Birdie

I thoroughly enjoyed the book as the author took us on a journey through Birdie’s story. Although it was a bit predictable at times, that didn’t take away from the way the book allowed you to follow Birdie and Mr Duke’s feelings and being able to relate the story to real historical events.

Ellena

Reader Leaders

This book was set just after WW1 and truly exposed they unjustness of the mines and how pit ponies are often abused and taken advantage of . We also see the danger's of the pit and how even if people did come back from the war they still faced the danger from the mines. We also see the dark truth of how so many people from the countryside are still very racist to this day.

ezra who know my abd's

ShadowBookers

Very interesting. The book talks about racism and the difficulties of being a black girl in a racist and patriarchal society. It also raises awareness about mistreating animals.

Carson

The SGS Book Bandits

I really appreciated this book for its overall educational yet truthful meaning. This book stars Birdie, a young girl and orphan who has a different skin colour to everyone else and is therefore treated differently. That's until she finds something special... It teaches young readers about racism awareness and a situation that still exists in today's world. This book overall ties together an impactful story-line along with an emotional twist. I would rate this book a 9/10 and found myself fixated on the book for long, intense moments. You should read it too!

Rudolf

The SGS Book Bandits

Chapters were too short, uninteresting and boring. 2/10

Connor R

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I found Birdie a heart-touching story about a girl who faces discrimination after being summoned to her great aunt's village from her care home. She creates a deep bond with a pit pony named Mr. Duke and she decides to secure his future. Overall, it is an exquisite and heartwarming story about fitting in and finding your place in the world.

Kushagra

The SGS Book Bandits

This was one of my favourite of the books, I enjoy the setting of a small village in the Yorkshire dales. I'm not a huge fan of Birdie as a character, however I like her character development as she gets used to living in the countryside. The relationship between her aunt and her is heartwarming.

Felix L

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This was one of my least favourite books, I didn't find it interesting and I found most of it was about horses, and I just don't particularly like them enough to read a book where most of it is about horses. I also found the use of thou and you in the same sentence was just confusing and annoying to read.

Henry W-R

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Throughout the book, we see Birdie’s friendship with a horse develop and the new people in her life come to realise that Birdie isn’t as ‘different’ as they thought she was. Personally, I thought Birdie was a great, compelling story which had me engaged throughout.

Dexter

Horsham BOok HUNTers

Despite this book not really being my style, I think it was written particularly well and had an interesting plot, however I only got to see its full potential in the last few chapters. Not for me, but a brilliant book none the less.

Bethan

Horsham BOok HUNTers

Birdie seemed really interesting at the start, and I was excited to find out what would happen next. However, as I kept reading, I started to get bored because the story felt quite slow. I couldn't stay interested in the plot, and I didn't enjoy it as much as I thought I would. Overall, it wasn't really my type of book.

Lucas

Bookwizards

I liked the book,although at first i thought it was a bit slow in my opinion. The book it very interesting and also spreads a really deep important meaning about racism. My overall rating is 6/10.

Liyana

Sale High Readers

Evie

Tractors

This book is about an orphan called birdie who after living in an orphanage since she was a baby, goes through a massive change and the one thing keeping her going is Mr duke, a horse she found in an old mine. I found this book good but I lost interest towards the end of the book as the plot didn’t go anywhere for ages and it only picked up again in the last chapter. I wouldn’t recommend this book unless someone has asked me especially for recommendations on books such as this. I would rate this book an 8+ as it doesn’t explore any adult themes and has a relatively easy plot line to follow. However I do love the friendship birdie formed with her pony.

Elsa

Helkats & Hardbacks

This is one of the most recent books I have read and I would say that while I thought that some bits were good, I think that the book as a whole has definitely not been my favourite one yet. I thought it got a lot better towards the end, especially in the last 75 pages or so as I thought the plot got more exciting, but it took quite a while for me to start enjoying the book properly. I would recommend this book to children 6+. The plot follows a girl called birdie who had just left an orphanage to go and live with her aunt and uncle, the Winterbottoms, but soon begins to think that she is not wanted there because of her skin colour. One day she goes down a coal mine and meets a horse, Mr Duke. She becomes emotionally attached to him and promises to never leave him. However, she goes home and is heartbroken to find that the coal mines are dangerous and she is not allowed back down there. This plot then continues around this and develops throughout the book.

Naomi

Helkats & Hardbacks

Great book. I enjoy the fact that it was based a long time ago. I really like the backstory/true story behind it. I recommend this for ages 8+ and i rate it 7/10.

Olivia

Stratton shadowers

I really liked birdie, what an amazing story! I loved seeing the friendship between birdie and the pony grow, her aunt and uncle telling her it was a lost cause only made me root for them more. It was a rollercoaster of emotion which made me feel almost as if i was in there. It made me sad when people treated birdie differently, and it made me nervous when she was first meeting the pony. I loved how Mr. and Mrs. Dudley's characters grew through the story.

sunday

LaviShadow26

This is a story a story that compleatly captured my heart. Set in the 1950s yorkshire mining village,the book follows a young mixed race girl named birdie who faces small town prejudice but finds comfort and courage through her increadible bond with a coal mine pit pony, Mr duke.

chloe

SHS Book Club

I thought Birdie was a decent book, however it was quite slow at the start. Because it was from Birdie's point of view, it showed the events of the book nicely, like how the teacher just gave her a puzzle to do even though she was as clever, if not more, than the rest of her class. Overall, it was a decent read and I would recommend to people who want to read a historical book with themes of racism, identity and one with horses in. I would give it an 7/10.

Alfie S

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book is about a black orphan girl who grew up in a mixed race children's home in Leeds and is and sent to live with her great-aunt in 1950's Yorkshire. Birdie is bullied and it gets extreme to the point where she needs to hide in a nearby coal mine, and is surprisingly rescued by a pit pony who she called Mr Duke. Over the next few weeks, Birdie makes an unusual bond with the pony. I rather enjoyed this book but it wasn't one of my favourites.

Lucas

The Fitzharrys Shadows

Nayra

The BSGC Carnegie Collective

Birdie is a book that I personally really liked but I also like the personality of the character and the important theme in it made it extra special. Im also a horse lover and I have always been interested in world wars and how life was not only for the people fighting it but also the people that lived through it.

Nayra

The BSGC Carnegie Collective

unrealistic timings wise but a good subject matter however it was very slow going and the storyline was dull

Freya

Sale High Readers

Birdie is an engaging and enjoyable book with interesting characters. The story is well written and keeps the reader interested throughout. I liked how the author explored the themes and emotions in the story. Overall, it is a memorable book that I would recommend to others.

Ishaan

MTS Northwood

One of the most empowering books I have read about racism, feminism and animal rights. It follows Birdie’s journey through her ups and downs of moving to the countryside to live with her great-aunt and uncle and her resilience to fight for her beliefs and to stand up for what is right. An easy read that I would recommend for Years 5 and over! Overall I would give it a 4.5/5!

Sofia

CSGS Page Turners 26

Birdie follows the life of Birdie Bagshaw, a young girl desperate to find her family. When a letter arrives for Mrs Dudley at the children’s home, Birdie is sent away to her great-aunt and great-uncle, who live in the Yorkshire Dales. As soon as she arrives, she finds that people treat her differently. Unkindly. But when she meets Mr Duke, a pit pony left down in the mines, she realises she has a mission. A mission to save him. Birdie is a beautiful story that explores opinions and prejudice in the 1950s, much of which has been left untold until now. It gently explained the history to younger readers and yet managed to delve in deeper too. I think it was good that it almost had two storylines – the historical side and the main story, looking at Mr Duke and Birdie’s friendship. I loved Mr Duke – he was such a sweet pony! I think this book reminded me of The Shadow Pony by Olivia Wakeford, which also looks at the pit ponies. If you enjoyed Birdie, I would recommend reading this, as it looks at the pit ponies’ history but from life today. Overall, this book was a sweet story, which treated big topics with tenderness, and included a charming pony.

Erin

Larkmead

I liked Birdie because it was an interesting and emotional story. Birdie is a brave character, and I liked seeing how she changed throughout the book. The friendship between Birdie and Mr Duke was one of my favourite parts because it showed trust and kindness. The book also helped me understand what life was like in Yorkshire in the 1950s. I didn’t like that some parts were a bit slow, especially at the beginning. It took me a little while to get interested in the story. Some of the characters were also not very friendly to Birdie, which was frustrating to read. Overall, I enjoyed Birdie because it has a strong message about friendship, belonging, and finding your place in the world. I would recommend it to people who enjoy emotional stories with realistic characters.

Sophia

Sale High Readers

Birdie lived in Leeds, until her aunt adopted her, going to live in the town of Barrington Dale. She is bullied just because of the colour of her skin and runs away to the mines. she meets a pony and becomes friends with the pit pony and when his life is in danger, she is the only one who can save him. If you like stories about friendship, horses and adventure, this book is for you.

Anna

Larkmead

This book is a tender, emotional exploration of belonging but also the theme of racism and animal friendship. I loved it because of its warm, loving plot and themes of friendship linking into everything within the book. This story is also within the spectrum of pony and equestrian themes so those who like ponies would enjoy this book thoroughly. This book also explores the themes of identity but also constantly juxtaposes the readers opinions of animals as it constantly presents animals (ponies) are spent underground in perpetual darkness, which is extremely sad to see. I was really invested in this book and it was so emotionally triggering to read.

Joshua

Stratton shadowers

its a very simple and childish book.Not many of the characters are likeable and they are all one dimensional. The language they use in the book, for example' thou' feels very out of place with the other modern language and feels like its trying to be quirky

amelia

Stratton shadowers

This book is something that I would not normally pick but I loved it and would definitely read again. It really showed the impact of racism and it was lovely description that really made me feel like I lost mister Duke as well. Overall, it's a beautiful book that made me see Birdie's beautiful imaginary world (temporarily.)

Amelia

Bassingbourn Readers

A very catching book of which emphasises the racism and loss of the 19th century. This book really shows the affection of the main character (Birdie) towards her horse. However, I do find the ending quite abrupt especially with the return journey to the village. I feel considering the effort of writing during getting to the barn, the journey back is a bit...lacking. I would read this book again and for me it's a 3.5 star book. (1-5 stars)

Matthew

Bassingbourn Readers

A really good book with a unexpected turn in the plot, I found the characters a bit annoying at some times but very in depth as well. The ending wasn't what I thought it would be but it still worked rather well. The story seems to show the power of friendship and family. Overall I think it a good book with a mostly happy ending

Eva M

BFS Umbra

I really enjoyed the book although it did move quite slowly but the storyline made me push through. The story was quite eye catching and also the plot is great as it is not fantasy it is reality as this was quite literally what happened to dark skinned individuals. Overall I'll give it a solid 6/10

LAKSH L

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

8/10 Really enjoyed this one.The main Character Birdie Bagshaw an 11 year old mixed–race girl who has spent her entire life living in Leeds but has been sent to live with her Great-aunt in the rural area of the Yorkshire Dales. The historical aspect of Birdie is really intriguing because of how we can learn from the prejudice and racism that happened after the war. The book describes the feeling of being an outsider and travelling on a quest back home. The loving bond between Birdie and Mr Duke is a really nice way for Birdie to have a safe place for her to be, away from the cruelty that she is facing. Overall this a really great book and would definitely read again.

Izzy

Vista Academy Littleport

Birdie is a beautiful and interesting story about an orphan dealing with discrimination (because of her skin colour) in a new neighbourhood. A caring and gentle pony called Mr Duke helps her deal with her problems, and the unexpected twist at the end broke my heart. Although I found it a little difficult to read because of the way the characters speak, the book helped me imagine that I was there in the Yorkshire dales; the descriptive writing was incredible. I would definitely recommend this book, 10/10!!

Maddie

Shelf Indulgence by JCG

Birdie was a very heartwarming book. She’s very determined and misunderstood. The book took me a while to get into as it was a bit boring at the start but as I got further into the book it was harder to put down.

Nyree

FCC Book Group

Birdie is an exciting and at times emotional story about a girl who moves from a children’s home to live with her aunt in the town of Barrington Dale. Confusingly to her, Birdie is treated differently because of the colour of her skin. While running from some bullies, she finds herself in a coal mine and befriends a horse which works carrying coal. I found quite shocking to learn about the discrimination going on in the mid 20th century, particularly given that it wasn’t set that long ago. I also enjoyed finding out about the important roles of pit ponies, which I wasn’t formerly aware of.

Louis

The Fitzharrys Shadows

Post World War Two Birdie Bagshaw’s life changes after being adopted by her aunt Wintertooth when she moves to the village in the Yorkshire Dales but suddenly people start treating her different and she doesn’t know why until her aunt explains that they had never seen a girl with black skin. But suddenly she stumbles in a mine and meets her soon to be friend Mr Duke the pit pony as she realises he’s going to be killed she takes action and runs away with Mr Duke only to then return after two men get trapped down the mine and they have to rescue them despite what they said to her.

owen

The Fitzharrys Shadows

Leah

The White Harts Book Club

Great book about a young brown girl living after WWII who finds a pit pony and rescues it to stop it from being killed.

Lachlan

KES Reader

Birdie is a book that i could not really get in to but I can see how it could appeal to some people because of the gripping plot.

Theo B

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I didn't really understand this book as it was a bit slow. It did show the feelings of the actual Birdie. It was ok but not for me.

Mohammed

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I would say overall Birdie was a decent book and was interesting. It was about a girl called Birdie who lived in an orphanage in Leeds then got adopted by her aunt. At first she struggled because she was bullied because of the colour of her skin and missed her friends from the orphanage, but as she starts to settle in catastrophe strikes. This book is about identity, race, courage and friendship. Birdie struggled because of the way people treated her because of her race. I thought the writing style was good, I liked the pace and how it was written from Birdie’s perspective – it helped me to understand her and how she struggled because of the way people treated her. I sometimes struggle with font when reading, but I liked the font of this book. I would give Birdie a 7/10.

Edmund

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The book Birdie by J.P Rose is a moving and heartfelt historical book that combines friendship, courage, and social justice in a story that is both emotional and inspiring. The book is set in 1950s Yorkshire, it follows a girl named Birdie Bagshaw, a young mixed-race girl who leaves her home to live with her relatives that she has never met before. Instead of receiving a warm welcome that she hoped for she faces loneliness and bulling in her village. Everything changes when she meets a pony that she comes to name; Mr Duke. the friendship develops between them which forms an emotional core to the story. Their bond shows kindness, loyalty and resilience. The readers will quicky be interested in both characters and their struggles to find acceptance and freedom. One of the books strengths is its mention of racism and identity, Rose does a good job of making that clear. Birdie is a courageous and loveable person whose bravery shows even in difficult situations. Her determination to help Mr Duke stand up for him self makes her a very inspiring character. J.P’s writing is accessible but powerful, creating an emotional story that remains engaging throughout the book. Overall, Birdie is a touching book that explores friendship, belonging and power of hope. I think this book is good for readers who like animal stories, historical fiction and stories about overcoming adversity. I give this book an 7 out of ten because I like how memorable it is and how it has a meaning to it but it is not my favourite.

scarlet

Larkmead

I think this book was amazing as it has a pony and I love ponies but that’s not the only thing it has good adjectives and is filled with anticipation. I like how the girl is going to live with great aunt but doesn’t expect to find a pony and keep it forever.

Olivia

Plumites

This book was really interesting at the beginning, i couldnt put the book down! Unfortunately, I began to dislike it more near the middle , finding the storyline random and weird. I wont read again, and haven't found anyone to recommended it.

Pola

The Fitzharrys Shadows

This book was so impactful and I really connected with the main character - Birdie. It has a great storyline and accurately expresses how racism feels and focuses on the minority which is extremely overshadowed. This book made me experience a whirlwind of emotions happy and sad ( a few tears in the last couple chapters). One of my best reads for sure and would definitely recommend.

Elissa

Harris Legends

The general story may be a little too childish for me as the plot is not too interesting.

Yan

Henry’s Shadowers

Rosie

Brookie Reads

I enjoyed Birdie. The setting was really interesting, and I was taught about something I had no idea about: pit ponies. I liked how Birdie became more comfortable in the village over time, and her Aunt progressing throughout the story. The sadly stigmatised society against mixed race couples was not something I had thought about, so it was a good topic to talk about, however I think it would have been good if the book focused a bit more on that and explored the theme more, as it was only really mentioned once, and rather suddenly. Despite this, I thought Birdie was a very nice story about fitting in, that taught me about some things I didn't really know of or consider!

Edward L

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed birdie as it reminded me of the Emma Carrol books that I used to read. I loved the post-war theme and the innocence of the character Birdie and her relationship with the pony Mr duke. I liked how the racism was not actually called racism but was very much the main topic of the book. It took a while for me to get into, but when I did I really started to enjoy it. I think the author wrote amazingly and very well about racism and I over all loved it.

Nell

Willow Book Whispers

This is a good book. It was about a girl who met a coal mining horse. I liked the horse. Very cool horse. He saves people, and I learnt that horses can swim. I did not like how it was the first single book that was not in a series, but I was satisfied with the ending I would recommend it to someone else who like horse power *super cool*

Ellie

Willow Book Whispers

I didn't really enjoy this book. The written accents annoyed me a lot because it kept flip-flopping from Olde English with "Thee". "Thou" etc., and then going to Yorkshire farm dialects which were a little hard to understand. The plot and ending were also quite cliche and trope-ey, being the average "Bullied girl finds horse, horse becomes best friend and gets people to not bully her." plot. I'm happy it had a happy ending though, however cliche it is. And it touched upon the issue of racism quite maturely. Overall, not my kind of book. I'm not a horse girl.

Klaudia J

Ousedale Shadow Chasers

My first impressions of this book was not very doubtful but once i started to get into it i was really surprised by it. The book explores themes of love and connection as the story deepens. I was in love with the ending of this and wish i could re-read it over and over again. This book is definitely a must!

Paris-capri

BFS Umbra

Birdie by J. P. Rose is a historical novel about identity, friendship and belonging. At the start, Birdie is excited to leave the children’s home and live with family, but she quickly realises life in the village is harder than she expected. In the middle of the story, her friendship with Mr Duke was one of the more interesting parts because it helped develop Birdie’s character. By the end, I liked how Birdie had become more confident and changed people’s views. Some parts of the book felt quite slow and a bit boring at times, so it was not my favourite book, but overall it was still a good story with an important message.

Connor F

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This was hard to get into it first, but it was a pretty good book. I loved the ending. I would give it about four or three out of five stars.

Sophie

Bassingbourn Readers

I really, really, really hated this book at first. It was so boring. Yes, Birdie was going through it, but frankly, i couldn't bring myself to care. It did grow on me though, and I quickly finished it, and I ended up really liking it. I really admire the passion Birdie held for Mr Duke, it is really admirable. Also. I liked how we (as readers) were introduced to something most people don't know about. Honestly I didn't even realise that pit ponies were a thing.

Duke

Mansell Library Reviewers

I didn't really have high hopes for this book when I first saw it, another girl from my group had read it before me and I thought that I wouldn't really like it. Surprisingly, I actually loved this book and rated it a 9.8/10 in my club session. It hasn't been my favourite so far because some bits were too slow but I would recommend it to people who love animals, brave characters who take on dangerous things for others and also just that really nice feeling of a book when you really just know it was a good book. I also liked how J.P Rose wrote this book to allow readers to understand discrimination in not a very heavy way. There are lots of sad scenes that really hit deep but overall I loved it! Just to say, my first concern about this book before I read was that I did NOT want the horse to speak! And it didn't! I can't handle talking animals. Would recommend to read!! Enjoy!

Marie-Anne

SHHS shadows

Birdie Birdie Birdie... where do i start? Birdie by J.P ROSE is a captivating and emotional novel that explores themes of identity, trauma, and healing through a compelling journey. Set against the rich backdrop of indigenous culture and traditions, the story delves into the complexities of family, community, and personal resilience. The narrative centers on Birdie, a young Indigenous girl navigating the aftermath of a traumatic past whilst seeking her own sense of belonging and purpose. The author masterfully intertwines her character's inner struggles with the broader cultural and societal issues faced by coloured people - creating a powerful story. What stands out most about "Birdie" is the lyrical prose and authentic voice, which brings to life the vibrant and often painful realities of birdie. The novel balances moments of raw vulnerability with moments of hope and empowerment, making it a deeply moving read.

Scarlett

The Shady Bookhounds

Birdie was AMAZING, I loved every second of it. The story pulled me in straight away and I couldn’t stop reading because I needed to know what would happen next. The characters felt so real, especially Birdie — you really understand what she’s going through and you feel every emotion with her. The book was exciting, emotional, and actually really inspiring. It wasn’t confusing at all, and the way everything was described made it super easy to imagine the scenes in your head. Overall, Birdie gets a full 5 stars from me. I’d read it again for sure.

Shifa Fatima

STAGS Shadowers

Adele

BUCS Library Book Club

I love this book and it shows a brave girl who has a happy life but not a proper family. People think she is different but shows kindness with a friend to help her through her tough times.

Bailey

Epsomians

I didn’t end up finishing this book as I found that it wasn’t really for me. I prefer contemporary reads, but it is well written and I think that others would find it really easy to read and exciting, so I would definitely recommend it if you like something gentle and historical.

Olivia

Epsomians

This book was so eye-opening to the times after WW2. The portrayal of emotions and the character’s intentions are beautifully curated. The emotional impact on the reader is is well done and you really love the way that each character develops. And the story line is a chef’s kiss, the character development, the emotion, the thoughts, the premise. Everything was lovely, a definite recommend.

Eloise

Epsomians

Birdie by J.P. Rose is about a girl called Birdie Bagshaw. She grew up at a children’s home for mixed race children where kindness was all she ever knew. Until she is finally wanted by her great aunt who lives in the Yorkshire dales. As soon as she arrives, everything changes. The air smells different, the people unkind and life unfair. On one unfortunate day, bullies come for her but she runs and runs and runs until she reaches the mines. Down in the dark, she feels scared and lost but then she comes across a pit pony. Will it be the friend she needs? Birdie made me think about how much world views have changed and how much we still need to change. I liked the storyline and themes of belonging. Sometimes, I found it hard to understand some of the older language (thee, thou, etc.) but it made the characters feel more real to the era in which it was set – 1950s. Overall, it was a good read but not the best. 7/10

Alice

Larkmead

Birdie was an ok book. It wasn’t my favourite, as I found it boring and unengaging. What I didn’t like about it was that the chapters felt too long in relation to what was actually happening in the story, which made it feel like it was dragging on a bit; if the chapters were shorter I think it would have been more engaging. I thought it was a heartfelt story, but I felt like not a lot happened in it. There were a few things I did like about it, such as Birdie’s love and devotion to Mr Duke. My favourite part was Birdie’s reaction when she saw that Mr Duke was ok, but what I didn’t like was when Mr Spivey tried to take Mr Duke from the mine to be killed. All in all, this was not my type of book, but I feel that other people might enjoy it more than I did, particularly if their day is going too fast or is too hectic for their liking.

Emma

Larkmead

I believe this book is a very good read, exploring the ideas of isolation and injustice following the young girl, Birdie. It's a little sad but very wholesome, and I highly recommend this story for children.

Boyan

The Tiffin Girls’ Shadows

I really enjoyed this book. It touches on alot of major themes like rasism and discrimination but also how you over come it with friendship and compassion. Birdie's story is a bumpy one as she moves away from everything she has known to a unknown place where she is bullied and looked down on. But she still has compasssion and dignity to help others. Overall, it was a great book.

Ruby

Thomas Tallis Reads

Birdie is a tender, touching story and is one of my favourite Carnegies. It is an excellent way of teaching children about racism and how we should challenge it. After all, why should the colour of our skin change who we are as a person? I would recommend this book to any age group. Overall, Birdie was a delightful read.

Hamzah S

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

'Birdie' is a fantastic telling of the story of Birdie, who could herself reflect many who had gone through similar experiences to her. The themes of racism are a major element of the story, while not derailing the main plot - I really enjoyed reading this!

James

Southmoor Shadowers

'Birdie' was a truly wonderful book. Readers can feel strong empathy for Birdie, the main character, and she herself is extremely empathetic towards Mr Duke. The book was very descriptive, and it can easily create a strong, vivid image in the reader's head. It couldn't have been clearer if it had pictures. Well done, and good luck to the author.

Aiden

PA TBC

I love the ending and the way the story is told. The accent was sometimes a little bit confusing though.

Charlotte

Fullbrook Bookworms

I really enjoyed this book, it was very emotional and it draws you in. I would recomend this book to people who somtimes feel left out or a bit out of the crowd or if you love animals. This woul also be a good book to read before bed because it is very calm and cosy.

qwerty

SJCSChatterbooks

Can you imagine Experiencing racism and not realising it. This book is about a girl who experiences racism but at first doesn’t know it’s racism when moving to a new home. She then meets a pit pony and becomes friends with it. The majority of the story is spent on her going to visit the pony, and promising to save it. It is a wonderful heartfelt book, however, for the first 50 pages it was not the most exiting of books, also the use of regular English and English words from up north which also seemed like old English was quite confusing but also helpful! I would never have picked this book up because I really struggle with books with complicated words as I am dyslexic so this book pushed me out of my comfort zone. While I was reading it I felt sadness, excitement, happiness and outrage at how people can be so judgmental BUT outrage overall. I love this book. I would give it 4.5/5 and I recommend it for 10 to 14 year olds to give it a read.

Aurora

Larkmead

Birdie is a book about a little girl called Birdie who lives in a care home until her aunt adopts her. Birdie is treated differently but she doesn't know why. I think that this book was ok but I found it hard to get into reading it and it was kind of boring in some places. I also didn't really like or have sympathy for the characters but the rest of the book was generally ok. I feel like there's not much to say about this book because there's nothing super good or super bad, so I would rate this book 6/10 because it was just kind of meh.

Mason

The Fitzharrys Shadows

I didn’t like Birdie. I thought it had a very slow start and didn’t have a great plot. It felt a bit like another Michael Morpurgo “connecting with an animal" story and wasn’t particularly good.

Rafferty t

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I loved this book soooooooo much!! It was really heartwarming and I really felt a connection towards Birdie and the love she felt for Mr Duke. The end totally broke my heart and I was almost crying when I turned the final page. I loved the name Mr Duke and I felt that it gave a fun personality to the horse. I also loved the fact that Birdie started making friends and people were not being mean to her anymore because she was able to stand up for herself. I honestly feel like this book will win because of the way that it stays with you long after you have turned the final page. 10/10!

Amelia

SHHS shadows

I think this book is very good for tackling some quite sensitive topics and I can see a lot of people liking this one due to its fun story.

Oscar (Occa)

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Very good plot, but the progression could have been faster.

Amna

JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

In my opinion, the book was very boring. Not much happened, the pacing was slow and the ending wasn't good for me.

abdul moeez

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie was okay. I liked the main character’s voice and some parts hit hard emotionally. But the middle dragged a bit and it felt repetitive. Still, the ending made up for it. Good if you’re into stories about family and growing up.

Aasyah

Lostock High Readers

A beautiful heartwarming story of a young teenager finding the right path about friendship and finding the final puzzle which is home!

Hannah

The Chapter Chasers

It is a good book. It is quite slow moving and involves serious talk about racism. I would recommend it for people over ten.

henry

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie Bagshaw is a mixed -race orphan who grew up in a children's home in Leeds until she is sent to live with her great aunt in the Yorkshire dales . From her arrival she is treated like an outsider and faces intense racist bullying because of this she runs away and hides in a cold mine , she's unexpectedly rescued by a pit pony. Over time she create a special bond with the pony . I loved reading this book. I thought that it was very touching and quite sad in some bits of the story . The messages of family and belonging were shown throughout the book. I would recommend this to any sort of audience. There is something for everyone in the book and I would give this 4 stars

Annabelle

Glossopdale Readers

The book felt similar to other brilliant stories set around wartime, like When The Sky Falls and The Ministry Of Unladylike Activity; the only real flaw was that the main character, Birdie, had literally zero character flaws and remained saintly throughout (this is possibly due to a younger demographic).

Sophie

Horsham BOok HUNTers

I did like the story, and I did like the character of Birdie overall, but I feel like the other characters could have had more to them and could have been more developed. I also feel like something else should have been done for the ending with Duke because it didn’t quite feel fitting. The book had a good setting and at the start it did feel like it could have had a lot of potential, but I think it could have delved deeper into the racism and how and why others had these prejudices. However, I did like the plot, and I did like the start. I think it was a 5/10

Sofia

BFS Umbra

I think birdie is a really good book, it shows emotions and feelings. I like it.

Chidumaga Aimee

The SBSJs

I like Birdie because it was a wonderful book, set in Yorkshire in the 1500s. It was gentle, emotional and, sometimes, a bit exciting. The only annoying bit in this book was the use of colloquial language (for example, the "Thee"s, the "Thy"s and the "Thou"s). The story revolves around a girl called Birdie Bagshaw, who was put in an orphanage in Leeds when she was abandoned by her mother, and a pit pony named Mr Duke. Birdie has spent the whole of her short, happy life at the care house with her friends until when she is summoned to live with her great-aunt. She was upset and I really liked how J.P.Rose expressed Birdie's feelings and how she reacted. When she arrived at the countryside, she was treated with racism and was bullied because of the colour of her skin, but was completely oblivious until half-way in the book, which I find a bit unrealistic. When her teacher accused her of cheating in a maths question when she answered it for herself, she runs away from school and hides in a coal mine, where she meets Mr Duke, the last pit pony in Birdie's village. It is love at first sight and they become kindred spirits, which is weird, as they make a deep bond with just a single stroke. When she discovers that they are going to murder her beloved Mr Duke, she is heart-broken and she lets him free from the coal mine and runs away from the village to try to save him. It is easy to imagine how Birdie feels, as the author clearly describes her thoughts. But, when half the village men are trapped inside the coal mine, which was releasing poison gas, she and Mr Duke return to the village, helping the men get out of there before the gas kills them all. But, when Mr Duke was pulling the rocks to make an entry to the men, Mr Duke gets stranded in the mine, which really affects Birdie. She becomes very depressed and even though the village celebrates her, she feels isolated from her friends. But the unexpected happens at the end, where her great-aunt and uncle and all of the villagers surprise Birdie with finding Mr Duke. I liked how the story changed when they find Mr Duke. The end was really happy and heart-warming.

Mithulesh A

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I dreaded reading this book, having received numerous bad reviews from my friends who have read this book. However, I would disagree, even though it definitely wasn't the best book I've ever read. The plot follows a mixed-race girl called Birdie Bagshaw, who moves from her orphanage for other half-black children like her, to her great-aunt's house in Yorkshire. She is met with prejudice and hate from her community, and her only friend when she first arrives is a pit pony, which she named Mr Duke. When Mr Duke's life is in danger, Birdie must launch a plot to stop Mr Duke's death. I found the character development on some characters to be lacking, and I found Birdie herself to be unrelatable. She would always burst into tears and she strikes me as a bit of a brat. Whereas, I thought some other characters were portrayed relatively well, like Birdie's great uncle and aunt. The storyline was decent in my opinion, but the author really made it worth reading. Overall, I'd recommend this book to slightly younger readers of around 9-11. Would I read this book again? No. But would I tell other readers not to read this? Also no. I'd give this book a 6.47/10

William B

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This was a great book! When I started reading it I was a bit thrown by the local Yorkshire dialect, once I got passed that it was such a sweet and wholesome story. I liked the historical setting and found the themes around mining and racial prejudice interesting. Birdie was confused by her reception in the village and that was understandable because racism is so illogical. I liked how Birdie's lovely personality defeated the local prejudice in the end. I would have liked a bit more on her enjoying the change in the village towards her at the end of the book. Overall I really liked this book and loved the characters 8/10

Klara

The Wondrous Book & Biscuit Club

Exploring the diversity and different reactions the characters felt at different stages towards Birdie was a revelation because I didn't realise people behaved this way even after the war. Even though I have met the author and heard her speak about the inspiration behind the book, her life and her experiences of pit ponies before I read it, I couldn't have anticipated how amazing and excellent this book really was going to be. To us, as readers, our bond to the love and connection between Mr Duke and Birdie, as we experienced the relationship grow between them - was really special.

Avery

TPS Carnegie Collective

All of the concepts explored by this book are truly beautiful and I’m so glad they’ve been celebrated! At times, it was also very touching and poetic. However, I feel that the plot was quite clumsy and unbalanced, thus damaging the overall message. It seemed as if three quarters of the book was exposition and a lovely (if at times quaint) coming-of-age novel, and the last quarter was whatever dramatic action the author could fit in. The journey away from the village seemed bizzare; why not just keep Birdie in Barrington Dale until the disaster strikes anyway? I think the book really lost its way in its final few chapters, as the emotion and action frankly both felt manufactured. In spite of this, I will reassert my earlier point: this is a beautiful concept and important message, but I just don’t think the story itself lives up to its potential.

Eve

St Kaths

This book , "Birdie" is about the protagonist who has ventured into the unknown of a new city, adjusting to her new life because she was adopted. However, stepping into this new world arose unfortunate challenges. One of which, was the protagonist 'Birdie' being treated as an outcast to society. Just as things were going disastrously, she meets an unexpected ally along the way. J.P Rose gives an unvarnished portrayal of people like Birdie who do not fit in by uncontrollable measures. I enjoy how the author depicts the protagonists resilience and alienation which makes the story realistic and immersive. To add to this idea of realism, this book is set in 1952, with Birdie speaking in a Northern dialect. This book explores the themes thoroughly (e.g racism and identity) . To conclude, Birdie is a fantastic read that I would recommend to everyone.

Atharva

MTS Northwood

I really enjoyed this book because this book showed how Birdie overcame her challenges in Barrington dale and she made a new family and met a really nice pony in the coal mines. I liked at the end that Birdie kept Mr Duke. I generally thought it was a well written and heart- warming story. 9/10

Maulik Linesh

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I enjoyed reading Birdie. It had Yorkshire slang in it, which I’ve never read before in a book. I read it for several hours and couldn’t put it down. One of my favourite quotes from chapter 27 is, “ I can see that sitting next to Birdie is clearly doing your mathematics… and your knowledge of pigeons, the world of good.” Overall I’d rate Birdie 4 out of five stars I would recommend it to other readers.

Isla

The Chapter Chasers

This book was really sweet. Birdie, having grown up in a 'brown' children's home, doesn't understand racism one bit. Not what it is and why people contribute to it. The pacing of the book was rather inconsistent and so was the historical language used. The ending did bring my rating up, so I'd give this book three stars!

Rida

HGS Book Club

'Birdie' is an amazing, one of a kind book. I love the warm, heartfelt message. It has a wonderful writing style and I love the plot. My favourite character is Julie . I would definitely recommend it

Emme

Sullivan Shadowers

Birdie is a wonderful, heart-warming tale of a young girl who was abandoned as a child. She was taken in by a children’s home and made lots of friends that felt like family. But one day, her great-aunt in the Yorkshire Dales, sends a letter to the home asking if Birdie will stay with her. From her arrival, Birdie is treated like an outside and bullied for her skin colour. When she is driven to hide in the near by coal mine because of the bullying, she is rescued by the towns last remaining pit pony. As the weeks pass, Birdie forms a special bond with the little pony. But when she finds out that is future life is in danger, she forms a bold plan to save his life… My favourite character from this book was Mr Duke, the pit pony. I liked him because he is very gentle, heroic and brave even if he was just a tiny pony. My favourite part of the book was when Mr Duke and Birdie were reunited at the end. It felt so real and made me smile whilst reading it. I would recommend this book to younger readers and animal lovers as it focuses on the pit pony but also teaches children the effects of racism and bulling. If I were to change the ending, I would make it so that Mrs Dudley came to visit them and Birdie shows her the life that she has built and all her new friends. Overall, I would definitely recommend this book and I loved to read it.

Gwen

Vista Academy Littleport

Birdie was an emotional and engaging read with lots of twists that kept me interested. Although it begins with heavy topics like racism and unfair treatment, it ends on a hopeful note. I especially liked how brave and determined Birdie was, even during difficult moments. The writing made it easy to connect with the characters and their struggles. Overall, Birdie was a powerful story about friendship, prejudice, and hope that stayed with me after I finished it.

Kyle

MTS Northwood

This is a book about a girl who moves to a mining village in the 1950s and has a tough time with bullies, but things get better when she makes friends with a cool pony.

Hasini

BAS Reading Champions

Birdie lived in a children's home called Fitzwilliams where she was left by her mum when she was a baby. When her Great Aunt says she would like to look after her, Birdie goes on the train to Barrington Dale. There, lots of the locals insult her and chase her because of her skin colour. She starts to hate it there and become homesick before she meets Mr Duke - a pit pony. I didn't find this book that interesting as the dialect was confusing and the character made illogical decisions, but there were some parts I enjoyed. One of my favourite parts was when Birdie was being chased and she went down to the mines where she met Mr Duke for the first time. The book covers issues of racism, attitudes towards unmarried parents and animal welfare. It also shows about trying to feel welcome and belonging. I would probably rate it a 6/10 as it was a good story but sometimes I found it a bit less engaging. I would recommend it to people who like books about social issues and animals.

Lydia

Larkmead

I was completely absorbed by this book from the very first page, and it made me feel like I was living inside its story. I loved every part of it, it felt both exciting and comforting at the same time. The main character goes on a journey that is full of surprises, and I could really relate to what they were feeling. i was drawn into the problems they faced and the friends they made along the way. The plot has moments that made me laugh, moments that made me think, and some that made my heart race with suspense.The story grabbed me and didn’t let go, and I found myself thinking about it even when I wasn’t reading. The way the author wrote made everything feel alive, and I felt like I was learning and feeling new things with each chapter. This book wasn’t just a story for me,it was an experience I didn’t want to end, and I will remember it for a long time.

Fatima

BAS Reading Champions

I really enjoyed reading Birdie. I think that it was a really interesting insight into racism in the time after the war. I loved the character of Mr Walter, and thought that Birdie would have been lost without him. I liked the ending (and, in fact, it was my favourite part of the book!) It was sweet and fitting, as I couldn’t believe at the time that the author would let Mr Duke die. There wasn’t much action in the book, but I think that that fitted Birdie’s calm and non-violent nature. I found it really interesting that it was based off of the real experience of the author, which made it feel all the more special to read.

Iris

The Perse Carnegians

This book was AMAZING I loved the detail put into it and how the story followed the main character and told her feelings this was a really good read and would love more books like this.

Gracie

Balla Bookworms

Birdie is a heartfelt story that shows what it is like to be a girl who faces racism and how nature can change someone’s life from nothing into something! At the start of the book we are introduced to a young, black, girl called Birdie who is leaving her foster home to go to her great aunts house. She travels on her own to the town her great aunt lives in! She then had to walk to her great aunts house who was utterly surprised to see her. Throughout this book we can see that Birdie makes a loving relationship with a pony that she nicknamed Mr. Duke! I would highly recommend this book to people of all ages and anyone who likes/loves animals and nature! Overall I really enjoyed this book and would give it a 4/5

Milo T

Larkmead

I thought Birdie was a good book, I liked this book because it showed how someone's life can change for the better when they have a special bond with animals. Birdie is an 11 year old in the 1950s and she's spent her entire life in foster care with a lovely lady called Mrs Dudley. She doesn't know much about her mum, only that she left her in front of a church in Leeds, she never knew who she was or why she left her there. That's why she was shocked when she was told that her Great Aunt Mabel wanted her to live with her in the Yorkshire Dales. She reluctantly goes and has a dicey relationship with her aunt at first but after a long talk with her one night their relationship improves. She loves her aunt and uncle but when she is misunderstood at school she is chased down into a mine by a bunch of bullies. There she meets a pony, who she eventually calls 'Mr Duke' and devises a plan to get him out of the dirty, pick black coal mine and into the nice green grass of the Yorkshire Dales. I liked this book for a few reasons, one being that the description in this book was very gripping and the emotions of people in this book were also very real. Overall, I really enjoyed this book. 8.1/10.

Sebastian H

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie was an AMAZING read and I personally loved it, the connection to the author was shown throughout the book and made the read so much more interesting, I really loved that the characters grew closer in every chapter and how Birdie's attitude to her great-aunt and great-uncle changed. Overall I would rate this book 10/10!

Emily

The Wondrous Book & Biscuit Club

This book is very boring. The main character does not do many sensible things and the story is too simple and predictable. The speech is hard to understand and there are a lot of grammar errors. The book is written in a childish tone and the characters are mostly very illogical.

Ella

Ink & Insight

It's a really lighthearted and fun book written in a childish tone that tells most of the story just by itself. It explores themes of family and belonging - making you realise who and where you're connected to.

Michaela

The Book Voya’s

Birdie, by J. P. Rose, is about how a young girl can step into the unknown and get through it. Set in 1952 in Yorkshire, it follows the story of Birdie, who is taken in by a family that she didn't know she had. However, she is treated as an outsider just because of the way she looks, and while hiding from bullies, she is rescued by an unlikely companion. But when her friend is in danger, Birdie makes a plan to rescue him. I found the characterisation very good - as you read the book, you start understanding the characters more and more until you have a sort-of encyclopedia of facts about them. I also liked how the novel is written in the type of language that Birdie spoke in - a Northern accent (e.g 'Alreet'). However, I found some parts of the story quite hard to believe. Overall, Birdie is a great book about differences and how animals can impact you.

Zach

MTS Northwood

For me this is clearly a book for younger readers, so I can see how it was written to appeal to them, but for me the book seemed to make complex issues overly simplistic. I don't feel the development of the characters was very realistic - I don't think inherent racism in a community would have been cast aside that quickly. In addition, the plot was not, with the exception of the mine, very original, although the familiar story of a child saving an animal against all odds may appeal to young children. The setting was something I thought was well portrayed, although I found the colloquial language use quite inconsistent, which confused me slightly and detracted from the book's flow. Overall I think it could be a very successful children's book, but for older children/young adults the themes and characters were very simplified.

Mabel

The High Storrs Shadows

This book is a true adventure! It had me on the edge of my seat. I was crying and laughing for the protagonist.

Aleeha

Winchmore School Carnegie Group 2025/26

Birdie is a book about a girl called Birdie Bagshaw, who is living in an orphanage in around the 20th century. She has never known her parents and struggles to fit in. She is sent to her great-aunt's in the Yorkshire Dales where she faces bullying and exclusion. One day, she is driven by bullies into a coal mine, she discovers the last pit-pony in the village and builds a strong relationship with him (Mr Duke). When Mr Duke's future is unfortunately threatened, she creates a plan to save him. It explores themes like friendship, racism, family and courage as well as portraying her difficulties in being an outsider. It's a very heart-warming and gripping book, a good read for 9 years and up.

Heer

Watford Girls

The book 'Birdie' reflects on the strong bond between humans and animals and shows their value and importance. The story was very well written, and I enjoyed following Birdie through her adventures in the countryside. The author describes the setting in great detail, which made it easy to imagine the village and understand how Birdie felt as she tried to adapt to her new surroundings. Throughout the book, she faces racism and struggles to fit into the village, but she teaches the people around her that the colour of someone’s skin does not matter. Her kindness, courage, and determination help change the attitudes of others and make the community more accepting. I also liked the relationship between Birdie and her great-uncle Walter. At first, their relationship seems distant, but over time their bond becomes much stronger. Along with her aunt, they slowly become a loving and supportive family. I enjoyed seeing how the characters developed throughout the story and learned important lessons about acceptance, friendship, and understanding others. The book also highlights themes of belonging and identity, showing that home is not just a place, but is also about the people who care about you. Overall, I really enjoyed the book because it was emotional, inspiring, and full of meaningful messages that readers can learn from.

Lowri

St George’s Dragon Readers

i really enjoyed this book, it was really heartwarming!

Eden

Winchmore School Carnegie Group 2025/26

I really liked Birdie and thought that it was a brilliant engaging book because of the well-thought through structure ,high level vocabulary and has brilliant historical themes.

Chloe

SDG Reads

Birdie is a heartfelt story set in post war, Northern England. It's about a young orphan girl. She spent most of life dreaming about one day having a family of her own. So when a letter arrives from her great-aunt she is thrilled, but also sad to leave the only home she's ever known. Upon arrival she is shunned by the people of Barrington Dale; even her own family is ashamed at first. Lonely, she wants to go home but then she meets a pony who she names Mr Duke. I think this book is perfect for slightly older readers as it contains themes that maybe a little confusing for younger readers. The most gripping part of the book for me was the ending . It was a brilliant conclusion to the story. Overall I would rate it a 9/10.

Adele

The Shady Bookhounds

I really liked the book I also fell in love with Mr Duke and the ending was my favourite part. I would definitely recommend this book for other readers.

Maya

SCD Pageturners

Birdie was a sweet story full of nature and great vocabulary. It was a really relaxing and refreshing story and it taught me a lot about how people treated each other at that time .I overall really liked it.

Josie

Chiswick Carnegie

Birdie was a very good book for me. I really enjoyed the relationship between her and mr Duke, and found the critisism she got very emotional. It was super nice to see that there were actually some people who liked Birdie for who she was and makes me think anyone can change

Maryam

SCD Pageturners

I believe it was a very good book. I did not expect that the characters had different personalities. I liked how they were going on adventures and the descriptions were clear. I believe that this book is in the top 10 books that I have ever read and I want to read more books like that.

Charlotte

Brockhill Book Club

Contrary to my initial expectations Birdie was not a particularly bad book. Perhaps if I was in Year 7, or at a push Year 8, it would've been a more enjoyable read as it dealt with themes such as grief and racism in quite simplistic terms, making it accessible to younger readers. I enjoyed the use of colloquial language yet found the plot was predictable in places and felt similar to books I'd read at a younger age. Whilst the use of a pit pony was something I hadn't seen before, Birdie's relationship with the pony was unsurprising, echoing the plot of many other children's books that centre around the relationship between an animal and child. I found whilst several character relationships had potential they were never fully resolved with any issues or grievances solved in a quick, unrealistic manner. Though Birdie's gradual realisation added to the book's tone of childhood innocence I found the way in which characters such as Mr Bradley changed their behaviour and overall view of Birdie was unrealistic and quite honestly boring. Overall I would give this book a 5/10 it had some slightly original elements an for a younger audience could be a 7/10 for those slightly older it was quite dull in places and I found myself skimming pages near the end so I could simply say I had finished the book before I lost my will to finish.

Eve

KES Readers

I really enjoyed this book because it was so touching and it covers topics that not many people really write about. The way the book explained about racism and animal love at the same time made me love it. It was very emotional at points and was just a brilliant book overall!

Chloe

CSGS Page Turners 26

This was a great book as it shows great friendship bonds with Birdie and the pit pony Mr Dukes but Birdie ( the orphan that she is ) is bullied at her new school because of racism. And they are shutting down the coal mine where Mr Dukes lives so Birdie and Mr Dukes leave and they will be forever friends. In the end this book was fast- paced , exciting and you would love this book if you read this.

Charlie

Bookwizards

Edith

Montsaye Shadow Readers

This book is about a girl named Birdie who is bullied and gets pushed into a mine where she meets a pit-pony. I enjoyed this book and how it explored themes of bullying. This was a very good read and I would definitely recommend it! 3.5 stars out of 5.

Edith

Montsaye Shadow Readers

The ending of this novel is very wholesome. The donkey is alive and the girl is finally welcome and included in the society. It is a very good book about racism and discrimination.

Carson

The SGS Book Bandits

I wasn't hugely excited by this book when I first saw the front over, and the blurb didn't draw me in at first either, not being a particular fan of animal stories, or historical fiction based around World War 2. Having said that, once I started Birdie, it was hard to put down. I very quickly fell in love with our protagonist, and felt filled with horror at the blatant racism she was faced with early on in the story. Her own empathy towards Mr Duke the pit pony started to tug on my heart strings and I realised I was also learning a lot about a historical community I previously knew nothing about. In the end, this has unexpectedly become one of my favourite Carnegie reads this year and I would absolutely recommend it to other readers.

Mrs Sirrelle

BFS Umbra

This book contains a lot of emotion, with themes of being an outcast, the impact of bullying and racism alongside the captivating wonder of animals. I personally enjoyed this book as it was a rather heart-warming story with a beautiful message of identity and finding a place to belong during difficult times. As it was set in 1950s England, the language used took a bit of time to get used to, which some may struggle with. However, after a while it became much easier to understand.

Cerys

Reading Wizards

I really didn't like birdie for a few reasons. First of all, the language. I found all the 'Thee, Thy, Thou' really annoying, even more annoying that they are inconsistent. I also didn't like that everything was 'reet grand' and things like that. Another thing is the story. I think it had a pretty rubbish story that was trying to sound tangible but just sounded a bit fanciful. Also, the crying. The first 5 chapters are basically all crying and I feel that Birdie overreacts to every tiny little thing, and has no resilience. overall 2/10. (shame it doesn't go into the minuses)

Toby M

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This was a very interesting read for me, especially because its not a book I would usually go for. However i was captivated by the beauty of the story and its ability to tie everything together so wonderfully in the conclusion. This book explores themes of change and adaptation, showing how difficult it can sometimes be, especially when it is unfamiliar. Although Birdie was labelled as "different" and struggled to fit in at first, she never backed down from who she was. Her kindness and selfless nature granted her a friend with whom she could relate: Her stallion Mr Duke. Although not a human, that did not stop them from growing a deep connection and becoming inseparable. Although they faced many difficulties, they both managed to pull through and found comfort in their home, Barrington Dale.

Abigail

The Paragons

Birdie is an amazing book about black identity and learning to embrace who you are. It shows how if you have good friends, what others think doesn't matter.

Phoebe

The SBSJs

A good book challenging racism. I liked the development of all the characters and I learnt more about the miners during that period of time.

Elizabeth

Sir Roger Manwood’s School Book Club

it was an interesting book and very emotional about your place in life and discrimination and how it feels. I liked the fact that the character, Birdie, is trying to help people or animals and overall its a very powerful story. Would 100% recommend.

Gracious

Baxter Booklighters

I think that the book birdie is a pretty decent book, a bit more historical than I am used to, but good for fans of historical fiction. This book is more about a girl who's from London and has travelled to the country side . When she reached her destination she is already facing racism towards her and it hits her hard . If you want to find more about birdie then I suggest you take a look and read it , but overall its a pretty good book .

Nafisah

The SBSJs

I enjoyed this book because I like how courageous, brave adventurous Birdie is and this book is just amazing because I was able to picture the book deeply in my head. So my overall rating is 4/5.

Sophie

St Cath’s Shadowing

A great and moving book, focusing on a black girl named Birdie from Yorkshire after the end of ww2 (1950s) living all her life in an orphanage for non-white children, she gets a chance to get a family of her own with her great aunt and uncle but will have to lose her childhood friends and the kind Mr and Mrs Dudley (the cares of the the orphanage) however the book felt childish and unrealistic however it is compassionate and about kindness making it a heart-warming and nice book. I would recommend to people who like horses and moving stories

Dima

The Leopards, Skinners’

Birdie is a very sweet book. It talks about change, identity, and belonging whilst keeping links to history (1950s).

Charlie

Skipton Shadows

Birdie is a captivating story of the profound and magic of animals. I loved reading THIs!

Scarlet F.

Lionheart2026

Birdie is a middle grade historical fiction set in the 1950’s Yorkshire Dales. It is a heartwarming story which carefully and sensitively handles themes of racism and social history. It follows Birdie and her experiences with friendships, adoption and animals. What I liked was how even when many of the locals in Yorkshire treated her with suspicion and prejudice, she was able to overcome that and develop a deep bond with a pit pony named Mr. Duke. To conclude, I think that Birdie is a very good read for teenagers and young adults on the topic of racism and introducing children to the era.

Quinn

The Lotus Readers

Birdie is an incredible book which really helps you to put yourself in other people shoes and to be more empathetic. I would really recommend this book to everyone especially to animal lovers .

Joanna

The Wells Readers

Birdie is an emotional and heart warming book. It talks about racism, courage and belonging in a new place. Birdie is a likeable character and the story is both sad and hopeful at times. I liked how the book was fast paced I really enjoyed reading it. It is a great book for people who love animals.

Mishael

The Wells Readers

The book was straight forward ,which I really liked. I really loved the ending. I understood the theme very clearly. The part where Birdie meets the pony, was really empathic and engaging. Overall this is one of my favourite books.

Priyanila

The Wells Readers

It is about a girl who is living with her great-aunt and even though she is treated different she develops a bond with a pit pony who saves her later on. the book is about racism and acceptance. I really enjoyed it.

Zamin

BAS Reading Champions

Very interesting and has lots of plot twists of what would happen to the lost horse ( Mr Duke ) and how life would be with her (Birdie) new family.

Cheryl

The Wells Readers

I loved how Birdie got her friendship with Mr Duke (the pit pony). Her parents left her in a care home because it was very difficult for her at the time for inter-racial relationships but at the care home, she showed her bravery. The ending was so emotional that it nearly made me cry. Her courage inspired others how animals should be treated. The characters are not only make sense but they are believable. I really liked this book! 9/10

Kamran

Booky Wookies

Birdie stands out because of her confidence and bravery. Even when life's difficult. She arrives at a new place but she still finds the courage to speak up (something I could never do), stay hopeful and be herself. Her confidence makes her easy to admire and her bravery shows in the show she faces challenges without giving up. These qualities, make her the character you can't help respecting and supporting. Birdie also promotes animal rights by showing how badly the ponies and horses were treated in the Mines, this helps the reader understand their suffering. These moments, especially Birdie's kindness towards the animals, makes us care about their well-being. The story changes by showing how Birdie's courage inspires others to take a moment to think how animals should be treated. Through her gentle bond with the ponies, especially Mr duke,show that the animals are also living things who have feelings too and deserve respect and protection 'Birdie' is the winning novel for me this year. It moved me with its powerful story of courage, kindness and hope. I was impressed by the beautiful writing and the way the author brings Birdie's world to life with honesty and a true heart. I hope young readers leave this book knowing that standing up for what's right, even quietly, can change lives.

Isabelle

North Manchester Novel Navigators

Birdie to me has a very set tone to it with the small hints of racism in a new town. I can relate because it's not easy to fit in to towns that don't accept as easily. I do like the setting but the way they specify it seems a bit to forced to be gloomy. Thanks for the book and i wish the author luck in the vote

Yannick

The SBSJs

Birdie Bagshaw is a brown girl that was moved to Yorkshire after the second world war, She finds a pony that she loves and she saves it from the people who want to sell it. I really liked this story as it has good bond of friendship worth a horse and girl. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who wants a cosy story with animals in it.4 out of 5 stars .

mahiru

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

A very nice reader about friendship and belonging. The book shows what it’s like to live in a place where you are discriminated for the colour of your skin and how Birdie overcomes her challenges through meeting Mr Duke (a pony) in a mine and how their friendship evolves through the book.

Tabitha

BFS Umbra

This book was very well set with the setting being presented through pathetic fallacy. The whole backstory invoked a constant sense of sympathy, and the ending was very emotional. I really liked the portrayal of Birdie being presented as an outsider as soon as she entered the village, but after a few weeks people were treating her like family. The use of the pit pony emphasised how humans influence the environments of animals. Additionally, the story presents how change takes time to adapt to a new environment. I really enjoyed this book and it was a fascinating read.

Raf

Ousedale Olney

I genuinely loved Birdie because not only did tug on my heart strings, but it also felt very relatable. The plot of Birdie was written brilliantly and my favorite character was definitely Mr Duke. The genre was also another thing that I really liked!

Skye

Vista Academy Littleport

I think Birdie was kind of bad because it had an awful plot and inconsistent use of thy, it used you a lot and then switched to thy making it hard to follow. In conclusion I think it wasn’t a good read. I wouldn’t recommend.

LeoL

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed this book! I thought that Birdie, the protagonist, was a very likeable character and I felt that I, as a reader, was made to empathise with her and feel for her as she was so ostracised from society. I usually don't like reading stories involving animals, however I liked the portrayal of Mr Duke as looking out for Birdie, but also being fixed in his ways as a pit pony, showing the effect that humans can have on animals and the environment.

Tim

St George’s Dragon Readers

I think Birdie was in my top 5 favourite books from the Carnegie. I really enjoy the unique style set in Yorkshire in the 1900's and teaching about racism in the past, as well as using pit ponies in the story which I haven't heard of before. 9/10

William S

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie by J.P. Rose 🌹 🐴🐎 I give this a 9.9 out of 10. OK, now we're going into decimals. Birdie was much more emotional than I expected. At first, I thought it would be a simple story, but it turned out to be quite serious and powerful. Birdie goes through a lot, and at times, I felt really sorry for her and wished things would get easier. However, it also made me admire how strong she is. Some parts were a bit uncomfortable to read, but I think that is because the book shows real-life problems. It is not a very cheerful story, but it is interesting and meaningful. I think it is a good book, just not one you read if you want something light and happy.

Fatimah

BAS Reading Champions

Birdie is now my all-time favourite book. I would recommend for animal lovers. This is a touching story and a wonderful one. It also keeps you intrigued, never wanting to stop. 5 stars!

Armani

Redhill Reviewers

Birdie was not my favourite book and is not the type of book I would read.One of the reasons for this is the over repetition of the metaphor of the ladybirds🐞. The phrase ladybirds, ladybirds fly away home was used when it did not need to be for example when she sees the mine workers this was not needed.But I think it was a really created way of showing discrimination.I wasn’t really my type of book and found it quite dull. There is an over description and I feel like the story was very slow and I got bored pretty quickly but I carried on reading to see if it got better.I think the ending was so built up and then kind of flopped. I think about how the pitt pony and the girl met was q was very beige and had very little detail or if it had a lot of detail it was over descriptive and led away from the story line. I read october october which is also one of her books and I felt the opposite was happening and there was not enough description.I felt like the book was over trying to be good book and that made me felt like she didn't believe that her skills weren't good enough even though i believe she s a good writer it just wasn't my type of book but others may really enjoy it. But I wouldn't advice this for my friend as this book is presented for middle group of people(year 7 to year 10) as it isn't for younger kids as the discrimination would go right over their heads but the cover and when they see the horse the cover attracts them and then they find the book boring and the message goes write over their heads.I think some people may really enjoy it but it isn't for me and my friends.The story line was very slow and kept going off track and that lead it to be very boring and i carried on to see if it was good but i am sorry to say i still stayed bored and most of my friends said the same things as me. But I do know people who really enjoyed it and i agree when they said it was a very unique way to show discrimination and i really enjoyed that part of the book and the aspect it brung

Allie

Redhill Readers

An amazing book that urges me to read on.

Joe

Rad readers

Birdie is a mixed-race girl from a children's home, who is sent to go live with her aunt. Once there she is lonely, until she meets Mr. Duke (a pony). When he is in danger, she fights to save him - which helps her to find a place where she feels she belongs. The thing that I liked about this book was the strong connection between Birdie and Mr. Duke and the ending was very nice (no spoilers). However, I did not like how mean Aunt Mable was to Birdie and I found some of the incidents involving racism towards Birdie to be quite harsh. Overall, I loved the book and would probably read it again. Four stars out of five (****).

Halima

Rockwood Reads

I enjoyed Birdie because it was set reasonably close to home. It is about a girl called Birdie who spent most of her life in a care home. When she comes to the Yorkshire dales she becomes friends with a pony. This book was a reasonably easy read and I would give it a 8/10

Cody w

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

My favorite character is definitely Julie as she is very friendly and king to Birdie despite their differences and she stands up for her despite her parent wishes. My least favorite moment was when Birdies teacher didn't allow her to be part of the lesson and denied the fact that Birdie was actually the smartest in the room and I quite like Birdies aunt standing up for her despite her reservations earlier in the book. The person with the most change and growth in this book is definitely Mrs. Winterbottom her reluctant acceptance of Birdie and then her outright love really helped Birdie open up to others and made her more confident speaking up for herself. I quite liked the ending as it really shows how anybody can belong if they try enough and the villagers realization of Mr. duke and Birdie being helpful and vital for them really shows how quick they where to judge and how wrong that was for everyone involved. I enjoyed the themes of fitting in and finding your place however I wouldn't necessarily read this book if it wasn't given to me.

Charlie

Clyst Vale Carnegie Crew

I liked how Birdie explained someone moving to a different place, expecting acceptance but getting rejected, the author does this really well by other people treating her differently like the school teacher. I also like how the pony was the turning point of the story as after she found love everyone else started slowly accepting her. It was quite a short read but well done. 7/10

Muyang

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The book Birdie is a post world war story that tells the experience of a girl who leaves the safety of a brown baby care home to a completely different environment. I like how the author J.P. Rose shows her home sickness with frequent anecdotes to her previous life with Mrs Dudley. But gradually, once she settles, they appear less and less and instead she is engrossed with her mission to look after the future of a poor pit pony. Although, I do find the plot generic in the genre of "saving animals from adversaries" (if that exists); and plot is revealed quite early in the novel. However the ending is still entertaining and worth reading till the end.

Martin

TBGS READERS

I partially enjoyed Birdie by J. P. Rose because it was emotional, powerful, and easy to connect with. The story follows Birdie, a mixed-race girl living in a mining village, where she faces racism and is treated unfairly by some people because of the colour of her skin. This made me feel sorry for her and helped show how difficult life was for her at that time. My favourite part of the book was Birdie’s friendship with Mr Duke, the pit pony, because it brought warmth and hope to the story. One very big downside was that some parts felt a REALLY slow and quite sad, but overall I still thought it was a really meaningful and memorable book. I would rate it 6/10.

raqeeb

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed this book and I would highly recommend this to anyone who loves animals and quick reads. This was a heart warming book and it had lots of descriptions which made feel immersed in the book and in Birdie's life. I also thought that Mr Duke, the horse, was the main character and the real hero of this book. One of my favourite parts of this book was finding out about history in a fiction book so it was very fun to explore.

Bibi

Diary of a Wally Kid

Birdie is a powerful book about racism and friendship, showing how you can find the positives even in the worst situations. Set in the 1950's, some of the characters ideas and speech were more difficult to understand at the start, but the story pulls you in as it goes. Birdie's sense of right and wrong is very definite, and added another layer to the story. The connection Birdie had with Mr Duke was really sweet and felt very real, I loved seeing the development between them and everyone else. There were some very definite themes that were shown clearly and it was really well written.

Lettie

Diary of a Wally Kid

Birdie is a heartfelt book about refugees with a good plot and the blurb gives no spoilers.

leo

Waddesdon Shadowers 26

Test 20

CILIP Test 1

Birdie was a great book, the protagonist Birdie Bagshaw embodies everything we should be, she is kind to animals, she is kind to people and she is brave, she shows us to never give up and to fight for who we love. The book is also very eye opening and shows us what young black people had to go through in the 1900s and it show us to always stand up for our friends if they are bullied. I LOVED IT.

Raphael

SCD Pageturners

This is a fantastic book for people who enjoy unexpected unbreakable bonds that face challenges and adapting to new places while making new friends. A definite 10/10 and is very relatable for people who feel that they do not fit in.

Rose

Henry’s Shadowers

This was such a sad, yet sweet book, that shows you what life might have been like after the war. It is especially good if you love animals and it has such a lovely storyline of friendship and kindness.

Tamsin

Epsomians

I found this book extremely boring. It is about a girl who experiences racism when moving to a new home. She then meets a pit pony (a pony who lives in a mine) and becomes friends with it. The majority of the story is spent on her going to visit the pony, and promising to save it. I stopped halfway through the book and skipped to the end to see what happened. Basically, she rescues the pony, but then they have to go back to save some trapped miners, but then they set the pony free after that because it saved the miners. And they all lived happily ever after.

Emanuel

Belsize Stories

I thought 'Birdie' was an apt, fitting and in general heart-warming book, in wider context and just as a good read. The book reveals difficult themes from an entirely new perspective, and, although I maybe not be the book's target audience, I found there were multiple layers to uncover, from an older and younger mind. The author's use of language to portray different characters was well thought-out, and helped bring the book to life (I particularly liked the accents). Overall, I thought it a fairly good read.

Barney

KES Readers

This was such a sad, yet sweet book, that shows you what life might have been like after the war. It is especially good if you love animals and it has such a lovely storyline of friendship and kindness.

tamsin

Epsomian Shortlist Shadowers

Set in a post WW2 world, Birdie is a story where the protagonist is forced to tackle racism, without knowing what she has done to deserve this treatment. It also deals with forbidden relationships and friendship issues, mainly because of a horse. Overall, a heart-warming story, dealing with some tough issues. Not my cup of tea though. 7.6/10. I would recommend this to an audience the same age as me (10-14)

Eashar

MTS Northwood

This book is called Birdie. It is about a girl who was a an orphan. Her great -aunt wanted her but she didn't want to go. She went to the Yorkshire Dales. She found a horse. There was an explosion and the horse got badly wounded. At the end the horse got better. 7/10

Musa H 7P

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I LOVE THIS BOOK!!!!!!!! The heartwarming parts of and BIRDIE finding a home, friends, family and most MR DUKE i love JP ROSE put a horse into the book and the writing style which is not used in modern day is VERY GOOD and i would love to see a PART 2 to this book.

Emilie

County Shadows

I really loved the country feeling and the use of vocab. This was a very heartwarming story and is an excellent story for animal lovers and tells a great story.

Tapi

BCS Book Squad

Testing 11

CILIP Test 1

This book kept me on the edge of my seat for the whole thing, it was truly heart-breaking. I really liked when Birdie and Aunt Mabel first met, it was different to anything I had ever read before. It was good to see how their relationship developed and how Aunt Mabel became a better person through contact with Birdie. I thought certain parts of the story were a bit skipped through and I would have liked more detail. I think the whole book as a whole was too short. I also felt that the ending was very eventful but there weren't many details. Overall I really enjoyed it I just wanted more!

Harry

The Wondrous Book & Biscuit Club

I really enjoyed this book. I thought it would be dragged out for no reason but I liked the relationship that blossomed with Birdie and Mr Duke. Would recommend.

Eli S

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Unlike the other books from the Carnegies that I read, Birdie is a book that I don't really like. I do like how the book (as in the story) has its own history. The book is mostly about trust and friendship and a pit pony named Duke (not really sure if that is the name of the horse). Unfortunately, the idea of the story in my opinion is quite boring in general.

Tahmeed

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

'Birdie ' by J.P Rose is a powerful and emotional story about a girl dealing with friendship, family, and growing up. I really liked this book because it feels real and relatable with strong characters and important themes. It shows how hard things can be but also the importance of support and understanding.

Hannah .S

Vista Academy Littleport

Birdie by J.P. Rose is a poignant and thought-provoking book that explores themes of identity and friendship. The story follows Birdie as she navigates personal challenges, allowing readers to connect deeply into her experiences and struggles. When everyone rejects her, she finds hope making friends with the village pony, having no idea she has just made a decision that will change her whole community. Strong characterization, relevant themes, and deep emotions are the highlights of this story. It made me reflect on the challenges of navigating friendships and left me with a heightened awareness of the its complexity and dynamics. If you are on a self-discovery journey, there's a lot to reflect upon and learn from Birdie’s account.

Fareed

The SGS Book Bandits

I really enjoyed reading this book. This is because it blends one of my favourite genres (historical fiction) with animals. My favourite character was Mr Duke because just like Birdie I know a lot about horses. If you like this book I would recommend reading 'When The Sky Falls' or any book by Michael Mopurgo.

Iliana

Redhill Reviewers

It 's a beautiful story filled with friendship and heartache. This book's for anyone who loves animals and a bit of adventure as well.

Ruby

Redhill Reviewers

I really enjoyed this book as it was really moving, but also upsetting. The only bad thing I would say about this book is that it wasn't really my style of book, but still it was really enjoyable. I really felt empathy for Birdie when she was bullied. I would rate this three stars.

Matilda

Kingdown Wilts

Olivia

Montsaye Shadow Readers

I liked this book because I love animals and it got me stuck into it. My favourite character was Birdie herself. I think if the book was to have some pictures in it it would bring it to life a bit more. It is heart warming and an adventure.

Demi-Leigh

Redhill Reviewers

Birdie was such a heart warming story of a courageous little girl going through so much and how she still found the goodness in her heart to help an injured horse. Birdie is an incredible role model, fictional or non-fictional.

Valerie

Redhill Reviewers

Birdie is a young orphan and is going to start a new life but she faces racism. I really enjoyed this book and I think it really shows the impact of racial and sexual discrimination. It also touches on displacement, belonging and your identity. 4 out of 5 stars.

Olivia

Montsaye Shadow Readers

Birdie finds herself in a mine and then finds a pit pony. I loved this book. It's a sweet story of a girl and her pony. It's also a story of a girl finding her forever home. I would give it 4 stars.

Elspeth

Montsaye Shadow Readers

Birdie is a historical-fiction novel that tackles themes of racism and prejudice. It focuses on Birdie and her life after moving away from the children’s home where she grew up. Rose keeps this novel in a simple structure but also incorporates deeper topics. What I enjoyed most about this novel was how Birdie and her pit pony, Mr Duke, developed their relationship. When Birdie first arrives at Barrington Dale, she faces lots of challenges and gets bullied because of her skin colour. As she is running away from her bullies from school, she comes across a pit pony when she is hiding in the mines. Birdie’s journey to growth is complicated and her relationship with the pit pony plays an important role. Overall, Birdie is a meaningful book with serious themes. It highlights the many issues that happened in the past and how we should look at similar problems now. I would recommend this book to those who are interested in a simple book but also gives a detailed understanding about prejudice and unfairness.

Theresa

The Lotus Readers

The historical basis of the story was nice, however I found quite tick-boxy, with exception to the pony, which was an interesting addition to the historical side of the book. I also found that the writing in a Yorkshire accent made it more difficult to read.

Ben

TBGS READERS

This was a very heart felt book showing the hardships for Birdie back in 1950 UK . To then meet a friend of Mr. Duke who was going to be taken away from her . The plot twist at the end of Mr. Duke livening was a heart felt moment . All around a very good book that I enjoyed reading.

Conor

Bramcote College Library

Birdie is a good book. It follows Birdie as she moves from her home in Leeds to the village of Barrington Dale to live with her great-aunt. When she's there she faces racism and bonds with a pit-pony who lives in the mines. The books message is undoubtedly important. However, I really disliked the writing style and the character's personalities. I found Birdie a little bit simple and I didn't agree with her constant visits to the dangerous mines. Whilst I understand the book's use of Yorkshire language (as it is set in Yorkshire), I would argue that this could disorientating, especially for a book aimed at younger readers. Overall I would give it 2 Stars as it was a good book, but just not for me

Emily

HAEC Books and Biscuits Carnegie Shadowers

Birdie by J.P Rose is a heartwarming book about the bond between Birdie and Mr Duke, the town’s last pit pony. I really enjoyed the book and its message about fitting in with an unwelcoming society. It is a story about acceptance and one that challenged racism and discrimination, and its message is one that society needs. I really liked the character of the pony; Mr Duke, although the word ‘thou’ seemed to be overused. Overall, this book was a relaxing read, with an interesting storyline. For future readers, I would rate this book a 7/10.

Oliver (F)

The Fitzharrys Shadows

This was a lovely book which I think my only criticism is that it was short, which meant that bonds between characters didn’t have much time to develop. I did also really enjoy Birdie’s character - she felt very realistic. This was definitely a book for younger readers, but I thought it was nonetheless well-written and had important subject matter, with meaningful messaging.

Maddy

JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

it was decent... i would recommend to my sister the setting was random because she was walking in an field for forever overall not my favourite .

poppy and claudia

Cottingham High School

My favourite book, I loved Mr Duke and thought it was written very well

Beatrice

Cottingham High School

I quite liked the storyline but it took me a while to get into it.

Matilda

Cottingham High School

I really enjoyed this book, as it was a sweet story about Birdie and Mr. Duke's bond. I expected it to be like every other horse story but was pleasantly surprised as it wasn't all just about their bond - it was also about how Birdie was trying to fit in.

Annabel

Cake a Book Club

I love horses and I thought Birdie was great. This book is so important as it is challenging racism and and really showing us how some people are raised and what they must go through. I also thought that the character development was exceptionally good and a really magical book. I really recommend that you read this book.

Blaise

Bookwizards

I quite enjoyed this book, I was skeptical at first but it turned out to be very wholesome and a bit sad. It explored interesting themes of identity and race while capturing the exciting element of horse adventures. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and would definitely recommend it to others.

Sophie

Cake a Book Club

I did not really enjoy the writer's style but I liked the plot of the story and how she becomes friends and bonds with the pony.

Albert

Carnegivores

Birdie Bagshaw is a young girl. the story about her life is a truly impeccable and heartwarming tale. Picture this, you are an orphan who has never known her family. you are now - out of the blue - going to live with your aunt who treats you like an outsider. However, this treatment is not because you are an orphan, it is because you are a darker skin tone in comparison to her. Racism is a horrible thing and this tale about her miraculous life really encourages you to think before you act or speak. Despite this unrighteousness, a spark of hope encourages her to push on and keep going despite the bumpy journey. She finds a friend. A little pony in fact. But would it embrace her equally or treat her like the rest?

Aaryan

MTS Northwood

I thought birdie was quite a good book as the girl builds some strong relationships with a horse when everyone else rejects her. Slowly people begin to realise that the colour of there skin does not define who she is but her kindness.

Hannah

Esher High

Birdie is a historical fiction novel by J. P. Rose which follows the story of a young mixed race girl named Birdie Bagshaw who is sent from a children’s home in Leeds to live with her great-aunt in the Yorkshire dales, where she befriends the last remaining pit pony in the village. I enjoyed some aspects of the book, such as how she fought back at those who underestimated and ridiculed her for her skin color. Additionally, it was touching to see her bonding with the pit pony, who she later named Mr Duke. I quite liked seeing her develop from a sheltered and impulsive young girl to a caring, understanding and brave person. However, there were some parts I did not really enjoy, such as when she was very stubborn about staying with Mr Duke even when the mine was collapsing and her running away for a pony she had only met a few times before. Overall, I found Birdie to be an enjoyable book about the friendship between humans and animals and I believe it is suitable for ages 9 and above.

Yu-An

The Lotus Readers

Birdie is a book about a young girl who has a fascination with animals, particularly the horses that used to work in the mines near her new home in the 1950s and wants to help them. In my opinion the main themes of this book could be animals and their rights as well as racism and family. I think someone that would enjoy this book would be a person who likes animals and horses as that is the main focus of this book it might also be interesting to a person who is intrigued by mines and their history especially in the UK

lily

The Lotus Readers

I didn’t think i’d enjoy it at first but it ended up being a really nice book. I can’t remember if I posted a review for this one so i’m doing it again just in case, but I liked how instead of her making a normal friend like most books would have, the friend was a horse.

Lorin

Carnegivores

In my opinion, Birdie is a heart-warming novel that starts off quite slow and then speeds up. Birdie arrives at Barrington Dale after being summoned by her aunt from a home for brown babies. She is very sad to go as she has many friends. Once she arrives, she is treated very badly by everyone and even her aunt (who is called Mrs Winterbottom) is surprised when she sees her. I think that this is a very sad bit of the book as Birdie has left a place she likes and now is being discriminated against because of the colour of her skin. Things get more optimistic when she meets Mr Duke, who is a pit pony in the mines. However, when she finds out that Mr Duke is going to be killed, she tries to run back to the orphanage, but comes back. One of my favourite parts of this book is when Birdie tries to steal some mushy carrots from the church for Mr Duke and the vicar tries to stop her, but she talks to the vicar about Mr Duke, but finds a way to say that Mr Duke does need help, but doesn’t mention the fact that he’s a pony not a human. Overall, I think this book is a very intriguing book that I thoroughly enjoyed. It explored themes of racism, new beginnings and acceptance. It was a bit fast towards the end, especially when she runs away with Mr Duke. I feel that that part could have been a little bit longer because of the amount of emotion that was enclosed in one or two chapters. Other than that, it was pretty much perfect.

Siddharthan

The Perse Carnegians

Birdie is a book you just can't put down! It's an emotional rollercoaster, full of adventure and hope. This book is about a girl who is discriminated because she is black. It is set post war in a small, white Yorkshire village where Birdie has to find a way to fit in, while facing challenges along the way. But will she find her way in the end? Birdie is determined, curious and sometimes naive. This story shows the struggles of fitting in and finding the place that you belong. I would 100% recommend this book as it's a beautiful story and generally just a great read, which I'm sure a lot of people would enjoy. I would especially recommend this book to ages 10 and over. I loved it!

Eva

The Shady Bookhounds

My first impression on the book was interesting it really opened up my eyes for a life of someone who feels like they are different. It is quite a sad book but happy in the end showing a lot of racism which makes you feel some what sympathy for Birdie and her life. I do recommend, it is an amazing book which deserves to win and be read all around. I would love to read this book in lessons exploring the vocabulary and the characters more. If you are a horse lover then this book is also for you. No one deserves to be treated like they are no one just because they are different because we all are. That’s why this book is sad but true. But has a hook to pull you in, wanting more. It is a great book to teach kids that racism and no accepting people for who they are isn’t right. And that’s why this book deserves to win and be read it teaches you to always think from your heart.

Eva

MSJ Shadowers

I did not enjoy this book. After looking back on this after I finished the Challenge this book is the worst. The story had potential but it didn't use it and absolutely bored me out of my mind.

Henry D

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The book “Birdie” is a heartfelt book about a girl named Birdie who tries to find her own place in the new neighborhood she moves to in the first part of the book. This book mainly follows the theme of identity and finding your place. I enjoyed how the book shows this character development of trying to fit in with the other children even though she gets hated and bullied. This shows the finding of identity and that everyone can fit in no matter what difference they have. In addition, I loved that the book included the part where Birdie falls in love with a horse and executes a plan to save it because it shows the love connection between a human and an animal which can be heartfelt if they have a deep connection with each other.

SeaUn

The Lotus Readers

'BIRDIE' is the type of book that includes a hooking plot that you can’t seem to stop reading. As a result, I have finished reading this book within a week. This specific Carnegie book has kept me on a hook as it was a very profound book that included a plot swarming around a bond between Birdie and a horse she’s befriended, and the adventures and struggles she faces through starting fresh. However the most noticeable and savoured part of the story is when you can see multiple characters having character-development and changing for the better in the story, which most likely teaches us that sometimes you have to prove yourself capable of something to see people accept you, but Birdie wasn’t one to prove herself, she was a girl that just did what was right. Overall, I have really enjoyed BIRDIE as it creates a realistic plot of how our world works, and I would recommend this book suitable to anyone above the age of 10 as it includes themes of racism, which could be taken the wrong way for anyone who doesn’t have a deep understanding of criticism towards people.

Eine

The Lotus Readers

This book is about a girl in the 1950s with dark coloured skin struggling with friendships and fitting in. She finds her first friend and wants to stick with him till the end. I really liked this book as it had captured emotions very well and how the people were back in the day. It really had good dialogue with how they had spoken back in the day. I really loved the ending it was very sweet and made me a bit emotional. My favourite character was Aunt Mabel and how she had overcome her views about black people and how she had accepted Birdie for who she was and not how she looked. In conclusion this is a very nice historical book about friendship and racism back in the day. It is a very good read for teenagers and young adults with the topic of racism and showing that skin colour does not matter and how you can form friendships with animals and not just other people.

Red

Vista Academy Littleport

I thought this book was amazing and I loved how J.P Rose incorporated her own story and own background into the book. I also loved how at the end people didn't hate her anymore because she saved the people of the town. But this story was magnificent and should be told everywhere around the world to say that all children no matter their race or gender can do anything they put their heart out to do.

Taylor

Bramcote College Library

I enjoyed this book and finished it very quickly!

Ronan

Winchmore School Carnegie Group 2025/26

I thought that 'Birdie' was a good book, because it had a great plot and it was followed through nicely. On the other hand, the climax of the story was postponed until the end, making the first part a little dull. I also think J.P. Rose could have built the story up to the point where Birdie and Mr Duke ran away, to make people want to keep on reading until the end. Overall, I would read this book again, but would recommend for younger children around Y5-6 because it was quite and easy read for me.

Clara

CSGS Page Turners 26

This was by far my favourite Carnegie book because it gave an insight into the life of someone who is visually impaired, rather than the majority of books, which are targeted for children and adults who have no experience of disability. This book also has a main theme of feminism, weaving a well-known fairy tale and an ordinary young woman's life together. I rather like this because it contrasts to many books where everyone is perfect and the plots are quite dull and repetitive. In addition, the book 'Wolf Siren' included multiple genres inside of one book, such as fantasy, adventure and death. I am a fan of murder mysteries, so this encouraged me to choose this book for the Shadower's Choice Award, along with everything else!

Clara

CSGS Page Turners 26

Orla

Page Wanderers

The book wasn't bad but it was a boring book. The main character jumped from acting the most sensible to the least instantly and from the front cover you would of thought the pony leaves with the girl way sooner but it was just delayed to the very end so you wait the entire book for the last scene in the book just for that to be boring as well but it did the characters talking very well within the time frame.

Patrick

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book is a beautiful, the author researched this so deeply and clearly cared about the pit ponies, miners and the characters.

Isabelle

SCD Pageturners

I think Birdie was a good book. I really liked the main character Birdie Bagshaw and her determination to save the pit pony, Mr Dukes (I think that's his name). I also really loved her relationship with Walter and the way the story tackles racism. I do wish that the cover had a better view of Mr Dukes, with his importance in the story and whatnot. Overall, a good read and would recommend to those who are interested in animals and perhaps history. It does use a lot of "thee"/"thou" if that bothers you, but it's fine with me. Loved it!

Kayla

SCD Pageturners

A terrible book no plot really the main point of the story came in at the end with her doing what was very predictable. I don't really need to say anything else since there is not much to credit about this book 2/10.

Seb

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Orla

Page Wanderers

Birdie is a brilliant book which is all about a girl facing her fears with help from a spiritual pony. It explores the life of Birdie on her journey through her new life in the Yorkshire Dales. Many challenges cross her path including discrimination in her new town and bullying. Eventually she ends up in a coal mine where she will be rescued by her lifelong friend. This book is full of emotion, friendship and connection.

Orla

Page Wanderers

"Birdie" by J.P. Rose is an eye-opening novel set in the 1950s that follows a young girl (Birdie Bagshaw) as she navigates the struggles of moving out of her children's home and living with her family. At the start of her story, she faces racism and bullying without fully understanding why, but then we see her teaching her small community the importance of friendship and acceptance and in the end, they help her accept herself and her situation too. It's a heart-warming story and perfect for anyone who loves animals and happy endings!

Krisitina

The Laureate League

I think Birdie is a must read for all ages. It is an engaging, well written book set in the 1950s and carries extremely important messages like racism, belonging and animal rights. The end had me gripped and I was so happy that Mr Duke survived (even though I don’t know how realistic it is). One thing I might change is the overused word ‘thou’ because even though it might have been said at that time, it was not very common, and it was used a bit too much. But overall, I really loved this book, and Birdie is very well written.

Jana

The Perse Carnegians

I enjoyed reading this book because it's interesting to see how much Birdie the main character changes throughout the book. However, I think the story plot is a bit too unrealistic, and there was a part in the middle which I found quite boring. But, I think the message and themes of the book are good. I also like the historical background and the setting.

Anita

St George’s Dragon Readers

This was a beautifully written book set in a different time period that I am not used to reading. The book had me hooked in during the first 20 pages or so, and this was such a captivating book and storyline. However, some parts of the book were a little bit unrealistic, especially the bond between Birdie and the pony. It did get me confused on how fast the two have bonded over a short amount of time, but if it's book logic, then its book logic! Overall, this was such a lovely book and such a fantastic read!

Afreen

Skipton Shadows

Erin

4Shadowers

Beautifully written, moving and tender story. So much kindness to be found. I loved Mr Duke and was very happy about the ending. Really think this has a good chance of winning the award!

Cook

IVC Readers

Birdie is a heartfelt story set in post war Northern England about a young orphan girl. She spent most of life dreaming about about one day having a family of her own. So when a letter arrives from her great-aunt she is thrilled but also sad to leave the only home she's ever known. Upon arrival she is shunned by the people of Barrington Dale;even her own family is ashamed at first. Lonely she wants to go home but then she meets a pony who she names Mr Duke . I think this book is perfect for slightly older readers as it contains themes that maybe a little confusing for younger readers.The most gripping part of the book for me was the ending

Adele

The Shady Bookhounds

I really liked Birdie because it was about an unlikely friendship that ended well. I think that Birdie was a really good character because she was alone and just needed a friend to help her. I would give this a 9/10

David

RGS Junior Book Club

I really did not like this book. While I do understand the direction it was going for with the old setting the dialogue very much irritated me. The entire problem of the way they talked could have been avoided if they just set it modern day. I HATED it when they said "thee" and "thou" and it was not pulled off well. I did not understand how utterly oblivious she could be to her skin colour and I do understand the message trying to be put across, it was not executed well at all. This book was an annoying read and completely boring and stupid at the same time. 0/10

Elliott.H

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book was okay. The old man was a deus ex machina and the pony should have died in the end, but every children's book has to have a happy ending, so the pony somehow survived blowing up.

David

Elms Shadowing 2026

Birdie is a touching story creating inspiring emotions of hope and courage. It's about a young girl going through difficult times but somehow always staying hopeful. With this hope, she learns how to deal with problems and becomes braver with every page. In my opinion, the best themes are growing up and especially being strong and the themes stay consistent throughout the rest of the book. Overall I mostly liked this book.

Kai

Elms Shadowing 2026

Pages 1-21. The beginning 20-21 pages show the main character Birdie leaving her home in Leeds which she lived with Mrs Dudley. The only mother she’s known to go to a place called Barrington Dale. Birdie is leaving due to a letter from her Great Aunt Mabel. She believes her great aunt wants her. When she arrives at Barrington Dale, it is freezing and empty and she is left there whilst parents are coming for the other children. Because of this Birdie walks through the snow whilst bringing her heavy suitcase with her. When she arrives at Mabel’s house, Mabel isn’t nice instead she is harsh and gives our main character in the book, birdie an attic room which it is freezing in. So far in my opinion, these pages show how harsh it is being an outsider. An example is how I mentioned prior, parents hugged other children whilst birdie was left alone and made to walk all the way to her great aunt’s house. Pages 22 – 150 In the following section of the book, Birdie attends the village school. It is evident that she does not belong to the local community. Her teacher Miss Skerren, acts with cruelty and treats Birdie as if her intelligence is low because of her origins. To avoid the people who harass her and the low temperatures, Birdie locates a hidden area within a coal mine. There is a pit pony named Mr Duke whom she encounters in this location. As the local residents behave in a harsh manner, the pony is gentle with her. For Birdie, the animal provides more emotional support than the humans, because the pony does not form negative opinions about her based on her differences "home". Pages 151 - 220 As the narrative continues, the closure of the mine is imminent. Due to the advanced age of the pony, the owners intend to kill the animal - but Birdie feels unable to accept the loss of her only companion and she creates a strategy to protect him. On those pages the text also indicates that Great Aunt Mabel has reasons for her behavior. It is clear that she experiences isolation and sadness. By this point Birdie transforms from a child who feels fear into a person who acts with courage. If she must violate regulations to achieve a moral outcome, she is willing to do so. Pages 221 - 256 As the book starts to reach its conclusion, the atmosphere is full of pressure. To save the life of Mr Duke, Birdie guides him through mine tunnels that contain many hazards. It is a significant danger but the residents of the village observe her actions for the first time. By the conclusion, she is no longer the isolated girl who carries a large and heavy container for belongings. And the ending suggests that a person can find a "home" in any place if they have the bravery to pursue it - it finishes the story.

Binyamin

BAS Reading Champions

'Birdie' by J. P. Rose is a heart-warming book about a black girl who starts living with her great-aunt and uncle in the countryside. This book is about how she proves herself worthy and doesn't let harmful racist comments get to her. I loved the way Birdie had the courage to go down to the mine to feed Mr Duke even after Mr Walter (her great-uncle) warned her of the risks. I enjoyed this book and I would definitely read it again! I would recommend this book to people who are Year 5+ because it was an easy read and wasn't any hard elements to the plot. Overall I would rate this book a 4/5!

Lukshmi

CSGS Page Turners 26

Once again, I found myself disliking the book. Birdie really didn't have what it takes to make its way into my 'good' category. One of the main reasons for my dislike of Birdie was the consistent use of 'thee' and 'thou' as well as lots of other similar, 13th century sounding, vocabulary. This really didn't fit with the 1950s town vibe and was very repetitive so got me rather worked up by the end. Another reason why Birdie wasn't great was because the character of Birdie was terrible. I found her pulling the sympathy card far too often (which was once again repetitive and annoying) as well as being 100% oblivious to her skin colour and also the world around her. Even after many not so subtle hints, she was still wandering blindly about. In addition to this, her bond with Mr Duke was created far too quick as it almost seemed like they were in love at first sight, which was not very realistic. How can you expect me to believe that a girl and a random horse made a lifelong bond after she stroked him one time? However, the plot was not bad (somehow it is the best one so far which tells us something about the quality of the books this year) as there was a strict storyline to it and it did not wander too far from the beaten path. The character of Aunt Mabel and her development over time to love Birdie despite her looks was also quite good. Despite this, I personally think that the idea to merge two styles - one similar to a Michael Morpurgo when a child makes a bond with an animal and one about the challenges of racism - was never going to work, as pushing too hard on one side will leave nothing for the other and J.P Rose has done a great job in balancing them out but I think this could actually be worse as now there is no 'main feature' just two ideas that don't really work together sitting there with no support. This led to the book being a bit bland and being half saved by a mediocre plot. Overall, Birdie was not great as there was a bad use of 13th century language, two different styles pushing each other away and a rubbish main character. Plot:6/10 Characters:4/10 Setting:6/10 Style:2/10 Total:18/40

Sevan

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie is a nice book about a girl who moves away from her home to live with her aunt. It is a heartwarming story filled with love for horses and learning to accept new things and people. However, I found that the story was a bit shaky at the start and didn't have me very engaged or interested. I was also sceptical of the book from its blurb. The words ' spirited little pony' made me think it was a book for younger readers. Some of the language like 'any road' was also hard to get used to at the start. I recommend it to readers who like animals and a bit of historical writing told in a compassionate and child friendly way.

Anthea

Larkmead

Birdie- theme: historical fiction set in the 1950's. Birdie by J.P. Ross is a heart warming, sweet book about a girl, Birdie Bagshaw who moved from a foster home with Mr and Mrs Dudley, to Yorkshire with her great aunt and uncle. I really liked how Birdie's aunt at first didn't accept her, but then once she shared her story, they actually started caring about each other. I also liked how much Birdie cared about about Mr Duke, saving him in that mine and being willing to going away with him to give him to Mr Dudley's farm. I also really liked Brian's character as at first, he made fun of her and was mean to her, but then he got used to her and ended up being really nice to her and protecting her from the bullies. Overall, it's a book about fitting in, moving to new places, racism and people fitting in. It is a sweet book, that I would give a 3.5/5.

Anya

Carnegivores

This book was one of the first books I read and I'm glad I read it first. This was an amazing read. The characters had personality and I would definitely recommend this to new Carnegie readers. I'm looking forward to seeing what the judges have to say about this great book.

Callum

The Narrative Navigators

I thought the book Birdie was a book that showed friendship. I think this because Birdie finds Mr. Duke in the abandoned mines but has to leave him in the mine when she gets out. But she keeps coming back to care for him and make sure he is ok. She started making friends above ground also like Brian, who once bullied her, turned into one of her new friends at her new home. I felt sad for her when she left her Great Aunt and Uncle because they did not deserve to feel like they did after there son died at war. Including that she almost lost Mr. Duke in the process of running away because he got a stitch or belly blockage from him eating fresh grass. Eventually they came back and stopped people from being killed down in the mines. Sadly Mr. Duke was thought dead after running into the mines as a gas explosion happened. Eventually though, they found him alive and nurtured him back to health. Overall I am really happy with how the book turned out and I loved how Birdie found her forever family.

Rowan

KAEP Lions

This book is cute and heart-warming, and the main character was very sweet to follow through her story. The writing was slightly lack-luster, but I suppose that's to be expected in a book for a younger audience. Overall, it's a solid 3 star read from me.

Alice

Cleeve Carnegie

Great book, would definitely recommend. Guaranteed to bring a smile to any animal lover's face and also has some good history in there too! 9/10

Jackson

Brookie Reads

I thought that this book was lovely because of the well-rounded characters and progression of the villagers and Birdie's personalities and understandings. I think people will enjoy it for its themes and length.

Seren

Fullbrook Bookworms

I just finished reading Birdie and it was actually really good and super emotional. The way it was written made me feel exactly what the main character was going through, especially during the sadder parts. I couldn't put it down because I just needed to know how it would all turn out.The main character was really relatable and I loved how she found her strength in the end. The setting was vivid, and I felt like I was actually there with her. It made me think a lot about family and growing up, which is pretty cool for a book. Overall, I totally recommend reading this if you want something that makes you think and feel. It is definitely one of the best books I’ve read this year.

Ulysse

Wetherby Prep Book Club

I really enjoyed Birdie as I found the story very interesting and gripping. It is about a young girl called Birdie who is an orphan who is forced to leave her beloved orphanage to go live with her great aunt. When she arrives in her new village she is discriminated against for her skin colour and no one wants to be friends with her. However through her loneliness she finds a friend in the coal mine who is a pony. I love how determined she is to keep Mr Duke (her pony) safe. Furthermore, I like how it gives me an insight into the industrial revolution and how badly some people were treated. I enjoy how much love and care Birdie gives to Mr Duke and in return he gives her friendship and he is always there when she needs him. Parts of the novel are sad but Birdie never gives up and always gives all she has to protect Mr Duke. Overall, I really enjoyed Birdie and would highly recommend it to everyone.

Hattie

Chiswick Carnegie

Birdie is a brilliant book which gives me an insight on how it must have been to live as a mixed-race child during the Industrial Revolution. I loved Birdie because it demonstrates themes of bravery, stamina and determination. The story really is inspirational as it shows how to keep pushing and how to carry on, even when life seems unfair and cruel. I would wholeheartedly recommend this tale to all readers who love a good page-turner.

Molly

Chiswick Carnegie

Birdie was a good read. It covers the ideas of racism for young minds and I started to really feel the emotions of the characters. It wasn’t my favourite book.

Olly

Horsham BOok HUNTers

The book cover was well designed, I feel like the illustration of the character correctly portrayed her attitude throughout the book. It took me 2 weeks to read the book. The main plot is about an orphaned girl who gets adopted by her aunt and has to move to a forign area and face unexpected racial discrimination. The main themes are racial discrimination, community, nature, and identity/belonging. I thought the most memorable moment was when aunt Mabel opens up about how she was effected by the death of her son, and apologises for the unfair way that she treated Birdie when they first met. I found this scene memorable because it avoided the cliche of the cold and caloused great-aunt who is stuck in her ways and past the point of change. Through this moment the author acknowledges that people are always capable of apologising and changing thier behaviour. I think that the book is suitable for both genders, but targeted towards girls. I think that the ideal reading age is between 10-14. I don't think children under this age would understand many of the deeper themes. Since the book explores ideas about racisim, it may be targeted towards people of color, but I belive that it would still be enjoyable for all children. However, the plot of the book itself was sometimes hard to follow, and it wasn't really made clear how much time was passing between different events. The author assumes that the reader has at least a minimal understanding of historical events (such as the world wars) this may be an issue for younger readers. I would give this book an 8/10. I would reccomend it for other readers and think it deserves a carnegie medal.

Erin

Gibraltar Carnegie Scholars

Birdie is an amazing book as we navigate through the book in Birdie's shoes. As Birdie starts a new life where she struggles to fit in, Mr Duke was always there for her. I loved how she is so relatable in many ways, because sometimes you do really feel like you don't fit in. I loved the very heartwarming ending where Mr Duke courageously saves the men in the pit with Birdie. I love the powerful message in the book and I love how it's really easy to just see the bullying that Birdie experiences through her eyes. I like her character and how she first arrives very innocent, sweet and nice, but as she goes through a tough journey, she grows more mature and has a stronger bond with Mr Duke.

Nathania

St George’s Dragon Readers

'Birdie' by J.P. Rose is the story of Birdie who goes to liv ewith her great aunt in the english countryside. There, she meets a pit pony, who she loves and is determined to save from the dangerous mines. I really loved this story as i love horses and you can see and understand Birdie's passion and determination to save this pony. It has lots of short chapters and is quick to read.

Anna

4Shadowers

this book was set in an interesting setting but the plot itself lacked anything to make me feel emotion. The racism themes were quite in depth but I felt using a pony as a plot drive was a bit strange.

Thomas

Forest Hill Library

The book I am reviewing is 'Birdie' by J. P Rose. This is a book about a black girl living in a children's home in Leeds just after the war. Her aunt then asks for her to move in with her to the countryside. There she faces a lot of racism from the people who treat her like she's stupid. I think it was a good story but I think there could have been a bit more action rather than just all the talking. This book also goes at quite a slow pace which gets a bit boring after a while. However in the last 50 pages, it goes at quite a nice pace and there was quite a lot of action. For me, this book really showed what was going on with racism at the time and in some parts it does get quite sad. Definitely a happy ending for the people that like those! I also like the way she's written as she uses words such as thee and other slang which does sound quite good, although this did make it a bit difficult to read sometimes. I would recommend this book for anyone who wants an easy read that might make you a bit emotional. I'm going to rate this book an 8.5/10.

Tom

Hope Valley Literati

I really loved the unique storyline combined with an amazing representation of the realities of living with racism! It was full of emotion throughout and the ending had me on the edge of my seat.

Rachel

LSST Library Shadowers

I thought that this was quite a thoughtful, insightful book that talked about England before it became accepting and diverse. It's a powerful book that shows animals can the greatest support and comfort sometimes when no one is around!

Muhsina

Carnegivores

I didn’t think Birdie was a bad book. I thought that it would have been a very good book, if I had been younger, because it talked about grief, racism and the war in a very watered down, child- friendly way. I also found that the book itself and the characters all seemed to be lacking something, it didn’t feel like a finished book, but a good draft. I did like the way Birdie’s relationship with the pony, was realistic and portrayed the relationship between human and animal very well. I found the ending to be quite a letdown, as I felt it was extremely unrealistic (all of a sudden, in a very short space of time, everyone sees the error of their ways and are all good friends) and like your average children book ending. One of the things I enjoyed, was the slightly slow buildup of realisation from Birdie, as it really came across as an innocent child’s viewpoint of the world. Personally, I had no emotional attachment to any of the characters, and really struggled to picture them in my head and felt that there were far too many coincidences to fully believe the story, I do think that a younger child could find much joy and love for this story, as they won’t pick up on these sorts of things.. Overall, I think this book was by no stretch a bad book, but it is not one that I will read again. I would, however, recommend to a younger child who wanted to learn about the impact of the war. I thought this book was similar to some of Michael Morpurgo's and Lauren St John's works. 6/10

Lulu

KES Readers

I forgot to say but i would HIGHLY recommend it to ALL my friends 🩷*＊✿❀ ❀✿＊*.・゜-: ✧☾　☽✧ :-゜・..｡*ﾟ+.*.｡ ﾟ+..｡*ﾟ+✧･ﾟ:* *:･ﾟ✧୨୧・・・・୨୧・・・・✼　 ҉　 ҉　 ҉　 ҉　 ҉　 ҉　✼ . 。・゜✭・.・✫゜・。

Florence✧･ﾟ:* *:･ﾟ✧

Lionheart2026

I really enjoyed reading Birdy as it really tugs at your heart It's very heart warming as you follow Birdy's thoughts and feelings.She is an orphan and is different because of her skin,hair and personality . J.P.Rose really makes you feel ... there.Birdy makes a friend and finds her place to call home . it is VERY heart warming.🐎😭❤🐦🩷ʕっ•ᴥ•ʔっ the way i see it you kind of just want to give a hug xxxx(｡･ω･｡)ﾉ♡✧･ﾟ:* *:･ﾟ✧.・゜-: ✧☾　☽✧ :-゜・.

Florence✧･ﾟ:* *:･ﾟ✧

Lionheart2026

I Have loved reading birdie because it has really inspired me and I just really enjoy reading it overall because it is so nice and for me I really enjoyed all of it

Jessica

Balla Bookworms

Birdie by J. P. Rose is a moving and heartfelt novel about courage, belonging, and friendship. Set in 1950s Yorkshire, it follows Birdie, a mixed-race orphan who goes to live with her great-aunt and struggles to feel accepted in her new village. The story explores difficult themes such as racism, loneliness, family, and identity in a sensitive way. Birdie’s bond with Mr Duke, the last pit pony, is one of the most touching parts of the book, as their friendship is full of trust, loyalty, and comfort. This is a beautiful and emotional story, especially for readers who love animals, and it shows the importance of kindness, bravery, and finding your place in the world.

Yasmine

4Shadowers

Birdie book review Birdie was a captivating book and a heart-warming story. It has a main message of no matter your skin colour, you can always make difference. Set in 1952, just after the war ended, Birdie Bagshaw lives in a brown babies orphanage. She loves all her friends and when her great auntie calls for her to leave, she is devastated. When she arrives at Barrington Dale, she wishes even more that she could come home. Her auntie doesn’t like her, neither do the villagers, even her teacher thinks she is incapable. But after she narrowly escapes some bullies, she meets a beautiful pit pony, and the moment Birdie sets her eyes on her, she falls in love. Birdie slips away every day to see her beloved Mr Duke and she soon forms a great bond with him. However, when someone whom Birdie doesn’t know comes to her aunt and uncles house telling them that Mr Duke will be killed, Birdie decided to run away with Mr Duke, only to come back the next day and save 2 people that are stuck in mine that collapsed. I think that this book was a great reminder of the difficulties some people have faced because of the colour of their skin. It was a story of adventure and love and resilience. I would recommend this book to others: I found it a real page turner and hope other readers do too!  

Harry

The Perse Carnegians

I was slightly disappointed with Birdie. The plot line didn't really go anywhere and it got quite boring at points. Birdie, the main character, was nonsensically stubborn and got in high danger that risked herself and her family so much that it didn't seem right. Her aunt and uncle seemed to just let her go wherever she liked, and then get really annoyed when she came back. Birdie could just skip school and do whatever she liked, and didn't get into trouble that much. However, the setting was described very well and I loved how the author brought historical facts and events into the story. The ending, though, felt a little bit like a children's story, everything and everyone was happy and alive even though the actions of the main character were so dangerous. I would rate it about 3/10

Faye

Kingdown Wilts

Birdie is seriously one of the best books I have ever read,and I read loads of books. The story and the detail about life after the war are exquisite, especially how being mixed was so shocking that Birdie was sent to a special care home.I loved this story and how it's a symbol against racism and how acceptance, while it may not be easy, can always happen.10/10

Sandy

Dunraven Carnegie

birdie was fine. overall its a pretty good book if you like historical fiction and i liked the bit at the end, but its slightly boring and i, personally, don't mind but some people might not like the "old language" in the book, e.g. thee, lass, thy. It has a lot of inspirational quotes and the likes, but it sort of gets annoying after some time. It gets a bit boring after a while, but if you enjoy that sort of thing, then its just way easier and more enjoyable to read. I would rate it a 4/10, for readers ages 8-13

Nella

Dunraven Carnegie

Birdie is an astonishing book regarding racial challenges, empathy and history (1950s). It is an amazing book about a girl that faces racial inequality in her new home town; after hiding from some bullies she finds herself in a mine shaft. Later she is rescued by a gorgeous pit pony whom she instantly falls in love with. Subsequently she rescues the pit pony and helps the village after a disaster in the mine. Generally I think that Birdie is a wonderful book and is definitely worth a chance. 8.8/10

Sara

Chiswick Carnegie

The book, Birdie, is a very intriguing book. I like how it all starts in the middle of her story, where she knows nothing about herself. However, as the story progresses, she finds more about herself and her past. I feel the main theme is trust, as Birdie's whole lifestyle changes and she needs to build new friendships and trust. I like how they added someone, who could look past her differences, no matter what her race is or her hair. I feel they could've added Birdie with her new life in detail, and how she was doing after the incident. I really love the connection between Birdie and her friend she met in the pits. The detail added to this story is great and I would definitely recommend this book to anyone looking for a good book.

Suheyla

Chiswick Carnegie

This book drew me in really quickly, in comparison to the Chronicles of a Lizard Nobody, where I was hooked after about the first fifty pages or so. By page 10 on Birdie, I decided I must read this book in two or less sittings! The style of the writing is very captivating, and one thing I really love is how the obvious problem of racism that the reader is expecting isn't addressed directly at the beginning. Birdie is raised in an all-black, or brown, orphanage, without much outside-world contact, and so she is very inexperienced in the ways of the adult, divisive world. Her skin colour is not explicitly mentioned, showing the reader that Birdie does not care, does not know that people can be divisive simply based on the colour of their skin. Upon arriving at the Winterbottom household, she begins to face racism, and, as a reader, I think it was a very realistic description of a young girl trying to figure out why everyone would look down on her upon sight. J.P Rose trusts the reader to piece together what is happening before Birdie does, and I find it creates a highly intimate connection between us and the events of the book. The themes of the book were handled brilliantly and with a lot of unsaid depth, shown and not told. However, I find the interactions slightly too hurried, for it's almost as if Birdie talks to someone once, they are racist to her, she talks to them again, and the other person apologises. As a reader, I personally would have enjoyed some more interactions of Birdie with said character, in which said character learns about who Birdie is as a person and the colour of her skin does not matter. I find the way Birdie keeps on going to the pit pony slightly unrealistic, but I think it provided enough interactions for the relationship to be created in depth and for me to actually care about what happens to Duke (the horse). I think the story represents innocent minds being victim to these divisive historic societal beliefs in a very historically accurate and emotional way, and of human and animal connection in a very raw and true manner. Overall, a highly interesting read and I would definitely recommend!

Roosha

The Perse Carnegians

this book is one of my favourite books i really likes the description of the book i was impressed by the girls character it was the best one at the story all the book was really nice .

lamar m

Lionheart2026

Birdie- theme: historical fiction set in the 1950's. Birdie by J.P. Ross is a heart warming, sweet book about a girl, Birdie Bagshaw who moved from a foster home with Mr and Mrs Dudley, to Yorkshire with her great aunt and uncle. I really liked how Birdie's aunt at first didn't accept her, but then once she shared her story, they actually started caring about each other. I also liked how much Birdie cared about about Mr Duke, saving him in that mine and being willing to going away with him to give him to Mr Dudley's farm. I also really liked Brian's character as at first, he made fun of her and was mean to her, but then he got used to her and ended up being really nice to her and protecting her from the bullies. Overall, it's a book about fitting in, moving to new places, racism and people fitting in. It is a sweet book, that I would give a 3.5/5.

Anya

Carnegivores

Set in the prejudice-heavy 1950s, this moving tale follows Birdie. A black baby is sent to an orphanage at birth because of the colour of her skin. When she is eventually sent to live with her Aunt Mable, she is met with coldness and cruelty rather than the love and compasion she deserves. Birdie’s life changes forever when a gang of bullies chases her into a dangerous drift mine. Lost in the dark, she is rescued by a horse she named Mr Duke, sparking an unbreakable bond that becomes her only sence of belonging and worth. However, her safety is constantly threatened by local prejudice—including a neighbor determined to keep Birdie away from his daughter. When Birdie discovers a plan to send Mr Duke to the knacker's yard, she orchestrates a daring escape. Their journey is fraught with peril; after a narrow escape from drowning, Birdie must find a way to save a collapsing Mr Duke With the help of a kind vet, they survive. In a gripping climax, Birdie and Mr Duke return home just as disaster strikes the community. Following a heroic rescue mission to save trapped locals (one of which was Mr Walter) in the mines, Mr Duke disappears back into the depths, leaving Birdie shattered. It was not possible for a Christmas miracle to finally bring Birdie to leave her room but is astonished to find Mr Duke healthy again and is happy for the love and acceptance she has fought so hard to find?

Jonathan

Bookwizards

I find Birdie to be an inspiring book that resembles resilience and upbringing into a new life. Birdie is a character that is mature and kind-hearted that makes the book very warm and friendly. If I had to give a negative it would be the sadness of Birdie leaving her happy life in Leeds to then feel disturbed in her new community. Thank you!

Zach

Wetherby Prep Book Club

I recommend Birdie for younger readers ( 9-10 ) who like action. It was an original story idea and had lots of action near the end. It was a unique ending which was believable. It was consistent, and the villagers dislike for Birdie created a tense atmosphere, but nearer the end friendships were born. Birdie is a realistic tale about a girl, a horse and belonging.

Florence

Diary of a Wally Kid

I really enjoyed this book. I would give it a 10/10 because it was really enjoyable to read and it had a really nice storyline. This book is all about bravery and friendship. This book shows that you just have to keep on trying no matter how many people tell you to give up and that everybody is different but that it does not mater. I really enjoyed when her aunty who is called Mabel says sorry for judging her and Birdie forgives her. I would say that this book is good for 10 year olds and over. This is a really good book and i really recommend it.

Sophie

RGS Junior Book Club

It was a nicely paced story that was easy to understand. Though I believe the issues presented in the book should have lasted until the end of the story rather than split into two parts

GreatB00ks

I really enjoyed reading this book. I like how she met the Mr. Duke in the mine and started to care about him a lot and that he was her first friend there, even if he is a horse. I also like the ending when she finds out he's still alive. This book is about racism, bravery and friendship. It shows that everyone is different but unique and special at the same time. I would rate it a 9/10.

Drishti

RGS Junior Book Club

This book is a really good book with adventure and drama. This book spreads the message that everyone can make a difference and everyone can be brave. Even if nobody believes in you don't let that stop you because you can do it. My favourite part was her meeting with the pony because of the interaction. This book is really good for 9+ and I would give it an 8/10.

Alyssa

RGS Junior Book Club

This book is a really good book with adventure, drama and bravery. This book helps spread the message that you can be brave and make a difference, even if nobody believes in what you're doing. My favourite part of this book was when Birdie and Mr Duke go into the mine to rescue the people that are stuck down there, despite being scared. This book is perfect for people age 8+ and I give it a 9/10 rating.

Freya

RGS Junior Book Club

i enjoyed this book as it was a story about friendship against all odds and also about discrimination. My rating is 6/10.

Nathan

RGS Junior Book Club

Birdie is a book that is amazing in every aspect, with its funny moments, but also with sad and comforting moments too - it really makes you think. Birdie is set in the 1950s where everyone treats this wonderful and kind girl differently (at first) because she looks different from the children they are used to seeing. It makes you really confused at first because she is so nice and they don't even know her. Then, you find out that Birdie is brown-skinned. It makes you sympathise with her struggles as she fights the prejudiced beliefs that plague England and dictates how people see Birdie and every other black kid in the nation at that time. The book has sad moments as she risks everything to save a friend that had her back since day one. I liked this book very much and would recommend it to all ages.

Toby

The Wondrous Book & Biscuit Club

Birdie is set in 1950's Yorkshire and finds Birdie, a mixed race girl, moving from her beloved children's home to her newly found Aunt and Uncle. Whilst battling prejudice and isolation in her new surroundings Birdie finds Mr Duke - the last remaining pit pony still living in the mine. Can she find solace in rescuing Mr Duke and at the same time herself? This is a great read that tackles prejudices in post-war Britain that felt heart breaking at times but then felt healed by the delightful bond between Birdie and Mr Duke. A truly heart warming read.

Michelle

AB Everyone Reading

Birdie is a wholesome story full of danger and adventure. This is one of my most satisfying reads of all the books I’ve read. Set just after World War 2, Birdie is an orphan girl sent to live with her Aunt in a mining village. The story revolves around her life when she first moves here. She is discriminated against by many of the villagers, her only friends being her Uncle, the local Vicar and a pit-pony. This is a story about a young girl bringing joy back to a post-war village after a period of mourning. She reminds the villagers of pre-war times and helps them to recover. This book makes me feel depressed and angry at the unfairness of post war Britain. However towards the end I felt more joyous as Birdie helps them recover.

Oliver

The Fitzharrys Shadows

The book Birdie is a wonderful, heartwarming story of a young girl's love for a mistreated animal. The whole book is written so you can easily understand both Birdie and the rest of the character's perspectives. I had a wonderful time reading and got my heart shattered and pieced back together a good few times. However, I find the perspective to be slightly outdated, which is both good and bad. This means I cannot fully understand Birdie's morals or thoughts but it makes a great personal history lesson I can pick up and sadly put down. I would give this a solid 9.5/10 as the only problem I have is No.1, having to finish it sadly, No.2, the date of this book is not fully relatable to me and No.3, the way it was written is a bit comedic sometimes, meaning it isn't fully serious even when it should be. In conclusion, Birdie is a great book that really makes you rethink every racist joke you've ever laughed at or brushed off. It truly made me smile and want to cry at times. Would definitely recommend!!

Sophie

Baxter Booklighters

Birdie by J. P. Rose is an exciting book about a young girl called Birdie, based in the 1950s, who moves out of her orphanage hoping to belong and be loved, only to find that no one knew or wanted to know who she really was. Birdie is a brave and strong character and I would recommend this book to all readers, even those who don’t usually read these types of books. Overall it is an interesting topic and will keep you wanting to find out if Barrington Dale will ever accept Birdie for her identity.

Annabelle

The Fitzharrys Shadows

Birdie is a very beautiful book which I enjoyed from start to finish. I really enjoyed the themes of black prejudice and discrimination because it gave me information and I empathized with people of colour during aftermath of slavery being abolished. The area in Yorkshire where Birdie was sent to still had major superstitions as it was a more discreet area still having major negative thoughts about black peoples' intelligence and manners. The book is also about being able to stand up for who you are, as well as the awareness of animal abuse and the heroes of the Industrial Revolution - the pit ponies! The book was heartwarming and it felt like a wonderful journey, with likable characters, genuine emotion, but also with villains. This book for me was a 10/10, I would recommend to animal lovers, people interested with the Industrial Revolution and the pits and people wanting to learn about black discrimination and their personal experience.

Elliott

Brookie Reads

Birdie is a heart filling story about friendship and trust. The author describes the scenes so detailed it feels like you're in the book itself . Outstanding artwork shown on the cover (they say to never judge a book by its cover but I did and it turned out amazing) I really loved this book and would totally recommend! :)

grace

Brookie Reads

It is a very good book and is very heart warming between the pony and Birdie. Unexpected plot twist : )

Rosie

Brookie Reads

Alice

Montsaye Shadow Readers

This book is really good at showing how people make wrong assumptions. As well as the fact anyone can be a hero even if they don't do what they are told or fit the normal for the area.

Arthur

The Fitzharrys Shadows

A thoughtful and heartwarming novel. The Northern setting appealed to me because I am from the north. I certainly sympathised with the characters and overall enjoyed the book.

owen

Bramcote College Library

I quite liked this book, as it liked how it showed people overcoming their initial prejudices. At the start of the book, Birdie moved into a village in the countryside from Leeds, and I liked how it portrayed her emotions upon leaving her friends and carer. Then she suffered racism at school, even from the teacher, as the teacher gave Birdie a jigsaw instead of a workbook, and then proceeded to accuse her of cheating when she answered a simple maths question. Because of this, Birdie ran away and ended up in a mine where she met a pit pony. After escaping the mine she was told not to go there again, but she did, and I found it quite funny in the way it showed her defiance, as a young child preferring to keep a promise to a pony despite the risk to her own safety. This was until eventually, after discovering that the pony was going to be slaughtered, she decided to run away with him. I enjoyed this bit as it feels like something a real child would be prepared to do, and she does it with a realistic lack of planning. She also, strangely, thinks it as a good idea to swim through a river on this escapade. After a day, she ended up returning as she believed she and the pony could help get some trapped miners out. This one time she was actually allowed down the mine, she didn't come back when she was told. After becoming the hero, the racism stopped as people realised she was just as capable as everyone else, and she got to keep the pony in the end, which I thought was quite nice. After much consideration, I would give this book a 7/10.

Edward M

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I read Birdie and enjoyed it. I thought it was a fantastic book with themes touching on fitting in and identity. I found it inspiring and loved the story that made me realise exactly how much our actions matter.

Bethany

The Broxbourne Readers

I had mixed feelings about this book. I found that it was aimed at a slightly younger audience than me, which made it an easy read but also a bit outside my usual interests. However, I really enjoyed the focus on nature, especially the bond and relationship with the pony, as well as the presence of animals throughout the story

Amelie

Larkmead

Birdie by J.P. Rose is a really moving story about a girl in the 1950s who moves to a village where she isn't welcome. I liked how she bonded with a pit pony named Mr Duke because they both felt alone. It’s sad to see the racism she faces, but it’s inspiring to watch her fight to save her friend. It’s a great read if you like historical books that feel real.

Isabel

Vista Academy Littleport

Fantastic book in overall. I just realised this was a real experience for the author and reflected her life experience, making it more emotional and relatable. It still lacked some emotion and required a bit more depth to attach to the characters. Though I did enjoy the journey (and how they vividly express Birdie’s curious and somewhat stubborn character), the ending was a bit rough and felt like an average children’s book ending. There isn’t any tension unrelieved at the end, it doesn’t make us question back to the end. Everyone basically is her ally. Yet, it’s still a good read and I would recommend to a younger audience. I enjoyed the introduction of the home for black kids and the slow build up of knowledge and realisation. I honestly disagree with people who say they do not enjoy because it seemed unrealistic on how Birdie doesn’t notice the difference in colour because it is shown in a child’s perspective and she was raised with people of same colour, she would be too young to understand and feel emotionally hurt. It’s like a young seed in a field of roses who doesn’t know it’s growing up to be a sunflower rather. Conversely, I didn’t enjoy the lack of emotional attachment to the characters nor the convenience of having someone helping her at any moment. Sometimes it would be better if she was helped by the pony or faints and wakes randomly, that way it would feel less realistic that there is a farm house going to save them. Yet again, the themes weren’t represented directly like in To Kill a Mockingbird, but rather, slowly and through a series of dangerous looks and confusion, which builds in her mind something is wrong about her, though she doesn’t understand why, perfectly representing how children who experience racism feel. Though this book is in the Carnegie medal shortlist (and is very interesting ) it’s not one of my top picks because I thought it should be more realistic. Not all of them have a happy, conclusive ending. Some continue being bullied and (unlike the priest) the other people may not help them in struggle, even if they’re religious figures. Overall, great (almost five stars for the first 3/4 of the book) book and definitely recommend to anyone who feels agitated or feels bullied, this book will help as the experiences are relatable. It is amazing for people who are unkind (like the bullies) or people who have been treated unkindly, like Birdie to realise everyone is the same and deserves to be loved.

Esa

Wetherby Prep Book Club

I thought that this book was very heartfelt and also extremely informative. The characters were each written very well and I enjoyed the main character's personality. A very good read that I would recommend to a lot of people!

Wilbur

NDHS Book Group

I enjoyed the book because of the links to animals. I didn't really understand some of the language because of the period in time it is set in, it obviously uses different language. Overall, I wouldn't normally read books like this but I really enjoyed this one. My favourite character was Mr. Duke obviously!

Claudia

Cottingham High School

This story is about a girl called Birdie who was invited to live with her aunt. As soon as she left her home town everything changed. She felt like no-one treated her fairly, only the kindest of people. Then she met Mr Duke her friend. After she met him, her life felt happier. Little did she know what was to come... This book teaches people that they belong here and it takes time to accept things, but it's ok. We should judge people on who they are, not what they look like.

Alice

Montsaye Shadow Readers

This was a wonderful read, filled with lots of memorable characters. I loved learning about the cared for children in the UK after the war. It was hard to read about the prejudice they faced and how they were treated by members of the community. I loved how the bond between Mr Duke and Birdie helped her through and how it mended the broken hearts of her aunt and uncle.

Shireen

Wetherby Prep Book Club

Birdie is a book about a girl who is an orphan and she moves in with her aunt but she faces problems such as racism and bullying. I enjoyed the book as it was very heart-touching and it really made me think more about friendships. It was definitely worth reading. This book was a ⅘ stars as, it has a good plot and a powerful message. I would recommend that anyone in school should read this book because it is about bullying and people could relate to this and it was intresting

huey

Glossopdale Readers

This book is quite enjoyable. I like how the author did an "Olden Day" sort of book, instead of "Modern Day". I also find that I enjoyed reading Birdie's backstory; it felt really sad, and I feel sorry for her. In general, this book was fun to read.

Amelia

Weald of Kent Grammar (Sevenoaks)

Birdie lived in an orphanage in Leeds with a lot of kids and Mrs Dudley. Then one day her aunt in Barrington Dale says she will look after Birdie. But people are mean to her in the new home but she makes new and unexpected friends. The main character was Birdie. I liked her character as she experienced a lot but keeps on pushing on. My favourite character was Mr Duke because he was very kind and I love horses too. I really enjoyed this book because I thought it was interesting and I liked the storyline. I also loved some of the cliff hanger bits of the story.

Evie

HHS 2026

I thought Birdie was a great read! The viewing of racism made if feel real as this was something many young kids and adults had to go through. I loved Mr.Duke, he was like a rock to birdie, helping her get through a difficult phase in her life but it could of been better if we had a little more information about birdies past and her friendship with Julie. Overall I really enjoined the book.

Imogen.H

Ousedale Olney

Birdie is a book about a girl who struggles to fit in and finds an unlikely friend in a pony. I enjoyed the plot of the book and I liked some of the characters. I also liked how Birdie had many friends with different types of friendships, I think they should have explored her relationships with them more though. Overall I thought the book was enjoyable but It isn’t the kind of book I would usually read. I would recommend this book to students around year 7 because it has quite simple language and a lighthearted story. I give this book a 2.5 out of 5.

Thea B

Glossopdale Readers

I was not a fan of this book because I felt that it was lacking any drama or interesting characters. However, I liked the connection between Birdie and Mr. Duke, the last pit pony in the abandoned mine. Overall, I think this book needs more danger and exciting cliff hangers. 6/10

Henry

The Fitzharrys Shadows

Birdie is such an amazing book with a touching story .

Inisija

Dunraven

I would rate birdie a 3/5 because I don't like the plot. I think the plot being the horse lives in the very last page of the book isn't the kind of plot I like. For example I would have liked it if it were to be spread across a chapter maybe two. I am also not a fan of the old language, I know it fits the scene but some of the key sentences don't make sense for someone like me who don't read old language books. It would have been nice if they had made a key. Also I would've liked it more if they hadn't spent so many chapters on birdie giving Mr Duke food. although these negative comments the one big thing that gives it this ok score is the message, showing that all people should treated the same is a very key message and I like that.

Arya

The Perse Carnegians

theme: historical fiction set in 1950's. I really like 'Birdie' as I thought it was a very happy, heart-warming book, not only about racism, but about people who live in less fortunate conditions. I really like the using of listing, often at the end of a chapter, for example, down, down, down and waiting, waiting. I also like Brian's character as he starts being unsure of Birdie, but then starts to like and accept her, and then ends up protecting her. Overall, it is a book on friendships, new communities and being accepted. I would rate it a 3.5/5.

Anya

Carnegivores

Birdie Bagshaw has never really known anyone but her mother in her life, who gave her up after she was born. But when she was sent to live with her great-aunt in Barrington Dale, a place based on mining, everything becomes different. The people there treats her differently and unkindly with suspicion, until she meets a pit pony, who she calls Mr Duke. Birdie eventually forms a bond with Mr Duke, but has to now try to save his life when the slaughterhouse comes to try and kill him. I really enjoyed this book because it helped me understand the cruelty that animals like Mr Duke were experiencing and these kind of things still happen today worldwide. My favourite character was Mr Duke because he was gentle, brave to rescue some of the men trapped in the mines and is friendly to Birdie.

Ibsan

The Perse Carnegians

I really don’t think this was the right book to tackle the issues it tried to. To start, the mix of old English and type dialect of the different places she was through the book made it quite a hard read. There’s a lot of repetition. I don’t think I’ve ever read the words ‘any road’ so many times in one sitting and every time a character cried, they ‘burst into tears’. I also found it quite hard to like Birdie and relate to her despite also being a mixed race girl and I found her quite annoying. Furthermore, the plot line of her, her new family, the village and the racism she experienced could have been a completely separate book to the one of her and the pony. Also, it’s wildly unrealistic to have half the town suddenly change a deeply rooted belief that’s likely been with them since childhood overnight because of a simple note at the end of a sermon, and then for the other half to follow along at the end of the book which completely ruined the opportunity for a message about how hard it was and how long it took for racist beliefs to have declined so much to where they are today. Lots of sentences felt clunky or poorly written and should have been edited like “she kneeled up onto her knees” or “he pushed up his cap with his thumb which he always wore” - just things that ruin the flow and make you have to read it again. Back to the plot: the ending felt extremely rushed. All the problems of her grief, the pony and racism were solved in practically one page. Lastly, I already mentioned the missed opportunity of a message about racism but I also think it missed lots more along the way: overcoming grief (both that of her and her aunt and uncle seemed solved instantly (in Birdie’s case by finding Mr.Duke again and in the other by taking in Birdie) and how actions have consequences. None of her poor decisions (and there were many) made much of a lasting impact which makes the ending, in my opinion, too happy and too resolved almost. To conclude, I was left very much disappointed by this book.

Georgia

WSFG Carnegies Shadowers

Birdie by J.P. Rose is a coming-of-age story about identity and figuring out where you fit in. It follows Birdie as they deal with school, friendships, and their own thoughts, which made it feel pretty realistic to me. One of the main ideas in the book is the struggle between being yourself and trying to fit in, which I think a lot of people can relate to. I also liked how the friendships weren’t perfect—they change over time and sometimes become complicated, which felt true to real life. Birdie felt like a genuine person, although I think some of the side characters could have been developed a bit more. The writing is simple and easy to read, which made it accessible, but at times the story felt a bit slow since there weren’t many big events happening. Still, I didn’t mind it too much because it focuses more on Birdie’s thoughts and experiences. Overall, I think it’s a meaningful and relatable book, especially if you enjoy character-focused stories. I’d give it around an 8/10.

Srishti

HGS Book Club

This was a really good book and I really got into reading it. The only bad thing about the book is that its written in old English. I already have trauma from doing Shakespeare books for my English. Still, I really think people need to read this at least once in their lifetime. The book is a bit childish though.

Kenul

Folkestone Academy Readers

Having read all four of the shorter books, this one was not my favourite. I'm going to be very harsh towards Birdie but she needs to get over things. She cried 17 times in the book. She cried because of the word different was said around her and she even went into a two-day sulk after someone said she was brown. Don't get me wrong, the plot of her moving away and growing up around white people and overcoming adversity is great. She just needs to stop being a cry baby. Okay book. 6/10

sam w

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Horse. Birdie started out with promise. It approached the problem of racism in the 50's in a good way. Birdie began to become accepted, have people see her for more than her skin - she began to have friends, family, began to belong... ...and then she threw it all away for a horse. I don't think I've been that disappointed in a book. It felt like they'd built up these really meanginful concepts and then tossed them aside.

Hanzalah

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie is such a breath of fresh air, a passionate and optimistic child blown into many people's lives, and an innocent surrounded by prejudice and judgement. Of course, everything does catch up with her and then a different sort of adventure with a downtrodden pit pony begins. I could not put the book down. Birdie has a positive impact on everyone about her and this is a delightful story through which real life issues of 1950s Britain are tackled.

Mrs Jones

GODOLPHIN

Very good, but I would like to see more of the characters in the village, more of the orphanage and Ms Dudley. I think the storyline is very good.

natalie

Hayes Bookstops

This is a book called Birdie by J.P Rose. Birdie was a good book about a girl who gets a new family and finds a mine which she then finds a horse which she then falls in love. She struggles with school life because she has a different skin colour. Thanks to her great aunt she manages to get through her tough time.

Musa

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie is a nice story about kindness with topics like adapting to change and belonging. It is set in a village in a rural part of Yorkshire. Previously, she lived south in a care home for people of colour before receiving a letter from her great aunt who doesn't know what she looks like telling her to come and live with her and her husband in a mining village in the middle of Yorkshire. I really liked the middle of the book, especially when you find out about the mine when she and her great uncle go looking down the mine to see Mr Duke. I also liked the ending with the explosion and Birdie thinks Mr Duke has died when he actually has not. Overall I liked the book but I think it was for under my age group.

JULIA

Diary of a Wally Kid

This was an interesting story from the point of view of a young orphan who has just moved in with her aunt. At the start of the book we are not aware what she looks like or what her situation is until we see how others react upon meeting her. I really enjoyed this technique as it showed how prejudice and racist some people are without even knowing that they are and how it makes the person they are being mean to feel. The plot followed the relationship between a girl and a horse she met and is trying to save from being put down as he is old. I feel that it accurately represents the relationship and bond between a young person and any animal. It had a interesting story line even if it was a bit young for me. I would recommend this book to someone who is looking for a fun, heartfelt story.

Kate

Diary of a Wally Kid

'Birdie' is a story about a young girl who reluctantly leaves her foster family to pursue her family in the Yorkshire Dales. However, along the way, the book takes an unanticipated turn when she encounters an unexpected friend. This book had a good plot full of friendship, challenges, animal love and the authors very clever way of introducing themes of racism to a younger audience in a way that they can easily understand and process. I believe this book will appeal to children aged 6-9.

Noa

Diary of a Wally Kid

I loved Birdie! It was TOTALLY AMAZING, I loved the dialect and way it was written. I also enjoyed the loving way Birdie looked after Mr Duke. It's not a book I'd normally read, but I enjoyed it immensely.

Sherlin

Crypt Bookworms

I thought that this book was very moving and shows the importance of companionship and care. It also contains a varied and interesting plot which makes the book fascinating to read and and certainly a good book. I also think that it helps to show that everyone is equal and has the same respect despite having different backgrounds or cultural heritages. I would recommend this book to an animal lover or someone who likes slow calm books.

Pyrros

NDHS Book Group

I think the book Birdie was a good historical fiction. Her longing for a family lead her to stay with her Great Aunt in the countryside, moving away from her orphanage in Leeds to explore a new life in the countryside. She faces bullying, and is chased down to a coal mine, where she finds a pony. Overall, it was a very good read, the bond between Birdie and and Mr Duke very touching, and well written. I think the book was enjoyable and eye opening as well, as it shows the crueller aspects of bullying, and helps deter it.

Shi Ying

HGS Book Club

I definitely underestimated this book, it was better than I thought it would be. I found the plot interesting and fast paced. But I didn't really connect with the characters. The struggling-to-breathe scene in the coal mine confused me, at first, but after looking up the canary tests, it made sense. The book features some post-war experience, since the story is set in 1952 and the ending is bittersweet. I recommend this book for 9+ and animal/historical fiction lovers.

Isla

Ousedale Shadow Chasers

Children all over the country will be excited to meet the strong, independent protagonist in this tale of friendship. Birdie has always lived at Fitzwilliam’s Children’s Home in Leeds but, now, she must leave her beloved Mrs Dudley for a new start in rural Yorkshire, changing the lives of her Great Aunt Mabel and Uncle Walter at the same time. As a young girl of colour, Birdie Bagshaw was abandoned by her mother in the local church. But when her great aunt sends a letter asking to take custody of her, Birdie jumps at the chance to have a family. Little does she know that, in the village of Barrington Dale, life won’t be quite what she hoped for. Upon her arrival, Birdie is baffled by the disapproving looks she receives. Experiencing prejudice for the first time, she is bullied for her appearance and talked about behind her back. Despite these challenges, Birdie remains true to herself, treating everyone she meets with kindness and generosity. Eventually, she finds a friend in an unexpected place: a pit pony, Mr Duke. When she discovers that he is being taken to his death, she sneaks down the mine and runs away with him. However, when she hears about a pair of trapped miners, she knows she must risk returning to save them. Birdie’s bravery and unrelenting resilience serve as a reminder that character is more than skin deep. This heart-warming story is perfect for all readers, particularly fans of historical fiction.

Toby

Bookwizards

Birdie is an amazing book, which makes the reader explore nature and the bond between a girl and a horse. The story is about a young girl called Birdie, who is sent to her greant-aunt's house in Yorkshire Dales. Since the beginning, Birdie is treated like a stranger, an outsider, someone who she felt did not belong there. One day, she is bullied by children, and is forced to hide near a coal mine, when she is surprisingly welcomed by a small and warm pony. The two of them immediately form an unbreakable bond, but soon, the pony is in danger. That is when Birdie comes up with an extremely dangerous and bold plan to save her new friend.

Diane

4Shadowers

Set in the Yorkshire dales, 1950s, Birdie Bagshaw never got to meet her parents. She always lived in a children's home for as long as she could remember. But out of nowhere she got sent to see her great aunt in Leeds. Away from everything she had ever known. When she got there, because of her mixed race, there was confused and worried faces everywhere. But while trying to fight off of the bullies Birdie finds on of the last pit pony and she tries to fight for it's life. This book wasn't one of my favourites, however it wasn't the worst. I like how Birdie is trying to save a pony because that shows how much she loves animals. (I can relate to that) It made me feel sad that she was discriminated against because of the colour of her skin.

Natalia

Vista Academy Littleport

I really liked this book. I enjoyed the storyline, and it has a strong meaning behind it. I was really happy that, in the end, Birdie was happy, and I liked the ending very much.

Kate

Rainbeau Readers

Theme: Historical Children’s Novel The story is set in the 1950s, about an 11 year old girl named Birdie that has lived in an orphanage for mixed race children in Leeds since she was little. Even though she loved the orphanage, she wanted a family of her own, and unexpectedly got a letter from her Great aunt to come live with her. Birdie left the bustling city of Leeds and everything she’d ever loved and known to the countryside of Barington Dale to live with her Great aunt that she’s never seen before. When she arrives Birdie wasn’t invited with a warm welcome as she expected. Everyone around her in the village, including her aunt, were treating her differently in a way that she didn’t quite understand. When Birdie was chased by a group of bullies towards a coal mine and she accidently went in, she discovered the most magnificent pony she’d ever seen. She goes on a mission to rescue the pit pony from the mine. I liked how the book created suspense of what may happen next. I also liked that Birdie was a kind and lovable character because the author expressed Birdie as a very animal-loving person, having strong emotions about the ones she cared deeply for. Although I loved the story, I didn’t like how Birdie was bullied and criticised a lot by many around her which made the book a bit harsh to read. Overall I quite enjoyed the book and I recommend it to children who want to understand the deep bonds people can make with animals, and to learn what it was like recovering from the impacts of the world war as it particularly impacted on the story.

Jethmi

Euro Champs

Birdie was a good book about a girl who gets a new family and finds a mine which she then finds a horse which she then falls in love. She struggles with school life because she has a different skin colour. But I did think that some of the emotions were forced and in pretty much every chapter was someone crying which made the book similar in places.

Joshua R

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I thought Birdie was a brilliantly written novel, with a very powerful message behind it. As the book progresses, you can see how Birdie changes through the novel as she discovers the hard truth of this world, that some people are treated differently to others. She doesn't accept this and fights to change it, which hopefully has and will inspire other discriminated groups to do the same. The book also talks about friendships and fighting for the people you love, whether that's saving them from the knackers yard or just when you've got a friend in a race, so your screaming their name louder than anybody else just so they can hear your voice and keep pushing. Finally, it talks about not dwelling on the past, enjoying life, not thinking about what you missed out on, what mistakes you make, and how much you miss someone. Any road you should read Birdie Bagshaw's story.

Emilio

Thomas Tallis Reads

I enjoyed ‘Birdie’ because I thought it was a really novel idea for a story. It is quite rare in books to have an animal that close to the main character, and it added a completely new perspective to the story. It also makes you really think about the consequences of war. Birdie is a great protagonist who shows the reader what self-belief and self-confidence can do to a person.

Eleanor

Shelf Indulgence by JCG

The book birdie has highlighted that being brutally stereotypical can hurt someone. Birdie is a very intresting book and i loved how her first and best friend was a horse named Mr Duke ( which i love by the way). The slow-burn in this book was so good and it had a lot of details in it. And I'm glad she had her happy ending.

Lily

PHS Book Explorers

Birdie is one of my favourite books that I have read ever. It carries so much emotion and sometimes people don’t realize how much words can mean if they will make you happy, joyful, or make you feel like you are not alone, but they can also make you feel sad. In this book it was a bit of both my favourite part was when they forced her out of the house to the turning on of the lights and so when she turns on the light then on the stage lies Mr Duke. It just is so wonderful to see how much an animal can even mean to a girl one who has a heart of gold. My favourite character is Birdie because she risked her life to save that pit pony, she is also very strong and resilient. I loved this book.

Linnea

Chapter Chats

Birdie is a perfect example of a wholesome YA novel, focusing on themes of racism and animal love.It is aimed at younger teenagers (10 to 11 year olds). It is not a particularly outstanding book and probably won't stick out to me for a long period of time. There are a few quite moving scenes, about the racism showed to the lovable main character, Birdie. Overall it is a good, but not great, wholesome book for young teenagers who want to get more into reading.

Alice

SMMA BOOKWORMS

In this book, it really did make me feel Birdie's sorrow in my heart and she is a very relatable character with realistic struggles and understandable mindset. I love her determination but she can be a bit hard headed and thick-skulled. Maybe a bit stubborn. Although the ending is a bit boring and happy go lucky. The fact that Mr Duke happened to be alive after surviving impossible circumstances is a bit anti-climatic. I wouldn't change anything about the book other than the ending.

Tasmia

Yardleians

The book Birdie was such an amazing and intriguing book because this was the kind of book that has an adventurous journey to it

Ramiee

Yardleians

amazing book. very nostalgic. remind me of my childhood books. its a little mysterious which piques my interest

Mui

Yardleians

I think the book was very interesting and unique, I think I would recommend this book to someone who loves animals and nature. If I had to rate this book, I would rate this book 3/5. This book is mainly about a young girl, who is abandoned by her mother when she was younger. Overall, I think I did enjoy this book.

Haleema

SHLA Carnegies Shadowing Group

The story follows Birdie, a young girl who was abandoned by her mother when Birdie was a baby meaning she couldn't understand and has no memories of ever having parents. Birdie is raised in Fitzwilliam's children's home where she is looked after by the Dudley’s, who treat her and the other children with as much love as if they were her parents. When she is 11 years old, her Great-Aunt Mabel asks to look after Birdie after searching for her. However when Birdie gets there she is treated like an outsider even from her Aunt. When she runs away from some older bullies, she finds herself lost and alone in the bottom of a coal mine with no seeming way out. She is then miraculously saved by a pit pony who leads her back to the exit. Birdie is then attached to the horse and when speaking to her Uncle Walter, who seems to be the only one who accepts her and likes her, she realises that the pony is probably never going to leave the mine and has been left by the miners because he is either weak, injured or old. Against the Aunt and Uncle’s objections Birdie sneaks down the mine to see who she calls “Mr Duke” and feeds him and looks after him. When Mr Duke’s life is at risk, Birdie realises she must save him just like he saved her at the start of her time in Barrington Dale. The book is fine and it is a nice effective way for all ages of readers to read about racism and to be educated against it but the language was too repetitive especially using triplets such as “down…down…down”. The metaphorical language consisting of the ladybirds, I found, was overused and unneeded. I really didn’t like it when it said “ladybird, ladybird! Rush, rush! Fly away home!”. This is because the ladybirds are often used when they are really not needed and was just annoying after a while as it was trying to hard to be deep when it really wasn’t and just seemed random, especially when they say “ watching as a group of tired-looking miners covered in coal dust trudged up the lane. She thought about her ladybirds again”. This felt pointless as it had nothing to do with the book. I would recommend it to people who enjoy books about war and ponies.

redhill

Redhill Readers

Birdie is an inspiring tale. I really like how bold and headstrong Birdie is as a character, and I think you can really see her personality shine through. Her friendship with Mr Duke was really heart warming and it was refreshing to see how adventurous and brave she was. I think it was hectic, and there were son many unexpected death scares that it got a bit convoluted. I found Birdie and Julie's friendship to be very touching and I really enjoyed watching Brian change for the better. However, I feel like the ending was quite rushed and all the action happened at the end. I also think Mr Duke had too many close calls and at some point it got a bit annoying.

Elliora

Cottingham High School

I loved this book! It is probably my favourite! A wonderful piece of writing, and I must admit I grew quite attached to Birdie and Mr Duke.

Evelyn

NDHS Book Group

Birdie is an amazing story about change, acceptance and empathy. The story was well written and kept me hooked throughout the story. Definitely a must read (especially if you love animals)!

Archie

Cottingham High School

I found the book boring and thought it wasnt my type of book but others may injoy it

Allie

Redhill Readers

A heartfelt tale which I quite enjoyed. This tale shows struggle and triumph and is a very good Carnegie book.

Charlotte

St Kaths

I found it boring. It's a typical bland children's story lacking basic elements of engagement. Unlike last year's Carnegies, these year's lacks uniqueness and creativity. The plot is very predictable, unsurprising and dry.

Mahad.k

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie is a book set around the 1950s in Yorkshire. It follows the story of a young girl who experiences unacceptance, due to the colour of her skin after leaving a childrens home to live with her great aunt. It explores themes of racism, identity and belonging. Personally, I like this book so far because of its emotional depth and how real the story feels, making it so i can imagine clearly how people at that time, both adults and children could feel. I would recommend this book to readers older and younger than me since i feel that Birdie is a great story with no limit for ages. I think that younger readers could benefit understanding of racism and feelings of belonging from Birdie's story. So i would say my overall rating of Birdie is 7/10.

simran

Xenial Readers of Rushey Mead 2026

'Birdie' is an amazing book. While keeping the beautiful friendship between Birdie and Mr. Duke, Rose also keeps a clear focus on the blatant racism, making for a heart-wrenching story. She really shows life in Yorkshire at the time with the Great use of vernacular and the difficulties of the recent war in her writing.

Siya

KECHG Shadowers

Birdie is a powerful story set in 1950s Yorkshire. I loved the emotional bond between Birdie and the pit pony, Mr. Duke. The book deals with tough themes like racism and isolation, but it is also a beautiful "love letter to the North." It’s a moving read that shows how resilience can help you find where you truly belong.

Lojine

Lionheart2026

The book starts with a young girl in an orphanage, Birdie Bagshaw, who is about to go to Barrington Dale to live with her aunt, Mrs Winterbottom. But her time in Barrington Dale at first wasn't great, as she was bullied by most of the townspeople. They saw her as different, because of her skin colour. Then at school, the teacher also treated her differently, which led Birdie to run away and end up in the mines. While in the mines she met a pony, and it seemed as though she felt the pony understood her - she felt a connection with the pony, who she later named Mr Duke. She secretly visited him every so often after that, and she was happier when she was with him. It's an interesting story that shows that words can be harmful and effective. It was quite an easy read but intriguing as it shows Birdie's thoughts and feelings throughout the book. It had a nice happy ending as she was more accepted by the townspeople so she was happier living there. Although the world has changed in real life, people are still sometimes quite unkind, and this is quite a good reflection on that.

Alba

Euro Champs

Birdie Bagshaw is leaving Mrs Dudly and her friends at the orphanage to live with her great aunt and uncle in the country side. At first her aunt is not accepting of Birdie because of her colour but she softens quickly toward her. However, the villagers are not. When birdie is being chased by some school bullies she accidentally ran into a coal mine. Lost in the darkness, she finds a pit pony and it leads her to the exit. Despite how many times her was warned not to go in to the mines she keeps visiting the pony. So Mr Walter ( her great uncle) takes her to visit him safely there she names him Mr Duke. Later that week she meets Mr Spivy the Nackerman at her front door to remove or clear animals dying,dead or injured. She over hears Mr Walter and his conversation. Upset, she takes action immediately. My favorite part was when birdie meets Mr Duke because it shows how kind animals can be . I would recommend this book to people who like animals or history.

Ailsa

Vista Academy Littleport

I really liked Birdie but it took me a while to get into. Other than that it was amazing.

Miriam

Dunraven

I really enjoyed this book because it showed the joy of the relationship between a person and a horse developing over time.

Aurelia

Rainbeau Readers

I really enjoyed reading birdie! I loved how all of the characters were portrayed and the variety of themes. Would absolutely recommend to anyone who likes historical fiction.

Heidi

Carmel Shadowers

'Birdie' is a good book. The writer encompasses life on the Yorkshire Moors well and shows the weirdness of being placed in the middle of a different culture. It also shows a child learning to understand what is different about her, though by far my favourite part is how she thinks of her mother and what a child's mind will do to those they have never known, but still idolise. 6/10 would recommend to those who like animals.

Grace

KES Readers

Birdie’s story is an emotional rollercoaster. I was heartbroken to read about this lively, spirited girl becoming the victim of unashamed racism - particularly when even her teacher denies her an education because of prejudice. The parallel drawn with the pit pony is especially poignant and deeply affecting. At the same time, it is heartwarming to watch Birdie win people over through her courage, resilience, and grace. Both sad and happy tears were shed.

Celine

Sandroyd Bookivores

In this book we see Birdies experience of finding her new home and making friends such as a pony- Mr Duke. The book explores Birdies feelings of being excluded and different and also as she eventually becomes accepted and finds her home. Mr Duke contributes greatly to the book and the strong relationship between human and animal creates a compelling story of friendship for the reader.

Deshna

The Tiffin Girls’ Shadows

This is a beautiful book about a heart warming friendship between human and horse. I found it both knowledgeable and realistic, using language to display the period of time it is set in. I really enjoyed reading Birdie and found that I couldn't put it down!

Maya

St Kaths

This was a lovely book that managed to portray the distinct racial injustice present in the 1950s whilst blending hope and realisation that everyone is equal in the story. The characterisation of Birdie and her unique views are really interesting, especially how she couldn't understand how she was different from everyone in the beginning. I believe this a powerful statement the author is making and that the whole book was enjoyable. The way Birdie manages to sway the people of Barrington Dale truly shows it doesn't matter what you look like.

Isabel

NDHS Book Group

Such an amazing book! I loved the story and all the characters and their different personalities and how an important topic can be taught through a wonderful story of friendship and also a history lesson! I would definitely recommend this book to any readers who love stories about animals and friendship with some important lessons!

Alex

The Mockingjays

I love The Book, Birdie, The theme and settings of this book are pretty good, I like the setting because it was set in 1950s after world war 2 and the theme of this shorlist book is about identify, belonging, empathy, children's home, animals and many more! The character that i love in this book is birdie bagshaw and mrs dudley, i totally recommend this with the people who wants to know what is it to live at 1950s in u.k., the diverse people who wants to read this book and i hope everyone picks this book because the characters are pretty good, the settings, and the themes are good!

Filip

9y4

I love Birdie! The author uses great imagery and I also enjoy how she writes the story in Old English.

Marwa

Dunraven

I am a big animal lover and think this books writing is really nice. I would totally recommend it to lots of my friends.

Sage

Lit Legends of Swavesey

Birdie was an enjoyable read, the setting was well written as were the characters. The book follows the story of Birdie Bagshaw who was put in an orphanage after being abandoned by her mother and later on adopted by her great-aunt. Her aunt lived in the countryside where everyone treated her differently leaving Birdie feeling alone. One day however, she goes to the mines where she befriend a pony ( Mr Duke). The book was a great read and I liked how it showed Birdie coming over her struggles.

Libby

Vista Academy Littleport

This book is great. I really like how it explored some topics I don't often find books, about racism in the past and the life of a mine pony. I really liked how all the characters were portrayed. Highly recommend.

Zoë

Skipton Shadows

I quite liked this book due to the deep connection between Birdie and the pony she befriends . I believe that a relationship between a human and an animal has an almost greater bond than one with another human as it requires a deeper emotional understanding of one and other . This is what I enjoyed about this book and also how over time the theme of beonging was enhanced as the main character herself fitted in more . This was a nice book but I found it a bit of a slow read and for those who enjoy faster paced books over heartwarming ones it would not be my top pick .

Layla

The Tiffin Girls’ Shadows

Birdie had me hooked from the start. She is a well written character who immediately inspires connection and empathy in the reader. The description of her new life in the dales brought the book to life and I felt I was there. Birdie's emergent understanding of why the adults have reacted so strangely to her through the sudden exposure to the open racism of children in the village highlights the shocking cruelty of prejudice from the victim's perspective. The story and characters reminded me of Anne of Green Gables - a book I loved as a young girl - Birdie brought that sense of nostalgia and exploration of belonging. A beautiful piece of storytelling.

Ms Devine

Booky Wookies

Birdie was a nice book. I enjoyed the setting because I love war/post-war books. My favourite character was Julie who is Birdie's neighbour when she moves to Barrington Dale. She was a great supportive friend to Birdie. Her rebelling against her father's racism towards Birdie was really sweet as well. The scene between Birdie and her Aunt Mabel where her aunt opens up about why she was cold to Birdie and telling her about her mother was my favourite. Overall, the book was enjoyable with everyone warming to Birdie especially at the end when she came back with her pony, Mr Duke. However, I feel as if conflicts were gotten over too quickly. People were just warned once and then it was fixed. I felt that was a bit unrealistic but other than that, Birdie was a good book. Not my favourite, but still nice.

Valentina

Chiswick Carnegie

Birdie's character is so unique, she talks sooooo much but it fills her role properly, she's also smart and courageous making this a lovely read.

Isabelle

SCD Pageturners

I love how this book shows how much animals can hep us adapt to changes, like Birdie and Mr Duke. he is such a sweet pony!

Hannah

SCD Pageturners

I thought this book was really well written and it had the best storyline of a bond between horse and human. This is one of the best books I've read and I loved reading it!!

Nadia

St Kaths

Birdie lived in an orphanage in Leeds with a lot of kids and Mrs Dudley. Then one day her aunt in Barrington Dale says she will look after Birdie. But people are mean to her in the new home but she makes new and unexpected friends. The main character was Birdie. I liked her character as she has experienced a lot but keeps on pushing on. My favourite character was Mr Duke because he was very kind and I love horses. I really enjoyed this book because I thought it was interesting I liked the storyline. I also loved some of the cliff hangers in bits of the story.

Evie

HHS 2026

Birdie is a book that talks about a black girl who is adopted by her great aunt and uncle. She is treated like an animal and to her it felt like no one wanted her other than one pony. Every week she would escape school to go down the mines to see it as she felt that it had been abandoned. Birdie saw herself in its situation. I quite liked this book and think its themes can appeal to a large range of audience because, firstly, it is a well written book and, secondly, it contains a lot of good moral themes like “treat people for who they are on the inside”. I loved watching Birdie slowly get accepted after apology after apology and thought that the author did an especially good job at making Aunt Mabel come out to Birdie. The only downside of this book was when Birdie thought Mr Duke was going to die. This is a common thing that happens in books; characters are just about to do what they wanted but then, suddenly, the character is dying. This often brings out a lot of emotion in a reader (this happened to me in a book called I am Rebel) but I don’t think the author executed it perfectly because, firstly, I personally didn’t see the bond with Birdie and Mr Duke grow throughout the story and it was more that Birdie liked him instantly, and, secondly, the scene felt a little rushed to me because it all happened very suddenly and he was saved by someone we don’t really know. Overall, I still enjoyed this book very much and hope others will too.

Hal L

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie by J.P Rose is a fascinating historic novel evolving around the life in a mining village and delves deep into animal use in the mines. The story comes from the point of view of Birdie Bagshaw , a trailblazer of a girl who moves to her aunts house after living in a children’s home most of her life. She hopes for a new start but instead faces unkind behaviour because of how she looks. Birdie doesn’t initially understand why people treat her differently, which makes the discrimination she faces even more upsetting for the reader. However, the novel balances these difficult themes with hope and resilience. She is brave, kindhearted and pure joy. After venturing into the old mine shaft, she comes across the most extraordinary thing. A beautiful horse. A pit pony She develops a close friendship with him and names him Mr Duke. Their relationship is filled with beautiful mischief. Their connection grows stronger and is a source of comfort even when Mr Dukes future is threatened. The book is written very clearly and the historical writing is really well written. I loved this book because I believe it really centres on that you can find friendship and kindness anywhere, even in the most unusual places. The story is a very memorable one and leaves happy lasting impacts.

Maggie

Helkats & Hardbacks

This in a heartwarming book that is all about accepting people's differences and treating others equally. I really liked the character Birdie and enjoyed following her in this story as she is just a fun, quirky character and it is an easy read. I would recommend this book to 10-14 year olds as it is a younger read but does touch on some important topics. The author did a great job writing this and made it very easy to read and follow, whilst understanding what is going on. Overall, great read and I hugely recommend.

Amelia M

Skipton Shadows

This novel is a story about a little orphan named Birdie who moves to live with her great-aunt in Barrington Dale, where she is not given the warmest of welcomes. At school, she is the subject of shocking racism and feels like an outsider to both the students at school and her great-aunt. When she tries to run away from some cruel boys, she meets for the first time the last remaining pit pony: Mr Duke, her future best friend, for who she will do whatever it takes to protect him. Birdie is a heartfelt, moving story that I particularly enjoyed because my happy place is also alongside horses, they are so understanding and kind. The complicit friendship between Mr Duke and Birdie described in this book is filled with trust, loyalty and love, proving that some animal-horse friendships can sometimes be stronger than anything. Both beings give each other the strength to overcome the numerous difficulties in life, and I find that beautiful. In conclusion, I really appreciated reading this wonderful novel, and I really hope it wins the Carnegie Shadower's award! Thank you J.P Rose for giving us this great reading opportunity! Erin Livia Boutrif 4e - 4Shadowers

Erin

4Shadowers

We rate Birdie 4 🌟The plot was good and we enjoyed reading it.

Tilly & Olivia

Bramcote College Library

Birdie was a very good book!!! Its very exciting but it is also very well written!! ❤❤

Emma

Dunraven

Birdie is a brilliant book I really recommend it. It's about a girl called Birdie (the main character) and her friend thats a pony. In this book she feels a roller coaster of emotions and experiences racism before she even recognised what that is. The author wrote it really well and I really recommend it.

Arietty

The Shady Bookhounds

I really liked this book as it showed what it was like in the past, and how the main character showed careness to the horse when others couldn't. This would be a perfect book for readers aged 9 or older who love animals (especially horses), and would do anything to protect them and show their love for them.

Tarja

GreatB00ks

Birdie is a well researched and touching tale set in a post war Yorkshire mining community. A young girl, Birdie, is trying to find her way in a new community, whilst navigating new friendships, fighting racism and prejudice, along with demonstrating unwavering loyalty and compassion to a pit pony named Mr Duke. Birdie also fights to discover more about her family heritage and the sense of understanding this brings her. A thought provoking and moving read.

Sue

Central Teen Reading Group

“Birdie” is an interesting read with a well written setting and pretty good characters. I thought that the quality of the writing was very good, as well as some of the descriptive devices. The beginning of the book discussed some details about Birdie’s life but didn’t reveal all her character development. As the story progresses, the reader learns more about Birdie’s life, as well as further details about her life. The middle was interesting; it felt a little bit cliché, but it still made sense in the time-period it was set in. It is in this part of the book where the characters really start to feel alive and real. I thought that the ending was a bit too good – all the loose ends were tied up – because I prefer books that still have open ends (small ones). Throughout the book, I was dreading a certain moment, and I wished that I wasn’t as the overview of each of the books contained a fairly big spoiler for “Birdie”, which ruined part of the story for me. Overall, solid writing, good description and only slightly cliché with some of the arcs in the book. 7/10

Thomas

Hope Valley Literati

This book is about a girl called Birdie, whose mum left her and she was put in a orphanage. Then one day her aunt reached out and adopted her. When she got there everyone treated her differently. One day Birdie went down in the mines and found a pony. Over time they became best friends. But her uncle said she couldn’t visit him anymore. One of my favourite parts of the book is where she first discovers the pony and she straight away knew they would become best friends. Overall I found this book a really fun and interesting book, and I would recommend to other readers.

Summer

Vista Academy Littleport

Birdie by J. P Rose is a powerful and profound book about a mixed race girl who battles racism and life in foster care. There are key themes in the book like identity, racism, resilience and friendship. the book focuses on the challenges black children had to face in the 1950s which I found educating since most people are not taught about the discrimination and prejudice black chlidren faced.

Mazin

Elms Shadowing 2026

Birdie is a book that I overall enjoyed. I was able to understand Birdie's struggles; her difficulty to fit in and her frustration with the unfair beliefs of the people in her village. I was constantly moving between different emotions as Birdie interacted with other characters going from frustration to relief along with her. She is a lovable character and her childlike loyalty to her friend Mr Duke was heart warming and sweet. My only critique would be that I would have liked more of Birdie's worries to be explored, as during a conversation with her aunt we learn that Birdie was worried that her mother did not want her. I would have liked that worry to have been explored more beforehand as it came as a shock to me that Birdie was worried about that. But overall it was a very enjoyable book.

Genevieve

Elms Shadowing 2026

I found it okay to read. I liked how it gave me an insight on how it was after ww2 and its mature themes of racism made it feel more real or fleshed out as a story. I found it a bit hard to read overall just because its not particularly interesting to me in comparison to the books i read, due to genre differences. It wasn't bad, just not for me. I think a lot of people will like it.

Amalia

Elms Shadowing 2026

Birdie is a book about a girl who lived in an orphanage after being sent to live in the countryside and finds a pit pony. The book focuses on the racism shown at the time the book is set. I liked how real the characters' emotions felt. I also liked how the book has a mix of action, emotional and happy scenes. The book focused on lots of different plot points which kept the story interesting. The only thing I didn’t like was the start of the book as it felt slow and a bit boring. Overall I really enjoyed this book because it is exciting and interesting.

Sophie

The Fitzharrys Shadows

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. The story follows a young girl, Birdie Bagshaw who goes from an orphanage to a countryside area to live with her aunt and uncle. After being “abandoned” by her mother when she was a baby, she always wished she could have a photo of her mother, who she believed was royal. When she moved, she faced a lot of racial discrimination, even from her aunt. When she got bullied at school and her teacher thought she was dumb, she ran to a mine. Trying to hide, she went into the lift and was transported underground. This was where she met a horse. Throughout the book, she tries to see him and feed him and always wished she could save the horse. She also makes amends with her family and the whole town, even a few friends. When she learns that the horse will be killed, she rescues him and ‘rides’ away from home with Mr Duke (the horse). However she comes back and - without any spoilers - uses the horse to save someone. My favourite part was the ending as she was with Mr Duke forever and she finally felt at home in the town.

Hana

HGS Book Club

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. The story follows a young girl, Birdie Bagshaw who goes from an orphanage to a countryside area to live with her aunt and uncle. After being “abandoned” by her mother when she was a baby, she always wished she could have a photo of her mother, who she believed was royal. When she moved, she faced a lot of racial discrimination, even from her aunt. When she got bullied at school and her teacher thought she was dumb, she ran to a mine. Trying to hide, she went into the lift and was transported underground. This was where she met a horse. Throughout the book, she tries to see him and feed him and always wished she could save the horse. She also makes amends with her family and the whole town, even a few friends. When she learns that the horse will be killed, she rescues him and ‘rides’ away from home with Mr Duke (the horse). However she comes back and - without any spoilers - uses the horse to save someone. My favourite part was the ending as she was with Mr Duke forever and she finally felt at home in the town.

Hana

HGS Book Club

I really enjoyed the book Birdie. It was an emotional tale of a girl who perseveres and shows determination even things get hard and she suffers. She finds company in different things (e.g the pit pony she's friends with) when everyone around her is ignoring her. It highlights to us how to find happiness even when times are hard. It really encouraged me to try harder to find good even when it's not apparent.

Japmeh

KECHG Shadowers

Birdie is a touching book that shows how racism is so wrong and how cruel some people could be towards animals and humans alike. It’s beautiful, and full of sensory imagery. Bought up in a children’s home, Birdie Bagshaw’s great aunt reached out to her and she moved to the fictional Yorkshire town of Barrington Dale. Birdie faces racism, which I don’t get, because just because someone looks different, doesn’t mean they’re any less of a person. Birdie found a friend in a pit pony, and while the book focuses primarily on their friendship, people become less mean as the book moves on. I loved reading it and it made me laugh, and cry. Definitely one of my favourites.

Kirsty

Vista Academy Littleport

Overall, Birdie is a very interesting and well-thought book that highlights the topic of dealing with prejudice and racism. Even when her family did not accept her, Birdie persevered and managed to change their attitude. The book also stresses the value of caring for each other. This is shown when Birdie doesn’t stop caring for the pony and even when the pony is very ill and about to die, she does not give up on trying to get help. The description of the ‘raincloud over the village’ and the families’ discussions about their loved ones who had died in the war was fascinating. I enjoyed this novel a lot; the idea behind it is very original.

Sotiris

The Perse Carnegians

“Birdie” is a heart-warming, moving and beautiful story, as Birdie struggles through a world not yet ready for her. I found it easy to empathise with her, as she risks everything to protect what she holds dear and is even willing to put her life on the line for the freedom of a pit pony who she feels a strong connection to. I also loved the shift in outlook expressed by Mrs Winterbottom, as she realises that the fear of putting a foot wrong in society and being shunned socially is worth a lot less than caring for a young and lovely member of her family who desperately needs a loving home. I also loved how it highlights and brings awareness to the subject of old mines and what the pit ponies were put through. and the horrific and perilous conditions in the pits. A truly poignant yet captivating read. Highly recommended.

Alexandra

Shelf Indulgence by JCG

Birdie by J.P. Rose is an emotional story about the friendship between a lonely pit pony and a black British girl in Yorkshire. Although the main subject is their relationship, the book also highlights the issues black people faced in the country at the time. It is an amazing read for animal lovers, especially as the pony seems to understand everything Birdie Bagshaw says to him. At first, Birdie's great-aunt is unhelpful, telling her not to visit the pony, but accepts Birdie's choices later on. I would recommend it to anyone who likes animals and family-related stories.

Ruben

Euro Champs

I enjoyed Birdie as it reflects the author which explains why the book is so well-written andin detail. I would recommend it to animal-lovers or people that had some problems to adjust with society.

Félix

4Shadowers

Birdie is a good book about an orphan girl who moves to Yorkshire with her great aunt & uncle, where she is treated differently because of her skin colour. Then she meets a pit pony that saves her life when she gets lost in a mine. I think Birdie has good messages and they are well conveyed. Overall I would give this book a 10 out of 10.

alfie c

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This was an excellent book. I found the issues it discussed around mixed-race children post WW2 and conditions in mines, particularly for animals, really interesting but also quite challenging to read at times as I felt strongly the injustice of it all - particularly as Birdie and Mr. Duke were such wonderfully written characters. Their kindness and strength, despite the hardships that they faced, were admirable and it made for an incredibly heartwarming and inspiring story.

Hannah

AB Everyone Reading

"Birdie" is a wonderful book. The characters are some of the most thought-provoking and well imagined that I have ever read about. The story also tackles the important themes of racism, loss and hopelessness in a way that reflects upon the innocence of the character "Birdie" in such a beautiful way. The book was written in such a manner that keeps you enthralled right to the end of the chapter - and then the next, and the next and so on. I just could not put this book down. Perfect for horse-lovers, and by the end of this book I think anyone who reads it would be one.

Ivo

The Shady Bookhounds

Birdie is a book about a black girl sent away to a small village to live with her Aunt Mabel, but finds that, to start with, she is discriminated and bullied, as would have been the case for people in a similar position to her in the 1950s. 'Mr Duke' the horse acts as Birdie's best friend in a time that she is feeling left out by everyone, and leads her to the dangerous mines and determines the main plot twist of the book. I like the storyline and the themes of friendship and everyone being friends again, however I found the book hard to read at times because of the use of words like 'thee' and 'thou' that I'd associate with medieval english, not with a post-war village. Overall, I would rate this book 3/5.

Felix C

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Emotional story about how people were racist even to kids, and the tough conditions horses in the mines survived. While also showing that the most unlikely people can become friends.

Julia

Reepham Reads

This was an excellent book, 5/5. During the book Birdie has to overcome many challenges and being treated badly by the people around her.

Mark

Bassingbourn Readers

I enjoyed reading Birdie because the main character Birdie is very courageous even when she is isolated by the rest of the people living in Barrington Dale just because she doesn't look like them. I also admire her kindness towards other people and her ability to forgive people who have upset her. She also had faith in her new friend Mr Duke the pit pony , even when they bad to overcome difficult challenges. However I did not like how at first her Great Aunt refused to accept her even when Birdie had done nothing wrong. Overall I also liked that you learn from the book what life was like at the Yorkshire Dales in the 1950's and how racism had a massive effect on the rules of how you were supposed to live and behave at the time .

Olivia

Bassingbourn Readers

This book follows the story of Birdie Bagshaw, who has lived in an orphanage her whole life. She moves to Barrington Dale to live with her great aunt and befriends a pit pony who she later names Mr Duke. I liked this book in the sense that it showed Birdie growing as a character as well as the deeper message about friendship and overcoming racism. However because the book is aimed at slightly younger readers, I got bored in some parts. I felt like sometimes what would happen next in the story was quite predictable, but overall I quite liked this - it gives readers a powerful message about fitting in and finding friendship.

Emma

Vista Academy Littleport

Birdie is such a beautiful book. It is about a determined and loyal girl named Birdie Bagshaw who lives in a children’s home. She then goes to live with her great aunt and uncle, Mabel and Walter. Birdie suffers prejudice and discrimination because of the colour of her skin. When the school’s bullying drives her away, she discovers the mine and the most beautiful pony she has ever seen. She endures an incredible journey with the pit pony throughout the story and discovers the truth about her mother and her great aunt and uncle. Overall, J P Rose has very successfully created an astounding story.

Erica

Folkestone Academy Readers

When Birdie moves to Barrington Dale with her great aunt she is an immediate target for bullies in her village and at her new school , but when she meets a horse down in the coal mines she forms a special bond with it . The book did well at showing how Birdie overcame her struggles and persisted even when times were tough and I also enjoyed how the relationship developed between Birdie and her great aunt . The book was very slow moving and nothing too exciting happened until the last few chapters but it had a good strong and sweet ending . The eye dialect ( when things are written as they are spoken ) was a little hard to get used to but overall it's probably not something I would read again however it was a good one time read . I would rate this 4/5 stars .

Holly

Vista Academy Littleport

Animal lovers will like this book, and so will people who like stories set in the past. It had a confident storyline with plenty of twists and turns, although at times these were a little predictable. This book effectively portrayed racism in the 1950 sensitively and well. I would rate this book 3/5 stars.

Lottie

Beacon Thursday Book Club

"Birdie" is an enjoyable book which I feel tries to tackle too many problems at once leaving each commentary feeling quite sparse with conviction. I felt the main idea of belonging and changing people's assumptions was well thought-out and very moving. However, I did find the pace of the book a bit unusual and I felt the ending was a bit too "perfect" for my liking. However, overall it is a well-written book which I feel tries to tackle too much at once.

Benjamin R

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I found Birdie to be a haunting read that stayed with me long after I finished the final page. J.P. Rose dragged me right onto the bleak Yorkshire Moors, and I could practically feel the chill of the mist as Birdie returned to face her family’s dark history. What struck me most was the blurred line between reality and folklore. I loved how the "curse" felt like a physical weight on the characters, making me question if the danger was supernatural or rooted in deep-seated trauma. It’s a well-written, atmospheric mystery that kept me guessing—a perfect pick for anyone who loves a "Gothic Noir" vibe!

Mr Donnelly

MCM Shell Readers

I have really enjoyed Birdie and I think it is a really interesting book that portrays what life was like in the Yorkshire dales in the 1950s. The start was nice as it got straight into it and really interested you which some authors haven't managed to do in the first chapter. The theme through out the book was also very nice as it helped teach you about important topics like racism respect and empathy. Finally I really liked the attention to detail as it allowed me to connect with the characters and go,'yeah I do that,'or,'that's what happens to me.' Therefore overall I think this was an amazing book.

James

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

If you like stories about heroines challenging racism, untold truths and the hidden resilience of pit-ponies and an old English setting (that also includes old language like "thee" or "thou") to fascinate your imagination with, then Birdie is definitely your cup of tea with a slice of parkin cake. I love how Birdie, the protagonist, fights the stereotypes of her forced new life in the fictional 'Barrington Dale' and has to persevere when she is treated with disrespect for how she looks, for example when a group of boys bully her in only her first few days of arrival, saying, "look at the state of thy hair" or "does your colour wash off?" And other racist comments like these which made me so furious at the characters, sometimes I didn’t even want to read any more! This is such an empowering book about a topic that also links to schoolwork, and it is good to find an interesting story that delves into untold details about England's coal mining history. Furthermore, I adore how J.P. Rose included an extra 'History Note' at the end to show how the book Birdie was based off of true stories, including some of her own. So, I rate Birdie 8/10!

Mae

Helkats & Hardbacks

Loved the book! The story was so thrilling to read. I loved the ending it was very belivible and so engaging. Made me want to read more.

Hollie

St Kaths

Birdie is a heartwarming story of the connection between a girl and a pony. The trust in their relationship is beautiful and inspiring. I find that their reliance on each other emphasises the problems that each of them face- Mr Duke's exploitation as a pit pony and Birdie's experience with being abandoned and facing discrimination. I'm happy for Birdie as she finally gets a family of her own and her pathway to it seemed realistic. However, it almost seems as if Mr Duke is brought back from the dead just to create a happy ever after whereas in reality this is rarely the case. I feel like it would have made the book more memorable and emphasised its meaning if Mr Duke died -not to say that I didnt like Mr Duke; it just adds more emotion to the novel. I also liked the charecter of Mr Walter as well as the use of old english in words like 'thee', which made the book more interesting and really tied in with the context but was still understandable.

Emaan

Carnegie Shadow Judges MEAC

The book Birdie is perfect for anyone who is looking for an enjoyable read as it covers adventure, identity, courage, and suspense which keeps an entertaining rhythm. Birdie’s quick connection with a pit pony when she runs into a mine after being discriminated against gives deep a resemblance to all children who were once misunderstood. Birdie goes on an unimaginable adventure with bullies, friends and daring escapes which makes us adore her defiant nature even more. The changing setting and introduction to new characters kept me hooked and the dramatic turns made this more interesting. The historical language was quite enjoyable, and the context about pit ponies and olden time Britain informed without becoming boring. The ending is uplifting and gave hope for the town of Barrington Dale as well as Birdie’s character. Her resilience and empathy inspired me especially as her character seems to be a young girl who is often troubled and misunderstood. I would have enjoyed it more, however, if the new setting had been more explored, especially since it would not be similar to day-to-day towns with mines and different styled buildings etc. The escape near the end also seemed quite out of character, as, despite her repeated tears, she seemed mature through easy understanding of her situation and the ability to make her own, uninfluenced choices. Despite this, Birdie was an enjoyable read and left me thinking about it long after I had finished.

Meerab

Carnegie Shadow Judges MEAC

I loved this book. From the character developments to the strong friendship between human and animal. The author perfectly writes about the hardship of surviving constant discrimination and racism, yet at the same time slowly adds character development with the small yet kind actions of the main character Birdie. The strong bond that Birdie and Mr Duke really makes you appreciate how those two have each others back, protecting each other when one of them was in danger.

Alisha (O)

LSST Library Shadowers

Birdie has a great story line that covers part of our history that we get to learn very little about in school I loved the interaction between characters and the use of how they spoke to display the time period.

Henry

St Kaths

I found Birdie a really interesting read. I thought the themes and messages around racism and feeling accepted were conveyed very well in a book that would appeal to younger readers that may not be able to cope with books that convey these same messages in a more adult fashion This meant in parts the book did seem to be clearly targeted towards younger readers than myself, which slightly hindered my enjoyment and investment in the book, however I think the younger me would have found this a much more exciting and meaningful read, and I think it is a great novel for its target audience.

Freya

The Maynard School

Birdie by J. P. Rose Birdie is a historical fiction about a girl named Birdie Bagshaw who is living in a children’s home for “brown babies,” as said at the end of the book, and is sent to go live with her great-aunt, Mabel Winterbottom, in the Yorkshire Dales. She meets a pit-pony in a coal mine after running into the forest from being bullied and forms a strong bond with the pony. My opinion on this book was that it was very fun and whimsical. It got very fast-paced at the end parts. Along with being a fun book with pit-ponies, this book also touches on heavy themes such as bullying, racism and standing up for what you think is right. Overall, I think this book is a fun and whimsical story for any animal-lovers (specifically ponies) out there!

Leopold

The Perse Carnegians

This book really utilizes the themes of identity belonging and home and wraps them all together to make a beatiful heartwarming story.

Ernest

TBGS READERS

Definitely of it’s time - you absolutely have to understand the context to appreciate the characters’ struggles properly. I felt strongly for poor Birdie and wanted to pick her up and hug her and tell her everything would be ok. It’s just a shame the ending was a tad predictable… I would recommend this book to anyone who likes Michael Morpurgo.

Mrs Webb

Vista Academy Littleport

Birdie is a story about a girl, with the same name, who moves to a town in England to live with her great aunt (Mrs Winterbottom). She struggles to fit in because of her skin colour, but she slowly gains everybody’s trust and by the end everybody knows how kind-hearted and brave she really is. I also liked how she stuck to her values and didn’t change herself to fit in to other people’s views of her. I liked the backstory of Mrs Winterbottom losing her son at war and then how Birdie shows up and it feels like she was always meant to be there. Overall, this was a very interesting read.

Anya

Shelf Indulgence by JCG

Birdie was a really interesting read as it explores the struggles a mixed race person faces in a not-very-diverse village. There were so many moments in the story that made me emotional, like when finding out that Mrs Winterbottom’s son died at war, and thinking that Mr Duke had died at the end. There were so many likeable characters too. For example, Mrs Winterbottom starts out as a character we as readers perceive as racist and rude, but she turns out to be very kind and accepting of Birdie in the end.

Philippa

Shelf Indulgence by JCG

Birdie by Hannah Gold is a tender and touching children’s novel that follows the journey of Birdie Bagshaw, a girl who has never known her family and is leaving Leeds and Ms Dudley’s children’s home to begin a new life in the Yorkshire Dales with her great aunt. However, when Birdie arrives in the village of Barrington Dale, she is not met with warmth or kindness, but instead with coldness, as if an impassable grey cloud hangs over the community. After being bullied by the local children, Birdie seeks refuge in a nearby coal mine, where she loses her way and is rescued by the last remaining pit pony—an unsung hero who not only saves her life, but, with her help, begins to thaw the hearts of those around her. Birdie is a well-written novel that reflects the author’s strong sense of identity and voice. The book explores a range of themes, including identity, belonging, history, adapting to change, and racism, particularly through a mixed-race, post-war experience, as well as ideas of respect, empathy, and the importance of animals. As a result, the novel presents a variety of vivid characters with strong personalities, allowing the reader to form clear connections with them. However, despite this, the story as a whole can sometimes feel unrealistic, cliché, or even slightly forced. While choosing a young child as the main character offers an interesting perspective and insight into different situations, it can also make parts of the story feel overly simplistic or lacking in emotional depth. At times, it feels as though the characters’ actions lack realistic consequences, which makes the story less believable. As a result, although Birdie is a pleasant and well-intentioned narrative, it may not feel as impactful or inspirational for older readers. Birdie does convey a meaningful message; however, the way it is written does not always give enough weight to the significant historical and social issues it raises, such as racism. At times, the novel lacks the depth of emotional description needed to fully capture the intensity of these experiences in a realistic way. On the other hand, Birdie remains a strong example of courage and self-discovery, and is likely to inspire younger readers to follow in her footsteps. It is a gentle and heartwarming story that will particularly appeal to animal lovers.

Noemi Grace

Euro Champs

Wow! What an amazing, beautiful and heartwarming book. One of the things I liked most was the main character, Birdie. Her voice felt honest, thoughtful, and brave, and I liked seeing the world through her eyes. She notices things adults often ignore, and she asks questions that really matter. As she learns more about the past, you can feel her trying to make sense of it and connect it to her own life. It made me think about how young people often understand unfairness better than adults do. Overall, Birdie is a book that stays with you. It’s meaningful without being confusing, emotional without being overwhelming, and educational in a natural way. I would definitely recommend it to anyone, especially if they enjoy stories that teach you something important while still being gripping and full of heart. Birdie was full of surprises and twists.What an amazing book.

Indi

Shelf Indulgence by JCG

This book to me started off quite slow but throughout the story it builds into a beautiful book. I adored the character of Mr Duke. This book sent my heart on a roller coaster with many melancholic moments but also a contrast of truly joyous ones to. When the Carnegie's came out I never thought I would pick Birdie up but the absolutely amazing content and concept must have superglued me to it as I was not able to put it down. I Commend this author and would love to read more of J.P. Rose’s work. Thank you for an amazing read

Seren

The SBSJs

This book was really quite good, however not my favourite, as I feel that the plot and story were not as in-depth as some other books. However, the way that emotions and feelings developed over the course of the book really stood out to me and made this book really quite enjoyable. I like the fact that, as the book goes on, the characters opinions of Birdie begin to grow and change rather than just staying the same all the way through. Mr Duke was my favourite character because of the impact he had on the story.

Theo dP

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie by J. P. Rose is a wholesome and sad story that follows an orphan girl left by her Mother in a patch of turnips. She grew up in a children’s home in Leeds before moving to Barrington Dale to live with her great aunt Mabel. Birdie was left outside a church when she was a baby in a patch of turnips. She lived in a children’s home and went to school there. One day her great aunt said she wanted her so she moved to the Yorkshire dales to live with her. Her aunt is surprised by something about her but she won't tell Birdie what it is. She even refuses to let Birdie call her aunt. Birdie goes to school there, but is unfairly treated by the teacher, Miss Hartley, so she runs away. Birdie finds herself in the nearby coal mine and lost, when she meets a kind and gentle pit pony, who leads her back to the lift where she goes back up to the top. Despite her aunt’s warnings, Birdie finds herself coming back to see the pony in the mine and feeding him grass from the surface. Some themes in this book are, family and racism. This is shown when the whole Village of Barrington Dale doesn’t accept Birdie because of her race. She has many hardships because of what she looked like even though she is a kind hearted and loving girl. Even her family didn’t accept her as their relative when Mrs Winterbottom refused to let Birdie call her aunt Mabel. Reverend Hepplewaite and her uncle Walter were friendly and welcoming to her and were kind when others were mean. I loved this book and it is my favourite book so far! I would recommend this book to anyone who loves wholesome stories and who likes to be challenged by the books they read

Greta

Helkats & Hardbacks

I found this book very heartwarming because the main character, Birdie, is forced to go to a new place where not everyone accepts her. Then, by some sort of destiny, she meets a pony called Mr Duke, who she vows to save. Slowly, people start to accept her and time is ticking to save Mr Duke. I like the part where they run away but are forced back because they only need each other. My favourite character is Birdie great uncle, who she calls Mr Walter, because he was the first person who was actually kind to her and also saved Mr Duke.

Buddhan

The Perse Carnegians

Personally, I thought the book "Birdie" by J.P. Rose was an exhilarating read of highs and lows of being two ethnicities - accurately reflecting on perhaps the author's own personnel experiences making the piece feel truly authentic - of what was regarded perhaps taboo in the period that Birdie is set in, and the hardships Birdie endures becoming stronger and more true to herself by the end, with the other characters around her embracing her for who she truly is ; not trying to get her into society's norm. Despite this though, I feel as if the book is seeming hollow, lacking true emotive quality and a gripping plot ; with much of the book only being the build-up to the actual main event. Furthermore, certain characters such as the teacher of birdie and the boy that we meet in the book are only briefly touched on, which as  a reader we are given an inkling clue of a possibly romantic relationship - possibly needing more character development. But overall, the novel "Birdie" is a great read for all!

Ryan

The Perse Carnegians

I found Birdie very intriguing, the idea is very good and I love how they add in some old English words here and there and facts accurate to the time period the book is set in.

Emily

Reading Wizards

Birdie by J. P. Rose is a thoughtful and emotional novel that explores themes of belonging, racism, and resilience. I found Birdie a sympathetic and engaging character, and her friendship with the pit pony adds warmth and hope to an otherwise difficult story. I really liked when she described his colour as if he was “dipped in a can of paint”–it made me imagine exactly what she saw, I think. While the story is endearing, certain parts felt slightly predictable and the story seemed to progress too quickly in some places, in my opinion. I really wished that the author had focused more on Birdie running away with Mr Duke, because I loved how free and happy Birdie seemed then– it was my favourite part!

Jackie

The Perse Carnegians

This book is amazing I recommend this book so much. It is a beautiful, easy-to read story that got me lost into the pages of this book. I love the friendship between Birdie and Mr Duke. I loved it!!!!

Kyra

SCD Pageturners

I really enjoyed Birdie and the kindness, animal facts and 'old language' throughout the book. I felt especially sorry for her when the older boys ( and even the teacher!) were very racist to her. I was not bored once through the book especially the scenes with Mr Duke, and I felt quite sad when everyone thought he was dead. But it made the story even more enjoyable when he survived. I would recommend this to people age 8 to 14 and I am glad I chose to read this one.

Hannah

Rainbeau Readers

Birdie follows the story of a girl called Birdie who goes to live with her aunt in a coal-mining town in Yorkshire. She faces racism and discrimination from the other people in the town, and, one day, she stumbles across a pit pony in the mine. She and the pony find solace in each other, but when the pony's life is in danger, Birdie has to choose between family and the pony. I enjoyed reading this book because the way the author writes is intriguing and makes you want to read more.

Alexandra

Chiswick Carnegie

Birdie is an amazing book. It is all about a young girl that grew up in an orphanage and had to be adopted by her long-distance aunt who lives in a new city with new people and a new school. The part of the story that stuck out to me the most was when she started a new school and got bullied by a group of boys. This made me feel empathy and interest in the story. I have never read a book that I loved reading before, until I read Birdie. You should read this book, it inspired me to read more and maybe it will you too.

Caelan

Vista Academy Littleport

The pacing was good, and there was no point at which I was bored with what was happening in the book, but, although obviously it was awful when she faced racism, I felt no connection with the characters or the story. The only time the book made me feel emotional was when the horse 'died' but then it was magically ok again just so there could be a happy ending! I know that makes me sound really grumpy, but I feel it would be more effective if he stayed dead (Sorry Mr Duke!)

Ilsa

The High Storrs Shadows

The pacing was good, and there was no point at which I was bored with what was happening in the book, but, although obviously it was awful when she faced racism, I felt no connection with the characters or the story. The only time the book made me feel emotional was when the horse 'died' but then it was magically ok again just so there could be a happy ending! I know that makes me sound really grumpy, but I feel it would be more effective if he stayed dead (Sorry Mr Duke!)

Ilsa

The High Storrs Shadows

Birdie is a heartfelt story about homecoming and belonging. When Birdie moves to Barrington Dale she is shunned by the villagers, simply because her father was a USA soldier who was black. Abandoned in a turnip patch as a baby, she dreams of one day finding her family. So, when a letter comes from her Aunt Mable, she jumps at the opportunity and goes to live in Barrington Dale. When, the villagers push her away she runs to the shelter of a disused mine and befriends a pit pony who she names Mr Duke. What she doesn't know is Mr Duke is destined for the knackers yard. Can she save Mr Duke and either learn to fit in, or make the village accept her? I would rate this book 8/10 because it is well written and at the end, all of the threads have been tied together neatly

Sophia

The Shady Bookhounds

I didn’t really enjoy this book, as it took me quite a long time to get through and I found it quite difficult to stay interested. I also didn’t like the plot, as I felt it was slow and not very engaging. I think this might be because it’s aimed at younger readers and isn’t really my type of book. However, the writing was very good, and I would recommend it to readers aged 7–12.

Arya

Rainbeau Readers

Not a bad read. The 'thee' and 'thou' was really irritating- the book is set in the 50's and there is no other olde English used. I did like the Birdie character and her aunt and uncle quickly became so beloved. Having grown up with grand parents alive during WW2 the racism did not surprise me and I thought it was very well dealt with- however, not dealt with clearly enough for the younger reader to understand the importance. Mr Duke- all my fears and tears were for him. Thank goodness it was a happy ending.

Debbie

Ousedale Olney

I found the book birdie a really interesting one, as she was a girl of colour who got bullied for it . I also really liked the time setting it as it gave it more understanding and depth rather then it being set in the 21st century. Overall I really enjoyed this book and will look for more similar stories or other novels by the author.

Poppy

HHS 2026

Birdie has been an exciting book for me, filled with friendship, adventure and belonging. My favourite part is when she finally finds her place in Barrington Dale and how her friendship with Mr Duke, the pit pony, really helps her build her courage. She is a resilient, kind and smart girl and I am happy to find this amazing book.

Teni

Carmel Shadowers

This story is very inspirational because Birdie doesn’t give up. When things get tough, she always finds a way out of it. Birdie will do the right thing even if means losing out on something she wants. Birdie is a reflection of how we could be in our lives. Kind, empathetic and righteous. I really enjoyed this book and will remember its message always.

Zeven

Rainbeau Readers

This book was a very heart-warming story! I absolutely love it and would recommend it to anyone who would seem interested. So far, this is my favourite book! I really do hope this book wins the Carnegie Medal for Writing. The storyline is well put together and shows how you can be apart of a kind community, no matter who you are.

Miguel M.C

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I think its very good book because it is about a wild girl who experiences racism but she does not find out until everyone doesn't want to talk to her. Due to this I find this book awesome and I recommend it to all readers if they like adventurous and emotional books.

Aadam k

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Personally, I think that this was a very good book with a very compelling and emotional storyline with a close connection to animal companions which I think is quite unique as I don't usually see many books centred partly around the animal. As well as this, I love stories about orphans because they are very interesting due to the amount they have to fend for themselves and another inspiring aspect I loved was that she overcomes bullying which is very good role modelling for young children in similar situations.

Maryam

HGS Book Club

I liked reading this book because of the way it helped me engage with birdie. I really enjoyed how it was explained for how she felt about how she was being treated and what she did to try and change perspectives about not just herself but others like the pit pony’s too.

Bronte

Crypt Bookworms

A touching story in which people's prejudices are challenged by a kind and loyal heroine. It was interesting to learn about themes I knew very little about.

Bibliophile

Angmering Book Lovers 4 Life

My thoughts on Birdie varied throughout the book. At the beginning, I loved the touch of racism to add the reality of what it is like for a black girl in 1952. The pony Mr Duke was a personal favourite as I believed that it was a personal support animal and Birdie's best friend. Birdie had a heart and soul along with Mr Walter who was kind from the beginning however it took a lot for my head to change about aunt Mabel. I would of liked to see more of Julie and also Mrs Dudley's and Birdie's childhood. Overall my verdict is that it was a great read and a great adventure to dive into.

Lilah Jeavons

Ousedale Olney

I enjoyed this book. It gave me an insight to the coal mining industry of Leeds, and, having not known much about the pit ponies before, I feel I learnt a lot about their lives. I also enjoyed how the author has incorporated black history into this, and I felt the racism of the 1950s brought to life by the characters in the novel. My favourite character, however was Birdie’s great-uncle. I loved his commitment, but also his sorrow and heartbreak of before. 4 Stars. Thank you

Clara

Bassingbourn Readers

I read Birdie in its proof copy form and enjoyed both the story and the historical background. I'd been curious about these children of mixed parentage as a friend born in 1954 found herself with a similar origin story to Birdie, being fostered from a Barnardos home and taken to live in a rural town also in Yorkshire. Birdie's resilience is enviable as she just wants to be accepted for who she is and not judged on her background. I loved the relationship between Birdie and Mr Duke the retired pit pony, both outsiders in their own way.

Mrs P

Cake a Book Club

It was a good basic story that pointed out an ignored issue of racial surprise? The ending was very unnatural and it felt like they were trying to do two endings in one when they just needed to make up their mind.

Willow

CGS CAKE Club

It's the 1950s and there is a girl called Birdie who has never met her parents. She was abandoned and left in a church with a picture of her mum (which soon got destroyed). She lived with Mr and Mrs Dudley until she was given away to Aunt Mabel. Obviously, Birdie was sad and reluctant, but she left and went to the Yorkshire dales. When she was taken in by Aunt Mabel, she seemed kind but further in the story she acted quite suspicious. She kept telling Birdie, “it's nothing do not worry,” when there was something. Ever since she came, she was not treated like Mrs Winterbottom's nephew (she told birdie to call her that) but like a stranger. All of a sudden, one day, she was bullied by a gang of kids and in a desperate manner, she went into a building called Winding house and that was the coal mine. She was hiding and hiding but then she fell into a lift which said NO3 shaft cage. The lift fell and suddenly...stopped. There was nothing but a wall of coal in her way. She lost all hope and gave up but then she saw a pony. She said, “what are you doing here?” However, she was glad that the pony was there, and the pony started to walk, and Birdie Bagshaw followed where the pony went, and they had reached the lift again. She thanked the pony. She soon called him Mr Duke and that is where the story started. I like this book as it was an old fashioned book but usually I do not like these style books but I'm glad to have liked it. I recommend this book to those who want to see if they will like this genre (which they will after they certainly read this).

Ihsan K

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie lived in an orphanage in Leeds with a lot of kids and Mrs Dudley. Then one day her aunt in Barrington Dale says she will look after Birdie. But people are mean to her in the new home but she makes new and unexpected friends. The main character was Birdie. I liked her character as she has experienced a lot but keeps on pushing on. My favourite character was Mr Duke because he was very kind and I love horses. I really enjoyed this book because I thought it was interesting I liked the storyline. I also loved some of the cliff hangers in bits of the story.

Evie

HHS 2026

Birdie is a story of a young girl (named Birdie, hence the title) who moves from Leeds to the countryside to live with her great-aunt. But the folk here are not like those at home, and Birdie becomes an instant target for the bullies. One day, when it all gets too much, Birdie runs away and ends up in the mines, where she meets a pit pony. But his life is in danger, and Birdie may be the only one who can save him… My favourite character in this book was Birdie because she is so persistent and believes in herself. My favourite part of the book was when Birdie first met Mr Duke, having just run away from the bullies. I would recommend this book to people who like horses, and tales of courage, bravery and kindness.

Catelyn P

Vista Academy Littleport

This book is about Birdie Bagshaw, an orphan in a care home for 'brown babies'. She comes to live with her great aunt and uncle in a small mining village near Yorkshire. She faces racism and because of this, ends up finding Mr Duke, a pit pony who she befriends. I didn't particularly love this book because it was a bit boring-I did not find myself wanting to keep reading on, especially at the beginning. I did think that the character development was good but the characters kept saying Shakespearian language like 'thee' and random phrases like 'any road' instead of any way-it was very annoying. Overall, it was not an amazing book. 6/10

Elijah

Vista Academy Littleport

Birdie is a book about the friendship between Birdie and a pony. Birdie never knew her parents and she was growing up in a children's home for mixed race children in Leeds. She went to live with her great aunt in the Yorkshire Dales and is bullied by local children. She develops a bond with a little pony, Mr Duke. I liked the special bond between human and animal. I found the book dramatic and a bit emotional in places, I also felt very bad about the children's behaviour towards Birdie.

Samuel H

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The overview, it was set against in stark, soot-stained backdrop of 1950s Yorkshire,Birdie is a poignant and atmospheric historical novel that explores themes of displacement, masterfully captures the “windrush generation” experience though the eyes of a young girl, making the historical personal and deeply moving. There are also plot and character development, which the story follows Birdie, who travels from the vibrant, sun- drenched landscapes of Jamaica to a cold, grey mining villages in England. The contrast between her two worlds is not just physical but emotional. Rose develops Birdie as a character with immense internal strength; she is a”bird” trapped in a cage of cultural shock and social hostility. The style used a real 1950s racism and the isolation of being an outsider. Rose uses sensory language using the 5 senses. The conclusion, Birdie is more than just a historical fiction, it is a lyrical exploration of identity. It challenges the reader to consult what “home” truly means honours the courage and the people who help rebuilt post-war despite the cold.

Peace

Vista Academy Littleport

This book is about a young girl called Birdie. She lives in a foster home in Leeds with the lovely foster carer Mrs Dudley. One day, she goes on a train to a place called Barrington Dale because her Aunt Winterbottom has accepted to look after her. However, living in this new place isn’t so easy especially when you look different to everyone else. But Birdie finds a special friend, the pit pony Mr Duke. She goes on a journey of discovering friendship, love and seeing that how you look, doesn’t define who you truly are. The main character in this book was Birdie. I really liked her character as she is very bubbly, joyful, kind and loyal. I liked Aunt Winterbottom’s character as well as even though at the start, she didn’t seem like someone likeable, you understand why and grow to like her. My favourite character has to be Mr Walter. He is such a jolly, kind and fatherly character towards Birdie, even after everything he has had to go through. I really enjoyed this book. I thought it was fantastically written. I think it teaches you a lot about not judging someone by how they look and that you are enough.

Priya

HHS 2026

So far, I am on the part where Birdie finds a pit pony, who lives in a mine, and later on, learns more about why the pony is there. I can tell how much she cares and loves this little pony. I love how they find friendship between them, the moment they set eyes on each other. I'm finding 'Birdie' a really great book; I enjoy how smart and chatty Birdie can be and I look forward to finishing it.

Teni

Carmel Shadowers

Birdie spent most of her life in a foster home, then her great aunt and uncle decided to adopt her, but they didn't realise the problems that they are going to face. Birdie faced a lot of racism when she moved to Barrington dale, she felt like an outsider. then she found a pony that made her feel not like an outsider. They form a special bond. This book really broke me because it shows how horrible racism was around that time but it was also heartwarming because it shows the magic of animals.

Michelle

Vista Academy Littleport

I found the book to be really enjoyable to read and the setting set me off on a journey I never thought of stepping into.

St Kaths

I enjoyed this book as it showed racism in the 1950s and that people are people no matter what skin colour they are, and that anyone can get on with each other. I found Birdie's love for Mr Duke nice but could have been explored more than just her meeting him and sneaking out to go see him, as she seems to care for him so much and base her whole life around him for no real reason. I liked how the book looked at mines and how whole communities worked around them and the impact of them shutting and the Second World War. I would recommend Birdie to all ages as it explores racism in a fun way with animals and it is easier for younger readers to understand. Overall I would give it a 7/10

Robin.O

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The book was ok but one thing I didn't like was the bullying that happened. But I like how it involved bullying to show that bullying is NOT a way to go. Overall a good book a solid 9.6/10

Thomas

The Broxbourne Readers

This book is very unoriginal, with same stereotypes as thousands of other books, with an orphan child who has never seen her parents and wants to find them, who gets bullied and finds magical animal friend and feels better. Acceptable, considering the 9 year age rating, but not fun to read.

HarryF

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I thought that Birdie overall was a very good book. But I did feel that some of it didn't make sense. For example I didn't particularly understand why she would choose a horse over family and friends that genuinely cared for her and wanted the best for her. But ignoring that I felt it was really well written and it was sweet the way Birdie had a deep connection with a horse. And when everyone apologised for being racist to her it felt nice finally knowing she was accepted.

Aiden

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

An incredible read about identity and history in the north. With exceptional meaning and depth, it is a book for anyone to read about history - however it considers the ideas of severe racism in the 1950s as war ends. This book, although touching upon harsher themes in society, acts as an important book for people to read and consider how to treat others well.

Kaleb

Folkestone Academy Readers

I quite enjoyed this book. It follows the story of Birdie Bagshaw, a young girl who'd been adopted by her great aunt and uncle after living in an orphanage for "brown babies" her whole life, and as she's running away from a group of older boys taunting her, she stumbles into a mine and meets a horse she later names Mr Duke. I think the pacing of this book was quite good, as it doesn't have any weird jumps but there aren't any plot holes that need filling, and I also liked that it was based in reality and it demonstrates what it was like for people of colour in the 1950s. The plot developed well, and I liked that it had a happy ending, but it was targeted to younger audiences so at some points I got a bit bored. Overall, I think it was a good read though.

Lyra

Vista Academy Littleport

While I liked the messages of this book, I did not enjoy reading it. The dialogue felt stunted. The mix of 'Leeds speech' with older words (such as thee, art, etc.) made the story feel harder to associate with as it isn't modern or realistic. The plot was okay but I feel it could have been improved by explaining the situation of Birdie's life more thoroughly. I did, however, enjoy reading a story set in the local area. The messages of friendship, acceptance, and courage weren't integrated into the story, I feel, as I was overly aware of the point JP Rose was trying to convey. Overall, it is an interesting story which I, sadly, feel was not written as well as it could be.

Oliver R

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie is a wonderful book, full of emotion and heart. I really enjoyed it. it will be my new favourite book and I will recommend it to everyone.

Niamh

Rebel Readers

I really enjoyed reading this book, it had many sad bits and amazing bits. Also I am a person that enjoys adventure books so this turned out to be an amazing book for me.

Adidev

The Fitzharrys Shadows

The story is about a young black girl called Birdie become friends with a pony she names Mr Duke. It was interesting seeing as it was set in England after world war two and was still quite a racist community and she had a black father but a white mother. Birdie is an orphan and was taken in by her great aunt and uncle who had lost their son in the war. It was touching watching Birdie's aunt and uncle slowly find themselves as Birdie brings them out of depression. I also enjoyed it because I live in the Yorkshire Dales which is where the book is set. Birdie was a touching character since she was willing to give up everything for the sake of a pony she had just recently met. One of my favourite characters was Mr Lofthouse since he was kind to Birdie and gave her medicine for her pony for free. Overall I really enjoyed this book and would recommend it.

Thomas F

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed this book and it's one of my favourites I've read so far. At first, I struggled to enjoy it as I felt the plot went quite slowly, but I ended up getting immersed in the storyline and characters! The author definitely had a way of making the characters feel real, and I was really hoping everything would go well for all of them, and I just found it really cosy and enjoyable. I thought it struck a balance between teaching important lessons about history without making it feel unrealistic and like a textbook. It had some really important messages delivered in a heartwarming, interesting way!

Iris

Skipton Shadows

This book is an interesting story about racism and friendship. It wasn't really my kind of book but I'm sure some people will have enjoyed it. I found the plot was rather weak and so were the characters but other than that I thought it was nice that it was set so locally and with very important messages in it. I couldn't relate to the characters however.

Rowan

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie was a lovely book, written about a girl called Birdie in Yorkshire. It was nice to have a book set so locally, even with a reference to where I live. The book was set in the 1950s, the post war period I didn't know much about. Overall, the book was a great story with lots of little sidestories to keep the chapters in the middle entertaining. The RCD may have been predictable but it was also very happy which was a nice change from other books on this shortlist.

Aidan

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Birdie is a thought provoking book about racism, identity and belonging. The protagonist is a girl called Birdie Bagshaw who is an orphan who goes to live in the Yorkshire Dales with her great aunt Mabel and great uncle Mr Walter. Even though Birdie gets bullied and treated like dirt by her classmates, teachers and even other adults, because of the colour of her skin, she still prevails. One day the bullying goes too far and leads to her hiding in a tube which then goes down to an abandoned coal mine. She gets lost trying to find a way out and discovers a pony which helps her escape the coal mine. I have mixed feelings about this book as it is a very good story and has many great scenes and parts, but I found it was too short for a book of its quality.

Sylvan C

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book was an amazing story of friendship and loss. I like how it highlights racial discrimination, bullying and what it is like to feel different to people. I particularly like this book because it reminds me of the book Black Beauty and the power of animal companionship. I found that the pace was slightly too slow for me and I would have liked it to be a bit faster. Overall, I thought that this was a great book and I recommend it to animal lovers and younger readers.

Annie

NDHS Book Group

This book is about a girl named Birdie who lives in England a long time ago. She is an orphan and has to move to a small village in Yorkshire to live with her great-aunt and great-uncle. The village is a mining town where everything is covered in coal dust. Life is very difficult for Birdie because she is mixed-race, and many people in the town are unkind to her because she looks different from them. She feels very lonely until she discovers a secret. My favourite part of the story is the pony Birdie finds a horse named Mr. Duke who works deep underground in the coal mines. They become best friends because they both feel alone. Birdie works very hard to take care of the pony. It shows how brave she is, even when things are scary. I liked this book because it shows that even if people are mean to you, you can still find friends in unexpected places. It made me feel sad sometimes, but it also made me happy to see Birdie find a home where she belongs.

Patrick J

Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group