character relationships and get a sense of the setting of our love story. Then the main part of the plot hit and I finished the book in a matter of hours! The initial set-up of the book grabbed me up quickly and I was hooked in a matter of pages. Stephen, and the rest of the main character cast were introduced in a very intriguing way and I really loved Danny's first interaction with Stephen. The foreshadowing of Danny and Michael's similarities and the drawing motif really hit me later on in the book. Mostly, the entire world was very well plotted and honestly very believable. Hussey masterfully weaves the themes of war, love and homosexuality together not by keeping them separate, but making them constantly collide in a fast-paced series of events. Stephen's omnipresent terror doesn't just come from the looming threats of the Germans, but also the systematic homophobia and truly horrendous and unfair commanding officers he had to deal with. Once Danny and Stephen got together, this made the danger of being found out even more relevant, and it helped add to the main premise of the story as a ticking time bomb leading to the Battle of the Somme. Personally, I really loved the characters. They were very well fleshed out, not only as people, but also in the way they interacted with their comrades. For example, Jackson is a very strong person, and he felt slightly stand-offish to me at the beginning. Yet, as the story continued, he opened up and became much warmer to Stephen and he even supported Stephen's relationship with Danny because Jackson was gay himself. I also almost shed a tear at the death of Percy as it really highlighted the brutality of war and losing close friends, even if you've known them for a few months, hurts so much. The overarching themes of loss, like Michael, the German "Kamerad" officer and Percy were also really well explored throughout the book. Honestly, the only problem I had with the book was that it dragged on for quite a bit at the middle of the story. I got exceptionally bored, but that may have just been my experience with the story. One improvement that could be possibly implemented is to maybe pace the book slightly faster in the middle. Other than that, I loved the pacing and premise of the story. Overall, an excellent read!

Roosha
The Perse Carnegians

This book was an interesting combination of a gay romance novel and a World War 1 novel. I think the combo was to over-the-top and the ending was quite underwhelming. If I was writing the book, I would write a detailed description of Lieutenant Wraxall and Danny's experience in the 'push.' I would've liked it more if Danny was crippled or fatally injured at the end so Stephen can have a sad moment remembering him. Also, to give the book more variety, I would've written it from both Stephen and Danny's perspective instead of just Stephen's. I would overall rate this book a 6/10. I don't like either of the genres but I like the style.

Felix
The Perse Carnegians

It was one of the better Carnegies books even though it was a romance book. I felt like the majority of it was a history book and the history seems really accurate and that's what it does best. There are a few problems like how the main character mentioned the German boy he killed a lot more than his previous lover which doesn't make much sense. The deaths were good and all around it was a good book 7/10

Patrick H
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I thought this book was quite good. I think it was very realistic about the hardships of WW1. I do think the start was quite slow but it did pick up the pace. Good book

Ben P
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book was quite boring and most of the chapters were just side quests.

Moeez
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Iona
Tractors

Amalia
Leading In Reading

I found this book to be very touching. When I read it I experienced all types of emotions, happiness, sadness, even anger at some of the characters. This book really sent me on a roller coaster and it was such a thrill!

Amalia
Leading In Reading

This book is about two young soldiers in WW1 that come to love each other. I think that the way it was written was heartfelt and dealt with the topic of LGBTQAI+ and WW1 well. Overall an 8

leo
Waddesdon Shadowers 26

This book is really good as it covers a topic I had not thought much about before and I thought the ending was really good - sad but good - ending how it may have ended in real life, not a false happily ever after ending.

Zoë
Skipton Shadows

The Boy I Love by William Hussey is a book in which Stephen and Danny discover the harsh truth of war and the struggles of hiding a forbidden relationship. It covers themes such as WWI, LGBTQ+ and Discrimination. It is set in the trenches of France and the front lines. I like the historical accuracy used and the mention of a soldier who the story was based on as it made it feel more possible and realistic. However, the story felt a bit slow and some events were very sudden without any explanation. Overall, it was an okay read, and I would give it a 3/5. I would recommend this book to ages 14+ as it contains more mature content.

Sofia
CSGS Page Turners 26

I really liked how this book links to the history of world war one but still keeps a storyline. It helps you think about the struggle soldiers had fighting in the war. The amount of action keeps it engaging and you want to keep reading to find out what happens.

Niamh
Waddesdon Shadowers 26

Evelyn
Ivybridge Carnegie Club

I absolutely loved this book! Not normally a huge fan of romances, but this had just enough historical accuracy and the characters were so well crafted that I actually got really stuck into it! Lots of tears, but also a really great read. 10/10 would recommend and definately my choice for the winning book!

Evelyn
Ivybridge Carnegie Club

I enjoyed The Boy I Love because it was emotional and interesting. The story shows the challenges people faced during World War I and has strong themes of love and courage. The characters were realistic, and the book made me think about how difficult life was at that time.

lea
Waddesdon Shadowers 26

I think this book was really good, show the life of two people having to go through the war with even more to lose than others and how the LGBTQ+ community was so different even 100 years ago, the people in this book all feel real and you can see into their side of the story when it comes to the secretive side of being gay in the army. Both of the main characters were so sweet and both have interesting back stories and lives.

Flo
Dauntsey’s Carnegie Shadowing

This book was not really as engaging or entertaining as the other ones, however, it showed lots of evidence on how much effort the author put into the story, telling us how much the topic really means to him. It was hard to read as each sentence had some sort of jargon. I had to reread each sentence to understand the meaning. It was still a heart-warming, wholesome novel with a very educating ending that teaches people how society treats each other.

Rafa
Chiswick Carnegie

Rating: 4/5 Stars Chemistry with a Heartbreakingly Realistic Ending The Boy I Love by William Hussey is a great bit of historical fiction. What makes the novel so incredible is the tender chemistry between Stephen and Danny. The undeniable spark between them makes their forbidden moments of love in the trenches feel fragile, and pretty moving. Instead of a typical tragic ending where a main character dies, the author has made a different kind of heartbreak. After Stephen is knocked out in an explosion, the story jumps two years to 1918. Stephen has survived, but his sexuality was exposed, unfairly forcing him to spend time in a grim prison for "gross indecency". The book ends with a bittersweet reunion at an art gallery in London. While it is not a magically perfect happy ending, seeing them find each other in a hostile post-war world feels fitting and realistic for the era. The emotional payoff and the undeniable chemistry between the main characters make it a must-read.

Rowen
Ross Readers

I thought this book was quite good, apart from the very start which was a bit slow. However the rest of it made up for it with its entertaining plot, realistic characters and constant action. I think this book did a good job of showing what many men went through in WW1, and how there are good people like Captain Jackson despite many of the other commanders. I enjoyed reading this book and would definitely recommend. I would give this book a 8/10.

Alfie S
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I believe that ‘the boy I love’ is a great book as it shows that you shouldn’t be ashamed by being LGBTQ today and that it should be taught in more books around the world. It is also a book which has lots of empathy romance and discrimination. It is a fast paced book where you’re joining Stephen’s journey through World War Two.

Charlie
Bookwizards

I found this book to be very boring at the beginning of the story due to the changes in the amount of words per page but the more I read, the more interesting it became and I grew more fond for the book. Also I found myself rather invested in the story overall. I believe the book to be a very good read and I would recommend it to other readers

MrGoddytheboddyIV
ShadowBookers

I found this book quite moving and it had a commendable amount of emotional depth and historical detail while maintaining a rather bittersweet tone.

Afizah
ShadowBookers

I enjoyed this book, I think its a very real story that many men likely had to go through. The descriptions of the war and the story it follows is very accurate and clearly well researched, it made it interesting and enjoyable to read.

Felix L
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The Boy I Love wasn’t something I expected to like as much as I did, and it left me thinking about it constantly for a while after I read it. The book being set at a time where queerness wasn’t always accepted made the characters relationships feel more emotional, and combined with the book being set during a war, it created tension, keeping the story engaging throughout.

Dexter
Horsham BOok HUNTers

‘The Boy I Love’ was an interesting read and very likeable. It follows Stephen, a soldier who returns to the front lines of World War I after an injury. Stephen is Lieutenant and he meets Danny, who he first doesn’t get along with, but eventually likes. It explores Stephen and Danny’s forbidden relationship in the 1900s and the fragile but tender love between them. We see Stephen’s past and how it has brought him to where he is now. It shows the horror of war and the brutal casualties at the front lines. The ending was very moving and emotional after the highlighted danger of their relationship and the cost of the war. I would recommend this book to readers that want to read a story of love and explore historical events.

Hailey
Helkats & Hardbacks

Such a beautifully written book! It details so much about the hardships of modern day homosexuality, yet in such a brilliant, more raw way. The setting was gorgeous, all round my favourite book.

Bethan
Horsham BOok HUNTers

The Boy I Love was quite an interesting book. I really liked the setting and learning about life during the First World War. The historical parts kept me interested and helped me understand what life was like at that time. Although some parts of the story weren't really my thing, I enjoyed the wartime setting and the way it brought history to life.

Lucas
Bookwizards

I enjoyed The Boy I Love - the plot was interesting and original, and the characters had depth to them. I felt it opened my eyes to the persecution and discrimination in the armed forces, but Captain Jackson sort of balanced it, showing how there is also kindness and sympathy. I learnt a lot about WW1 as well, especially for a fiction book. I felt that the ending was heartwarming, and showed how that there is always hope, even in seemingly hopeless situations. Emotions were portrayed very well - I could feel some of the frustration when the higher ups don't listen to Stephen and Danny's findings from a mission that they were told to do, which also revealed the flaws in the armed forces at the time. Overall, I found it a nice way to explore the relationship through the lens of World War 2. 7.5/10.

Aashaz Z.
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Absolutely loved this, massive fan of William Hussey's other books. Found it a really interesting read, I love learning about experiences during war and this was something I've never looked at before, so a great read. Really gripping and its so easy to love the characters. Would recommend!

Phoebe
Netherhall Shadowers

I recently finished The Boy I Love and overall, I enjoyed reading it. The story has a sweet atmosphere and some interesting characters that kept me engaged. That said, I felt that the plot moved quite slowly at times. Not a lot of major events happen throughout the book, and some parts felt repetitive. Because of this, I occasionally found it difficult to stay fully invested in the story. I dislike that the book focuses more on emotions, relationships, and character development than on action or dramatic twists. The advice I would give would be to try and avoid repetitive moments, and make the storyline clearer. There is definitely potential in the writing, and I would be interested in seeing how the author's work develops in future books. Overall, I would give The Boy I Love 2.5 out of 5 stars. It wasn't exactly what I was hoping for, but it was still an enjoyable read with some memorable moments.

the Duckling
College Francais Love Books !

The boy I love is a touching novel set in world war ll . It tells a story about Stephen , a young soldier, who falls in love with another soldier, Danny . I thought the book was emotional and engaging . I like how is showed us the importance of love and acceptance even in difficult times . I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys historical fiction

Therrin
Vista Academy Littleport

The Boy I Love focuses on the love of two gay men but, oh no, it's WW1 and it is against the the law to be part of the LGBTQ+ community. Stephen is a lieutenant who is returning to the war for the Battle of the Somme. Danny is a new recruit and is appointed the role of Stephen's servant, then they adventure through a forbidden love in the background of war. I really liked this book but I do not generally like gay books.

Lucas
Hope Valley Literati

The Boy I Love was a very enjoyable read. It was the first book by William Hussey that I read, and I really liked the way the story progressed and flowed - although it did get a bit confusing at times, I still read it in about two days. I found the scene of Stephen getting stuck under dirt and grime after something blew up really fascinating: I enjoyed the description of it and how he felt being trapped, as well as the final scene at the end with him and Danny. It quickly hooked me and I couldn't stop reading. The constant reminder of the young German soldier Stephen killed throughout the whole book was a great addition, too. I liked how the book made me feel a certain way about certain characters purposefully. I ended up giving the book to my friend, who also enjoyed it, after I got a signed addition in a bookshop.

Merry
Ross Readers

The Boy I love is a brilliant books about how difficult war is on everything, and how utterly devastating it is. The plot, romance and characters are superbly crafted, the setting makes it feel super realistic, and it’s a story that will stay with me for a long time.

Amelia
Horsham BOok HUNTers

This book is about a nineteen-year-old soldier named Stephen who returns to the front line in World War I after having his ear blown off by a grenade. He is quite shell-shocked by the horror of war until he meets Danny, a young new recruit. They quickly form a secret, forbidden bond that goes against all the rules of the army. Stephen does everything he can to keep Danny safe as an enormous battle gets closer and closer. I found the war aspect of this book quite interesting, so I didn't not like it, but I didn't like it.

Lucas
The Fitzharrys Shadows

The boy I love was a touching although stereotypical forbidden romance. With the two boys having to survive almost two wars; their forbidden love in a world of prejudice and the battles they face on the front lines.

Hannah
St John’s Book Groups

Beautiful perfect a wonderful literary masterpiece one of if not the best book I have read all year the characters were accurate and the descriptions were wonderful

Freya
Sale High Readers

The Boy I Love is a story about Stephen and Danny, two soldiers during the First World War who fall in love but have to survive against both the Kaiser (German Emperor)'s army and the condemnation of homosexuality by their own side. It was my favourite Carnegies story, one of the books that I absolutely can't put down. The Boy I Love was the best book I've read all year and I would definitely recommend it. Furthermore, I really liked the level of historical detail – I learned so much about WW1 throughout this tale and it made me shocked how horrific the public views were on homosexuality in that period. Overall, it was brilliantly written, with amazing description – I felt like I was really there. 10/10!

Louis
The Fitzharrys Shadows

The Boy I Love is a historically accurate book about a forbidden relationship, the brutality of the trenches and Social class in the First World War. The story is about two boys, Stephen and Danny, and how they look out for each other against their common enemy, their cruel leaders. They try to get them to stop the battle of the Somme, as they knew that it would fail. William Hussey threw in lots of important detail that made this book come alive. I had huge fun reading this book, and felt that it portrayed the barbaric and wasteful loss of lives that took place due to higher command's idiocy. It is definitely for over 13s, though.

Benjamin
The Perse Carnegians

In first place I have chosen The Boy I love, as it told a story we all know of, of the war, but from a different, unique perspective. The Boy I Love is gripping, thrilling, and terrifyingly accurate depiction of life in the time of the war.

India
Broadland Bookworms

At just nineteen, Stephen has already survived a year at the front. Now he is returning to the trenches to lead a platoon, despite his wounds. Broken-hearted from the loss of his first love, Stephen wonders what he's fighting for. Then he meets Private Danny McCormick, a smart, talented young recruit. From their first meeting, there's something undeniable between them – something forbidden by both society and the army. I didn't really enjoy the book because of how hard it was for people who fought in the war. It is not normally my kind of genre, but Iearned a few facts and found some of it interesting.

Michelle
Vista Academy Littleport

The boy I love is an amazing book about the strength of love between two people during a terrible moment in history. Stephen is a young, troubled lieutenant who has seen the terrors of war and experienced them first hand. Danny is a new soldier, not used to war and the trauma that comes with it. Stephen is originally annoyed with the fact that he can act so happy and joke around, I think that he regrets that it got taken away from himself too quickly and is sad that the same will happen to Danny eventually. When reading the book I was immediately aware of the amount of loss that so many families had to face during that time, Stephen at the start had lost his best friend/boyfriend to the horrors of war and this is another reason that he felt the need to protect Danny so much. Danny on the other hand, got as close to breaking the rules as he possibly could- not on purpose, but just because he was speaking up for those who were too scared to and I respected that in him, especially as he could’ve gotten killed for it and he did get punished eventually, getting tied up to a post for three hours with no water. The most important part of the story for me is when the troop of soldiers Stephen leads make it into the enemy trench during the battle of Somme and realise that the Germans weren’t killing machines that followed the orders they were given happily, many of them had family and partners back home that they wanted to see again and were quite similar to the men in Stephen’s own troop. Who knows, maybe in a different circumstance they could’ve been friends. The ending for me was bittersweet, Stephen got injured by a piece of shrapnel embedded in his thigh and had to be taken to hospital and then eventually served a two year sentence for being gay. During that time Danny had to fight in the ongoing war without Stephen, neither of them knowing if the other was alive. Eventually, they reunite in an art gallery at the end of the war and that’s when the story ends. I was happy with the ending because i was free to imagine what happened to them after, whether they got back together but had to face the discrimination they would receive for being gay or decide to just be friends but remember the feelings they had for each other. Overall, I loved this book and would definitely read it again if I got the chance :)

Frankie
Tractors

it was an amazing book. way better than the rest in my opinion. I loved how it portrayed what gay men went through in the war. and the ways they had to hide their sexuality. i love gay books the have great stories , this was a phenomenal example . i would love to read more books like this

Evie
Stratton shadowers

This book was an amazing sense of war but also relationships, the plot advances at a steady pace while collectively introducing characters through the use of many nouns and adjectives to describe their personalities. Hussey does a good job at juxtaposing the trench warfare and battle, which differs from the love story throughout the entire book. Beyond the warfare in the book, the book tackles / brings attention to the social prejudices and opposition that gay / queer soldiers has to endure on top of the physical trauma and drama of the war itself.

Joshua
Stratton shadowers

Take yourself back in time to a world many years ago. It’s World War One and Lieutenant Stephen Wraxall is going back to the front after injury. On the train, he meets Private Danny McCormick, a new recruit. Stephen realises he has a mission – to save this boy from war. But as their friendship grows into something more, will their love save them or destroy them? The Boy I Love gives a very different outlook on World War One. It realises the horror of the whole thing – these boys fighting for a country that condemns them. You learn a lot of history unconsciously through reading this book, I think. It was interesting to hear more about these battles that we’ve all been taught about – The Battle of the Somme particularly. They lived in this book as they’ve never done before and it feels very real. I’ve read The Fights That Make Us before, which also looks at LGBTQ+ but from today’s perspective. If you enjoy The Boy I Love, I think you would also enjoy The Fights That Make Us. Private Peaceful by Michael Morpurgo also looks at WW1 and the soldiers at the front, which I’d recommend if you want to know some more about WW1. The Boy I Love is a touching story of love and loyalty and I would definitely recommend reading.

Erin
Larkmead

I really loved this book! It reminded me that queer couples have always existed and what consequences they had to face. The setting gave an interesting twist on the plot. The epilogue made me scream a few times, I temporarily stopped reading to shout about Steven's horrid father!!! I was disappointed in Robert's opinion although it made sense for the time. I remember my excited cheers when things finally started between Steven and Danny. As did steven, I platonically fell for Danny due to his kind personality. I cried with them about their trauma. Also , I'm no.1 Bedowwes hater!

Lily
Sale High Readers

This was a slow burner to start with but the action did rack up halfway through. This was another side to to World War 1: forbidden love in the trenches and how Stephen and Danny start and manage their relationship despite all that was going on around them. The author had researched aspects of the War incredibly well and you felt you were in those places with the characters. A stark difference between the entitled officers at HQ who had rarely set foot in a trench or been in combat so lacked any understanding of the Tommies who were existing on a knife edge in those trenches. For those who want to know more there is an excellent list of sources at the end of the book.

Mrs P
Cake a Book Club

PERFECT This book accurately represents the struggles of a gay relationship in the early 1900s, especially in war, where the punishments were severe, including hard labor or even death. It also has a pretty accurate retelling of the first world war and the battle of the Somme. It contains emotional, suspenseful, happy and drastic scenes, all well done and all have the desired effect on the reader. The descriptions of emotions and violence are well portrayed and i felt like i could see and feel the surroundings and experiences. It doesn't give a perfect 'happily ever after' ending, but still gives hope. I think this book is a good mix of historical accuracy and fiction. I think this would be a good book to present the knowledge of gay relationships and experiences in war to those who don't already know about it, however knowing about it previously gives the story more suspense and fear for the characters. I love this book 9/10

Alice
Sale High Readers

I thought that 'The Boy I Love' was written phenomenally with so much detail and a narrative that kept me gripped throughout. The description of landscape and of characters was just so that I could perfectly picture every scene, and although I know that I can never properly understand the horror of the trenches during WW1, I think that Hussey did an excellent job of trying to replicate such an environment through printed word. I was impressed at how we were given just enough information about each character for them to be used effectively as plot devices but also not just to seem to be tools used to keep the storyline going. I thought that especially the protagonists of Stephen and Danny were well-described and made to seem like real people. Another particular thing that intrigued me about the story was that I couldn't genuinely tell how it was going to end like I can roughly predict with so many others. The author was careful not to drop enough hints for us to be able to tell if it would end happily or tragically, which I think must have taken some skill. One thing that I would change is to make the story less biased against the 'top brass' because it uses a lot of stereotypes to make them seem lazy and not-in-touch but in reality it wasn't like that for everybody. Overall, I really enjoyed it and highly congratulate the author on such a work of literature.

Matilda
Bassingbourn Readers

I quite liked this book, I think it had a good story to tell and anyone could understand the emotion and hard work the people go through. It had action, love and hate in it everything a good story should have.

henry
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I enjoyed this book very much, due to its incredibly moving story and well written characters. I found the LGBTQ+ representation was very good.

Richard
Bassingbourn Readers

I like the characters but I feel like the LGBTQIA+ aspect was a little bit poorly written and it seems a little bit rushed and I feel their story is not very developed.

Ashe
Bassingbourn Readers

The boy I love is painfully truthful to its time and shows how a gay relationship may be persecuted in the 1st world war, and the struggles in hiding it and the fear of being caught.

Matilda
Sale High Readers

I love the character development and relationship building as the story progressed. It was laid out well.

luke
Bassingbourn Readers

I enjoyed this because it was an incredibly moving story! My favourite character is definitely Private Danny.

levi
Bassingbourn Readers

The Boy I Love is a novel about two men falling in love in world war one. I liked the LGBTQ+ representation and the way the author described the war. The romantic scenes were good. The writing style was very nice and kept me hooked throughout the book. I found the start of the book a bit hard to get into but once I got a few chapters in I got invested in the story so much that I couldn't put it down. I like how the book contrasted the romantic scenes and the war. The way that war was depicted in the war was realistic and I think it portrays the more gruesome aspects of the war. Overall I loved this book and would recommend it to people who are interested in war or like romance.

Sophie
The Fitzharrys Shadows

In 1914 world war one started and lieutenant Stephen Wraxall goes back to the front after his company is killed when a German patrol ambushes them. Stephen is the only survivor after playing dead he shoots a young boy just after he tells the lieutenant one word kamerad when he returns, he learns that his close friend Michael has died. On his journey he meets a soldier called Danny. Stephen wants to try and save him from the war so he chooses him as his soldier servant and as things develop he finds himself attracted to Danny, but he has to hide it so he isn’t court marshalled and killed.

owen
The Fitzharrys Shadows

This book was amazing. It taught me how cruel it could be back then during the war and also how devastating and horrible the war was. It showed that people were treated badly for being themselves and the inequality there was. The start was really hard to get into but as soon as I got past the first 4 or 5 chapters I was glued to the book. The plot was amazing and I really liked how it lined up with real historical events. Overall I really enjoyed it.

Nyree
FCC Book Group

In The Boy I Love, Lieutenant Stephen Wraxall is coming back onto the battlefield after having a wound. He meets Private Danny, and immediately wants to save him from the terrible thing that is the war. He makes Danny his soldier servant. As the book goes on, many of Stephen’s platoon die. I think what I like most about this book is how realistic it is. I especially liked the way the author expressed this. Another thing I like about this book is how Stephen feels so many emotions and progresses as a character throughout the book. In the beginning, he was grieving for Michael’s death, on the train he was disappointed in the system of conscription, in the marching he felt anger for the person made to march on an infected blister and of course he always feels love for Danny. Due to this, I would rate it a 8.9/10.

Siddharthan
The Perse Carnegians

The Boy I Love is a book set during The Battle of The Somme in WW1 and is about the relationship between Stephen Wraxhall and Danny McCormick. It was a time when relationships between two men was illegal. The two soldiers had to keep their relationship secret while doing their jobs and fighting Germans. I enjoyed this book because of the descriptions of trench warfare and how soldiers lived as well as showing people who had to hide their feelings. It's not a book genre that I would normally choose but I liked this book. My favourite parts was when they went across no - mans land for 'The Push' as it was suspenseful if they would survive or not. I would recommend it to people who enjoy books about: warfare and love between people of the same gender. Overall I would rate it a 7.5/10.

Lydia
Larkmead

I enjoyed the presentation of homosexual relationships during WW1 and how society responded to it. It's written well, hooking me with Stephen's cautious emotions and memories, and Danny's lively personality. However, I believe that the title and cover are slightly misleading, where I thought the book was more of a romance when in reality it's more of a historical romance, and goes into quite graphic descriptions of war and trauma. Furthermore, in my opinion the progress was quite slow, and I took a while to get invested in the book, but once I was around Chapter 6 it had all my attention.

Anon
St George’s Dragon Readers

'The Boy I love' is a thrilling novel about wartime romance. It explores LGBTQ+ culture in the past and shows how far we've come in accepting people who have different beliefs. I would highly reccomend to those who enjoy a romance novel with a bit of adventure and thrill. Very good book.

Verity K
The Mockingjays

Very good and entertaining. Keeps you on the edge of your seat and has interesting historical facts. Would recommened.

Emma
The Mockingjays

I didn't like the main aspect of this book with the two boys being together but i did like how the book illustrated how gay people were treated in the 1900's. It shows how if someone found out about your desires. your whole world would turn upside down. This shows how far we have come to supporting the LGBTQ+ community and how we can all be united as one

Akmal
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book was very emotional, talking about how the war can split and destroy so many relationships and how really brutal the trenches in the battle of the Somme was. The book was ok but I would not read it again

Joshua R
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I quite liked this book the aspects of a a big story before this book is based about Michael's death intrigued me I also like the character development of Danny and how Wraxwell looked over him whilst also looking after his troop (wing thingy). I liked how Wraxwell and Danny developed as a pair, but I think it was a little bit rushed. 7/10

Billy C
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book honestly surprised me so much with how well written it was. It never once downplayed the horrors of war or the lasting trauma caused by it. If anything, I feel like the romance drove home just how devastating the war can be as it destroyed so many relationships. I liked the pacing of the plot, things also felt natural between the main characters (ie. the romance didn't feel forced) and the supporting characters were often fleshed out with their own stories that were told beautifully. My only (extremely minor) gripe though was how fast Stephen moved on from his first love. I feel like their story could've been explored further, especially since its the reason he joined the army in the first place.

Afrin
FGCS Bibliophiles 2026

Set during the Second World War, The Boy I Love by William Hussey tells a tender, heartbreaking story of Sam and Frank – two young men who fall deeply in love at a time were their relationship was not just disapproved of, but against the law. In 1940s Britain, being gay was a crime, carrying the risk of great, shame, or being shunned by everyone you know. So every meetup, every look, every quiet moment they share has to be kept secret and hidden from eyes. Hussey writes really well, making the coastal setting and the tense mood of the time feel almost real. You can feel how much they care for each other, but also the constant fear and pressure all around them. The characters feel like real people, not just made up – there love is soft, true, and full of wishful thinking, which makes every little happy time feel special and easy to brake. Its a strong story about bravery, who you are, and standing by your self even when the world says your wrong. Its sad in parts, but also has pieces of hope, and shows how love can give you strength even when things are very hard. Touching, well written, and unforgettable.

Peace
Vista Academy Littleport

The Boy I Love is an interesting story that shows a historical aspect being set in WW1. This made me enjoy the book because it felt a bit of a change to what I have read previously. I really liked the way that the author made it balanced between the brutal war, a loving relationship, and LGBTQ+. I feel like the author could have also made the start a bit more exciting. At the start of this book I really struggled to get through it which almost made me think the rest of the book would not be good. (it was very good though!) Spoiler alert!! My favourite moment in the book was when Stephen woke up and found out that Danny was still alive! I would recommend this book to people who want to learn more about LGBTQ+ and also people who want to read books set in very important times. I do also not agree with the age rating and think it should more be 12+. Overall I would give this book a 3/5.

Milo T
Larkmead

I thought the story was heartfelt and extremely touching and picturing the characters in the book make me feel as if the book was coming to life.

Ella
St Kaths

The Boy I Love is a really amazing historical fiction - so if you like the genre then you should definitely read !! I could truly teleport myself to the brutality of WW1. The characters are beautifully written, and really expressed the difficulties of being gay in WW1. I cannot express how much i love this book, and will definitely read again !!! I recommend this to YOU !

Pola
The Fitzharrys Shadows

The Boy I Love is an amazing and heartwarming book. It gets the message across clearly and the storyline is great. The only problem I have is it is a bit hard to understand at points, but once you figure it out it makes perfect sense.

Erin
Lost in Pages

This book thoroughly surprised me ! There I was sitting in my evil lair ( D.E.I. (Those who know)), ready to crack into yet another YA fiction on my evil couch, when I started the book I thought it was boring at first But slowly but surely i started to warm up to the story, the diverse characters, vivid descriptions and complicated ideals all added to the experience of reading the book. It give it nine prehensile platypuses out of ten prehensile platypuses.

Heinz Doofensmirtz
College Francais Love Books !

I really enjoyed this book. The world building made it feel very real as well as the story being very emotional. The characters were very well written making me fully invested in the story. But I felt the end was a little rushed and unrealistic. Overall i think it is an amazing book.

YaoiLover
College Francais Love Books !

Your book is great! I really enjoyed the story and it was very interesting. I loved learning about the war and I found the boys' love very cute although it was frustrating when they got caught at the end! I only thought the story took a lot of time to start and the end was very rushed.<3

Elise
College Francais Love Books !

I'll keep it short and simple: I loved this book, it's the same genre I've read thousands of times remastered, a nice slow-burn that kept you hanging on each sentence, captivating each moment and kept me on edge waiting for them to make a move. :]

Lucas
Willow Book Whispers

"The Boy I Love" by William Hussey is an interesting book set in WW1. I really enjoyed the historical aspect of the soldiers living in the trenches and how well-described they were, as well as a very strong and obvious chain of command among the men that were there (and those who had passed). The way the forbidden love was portrayed from the very start showed a strong understanding of both contextual societal rules and how to structure a good romance novel, which really engages the readers and makes them want to know more about the characters. Another aspect I enjoyed was the emotionally intense scenes were followed by lighter moments, whether that was comedic relief characters or brief and memorable interactions between the other characters. Overall, this book is my favourite from the shortlist so far, and I recommend everyone reads it!

Kistina
The Laureate League

I really actually love the world building and I love the dynamics between each character and I believe we can see the main characters views and interests in it and I can understand how the same sex relationship without context of the war happing, and I got really attached to the characters which is terrible after the trouble they went through and I do like the fast paced writing though their was some parts I had to read all over again to understand though i did love the flashback and singing verses though I understand someone not liking change in the font doing freestyle. So I give it 4 and a half stars

Fatima
The Shadows of Silverdale

I really enjoyed reading this book. I feel like the author did an incredible job of showing the brutality of the first world war, and the struggles that each and every soldier faced. They also showed that not everyone from one side was the same, and even people fighting for the "wrong" side were victims. I really enjoyed this book.

Izzy
The Shadows of Silverdale

I found The Boy I Love an outstanding heartbreaking and vital story. I love the fact how they managed to manage the absolute grimness of the war with an incredibly tender romance and also yeah this book doesn't sugarcoat anything especially the trenches in the battle of Somme which is vividly portrays. And if they got caught they would be literally done for life. I'd give this a solid 7.5/10

LAKSH L
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

It took me quite a while to get into this book, mostly because there was a lot of subject specific terminology which i just did not understand. However, I did end up liking the book, because it was very interesting. I really liked the characters, they had such complex stories. And the love they shared was beautiful.

Daniel
Mansell Library Reviewers

I really loved this book, firstly, because it was set in ww1 and I find books set in periods like this one. I also like the theme of forbidden love and think it a super engaging idea. The description of the trenches and the camps really puts you in the shoes of a young soldier and helps you relate to their situation based on a feeling where you have felt alone yourself.

Martha
CSGS Page Turners 26

I loved the historical accuracy and description. I found the romance wasn't fully explored but it was very full-on at the end

Josh
Tenbury Page Turners 26

It was really sweet and it made me cry but it was such a good read. The story was really sweet but it kept to what actually happened in WW1 which was very nice. The characters were really well thought out and overall it was a great read.

Rozje
STAGS Shadowers

The Boy I Love is an eye-opening book that perfectly portrays the horrors of war and how tragedy brings people together in a way that nothing else can. The book follows Stephen Wraxall, a soldier forever scarred by WW1. He meets Danny, a lively soldier whose bright personality hasn't faced the harrowing touch of war. It is a beautiful tale of two souls who have to face the brunt of war in the trenches.

Skyla
STAGS Shadowers

I personally loved reading this book. I found it really enjoyable and extremally well written. The book is really eye open and brilliantly written. Definitely recommend.

Kirah
Ms Dodd’s Carnegie Team

Princess-Tessy
BUCS Library Book Club

This is a wonderful book that portrays the horrors of war and what really happened in the battle of the Somme. 'Love will always prevail' is a key message that dictates everything that happens in the book and shows how far people are willing to go for the people they love. But it is also dark and shows how soldiers dealt with the death of their friends, how the enemy is not that different in reality and how the real villains are the ones behind the desks who don't endanger themselves but they decide who goes over the top every single day. I would recommend this book.

Toby
The Wondrous Book & Biscuit Club

This book is fantastic. The romance, the realism of the battlefield and the war are absolutely terrific. The chemistry between the characters, the premise of the book, the plot and the characters, everything was just absolutely fantastic. I read romance a lot and this is definitely one of my favourites and I would heavily recommend it to almost everyone because it is just so beautifully written. I give it a five star rating!

Eloise
Epsomians

I really enjoyed reading *The Boy I Love* because it was emotional, powerful, and easy to connect with. The story had a good balance of romance, sadness, and hope, which made me want to keep reading. I liked how the author showed the struggles the characters faced and how their relationships changed throughout the book. The characters felt realistic and believable, especially the main character. Their emotions were written really well, so I could understand how they were feeling during difficult moments. I also liked how the book explored themes like love, courage, and identity, which made the story more meaningful. Another thing I enjoyed was the setting and atmosphere. The author described everything clearly, making it easy to imagine the scenes and feel the tension in important parts of the story. Some parts were quite sad, but that made the book even more emotional and memorable. Overall, I think *The Boy I Love* is a touching and well-written book. I would recommend it to readers who enjoy emotional stories with strong characters and meaningful themes.

Zuzy
BUCS Library Book Club

The Boy I Love is a vivid and emotionally raw young‑adult novel set during World War I that follows Stephen Wraxall, a nineteen‑year‑old lieutenant returning to the front after injury and heartbreak, and Danny McCormick, an eighteen‑year‑old private. Their connection emerges under impossible circumstances — amidst the mud, fear, loss and prejudice of the trenches. Historical setting with emotional realism. Hussey does impressive work immersing the reader in 1916: the dangers of war, the camaraderie among soldiers, the psychological scars, and the social risks gay soldiers faced. The trench scenes are harrowing and visceral. Love in constricted spaces. The romance between Stephen and Danny is tender but complicated, not idealised. The constraints of rank, social expectations, shame, and the chaos of war make their relationship risky and fragile — which gives their moments together extra weight Character depth - Stephen’s grief, guilt, PTSD, and Danny’s resilience shine through. While some side characters are less fully realised, the emotional lives of the two leads pull you in strongly.

Bea
BUCS Library Book Club

I quite liked this book despite it being in a genre that I wouldn't usually read in. I really liked how the story progressed and how historically accurate it is. I think that it talks abut a topic that is extremely important currently.

Henry W-R
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book is about two men fighting in the first world war that have fallen and love. They had built up their relationship during their time together and had fallen in love with each other. They had to keep their love a secret as having same-sex attraction back in the day was considered as a criminal offense and unnatural. I like this book as it had captured emotions beautifully and it really made me feel all the emotions they had felt as if you were in that moment with them. The way that when they had moments alone they had shared tender and love filled moments. It also captured very well at how it was back in the day and how people believed only heterosexual couples were the only natural way for people to live. The way it was slow at first and started to speed up as their emotions got more and more intense. I didn't find anything I had disliked about this book. Overall, this is a beautifully written book and perfect read for young adults and for the lgbtq+ community. It captures emotions well and the time that the book was set in captured almost perfectly.

Red
Vista Academy Littleport

I found The Boy I Love to be rather over hated on. After hearing one too many negative reviews about this book I was not too excited and for the first 30 pages it appeared that these people were right as it started quite slow (as many a good book does but I was worried as I believed the whole thing would be slow as that was the main problem many had complained about). However, immediately after this the action started and I found myself immersed in this novel I once feared. I thought that Stephen and Danny had great chemistry and really added to the plot. Although I did get a little confused between the many army official's names, Beddowes was presented as a good enemy as opposed to the Germans who are seen as comrades in arms. I really liked this as it highlighted the misconception that the German soldiers were bad, as the majority of them were forced to fight for their country and were really just regular working citizens with guns. I was, however slightly disappointed with the final push that they made as it lacked depth and the main part of the action was over a little too quickly. The ending was also just ok, nothing special but not bad either. I learned rather a lot about WW1 and trench conditions in this book which was nice. Overall, I found The Boy I Love to be a good book with a decent plot and strong characters. It gave a nice perspective on WW1 and taught me some things. Plot:6/10 Characters:9/10 Setting:7/10 Style:6/10 Total:28/40

Sevan
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book is about a boy, Stephen, who had lost is life long love during the war and how he finds a new sweet romance with a boy called Danny. Personally I didn't really like this book as I felt that the side characters weren't really developed enough and it all just seemed a bit to unrealistic; especially as their love sprung after 3 days of the book which was really not long after his so called previous loves passing. However I would recommend this book to readers over the age of 12 as it covers some war topics and the battle of Somme while displaying a sweet newly-found love.

dainton
Vista Academy Littleport

This book was unique among the other Carnegie Shortlist books because of the interactions between different characters. Each conversation felt like it showed us a new piece of the puzzles that were Stephen and Danny. One of the best dialogues is between Stephen and Captain Beddowes when they first meet; the author has done a brilliant job of portraying the thinly veiled disgust of Beddowes in sharp contrast to Stephen's composure. The end of the book is particularly beautiful. The short, sharp style of writing helps to emphasize the nerves of the soldiers in the trenches as the Battle of the Somme looms ever closer. Overall, this book has the best structure of any in the shortlist: the beginning pulls you in, the middle keeps you in suspense and the ending cleanly finishes off the story.

Leo
The Perse Carnegians

Set during World War One, the book tells the story of Stephen Wraxall, a British Lieutenant, returning to the French battlefield after being injured and losing the person he loves. On his journey back he meets Danny McCormick, a new recruit, and a new relationship begins. Working as both an LGBTQ love story and as a piece of historical fiction, it is clear to see why this book took the author three years to write - with both excellent pacing and incredible historical detail leading up to the events of the disastrous 'Battle of the Somme' in 1916. The book really makes you feel the losses of war and the tragedy of men like Stephen - who fought for their country, while also being demonized by it, due to their sexuality. The ending, although feeling a little quick, contains a strong message regarding attitudes of the times, in an excellent piece of literature that still feels relevant to parts of society today. Overall, a powerful story about war, love and loss - which I would recommend to others to read. ***** (Five stars).

Mr. Robinson
Rockwood Reads

I really enjoyed reading this book because it was a story about forbidden love. I loved reading how each character changed and reacted to the events. My favourite part was the Epilogue as it told us more about the characters. Overall, I really enjoyed this book as it left me wanting more.

bethany
The Wondrous Book & Biscuit Club

I connected with this book on an emotional level. Danny was well portrayed with a real love for Stephen. His PTSD was portrayed beautifully. I adored this as it was a good representation of gay love in times of wide spread Homophobia.

Lilly
Kingdown Wilts

The Boy I Love is a heart-wrenching novel set in 1916 during the fighting on the Western Front. It follows the relationship between Stephen Wraxhall and Danny McCormick as they develop feelings for one another but are forced to keep their love a secret because, at the time, same-sex relationships were illegal. I found the book deeply moving and mournful, particularly because several characters die throughout the story. However, the ending offers a sense of hope for a future in which LGBTQ+ people can live openly and be accepted. I would rate this book 3.5 stars. While I enjoyed reading it, I felt that the story was quite slow-paced at times.

Georgina
Epsomians

Georgina
Epsomian Shortlist Shadowers

I LOVED THIS BOOK BECASE IT TALKED ABOUT HISTORY AND IT ALSO ENCORAGES BL LOVE

Deborah
Ossett Academy LRC

In general, this book was one I enjoyed. It follows Stephen, a soldier returning to the trenches after recently finding out that his lover, Micheal, had passed away. On the train, he meets Danny, and their relationship progresses throughout the book set during the battle of Somme, 1916. One critique I have is that Stephen moved on far too quickly from Micheal, and the pacing for Danny and Stephen's relationship felt a bit rushed. I also feel like the premise of the book better set up a more tragic ending, and the actual outcome was a bit too hopeful to be realistic. However, I did enjoy the writing style and despite Danny and Stephen's relationship being very quick, the pacing of the book itself was good. Overall, I liked this book a lot.

Lyra
Vista Academy Littleport

In The Boy I Love, Lieutenant Stephen Wraxall is coming back onto the battlefield after having a wound. He meets Private Danny, and immediately wants to save him from the terrible thing that is the war. He makes Danny his soldier servant. As the book goes on, many of Stephen’s platoon die. I think what I like most about this book is how realistic it is. I especially liked the way the author expressed thisin the book. Another thing I like about this book is how Stephen feels so many emotions and progresses as a character throughout the book. In the beginning, he was grieving for Michael’s death, on the train he was disappointed in the system of conscription, in the marching he felt anger for the person made to march on an infected blister and of course he always feels love for Danny. Due to this, I would rate it a 8.9/10.

Siddharthan
The Perse Carnegians

I think this book shows many good topics such as homosexuality in history and also horrors of war and how war constantly tears people and countries apart. Overall an alright book.

Oscar (Occa)
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Really good book exploring a diverse range of themes and it is a nice change of book compared to normal books.

Ethan
Reading’s Readers

Its a really good book, I really enjoyed it and I loved the type of genre

Meera
Reading’s Readers

i wasnt able to get into the book enough to actually continue reading it past the first couple of chapters. in my opinion it moved too slow and i couldnt fully get a grasp on wht was happening.

Anthony
Reading’s Readers

9/10 VERY INTERSRTING THE PLOT WAS NICE ALTHOUGH I WAS EXPECTING A SLOOW BURN STORY BUT STILL IT WAS GOOD.THE FACT ITS WORLD WAR 1 MEANS DOOOMEDDDDD. I LOVE HISTORICAL FICTION COULD BEEN REAL .

jaanavi
BAS Reading Champions

gorgeously written, heartbreaking . historical novel set against the brutal backdrop of the First World War

lamar
Lionheart2026

The Boy I Love is a slow read if you don't like books about war or love, it goes against discrimination and social expectations at the time. 7/10

Connor R
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The story the boy I love is really engaging since its about two boys who meet during world war 1 and how they navigate a relationship not only in a time it wasn't accepted but also during a war.This book is really captivating since since it seems very original and I also like how the book gives dates and follows the history timeline. I really like the characteristics each character is given since each personality adds something to the story like humour or tension. I would rate this book a 4/5 since it really put into perspective how hard it was for LGBTQ+ relationships in the past and i would recommend this book to teenagers since it could educate on war and how its okay to like who you want.

Skye
Glossopdale Readers

This was such a heart-warming read and I enjoyed it a lot! The writing was eloquent and created imagery that allowed me to immerse myself in the characters' battlefield both on the front and behind lines. The exploration of internal conflict between military ranks and the humanisation of both killers and the killed was really refreshing to read. Not only was the plot evenly paced and the perfect amount of intense, it also introduces the reader to the setting and sets the characters up effectively. Following the journey of Stephen and Danny is at first intriguing, but slowly reels you in for certain well-timed heart-wrenching moments. That being said, I do think their characterisation could have been developed further, as I would have loved to learn more about them as people outside of their backstories and the war itself. Additionally, their love, for me, was not the driving force of the book, but rather the harrowing descriptions of the war around them. For a historical fiction, it contains a good balance between the romance and conflict, but for a book that advertises itself on their love story, I was personally more moved by the conflict itself. Lastly, I wish events mentioned in the epilogue were expanded on and made a continuation of the previous chapters instead. This lead it to feel somewhat abrupt and unrealistic. Had they been extended into the story, the ending would feel more gratifying in my opinion. Nonetheless, this book is a solid 9/10 given its intensity and the emotions it easily evokes.

Claire
Watford Girls

The boy I loved was a really emotional and powerful read. The way William Hussey wrote it created such an incredible atmosphere that made me feel like I was actually right there with Stephen and feeling what he was feeling. It really made me think about the horrors of the trenches and life at war for the young men and what they had to go through and experience each day and the book was packed full of interesting and thought provoking details and moments. A brief summary of the book is Stephen meets Danny on a train back to the trenches and training camps. Stephen sees some of his past, younger self in Danny, all young and innocent with no clue what he's getting himself into and he finds himself wanting to protect this boy from the horrors of war that will slowly eat away at and destroy him. When Stephen is given the choice of who will be his soldier servant his mind immediately flicks to Danny and he pulls some strings to allow him to choose him because he wants to keep Danny close and take him under his wing. Fast forward a while past all the times Stephen and Danny spend together, the times Stephen sticks up and protects Danny and the times Danny sacrifices himself for others and Stephen. Until the end of the battle of the Somme when it is found out that Danny and Stephen love each other after they both barely survive the battle and Stephen is sentenced to 2 years of hard labour. When the two years finally come to an end and the war is over stephen is shunned by society and his own mother and father despise, he is finally reunited with danny and although they know they will never be accepted by society they don't care because all that matters is that they have each other.

Lara
Tractors

The Boy I Love by William Hussey is an empathetic book focusing on two soldiers in WW1, Danny and Stephen, fighting to keep each other safe. It follows them from their homes in England to the front line and then, into the disastrous Battle of the Somme. The way this book was presented and the descriptions inside it immersed me and made me realise how the horrifying battles of WW1 must have felt to the soldiers. I really enjoyed how Danny and Stephen's relationship developed from just greetings on a train to loving each other completely. However, one small detail that caught my eye was the presentation of the front cover. Based on the descriptions, the person on the right of the cover is Stephen, who is described as missing his left ear, an important detail that shapes who he is over the course of the book and is missing on the cover. Overall, this is an amazing book that I will almost surely be voting for and I would give it an 8/10 for future readers.

Oliver
The Fitzharrys Shadows

The Boy I Love by William Hussey is a brilliantly written book that includes so much detail you feel like you are either listening to the story from Danny and Stephen or were there at the battle. The story follows Stephen and Danny's relationship as they realise that the way they feel towards each other is unthinkable for the time. Readers follow their story through allies and enemies, friends who do not understand them and fellow officers who understand the hardships they are having to face. I would recommend this book to readers 12+ as a thrilling and engaging story where happy endings are more of a dream.

Annabelle
The Fitzharrys Shadows

The boy I love is a heartfelt and sorrowful romance between two young soldiers during WW1. The story is written from the perspective of the main character, Stephen, who loses all motivation and hope when his best friend - who he loved more than life would allow - sadly died. Then he meets Danny (who soon after becomes his new best friend and forbidden lover) and something to fight for, someone to fight for. If I had to choose, I would say my favourite character is Danny, His brazen and humorous personality is hard not to be fond of and his loyal, protective side makes him a great, but unpredictable character. I'd really recommend this book to people who like historic or romance novels. A great LGBT+ read.

Arietty
The Shady Bookhounds

I really liked this book and I thought that it was very well written! I love historical fiction and I haven't read many books about soldiers in WW1. I found their lives away from the trenches, in the french towns and villages very interesting. I thought that the relationship between Stephen and Danny was very well developed and really interesting to follow and it added an extra level of sadness when you consider that they wouldn't ever be able to publicly express their relationship due to the time period. I also loved the presentation of the "Toad" and the "Snake" and it highlighted the irony of generals who never visited the trenches giving out orders. There were times when there was in depth description of fighting and the trenches, which I wasn't that interested in and I disagreed, at moments, with the presentation and glorification of war against the "Huns" and the patriotism, yet I know that it was (and is) a view shared by some people.

Tim
St George’s Dragon Readers

The Boy I Love is a story set during the Battle of the Somme and is about love, bereavement and war. It is told from the point of view of 2nd lieutenant Wraxall and his soldier servant, Private McCormick. They are sent on a dangerous mission to observe German trenches to try and end the war. They narrowly escape with their lives and report back to their captain. It made me feel sad and I thought about how terrible life was in the trenches. Some of the language used in the book is not appropriate in today’s world but was common at the time. There are very descriptive parts about warfare and injuries, so is not suitable for younger children. This isn’t the sort of book I would normally read, and I didn’t enjoy it as much.

Oliver
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Lieutenant Stephen Wraxall is returning to the war after his best friend, Michael, died. He is sad about his death and feels haunted by his death. On the train he meets Private Danny McCormick who is a new recruit for the war and from the start they have a really good chemistry. Stephen feels bad for Danny as he’s never experienced the horrific nature of the war so he makes Danny his soldier servant. I love how the author made it so that the story is not all fighting and training and how there are some nice moments in the book. I also liked how he incorporated a whole range of emotion like love, grief, sacrifice and anger and didn’t make all the soldiers just aggressive men with no personality especially with the main character, Stephen. One thing I didn’t like about this book were the marching scenes as I felt that not a lot was happening in them and they were just overall boring. I also didn’t like the pacing of the book that much. Overall, I liked this book as it incorporated many emotions whilst balancing the war themes and would recommend it to anyone who likes romance books with deep themes!

Leopold
The Perse Carnegians

I really enjoyed this book. It’s dramatic storyline and attention to historical events make is an absolute treat of a read. The only thing I don’t like so much is the fact that Stephen got over Michael very quickly. I feel that there could have been more on Stephen’s life at home, but otherwise, it’s a very good novel. 8.5 stars.

Lucy
Sullivan Shadowers

I love this book because it is a heart felt YA book full of love, fear and constant dangers. It is full of authentic emotions and human experiences while keeping the realism of war.

Abigail
PA TBC

It is a wholesome story about love in difficult times and in hard situations. With homophobia being a challenge they over come, because it was very common in that time

Zara
PA TBC

I love this book because it is a heart felt YA book full of love, fear and constant dangers. It is full of authentic emotions and human experiences while keeping the realism of war.

Abigail
PA TBC

I really enjoyed The Boy I Love. The characters were memorable, there were moving scenes and it felt evident that a lot of research was put into this. Highly reccomend.

Elsie
St Kaths

This book was so well-written I am lost for words to describe it. ‘The Boy I Love’ was a really thrilling book to read, and one of the only stories I have seen with unique twists that drew me in. World War 1 mixed with forbidden love — a book so great my words have flown out of my head. This could possibly be my new favourite romance book. Overall, I really enjoyed the storyline and plots, and as a LGBTQ+ person, it was such a creative and engaging story , and I would love to read more.

Raine
Rainbeau Readers

Lieutenant Stephen Wraxall, 19 years old, re-joined the army after injury. From there, he meets Private Danny McCormick, a young talented new recruit to the army. Stephen felt the need to protect Danny from the war; after all, he had experienced his own share of heartbreak when his best friend Michael died. Stephen made Danny his soldier-servant, and his platoon had to make their way to the Somme. Stephen and Danny soon find their friendship more than that. But with the Battle of Somme nearing, Stephen and Danny had to find out whether their love for each other can prevent death or fail in despair. I really enjoyed this book because it was heart-warming, brilliant and gives us an insight of what LGBTQ+ people like Stephen were during the First World War, when being gay is against the law back then. My favourite character would be Private Danny McCormick, because he has a great sense of humour and cares about others. During his time in the platoon, Danny almost acts as though he had ordained a great deal of experience, which is what I would typically expect of a good character in a story. Finally, I would recommend this book to anyone who wants to lean a bit more about World Wars and LGBTQ+ lives back then.

Ibsan
The Perse Carnegians

I really liked reading this one as it was historical fiction, and history from that period of time really interests me. I also liked how thorough the research was, and how we got to see some of that. However, I would have liked there to be an explanation of the military rankings in order so that it would be easier to see which rankings were higher up. This also caused me to do my own research about LGBTQ+ relationships in the time period. The story was a bit underwhelming though.

Bella
TGGS Carnegie Readers

I appreciated the imagery, description and historical accuracy in The Boy I Love, however I found the romantic elements and the characters not quite as engaging. But I was particularly gripped by the Battle of the Somme, as I felt the writer was very effective in creating the tense and terrifying atmosphere. Clearly it was all leading up to that battle, which removes some of the mystery and suspense if thought the author was trying to create, as it was such a well known event. In addition, I didn't enjoy the epilogue, it felt a bit 'tacked on' and didn't fit very well with the rest of the book. I think the author was trying to add on a quick happy ending, but I don't think it was ultimately successful. I didn't really enjoy it, but I can see how other people might.

Mabel
The High Storrs Shadows

The Boy I Love is a really emotional and intense read that explores identity, love, and growing up in a difficult situation. I found it quite powerful because it doesn’t shy away from serious topics and feels very honest in how it shows the character’s experiences. At times it was hard-hitting, but that’s what made it memorable. Overall, it’s a moving book that definitely stays with you after finishing it.

Sebastian
St George’s Dragon Readers

William Hussey's The Boy I Love is an emotional, heart-wrenching historical fiction novel set during World War I. It follows a 19-year-old officer, Stephen, returning to the trenches of the Somme, who finds forbidden, tender love with a bright new recruit, Private Danny McCormick.

Zoe
SDG Reads

I thought this book was pretty good. While I don't really like romance books I thought that they presented the war quite accurately. I felt that some of the romance felt a bit predictable and basic. I think that some people will definitely enjoy this book but it is not my kind of book.

Yusuf K
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

personally, i couldn't get into the book, while i do belive it had great promise, and it seems highly realistic with a promising storyline, I do find it hard to get into.

Poppy
Stratton shadowers

I loved this book! As my first LGBTQ+ book it was definitely a good one to start with. I honestly could not put it down and fell in love with all of the characters. I was so annoyed when they allowed the Final Push to still happen as scheduled even when Danny and Stephen found out how deep the trenches were. Some of the Language and Military terms were confusing but will read again! 10/10!

Klara
The Wondrous Book & Biscuit Club

I found "The boy I love" was a really good book because it showed the struggle of Danny and Stephens relationship during WW1 whilst maintaining a fast paced and exciting storyline throughout the book. I liked the contrast between Stephen and Danny's characters, Stephen being a more careful and reserved character vs Danny being more outspoken and loud character. However, I found the ending to be a bit blunt and sudden, I found it was a bit of a bad way to end a great story. Overall it was an interesting historical fiction that I found believable and kept me reading page after page.

Evie
Tractors

I loved this book, I thought it perfectly depicted the horror of war without romanticizing the conflict of the Great War. This was perfectly balanced with the doomed romance between Danny and Stephen. It was cathartic and bittersweet to realize that they can never truly be with each other, and that there was no-one who they can truly share their secret with. The characters were beautifully written in such a way that I found myself cheering for the protagonists and loathing the antagonists. On the topic of the antagonists, it was refreshing to see that they weren't "evil Germans" at all, rather truly heartless military commanders on the British front, which was much more believable. It was also heart-crushingly beautiful that Hussey humanizes the German forces (such as Wraxall's "Kamerad") rather than depicting the conflict as being in black and white. However, I thought that where the book truly shined was in it's wonderful descriptive language and detailed depictions, lavishly sculpted imagery of scenes both of wartime and of beauty. 10/10

George
ShadowBookers

I really enjoyed this book because of how it described and depicted WW2 and the struggles that the characters faced.

David
ShadowBookers

The Boy I Love by William Hussey is a book about two military officers who are in the sane sector and find out that they love each other. I found this book really hard to start as there wasn't much happening. I think that only near the end did things start to really improve. I think I nearly stopped reading the book in the middle because I found it very boring. I wouldn't normally chose a book of this genre but I would recommend this book to people who enjoy books about WW1 and romance. Overall I would rate this book a 2/5.

Lukshmi
CSGS Page Turners 26

I really enjoyed 'The Boy I Love' as it was a nice eyeopener to the dark side of the war and how so many people died from it. The book reminds us that even in those darkest moments, love can still happen.

ezra
ShadowBookers

This book was more character focused than plot focused overall. It was interesting to read about about Stephen and Danny's past lives and how they ended up in the war. I did like the ending as it was a nice contrast to how tragic war books usually end up. However, it was dissapointing how the plot was lacking in the story.

Chloe
GreatB00ks

I loved it and it perfecly shows the losses of war and the beauty of love and life

Danuji
GreatB00ks

I loved it

Danuji
GreatB00ks

The Boy I Love was definitely the book to get the most attention just from the front cover in my group. With a foundation in historical fiction, it was bound to be popular, and featuring LGBTQ+ characters made it even more so. The attention hasn't been undeserved - Hussey has balanced the plot incredibly cleverly between the horrifically short life young men experienced in the trenches of WW1, along with the 'socially immoral' (at least to the time period) relationship between Stephen and Danny. The Boy I Love is a delicate love story which, without getting graphic, features a beautiful romance in a dire situation. Having spent time running tours along some of the Somme battlefields myself, I found the lead up to the push and the date countdown of the chapters incredibly suspenseful, and really appreciated the accuracy with which Hussey described trench warfare, again without needing to be too overly graphic about it. I confess, having enjoyed the book as much as I did, I was a little disappointed by the ending - but no spoilers here!

Mrs Sirrelle
BFS Umbra

I found this book the best out of the all carnegies. I loved how there was so much research put into the book, and the history involved. The only thing is that danny and stephen's romance was a bit....... underdeveloped- it needed a bit more exporing.

Zoe
County Shadows

I found the boy I love very interesting because of the way it dove into relatively untold stories about LGBTQ+ people during WW1 and how they were discriminated I think it also had a great plot and a lead up to the battle of the Somme. I honestly thought the book would end in tragedy, but I thought the ending was great. I found that it was written fluently and felt easy to read. I think this is my 2nd favourite book I have read so far. I also like how it was very historically accurate. I would recommend to any one interested in WW1 or LGBTQ+ history.

LeoL
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I am almost at the end of the book and it has interested me more than I thought. Although this is not the genre I would usually choose, I thought this book was well-written and quite factual about what life in the trenches would have been like in WWI. The characters are interesting and I was curious to see how their story unfolds. I probably will finish this book and even if it may not have been one I would have chosen for myself, I can imagine others would enjoy it and find it both entertaining and educational.

Mariela
The Paragons

The boy I love is an amazing book written very fluent and gently. However, I found it difficult to start but once I had got into it I couldn't stop reading it. I loved the setting and plot because it may look like a romance but it really isn't. I thought it was an amazing book.

Henry
St Kaths

The boy I love is a tremendous book filled with emotion and heartbreak and a true sense of war. This book shows that even in the darkest of times there is love. This is probably my favourite book so far of the Carnegies. The way the writer portrays the scenes makes you so hooked and made me feel like I was there. GREAT BOOK.

Aiden
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The boy I love is a book about 2 military officers who are put together and eventually find that they love each other but they face challenges like homophobia and strict rules. I personally didn't like this book because it was set a long time ago during the battle of the Somme and I am usually interested in books set in the modern era. I also just found the book boring as there wasn't enough action. Overall I would rate this book a 2.5/10

Hisham N
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed the Boy I Love. However, I distinctly hated the epilogue. I felt that the book would have worked much better if it ended without the epilogue. I felt that the epilogue was sitting on the fence and that either they should have both died or they should have both survived and been together for the rest of their lives. I think that the storyline worked well and that the plot twist with Captain Jackson being gay was extremely well thought out, unexpected and definitely contributed to the plotline and made the story better. If you enjoy books about War and love then this entertaining history read is one for you.

Ben
The Leopards, Skinners’

I thought this book was one of the most boring books I have ever read, the book highlights this years books being average not to the standard of the previous years. I feel like the only reason this book was picked was because of the not so unique feature about being gay, the book wasn't all that special apart from that, although giving some interesting facts.

Muyang
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

At the start of this book I did not enjoy it that much. However as I read more I started to enjoy it and how it portrayed the army as it seemed quite realistic. I would recommend.

Hasan i
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The Boy I love is a great book. It includes romance and themes to do with wellbeing whilst keeping links to history like social class in World war One. I found myself getting quite emotional throughout the book although I still enjoyed it.

Charlie
Skipton Shadows

I really enjoyed "The Boy I Love". It was very emotional and the storyline was very interesting and had me hooked. The characters were portrayed really well and were made in a way people can relate to. I really liked the characters because they are inspirational and I can emphasize with them. The moral behind the story was something everyone can relate to and is a great moral to have and act by. The story was written well and left me on a cliffhanger at the end of part 1. This had me wanting to read on as I wanted to know how it ended. There were a lot of events that were very interesting and dramatic. Overall I really enjoyed this book and I would definitely recommend this read.

Rose
Skipton Shadows

Of the books I have read so far, this one has certainly stood out to me. Not only did I love the storyline and the characters, but reading this book taught me a lot about World War One. I didn’t know that much about the Battle of the Somme, and I ended up rereading those few chapters multiple times, flicking back to the glossary as I did. After finishing the book, I had a look online to research more into it. Of course, the main story is the romance between the characters Stephen and Danny, which I did love. The characters were written so well, and you genuinely felt sorry for them, but at times, also a little bit happy. I’m not sure I was a big fan of the ending, but otherwise, this book is fab.

Sofia
BFS Umbra

Read this book with the knowledge that this book was not to my taste I really did not enjoy The Boy I Love to the point of when I got to chapter 10 I truly debated whether to continue it and it was only my determination to complete that persuaded me to continue and the whole reading experience felt like a slog. I thought that the description of the pre-front training was unusual however I have read very few War based books I also found the writing style felt very new author style . A 1/10 book

Grace
KES Readers

A really good book that I loved reading. It captured the war and people's lives in it really well. I would recommend it.

Elizabeth
Sir Roger Manwood’s School Book Club

The Boy I Love is a great book about homosexual relationships and homophobia during World War One. This book is great as it really shows how bad homophobia was in reasonably recent history. I really enjoyed this book as it shows the struggles that the LGBTQ+ community had to go through.

Estlin K
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

4/5 stars. Quite good, wished that Oliver Murray's death didn't come so soon, terrified during the Battle of the Somme. Overall I enjoyed it but I got confused in chapter 31.

Scarlett
LGA Page Turners

this books has excellent descriptions, and it is very educational about World War 1 it talks about the western front and what the trenches were like. It shows the struggles of the LGBTQAI+ community in those times and how they couldn't truly be who they are. Overall I loved this book.

Eliza
The Wells Readers

This book, despite the age rating, was one of my favourite books so far due to quite a few things. Firstly, this book had so many unique characters and personalities, with quite a lot of them being extremely likeable. Secondly, the way this book portrayed the world war and the scene around the main plot really engaged ad hooked me on the book. Finally, the plot itself and the writing style was extremely good and kept the book from being boring or monotonous.

Theo dP
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I wasn't really expecting much from this book, and I'd never read a gay romance book before, but I was blown away. It was so accurate to the war and all the details seemed tangible and real. The romance bit was OK, but my favourite bit was the very climatic ending. overall 9/10

Toby
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

"The boy I love" by William Hussey is a very touching and intriguing novel, which takes place during the First World War. In this work, we get to know about the story of two young soldiers, Stephen and Danny, who fall in love with each other while taking part in the war. This novel describes what kind of hardships the men had to go through, and what kind of attitude prevailed toward those whose loves were not considered socially acceptable.

Anika
Diary of a Wally Kid

Review of: The Boy I Love I found the intro of the book enticing, the story starts slowly but the build-up is worth it, the “world” created in this book is created carefully making this book easy to become emersed in. The plot is well constructed as it leads to a satisfying end of the book. When reading the book there isn’t much chance to explore the characters, it feels like you’re being led through the story in real time. There is protected characteristics but although the book focuses on it doesn’t block the story from moving on. The book covers difficult situations of being homosexual during the first world war, but it doesn’t make you feel uncomfortable as such. The story follows a battled hardened “hero”, he is choses as the narrator because he has been through the conflict which gives him a different point of view compared to the other new soldiers. The characters are portrayed realistically; the dialogue is very believable. I think the book is worth rereading.

sam
Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

I was intrigued by this book; it was one of the three books in the shortlist that I would consider reading outside of the carnegies. When i did read it, I shot through it in just over 24 hours, very different to the last carnegie book I had read, which took me three weeks 😅. This book was sweet and romantic, but not without its darker side. When (spoiler alert) Percy died I almost cried, it was so sad. Not to mention that they cannot live out their lives together because of the ignorance of others. I really liked this book, and i will probably be voting for it. Just one piece of criticism though: there does seem to be a power imbalance. I know this is necessary for the plot, but still, and also it is a little pervy when Steven watches Danny go for a swim. I know you have a crush, Steven, but give him some privacy!

Arianne
The High Storrs Shadows

I really enjoyed this book and felt that it perfectly captivated my interest. I found myself being affected by this and my emotions were strung along

Poppy
LSST Library Shadowers

I quite liked this book as it explores some very important themes. Though for mature readers only, this book does a great job with the romance without compromising the key message - of forbidden love. 3.5/5

Edward
The Barty Book Bunch

I only read a few chapters but it was really enticing and I will probably read more in the future

Arwa
Rad readers

I only read part of this, however it’s very well written as far as I saw and I enjoy the idea behind what’s being written.

Bryony
Rad readers

It was a really good book once it got to the middle and near the end but at the start it wasn't really that good, quite boring.

Bayony
Rad readers

It was kind of interesting but it's not really my favourite but it was still a good book for someone whose really interested in world wars and wants to imagine how life would be like at that time.

Juwayria
Carnegivores

A beautiful book. The cover called to me as soon as I glanced at it and the book was nothing less! A heartwarming portrayal of the difficulties and challenges faced by homosexual soldiers in the army during WWI. Hussey beautifully accumulated tension and suspense throughout the book using simple, meaningful methods. The characters (especially Danny and Stephen) felt like real, raw people instead of words on paper and Hussey added depth to each character throughout the book. Although I started the book believing I would be met with a gut-wrenching ending (due to them being stationed at the Somme in 1916), Hussey opted to provide a bittersweet ending to the couple and he did it without making the reader feel like the couple simply had plot armour. Overall, it was an amazing book that took you on a rollercoaster of joy, grief, and love while providing real, accurate information on the technical and emotional difficulties of the war, with great prospects for rereads.

Edlin
Reading Wizards

I think this book was great, it brings a typically unheard of topics (homosexual people during ww1), being a mix of homosexual romance category and historical categories.

Stanley
Waddesdon Shadowers 26

The Boy I Love was emotionally rich book full of romance and mystery .This book was a real page turner! Every moment was so captivating and really represented the life of a average gay soldier on the trenches of WW1. In my opinion, it definitely is a book for people that enjoy romance, WW1 or LGBTQ+ based storylines because it represents the general struggle people of the LGBTQ+ community go through. As someone who does not know much about the lives of a gay soldiers in the trenches this book definitely changed my perspective on this topic. Although, I would recommend that someone under the age of 12 probably should not read this book unless they are viewed as mature enough. Overall, I think this book was very well set and really painted a picture of the aspects of gay soldiers during the time period of WW1.

Kat
Waddesdon Shadowers 26

I loved how this book portrayed the the individual and presence of the characters and how we get to learn their personality very strongly. I also liked how the book/author enhanced he setting to make it as if you were there in real life (The trenches in WW1).

Benjamin
Waddesdon Shadowers 26

Personally, I really loved this book in general. I'll read any historical fiction book on WW1 or WW2 and I think this one was particularly captivating. The writing style is so beautiful, especially the descriptions and I think it portrayed the brutality of a war extremely well, in juxtaposition with Danny and Stephen's loving relationship. I normally have a pet peeve against time-skipping epilogues, but I think that in this novel, it was developed extremely well and encompassed a sense of nostalgia and finality. Although it was rather sappy at times (like most romance novels), I personally thought it was incredibly heartwarming to witness the evolution of a bittersweet relationship enduring several harsh and often homophobic situations. In my opinion, I don't like illustrations of characters on the front cover, as I would rather imagine my own (but the illustrations are gorgeous!). I would recommend this book to any avid historical fiction readers and anyone who seems intrigued by it - trust me, it's worth the time!

Erin
The Tiffin Girls’ Shadows

I was so excited for this book and the themes, and even though in some ways the storyline lived up to my expectations, the pacing was disappointing. The first 100 or so pages were quite hard to get into and I felt I was forcing myself into it. The middle section was incredible, the slow burn romance was so intriguing, and the topics- though difficult, such as the pain that came with homosexuality at the time and war- were handled so well. I really, really enjoyed this part, it was so well written and had elements of humour as well as still handling the main themes maturely. HOWEVER. The ending was awful. I felt it was super unrealistic and completely abolished the character arc Stephen and Danny were about the complete. It completely ruined my satisfaction of the novel. Although the two never meeting again would be sad, I think that’s the point- it would have stayed with the reader longer. Overall- 3.5 stars. It was great, but it could’ve been so much better with a few tweaks.

Lily
Sullivan Shadowers

I really enjoyed this book and it was very revealing, my only issues were the fact that the end was waaaay to fast , the print was small and Steven got over Michael very quickly and Michael’s name popped up a couple random times however this book was very good and I loved Danny and I would read it again 9/10

Clodagh
Sullivan Shadowers

Lovely romance story, accurate with history facts. Would rate a 8 out of 10. Writes about some major wars like the battle of the Sommes. Touches on discrimination against LGBTQ people and identity. Would read again, and would recommend to others.

David
Henry’s Shadowers

The Boy I Love is an incredible book - it's so descriptive that you feel like you really know the characters. It is heart wrenching, emotional and enthralling and I couldn't put it down!

Tamsin
Epsomians

This book is needed in society. This displays to many people that homophobia can ruin gays lives. It is also displayed in great writing and the world war 1 knowledge/writing and although it doesn’t end with a happy ending it is a great story and we should all read this and get the message.

Blaise
Bookwizards

The Boy I Love is an incredible book - it's so descriptive that you feel like you really know the characters. It is heart wrenching, emotional and enthralling and I couldn't put it down!

tamsin
Epsomian Shortlist Shadowers

I enjoyed 'The Boy I Love' much more than I thought i would. Although it is quite similar to the type of books I would normally read, I was initially put of by the cover (sorry person who designed it) as I felt that it was very cheesy. I know you shouldn't judge a book by its cover, but lets be real, it is definitely less likely that you will read a book if you don't like the cover, as it is one of your first points of connection with the book. Anyway, I did end up enjoying this book. It was captivating, exciting, moving, and I ended up reading it all in less then 24 hours. Although i liked it, I have two pieces of criticism: 1. It was very sweet and lovely when Stephen and Danny were reunited at the end of the book, and it was very romantic, but I feel that it would have been more effective if they had never seen each other ever again. 2. I know that for the purpose of the storyline, Stephen had to be a higher rank than Danny, but the power imbalance was not very good ,especially when Danny has to call Stephen 'Sir'. In conclusion, this was a worthwhile read and I would give it a 7.75/10

Ilsa
The High Storrs Shadows

Very sad, but also a really good book to read.

Natalie
BCS Book Squad

This was a beautifully written, extremely moving piece, I loved it! The ending was so bittersweet it made me cry which is always the sign of a good book. I thought the juxtaposition of the harshness of life in the trenches and the relationship between Danny and Stephen really emphasised the emotion. This has been one of my favourite books ever and is definitely a favourite to win.

Martha
IVC Readers

I loved the way William Hussey wrote the characters of Stephen and Danny. They felt very alive. Their problems felt so real. Their story made me feel all sorts of emotions ranging from rage to sorrow to joy and relief. My favourite part of the story was the ending, it wasn't your typical fairytale happy ending but a bittersweet and realistic ending.

Elizabeth
Hunt for Excellence

The Boy I Love didn’t leave me with much of a strong opinion. I think the idea was quite original and the story was realistic. I did not really find the book very engaging however and it is hard to really describe the plot as all that really happens is they're going to war and falling in love. I liked Captain Jackson the most as he was very fair and revealed he had gone through much of what Stephen had. The ending was very realistic but despite (and really, because of) that it did feel a bit disappointing and underwhelming. Overall I would rate this a 8/10 for the actual book and 6/10 for my personal reading experience. I would recommend this to secondary school age people.

yuding
The Perse Carnegians

Stephen goes to war and falls in love with Danny (a new recruit). I did not finish reading this book and I didn't really like it. I found it goes on and on and doesn't stay within the plot line.

Zara
Montsaye Shadow Readers

This book is absolutely brilliant and I love the representation of LGBTQ+ in books. My favourite thing is how it is set. I love how they face homophobia and [at the end] overcome it.

Tomalyn
Plumites

This book was a very interesting look at the experiences of young men on the battlefields of World War 1 through the eyes of someone who is gay, and from the traveller community. Being gay at this time was dangerous - however, this love story transcended the difficulties this character experienced. I really loved reading from this perspective.

Mrs Patel
Portland Readers

The Boy I Love is about two men who fighting in the trenches during World War 1 falling in love even though they were not allowed to. Throughout the book there is fighting, death and the grief that comes with that. It also points out things that could be considered as wrong in the terms of all the rules they had to follow. I think someone who would enjoy this book would be someone who likes romance stories. Another person could be someone who likes history as it takes place during World War 1 and has some real events that had happened there. In my opinion a good age rating for this book would be 14+ because at that age you would have the maturity to read the book and the background historical knowledge to understand the book.

lily
The Lotus Readers

The book “The boy I love” is about Stephen and Danny's forbidden relationship together during WW1. This book shows the harsh truth about gay relationships in the past. William Hussey helps us understand more about their relationship and helps others to find out their identity. He also describes WW1 in a very realistic way where it feels like you are in war. The book shows us that in the past we had no option to choose to go into war or not; even up into now there is still that problem. The author shows many other soldiers' points of view in real life as well. Stephen has been traumatised because of war which also connects to most soldiers that were in the army. The book shows the truth about war and how it ruined many relationships because of this. For example, losing someone very important to you even if you have protected them the best you can.

May
The Lotus Readers

To be honest, I truly thought that I was going to enjoy this book as this is the type of topic that I enjoy to read. Unfortunately, I was disappointed by the pacing to an extremity and felt that it did not actually capture the struggles of being queer in the second world war. Furthermore, the ending made little to no sense to me and I feel it would've been better if Danny and Stephen never met again.

Trinity
FAB(C)

The Boy I Love was a really good book. Set in the trenches of WW1 before the Battle of the Somme, it follows two soldiers, fighting on the British side that fall in love during a dangerous time for queer people. I really enjoyed the book as I don't think this topic is talked about enough. The writing style was engaging and the plot was gripping. All of the characters (even the side characters) I found well-rounded and overall I would definitely recommend. 4 Stars.

Emily
HAEC Books and Biscuits Carnegie Shadowers

While I enjoyed the WW1 setting of the book, I found parts of the story to be quite boring and lethargic. The protagonist, Stephen Wraxall, had a strong, well-developed backstory but with very little personality. He had few character traits which made it difficult for me to root for him. Danny was slightly more nuanced, although neither of them had a dynamic character arc. However, I loved the slow-burn romance, which is difficult to achieve in a setting like this one. I also loved the LGBTQ+ representation, which is especially important in historical fiction to recover the lost narratives of people like Stephen and Danny. Overall, I enjoyed the setting, the representation and the romance, but disliked both characters as well as some of the slower-moving aspects of the plot. I would rate it three stars.

Abby
JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

Sofia
JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

The text explains that world war 1 and why it is important. It talks about how world war 1 happened and what effects they have on people, in the trenches and in the towns. Overall, it shows how bad it was to like the same gender and how difficult it was. It helps readers understand being LGBTQ+ in WW1 in a simple way.

Tara
HAEC Books and Biscuits Carnegie Shadowers

It’s a topic that's never talked about. It’s taboo. We don’t like to think about LGBTQ+ people in history because we don’t want to think about how they were treated and we don’t like to talk about war because it’s depressing and makes people feel uncomfortable. But The Boy I Love mixes both these themes together in a book that makes you smile, cry and leaves you feeling bittersweet about everything. It’s a powerful story delivered in a way that feels accessible for everyone, no matter if you identify with the LGBTQ+ community or not. Whilst the message was sorely needed, especially on a wider scale, often times I felt the pacing falling flat. The romance was very well done and I do admit that slow burns are hard to achieve in stand alone, but the pacing was uneven and sometimes confusing. I also feel like Stephen’s character arc didn’t hit very well but that would be difficult to achieve given that there was no reason given for Stephen to change as a character. I feel similar for Danny’s character development because, again, there was no catalyst to kickstart his arc. Overall, this book has a strong message and it delivered it beautifully. Love is love. The characters however were one note. I’d give the plot 4 stars but the characters 3. I think, for the entire book, I would rate it a 3.5.

Sofia
JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

I liked the twists and turns in their romance and the context surrounding their relationship and the time period

Beatrice
Cottingham High School

I would never usually choose to read a book set in the war however I am glad I have read this one. The details of the war were interesting and told tales that I haven't heard before such as how soldiers were punished. The love story was told in such a way that it didn't overshadow the turmoil of the war and you were left rooting for the couple. There was tension, drama and victory in equal measure. I loved reading from the perspective of the Lieutenant. It created emotion and empathy for me as a reader. I cried near the end and couldn't put the book down. I would recommend this book to age 15+ for readers interested in romance and history. Big fan of this one 5/5 stars.

Fiona
The Carnegie Coast Readers

The Boy I Love, by William Hussey, depicts the brutality and horrors of the First World War and the Battle of the Somme alongside many social issues that still exist today, such as homophobia. Throughout the novel, we can observe a strong and intimate relationship building between the two main characters, Lieutenant Stephen Wraxhall and Private Danny McCormick, who both serve in the British army and are deployed to France. It combines the themes of homosexuality with war, which is completely new and unique to other novels which I have read. However, although the theme is unique, I didn’t really enjoy the book as much as other books I’ve read. The book has a lot of vocabulary which may be hard to understand and I think that the story would have been more compelling if there was more jeopardy when Wraxhall and McCormick were getting closer. Some readers may find reading the book uncomfortable due to its themes , but overall it is a good book for those over the age of 14 to read.

Sam
The Lotus Readers

The Boy I Love is a lyrical and touching book about forbidden love, tender LGBTQ+ romance between two British soldiers. Stephen and Danny are serving in the trenches during the 1916 battle of Somme in WW1. The story follows the attempt to find love and humanity amongst the brutality, fear and prejudice of the war. The novel also vividly portrays the harsh realities of life in trenches and the danger of their relationship being discovered which would lead to court-martial. And due to Stephen's haunted past, Stephen is determined to protect Danny from the brutalizing effects of war which led to a deep bond between one another.

Thao
The Lotus Readers

I loved this book. The story followed two boys who loved each other even when they shouldn't and honestly forbidden romance is one of my favorite tropes. My most liked character however was Robert as he was truly loyal towards the end. The book overall seemed to be quite accurate which I liked about it as well as the teamwork and hard felt emotions throughout the book. Also shout-out to the artwork on the front it's amazing and a real pull for anyone who looks at it to read the book

Lakshake
HGS Book Club

I absolutely LOVE this book, it's amazing! However, I was a bit disappointed with the ending, I'd hoped it would be happier. Nevertheless, this book was written amazingly and I really enjoyed reading it. It was super easy to get into and I thought it was very enjoyable. I loved seeing how Danny and Stephen's relationship progressed. This book made me cry, but it was totally worth it. 5 stars.

Rosie
STAGS Shadowers

I absolutely loved this book. Hussey researched a lot for this book and it clearly shows in how accurate and realistic it is. Sometimes it felt like I was literally in the trenches with the characters. Additionally, it’s so great to see representation of queer people in literature, especially because at that time being gay was not just frowned upon, but seen as condemnable.

Kirsten
Bellerive Bookies and Cookies

William Hussey’s The Boy I Love is a novel that explores the complexities of a unique identity during the first world war. The story follows Edward, a young man navigating the excitement of first love while living in a war zone environment. Hussey balances the warmth of a still unpopular romance with the harsh, historical reality of fear.

Ethan
Carnegivores

"The boy I love" is my favourite Carnegie read. It is about Stephen (a lieutenant chief in the Somme) falling in love with his assistant Danny. I love the story line and how everything was put together. It made me feel like I was actually in the trenches myself. This book shows all the feelings that actually went on in WW1 and how disapproving the world used to be. One criticism I would have, is how fast he got over his dead first love Micheal, but overall I love how LQBTQ+ is being shown in history! I would reccomend this to older students for there are some traumatic parts. 10/10 would read again!

Philippa
The Shady Bookhounds

The story follows Lieutenant Stephen Wraxall, a 19-year-old soldier fighting in World War One. Returning to 'the front' after an injury and the loss of his first love, he meets a new soldier, Danny, and feelings develop for him - but he is someone who he can only call a 'friend' in public. The novel follows the progression of their relationship, both publicly and privately. It is a story set in the past, with a message that transcends time. William Hussey writes in a way that captures the attention of the reader and we feel for the characters and the situations they are in. It never felt like the book was dragging on, which was a good thing, the pace of the story was well-maintained - although the war scenes were very fast-paced, but this could be to reflect how it felt to be in the moment of battle. Overall, I thought this book had an important message and found the book very engaging - I would recommend it to other readers. ***** (5 stars).

Hasher
Rockwood Reads

The boy I love by William Hussey is a powerful historical novel set during World War One. It follows Stephen, a young soldier struggling with both the horrors of war and the fear of hiding his relationship with Danny in a society that would not accept them. I found the book emotional and gripping because the contrast between the violence of the trenches and the tenderness of their relationship made the story feel even more heartbreaking.Hussey describe the brutality of war vividly, while also showing how secrecy and discrimination affect people at the time.Although the ending was tragic and not completely satisfying, I think it suited the novel because it felt realistic and stayed true to the historical setting. At times the pacing felt slightly rushed, especially in the romance, but overall I thought the novel was memorable,emotional, and important because it gives a voice to stories that are often ignored

Jort
The Lotus Readers

‘The Boy I Love’ by William Hussey is an impactful and emotional story that I enjoyed and I think a lot of people can relate to. For example, the way Stephen's diary entries were written made it feel very personal and realistic, as if it were reading someone's private thoughts, which really allowed me to connect with the character on a deep level. Stephen and Alfie’s relationship felt very genuine, and I liked the fact that their love was shown as beautiful but yet very fragile. What was interesting about the story was how the story combined both romance and war. It taught me about the hard lives of people who constantly had to hide their identity due to discrimination and prejudice. The story often had lots of sad and intense moments, which helped make the story very meaningful and emotional.

Andy
The Lotus Readers

I think it’s a cute story for young adult readers. It’s not the most sophisticated war book, and there are plenty of other great LGBTQ+ books set during this time. The writing is lovely, and the characters are interesting. You don’t really get to know them that well because there’s a lack of character development. Still, it’s fine. It’s a YA book, and it feels very simplistic. I understand that it didn’t want to go into too much detail, but I think it could have been stronger. It’s not going to be something I go back to, but I don’t regret reading it.

Andrea
CSGS Page Turners 26

The Boy I Love is an important story about how life was really like leading up to the battle of the Somme in France. It also shows us another insight into how actually gay people didn't just appear this century and the dangers they had to face knowing the world wasn't ready for them yet. The book shows how the generals and people in charge couldn't care less about how many soldiers they lost only to push forward a few miles. The main characters Stephen and Danny have to try and navigate their love as well as their seemingly impending doom away from home. (reading note : look at the glossary in the back if you don't know the terminology)

Briana
SWA Readers

I like the book how it is create. I like the book how it is describe. I like the book how the picture is like. The book was not that much hard at all.

Minahil
BAS Reading Champions

Halima
Core Jewellery Group

The Boy I Love is a book about a 19-year-old boy (Stephen) who is off to war for the 2nd time. His lover - Michael - has died and Stephen is left grief-stricken. But there is another boy called Daniel, and they fall for each other. Stephen will do anything to keep Danny safe - but is it enough? I love this book! My favourite character is Danny because he is so kind and upbeat, even in dire circumstances. He is loving, loyal and trustworthy. My favourite part of the story is when Danny and Stephen are in the lookout hole, writing heartfelt notes to each other. I would recommend this book to anyone who likes romance or historical fiction. 5 stars!

Catelyn P
Vista Academy Littleport

I cannot put into words how intensely beautiful this book was. The romance was painful, complex yet hopeful: a gem of beauty amid the thunderous fear and fatality of the trenches. Hussey is able to highlight the horrors of war yet offer a resonant message of optimism to the reader. The ending of this book really made me feel a million emotions deeply - melancholy, grief and hope. My only criticism is the language: I felt it began with an over-explanation of the events yet sometimes lost its way in the middle of the book, where too much was implied (e.g. descriptions of soldiers and telling us who is speaking!!). However, the fundamental ideas and emotions in this book will stay with me forever - please please make LGBTQ+ history and literature more widely accessible!!

Eve
St Kaths

At only nineteen, Stephen has already survived a year of war. He is now coming back to command a platoon of men, despite his injuries. Heartbroken over losing his first love, Stephen finds himself asking why he is fighting. It is then that he meets Danny , a smart new soldier. There is an instant connection that cannot be separated between them, something that is banned in the world at that time and definitely the army. Stephen feels like he has to protect Danny but he has to face the discrimination of the officers along with the relentless attack from the Germans. With the end of summer of 1916 approaching, the final offensive of the Somme comes into view. I really like this book because it shows you can be yourself and different even if people might not like it. I would recommend this book for people who love history and adore romance.

natalia
Vista Academy Littleport

'The Boy I Love' - I did not find this book particularly interesting, the storyline of the protagonist and his love interest was unrealistic along with the life of a soldier in WW1. I felt betrayed that the main character quickly got over his childhood love and fell for another boy in a few days. The plot followed other YA romance books and could have been a very good if written differently with more originality, personally I believe the book would have been more interesting if the author had written and about the protagonist during the beginning of his military career which shows the contradiction between the view of war at home from propaganda and the reality of war and being in love with another soldier. Not knowing whether the other was alive would make the ending of such book bittersweet. I did enjoy how the book portrayed the different of being gay in 1916 and in the army, if the book leaned into this message more I would have appreciated this book more. I did also enjoy the parts where it shows the soldiers in the trenches trying to find hope in what bleak their lives had become, camaraderie, talk of their lives at home, their lovers and fun was what pushed many soldiers to the end. Overall I would say this book is a solid 6.5/10, although would not read again.

Jess
KES Readers

I found the book very interesting and I loved how it explored areas of LGBTQ as its a very sensitive topic for some people, especially since it was set in 1914 where people were not allowed to be interested in the same gender. The plot was thrilling and exotic and the history in the background is very well written, I especially love how their love grows as the story goes on, and its very chaotic at times, this story is very good and I'm sure many people will find that the book is very helpful in certain areas and will love to read it as it may be relatable for some. The style of the book is one to enjoy, the plot is slow and easy to read, which is very nice for our short attention span readers.

Sophie
Tenbury Page Turners 26

9.5/10 A heart warming historical fiction novel, set at the Battle of the Somme, which was so well written and researched. The Boy I Love was carefully crafted and told the unseen story of two soldiers who fell in love on the front line. We follow Stephen, a 19 year old soldier who is returning to the war after recovering from an injury as he grows closer with his "squire" Danny. I could not put this book of forbidden and heart wrenching love down, and was hooked immediately. This is one of my new favourite books, and I would recommend it to anyone and everyone.

Jex
IVC Readers

I loved the way that a narrative account was merged with an amazing historical event, so I was hooked to read it, but also Iiked learning new things about WW1 and the life of a solider that I would never have found out just reading facts off Google. Purely, because the author used this information and structured it in a way which created an interesting and emotional story, that was gripping to read. I really liked how there was sadness and bravery, representing so many soldiers who lost their lives fighting for Great Britain. In a way, I think it is an amazing tribute to those who went unnoticed in the war, especially those of different sexual orientations, who were often underrated and disvalued.

Cecile
St George’s Dragon Readers

I really enjoyed this book, especially the bits where Danny and him are in the trenches, and have a narrow escape from a crumbling tunnel that has been hit. I think the ending is really satisfying and ties up all the loose ends. I like the way the romance is gradually introduced and then gets stronger and then when he thinks Danny is dead, but actually he's not really scared me and then i felt relief. I also think the way the flashbacks are written is really effective as it's almost like you're there, feeling it with him

Elodie
County Shadows

I loved it! The plot and characters were amazing and it made me cry (in a good way).

Olwen
County Shadows

Well written with a good storyline

Ellie
GreatB00ks

I would rate this book 3/5. This is because it displays LGBTQ+ themes and does a great job at emphasising the difficulties people would have had being gay at the time, especially in war. However, in some parts there was a lack of action, making it a bit boring to read, which is why it gets 3/5 and not a 5/5.

Kiaan
The SGS Book Bandits

The Boy I Love is a book I wanted to read the moment I saw it and it I must say it did not disappoint. Stephen and Danny's relationship is so loveable. I love how Stephen slowly rebels against the rules and I felt every moment of frustration along with Stephen and Danny. Definitely my favorite book so far.

Genevieve
Elms Shadowing 2026

An adorable and heart wrenching story that makes me equally sad and joyous. It reminds me of how much work we have done in the world to protect people like me, and how much more it will take to ever feel safe.

Nadia
Elms Shadowing 2026

I enjoyed the book because it explores a theme which, during that period, is borderline forbidden because of different beliefs, and we get the perspective of someone who has to put on a facade to fit in with the rest of the soldiers. I also enjoyed the book because it reveals the harsh mentality soldiers gain from war because of the constant violence and brutality; it really significant because it shows what real soldiers in the war went through. I think the book accurately portrayed what life is with war and forbidden love.

Aleeza
Elms Shadowing 2026

"The Boy I Love" is a moving historical drama set during WWI, but while the emotional premise is strong, I personally found the execution a bit confusing. To be honest, it felt like the different parts of the story didn't really link together well, which made the plot feel scattered and hard to stay fully engaged at times. However, the book still does a good job of capturing the atmosphere of the war and the bravery it took for people to be themselves during such a difficult time in history.

Lojine
Lionheart2026

At first I wasn't the biggest fan of this book as it was quite boring but I suddenly found myself really enjoying this book. It was very intriguing as I went further into the story, I would definitely recommend as a slow burner.

Harriet
Cleeve Carnegie

I loved the opposing narratives of Stephen’s becoming more advanced in the army while also rebelling against authority and societal expectations. The evil characters felt slightly exaggerated, but the book as a whole was evidently well-researched, well written, and unputdownable towards the end.

Sophie
Horsham BOok HUNTers

I really liked reading The Boy I Love because it shows the true brutality of war and how unfair society was and slightly still is. Overall it has an excellent plot, the format is quite complicated but apart from that I think it's a really good book.The Boy I Love has some key themes I don't think I have ever read before, such as WWI mixed with LGBTQ+ and Discrimination. I think William Hussey wrote an amazing book. 9/10

Sara
Chiswick Carnegie

The Boy I Love was an amazing read. It links to the historical context so well that it felt real despite the story being mainly fictional. I really enjoyed viewing the relationship between Stephen and Daniel which had a strong bond with Wraxall's relationship with Michael. The accuracy of the horrors of war caught my eye, with the losses throughout the story being very emotional. My favourite part was the day of the Somme, as it replicates that of the real WW1 as they had lost many of their platoon, just as how Britain had lost many soldiers. It was an amazing read and I felt like I was there in the scene. I would definitely recommend this to anyone above 13. My favourite read so far!

Raf
Ousedale Olney

The Boy I Love is a heartbreaking story that shows the brutalities of war. The relationship between Danny and Stephan broke my heart. I know quite a bit about WW1 but this shows you how they would send millions and millions and they would just be shot down. It shows that homosexuality was a huge problem in the early 20th century. I felt overjoyed when they reunited in the end. The anticipation throughout the book was great. Overall it was one of my top 3 Carnegie reads

Lilah
Ousedale Olney

“The Boy I Love” by Willian Hussey was an excellent book in my opinion. During my reading experience, I could feel the raw emotions of Stephen (the main character). I really felt the tear between his tragic loss of Michael and the developing love and protective instinct for Danny. The concept of the book shows a contrast between internal and external conflict: love and war, things that cannot coexist. The book doesn’t hold back on the descriptive factor, and every single vocabulary choice feels deliberate to drive home a message. Personally, I don’t read much of this genre, but after this book, I would love to read more. Overall, this book is one I would recommend to ages 13 and up. It is a semi-mature book that deals with heavy themes such as loss, LGBTQ+, war and more.

Dat
The Lotus Readers

I like the book, but I didn't really like how the fonts were so small. I like how Stephen slowly started developing feelings for Danny, admitting to being attracted to him and even breaking military rules for him. I like how the ending was realistic and bittersweet.

Miguel M.C
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

"The Boy I Love" is a moving historical drama set during WWII, but while the emotional premise is strong, I personally found the execution a bit confusing. To be honest, it felt like the different parts of the story didn't really link together well, which made the plot feel scattered and hard to stay fully engaged at times. However, the book still does a good job of capturing the atmosphere of the war and the bravery it took for people to be themselves during such a difficult time in history.

Lojine
Lionheart2026

This was an amazing book! I was hooked immediately, and found I could not put it down. I found myself getting emotional at some bits, and overall was a really great read!

Heidi
HGS Book Club

The Boy I Loved was a really interesting read. I enjoyed the writing style, it followed Stephen’s viewpoint and it helped to understand his thoughts. The storyline was really good, mainly taking place before the battle of the Somme, showing us what happened in the battle. I liked moving between the setting of the war, starting at the beginning when he had gone back into the war as an officer, then we learnt more about the past and how he was sent back to the War, and then it went back into the present. I really enjoyed learning about the history and the First World War. I found the detail about the trenches really interesting, it gave details about the rituals some soldiers had. The book showed how hard it would be to kill another person. The book showed how soldiers weren’t treated as humans, the harsh conditions of the training camp before they went to battle and how some died from infections and injury before they went to battle. The books also showed the injustice as some officers didn’t go into the trenches so they didn’t know what it would be like and didn’t listen to what people were saying. It showed how they still went ahead with the Somme even though they had been warned it wouldn’t be effective, we learnt about people spying into the German trenches and seeing the differences in conditions, but the officers making the decisions weren’t listening to the warnings about how bad it would be. I found it awful how field punishments took place, soldiers were hung up and treated really badly. The book was also about identity and the way Stephen was treated because of who he was in a relationship with. It showed how hard Stephen’s life was and how he was treated by his family. I would really recommend this book – especially to people interested in World War One.

Edmund W
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I thought that this book was very interesting but it wasn't very exciting until the very end of the story, which made it a bit hard to keep reading. I think that the reason that it was very slow was because they were at war and it gave you the feeling of waiting for your first or next battle and until you die. The character of Danny was a nice and believable but I thought that the story about his mother didn't give the story anything and all it did was explain Danny a bit and push him into a bad light because up till then he was nice and normal but he then told his whole story which complicated him a bit. The rest of the platoon acted as you would imagine twentieth-century soldiers to act. When the Germans put up a sign about their doom, some of them responded with saying they could sort out the whole of the war over a pint of beer. Why were Stephen and Danny the odd ones out? It made them seem a bit unreal. I think that the fact that the main character, Stephen, was a Second- Lieutenant and he was only nineteen was very interesting because he had had so much more experience than all the other men who were twice his age. Overall, I thought that the characters were very believable and the plot was made on the basis of an actual story that happened in World War 1.

Ruby
The Perse Carnegians

The Boy I Love was a great book. It's about a Lieutenant in the First World War called Stephen who comes back to duty after getting his trench raided and therefore losing his friends and getting his ear blown off, however receiving a Military Cross for killing a young German boy who raided his trench. He could've stayed home to have a nice life while all his friends went to war, but he didn't, because he thinks he didn't deserve the glory of an MC. Because instead of going head on to face the Germans attacking his trench, he played dead and waited for a young German boy to stray away from the group and shot him dead, just after the boy said ' Kamerad' meaning Comrade. He returns to the Front with the guilt of killing a young boy in cold blood. But when he meets a boy called Michael his world turn upside down, from misery and despair to happiness and joy. On the lines of the Front, they face unfair Leadership, bullying from other Officers and tough times talking to each other about their past. When they're given the order to go over the top of the trenches in the Battle of the Somme they face constant bullets from snipers and machine guns injuring Stephen and leading to Michael to save him. This book was very detailed and even though I didn't find some of the things Michael and Danny did very pleasant I still enjoyed it greatly because of the accurateness and detail in the book and to the superiority in the German trenches compared to the British. Overall, I really enjoyed it. My favourite so far. 9.5/10.

Sebastian H
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed The Boy I Love, it has made it into some of my top reads! It was a captivating book that really roped you in. This book explains the horrors of war and how unaccepting the world was of peoples sexualities at that time, experiencing the loss of friends along the way because of the ugliness of war and the brutal conditions in the army. Stephan and Danny's relationship had some little bumps along the way which made the book even more lovable and relatable to an extent. Hussey shows in this book the struggle some people have to go through to survive and having a troubled childhood and accepting the ones you love no matter what. Overall I really liked this book and will definitely look into reading more of William Hussey's books.

jess
Diary of a Wally Kid

I found this book very boring. I found the characters to be one-dimensional and uninteresting. on the subject of the characters I found them to be unrelatable and I couldn't connect with the characters very well. I didn't like the choice to have the setting in the First World War but I did understand why it was set then to emphasise the homophobia of 100 years a go. The book was way too long and it felt very boring as I was reading this book and it honestly helped me get to sleep. The problem was not how long it was but was how it was written as some long books can be very enjoyable to read. this book was my least favourite so far and I found it to be mind numbingly boring. However I appreciated the message of how bad homophobia used to be so it gains an extra point. 1/100

Elliott.H
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The boy I love was a book filled with love, death and the hard times of the first world war. I thoroughly enjoyed the language the author chose, really depicting what those times might have sounded like. Another thing that surprised me was the fact that the book was not only about love, but the war too, it made the book exciting and expanded my knowledge. If I could improve this book in any way, it would be to have a name glossary because for me, I find it very difficult to remember all the people's names and surnames! Overall, I really enjoyed!

Jana
The Perse Carnegians

A lot of war talk-fascinating and appalling-but made the book feel like it went on too much. The lives lost, bravery, horrific conditions, ill treatment of 'privates' and the atrocities of war were well written and well presented. The world view of homosexuality 100 years ago must be difficult for the younger reader to comprehend. A bit of a twee ending but after Percy's death any of them could have been next so it was twee but a relief- and a few tears!!! A bit long but the best of the Carnegie's on offer this year in my opinion.

Debbie
Ousedale Olney

I loved this book! I thought it was a sensitive and poignant portrayal of forbidden love through times of distress. Danny and Stephen’s love felt natural and the storyline overall was very engaging.

Yuvi
KECHG Shadowers

I feel this book is incredibly moving and relatable towards those within the LGBTQ, highlighting struggles we face in life - and past history. It's a good way to shine a light on the fact that the LGBTQ wasn't 'just around' in the 21st century and has in fact appeared much further in the past than some people perceive. This book has made me feel a range of emotions from upset to warm to angry; angry towards the idea these things truly have happened to people, upset through the events within the book making me feel moved, and warmth from how despite everything, they make it work.

Michael
The Wells Readers

Its a really sad but beautiful story about two soldiers in World War I who fall in love. It follows Stephen, who is struggling with his past, and a new recruit named Danny who helps him find hope again. I liked how it showed their connection even though they had to keep it a secret because it was illegal back then. The ending is quite heart-breaking because of the war, but it’s a powerful book that makes you think about the soldiers who were forgotten by history.

Isabel
Vista Academy Littleport

I thought that it was really rubbish and that the author mixed in the present day too much with the past. It wasn't really a needed story to tell and it was just a waste of time processing this book and I wish I didn't read it. It was so RANDOM!!! 3/10 #dontreadit

Isaac
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

i loved this book and it was inspired by an real story but it did have some sad moments defiantly would recommend

poppy
Cottingham High School

Edith
Montsaye Shadow Readers

I enjoyed the book. I found that it was characterised very well and I understood the characters. The plot was interesting and kept me engaged while reading the book. I would award this book 4.5 out of 5.

Edith
Montsaye Shadow Readers

The Boy I Love is a heartfelt book about friendship, love, and resilience during wartime. It follows two young men. The boys are in love with each other, while they face world war 1. The book was very engaging and I really enjoyed it because I find war novels interesting . Overall, I really valued this book and would definitely recommend it to my friends as it is very enjoyable to read and I genuinely liked it ! My rating is 4 stars out of 5 because this is the first book I have picked up in a while.

Oliver H
Glossopdale Readers

The boy I love was my last Carnegie book to read and it was quite good. The plot was alright, but I did get confused at some points. I struggled to get into it, but once I was about a third of the way through, I couldn't put the book down. The characters were fun and I quite liked Danny as he was a good chap. I thought that Beddowes was a character that exists in many wars, horrible and not caring about the healthcare of others. It was really interesting to find out more about life in the trenches and the protection/defensive that goes into it. The ending was a bit naff and seemed to wrap up quickly and didn't have the ending that I was hoping for. I would recommend this book to 13-15 year olds because some of it has sensitive themes but it is a good read. Overall I would rate it a 6.5/10 as it could have had a better ending and been more engaging at the start.

Amelia M
Skipton Shadows

This is the first book I have read from the shortlisted list. I had high hopes for this book, but it truly disappointed me. The first 110 pages were quite boring and hard to get into. I nearly stopped reading it because they were so boring. Then there were 50-60 pages in the middle that were exactly what I came for. I was actually planning to give this book 3,5 or even 4 stars out of 5 if that kept up. But then disaster struck. The ending... I do not have the words to explain how frustrated I was when I finished the book. The epilogue is so terrible in my opinion. I had the feeling the author wanted the book to end happily, but then remembered it was a war book, and in his mind, a war book can't have a happy ending (which I disagree with, and we should let some war books end on a happy note). But the author didn't want to kill any of the characters. He decided to force out a bittersweet ending that was definitely rushed, as 2 years were condensed into 10 pages. I hated it so much. Upon further thought, I also realised that Michael, his ex-boyfriend, isn't a real character either. Our main character will be out there drawing, will think of Michael for 2 sentences, and then go back to making out with Danny. Michael is so useless in this story! In the end I am giving this book 2,25 stars out of 5.

Aniela
Sullivan Shadowers

I loved this book so much and it gets a 9 or even 9.5 out of 10 from me. I thought the progression of the book felt natural and stayed interesting throughout, and the development of Stephen and Danny's relationship was well written. I also really liked that the ending was realistic yet also hopeful.

Linn
KECHG Shadowers

this book has taken me on a rollercoaster of emotions I had never ridden in my life until now. It's touching, poetical language made it impossible for me to put down for even a second. It's 1916, and young Stephen Wraxall is sent back to war after a cruel injury in war at the front, the memory of his old comrades and first love haunting him as he goes back. But when he meets his new soldier-servant, Danny McCormick, Stephen is made clear of one thing; the undeniable connection between him, and how he cannot let him go. But there is one unignorable question left: will this love between Danny and Stephen save them from this raging war? Or will it leave them damned in the horrors of war? The story of Danny and Stephen has made my heart both ache and burst with joy all at once. The book itself is full of characters to love and despise, all beautifully and amazingly written, but not too complex. It is emotional, but not to the point it's unbearable. It goes through the true gruesomeness of war, and how true lovers are torn apart in the process. Not only this, but it shows what war can do to a man, the scars that it leaves on them, that was what really rubbed the salt into the wound for me. Overall, this book stuck to me for a while after I read it, and that's exactly what the Carnegies look for: books that stick to the reader. Although I have yet to read the other books listed for the medal, this book has won my heart, and has definitely got my vote!

Afsheen
FGCS Bibliophiles 2026

I like how the setting is in World War One and how the characters connect together but I cried on the first part when it said Danny’s best friend Micheal died.

Isabella
Lionheart2026

It's a really good book with strong character development. It ended quite abruptly though which was a bit annoying as they where in the middle of the battle. What ever you do, do not read about the battle of the Somme as it can ruin the ending of the book.

Charlotte
Fullbrook Bookworms

The boy I love is a story of life at war, and the struggles soldiers faced every day. Set in 1916, this is a story of forbidden love in the trenches, Danny McCormick and Lieutenant Wraxall (the main character Stephen) must face their fears and head into war whilst keeping their love for each other secret. My favourite part of the book was when Danny and Stephen first met on the train. This scene felt so real and the emotions were very intense. My favourite character was Danny because he is so caring and considerate towards Stephen and his crew. I thought I would enjoy this book more than I did but I just struggled to connect with some of the scenes and didn’t feel the urge to continue the story, however towards the end of the book it became more tense and gripping. I would recommend this book to people who enjoy reading LGBTQ+ and History. Overall, I probably wouldn’t read this again, but it wasn’t too bad.

Gwen
Vista Academy Littleport

'The Boy I Love' is about Stephen and Danny, two soldiers during World War 1, falling in love when it was impossible and punished by law. This novel is deeply touching and heart-breaking, full of a never ending emotional journey transporting us in the everyday life of a lieutenant and its soldier-servant. I really recommend this book to anyone liking action, suspens and romance books.

Iris
4Shadowers

I thought that The Boy I Love was a beautifully written book. It had incredibly detailed descriptions of the scenery, and I really felt as though I was there. The plot was carefully thought out, and that, along with the character arc of the protagonist, Danny, contributed to one of the most heartwarming and yet also heartbreakingly wonderful novels I have ever read. I would absolutely recommend this to a friend, and if you haven’t read this yet, read it immediately.

Amelie
The Maynard School

The boy I love by William Hussey is an incredibly fascinating and heartwarming read.I loved how it was a mix of LGBTQ+and classical war story because even if the book was not necessarily relatable to an audience of a younger age it taught me a great deal about what soldiers had to go through in that time and made me feel allot of gratitude for those who fought for our country. Best booook evvveerrrrrr!!!!!!!!

Josie
Chiswick Carnegie

A truly heart-wrenching story of love and loss in WW1. The Boy I Love was a truly brilliant book filled with inspiring characters, detailed locations and the injustice that so many faced. It's absorbing, you feel every emotion with the characters, when they're scared so are you, when they're happy so are you but, most of all when they're sad the tears are streaming down your face too. The book builds brilliantly, the use of the dates shows you just how much anticipation there was building up to the devastating Battle Of The Somme. The balance of characters in this book was perfect, from the legend that is Captain Jackson to the monster that is Captain Beddowes and all the brave Privates in between and not to mention the honest and beautiful character that is Danny and the caring and loyal Stephen, who both have so much depth to their stories, and all the characters just really make this book beautiful. I cried many times during this book mostly out of sadness but sometimes out of happiness as this book is written so beautifully and so compassionately and gives the fallen soldiers all the respect that they deserve. The powerful message of gay soldiers standing together no matter what was beautiful and Danny's Mum's friend Laura is right "that there'd been people like (them) all throughout history, and that (they'd) be around right up until the final curtain was brought down on the human race", and this is something that everyone needs to remember and celebrate.

Lucy H
The Maynard School

Love in a book The boy I love by William Hussey had me giggling and kicking my feet like the teenage girl I am. This book about two soldiers in the military in WW2 (Stephen a Lieutenant and Danny McCormick a private) finding love in a place and situation so horrible and against them most would find it impossible as they hide their relationship from the Homophobic society of the time, finding small moments to love and live in each others presence. They go through thick and thin together, through being buried in a tunnel to the panic of having no way to keep each other safe forever despite their best efforts. This was such a character driven book you genuinely form connections with the characters so strong you cry when they cry you feel the same sadness and fear as the characters when you think you've lost another character. When you feel like Stephen running through the trenches, flipping through the pages to find out if they are still with you, if you'll get to see that dazzling smile, if you'll get to read about their gorgeous brown curls once more or if they'll be forgotten and buried like the rest of the boys out there in the book. My favourite character in the book is Danny with his light and airy personality bringing joy to everyone in the darkest moments of their lives though the character I felt most connected to was Captain Jackson as he had such a calm personality and helped those he related to and those he shared struggles with without openly saying it instead with subtle gestures and the knowing of how it is helping that person. I do think everyone must read this book at least once just to get the experience of it , the raw emotions fed to you through words, everything so beautifully described you could smell, sense, hear and feel them. The settings were so real I could step into them. A book you don't read through, a book you live through ,a book you get grabbed into, dragged through a battlefield of emotions with and spat out the other end with a book you can't stop recommending.

Eleanor
Euro Champs

The Boy I Love book review The book starts of with Stephen in a train compartment waiting to go to Etaples were he is stationed before he goes to the front. When Stephen is sitting in a compartment a boy called Danny enters. From this small part of the book you can already tell what sort of characters they might be by the way they speak and act. When they get to the encampment at Etaples . The two are split up and Stephen goes to briefed and that he will be getting a knew troop to be in command of after his old one was all killed. Stephen is also given the chance to select a soldier servant. Stephen chooses Danny from the train because of his kindness and cheekiness. Danny is then transferred. They spend time talking and you get the gist the Stephen is attracted to Danny. They set of to the front but the train has a hold up and they have to march the rest of the way. The troop arrives at a town and rest, the two continue to talk and Stephen tells us that he is attracted to Danny. When they get to the trenches in the troop is involved in the battle of the Somme, it was one of the bloodiest battle of WW1 and this book portrays it very well. Stephen tries to protect Danny and from the superiors and Stephen risks his position. In the end they both fall in love but realise they cant be together in the world they live in.

billy
Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

This story is a deep story following Danny and Stephen, and their battles on the frontlines, as well as their inward battles of self-acceptance and understanding. I really liked how the author balanced out the different scenes, as the tension running through the book was constant but not overwhelming. The character dynamics were natural and impactful, and it was clear the author had researched a lot. I loved Stephen's character progress as he gradually learned how to step away from the prejudices from his family and leaders.

Lettie
Diary of a Wally Kid

I felt it was very dark at the beginning but as the book progressed I found it was more enjoyable.

Emily
Carnegivores

I liked it but took me a while to get into. I would recommend it but it isn't a book I would usually read.

Matilda
Cottingham High School

I really enjoyed this book, it had a really enjoyable story and I finished this in one sitting. It had really good description of the surrounding and I loved the setting, it was really sad but showed the reality of WW1 extremely well. The build-up was great and what happened at the end was so unexpected but interesting. Overall, the book had a great atmosphere, had characters that I was invested in and I loved the setting and story so much. The romance between the two main characters was different from the typical romance you see and was so intriguing and very well built up. It left me wanting more.

Coey
Kingdown Wilts

The Boy I Love is a book about romance and is a thought provoking book. It is set in World War I in the military and is about a young man named Stephen Wraxall, a young lieutenant who is heart-broken from the loss of his best friend, who meets Private Danny McCormick, a talented, smart young recruit who becomes very close to Stephen. They have to go through WWI while being in love with each other. I think it was a great book as it probably makes people aware that it is ok to love a boy. 8/10

Sylvan C
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I thought this was an amazing book, with the LGBTQ+ inclusion and it being put into WW1 which thought was really cool. I did think at the start it was really slow but once you are halfway through that's when it gets really good. But other than that I thought it was amazing and would highly recommend.

Taylor
Bramcote College Library

The book is very good .For reader that love romantic storybook will love this. It has some word that are hard but basic is fine.The story line are great and it make me want to continue reading.Why I am reading this book one of the reason is because of the book cover it attracts my attention and the title make me know what is it going to be about in this book.

Jenae
Lit Legends of Swavesey

I believe ‘The boy I love’ is a book that I really enjoyed because it felt emotional and realistic, even though it’s set during a difficult time in history. The story is about love, family, and secrets, and it made me think about how hard life must have been for people back then. I liked how the main character is strong but also confused sometimes, which made him feel real and relatable and was a powerful moral to not give up on what you want.

Neveah
SMMA BOOKWORMS

Dear Mother, I hope this finds you well. I am writing to you from the trenches. We have been making the best of it but it is dashed hard at the moment good old Alfie from school was shot by the Hun last Tuesday. When I think of how sad it is for Maggie and that the baby she is expecting will never meet their father, such a tragic loss but we will not be defeated for good old blighty will triumph! But it is hard to keep one's stiff upper lip when you see so many young men die around you. I should be home soon. I can't write about it but the war should be over soon. Give my love to Father and tell little Dora her socks she knitted are keeping me nice and dry. I think about the last summer we all had together all the time. I pray we will be back soon and we can finish that game of cricket. Best wishes, Your loving son, Reginald

Hazel
Atlantic Awesome Readers

Its a good book however it is not very well thought out, most things happen just by chance and the characters are very 1 dimensional. The book ends very abruptly in the middle of the war and, any plot holes are left without any resolve. The story is quite sweet but unsatisfying.

Amelia
Stratton shadowers

I found this book very worth reading, and enjoyed the descriptions especially; they made me feel as if I were in the trench. My great-grandfather died in the Battle of the Somme, so this story feels quite meaningful in that sense. However, I sort of missed the storyline a little in some parts, and it was quite a heavy read. Nonetheless this book is definitely one of my favourites so far.

Clara
Bassingbourn Readers

'The Boy I Love' is a deeply moving and thought-provoking book. I found it both emotionally compelling and engaging. One of the novel’s greatest strengths is its exploration of identity, particularly through the lens of sexuality during a time of strict societal expectations. Set partly during the First World War, the story follows Stephen and Danny, two soldiers who navigate the the complex situation of their love for each other and acceptance in a world that demands silence. This creates a constant tension that makes the narrative feel urgent and, at times, heart-breaking. Hussey writes with sensitivity, allowing the reader to connect deeply with the Stephen and Danny’s internal struggles. I also love the quote at the beginning of the book by Wilfred Owen. The emotional impact is of this story is undeniable. The romance between Stephen and Danny is not idealised; instead, it is complex and shaped by secrecy. This makes it feel more realistic, considering the time period the book is set in. Particularly, I appreciated how the novel showed the truth of how LGBTQ+ individuals were treated historically. If I had to point to one negative element, it would be the pacing which felt uneven at times. Some sections are richly detailed and immersive, while others move more quickly, which disrupts the flow of the story. Overall, this book is a poignant and important novel that succeeds in telling a story often overlooked in historical fiction. It challenges the reader to reflect on love, identity, and courage. It is a memorable and impactful read.

Priyanshi
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

"The Boy I Love" was an amazing book! I personally enjoyed reading it as many emotions were brought out of me, such as, fear, sadness and joy. I loved the characters, the story and how everything was well written. This book may be one of the ones I wish to reread in the future if that be from me buying it myself or reading online if possible because of how it generally amused me. The book covers how devastating WW1 was, how many lives were needlessly lost, and how cruel it was. The story tells how horrid living conditions were in the trenches, and how soldiers might have felt in that scenery. It also shows how people of the LGBTQ+ community might have felt back then, silenced or maybe feeling it was wrong/unusual. My favourite character was the main one, Stephen! I like how he isn't a stereotypical fearless soldier, but instead someone who has interests, someone who wants to be better. His fear is shown through his hands shaking at most times and I like how subtle this may be. It isn't dramatized or made into a big thing as he "has" to be brave due to his role. Finally, what I mostly have to say is how I had to actually cover my mouth a lot to hide a smile or my shocked face while reading this in classes I had cover for due to significant moments. Only well-written books can do this to me and it felt refreshing for that to happen. Overall, The Boy I Love is an amazing book which covers many themes like forbidden love, fear, friendships/relationships and most of all War.

Danielle
Tractors

I really enjoyed the book because it talked a lot about he's Best Friend Michael that died in world war 1. and also about hes father on page 1 and 2 and how he had also explained it. The page i really liked the most was page 25 Lieutenant Stephen Wraxhall initiates his return to the frontlines in 1916 France, quickly requesting Private Danny McCormick as his soldier-servant following their initial meeting. This section highlights Stephen’s struggle with the loss of his previous love, Michael, and establishes the severe danger of their developing relationship, underscored by a superior officer's warning regarding homosexuality in the battalion. I would recommend this to a friend or a family member and also recommend this to 13+ or 14+

Nyah
SMMA BOOKWORMS

this book is super good i really liked it as i think some people might be able to relate to it and find some comfort in the book as not many people will agree with it i think its good for some teenagers that might be a bit lost in life and are trying to find themselve. it also talked about the boy losing his brothers which again people might find comfort in

shavani
SMMA BOOKWORMS

This was an amazing book! To show how hard it was for LGBTQIA+ people back in those days is incredible. Stephen is such an interesting character for me. He is so stone faced and mysterious at the start but begins to soften up once him and Danny spend more time together. Danny is almost as intriguing as Stephen, from his background to the way that he acts. This book was awesome, would totally recommend!

Fia
Knox Readers

I really enjoyed this book. I adored the relationship between Stephen and Danny. The description and the love between 2 men, despite it being illegal in the time, is so well done that it left me wondering if the was a book 2. Throughout the book, I enjoyed the tiny cliffhangers and at 1 point I thought Danny had/would die and I kind of freaked out because of how connected I got to the character. I loved the book because, not only was it so beautifully detailed, it was about a relationship between 2 young men fighting during WW1. I sure hope William Hussey makes a book 2 because I enjoyed the first book so much!

Lizzie
Ousedale Olney

The boy I Love by William Hussey is set in World War 1 where a boy called Stephen finds love in the horrors of the trenches and must keep his feelings hidden from his fellow soldiers. Stephen never wanted to go to war but was sent by his father to make him stop loving other boys and to be more manly. The boy he loves, Michael follows him into war because of his love and loyalty to him. Tragedy strikes when Michael dies in the war. When Stephen is sent back out to the Somme he meets a boy called Danny and falls in love with him. He must hide his feelings from his fellow soldiers while also working hard to keep Danny safe in the long and tiring war. The main themes in this book are World War 1 and the difficulties gay people faced in those days. It is about finding love in the horrors of the trenches and hiding it from everybody else. I enjoyed this book not only because it is an amazing story but because it also told me about some of the things that happened in World War 1. I would recommend this to anyone who likes a bit of history and some romance. Overall, I think The Boy I Love is a brilliant book that is informing about how much gay people in the olden days had to hide but also about World War 1 and what happened in France and the Battle of the Somme.

Greta
Helkats & Hardbacks

I’ve got pretty mixed feelings about The Boy I Love. I understand why so many people love this book, the storyline packs a real punch and has a lot of heart. It’s set during World War I and follows Stephen, a young soldier heading back to the frontlines, who falls for another soldier, Danny. Watching this forbidden romance unfold right in the middle of war is gripping. But honestly, even though the plot had so much going for it, I didn’t enjoy the book as much as I hoped I would. Sometimes the pacing dragged, and a few sections felt way slower than they needed to be and that it took too long to get to the real action. I also couldn’t quite connect with Stephen or Danny the way I wanted. You’d think with everything going on, the danger, the secrecy I'd really enjoy it but their emotions didn’t always land for me. Because of that, some of the big moments just didn’t hit as hard as they should’ve. Still the story itself is the book’s biggest strength. There’s a lot in there about forbidden love, prejudice, and the messiness of war, and all of it comes across in a really thoughtful way. The core idea sticks with you, even if the writing or characters don’t quite get in your head. In the end, The Boy I Love has a powerful and emotional concept, but for me, it just wasn't my favorite. I respect what the author was trying to do, and there’s a good story at the heart of it—it just didn’t fully work for me..

Maya F
The Maynard School

The Boy I Love is a thoughtful story about a young man figuring out who he is and what he wants. The characters feel believable, and the book shows how complicated friendships and family relationships can be without making things overly dramatic. The writing is clear and easy to follow, and the emotional moments feel genuine. Overall, it’s a quiet but meaningful book about growing up and understanding yourself. I give it a 8/10

Edison
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Melodic, old-fashioned and has brilliant world-building (be wary of spoilers)... The world of Stephen and Danny doesn't seem too far from ours - it's set in WW1 and I think it's really interesting to see the difference between how he talks and how characters in more modern books talk because of the difference in timeline. The tone is really refreshing and I like how he describes it as the "meatgrinder". I quite like Lady Labelle and Captain Jackson as characters. I find it extremely surprising though that Jackson is not a straight character because it is indeed needed to make Stephen and Danny possible, but I would be very surprised if that had happened at the time. In my opinion the more common reactions would be more alike that of Stephen's mother and Robert, only because at the time it was not considered acceptable. I also think Lady Labelle is a really important character and helps Danny find out who he is and I find it very sweet. I also find it heartbreaking when Jackson admits to being the reason for Percy's death, because the only difference between him and Percy was slightly more power but he and Stephen still couldn't do anything to stop them sending them up top while the wire wasn't cut. I found the use of repeating the memory of the German soldier saying "Kamrad" very powerful because it gave the readers an insight into the guilt of murdering as well. However, I find it odd how at the end, and even before, Stephen and Robert's injuries don't get mentioned very much, especially how Robert goes on to do carpentry, after being wounded by a chunk of shrapnel in his shoulder (wouldn't that stop him being able to do that or at least make it a lot harder?) Overall, it was a great book - however the injuries didn't quite add up for me and the ending seems kind of uneventful. Don't get me wrong - I like that they are reunited - but the rest of the book is really action packed and because of this I really expected a bigger ending. I love the language and the message that nobody really loves war unless they are far away from it and it's not their lives on the line.

Ellie
WSFG Carnegies Shadowers

I think this was an excellent book and the storyline was very enticing. I think it is an 8/10. I have 1 slightly negative comment about the book and it is that the ending is very very sad but that is just my opinion. I think that overall this book is a very strong contender to win.

Oserbea
HAEC Books and Biscuits Carnegie Shadowers

Testing

Claire
The Wells Readers

This book was a heartwarming story set in the war. I really enjoyed it and I found the book on the whole very interesting. I would definitely recommend it to others as it such an amazing book. I would rate it 5/5. My favourite character would be Danny because of his bubbly, cheeky personality and how he is so kind throughout the whole book. Overall, I really enjoyed this fantastic book!

Fleur
Rainbeau Readers

"The boy I love" is now one of my favourite historical fiction books because of its beautiful storytelling and wonderfully imaginative ways of expressing the characters' emotions and plot in general. William Hussey captures the tense atmosphere of the war perfectly (although I might not be the best judge since I’ve never been to war) and does so in an enticing poetic manner that keeps you gripped throughout the book. I also loved how the characters had so much depth to them and how we got to learn about their backstories as well! Overall a five star review from me!

Lucy B
The Maynard School

I found this book very enjoyable because it was very sweet and had a great plot. It got me attached to the characters very easily and I felt like I was going to cry from the first 5 seconds in because of how much I loved the characters. I felt as if I couldn't put the book down the entire time I was reading and almost finished it in one sitting. The only problem I had was that it was very confusing at some points but at least it helped me learn some new words for the future. This was by far one of my favourite romance books I've read in a while and I will defiantly re-read.

Amelie
Plumites

In the book The Boy I Love written by William Hussey, the plot features Stephen Wraxall, a 19 year old second lieutenant. In the book he is returning to the front line, after recovering from the death of his first love. This book features a forbidden bond as in 1916 it was unfairly said that being gay was a crime. Stephen and Danny, his new recruit and love are sent to do a very dangerous mission which had seemed to be underestimated. They come back scarred and wounded trying to tell their superiors how much they had underestimated them. This raises the tension because so many people’s lives rest in their hands. The main themes in the book are the forbidden love of Stephen and Danny and trying to hide their LGBTQ+ identity, this brings to light the regularly ignored being of queer people in history. It also brings to light the brutality of the war, and the countless loss of lives. The characterisation of the book mainly focuses of the wide contrast between the dark war and the bright, hope of a young couple. The style of the writing is a balance between smooth and flowing and the dark and gritty part of the war. It makes it a very interesting read. And would recommend to anyone else.

Hugo
Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

I'm not really interested in romance or WW2 but I liked the way that the author can explain the past and write it so well.

Marwa
Dunraven

I did not think that The Boy I Love was a particularly original book. I found that its plot mirrored many YA love stories and had limited originality. I was excited to read a romance book set in the war, but was disappointed by the lack of use of the setting. I feel the book could be set in any other time frame with only limited changes. I also found this book unrealistic, as it is mainly set within one month of 1916, and the pace at which the book went was not realistic at all. The romance within this book was not great either, while at times I felt it heart-warming and moving, I was constantly reminded that the protagonist had very quickly moved on from the death of the man he had once loved, which caused me to throw doubt at the truth within this new romance. However, I found the main characters overall likeable, however I found parts of their characters unbelievable. I found myself deeply moved by certain deaths and I felt true anger at the antagonists within this book. I also enjoyed the writing style and found it was used skilfully to reflect life in the trenches. I always love an ending that leaves the reader with unanswered questions, and this was quite the same. I feel there could have been slightly more links between the story and then the ending two years later and I found the ending a little too incomplete, but overall, I found the book enjoyable and easy to read but I think that if the love between the two characters had been forged under the duress of the war and strengthened by the grief they shared, it would have been a much better book. I would rate this book a 5/10, enjoyable if you’re looking for a not-overly realistic love story set with the backdrop of war torn England.

Lulu
KES Readers

t Is the Boy I Love stayed with me long after I finished reading it. From the outset, I found myself rooting for the unlikely yet inexorable love between Danny—a cheeky, West End chappy full of warmth and bravado—and Stephen, with his quieter, middle‑class reserve. Hussey plunges the reader into the horror and absurdity of the First World War, where young men are confronted with death at every moment. For Danny and Stephen, however, survival carries an additional peril: the constant fear of discovery in a world that punishes their love. Amid the mud, violence, and devastation of the trenches, the novel offers moments of profound tenderness and hope, much of it embodied in Danny’s brave and sunny personality. His humour and resilience act as a balm not only for Stephen but for everyone around him, illuminating flashes of humanity in an inhumane setting. Through their relationship, Hussey reminds us that love itself can be an act of defiance—something fragile, dangerous, and yet fiercely sustaining. The novel balances heartbreak with hope, making it both devastating and deeply life‑affirming.

Celine
Sandroyd Bookivores

This book was a beautiful, fascinating, yet heartbreaking story of love, loss and hidden identity. It was absolutely amazing and I loved it from the start right until the end. Other reviews have said that it was slow-burn but I honestly found it quite quick. If anything I found the relationship between the 2 soldiers very fast. Especially considering they had to hide their identity and they were suffering in a deadly war, it was perhaps a little too quick. Nonetheless, it was such a heart-rending and important story.

Emma
Ousedale Shadow Chasers

The boy I love is a story set in WW1 about 2 boys Stephen and Danny. At the start Stephen returns to the battlefield after the death of his boyfriend and platoon. On the way to France, he meets the charming private Daniel McCormick. This book is about Danny and Stephen's forbidden love story in the hell of the trenches of WW1. My favourite part of this story was when Danny and Stephen slowly started to fall in love with each other and when they first kissed. I think that the most exciting part was when Stephen was buried in the tunnel and all he could think about was Danny. I would recommend this book for anyone who loves Heartstopper and History.

Georgina
Sandroyd Bookivores

I absolutely loved this book. The way it explored themes of forbidden love in a war setting did an incredible job of keeping tension high whilst still providing the reader with those moments of downtime where the amazing writing and personal moments can really shine. I would definitely recommend this book.

Sophie
KECHG Shadowers

The Boy I Love was a very good storyline and I rate it a 10/10.

Tiana
Dunraven

This book explores the themes how people would have experienced having to hide part of their identity due to stigma. It was a very emotional book that gave me a view on the struggles of the war and the experiences of homosexual soldiers. The bleakness of the war is contradicted by Stephen and Danny's intimate relationship that kept them going.

Deshna
The Tiffin Girls’ Shadows

I loved this book, even though it nearly made me cry at the end! I would describe it as a reminder that the LGBTQ+ has always been here, and will always be here no matter how society can try to hide us. I particularly liked the way that none of the characters were perfect, and that made them seem so much more real. This book was amazing and such an important and moving read. I would really recommend it!

Evelyn
BCS Book Squad

The boy I love is a doomed love story about two men in the army during WW1. 19 year old Stephen is returning to the front line after injury when he meets Danny. As it's 1916, being gay is a crime and so they can't outwardly express their love for one another and as The Battle Of The Somme looms closer tensions rise in the ranks. The book is a heart wrenching love story that brings together the wholesomeness of young love and the grief of losing people to war. Beautifully written and sure to tug on the heartstrings.

Amelia
KAEP Lions

I loved the book and couldn't stop reading. Its hard to get fully invested into a book that isn't normally about adventure. Having a romance book that isn't just "they fell in love" is an good idea and I think we need more books like this. bravo.

faith
Waddesdon Shadowers 26

I absolutely loved this book. It brings to lights the stories that would have been kept a secret and in such an amazing way. It was well paced with great characters and a wonderful storyline. It’s become one of my favourite books of all time and I was so upset when it ended because I wanted more. If a book deserves to win an award, it’s definitely this one. I’m so grateful that i participated in Carnegie because if I hadn’t I may not have found this book.

Lorin
Carnegivores

I wasn't expecting The Boy I Love to be so good, normally i dont like romance or history, but the the story line is great, and I love how Stephen and Danny's love stick till the end!!!

Emma
Dunraven

good recommend for fans of history and romance could be better if focused more on the horrors of war and how it affects people and their relationships as well as the social problems

eryk
9y4

I found this book very interesting and impressively accurate to the conditions in the Western Front during the First World War. The descriptions and settings were very detailed and I found the plot both rich and understandable. The main character, Second Lieutenant Stephen Wraxall is a emotionally complex, traumatised man who has been thrust into action and finds himself falling for Private Danny McCormick when he returns to the trenches after a severe injury. I found this book very enjoyable. 8/10

Rowan
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I picked this book up because I believe that a setting such as war impacts the atmosphere . With "The Boy I Love" it certainy did not dissapoint . The book was exquisitely written with such good first impressions of characters established at the start that the character development was even better to follow . I now recommened this too all my friends even if they do not read books such as these because I thoroughly enjoyed this read and the representation within it .

Layla
The Tiffin Girls’ Shadows

From Stephan's Platoon get killed from German attack loosing one ear in the, killing one man and loosing his forbidden love. Danny a new Tommie appears into Stephan's life. Love blossoms from War. ◇This was A book that I could not stop reading i was up at night reading it again and again. This was The first book that made me cry. I love this LGBTQ+ book and I give it 5 stars.

Emilie :)
County Shadows

I personally quite enjoyed 'The Boy I Love' for many reasons. Firstly, the link to World War One. I really like books that link to that sort of thing because it adds more excitement to the story and more knowledge which I enjoy very much. Secondly, the LGBTQ+ it contains helps people understand how unfair it was back then to some people because of the rules they didn't want to follow. Even though some parts were not as exciting as others, I loved it.

Amelie
Chiswick Carnegie

This book was amazing! The beautiful storyline was so intriguing and the characters were so loveable and interesting. I loved how the reader finds out more about Danny and Stephens' backgrounds as they get to know each other. Stephen's traumas and PTSD was so well written and I loved how he started to acknowledge it more as the book went on. I wouldn't normally reach for a romance book, especially not if it isn't set in or around the present day but this book has definitely changed that! The boys' relationship is obviously so carefully created and realistic for the time period. I loved Stephen's character development as he looked to make Danny more serious but instead became more relaxed and happy himself. The two personalities compliment each other so nicely and I love the characters so much! The bittersweet ending was so beautiful and I couldn't think of a more fitting ending for the couple. If you are looking for a book to make you laugh, cry and everything in between, 'The Boy I Love' is definitely the book for you!

Roseanna
SCD Pageturners

I really enjoyed this book as it was really easy to picture and feel the storyline, emotions and settings. Even though the boy's experiences are very different to my own, I could still feel like I was living their lives too. I would have liked to hear Danny's perspective of the plot too. Overall, I thought it was a heartwarming and heartbreaking read that I really enjoyed.

Immy
Skipton Shadows

For the last year I have had every reader’s nightmare... readers' block. Then I discovered the following book, and I devoured it! The book in question? The Boy I Love by William Hussey I was transported to 1916 France in the weeks leading up to the Somme; one of, if not, the bloodiest battle in World War One. I followed Stephen as he returned back to the front, injured during an attack on a German trench. I smiled to myself when Stephen began to fall for Danny; before he realised himself. Prayed to myself that they would make it out alive. I will give no spoilers, but I haven't stopped thinking about this book since I finished it and I have returned to it several times to reread my favourite parts. The author is a joy to read and sucks you in as soon as you begin the book.

Jess
Orpington Library Older Teens Group

I love this book. I am a very big fan of history so I absolutely loved this book. This book is about Stephen Wonder who has to return to the front line, While he is there he meets the smart and cunning Danny McCormick. I also love the queer representation in this book. The ending nearly had me crying because I was so scared that they wouldn't get to be together. I could read this hundreds, thousands and millions of times and still love it. I give this book a 10/10

Lily
Rebel Readers

I found the Boy I Love quite a powerful book. It showed the reality of fighting in WW1 and the struggles LGBTQ+ people faced during that time. This book did really well portraying the actual lives of soldiers in the war and everything they had to go through - losing friends or how they were still affected even when the war was over. I did find it a bit unrealistic of how much time Danny and Stephen seemed to have in the trenches and some parts I found confusing because of the pace of the book. Overall though it was a good book, the author showed us the experiences of WW1 soldiers on both sides and how these were actual people in the war, which I think sometimes we forget about. I enjoyed the Boy I Love it was a really good read.

Emma
Vista Academy Littleport

I really like this book because it is WW2 and LGBTQ+ and they are things I'm interested in it is a good storyline

Miriam
Dunraven

A very moving and beautiful story, giving different points of view of the 1rst World War. It makes the reader reflect it’s opinion on the LGBTQ+ , and makes the reader discover how they were seen at the time. It also makes the reader imagine the emotional potential to explore, and it makes it even better when romance is envolved. William Hussey beautifully wrote this book, and I really liked it.

Abby
4Shadowers

I loved this book so much due to the mixing of history and queer representation! However, i did cry (in public, unfortunately) in the end (no spoilers dw). Anyway, i could honestly reread this multiple times but if i could read this without knowing what happens next, i would.

Zosia
GreatB00ks

| enjoyed reading this exquisite and extraordinary novel, as you used fascinating descriptive language to emphasize and highlight the terrors of the war. You also revealed how war at the time was tremendously dull and harsh. You also uncovered how at the time people of the LGBTQ community were not supported as it was actually illegal as it was seen as wrong and erroneous.

Kian
Elms Shadowing 2026

I really enjoyed this book because of the narrator's introduction and his tension with his father. And how we get to see both sides of his character and his interesting 'cog in the wheel' ideology, showing how he sees escaping his harsh reality as futile. His scarred ear shows how is forever changed by the horrors of war and can never be the same again.

David
Elms Shadowing 2026

I love how it represents homosexuality and the struggles of people who faced discrimination for their sexual orientation; 'join up now or forever be a stranger to me and your mother. Go do your duty, son. It will stamp out these degenerate impulses and make a man out of you'. It is heartbreaking and it shows how the main character can only make up for his 'mistake' (being gay) through going to war. I really enjoyed this book as it shows me what homosexual people faced and spreads awareness and tolerance towards the community.

halima
Elms Shadowing 2026

I enjoyed the Boy I love much more than I expected to as it showed the homophobic ideas of the time around world war 1 really well and was very good at showing the horrible conditions that the soldiers had to live in during the war. I thought that the beginning was quite slow and it felt like it was going to be a very boring book but it got better as it went on. I also liked how the ending was happy but still realistic so you felt like the story could have actually happened in real life. I would recommend this book to people aged 12 and over even if they think that love stories aren't really their thing. Overall I would rate this book a 9/10

Robin.O
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I went into The Boy I Love expecting a wartime romance. What I found was indeed a love story, but also a story of how we react under pressure, and what it means to be a good human being. The novel follows Stephen, a young soldier in the First World War, and his relationship with Danny, one that unfolds in the shadows of the trenches, where danger doesn’t just come from the battlefield but from the constant threat of being discovered. Their connection develops in fragments: small moments, coded language, the kind of intimacy that has to be carefully contained just to survive. Plot-wise, Hussey traces Stephen’s journey through the war while gradually revealing the depth of his relationship with Danny. There’s a sense of inevitability to it. There's a tension between what they feel and what the world will allow them to be. As the war intensifies, so does the risk, and the novel leans into that conflict between personal truth and external expectation. What struck me most is how restrained the novel is. Hussey doesn’t overstate the romance or the tragedy; instead, he lets the silences do the work. The love story feels precarious, shaped as much by what can’t be said as by what can. There is also the layer of Stephen's family, who have even sent him to war to try to 'cure' him from being gay. They are not proud of him, and that is awful to read. It’s not just a novel about forbidden love, because it’s about the conditions that make love forbidden in the first place, and the acts of resistance involved in holding onto it love. I very much enjoyed this novel. It fits into a real tradition of adult love stories in the trenches and handles the physical elements of their relationship with tenderness and subtlety. If you want to learn about life for gay people in the past, or life in the trenches, this book will be for you.

Mrs Dye
HGS Book Club

“The Boy I Love” is a well-written book set in the trenches of WWI. I thought that the characters were interesting, as they felt like people who could exist in real-life. However, I thought that the beginning of the book wasn’t very good, as the beginning feels like it’s stuck in the past and just a summary of the protagonist’s life. I think that the protagonist could’ve been written better if William Hussey introduced elements of the protagonist’s story instead of dumping his entire backstory at the beginning of the book. I also feel the same about the deuteragonist, as William Hussey does a better job about revealing his backstory throughout the book, but then just dumps his entire backstory halfway through the book. The ending was a bit dull. It feels like William Hussey just ended the book and then summarises the protagonist’s experiences over the last two years in around 20 pages. Finally, the very last part of the book feels a bit cliché, but I’m fine with this as the ending suits the rest of the book. Overall, a decent book, although I’d not read it again. 6/10

Thomas
Hope Valley Literati

The Boy I Love is a really emotional story set in World War I. It’s about two soldiers, Alfie and Arthur, who fall in love even though it wasn’t allowed at the time. I liked how the book shows both the sadness of war and the sweet moments between the characters. It also made me think about how hard it was for people to be themselves back then. Overall, it is a sad but beautiful story that I would recommend.

Isabelle
4Shadowers

The Boy I Love by is a powerful and emotional story about love, identity, and courage. Even though I didn’t personally relate to it, I still found it really interesting. It’s also really sad and reveals the truth about the horrors of war. The characters are well written, and it shares important messages about acceptance and being yourself. I would most definately recommend this book and hoping it wins .

Rahel
The SBSJs

The Boy I Love is a book about a gay relationship in WW1. Because being gay wasn't socially acceptable back then Danny and Stephan (The two main characters) have to keep their relationship a secret. I liked this book because it’s a book about two lovers but there is more to it than two people loving each other because they are fighting in WW1 and need to survive out in the trenches. This book also just kept me entertained and made me read on. There isn't much that I dislike about the book. I think I would rate it 9/10.

Mason
The Fitzharrys Shadows

I believe that this book got better as you read, so at the start it was boring with general army stuff and the same things over again. But by the end is was more interested and I'm happy it finished with a good ending. However I did feel that it could have been less boring and more engaging at the start.

Seb
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really liked this book. I felt that it explored mature but interesting themes and has a fantastic plot line.

Sophie
Cake a Book Club

The Boy I Love is an interesting book which concerns both the atrocities of the First World War and the political and cultural situation of the time. In terms of pacing and the story, it felt quite predictable and it was quite a struggle to grow a connection to this book. Overall, it was a tough book to read that contrasts the horror of the First World War with a very romantic relationship.

Conor D
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Emotional war love story that shows the love that helps survive wars to only be brutally separated by the government as it didn't suit their social standards. Shows how the people in command didn't have any war experience and ignored critical information that could have saved many lives, also how some soldiers were driven to death by unfair treatment and how brutal the first world war trenches were.

Julia
Reepham Reads

'The boy I love' by William Hussey was an amazing read and by far my favourite out of all the Carnegies shortlisted books. It explored a range of themes like war, LGBTQ+ and romance. It was very detailed and transported me back to 1916. The story was told by a young man called Stephen who falls in love with another young solider called Danny. The book takes us on an emotional journey where we learn about the hardships of world war one and what life was like for LGBTQ+ members in the 20th century. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who wants a historical, romance book.

Issy
Diary of a Wally Kid

This book felt like a recount of true events. The relationship between Danny and Stephen didn’t feel rushed or artificial, as it does in so many books. They both faced challenges, and while it wasn’t a fairy-tale ending, it was sweet and felt genuine as I read. I found the harsh portrayal of trench life eye-opening, showing just how terrible the conditions were for those fighting. I really enjoyed this book and would definitely recommend it.

Amelia
Rainbeau Readers

The boy I love was an interesting story to read. It's about two boys Steven and Danny who fall in love during the first world war. I didn't enjoy reading this book in my opinion however I still think its a well written book for somebody who likes reading these types of books. The reason I did not like reading this book was because it didn't really appeal to me as much as I thought it would, however I would recommend this book to someone who likes reading this genre of book.

poppy
Vista Academy Littleport

The Boy I Love is a really interesting but emotional story. I liked it because the romance feels almost forbidden, since it is set in 1916 when homosexuality was not accepted. This makes the story more tense and exciting, as it feels like anything could happen. The characters are brave, and their relationship feels very 'new' because of the time they are living in. Overall, it’s a great book that I really enjoyed.

Briana
4Shadowers

Personally, this book wasn't really the right fit for me. However, I loved the profound message of the book and I would highly recommend it to people who want to know more about LGTBTQ+ history, people that are in to romance or just people who are looking for a more mature young adult novel.

Liam
4Shadowers

I really loved this book. I loved the fact that even though it is a book about the second world war, it has beautiful moments, described in beautiful ways. One thing that I found extremely interesting is the way that they talked about the Germans. Sometimes they talked about them as the enemy, and sometimes, such as the time when they invaded the German trench and talked to the German soldier, they don’t distance themselves from them that much. I loved all the characters, especially Stephen, Danny and CO Jackson. The only thing about the book that I didn’t like was the ending. I think it was abrupt and didn’t make sense with the way the rest of the story was written.

Iris
The Perse Carnegians

The boy in love by William Hussey is an incredible book with,unlike other love books,many different outcomes.It is not a typical romance as it is set in 1916 during WW1. Stefen is back after having lost an ear at war. He has also just lost his dearest friend,Michael. On the train to France,he draws Michael out of grief which immediately interests a short and interesting boy,Danny. They fight in the trenches together and are always paying close attention to each other,afraid to lose one another.This book was very good for my age range and it really captured my attention as something unique. I read this exquisite book in about 4 days. It is deeply addicting and is probably one of the best books I have ever read. Though I haven't read the other books yet, I think this one is very deserving and should win the Carnegie award or at least the Shadowers prize!

Capucine
4Shadowers

The Boy I Love was beautifully weighted; Stephen’s narrative was perfectly balanced between his light, joyous relationship with Danny and the deeper, heavier war surrounding them. This allowed the novel to be reflective and thought-provoking while still being enjoyable. For me, this book was like a breath of fresh air. It stretched me enough to grieve over the horrors of WW1 and the mistreatment of LGBTQ+ individuals, while allowing me to relax through a gorgeous romance of two lovable characters that is many times re-readable. Now that I’ve finished it, I think it’s safe to say Hussey’s writing is as moving a work of art as The Fighting Temeraire he writes about.

Florence
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

This was a beautiful, well-written book set in a period of time where certain things weren't positively viewed in society. It was also intriguing that the ending didn't end the way that most love stories would. However, by reading the blurb of the book it kind of gave it away to me about how the story will end. overall this was such an intriguing read and I loved reading it!

Afreen
Skipton Shadows

I LOVE this book so much I loved the characters and how all he wanted was to protect him I also loved how it was written it made it so addictive because a part of me knew something sad was always going to happen but I guess they always do with books set in World War One I have read a few books set in this time but none have been this good I loved it from the cover when I saw it was showing an LGBTQ+ story of the war and what it was like for them I found it so interesting. The story follows two young men who find love in the midst of all the horror. Nineteen-year-old Stephen has just returned to the Front after recovering from an injury. He’s disillusioned with the war and is no longer sure what he’s fighting for. When he meets a new recruit, Private Danny McCormick, Stephen knows that he has to protect the boy from the reality of the war. As the pair become closer, they find themselves caught up in a battle with their commanding officers as well as German snipers.

Izzy
HHS 2026

I found this book really slow and boring to read. I didn't find it enjoyable and the plot was quite obvious.

Nadia
St Kaths

This 5-star book is written beautifully. I particularly enjoy the wit of the 18 year old Danny McCormick who seems unable to hold his tongue, even when in the presence of Captain Beddowes, a nasty piece of work who seems to have it in for 2nd Lieutenant Stephen Wraxall ever since the day he stepped on to the foreign fields of France. Stephen’s new unit is headed for the Battle of the Somme in the 1st World War. Whilst travelling through France, Stephen falls in love with Private Danny McCormick and Danny returns the feelings. They hide their love from higher command who can court martial them for how they feel. It shows the startling changes in the way we see people and who or how they love others since 1916. This book shows the harsh reality of war, without diving too far into the graphic detail of the wounds and injuries of the soldiers. This is a brilliant read, and I would recommend it to anyone!

Henry
The Fitzharrys Shadows

The whole thing is very realistic. It almost feels like you’re there with the characters. I enjoyed reading and overall it is a great book

Jasmine
Holyrood Horrors

A really well written book with beautiful descriptive writing and an enticing love story. I read it in a week and loved it especially the fact that it ended without a happily ever after, realistic to the times it was set in. It not only described the negative opinions of queerness at the time but the story was set in a place where it would of been even harder to hide. I loved the character of Danny and his feelings of having to be positive all the time as to suppress the badness he thought was in him. Hussey wrote the characters perfectly so that i felt the same admiration of Danny's positivity and the same hatred of Beddow's contempt for it.

Florence
Carnegie Shadow Judges MEAC

A breathtaking novel with history hand in hand. I particularly liked the suspense lingering behind almost every chapter. This was an amazing read and definitely has a shot of winning!

Charlotte
St Kaths

The Boy I Love is one of the best books I have ever read. Beautifully written throughout and lovely. The ending was bittersweet and heartwarming. I really enjoyed! A 10/10 read!

Annabelle
Crypt Bookworms

I really enjoyed this book. I’m a big fan of romance books and I love the fact that it was set in WW2.

Sage
Lit Legends of Swavesey

I loved the book. Made me want to keep reading even after I finnished it.

Hollie
St Kaths

The boy I love was eye opening . It showed a lot about what it was like to be LGBTQ at that time and the struggles these men had to face because of it . It also portrayed really well how much these soldiers had to go through - not only with fighting and living in the trenches but having to see the horror of seeing all the death and losing their loved ones and comrades. I think sometimes when thinking of the war we forget that whatever side the soldiers were on they were all just men fighting for their lives . They were not all evil - they were trying to do what’s right for their country and I thought this book did a good job of bringing a more human aspect to the topic of the war . Some bits were a little confusing as the book was very fast paced and I found how Danny and Stephen were alone so often a little unrealistic but overall , it was a good book and I enjoyed it . I would give it 4.5/5 stars.

Holly
Vista Academy Littleport

I really enjoyed The Boy I Love, it looked back in lots of events during the First World War and trench warfare. It is set in 1916 France on the run up to The Battle Of The Somme and reflects Lieutenant Wraxall’s encounter of Private McCormick, a new recruit. It was fast paced and a great read, I loved seeing Danny’s and Stephen’s relationship grow in such a horrible time. I also enjoyed the epilogue, it was lovely to see how Danny and Stephen were doing after the war. I highly recommend this book to 12-13 +.

Isla
Ousedale Shadow Chasers

The book was really good and I would definitely recommend it to others that like reading this genre. To be honest, I would read it again and again if I could as I would never get tired of it due to the fact that the characters are fun and loveable while the plot is just absolutely amazing as well. The main characters make the story at the start, middle and end of the book just so intriguing to read about their past and love lives together.

Shanuka
Baxter Booklighters

This was a very good book with many good descriptions, but I didn’t like the writing style as it was hard to follow.

Flic
Ink & Insight

Good book with strong characters but a bit of a sad ending.

Maya
St Kaths

It was very interesting and I loved how deep it went into the history of what happened. However, I would say that the ending felt slightly unfinished, with Danny and Stephen having quite a rushed reunion. I would’ve liked to see more about their life together. Other than that, it was a very good book.

Annabel
Cake a Book Club

The boy I love was an amazing book, my favourite in the Carnegie challenge so far, with heartfelt and intimate scenes. The book is set in WWII, and the language used is lyrical, and I was hooked from the first paragraph. The book is well written, with adjectives and adverbials that helped create clear scenes in my mind. The plot is about an 18-19 year old boy called Stephen who just recently lost someone very dear to him, called Michael Greaves. When Stephen decides to join the army, he meets a cheerful and high-spirited boy called Danny. Stephen immediately decides he needs to protect this boy, do what he never did for Michael. Soon, their relationship complicates, and they become closer, but will the war, and the ever-watching eyes of Captain Beddowes, separate them forever? Find out in this profound and captivating book that leaves you aching for more! Conclusion: Overall I give this book a 4.7/5 stars. Very entertaining and I love the intimacy! This book also highlights the gay soldiers in the chaos of the war, and vividly describes the danger and punishment that homophobics like captain Beddowes can inflict on secret gay couples.

Maria
Euro Champs

I really like this book because the plot was quite interesting and the character design was done amazingly well. Another thing I liked about this book was that I really liked the genre of the book as it had the LGBTQ+ involved with it and making about war added more detail to the plot which I really enjoyed

Skye W
Vista Academy Littleport

I found The Boy I Love a very powerful and hard-hitting book. To me, it highlights the prejudice faced by members of the LGBTQ+ community while also vividly capturing the horrors and brutality of the trenches during World War I. William Hussey writes with emotional depth, making the characters feel real and their struggles and flashbacks poignant. The contrast between love and violence is especially striking, and Stephen and Danny’s bond is strong, but their need for secrecy creates constant tension and heartbreak. Beyond love, the story explores friendship, loyalty, and courage under pressure. By writing from Stephen’s point of view, Hussey immerses readers in his thoughts and feelings, creating a deep sense of empathy for his experiences. Overall, the book is unforgettable, thought-provoking, and leaves a lasting impression.

Jackie
The Perse Carnegians

This book was amazing! Although I had to reread some of the pages as it didn't make sense, it had depth and was really interesting. The two boys from different backstories and different ranks but only 6 months apart made a perfect couple. The ending shocked me a bit as I thought that maybe one of them might die but I was grateful and happy to see they both lived. It was a good read and I enjoyed it a lot. I would definitely recommend for 12-16 year olds.

Alyss
Ousedale Shadow Chasers

I absolutely loved this book, I read it in in 3 hours and was rushed with so many emotions whilst reading this. It was a meaningful book rather than a smutty romance, it focused more on the war around them rather than the blossoming love between two young men in the middle of it all. If there was a sequel; it wouldn't do it justice for this may be a national treasure in the future.

Olivia
Rainbeau Readers

This was a very interesting and inspiring book that really brings the experiences of war to life. It made me feel like I was there on the battlefield, and my heart raced along with the characters as they faced the dangers of World War 1. It also felt very historically accurate. The contrast between Danny and Stephen made the story a really unique read. I liked how they stayed loyal to each other while fighting for their lives and dealing with life-changing choices and secrets. I don’t usually enjoy or fully understand war novels, but this one was definitely an exception. A fantastic book!

Mackenzie
Rainbeau Readers

I loved the book plot and the slow- burn. The angst also changed how I thought of the characters and gave me more of a backstory for the characters. It highlighted the time in which it was set as in 1916 homophobia had a big play in time. William Hussey showed me how Stephen felt through the first person narrative and gave me an explanation of why the characters felt the way they did. Overall I really loved this book and think its very inspirational.

lily
PHS Book Explorers

’The boy I Love’ is a heart-breaking yet beautiful story of two young men’s forbidden love. It is set during World War 1 and both young men are fighting for their country, Great Britain. Follow Stephen and Danny through heart stopping twists and turns, navigating marshy trenches and worrying decisions. As their relationship develops, flourishes and becomes more than just one between lieutenant and private, so does the danger they find themselves in. I would definitely give this book a 10/10!

Maddie
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

I loved this book. I was emotionally compelling and brought light to a time of war. The slow burn felt perfectly paced and I really felt connected to the characters. Some were well written enough for me to despise them. It did well not idolising WW1 without making it a depressing book.

Eilidh
Knox Readers

The story is about how a boy returns to war after an injury and is put back on the frontline. It speaks about the emotions he’s gone through and how when he returns he meets a Private and how their relationship is hidden and frowned on by society and the army. The story follows their love and conflict through the war and how their love is devastating but also beautiful leading up to the battle of the Somme the story to me talked about and highlighted how devastating beautiful love an war Is and although they’re on different spectrums go hand in hand. I give it a 7/10 it is a riveting read although not realistic according to the times.

Elsa
Blake Student Shadowers 2026

All the horror and cruelty of World War One told from a viewpoint we don't often hear about. Times have changed so much, but intolerance and bullying still happen, even now. We still have a lot to learn and this sensitive portrayal helps us by encouraging empathy with the characters.

Bibliophile
Angmering Book Lovers 4 Life

The Boy I Love was a romantic book set in the trenches. Despite how many books I have read set during a world war, I don't think I've ever read a book set in the actual trenches before so that was a new different concept to me. At first, I found it boring and slow with too much army terminology I didn't know, like which of Colonels, Lieutenants, and Captains were more superior. However the book soon improved and there wasn't too much romance. The ending was about how I expected it which was realistic but not too sad.

Aidan
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This is definitely one of my favourite books I’ve ever read! I loved the setting, characters and description. Often when I was reading this, it felt like I was there with the characters, and it was intense but also with a sense of hope, which really made me hope for a happy ending! I’m doing World War I in history at the moment, so it was definitely very useful to learn about how it affected ordinary people and what the fighting was actually like. I found this very impactful and was nearly crying at some points! I found this extremely moving and I was invested in the story, and it was so sad to finish it and know I’ve got no more to read! This is easily one of my favourites so far, I highly recommend!

Iris
Skipton Shadows

'The Boy I Love' is, overall, a well written book with vivid imagery. However, I believe that the romance progressed too quickly, resulting in a lack of emotional depth and connection between the characters. I felt like we moved too quickly past significant character deaths, as well as the world war two setting got relegated to the background and not given its due; it was completely overshadowed by the romance. Therefore, I couldn’t fully relate to the characters or be immersed in the setting. Having said that, I still found the book interesting and totally worth the read.

Evie
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

I found the book mostly boring. The book mostly feels like Danny and Stephen doing side quests together. Nothing really twisting or impactful till the end. It lacks the element of surprise.

Mahad.K
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book is like no other, it is incredible, not only does it show a perspective not often shown in books, but it also shows the light and love in war. I personally don't often read books about war or romance but I love this book. I also admire the way it's written and beautiful language used.

Maddie
Carnegie@StBede’s

A highly engaging but tragic read focused on the war. I feel that the glimpse of the relationship was vital at showing the reality of war and how people relied on each other when others would not help. The book encapsulates these emotions and realities strongly, especially in a period of time where LGBTQ ideas were seen as less valued or were undermined. Ultimately, the LGBTQ inclusion was realistic and more subtle than alternative titles, which allows more immersion into the text's purpose rather than a specific idea alongside it. Otherwise, its a successful book that I would love to see built on.

Kaleb
Folkestone Academy Readers

"The boy I love" was an educational book. It was set in 1916 during WW1. Whilst this book was not one I would usually go for, the pacing and structure was probably the best thing about the it! As a reader I found the book flowed very nicely. Now although the book was not terrible, it did seem to focus a lot on the love between the two boys which was of course frowned upon at the time which I thought was something that took away from the book as well as how Danny and Stephen were alone in the trench it just didn't seem accurate. Other than that the book was enjoyable but as I said it was not one I would go for again in future.

Libby
Vista Academy Littleport

'The Boy I Love' is a heartwarming novel about the second world war and gay love. It is sad, happy and a lot of other feelings. The story shows the difficulty and dangers faced by soldiers in WW2 as well as the prejudice against gay people at the time. I would recommend the book to ages 10+.

Anika
Euro Champs

The Boy I Love is an interesting book which concerns both the atrocities of the First World War and the political and cultural situation of the time. I felt that this book wanted to convey a hopeful message and I think it conveyed that message really well. In terms of pacing and the story it felt quite predictable but yet kept my interest throughout. Overall, a very enjoyable book that contrasts the horror of the First World War with a very romantic relationship.

Benjamin R
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I love this book because it explores a very detailed description of the First World War. There were definitely a lot of words (objects) that I didn't quite understand. The story was told through the main character, Stephan, but I think it lacked some thoughts from Danny (Stephan's love) . The 14+ mostly just goes to the action of the war and the brutalness of torture from the other Captains. This book definitely pulled some of my heartstrings because of the main characters' love for each other. Highly recommend it for people who are interested in the First World War. Loved the relationship between the main characters. Sweet.

Karuna
Norwich High Bookworms

The Boy I love is a book set in 1916 in WWI. It follows the struggles and discrimination coming against Stephen, a Lieutenant heading back to the front after some time at home. He is a homosexual, and on the boat, he meets another boy, Danny, who is also attracted to other men. Stephen tries his best to keep Danny safe, both from Germans, and their commanding officers who would arrest them if caught being gay with each other. I like this book because, while it is a romantic book, it also expresses the hardships that ordinary men who were called up to the Battle of Somme faced in which 20,000 died in a single day. However, The Boy I Love lacked many decisive plot twists and from about halfway through the book, I could predict what would happen based on the way the story was going. Overall, I give this book 4.5/5

Felix C
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The pacing and structure was really good, as well as the character development and plot change. All around a fun read

Elly
Rad readers

The book's writing was exceptionally structured - I'll give it that. William Hussey definitely knows what he's doing when he writes a book. However, that doesn't necessarily mean I instantly enjoyed the book. It felt like it was lacking in things that would actually make it interesting - twists and the like. Too much focus was on the romance and how it was forbidden. For me, when a story begins to revolve around that, it fails to leave room for much else, and becomes - I hate to say it - boring, without flesh or meat. It felt an empty book.

Hanzalah
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book was educational. It followed the story of Stephen, a gay second lieutenant in WW1. He falls in love with Danny, his soldier-servant, or squire, and they campaign for the soldiers not to have to go over in the battle of the Somme. I liked how the relationship was developed but I didn't think it was realistic how often they were alone in the trench. The description of war seemed accurate though, even if the ending was a bit hopeful, considering that all the gay characters survived. Overall, it was a perfectly fine read, just not one I would choose. 6/10

Elijah
Vista Academy Littleport

I really liked this! Nice structure, some emotive description, subtle links to Sassoon's war poetry. I give it 4/5

Mrs Radcliffe
Vista Academy Littleport

This book is beautifully written. It does not shy away from the realities of war nor from the punishments dealt to those who did not conform to societies expectations in those days. The themes of camaraderie amidst conflict, and enduring hope had me feeling uplifted.

Mrs Muller
Folkestone Academy Readers

I liked the development of the romance but I felt that there weren't many twists.

Libby
HGCSC Library

The romance between the two main characters and how it was a forbidden romance because of the time the book was set in (World War 1). I didn't like the ending as I felt the story shouldn't have had a happy ending.

Laura
HGCSC Library

I loved this story the best. I liked the descriptions and adjectives.

Grace
HGCSC Library

The Boy I Love

William Hussey

Author Interview

Shadowers’ Challenge

Submit Review

Submit Artwork

William Hussey

Shadowers' reviews and artwork