The Carnegies

The opening of the book throws us straight into the emotional difficulties that Finlay is facing, and starts to hint relatively early on about what happened those three years ago, which made me, the reader, want to read on to understand his character more. As for Banjo, we see immediately that he is quite troubled and difficult, with him starting a fight on his first day at his new school. Because we are shown these sides of the characters before getting any backstory, the reader is encouraged to carry on reading to uncover the answers as to why the two boys are the way they are, and to learn more about what happened those three years ago. Personally, I enjoyed the book, because I loved to watch the characters develop throughout the story, and it’s really interesting to compare them to themselves at the end of the book compared to the start of the book, and it’s great to see the two boys get over that indecent three years back, and reunite under their friendship. The only things that people might find difficult is the changes in perspective from chapter to chapter, and the Scottish slang/accent that Banjo uses. Overall, a very good book, and I would certainly recommend this book to readers in Year 10 and above (due to the language).

Jonathan
Augustine’s Carnegie Challenge

I thought it was a very well written book and approached normally unspoken topics. I enjoyed reading it from the two perspectives and it gave a very wide view on how tricky it can be coming out of care. I really liked the ending and overall felt like I followed along in their journey.

Isabelle
Horsham BOok HUNTers

Glasgow Boys is a very powerful book that shows the reality of living in care, through the characters Finlay and Banjo. It showed both boys' journeys and struggles as they deal with trauma from drug abuse or self harm. Their story together was slowly uncovered through flashbacks and mentions during the book, and I enjoyed reading about their individual recovery and eventually forgiving each other.

Elizabeth
Augustine’s Carnegie Challenge

Glasgow Boys was a deeply heartwarming read with excellent characters and fantastic pacing. Having read many similar books, I was impressed to see that McDonald had created a refreshing and unique story, and was also pleased to find a gay romance that isn’t used as a third act plot twist in a cliched crime novel. I also loved the dual narrative and thought the flashbacks were amazingly gripping and effective. That being said, I did dislike the fact that Finlay’s sexuality was the reason he and Banjo fought: It felt out of character for Banjo and very lacklustre of the author to use Finlay’s sexuality as a plot device. Additionally, I found the style of writing (third person, present tense) a little difficult to adjust to. I would also say that, although the book was superbly endearing, it did not feel particularly realistic overall, and it glossed slightly over the nastier aspects of the care system. However, this was generally a brilliant read, and I would definitely recommend it to a friend.

Alice
TGGS Carnegie Readers

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald tells the story of two boys and the problems they face growing up in the care system. Finlay must balance out his early morning job with the pressure of studying a degree, and on top of that he must not fall for the boy he likes at university (who happens to be an old friend). Banjo must control his anger, while finishing high school with good grades and trying to maintain his friendship with the girl he likes (who works at the same cafe as him). The split perspective allows the reader to dive into two different yet similar lives. My favourite character in this book is Alena, because she gives Banjo the confidence in himself that he needs, and she as well as her parents welcomed him into their family. My favourite part of the story is when Finlay and Banjo finally meet up, after years of being apart. overall, I really enjoyed this book, and I would rate it 9/10!

Asha
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald really pulled me into the world of 19th-century Scottish art in a way I wasn’t expecting. I loved how McDonald didn’t just focus on the artists' work but also gave me a glimpse into their personal lives—their struggles, dreams, and the tensions between their creativity and the world around them. The way she describes Glasgow during that time made it feel like I was walking the same streets as these artists, feeling the same influences that shaped their pieces. What really stood out to me was how their relationships and challenges were as much a part of their art as the paintings themselves, giving me a deeper understanding of the human side of their creative journeys.

Omar
Beauchamp Champs 2025

I found this book very nostalgic as it showed how memories can last forever. The struggles that Finlay and Banjo must endure are heartbreaking (sometimes). Finlay is gay and he sometimes realises that it’s hard for him to admit that, even to himself. Banjo has anger issues, so when someone angers him, he can’t stop himself from seriously injuring that person. Both boys have been tossed around care homes and foster families. Neither of them have been shown proper care or love. When they find themselves at the end of the book it is wonderful as they also reunite. Overall, this is a wonderful book and I think it is a great candidate but I cannot decide whether it should win.

Genevieve
Beauchamp Champs 2025

'Glasgow Boys' by Margaret McDonald is definitely my favourite of the Carnegie books so far. We are thrown head-first into the lives of two boys, Finlay (who has just left the care system) and Banjo (nearing towards the end of his time in it). Throughout the story, we switch between their perspectives as they narrate their struggle to stay on top of their lives and are finding their thoughts drifting back to the time they spent together. I absolutely love the way the 'flashbacks' fill in the gaps that are created through the brief mentions of past relationships, and found the other interwoven issues - like sexuality, behaviour issues, financial struggles and emotional detachment - incredibly fascinating. I really hope that this story reaches as many people as possible in the future because it shares many messages that people need to hear.

Kristina
Brooke Weston Book Busters

This book was so good in showing how difficult it can be for children from care to access the same opportunities as other children in the wider world. Beautifully written and explored topics often not talked about which should be like suicide and self harm

Emily
Lionheart25

I have rated this book 5 stars because the story is very captivating and heart-warming. This book makes the reader feel a variety of different emotions throughout and it is very informative about the topics that are discussed.

Sonia
Ousedale Shadow Chasers

Glasgow Boys was a powerful and beautiful novel that opened up a new world to me. Learning about the characters and their own personal and emotional journeys made the story feel real. I was hooked throughout the book and loved it. Overall, it was a great and exciting read.

Channah
Perusing Pelicans

A gritty, powerful and heartfelt coming-of-age story of love, friendship and family covering difficult, mature themes of child abuse, violence, attempted suicide and mental health. The story follows two estranged teenage friends Finlay and Banjo who have both grown up in the care system and are trying to fit in and find their way in the world, not letting anyone know about their past while at the same time avoiding emotional attachments. I enjoyed the dual narrative aspect and the flashbacks from three years ago that gradually filled in the missing parts of their story. The characters were believable, and I was rooting for them to find the happiness and acceptance they craved and deserved. A fast-paced read full of resilience, courage, and hope.

Mrs Mann
Brooke Weston Book Busters

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald follows the intertwined lives of two young men called Finlay and Banjo both who have been abandoned at some point and have both been in Foster care . Finlay who is now studying Nursing at Glasgow University has aged out of foster care and is now living on his own but he struggles with the lack of support he would get from a family. Banjo is still in High school and is having a hard time with his new foster parents. They end up finding each other and both of them helping the other sort their lives out, mostly for them both having a friend in the hard times. In my opinion the Author makes a great connection between the boys in the book and the reader which is great. However, the books amazing realism and the connection between the reader and Finlay and Banjo really makes you feel what they think and feel and all their hardships that they deal with keeps you turning the page even if you don't necessarily want to find out what happened you keep on reading. Overall, very good book :)

Hugo
Bookwizards

Glasgow Boys is a great book following the story of two boys who are in Scottish foster care the plot is really good and it is not very confusing.

Arthur
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Luke Palmer's Play is a real exploration of how adolescence, masculinity, and male friendship can be complex. Following the lives of four boys—Matt, Luc, Johnny, and Mark—growing up in a small English town, the novel delves into their ever-growing relationships and the choices that mould their futures. The story unfolds through the distinct voices of the four protagonists, each struggling with their own challenges and perceptions of masculinity. Palmer uses varying fonts to differentiate the characters' narratives, enhancing the reader's connection to each voice . Matt, the introspective artist; Luc, the athletic overachiever; Johnny, the reckless one; and Mark, the impressionable follower, each bring unique perspectives to the story. At its core, Play examines the pressures and expectations placed on young men. Through the boys' interactions and individual struggles, Palmer addresses issues such as toxic masculinity, the influence of abscent father figures, and the search for identity in a world that often offers bad messages. The novel also touches on how easy vulnerable youths can be dragged into crime mark is used as a construct to show this as he gets associated with county lines and dealed drugs.

Elma
Reading allowed

‘Glasgow Boys’ is a wonderfully written novel by Margaret McDonald centered around two boys and their broken friendship. Growing up in care, Finlay and Banjo were in and out of foster homes most of their lives until they met each other, striking up an unusual friendship. We follow two separate storylines of the boys as they struggle to live their lives at university, work and school. As both characters struggle through their new situations as a consequence of absent care and support growing up, they learn more about themselves and their relationships. The novel focuses on themes of masculinity, love and how it can take different forms - not necessarily romantic love. Throughout the book I felt engaged with the characters and found that through the words on the page, I could empathise with the boys. I felt the emotions conveyed were raw and real, creating a sense that the boys’ situation and growth was genuine. The book, however, contains some mature themes and a healthy dose of reality, making it a more difficult read then other novels. In spite of this the book is perfect for anyone who needs a story with deep emotion, a message and a comforting end.

Ellie-Anna
Rainbeau Readers

Glasgow Boys is a great book following the story of two boys who are in Scottish foster care the plot is really good and it is not very confusing.

Pola
The Fitzharrys Shadows

A brilliant book about two boys from foster care in Scotland struggling to adjust to their new lives. I really enjoyed it and would reccomend. Loved the writing style.

Elsie
St Kaths

I loved reading Glasgow Boys. The book is very relatable for lots of different audiences and it feels as if you are one of the characters. The two different stories that come together in the end is a really interesting idea because it means that the story doesn't get boring because you switch between the two characters instead of focussing on one person. Glasgow Boys had a very happy ending which is really nice because in a lot of books I've read recently there is a cliff-hanger or a sad ending but in this there is not. It was the first Carnegie book that I read and it was an amazing start and is probably my favourite one I've read so far.

William
Bookwizards

Glasgow Boys was a book that kept my eyes glued to the pages. The split perspective was very interesting as we get to see how the story unfolds from 2 perspectives. We learn about the upbringing of the 2 main characters (Banjo and Finlay) and how they were in the care system. The book shows us the nuances of their emotions and the coping mechanisms they have developed for problems. I also really liked how Banjo and Finlay interacted with the other characters in the book. Their conversations all felt very personal, almost like I stepped into their lives and that is a feat that I really appreciate in books. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who wants a grounded, bildungsroman experience. Heads up though, this book has lots of mature themes like suicide, the care system and heavy language. Overall, I really enjoyed this book and I hope anyone else who reads it enjoyed it too.

Kang Heum
The Lotus Readers

Glasgow Boys by Margaret Macdonald is a book that shows the struggles of 18-year-old foster children trying to get through their lives. The book focuses on two main characters, Finlay and Banjo. Finlay is trying to get his nursing degree to guarantee him a good-paying job, but he’s struggling. His story is very beautiful and dives into themes of sexuality and personal struggles. Readers at the targeted age range can relate to Finlay because his story includes a lot of school/university struggles, which will make readers feel empathetic. Banjo is a Scottish boy, characterised by his ginger hair and thick Glaswegian accent. He is getting through his school life whilst staying with his foster family but gets into a lot of trouble and needs self-control. Banjo’s story is amazing, giving the reader great immersion into his true feelings and a taste of his experiences. How the author tinkers and plays around with relationships is very interesting; it’s really cool to see how the relationships play out. I recommend this book to all teenagers within the range of 13-19 years old. If you are around this age, you should read this book, especially if you’re in university or high school. My final rating for this book is an 8.51/10

Rui Zhe
The Lotus Readers

I really liked reading this book- it beautifully describes the two boys' struggles of growing up, making their stories separate, but linked. I also liked how little pieces of their habits mentioned throughout the book, help shape the characters and their backstory, even when their flashbacks from 3 years ago aren't present in parts of the story. Examples of this can be that Banjo likes to run to calm himself down, and get rid of his problems, and it foreshadows to us that he can't deal with his stress properly, wanting to say sorry to Finlay for a long time, but finding it hard to do so because of his problem. Another example of this was that Finlay was originally perceived as very enclosed to himself, and socially anxious because of his past trauma of losing Banjo for not opening up to him. I noticed that, although this book was titled as a romance, yet I do not think so- there are love interests, but falling in love is not the main theme, however, Glasgow Boys IS about love, though. It was about finding your place in the world, learning to love your people, and also loving YOURSELF for who you are, and i found that quite beautiful.

Tazmeen
Grays Shadows

Glasgow Boys is one of the best books I’ve read in a while. I really enjoyed the switching of perspective every chapter showing the different sides of the story and the different experiences, struggles and feelings both characters went through, it really added to the enjoyment of the book. I found the Scottish dialect somewhat difficult at the start, but this changed very quickly with it eventually becoming something which I couldn’t imagine Banjo without. I loved how the book showed the difficulties both people who go through foster care and people who are trying/want to come out to their friends and family can sometimes go through. I also really enjoyed how both of them, over time, learned to share and trust their friends with knowledge of their past and feelings showing a real growth in both characters throughout the story. An easy 9/10 for me.

Johannes
Augustine’s Carnegie Challenge

I really enjoyed this book, and I could hardly put it down when I was reading it. The character were fully formed and alive from the very beginning, and even thought I don't normally like dual narratives, it did work in this work, portraying their contrasting characters. I also liked how their link was brought in in the middle of the book and not at the end, because it helped you to make links yourself and enjoy the build ups. I loved all the different types of friendships and relationships and how the characters managed to overcome their difficulties and enjoy life together. I especially liked the ending which brought them all together in all senses. Highly recommend this book.

Mabel
The High Storrs Shadows

I love this book because it is heartbreaking and beautiful. I would say that the genre in the book is novel. It is a must read for for anyone who is over 12. I loved this story and I bet u will to!!

Chiara
Sandroyd Bookivores

This book was incredibly well written. The switching of povs makes you see the story in different ways giving it a switch on the way the characters saw the world and their opinions which makes the story more enticing and a page-turner. The portrayal of issues was also well done making it incredibly relatable in certain parts which gave it a nice touch.

Lillie
Roaring Readers

I found this book very relatable seeing how the author shows their personal feelings and experiences. It shows the inside of the healthcare system and depicts the thought process and emotions of teenagers which is very uncommon. I found the Glasgow boys an amazing read and I could not put it down!

Izzy
Ousedale Olney

I was blown away by this book. The way the perspectives changed and we always got to know the other side of the story was amazing. The way the characters slowly told the people they trusted about their past was wonderful. The way Finlay and Banjo finally met after 3 years was long awaited and I could happily close the book because of its happy ending (doesn't happen a lot). This book was amazing, I loved the way the characters revealed their secrets to their trusted people. This book was brilliant. :)

Salm
Bellerive Bookies and Cookies

This book was the most beautiful book I've ever read. I read it as much as I could, in any spare time I had and was kind of disappointed when it finished, although it was a very nice, polished-off ending. I felt like each word was carefully and purposefully placed, each of them painting a breath-taking picture and world of Finlay and Banjo's world, making it seem so real and personal that I laughed when they laughed, and I was sad when they cried. The whole story was a whirl of resplendent colour and life, and I felt like I related to some of the feelings the characters felt like, it was so well-written and REAL. To say this is my new favourite book would be an understatement.

Francesca
Orpington Library Older Teens

I thought Glasgow Boys was an utterly brilliant book. I felt that this tells an important side of childhood that is not often heard. It was heart wrenching and hopeful, filled with the bitter harshness of the past and the yearning for a brighter future with people who matter.

Kaja
OP No Shelf Control

Miroslava
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Overall, I enjoyed "Glasgow Boys." Margaret McDonald's writing style is engaging, and I found myself easily drawn into the story. The way she crafts sentences and builds the world felt very natural for me. There were some parts I thought could be improved. The amount of swearing felt a bit much at times. And when it came to the fight scenes, the details were quite aggressive. I believe the story could convey the seriousness of those moments just as effectively without such intense descriptions. Banjo's storyline definitely captured my attention more than Finlay's. Banjo's life seemed to have more twists and turns, making his part of the plot feel more dynamic and interesting to follow. It felt like he was constantly navigating new challenges, which kept me thinking what is next. Finlay's journey was important, of course, but it just didn't have the same level of excitement for me. I would say that “Glasgow Boys” is a story about friendship, trauma, and finding your way, and the author does a good job of making you care about the characters.

Miroslava
Beauchamp Champs 2025

This took me a while to get into, but about halfway through I was completely hooked and devastated at the lives and experiences of Banjo and Finlay - our two main characters. This was a brilliant read and something really different to what I would usually choose. The Scottish dialect is tricky at first, but worth persevering with!

Miss Yeabsley
Lionheart25

I thought Glasgow boys was a really uplifting and interesting book. I enjoyed how the two boys each had chapters in their point of view and I felt like you could really understand the characters well.

Eva
Rad readers

I only managed to read a bit of the book, very sweary, not for tweens who don’t like that kind of stuff.

Nate
Lostock Carnegie Shadowers

This book was absolutely brilliant! It tells the story of two boys with big secrets, shared experiences, and a deeply connected past. Banjo and Finnlay grew up together in foster care, but a terrible incident tears them apart. They don’t see each other for three years and end up living completely different lives. Banjo keeps getting into trouble and moves from one foster carer to another, while Finnlay has aged out of the system and moved to Glasgow to study at university. Both boys say they’ve moved on—but that’s not completely true. Will they ever meet again? Can they reconnect? And most importantly, can they overcome the struggles that come with growing up in care? Margaret is a genius writer, and this book is just as amazing as her talent. Glasgow Boys was a real pleasure to read. If I could read it for the first time again, I would! It’s not a fantasy adventure, but it still feels magical in its own way. This book was awesome.

Alba
Rainbeau Readers

I loved Glasgow Boys, although it was slightly hard to understand what Banjo specifically was saying in his Scottish accent, that problem was mostly solved by the Scots glossary at the back of the book. The book is about Banjo and Finlay, two boys who grew up in care together. However, an incident occurs and the two go their separate ways and Finlay, 18, is struggling with trying to balance out nursing classes and multiple jobs as he finds it hard to have enough money to give himself good, nutritious meals. However Banjo, 17, is still in care and trying to juggle foster parents, his anger issues, and teenage love at the same time. I really liked the love plots for both Finlay and Banjo, although it was slightly hard for me to read Finlay's because it hurt to see him pushing away people who care for him. I also loved the fact that instead of finding out what happened all at once between the two boys, we see what happened in bits and both the boys' perspectives. An amazing read. 9/10.

Holly
Chiswick Carnegie

When I started reading this book, I wasn't sure I was going to enjoy it, but I am very happy that I kept reading because I loved it! I liked that this book is full of friendship and emotion, and I really liked that the author switched between their past and present lives.

Elsie
4Shadowers

I loved reading this book, and how it explored Finlay and Banjo's stories seperately until they meet again, bringing the whole story together. I also liked the depiction of both's experience of the foster system, and the portrayal of how they grow up.

Eleanor
The Tiffin Girls’ Shadows

I found it interesting find out each of their lifestyle and how they were each experiencing their life. It was a good book I really liked how Finley and banjo got to reunite in the end it was good. I would read it again.

Naomi T
Herts and Essex

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald is a moving, well-written novel set in showcases the lives of 2 young boys after leaving the care system – Finlay, an 18-year-old studying nursing at Glasgow University, and Banjo, a 17-year-old boy trying to settle in with his new foster family and finish school. The story is told in both of their perspectives, giving us a look at how both boys cope with the trauma in their past, resilience and their identities. Both are attempting to navigate their world, haunted by the past and uncertain of their futures. Through flashbacks of their time at St Andrews group home where they met, we get an insight into the bond they shared, and how much it meant to them; In my opinion, these are some of the most powerful scenes in the book. As young adults, they now face the lasting impact of what they’ve previously been through. The story is about the long-term effects of trauma, and how love and friendship can sometimes be both healing and fragile. It’s filled with small but powerful, memorable moments. One of the novel’s greatest strengths is the portrayal of Banjo and Finlay - they are complex, interesting characters who express their emotions, and I think this makes them feel very real. Also, I liked how Banjo had an accent! Overall, I would rate this book a 3.5/5

Zainab
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Set in Glasgow, this heart-warming book talks about two boys, with very different personalities, who were together in foster care but are now leading their individual lives apart , yet still connected in a way. I really enjoyed the double narrative in the book, alternating between each boy, which allows us to see how each of them is coping with their shared past. This style of writing helped me understand the feelings they had for each other. What I found wonderful in this book is the way the author makes us feel attached to the characters. We therefore bond with them and develop some admiration for their outstanding courage.

EmmaHG
4Shadowers

Glasgow boys is a wonderful novel about two boys Finlay and Banjo finding their own ways through university and school. I felt this book dived into issues that would not normally be mentioned and the importance of mental health. It explores emotions and feelings of young adults and people who have grown up in foster care. Overall I think this book is amazing and everyone should read it. I would rate it an 8/10.

Harriet
Weald of Kent Sevenoaks

I loved this book so much. It really showed amazing character development and storytelling in a way that completely hooks the reader. It made me feel genuinely sad and is a book I instantly want to read again. One of the best books I've ever read.

Emily
Kesgrave Bookworms

A beautifully written book from start to finish. It does a great job at addressing issues such as mental health, as well as bringing up issues which I would have never spent as much time thinking about. I found it easy to connect to the characters and the stories, especially when one character 'came out' to his friends and I think that all of the things, from everyday life, to higher issues were portrayed perfectly. It is a masterpiece of a book, filled with emotion, love and some more serious issues. I would read it again every time and while it may not be the type of book to catch my eye normally for me to read, I do not regret picking it up to do so. For a more basic rating I give Glasgow Boys a full 10/10.

Anonymous
St George’s Dragon Readers

I loved this book and the Glasgow setting really made it. The two main characters are fully realised and convincing, especially Banjo. The gritty, articulate honesty of the Glaswegian character shone out of him. It’s a great story, all about relationships of all kinds and the discovery of the importance of love - the ability to give it and receive it. I will certainly seek out other books by this writer. Definitely a strong contender for the award I’d say.

Mrs M
Blake Book Buddies

This was a good book in my opinion, i liked how they both had seperate lives and problems going on but still managed to be linked together throughout. I did find the beginning was a little bit hard to get into but overall i think this was a really good book.

Jenna
Eltham Hill Y9 Book Club

Margaret McDonald's "Glasgow Boys" Is a thoroughly enjoyable read. From beginning to end, I was captivated by the well-developed characters, each with their own unique personality and complexities. Their journeys are both engaging and emotionally resonant, making it easy to connect with their struggles and triumphs. The narrative unfolds at a satisfying pace, and the story itself carries a powerful moral message that lingers long after you finish reading. While I can't reveal plot details, I can say the underlying themes are both thought-provoking and relevant to modern life. If you're looking for a book with well-rounded characters, a compelling storyline, and a meaningful message, I would recommend "Glasgow Boys." It's a truly rewarding reading experience.

Shanelle
QEGS CARNEGIE BOOK CLUB

Glasgow Boys was honestly an amazing book to read, like I was not prepared for it to be honest. Two boys, one still figuring out what to do in his life, whilst the other is slowly figuring his identity out. It dives into mental health and how hard it can be to just be yourself sometimes. The way it is written feels super natural and its like you are in the minds of the characters itself; nothing feels fake or forced, just real. The characters? You will get attached to them fast, character development and everything. If you prefer stories that are deep, emotional but still making you feel grounded and not overly dramatic, this book is a MUST to read. Overall 10/10 to read and I would recommend this book to 13+ due to mature topics but other than that everyone needs to read this book, it is a life changer.

Hamida
FGCS Carnegies 2025

Glasgow boys was an especially intriguing Carnegie novel. the story was so clear and vivid in my mind I felt like I was encountering the same experiences, challenges and strong friendships that banjo and Finlay were.I also loved that the author Margaret McDonald has made a very powerful point of raising awareness for the effects children have during their childhood living in care. for example banjo's constant anger issues and Feisty nature to do with this reason of neglect at a young age. I feel like banjo's story was a lot more impactful and emotive than Finlay's and personality shone through. as well as the romance aspect which is a questionable stage of teenagers in this reading category. the other characters play a huge part in banjo's life as his girlfriend Alena's family becomes his which is very heartwarming. overall I give Glasgow boys a 4/5 star review

bonny
Logs

This book was brilliant. I loved how the author was able to show both Finlay and Banjo, in such their own ways. The story flowed well and the character development of Finlay and Banjo was written in an understandable way. It was enjoyable to read and was hooking. It didn't give away the story when Banjo and Finlay's worlds crossed. I think this is an amazing book and I would recommend it to everyone. 10/10

Kenzie
KES Bookworms

This was such a heart warming and emotional book to read, especially for people trying to get into reading or is in a bit of a reading slump. The two main characters have very chaotic and sad backstories and have learnt to deal with their past in different ways, one retreats inward and shies away and the other is loud and sees confrontation as something he deserves (especially when it harms him). These two very different characters become a part of each others lives and rely on each other for a sense of security, but when it all falls apart and their lives take them on different paths, both regret what happened that day while also trying to become a better version of themselves.

Bella
Balla Bookworms

This book wasn't my exact favourite. Though it was good, this book was not my style of book that I like reading. Also, it featured a lot of sad events, so I do not recommend this book to Year 7 or below. This book is about two boys who are in care, one is now in university, studying nursing and the other is still in high school. Their names are Banjo and Finlay. Overall, the book was not too bad and I would rate it 3 out of 5.

Anya
Beauchamp Champs 2025

i loved this book as it includes a lot of proplems teenagers face today would definetly recommend

scarlett
Waddesdon Shadowers

Only read half of the book but I stopped because the different people's narratives were confusing me. But from what I read it wasn't a bad book; I'd give it a 6/10.

lucas
Carnegievores

I loved the book it gives a good insight into someone's life in care. My only pet-peeve is that its written in the accent which can make it quite confusing to read.

Ruby
LatLit

Personally, I like how the author opted for two perspectives rather than just one, because it helped in showing the readers the range of issues that teenagers may face in real life and how they might affect someone. In this way, some younger readers of this book can relate to the main characters and perhaps find a solution to their own problems or a source of comfort in this book.

Ha Dan
The Lotus Readers

Anya
Beauchamp Champs 2025

I really enjoyed this book! I felt like I understood the characters and the style of writing was nice too. The book flowed really well and made sense at all times. I recommend this book to readers over 12, though, as there is frequent use of swears.

Bea
Ousedale Shadow Chasers

I absolutely loved reading The Glasgow Boys. It was one of the most relatable and emotionally honest books I’ve come across. The story felt incredibly gritty and raw, portraying real struggles in a way that didn’t feel sugar-coated or forced. Compared to other books I’ve read, this one stood out because of how true-to-life the characters and their experiences felt. I saw so much of myself in Finlay—his thoughts, insecurities, and the way he tried to navigate his place in the world really resonated with me. That strong connection made me sympathize with him deeply and understand the choices he made, even when they weren’t easy. His character felt like someone I could know—or even be—which made the story hit even harder. Another thing I really appreciated was the inclusion of LGBTQ+ representation. It was done so naturally and respectfully, and when I realized there was something developing between Akash and Finlay, I couldn’t help but start giggling—I was so excited to see that part of the story unfold. Their relationship added even more depth to the book, and it made me feel seen in a way I don’t often experience in fiction. Overall, The Glasgow Boys wasn’t just a great book—it was an important one. It’s one of the best books I’ve ever read, and I know it’s going to stay with me for a long time.

Ellie
Plumites

The book was relatively interesting and hooked me in from the blurb, it really drew me in seeing how all the characters reacted to everything and the amount of depth within their person. The authour is insanely creative, as it would be difficult to perfectly imitate the way people speak. Although the blub was a little misleading, as I couldnt always see the relevance. I think it was an emotional book, the plot was well thought out, and it is definetly my favourite so far out of the carnegie books.

Jennifer
Kesgrave Bookworms

This book was amazing! First impressions were great. I like how Finlay and Banjo are quite different people yet they have very similar experiences. I also love how we see the sides of both Banjo and Finlay. Banjo is a very loving character, as you read on you find out more about his character and I love it. I think their personalities reflect one another perfectly. Also I think the author conveyed their personalities very well. This is a fantastic book and I highly recommend.

Phoebe
JCA Book Club

I loved the characters and the overall themes of this book. It brought serious issues to light including addiction and abuse however, I think these issues were handled very delicately. Finlay and Banjo were brought together in sad and unexpected circumstances but their personalities (though different) complement each other perfectly. I can confidently say that this is one of my favourite books to date.

Rosa
JCA Book Club

This book was amazing- having me in its grasp within the first few pages. I loved how the scenes were written so we could explore both perspectives of the characters. Furthermore, I think it is quite impressive that the author could imitate accents so well- I felt as though I could imagine Banjo speaking. I also enjoyed how we could follow the characters highs and lows and experience the characters sorrows. Overall, the book was an enjoyable read.

Hayley L.
Newstead Wood Carnegie Shadowers

The book was very interesting and hooked me in from the blurb, it helped us explore the characters' personalities and how they think or react to everything. The characters also had lots of depth and the author was very creative; it must have been very hard to imitate the way people spoke and such so she probably did lots of research. Unfortunately, the blurb was a little misleading so I was a bit disappointed when I found out that I was wrong. Overall, I think it was quite an emotional rollercoaster, it had a unique setting, the plot was well-thought and it was good that it was a happy ending and the author did a good job writing Glasgow Boys.

Devika
Newstead Wood Carnegie Shadowers

Emotional. Page-turner and oddly relatable...

Jasmine
Newstead Wood Carnegie Shadowers

Glasgow Boys: Glasgow Boys is a romantic parallel novel set in Scotland. The protagonists, Banjo and Finlay, are two boys of 17 and 18 who are both in care. They met three years before the time the book is set in and fell in love. Since then, they went their separate ways- Banjo still in care and Finlay at university. Finlay is presented as a caring character, he is studying to become a nurse at Glasgow University and he quickly makes new friends and even meets some previous ones! Meanwhile, Banjo (who is 17 and still in care) has also found a love interest for himself. Overall, I thought this book was not my style and I didn’t enjoy the constant use of swear words. Another thing I think this author could improve is how they show Banjo to talk. Ofcourse, Banjo is from Scotland and has a Scottish accent but I found it extremely difficult to find out what the 17 year old boy was saying. The glossary at the back of the book was very necessary and without it I would not have been able to read half the story. However, not all my feedback is negative. Glasgow Boys has a greater meaning than one would expect about love, difficulties and grief. I respect the moral of the tale and have a deeper understanding of what it must feel like for those in care. I thank the author for the lesson that she has taught me and so many others who have learnt it too. I would recommend this book to people who feel comfortable with romantic happenings but would advise those who don’t and under the age of 10 to not read Glasgow Boys as it might upset or offend them. -Molly

Molly
Chiswick Carnegie

"Glasgow Boys" by Margaret McDonald was a very good book. I really enjoyed every page of it. It’s filled with many emotions with each one different from the last. It broadcasts feelings every person will experience through their life like struggle, worry, hurt, and empathy of hope along with a constant theme of identity. Very good book, highly recommend to year 9's and 10's , I wouldn't recommend to years 8's or below i think there is a lot of cussing for their age, very good story and interesting characters , outstanding . I hope every reader enjoys it just as much as I am. Overall 4/5!

Oussama
Isleworth & Syon

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald follows two boys, Finlay and Banjo, living in the Scottish city of Glasgow after being in the care system for many years. The two main characters have very different personalities that definitely shone through in their respective chapters; Finlay’s chapters were much more concise and easier to understand while Banjo’s chapters included a lot of swearing, which highlighted his tragic backstory. I loved that the author didn’t sugarcoat anything or tell a watered-down version of life in poverty, deprivation and the care system, and that the characters were very well-developed. Although you couldn’t relate to them unless you have faced the same challenges they have, you could fully grasp and understand their situation. The book explores themes like loss, identity, masculinity and forgiveness. The only thing I would change about this book is that I wanted more interaction between the main characters throughout the entire story, rather than just at the end. I also wanted a clearer ending, however on the other hand it might have been better if it was left for the readers to fill in the blanks. Overall, this is my favourite Carnegie book I have read, and I would definitely recommend it to a friend.

Abby
JGHS Shadowers

“Glasgow Boys” by Margaret McDonald is full of hope and was an enjoyable read for me. It is written with two perspectives – Banjo and Finlay. I honestly thought that the book was about the love story between the boys, but I later realised it was a platonic love. Banjo tries to settle into his new foster home, and I admire him for trying to control his anger and violence, which was a result of his trauma. I think the girl Banjo falls in love with – Alena – really helps him with this by being very understanding and this shows that they have a loving bond. When Banjo was checking on Alena before and after her surgery it made me realise just how much he cares about her. Finlay on the other hand comes from care and starts his nursing degree at university – personally I really liked learning about his training experience. Eventually, Banjo decides to get in touch and apologise to Finlay for their fallout that happened three years prior. The way that Finlay was able to recover somewhat from his suicide attempt made me feel happy and hopeful. I really loved reading about the completely different lives the boys had and how they were always linked, even when they were separated. I loved this book as it was very wholesome, and I would recommend it. I rate it 8/10.

Hannah
Augustine’s Carnegie Challenge

Abby
JGHS Shadowers

Glasgow boys by Margaret McDonald is a truthful, heart wrenching story about trauma and the effect it has on us. The story is told from two perspectives: the perspective of Banjo and the perspective of Finlay. Both of the boys have had experience in the care system and are trying to start fresh. For banjo that means finishing high school and for Finlay it means training for his nursing degree. However with unsolved conflict from the past still looming over, the two boys find it hard to forget. But as the story continues and relationships emerge, the boys begin to step out of their bubbles, things start to change. They start to change. I really enjoyed this book and the way it was written, each character had their own personality and skill set yet they both were connected. I thought it was pure and reflected well on the way people going through difficulties similar to Banjo and Finlay would feel. I would very much recommend this novel and I hope you enjoy it as much as I did!

Alice
JGHS Shadowers

Glasgow Boys completely surprised me—in the best way. I picked it up thinking it would be perhaps a romance between the two boys based on the blurb, but it turned out to be something so much more heartfelt and wholesome than I expected. It was still kind of a love story in a way but their own separate ones, but i found the stories linked and were intertwined. The characters felt real and easy to connect with, and the relationships between them were genuinely touching. There's a warmth running through the story that made it hard to put down. I found myself smiling a lot more than I expected, and even the quieter, emotional moments hit just right. It was such an enjoyable read from start to finish, and I honestly didn’t want it to end. If you’re looking for something comforting, character-driven, and full of heart, I’d totally recommend Glasgow Boys. Don’t let the blurb fool you—it’s way better than it lets on.

Trinity
Augustine’s Carnegie Challenge

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald is a dramatic novel that is a split story, one following Banjo, and one following Finlay, both boys live in the Glasgow area. Finlay and Banjo lived in care for a large amount of their life, and Finlay is still adjusting to life by himself, Banjo still lives with foster parents. This story deals with themes of bullying, feeling like you don’t belong and past trauma. This is a wonderful book, and I would definitely recommend it to my friends.

Clem
Parmiter’s Carnegie Book Shadows

Personally, I very much enjoyed this book. I found that the story was very fleshed out and I was quite unable to put the book down until I finished it. I think that is good indicator that this was a good book, especially when it made me somber when I finished it simply because it was over. I also quite enjoyed the flashbacks, which helped explain a lot and were very well understood as memories and not a part of the present time in the storyline. The only problems I had when I only found the Scots Glossary at the end of the book and when I initially had problems distinguishing between the characters' perspectives. I think if there was a clear note saying there was a Glossary at the back of the book, that would be more helpful. The perspective switching between the two boys was easy to understand when I got more used to it so I'd say that's more of a personal issue on my part. Overall I think this is a very good book.

Phoebe
BFS Umbra Readers

This book gave me high expectation, and it definitely met my expectation. This book will have swearing, but I think that it shows reality, and makes it more realistic and relatable. This book was hard to put down and was making me second guess. The story is an 8/10 but the way they output the story, made it to a 9/10.

Seb
BFS Umbra Readers

I think that in a way, this book was pretty inspirational. It’s about two different people who knew each other a while ago, and parted ways on bad terms. Also, the stress and problems in life that follows it, and the hope when they see each other again. It shows that sometimes you make wrong decisions, and end up carrying the guilt for a long time---but I probably just took it in a really deep way! Overall, I really enjoyed it, and would recommend.

Vanya
TPS Carnegie Collective

I blame myself for the initial skepticism I had - I could not be happier that this book went well above and beyond my expectations! Finlay and Banjo are such well-written characters, and I thoroughly enjoyed learning everything about their lives from regrets and misunderstandings to struggles with family and love. Their own paths were so elegantly crafted to diverge and merge at just the right places, and the suspense of the slowly revealed truth was just perfect. Reading this was being whisked away on a cathartic journey and getting a peek into the vulnerable, innermost thoughts and feelings of both characters. I experienced an emotional connection with the characters and felt all the hurt, love, anguish and so much more as if I was standing right next to them, going on the same path. The writing was that good!! Needless to say, I absolutely adored the pace and style, and generally just Margaret’s writing as a whole. All the plot elements are so well balanced and executed and it really has everything you could ask for in a book. And I could go on for a while but I couldn’t possibly capture the exquisite flow of words this book is and claim I’ve done it justice. But after nearly being moved to tears by the ending how could I not rate this a 10/10? Though I haven’t finished the other books yet, I have a slight hunch this will be my favourite. I’d also like to wholeheartedly thank Margaret McDonald for gifting us with an absolute gem - I could feel her love of Glasgow seeping through the pages, and I can only aspire to love like her. Please go and read this, I genuinely doubt you will regret it.

Claire
Watford Girls

This book was really enjoyable. It covers the short period of several years between two foster children, Finlay and Banjo, after their fallout three years previous. They both met at St Andrews's care home, a station before being assigned to a foster family, and the silent, sullen Finlay became almost immediate friends with his unexpected room partner, Banjo, who is suffering with withdrawal and violence. The unexpected pair both come from difficult backgrounds, and have never experienced the love of a family. However, it all comes crashing down when Finlay admits to Banjo that he's gay. Long story short- they both stop being friends, and Finlay ends up on the verge of suicide. But, most of the book is about their lives after the shocking ordeal, and how Banjo settles in with his new foster family, and Finlay survives a nursing course at university. The incredibly lovable characters, Alena, Julie, Carlos, Rhonda, Akash and more made this an interesting and relevant novel. I particularly liked the relationship between Banjo and Alena, both going through difficult circumstances. I found it a bit slow at the beginning, but it was well-worth it in the end! I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a heartfelt, emotional read and the unusual dynamics between friendships and different types of love.

Emily
Carnegie Elizabethans

This book by Margaret McDonald is about two boys, Banjo and Finlay, who have grown up in the care system in Scotland. They first met in a group home and formed a strong bond, helping each other through tough times before they were separated. The story follows what happens when they meet again later in life. I really liked this book because it’s full of love, care, and emotion. The author writes in a way that made me feel both the pain and the joy of the characters. I would definitely recommend it.

Isabella
Rainbeau Readers

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald is a compelling story centred around two young boys (in alternating chapters) and how they navigate life after the foster care system. It highlights how tough and unfair the system can be, the emotional tolls it can take on a young mind and how flawed it is. Most importantly, this book demonstrates how life lasting friendships and love can form in unexpected places and circumstances, and that life always has a way of making you face your past. I would recommend this book as the story is very easy to follow, and it’s very beautifully written.

Mathilde
4Shadowers

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald is an emotional novel about two teenage boys growing up in Glasgow while dealing with their own struggles and pasts. The main characters, Finlay and Banjo, come from difficult backgrounds and Finlay becomes a nursing student who when he was little grew up in care, and Banjo is a young teen trying to settle into a new foster home. Their lives slowly become connected throughout the book, and it explores how their friendship helps them both. What makes this book stand out is how real and honest it feels. The story doesn’t sugar-coat anything, and it looks closely at things like mental health, trust, grief, and how young men deal with emotions in a world that often tells them to hide how they feel. The writing is clear and emotional, and the characters are easy to feel for and relate to in some aways. Even though the story deals with some heavy topics, it’s also full of hope. Margret McDonald does a great job showing what it’s like to grow up feeling like an outsider in such a buys town such as Glasgow where they don’t know their way around or who to talk to really.

Oscar
Bookwizards

This book is amazing! All about friendships, relationships and life as a teenager in general, Glasgow Boys really had me hooked from page 1. I was so invested into Banjo and Finlay’s lives, it felt as if I was there with them. I really recommend this book for any teenager or young adult looking for an emotional yet relatable story.

Violet
Loyal Judging Society

You know, when I first heard this book was a candidate for the Carnegies and I heard what it was about, I thought (Fantastic, Orphans) I have changed my mind since then, now I think this is a candidate that should win. I loved it, Finlay being all timid and trying to navigate through college with not much help, was so sad to watch. Banjo's story is equally as tragic, he had parents who abused him and he was in withdrawal because they put him on prescription drugs and he didn't want anyone's help. That nearly made me cry. I also thought the story was wrapped up very well, with Banjo and Finlay's stories coming together beautifully. I do wish that Kyle wasn't forgiven since he LITERALY WATCHED BANJO NEARLY DROWN, but I guess nothing can be perfect. Actually I take that back, this book is perfect. Banjo's foster parents not being horrible to him was also a nice touch, since I hate stories where the main character is orphaned and is put in a bad home where no one loves him or her, but in this case, Banjo is loved. Loved both romances, Banjo and Alena were hilarious and Finlay and Akash were just brilliant. Excellent work Margaret, I am terribly sorry for judging your work and please write more characters with a voice like Banjo's, please and thank you.

Thomas
Rebel Readers

I think this was an amazing read, thought provoking, emotional and a complete gem of a book. From the very start to the beautiful end, I thoroughly enjoyed this. It explored themes of joy, distrust, pain, and the struggle that so many orphans that go through the care system experience. I couldn't put it down for hours after my bedtime, and though this book managed to tire me in this way, looking forward to the morning, when I could carry on reading, really lifted my spirits.

James
DauntseysShadowTeam

Too many thoughts, no words. READ THIS!! absolutely amazing storyline and thought provoking as well. Beautiful romance but not one you can predict from the start. READ NOW!

Max&Maria
DauntseysShadowTeam

I could go on and on about how amazing this book is, but I don't think I'd be able to get across how wonderful this book is. I genuinely couldn't put this book down, I read it through meals because I was so hooked. You fall in love with both characters, and you root for them throughout the entire book and you cry when it finishes because it's that good.

Eliza
DauntseysShadowTeam

This book was so enjoyable I finished it in 3 days. It tells the story of two long-lost friends trying to survive in a new environment whilst constantly coming face to face with new challenges or problems. Throughout the book, there were many flashbacks, and as you keep reading them you piece together bit by bit what happened to the two friends to make their friendship fall apart. The story eventually comes to a happy ending, when the two boys have overcome all their fears and the haunting past. It was one of the best books I read, and i strongly recommend it to anyone willing to give it a try.

Jayin
4Shadowers

'Glasgow Boys' by Margaret McDonald is a really powerful book that dives into friendship, survival, and what it means to grow up in tough circumstances. It follows Finlay and Banjo, two foster kids trying to figure out who they are and where they belong. The writing is sharp and full of emotion, making it feel real and raw. McDonald doesn’t shy away from the hard stuff—she shows the messy side of growing up while still keeping moments of warmth and humor. Even though I can tell it’s an amazing book, there were moments when I wasn’t as hooked, but that’s probably because it’s not the genre I usually read. I know I’m a little biased since I lean toward different kinds of stories, but I can still appreciate how well-written and deeply impactful it is. It’s the kind of book that sticks with you, making you think about identity, family, and the way people shape each other’s lives. Definitely worth a read!

Tayanya
Marshland Readers

Reading Glasgow Boys wasn't the time-pass activity I thought it would be. It was an experience—an adventure through the lives of Finlay and Banjo. And I enjoyed it—every. single. moment. It's an amazing book, that's for sure.

Anirudh
4Shadowers

The Glass Boy: Nobody is Looking by Julian Magovern is a touching and imaginative story about a boy made of glass who feels invisible to the world. As he journeys through a quiet desert landscape in search of connection and understanding, readers are drawn into a beautifully illustrated and poetic world. The book explores themes like loneliness, identity, and friendship in a gentle and thoughtful way, making it meaningful for both children and adults. While the story moves at a slow, reflective pace, it allows for emotional depth and quiet beauty. Overall, it's a memorable and heartfelt read—I’d give it 4 out of 5 stars.

Zara
BAS READING CHAMPIONS

honestly Glasgow Boys is one of the best books I have ever read, I would recommend it to anyone.

Davide
TPS Carnegie Collective

I loved this book! It was really enjoyable and I loved the way it had two perspectives in the book to really break up the story and keep you intrigued. My favourite character was Banjo because I loved his personality and kindness towards Alena as the side characters added a lovely implement to the story. Overall, a lovely book with a nice ending

Ananya S
Herts and Essex

I loved the character Alexa in this book as she is so outgoing and bubbly. She is very kind even through her illness. My favourite part in the story is when Finlay and Akash cook together as they have an amazing friendship, and later, relationship. I liked how the book did flashbacks to Finlay and Banjo’s past. I would recommend this book as it shows how people cope with grief and addiction.

Marianna
The SBSJs

Finlay just started school and met some new friends, and then a boy that went to his primary school but hadn't recognised him. Banjo has been to too many foster homes and he is finally settling with his foster parents. He had a troubling past so his anger gets a hold of him easily. Can both of them let go of their past? I really enjoyed this book because it made me not drop the book. I wanted to find out more that happened

Michelle
VISTA Academy

I think Glasgow Boys was an interesting and really well-written book. Usually I'm not really a fan of this genre but this book was so captivating it just kept me wanting to read more. The emotions of the characters in this book can be complex but the author is just really convincing when writing about them it even feels like you're experiencing these emotions yourself. Throughout the story you really get familar with the main characters, Banjo and Finlay, and you get quite attached to them. I think also how the story is structured is a really good idea because it is written either by Finlay or Banjo's point of view which is why, I think, you can really feel like you understand their emotions. The only thing that could have been a little confusing sometimes is the juggling beetween Banjo and Finlay's stories because it creates pauses in their stories so then you might forget what happened to one character after reading on the other.

Ella CI
4Shadowers

i really like both of the perspectives of both Banjo and Finlay and I relate to Finlay because he's polish and so am I.

Emilia
Elms Judges

its an alright book but i think there is too much swearing

Tierra-Michelle
Elms Judges

One of the best books I've EVER read. Need I say any more?

Greg
Desborough Reading & Biscuit Club

I loved this book and loved the plot and storyline I found it quite touching and it was easy to read and understand which I found really nice. This wasn't my usual genre but I enjoyed it none the less. One thing I have to say is that the accents are written when the characters speak and I only found out that on the last page there is a key words translation so you can understand the language better. I enjoyed this book very much.

Emily
St Kaths

This book is really gripping right from the start and is genuinely interesting to read. It explores themes like mental health and understanding others in a deep and thoughtful way. Out of all the books on the Carnegie shortlist, I think this one handles those themes the best. Even though some of the other shortlisted books cover similar ideas, this one stood out to me because of how well it uses flashbacks and plays with time. These techniques really helped show the characters' personalities and made their experiences feel more real. The contrast between the two main characters—who are very different but still have a strong bond—made the story even more engaging. I think the way the book explains things like PTSD and panic attacks is really powerful. It helps you understand what the characters are going through and makes them feel more realistic and relatable. Overall, this is a great book about mental health, relationships, and how difficult communication can be sometimes. It might even inspire people to talk more and try to understand each other better.

Hayden
Rainbeau Readers

Glasgow boys explores the story of two boys called Banjo and Finlay. It shows the story from both of their perspectives which allows the author to slowly reveal the details of their friendship. I loved this book because of the way the author balances the serious sides of the story with funny lighthearted humour. Although the boys face hardships within the story the overall plot is very hopeful and shows a genuine coming of age story that shows them growing up, falling in love and repairing friendships.

Liam
Horsham BOok HUNTers

I found this book at first hard since Banjo’s accent is thick. However besides Banjo’s accent it was a really good book and I would thoroughly recommend to any friend.

Raf
Horsham BOok HUNTers

Glasgow Boys is a great read that is credible and easy to believe. It explores each of the characters views and choices in a detailed way. The novel alternates between two characters whose stories, at the end, begin to intertwine with the other. You can strongly understand and emphasise with each of the characters. Glasgow Boys is an in depth, emotional and empathetic book.

Sienna
Diary of a Wally Kid

Precious A
Larkmead

If I had to describe this book in 3 words, I would say: emotional, suspenseful and eye-opening. This book really showcases the struggles that foster children go through. The way McDonald displays two different view points allows the reader to understand both Finley and Banjo creating a deeper connection between the characters and the readers.

Aisha
KECHG Shadowers

I love this book. I would most definitely recommend this to Year 7. I love how it was chill at the start of the story, then there was a plot twist when the youngest son got sent in to the hospital. The teachers were so supportive of the oldest son when the youngest boy ended up in hospital they were so kind to him. I would recommend 'The Final Year' to people who love plot twist books and poems it both of them together plus if you struggle to read small type like I struggle with it, you will find this a quick and easy read. thank you for the opportunity I was a memories from primary school thank you

Nell
Woodruffians

Even though I’m only half way through this book I am enjoying every second of it. It’s filled with many emotions with each one different from the last. It broadcasts feelings every person will experience through their life like struggle, worry, hurt, empathy and a glimpse of hope along with a constant theme of identity. I hope every reader enjoys it just as much as I am.

Alisha
Watford Girls

Very good book, highly recommend, very good story and interesting characters , outstanding 9.9/10

Elizabeth
Sir Roger Manwood’s School Book Club

The exemplary, emotional read powerfully explores the social divide of individuals lost in the family and education system. Glasgow boys, although mild at the beginning, quickly becomes heavily emotional as the reader connects strongly to the two boys over the 30+ chapters to read. Amazing book and a powerful read.

Kaleb
Readerraptors

This is one of my favorite Carnegie reads. The two storylines contrasted each other perfectly!

Livie
St Kaths

I would rate this book a 8/10. This book shows how difficult the care system can be and could be relatable to people who could have been in the care system.

ethan
Kingdown

I was not looking forward to reading this book but I absolutely loved it. I was so invested in the characters, who were believable, vulnerable, and drew me in from the first chapter. Finlay and Banjo have such depth and you find yourself rooting for them, hoping each will find the happiness that they deserve. My eyes 'leaked' in the last few chapters and I may even read it again some day.

Sandy
Readerraptors

I did not really enjoy this book to much. I am not a big fan of books that primarily focus on romance.

Yusuf K
Ermysted’s

The Glasgow boys was truly outstanding for me to read it was one of the best feelings and felt like I was there with them when they suffered mental health and the hardships they had to go through. One of the best things was their reunion as they finally meet which was kind of my best part to read.

Manasva
Bookwizards

This book was quite interesting overall. It tells the stories from two perspectives, Banjo and Finlay. Banjo was my least favorite character as I thought that the amount of swearing he used was a little unnecessary to tell the story, and i found him quite violent which was a little boring. However, Finlay had many good personality traits such as being hardworking and comforting. It made his chapters more easy to read, because he actually did things rather than in Banjo's chapters where it was mostly just.... violence and Alena. It was heartfelt and had a good ending where both characters were more developed than the start. I would recommend this to people interested in real life struggles, romance, and coming of age books.

Astrid
Larkmead

this was my favourite book. I liked how the story's linked up and it was emotional there nut also was discussing a difficult topic it was hooked and I give it a 9/10

Herts and Essex

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald is a novel about two youngsters, Finlay and Banjo, who develop a special bond while being in a foster home. They get separated and few years later they meet again in Glasgow. The author tells their story by switching between their perspectives, which helps to understand the main characters truly and literally to delve into their complex personalties. Finlay has just started his first university year as a nursing student. Banjo, who is still in school, is settling in a new foster family and a school. Both struggle to build new friendships and with relationships in general as they find it hard to trust anyone. At the start of the book, there is a lot of swearing, especially in the chapters with Banjo, therefore I would recommend this book only from 13/14+. I enjoyed reading this book, the more you read the more interesting it gets.

Eric
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Glasgow boys was one of the best books I have ever read. I loved the characters of Finlay and Banjo and felt all the other characters were perfect for this book. I also really enjoyed hearing about their daily lives, friendships and feelings This book felt realistic which I liked and I also liked learning about what it was like in the care system. I thought the ending was perfect and this story was amazing. This book would be enjoyed by teenagers who love stories about friendship, romance and like to learn more about people's lives in the world.

Annie
The Maynard School

Wow! Definitely my favourite of the bunch so far, and I think this certainly has a shot at winning. I love this! This book tackles heavy topics like drug dependency, fear of abandonment and more, but it doesn’t weigh you down too much. It’s a very enjoyable read; learning about Banjo and Finlay’s lives apart and slowly piecing together their pasts makes their reunion near the end so climactic and well deserved. I also really liked that, despite the relationship between Finlay and Banjo being the main focus of the story, it isn’t forced into being a romantic one. I feel like too many stories about relationships will only focus on romance, when there’s plenty of potential for a great story with a platonic relationship at its core, as demonstrated here. Speaking of romance though, the two couples in this work exceptionally well. The dynamics between Banjo & Alena and Finlay & Akash are so well written! Both of the couples fit together so well. The characters are also really well fleshed out and consistent! They’re flawed enough to be human and interesting, while still remaining likeable. The first person perspective certainly helps this — even when the characters make poor decisions, like Banjo’s picking fights or Finlay’s self-isolation, it doesn’t seem jarring or out of character because we get to see their thought processes. It doesn’t make them seem unlikeable, because it seems like something the characters would reasonably do based on their experiences and personalities. Banjo grew up surrounded by violence, so it’s now a twisted source of comfort for him. Finlay has been abandoned by too many people too many times, so he can’t let himself get close to anyone again out of fear of losing them. This doesn’t just apply to the main characters either, even more minor characters like Kyle or Banjo’s adoptive parents have this same level of consistency. One little detail that I really liked seeing was how Banjo’s Scottish accent becomes more pronounced when he’s angry or emotional. Finally, after reading about some of Margaret MacDonald’s life, it’s no wonder how she managed to craft such a believable and real world and story about such hard-to-tackle topics. Obviously you don’t have to have experienced something to be able to write good fiction about it, but I think it certainly made a large impact on the final product. Will definitely be on the lookout for more by her! Overall, a fantastic read. I would definitely recommend this to anyone interested in it! Certainly a potential winner.

Sofia
Wyedean School

I thought that Glasgow boys was a very interesting book, and that it was quite a safe and a cosy story, that really emphasised how odd relationships can sometimes be the best.Glasgow boys has quite a safe storyline, that wasn’t in my opinion, that gripping-but I still felt for when characters were faced with trouble.I enjoyed the use of extra characters such as Alena and Akash as I loved seeing how the boys(Banjo and Finlay)can love again after their troublesome upbringings.Even though I have much a praise for this book-I must say that I found Finlay’s perspective quite tedious and repetitive-equitably monotonous.Now-I understand that Finlay represented those with trust and commitment issues, but I thought it unrealistic and quite annoying how he would continuously push people away and complain and whine about how he was so lonely-it got to a point where it became such a normal thing-that I just expected to be bored whilst reading his POV.Although my tough thoughts on Finlay’s perspective,I am glad that I now know and(hopefully)can help a future or current friend in a situation where they want to commit, but can’t, and I do feel for him.On a happier note,I adored Banjo-he was funny, interesting and I thought it was so lovely how his issues and relationships developed and how by the end of the book he was happy.I did enjoy how the author made the story line quite cosy-but I can’t help but think that the major events could of been slightly more gripping?I don’t know, but they got kind of glossed over and swept under the rug quite quickly; except for when Finlay would stress out about them.On the contrary, it did make the story seem more realistic and life-like as sometimes life’s events are just simply brushed over.I’ve already used this adjective too many times, but if I were to describe Glasgow boys with one word -it would be cosy-as it is a book I will remember as I loved the message about how every relationship matters and no relationship is odd-just unique.Although it was warm and safe-it changed my perspective on how I view different relationships.Overall, I would recommend this book to people due to the story and underlying message rather than the plot.

Lucy
Logs

This book review is about the book called Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald. Meet Finlay, the boy studying at Glasgow university for his nursing degree. Then he suddenly meets Akash, an old friend again. What should he do? Follow his feelings or not? Meet Banjo, a boy with an explosive temper. Will he find love and happiness? But one thing is for sure, they need to confront the past before it threatens to spin their lives out of control. This outstanding book must be on everyone's must read list. In my opinion this superb book has everything that I enjoy reading in books: Drama, friendship, love and many cliffhangers. Banjo does an excessive amount of swearing, which is a little tiresome, though, in my opinion it does add a hint of realism to this book. I give this book 4.8 stars out of 5 stars. I recommend this book to those aged 13 to 14.

Danny
Europa Champs

This book was so good and so sad, it really describes what growing up in care is like, moving from home to home, and never feeling the feeling of having a safe home. I cried at the end and I think everyone who reads it will too.

Kaitlyn
UCC Avid Readers

Wow! What a rollercoaster of a read! I loved this. The two protagonists are so different yet both so alone and isolated in the world. The true tragedy of their worlds is revealed through the emotional rollercoaster of their stories. I really loved Banjo; his story of settling in to a new family, new school was funny and heart breaking at the same time. Due to his past his struggles to control his emotions and the writer deliberately gives us little snippets of the past until we have pieced the jigsaw together. One can only imagine what life was like for him and the writer does this exceptionally well. I just wanted to give Banjo a hug. I totally recommend this novel for anyone who is interested in relationships, love, school life and the raw emotions that accompanies abuse and trauma. A fantastic debut; I'm on the look out for this writer's next book.

Deb
Lost in Pages

I am not someone who tends to read anything that isn't fantasy romance or historical fiction, so 'Glasgow Boys' at first seemed like a huge step out my comfort zone. Written by an up-and-coming modern author, it weaves a web of heartbreak, complicated relationships and two boys struggling with their past. But despite my normal reading preferences, within the first few pages of this book, I was hooked. It was a surprise to me that I loved it so much, but also showed me that perhaps I should give other genres a try. I think Margaret McDonald touched upon difficult topics in a very sensitive and easy-to-read way, and made these topics accessible to a range of readers from different backgrounds and experiences. The book didn't, happily, end exactly as I had imagined it would. In parts of the story, there was the occasional twist in the plot, but the twists weren't extremely shocking, just slightly surprising. All in all, I am glad that I stepped out of my comfort zone, and read a book about modern times written by someone who is still alive. Thanks to 'Glasgow Boys', in future, I am going to try and read more modern books. It was a thrilling tale, brilliantly and delicately written, with lovable characters and an intriguing plot. Thank you Margaret McDonald.

Isabel
The Maynard School

Firstly I have to say that this book was massively out of my comfort zone and I was only really reading it because it was a Carnegie book but I must say I was so surprised at how much I actually enjoyed this book. I think that my favourite thing about this book is the use of the foster system that I and I imagine many other readers didn't fully understand or at least never really thought about how it would be for people in foster care. With books in general I do find I will always connect to each character but never really this much when I wasn't expecting or properly trying to, I even found myself wishing for people to get together which I have NEVER done before. Overall Glasgow Boys for me was a pretty good book but in terms of my expectations it completely knocked it out the park. I would definitely recommend this even if, like me, you would never really read anything remotely similar away from the Carnegies.

Freya
The Maynard School

This book is told from the perspective of Finlay and Banjo, who were each other’s only friends before they argued. Now they haven’t spoken to each other for years and are trying to find their way in life - Banjo in a foster home, trying not to get into fights, and Finlay trying to balance university and work while struggling with his sexuality. Glasgow Boys was definitely my favourite out of the seven Carnegie books I read, for the following reasons: (a) Banjo’s Scottish accent was great. (b) It dealt with some really serious issues but at the same time it was quite light-hearted, and (c) I could really relate to the characters, because I have Polish heritage, like Finlay, and was born in Glasgow - but I think even people who can’t will really enjoy it. I recommend it to everyone over the age of 11.

Zosia
Europa Champs

The book is about two boys from the foster system facing life challenges. They become friends, get separated and meet again. The story is written in first person, swapping perspectives from one character and then another. Finlay is starting his first year at university training to be a nurse, he is anxious and withdrawn. Banjo is still in school, he likes to run, struggles with friendships and has a complicated relationship with violence. I struggled to engage with the book as for me it lacked the depth of plot I usually enjoy and the pace was quite slow. I feel it would engage fans of contemporary fiction that dealt with emotions and family and friend dynamics.

Chloe
The Readinckley Book Worms

I loved the interwoven storylines. It gave a true to life insight with regards to the behaviours and feelings of kinds in care/care leavers. I really liked the characters which make a good book great. I loved hoe Fin and Banjo grew, their search for love and acceptance and how they were overcoming life's trials and challenges. It covered some real and thought provoking subjects. It was sad. it was funny. It was heartbreaking. My favourite!!!!

Inge
Ousedale Olney

I only read the first six pages of Glasgow Boys but it seemed like a good book and it got my attention quickly. I like how it is set in Scotland. Banjo has some anger issues but I think that he is still a good person.

Hannah
MSJ Shadowers

Glasow Boys is an incredible book, it has great character exploration and development throughout. The part that hooked me was the first conflict scene between Banjo and Kyle, I was intrigued and wanted to see Banjo’s reasoning behind his actions. As I read the book, I understood Banjo and his complex personality. He displays himself as tough and indestructible, which is a complete contrast to the other main character, Finlay. Finlay is shyer and more self-conscious. However, I enjoyed reading about him finding his confidence and breaking out of his shell. The writing style was also very impressive: The way the author uses the common dialect and writes words in the way are spoken makes the more seem more authentic and continuous. Overall, I would rate this book 7/8 and would definitely recommend to other people.

Stephanie
MSJ Shadowers

I really enjoyed this book and watching both characters grow and develop. What I especially loved was their intertwining storyline and how everything slowly started to make sense, and I could connect the dots. I feel Banjo was a relatable character and I liked how his past problems were presented to me as a reader. I liked how the parts about the character pasts were added to the book. However, with their being a lot of characters it was hard for me to remember who was who and sometimes I would have to look back in the book to figure out who was being talked about. I also think it would help if some of their names didn’t sound so similar. I liked how Banjo was so worried for Alena when she was in the hospital and didn’t show up for work. I love how Banjo feels and shows his emotions either way too much or not enough. Overall, this book kept me hooked and was enjoyable.

Hannah
The John Mason Shadowers

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald was a heart-wrenching story of two boys who met in the care system. It follows Finlay, in his journey through university as he learns to love and trust others, and Banjo who is struggling to control the hurt he feels. Both characters were beautifully diverse but came together as a duo equally as well and I loved the two girls in Finlay's story who helped to show him that not everyone who you care about will leave you. I found the metaphor of the airport that Finlay shares with Akash very powerful as it really showcases how troubled he feels but also that things could change in the future. Banjo's story is also heart-breaking although his relationship gives a break to the ongoing hardships described. I think the ending was perfect for such a sad story to that point and loved how the author managed to convey a sense of moving on with the next chapter of life without making it too awkward. In my opinion this book deserves a solid 10/10. I was an incredible read and I would recommend it to everyone!

Jemimah
KES Bookworms

This book i would love to win its a heart breaking and rebuilding story. Two boys come out of foster care but have not spoken in years. they build a life but something is missing. They go through so much only to find they need each other

Anastaisa Oliver
OLSB Shadowers

Reading Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald was an interesting book to read. The story follows Finlay and Banjo, two boys who grew up in care and are now trying to find their way in the world. Finlay is at university studying nursing, while Banjo is finishing high school and living with a foster family. They both face tough challenges, like dealing with their pasts and figuring out who they are. I found it really moving how the book showed their struggles with trust and connection, especially since they hadn't experienced much love or support growing up. It made me think about how important friendship and understanding are, especially when life gets hard. What stood out to me was how real the characters felt. The book doesn't shy away from serious topics like mental health and identity, but it also shows moments of hope and happiness. I liked that the chapters switched between Finlay and Banjo's perspectives, so you get to see how each of them is coping. Even though some parts were sad, the story left me feeling hopeful. It shows that even when things seem really bad, there's a chance for things to get better if you have people who care about you. also the book has flashbacks from past years when they must have been feeling happier. I'd recommend this book to other teens because it's honest, heartfelt, and reminds you that you're not alone in facing challenges also that if you have good friendships then there will always be people to support you.

Ahaan
Ardingly Carnegie Book Group

This was a book I enjoyed from the beginning but I can't say why! The use of both character viewpoints worked well. I related more to Finley through a shared experience of training to be a nurse but I recognised Banjo in students I have taught. The suspense of finding out what went wrong between them was well developed. I felt slightly let down when it was revealed as it wasn't as clear cut as I thought it would be. However on reflection guilt is often an individual feeling that doesn't follow logic. Nor is blame felt in the same depth necessarily. The memory loss of a childhood (friend) was well told. The variety of love we experience and how it impacts us was well described. I was left with an over riding feeling of how society is failing young people with a focus on those in the care system at the heart of that. It will be interesting to hear what younger readers get from the book.

Sarah
THS Shadowing

Glasgow Boys: I think Glasgow Boys had a very slow start and really started getting more intriguing from around page 70 into the hundreds and really went downhill at points. I have to say the second swimming pool scene was a massive heightening in the roller coaster of emotions and drama. It wasn't the most exciting book I've read but I really liked that there was a little index at the back for all the non-scots out there who didn't really get the slang/language that Margret McDonald executed extremely well in this sort of book. It was confusing at times and I probably wouldn't read it again but it definitely entertained me for a good two weeks. Overall rating: 6.5-7.5 / 10

Ayla
Plumites

Glasgow boys is the perfect example of raw emotion and the yearn for love within each page. It felt as though the author wrote each word with meaning and each sentence with feelings. The character development had me cheering on for each of the boys, rooting for their happy endings. This book also captured the essence of love and what family really is, and what it isn't, and what it could be.

Maryam
LPGS Readers

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald is a powerful, emotional novel about two teens, Finlay and Banjo. It’s beautifully written, capturing the pain and hope of broken families, friendship, and identity. The dual perspectives make both boys feel real and relatable, and the Glasgow setting adds authenticity. I’d definitely recommend it—especially for fans of character-driven stories that don’t shy away from tough topics.

Nailah
KECHG Shadowers

One of my favourie books of the carnegies. I loved the plot of the story and how they managed to meet up with each other towards the end of the book. I really enjoyed all of the relationships within the book and have already recommended it to friends!

Jennifer
GreatB00ks

I got attached to the characters and got invested in the story really quickly. I think it was a heartfelt story about friendship. Not only about old friends but also about connecting with someone new and accepting your mistakes and others.

Ksenia
STAGS Shadowers

One of the best books I've read this year. Margaret McDonald is a truly masterful author who perfectly weaves together Finlay and Banjo's stories while remaining ever captivating. Banjo and Finlay's struggles with mental health and their own masculinty are omnipresent in a post Andrew Tate society.

Jude
STAGS Shadowers

When I first started this book, I wasn't too sure as it's not the type of book I would normally pick up. However, this book led to be one of my best reads of this year! The style of writing was really good and the plot was so amazing - I even shed a few tears. I could not put this book down and finished it in under 2 days!

Mia
STAGS Shadowers

I only enjoyed the chapters with banjo especially with his character development but the book would have been better without finlay

mahad.k
Ermysted’s

I really disliked this book for the reason that while it is aimed at 13+, the amount of swearing on almost every page made the book difficult to read,un enjoyable and annoying,I felt that much swearing was unecceasry. On the other hand,the plot was heartfelt and the bond between the two boys was nice as the both related to foster care,I agree that this creates an emotional bond with the reader which supports the event that happen within the story such as violent fighting/bullying.

Candice
Bogle’s Book Worms

Glasgow Boys Margaret McDonald This book is about two adolescents, Finlay and Banjo, who met in the care system when they were growing up but haven't spoken to each other for several years. Though Finlay is studying for a nursing degree at Glasgow University, and Banjo is starting high school, they both share feelings of loneliness, frustration and memories of what happened in their past. As the plot unfolds, Banjo is supported to realise that there is more to life than acceptance, and that vulnerability isn't a weakness but that it helps him to connect with others. We also learn as readers the reason for their falling-out, and how they are drawn back together and learn together how to let go of the past. It was a bit hard to get into, but as the characters develop the plot becomes more gripping and emotional. Both Finlay and Banjo both felt very real, especially with Banjo’s accent, and I think that Glasgow Boys spreads more awareness about the care system and those in care. My favourite part of the book was the end because it was emotional, and the ending tied up all the loose ends and was satisfying in general. The scenes of emotional outbursts, of anger, grief and frustration were quite well written – the arguments felt real and believable, and made the book more gripping. I think that it is a generally a good read, because though it was sometimes confusing switching between perspectives, it made the book more interesting and memorable, as well as the complex characters and plot. I would recommend this book to ages 12+ because of some strong language, but I think that it is an especially good book for teenagers because it highlights what some teenagers go through at this stage in their lives. I give it a rating 3/5 because it was a bit hard to get into, though generally good.

Lydia
SHSK Shadowers

I think this book is really touching, and it allowed me to fully absorb all the emotions the characters felt. It’s heartwarming and explores important parts of everyday life, like friendship, family, and identity. I would definitely recommend this book because it deals with themes that many of us can relate to and need in our daily lives. The story is so gripping that I was completely hooked until the very last page. I also really enjoyed the flashbacks of the main characters, as they took us into their memories and helped explain some of their actions.

Charlotte
Rainbeau Readers

This book follows two estranged teenage friends who grew up in the care system- Finlay, who is studying nursing at university without much support, and Banjo, who is struggling in both high school and his new foster home. Three years after their unfortunate last meeting, the two find and reconcile with each other. The third person narrative switches between Finlay’s and Banjo’s perspectives, including flashbacks from three years ago, bringing these characters to life. Glasgow Boys carries an emotional message about love and healing from trauma. I would recommend this book to Young Adult readers, although it includes potentially triggering subjects such as self harm, child abuse and mentions taking drugs.

Anna
LGGS Shadow Questers

I LOVED Glasgow Boys. It is a beautiful story told from two different perspectives from boys that grew up in the care system. Both of the boys’ personalities and backstories were detailed and intricate, and I really enjoyed reading both of their perspectives because of how easy to read and understand they were. The characters were easy to get to know (in a sense) and I enjoyed reading about their lives and why they did the things they did in accordance to their backstories. I preferred Glasgow Boys to Little Bang because I found the characters to be more developed and likeable, and as well as tackling the theme of the book, it gave an interesting and developed plot, unlike Little Bang, where the theme was discussed well but the plot fell flat. The ending was very heartwarming and satisfying as well! I would rate this book a 10/10 because of how easy and accessible it is to read and also how well it gives insight to the reader about living in care. Margaret McDonald writes funny, deeply personal characters and I enjoyed every minute reading this book. :D

Amélie
Sutton Shadows

Glasgow Boys by Margret McDonald Glasgow Boys is a sweet, heart wrenching book about two conflicted boys trying to live life. Finlay has just left care as he is 18 years old and in university training to be a nurse. Heavily Scottish-accented Banjo is still in care, but only has a year left of the protection of his foster parents as he is 17. The book follows Finlay around uni, where he meets two girls and makes friends with them quick, and develops a crush on Akash, a boy from his past. Banjo goes to a new school and joins the athletics team, where he unfortunately makes lots of enemies. Things seem alright so far don’t they? Well, every few switches between Banjo and Finlay, there is a section from their shared past. When they where both in a place for kids without foster parents yet. Past Finlay discovers that Banjo suffered child abuse, his now-behind-bars-parents beating him up and then giving him painkillers to knock him out, so he’s out of the way. Banjo suffered violent withdrawal, and as his parents used to beat him up, he often gets in fights so he can be punched. Banjo starts working in a café because he wants to find a sense of community and normality, and Finlay gets his first job as a cleaner in primary schools, before school time. Both struggle with friendships and relationships, as their pasts of violence, abuse, neglect and loss stands in their way of love and affection- both ways. This is an amazing book and it is definitely worth the read. This book will break your heart and then patch it up again- before re-breaking it. Glasgow Boys makes you realise how lucky we are to have a good family and friends, and makes you think about how many children go through life as Finlay or Banjo- but don’t get their happy ending. McDonald is a brilliant author who published a brilliant book, which I would rate 9.5/10, and is suitable for people who are 11+.

Cora
SHSK Shadowers

Glasgow Boys is a sweet, heart wrenching book about two conflicted boys trying to live life. Finlay has just left care as he is 18 years old and in university training to be a nurse. Heavily Scottish-accented Banjo is still in care, but only has a year left of the protection of his foster parents as he is 17. The book follows Finlay around uni, where he meets two girls and makes friends with them quick, and develops a crush on Akash, a boy from his past. Banjo goes to a new school and joins the athletics team, where he unfortunately makes lots of enemies. Things seem alright so far don’t they? Well, every few switches between Banjo and Finlay, there is a section from their shared past. When they where both in a place for kids without foster parents yet. Past Finlay discovers that Banjo suffered child abuse, his now-behind-bars-parents beating him up and then giving him painkillers to knock him out, so he’s out of the way. Banjo suffered violent withdrawal, and as his parents used to beat him up, he often gets in fights so he can be punched. Banjo starts working in a café because he wants to find a sense of community and normality, and Finlay gets his first job as a cleaner in primary schools, before school time. Both struggle with friendships and relationships, as their pasts of violence, abuse, neglect and loss stands in their way of love and affection- both ways. This is an amazing book and it is definitely worth the read. This book will break your heart and then patch it up again- before re-breaking it. Glasgow Boys makes you realise how lucky we are to have a good family and friends, and makes you think about how many children go through life as Finlay or Banjo- but don’t get their happy ending. McDonald is a brilliant author who published a brilliant book, which I would rate 9.5/10

Cora
SHSK Shadowers

Glasgow boys is a brilliant book that delves into the life of two boys -Banjo and Finlay both who went through similar things and are both trying to get through life and fit in. Finlay who's just starting university and Banjo who's getting used to his new foster family and school. My thoughts on reading the book - it was brilliant. Sometimes I had a good laugh, other times I was left in a mix of shock and, frankly, sadness. A story that speaks about the struggles with people in specific foster situations and how they learn to live with that and get through it really got to me and allowed me to reach a greater understanding in life. I'd love to read this again and again. 5/5

Bethan
Book Squad

Aurelia
Europa Champs

Glasgow Boys focuses on two boys, Finlay ( who is still grappling with the fact he might be gay) and Banjo (who is scared that his anger might ruin everything) trying to find their way in the world and not let anyone know their past in foster care. Through love and turmoil, hate and care, will they be able to refrain from returning to their old ways? Glasgow boys is an amazing book that dives head first into a world of chaos and love. I would recommend this book to readers that are 13+ as there are so dark scenes and to readers that like gay books. If you are not into tension and/or violence this book is not for you! Still, I loved it! 9 out of 10

Aurelia
Europa Champs

Absolutely beautiful. An artful mixture of two different points of view expressed by two completely different speaking styles and dialects. Finlay with his soft, socially withdrawn attitude, craving for a fresh start and Banjo with his violent thoughts, anger issues and foul mouth, weighed down with regret and asking himself whether it’s a fresh start that he needs. This book shows them separately trying their best to fit in while letting us glimpse at the flashbacks of their shared past. I admire the way the author has structured the flashbacks: they progressively tell the entire backstory so that we know what happened that made the boys the way they are and how their relationship was affected, and by the time we have a clear picture, everything changes. This book provides an insight to the lives of people in care and I recommend it to everyone.

Aarna CI
4Shadowers

Such a tender story of both friendship and love. This is a powerful story of hurt and whether the barriers we put up to prevent us being hurt again can be dismantled. Plenty to think about after reading this novel which traces the story of two young men, one starting university and one in his final year of secondary school in Glasgow. Their paths have obviously crossed before, but how and what happened?

Ms Shakhov
Carnegie@StBede’s

The book is about two boys – Banjo and Finlay – who are both trying to fit in. They both knew each other from their adoption centre. Finlay is trying to finish his degree at Glasgow University, except he has no support network, whilst trying to find paid work and not fall in love. Meanwhile, Banjo is trying to settle in with his foster family, but his anger keeps getting the best of him – threatening his uncertain future. I really enjoyed how this book was set in Glasgow, as most books I read are set in either England or America. As well as this, I liked how the story had two points of view, which joined together towards the end. I found this quite exciting and different to the type of books I usually read. However, I didn’t really enjoy how Banjo’s accent is written – with words like “jus” instead of “just”, making it hard to follow sometimes what was being said, but I found the ‘glossary’ at the back quite useful. Overall, I loved this book and would recommend it to others (perhaps older readers, as it contains some mature aspects regarding ‘relationships’). Four stars out of five. ****

Aleena
Rockwood Reads

Really good book - I enjoyed it a lot but it was too short for my liking. I would give this book a 8 out of 10

Toby
QEGS CARNEGIE BOOK CLUB

Glasgow boys is a book which explores the care system for children without suitable parents. It is narrated by the two main characters, Finlay and Banjo. In my opinion, the book was very slow, and failed to draw me in. The themes have a lot of possibility, but the book is merely a mundane read.

Tejas
Colchester Royal Grammar School

Glasgow Boys is a beautiful, touching tale on learning to love and be loved. Readers experience a story of hurt and struggle but also of kindness and hope. We meet two boys who are running from their past, and who are fighting to keep their heads above water. Finlay, who can barely afford enough food to live and Banjo who holds so much anger and pain, it controls him. We watch them make connections with good people and find interests that help them understand their emotions. McDonald brings us along on their road to happiness and I enjoyed every swerve and bump. Finlay and Banjo are a beautiful example of a deep, loving bond that, at points in this book, both breaks and warms your heart.

Elle
KES Bookworms

Despite having a challenge at the start to understand Banjo’s Glaswegian accent, it became quite fun to read and learn the stories of the separated friends. It almost seems as if they become honorary brothers by the end of the book. I really enjoyed Glasgow boys and would definitely recommend it and read it again.

Holly
Horsham BOok HUNTers

Glasgow boys is an interesting story told by the perspectives of both of the main characters. However, I found it a little difficult to follow. I was often unsure which character's perspective I was reading, and what was going on. I also thought that the Scottish Slang was also rather difficult to read, I understand that it was important for the story, but often found myself skipping key bits purely because I could not understand the words.

Alice
Diary of a Wally Kid

I like how this book is written from the boys' different points of views and follows them on their journey and their struggles. It wasn't my favourite read from all 8 books and it did take some time to get into it.

Josh
The WH shadowers

A moving book that shows the lives of two boys and their lives in and after the care system.

Plum
St Kaths

I couldn’t put this book down. I was immediately drawn into the lives of the characters and deeply moved by the past and present challenges they faced . The story offers an honest portrayal of what it’s like to be placed in care, capturing the loneliness and emotional impact with raw authenticity. Every character felt compelling in their own way, and I found myself truly caring about what happened to them. It was an emotional roller coaster and I even cried at the end. This book is perfect for helping teenage readers develop empathy and understanding for others' experiences.

Céline
Sandroyd Bookivores

Glasgow Boys explores the different perspectives on life from two boys, Finlay and Banjo. Its a deeply moving and heart warming book that shows what its like growing up in a care system and the realities of the world.

Xander
Ardingly Carnegie Book Group

Glasgow boys was a really emotive and beautiful book. I liked how it was a dual narrative and how the reader got an insight into both Banjo and Finlay's lives in the present and flashbacks to the past from when they lived together. I think Margaret McDonald described and captured how both the characters feelings took over them and overwhelmed them. For example, Banjo and his anger and Finlay and his anxiety. Some parts made me laugh and others made me sad but I think there was a good balance between the two feelings. I was very engaged throughout the whole book and I really enjoyed it.

Chloe
Ardingly Carnegie Book Group

"Love me, just love me, even if it's hard and painful , please just do it, Banjo thinks. He needs Finlay to be the one to do it." Banjo, a seventeen-year-old foster child, has grown up with a fighting spirit, using aggression as a way to prove himself, but in doing so, he has pushed away those who care about him. However, a job at a cafe and a budding friendship with a troubled young girl, Alena, begin to show him that there is more to life than just violence and that he can find happiness and acceptance. Through his interactions with others, Banjo learns that he can trust them and let them in, and that vulnerability isn’t a weakness “... he wanted this tender love. He wanted someone to come along and adore him, and he wanted to adore them in return.” The narrator desperately longed for a tender, loving connection with someone who would appreciate and adore them in return. It was a story that moved them deeply, filled with beauty, courage, and warmth. The narrative transitioned effortlessly between the present day, with the perspectives of the two main characters, while also delving into their past to reveal how they once were friends. The book was a smooth read, with a natural and easy-to-follow writing style that made it easy to understand and relate to both of the characters’ experiences..

Owami
MHHS Shadowers

What a book! Makes one realise how important it is to have a support network. What a struggle for these two boys life has been and how difficult it has to be to trust people again. Although these boys are totally different, they have so much in common. Enjoy this book and cherish your friends and family!

Miss Geval
Balla Bookworms

I really enjoyed this book and how well thought out and different the characters were. I liked the ending and how the characters life graduallly began to improve 😄😄

Amelia
GreatB00ks

I liked this book because it had very realistic problems in it that can happen to anyone such as taking drugs and withdrawal. You can relate to the characters a lot. I sometimes found it a bit boring though because there wasn't very many exciting parts in it. Overall, I quite liked the book but I wouldn't read it again.

beth
Saltash Sprightly Scholars

I couldn't put this book down! It took me through every emotion and the ending made me cry, which isn't something that happens often. I definitely felt like I had gone through a journey with the characters and I became very invested in their outcomes. What a book! I recommend this very highly!

Mrs Shaw
Ely College Reading Group

I loved this book so much. The story progressed very quickly and I loved the flashbacks where the main characters interact with each other. The author described their emotions so well I thought I was with them through the whole entire story. I honestly couldn't put this book down once I had started reading.

Lena
Rainbeau Readers

Glasgow boys is an awsome book that I would recommend to anyone. It covers a variety of important issues with thought and nuance and highlights some of the issues that we have in society that tens to not be so talked about. While also being a hopeful story with truly nuanced characters that you can still root for . It is the kind of book that I try to push into the hands of as many people as possible as I think that it is a hopeful and incredible read while also being really important.

Izzy
Bennett Memorial Book Group

Starting off, the book starts with a brief introduction of Banjo; A short tempered, short, ginger 17 year old boy. As you turn to the next chapter, they introduce Finlay: Quite the opposite of Banjo; quiet, shy and studying for his nursing degree at the university of glasgow. The author touches on the early life of the boys on the end of each chapter, talking about their years together in foster care and their dependent relationship with one and other like pieces in a puzzle. She talks about their tense separation and how each boy went their own way and cut contact off completely with one-and-other and finally nearing the end how they came together. dropped their past behind them and let it all go for just a hug, reconciling.

Kian
Bookwizards

This book was a stunning blend of all the emotions. It tells the story of 2 boys straight from the care system. We meet Finlay who has just started university and is struggling with how to balance work, sleep and uni. We learn about his struggles and his drives but most importantly the fact that the people you love in life will always be there for you, you just have to let them in. We also meet Banjo who is just finishing high school and is trying hard to settle down with his new foster family. But due to all the anger and despair that Banjo has trapped inside he tends to get into fights. But, like Finlay we learn many things about Banjo, his strengths and his weaknesses but most importantly what it means to be the best version of yourself. This book stood out from any other book that I had read before, and I think it is because the main characters are in the care system. This factor brought a beautifully different dimension to the book. It was heart - wrenchingly gorgeous and everyone needs to read Glasgow Boys right now.

Lucy
The Maynard School

‘Glasgow Boys’ is about Banjo and Finlay- two boys that grew up in foster care- and their journeys through uni and high school. They both struggle with their past in different ways, and as they mature, find love, and have new experiences, they begin to miss their past relationship. I absolutely loved this book. The way it flowed seemed almost poetic, a style I really enjoy. It felt really raw and honest and beautiful. It’s a great coming-of-age story for teens- especially those in foster care. I really enjoyed how relatable certain bits were. My favourite character was Alexa because she seemed really confident and supportive. I would rate it 9.5/10.

Hannah
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Glasgow boys is one of the best books I have read in my time at Ermysteds. It shows the difficulties of being gay and how it can come across to others. Banjo is a great example of this as when he finds out that Finlay is gay and has been hiding it from him. He is very angry at how who he thought was a friend, had betrayed him and hid secrets from him.

sam w
Ermysted’s

Wow what a fantastic read. I had not expected to enjoy this so much. There was only one disappointment - when I got to the end! I wanted more. The story is told from two perspectives - Banjo and Finley. This is a great way to keep the narrative interesting and the characters are really well built, written in such a way that you really feel for them and care about them. Both boys have had a really difficult upbringing in the Scottish care system, children's homes, foster homes and the book starts with Finley becoming of age, leaving care and going to University and Banjo starting at yet another school. The link between them is revealed gradually throughout the book. It is a story of intense hardship, friendship and first love. My favourite read this year without a doubt.

Rachel
Floydians

I think it's a good read. I really like the relationship between the characters. It makes it feel relatable. I didn't learn anything from the book but to me it was a fun book to read and I do think it's suitable for a coming of ages audience specifically 12-16 years old. The book is honest and insightful and the theme is one I think more people need to read about or learn about- it's not something talked openly about I don't think. The glossary at the back was a good idea for those who found the dialect used difficult. Such clever writing, 7.5/10

Rudra
The WH shadowers

This book was one of the more interesting books I've read. The book showed two different perspectives but didn't make it too complex. The two characters were very different but also had one thing in common- they both didn't have parents.-

Mujtaba
Ermysted’s

Finding a family Being a teenager is difficult. Managing your studies, your part-time job, your friends, your enemies, trying to fit in, trying to mark yourself out… You could add dealing with your family to that list, but the truth is, a lot of us are lucky to have the love, support and security of our parents and siblings as we battle through all of the other stuff. The Glasgow Boys - Finlay and Banjo - haven’t. Finlay didn’t know his father, and his mother went back to Poland when he was eleven, leaving him to be brought up in a series of foster placements and children’s homes with their brief, tenuous connections, instability and uncertainty. That was Banjo’s fate too, having been born to drug and alcohol-addicted parents: a violent Mum and an even-more-violent Dad. Their stories are told in alternating chapters. Finlay is living on his own for the first time, struggling with the first year of his Nursing degree, but struggling even more with any social contact. The consequence of a childhood of neglect and insecurity is a young adulthood paralysed by feelings of anxiety and worthlessness. He’s unable to summon up the courage even to meet up for a second time for coffee with two girls from his course, let alone drop his guard enough to surrender to a relationship with Akash, an impossibly handsome medical student who is clearly equally-attracted to him. Finlay shrinks away from human contact, but Banjo’s route to self-destruction is by seeking out the only physical contact he feels comfortable with: fist-fights he knows he’ll lose - acting out the role he’s been cast in by his upbringing, by everyone else in his life, and by himself. If it happens again he’ll be permanently excluded from school - again. Starting a part-time job in a sandwich bar, he meets Alena, whose positive, open, trusting, non-judgmental nature gradually weakens Banjo’s bulletproof armour. It’s spending time with Alena’s loving family though, that really allows him to let his emotional guard down. Finlay’s route to self-confidence is similar: first through witnessing Akash’s own confidence and pride in his gay identity, then by allowing himself to get close to Akash, and as a result, Akash’s family. So, Glasgow Boys is about the devastating emotional costs of growing up without the support of a family and also about the healing power of family. The two stories are parallel and separate, but through a series of flashbacks, it becomes clear that three years before, Banjo and Finlay had connected briefly, but deeply, as roommates at St Andrew’s children’s home. The novel builds up to their inevitable reunion as we understand the emotional power of that earlier meeting and the following trauma of their dramatic parting. Margaret McDonald wants us to understand the psychological and emotional experiences of her two protagonists, and it’s this that can sometimes make the book, for me, a bit tiresome. For sure there’s drama here, especially for Banjo, but for Finlay it’s mainly internal drama, and there’s only so much microscopic description of a character’s emotional reactions I can take! Perhaps that just makes me more insensitive than other readers, who may have more sympathy, perhaps empathy, with Finlay and/or Banjo. I suppose reading Glasgow Boys is like reading two love stories. Will they? Won’t they? The twist is that, as the song goes, they are learning to love themselves. ***

Mr Hodgson
Ermysted’s

I really liked this book because it was heartwarming and made me feel connected to the characters and everything they were going through. The story was powerful and moving, with moments that made me think deeply about identity, friendship, and the pressure to fit in. The author used strong emotions to draw the reader in and build a real connection with the characters. Margaret McDonald brought both the setting and the feelings to life, which made the book even more enjoyable and emotional.

Vanessa
Rainbeau Readers

The book Glasgow Boys is a book about 2 boys who have grown up in the foster care system and both struggle with past trauma. I think this book was good because it was insightful and showed how people grew up in the care system and how people struggled with their mental health. Additionally, I like how this book is written from the boys' different points of views and follows them on their journey and their struggles. Overall, I would recommend this book to people who like books about coming of age and friendship.

Eloise
The Fitzharrys Shadows

I really enjoyed this book on two boys who were adopted. This book shows how the reunited after many years. I was hooked because the author expressed their emotion using pathos to make us feel sorry for the characters. It also had a gripping storyline and showed us what it was like to be adopted.

Ned
Bookwizards

Glasgow boys by Margaret McDonald is by far my favorite book of the year, if not the best book I have read. It follows two boys around university age through many challenges and unexpected reunions, whilst they both try to outrun the past. They both find relationships, make new friends and try new things. It explores themes such as anger, happiness, new beginnings and forgiveness. It is written in a dual narrative, set through a coming-of-age lens focusing on the resilience and courage of the characters. The two boys are Banjo, still in high school learning to manage anger and adapting to a new foster home within the care system, and Finlay, new into nursing school and exploring who he is, and looking for a support network of friends whilst learning to trust and forget is relationship with Banjo. In this book I really liked the use of language and the dual narrative, exploring the perspectives and lives of the two boys. I felt it really connected the bits of story and made it an easier read, as well as adding more to the story. By using the Scottish language and accent in Banjo’s story but not Finlay’s, it brings a sense of difference to the story, showing that there was a great connection and friendship, but that they are also different people. I also enjoyed the mystery that the book builds, becase you see little snapshots of Finlay and Banjo’s life together later in the story, but at the start of the book I was trying to think of how Finlay and Banjo could know each other because they wouldn’t be sharing a book if they didn’t know who the other was. Personally, this is what made the book impossible to put down, because I was just desperate to know what the connection between the two of them was and every time you got a bit of the ‘three years ago’, It intrigued me so much and then I wanted to find out more. I didn’t dislike anything about this book, which was very unusual for me but I would recommend this book to anyone, especially those who are figuring out who they are and I found this book really refreshing for my mind, because I could relate to some of the struggles of the characters and overall, I loved this book so much I could read it every day and never get tired of it.

Nellie
SHSK Shadowers

Glasgow boys by Margaret McDonald is a realistic fiction book. In the book we get introduced to Banjo, he is in a foster family and has a short temper, making finishing his last year of high school difficult. Then we have Finlay, who having recently come out of the foster care system, is struggling to get his nursing degree and finding it hard to find work. The book is about Banjo meeting new people and he gets into a fight on his first day, but when he starts a job he meets a girl he loves, she is Alena and they work at a café together. Throughout the book you can see Banjos character develop in to a less aggressive person after being around Alena . The rest of the book is about Finlay writing an essay for his degree and managing to fit in work, Finley at the start of the book is a very anxious person, but when he meets Akash, Finlay feels he is the only person he can be himself around. I liked the book because you could read one person's perspective at a time, I also liked being able to read about two characters that are completely different to each other. What I didn't like about it was I thought Finlay and Banjo would be together in the book but all we see is they have one conversation at the end. I expected more development on their friendship. Overall, I think the book was very good and would recommend to a friend because of the plot and engaging characters.

lily
Plumites

This is a book about a beautiful, raw, challenging, special relationship between two male characters - two male characters that have been dealt a pretty rotten hand. It's honest, insightful, difficult, infuriating, but most of all real. I loved it. I haven't read anything like it - ever.

Lara
Horsham BOok HUNTers

I read the book called Glasgow boys written by Margaret McDonald. It is a book set in the modern day which battles modern day issues in Glasgow. It is written in two separate 3rd person narratives, Finlay and Banjo. The main plot of the book is as follows: two boys are trying to make a name for themselves in the big wide world. Against all odds, Finlay begins a nursing job at an elderly person care home, through university and Banjo has found himself a job at a food establishment. Both boys have spent a large amount of their life in childcare homes so especially Banjo has a very large and fiery temper which gets him in trouble at school and is close to being expelled. My favourite part of the book is when Finlay and Banjo see each other again in the hospital.

Zack WF
Ermysted’s

A brilliant coming of age book that navigates Banjo and Finlay's pasts with themes of neglect and drugs. This book also explores types of relationship as well as family, with my favourite quote from the book being “My family is who I allow it to be”.

Lizzie
Presdales Carnegies Reading Group

I liked this book a lot because I like how it switches from the characters perspectives. It was about two young men who grew up together and how they became friends again. I liked this a lot.

James W-B
Ermysted’s

Glasgow Boys is an amazingly well written book that follows two boys, Finlay and Banjo, in their separate lives, and stuggles. It demonstrates their different personalities with ease, and hooks the reader into their story, and shows you their past throughout the book, without overwhelming you with it from the beginning. It is an emotional, well-written tale that had me rooting for all characters, as well as allowing me to truly feel like I was in their shoes, and immersed in their world and struggles. While this book is raw, and discusses more mature themes (substance abuse and others), it is an amazing read I would recommend for any reader, typically over the age of 13. 10/10.

Addisyn
Book Squad

I really like how the author wrote the story from both Banjo and Finlay's perspective, and that they both have their own struggles. They were both put into the same care system (St Andrews), but this was slowly introduced to the story when Banjo and Finlay started thinking about each other. At first it didn't really make sense, but I soon realised that Banjo grew up with abusive parents and was given drugs to forget his pain. This was why he needed paracetamol (because he was going through drug withdrawal) and lied to the carers that he had a bladder infection. In the present, Banjo is struggling to control himself and is getting into fights, but this is only because he wanted to get hit so he feels pain. This is really sad, because it links back to his dark childhood. However, he soon finds happiness with Alena and they become a couple. At the same time, Finlay is going to university but with a scholarship because or else he can't afford it. His mum left him and this made him wary of having close relationships with others. He also embraces his identity of being gay and realises he does love Akash who was his only friend in primary. In the end, Banjo and Finlay met up and apologised to each other. It was because Banjo thought Finaly liked him and lied to him. Finlay was insecure and decided to kill himself by overdosing himself with pain relief tablets. The story is really emotional, and I really loved it. I really felt connected to the characters, and I was so happy when they talked it out. I would recommend this book to others, and it contains serious messages and some bad words. Still, it's 10/10!!

Mila
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Glasgow Boys was such a heart-warming story which took you on a journey of grief, remorse, healing and love. I really enjoyed learning about Banjo and Finlay and their different experiences and struggles. This book show a lot about what it’s like to run away from your past but also the importance of love and family.

Ruby
Wyedean School

Glasgow boys is about a pair of boys that are living in temporary foster care together, they are both such clear characters in your head you can easily sympathise with them. I immediately loved and related to the characters and cared so much about them. It is probably the best book I ever read, it is quite heavy though so if that's not your kind of thing don't read it, but if it is you must read it! It was a fantastic book so well written.

Eben
THS Shadowing

This fabulous story is set in modern day Glasgow, featuring two boys who lead different but very similar lives as well. I really enjoyed the way this book is narrated by the two boys in a double narrative as they talk about their lives, which are affected by one important past event they both lived through together. This double narrative, linked to this (initially) unknown event let me piece the their different feelings together, finally understanding the cause for their emotions and attitudes. However, what really made this book extraordinary in such a heartfelt way is the the bond that the two boys share and the bond they create with other people amongst the hardships and griefs of life. This book was so fully charged in beautifully captured emotions that it made the characters relatable in many ways, making them even more endearing to the reader

Margot4hg
4Shadowers

I thought that Glasgow Boys was a wonderfully written book which diverged from the usual topics of drugs and gang violence, providing a refreshing new topic for readers. This is my favourite book so far as I thought shadowers could really empathise with the characters, and it raises awareness of the hard work put in by nurses-in-training and the NHS. 9/10.

Laurie
Bilbo Baggins’ Bookworms

This book just blew me away! Staff in schools should read it to appreciate the journey that kids in care have been on. The two main characters were drawn so well, you just knew through the narrative how they felt, how they had been let down and why they tried not to get close to people. The concept of touch was also enlightening and how both Finlay and Banjo felt that eventually they could let their individual guards down because those around did love them and care for them. They in turn found people to love and care for. The dialect for Banjo was spot on and as an Ulster Scots person I didn't need the glossary at the back but can see how it would help explain words and terms. Such clever writing, Margaret McDonald deserves a round of extended applause for this story. This should be a film!

Mrs. P
Cake a Book Club

I really enjoyed reading 'Glasgow Boys'. I think it is a book which is really well written. I like the way it splits into 2 different narratives and each has their own stories. Sometimes this can make the overall story really confusing, but not with this book. Finlay and Banjo's stories are too memorable to forget. I definitely would recommend this book to anyone over the age of 13. It is a really strong book from the very start to the very end, and the ending was really good. I would rate this book 10/10.

Jennifer
Rebel Readers

“Glasgow Boys" by Margaret McDonald is a moving exploration of identity, community, and the struggles of the Scottish working class. The novel follows the lives of two young adults, Finlay and Banjo, as they navigate the challenges of their unique circumstances. Finlay, an 18-year-old nursing student at the University of Glasgow, and Banjo, a 17-year-old high school student in foster care, both struggle with their pasts and the challenges of their present situations. I think the novel's power lies in its authentic portrayal of the character's emotional journeys and the societal issues they face. One of the central themes of "Glasgow Boys" is the impact of the care system on young people. Both Finlay and Banjo come from care backgrounds, which significantly influences their lives and decisions. Finlay's struggle to balance his nursing studies with the lack of a support network highlights the systemic challenges faced by care leavers. Without familial support, he must navigate university life alone, intensifying the pressures of his coursework and clinical placements. This isolation underscores the broader issues within the care system, where young people often transition to adulthood without adequate preparation or resources. Finlay's journey sheds light on the urgent need for structural changes to better support care leavers in their pursuit of higher education and personal development. Similarly, Banjo's difficulty in adjusting to his new foster family and managing his anger highlights the emotional toll of the care system and also how children within the care system should be cared for as if they were in a “normal” family for example their emotions taken notice of. McDonald effectively uses these characters to expose the broader issues within the care system and its long-term effects on individuals. The novel also delves into the theme of masculinity and emotional vulnerability. Finlay and Banjo's experiences reflect the societal expectations placed on young men to suppress their emotions and appear strong. McDonald challenges these stereotypes by depicting the boys' internal struggles and their need for emotional connection. For example in the quote “It’s a teddy. He’s fifteen. He doesn’t know how to explain it without opening up his insides.” Is a clear reference to how Finlay feels he needs to tell Banjo why this toy is so precious but can’t because it would be perhaps wrong or inappropriate for him to do so. The novel suggests that true strength lies in acknowledging and expressing one's emotions, rather than conforming to traditional notions of masculinity. This theme is particularly relevant in today's context, where there is a growing recognition of the importance of mental health and emotional well-being. Community and friendship play a crucial role in "Glasgow Boys." The bond between Finlay and Banjo, despite their estrangement, serves as a testament to the power of human connection. Their journey towards reconciliation and self-forgiveness is a central narrative arc that drives the story forward. McDonald portrays the boys' friendship as a source of strength and resilience, emphasising the importance of supportive relationships in overcoming personal challenges. The novel ultimately conveys a message of hope and the possibility of healing through connection and understanding. Banjo’s connection with Alena and her family is a prime example to how small and simple connections to people can make life an easier experience for those who struggle with their mental health. In conclusion, "Glasgow Boys" is a compelling and thought-provoking novel that addresses significant social issues through the lens of its well-written characters. Margaret McDonald's debut work is a testament to her ability to capture the complexities of the human experience, particularly within the context of the Scottish working class. The novel's exploration of the care system, masculinity, and the power of community makes it a relevant and impactful read. Glasgow Boys was an excellent read that I really enjoyed that I otherwise wouldn't have read.

Iona
Logs

Glasgow boys is a raw, honest story about growing up in working-class Scotland with tough childhoods, tight friendships, and the quiet hope that things can get better. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and would give it a solid 4.5/5.

Jola
Beauchamp Champs 2025

From reading the blurb, I thought this was going to be a story where Finlay and Banjo find each other and develop a friendship. It was not. Reading the first few chapters, I felt I had started mid-series where there was missing context and reference to a mysterious 'Incident' but everything was gradually revealed. I now realise that the start of the story was the beginning of the resolutions to their internal conflicts and instabilities. Overall, the friendships formed and peace made within themselves and everything that happened set an enjoyable and satisfying denouement. I would definitely recommend to all!

Phoebe
Ousedale Shadow Chasers

Glasgow Boys by Margaret McDonald is a book about the lives of Finlay and Banjo, who are two boys that have just been released from foster care. To me this book felt that it could be a reality, and it really kept me guessing. My favourite character was Finlay, as he was very kind and considerate towards others. Personally, it focused on a theme that I didn't enjoy as much, but I would still give this book a 4/5 star rating.

Oliver
The Fitzharrys Shadows

If I had to rate this book out of five stars, I'd give it four stars. My favourite character is Banjo, as his character is so well-written and has so much depth. I really appreciate how his character isn't that one angry character with no good to him who suddenly improves and becomes an empathetic angel like people usually do in movies. He has so much more to him, and I felt as if I could feel his raw, unfiltered rage and hatred at the world through the pages. I love the layers in his personality; how deep down he isn't throwing a pity-party for himself. He isn't a sad, weak person, yet is still upset and hurt at heart, and just wants to be wanted. His character development is amazingly represented - his trauma from the foster care system and abuse of pain-killers is portrayed in a real-life situation and not romanticised at all. He is a stubborn person at heart and his struggle really helped me relate to him, I particularly adore the way his anger and rage is portrayed and the thin line between anger and hurt. The way he begins to love Alena genuinely isn't too passionate, movie-seeming or instant and I feel as if that was a really good touch, since the emotional connection between the two builds up gradually and the slow process is shown realistically. Finlay, on the other hand, is a great character as well, since the way his financial situation is portrayed, his own struggles from the foster care system and the exhaustion from schoolwork really ensured that he is a relatable and well-written character. I really feel as if we could've done with more of the context of his and Akash's previous friendship in Primary school, as I felt as if Akash confessing to him seemed all too good to be true. It comes across as very sudden and their relationship should've had more depth, with a longer, maybe more pained process to it, rather than being easily resolved. What I absolutely ADORE is the way Finlay and Banjo's friendship seems neither platonic nor romantic, but just this really complex yet understanding love: a quiet, simple, yet simultaneously complicated understanding and intimacy, not physically but emotionally, with one another. It is such a rare and difficult platonic-seeming love to portray yet is written and represented so beautifully through their shared traumas and experiences. It isn't too movie-like and they don't fall in love at all; they just appreciate each other as companions. Overall, the realistic experiences, trauma and emotions (except maybe Akash in general) were quite impressive. Would recommend!

Rameen
LGGS Shadow Questers

I really enjoyed this book as it makes you feel. I say this as you feel as if you are the character and the events are happening to you. I really liked that the book shifts between characters as you can see that they kind of mirror each other. For example, when Banjo and Alena got together, the next chapter Finlay and Akash did likewise. I also really enjoyed the sense of time travelling when it went back 3 years to give the reader more information. It is hard to describe in words how good this book was and how much you could relate to someone totally different to yourself. The only thing I didn't like was the cover as I don't think that it portrays the book as well as it could have.

Liam
Bookwizards

I really liked this; especially towards the end. One of the reviews said it was like reading your heart on a page and at times it really was

Aanya
KECHG Shadowers

Glasgow Boys is just really wholesome. It's not without dark character-shaping moments of course but on the whole both Finlay's and Banjo's journeys are really sweet. I really enjoyed the flashback sequences sprinkled throughout showing the slow creep towards friendship the two protagonists experience and even when they are ripped apart I never felt entirely hopeless, always rooting for the pair. The social lives of the two of them are also really realistically written: it's messy, embarrassing, mistakes are made and not always immediately forgiven but again, I was always rooting for them. Themes of substance abuse, attempted suicide and violence are handled in a way that they sink in and I understood what the author was trying to say without making it hard to read or too heavy. Overall, I just adored it, could just be because this is the first one I've read so far but it was just a good time.

Alexander
THS Shadowing

The layout of the book is brilliant with it swapping the point of view to the two main characters. Banjo and Finlay's backstory is excellent. They are both alone, but their lives get better when they end up knowing each other. The mix of happiness and depression is perfect. Banjo's parents set the base of his life, but he manages to be better than them. No one in the story is perfect and that's what makes it good.

Noah
Southmoor Storywriters

This book was a great read. I love how it uses double narratives and has a glossary at the end of the book for words spoken with accents.

Eva
KECHG Shadowers

I thoroughly enjoyed the book from the plot to great characters to a phenomenal backstory. I thought that it was incredibly The important theme tackled by the book were themes of trauma, addiction, suicide, anxiety by showing this through differences of experiences, Banjos need for violence due to how he was treated in childhood, and Finlays avoidance to loved ones and keeping them at arms length due to his abandonment experience in his childhood, is very important to acknowledge as a society to help this and cultivate a better understanding of these pressing issues. I found the split perspective really enjoyable and the reflective outcome it has on the reader is absolutely fantastic. My feedback would be that the third person narrative was a bit confusing but overall I really enjoyed the novel - 7/10

Jade
TGS Book Group

Glasgow Boys is a romantic and social-realistic novel about two boys who had previously been in foster care together and had moved on. This engrossing book talks about their separate lives, how they overcome difficulties, how they find love and themselves, eventually reuniting and discovering the real meaning of friendship. I enjoyed reading this book, as it initially didn't tell how the two boys knew each other and kept me engaged until the end, as I wanted to know their relationship. I also really liked this novel, as I learnt that having true and loyal friends was beyond special and not everyone got the chance to find such people in their life. Finally, I loved the ending because not only was it emotional, when the two boys reconciled, but it was also mixed with humor, giving me a chance to cry but also laugh, and at the same time making me think thoroughly about the choices I make in life.

SrishtiHG
4Shadowers

The storyline was very good and made you want to read on however occasionally the switches between characters confuse and I had to re read it a few times to understand.

Finn
St Kaths

This book is about two different boys who knew each other long ago. since then they have gone their separate ways.one boy called Banjo had a very hard childhood. this has made him believe he needs to be hit as punishment so he gets into many fights. but now he has a girl he loves and is doing good. The other boy Finlay has a very hard time during school. trying to balance work and school. He meets up with a friend from primary called Akash. In the end Banjo and Finlay meet up and apologise. I would definitely recommend. I can relate to one of the characters. Tt's like if a path splits into 2 but has the same destination. Great book

Pranav Rajan
Ermysted’s

I think that this book was based a really good concept, but it often felt quite jolting due to being a dual narrative in third person, and the emotions may have been better conveyed in the first person. However, once the reader was introduced to the style, it became more readable as the plot progressed and I began to enjoy it around halfway through, possibly because more context was given. A multitude of sensitive themes are covered too, really detailing the complexities of the care system and how many are left feeling abandoned. Overall, I quite enjoyed this book, but thought that it got better as it went on.

Eve
St Kaths

Wonderful and thoughtful, showing how two very different people can develop such strong bonds.

Arlo
Crypt Bookworms

Glasgow Boys is a compelling story of two boys - Finlay and Banjo - who three years ago took separate paths and never saw each other again. Finlay goes to university, struggling to find paid work and living off instant noodles, but then he meets someone who he just cannot stop thinking about. Meanwhile Banjo is in foster care, and has joined the athletics club in his last year of high school. He too finds someone who begins to occupy his mind constantly. But will their two worlds eventually connect together again? My favourite character in this book was Alena, who showcases in Banjo's story. This is because she always smiles, always has a good thing to say about people, and her positivity never falters when something doesn't go right. What I also liked about the novel was that there were two different stories alternating between chapters - I was either reading about Finlay's life or Banjo's. I enjoy this way of structuring a book - it allows you to take a break from one of the characters and cone back to them later after reading about another. However, there were some things I disliked about the book. Even though I liked the two different stories going on at once, it was a bit confusing at times with the flashbacks randomly happening in chapters, and then going back to the present tense of the book. To end on a positive note, this was a very good novel - it was an insightful story telling us about the world of young people and the challenges the can face. I would recommend this to all young adults, it was a worthwhile read!

Emma M
VISTA Academy

Glasgow Boys tackles heavy themes like trauma, but I found it hard to follow at times. The pacing was slow, and I struggled to connect with the characters. The setting was well done, but overall, it wasn't my type of book. 4/10

Baasit
Ermysted’s

This book was truly amazing and I struggled to put it down! So many topics of distrust,love, hate, envy and fear all expertly written so that I ,as a reader, was able to grow almost attached to the the two main characters (Banjo and Finlay). I found that the flashbacks were a nice touch and eventually I was able to find out the whole story and helped the story line to flow nicely. Overall, this book covers topics that are sadly common in society today (such as anxiety and suicide) and it was written so attentively, helping me to understand what Banjo and Finlay were feeling throughout the story. I would recommend this to anyone and would love to re-read it! I also really appreciated the 'Scots dictionary'.

Libby A
VISTA Academy

The book was really interesting and heart warming. I really love Banjo’s backstory and I think that his and Finlay’s connection was very smart! At first, I was confused but as I read on I became addicted and started to understand the book and feel sympathy for the boys. I think this book is amazing and really original.

Saanvi
Beauchamp Champs 2025

8.5/10 - This book excels in conveying raw emotions from gut-wrenching trauma to ecstasy. I thoroughly love the unique way that the sentences were structured as both point of views, feeling different and like true representations of the characters thoughts. The steady build up to Finlay and Banjo's history being revealed was executed well, and was heart-breaking to read. I adored the story and progression, however, I feel it was concluded too well which slightly diminished what the characters went through although the soft finality is very cosy. I grew very attached to the main characters as they were wonderfully written and have a lot of depth that you feel relatable to them. LOVED this book.

Connie
OAJW Golden Reader Club

Glasgow Boys was a very emotive, emotional and heartfelt story about friendship, old teenage life and how important people mean to you in this world. Going along the journey with Finley and Banjo was a very immersive experience- I could feel what they were doing, know what they were thinking. It shows how even if you have hit rock bottom, there is always a way to get back up to a happy life full of people that you know and love and things that you want to do. This book would be perfect for you if you are into romance and rational struggles that teenagers go through. A very emotional story that ends up with everyone happy and the whole world ahead of them, a very heartfelt story that I overall enjoyed reading.

Grace
Chiswick Carnegie

Hanzalah
Ermysted’s

This book surprised me, as it is not a book I would usually read. it is a great novel, and, though I didn't expect it to be, I found this book difficult to put down. The flashbacks break up the writing nicely, and the different, yet intertwined, story line flowed well. Unlike other books in the Carnegie shortlist, the author used swear words sparingly yet effectively. The relationships worked well, and the fostering element added another layer but all the different layers of hate, love, distrust, jealousy and fear between the two protagonists worked really well. The inclusiveness in the book was also very heart-warming. over all, I have nothing bad to say about this book, other than the fact that it is not my preferred genre. 8/10

Elijah
VISTA Academy

This book was brilliant. I loved how the author was able to portray the characters, Finlay and Banjo, in such a unique way. The relationships and friendships in the book were also written beautifully, with the complex friendship between Finlay and Banjo, and then their separate relationships with Alena and Akash. The story flowed and the character development of Finlay and Banjo was written really well. A few people have written that they didn't like that the book was written in 3rd person, and I do agree with that, I think if it was in 1st person, the characters would feel more personal and their emotions would feel more real. But even so, this book was one of the best I've read in a while and I would recommend it to everyone.

Ela
KES Bookworms

OMG! I loved this book so much, I especially liked how you can see the contrasts of the two personalities in each chapter. I also thought the “ Scottish dictionary” at the back was pretty cool!!! 11/10

scarlett
The Fitzharrys Shadows

The book is a story that paints the problems that is plaguing society like suicide, anxiety attacks and others. It showed how the two characters, Finlay and Banjo, were feeling throughout the book.

Ming
Ermysted’s

Wow!! I love, love, loved this book! It was heartbreaking and heartwarming all at the same time. I loved how fast paced this book was and how you could feel the emotions of the characters. I could read it all over again with ease. I highly recommend it!!

Immy
Skipton Shadows

Glasgow boys is a heart-breaking story of two boys who grew up in care and is about their lives overcoming their past trauma and the reconnection between the two. This book is full of emotions and is beautifully written. A solid 10/10!

Thushara
KECHG Shadowers

In Glasgow boys, there are 2 kids who grew up together but found out they are not close friends. Banjo and Finlay both got separated so Finlay is at university studying to be a nurse and Banjo is still in high school. They both are also described as resilient and perseverant and also confident in life

Ellie J
VISTA Academy

Glasgow Boys is a novel about friendship and life in care. The two narrators are starting a new life but their secrets are slowly being revealed. Finlay and Banjo are very distinct narrators and they keep evolving and changing through their life experiences. Finlay is sensitive and guides his decisions through his interests which is nursing and caring for others. Banjo is a people-person and considerate of how he affects people around him but he often solves his problems through violence and looks up to Finlay's sensitivity because he wants to change. I also liked the patients at the residential care home where Finlay is working while studying nursing, as they are funny and cheer him up. My favourite part of the book was Finlay's descriptions of his surroundings and how he is observant and sensitive. The plot moves very quickly, mainly through the emotional development of the characters. The book made me both laugh and cry. The is a nice balance between the soft and strong moments so as a reader I didn't feel overwhelmed. The flashbacks are well laid out throughout the novel and it's made clear that the past memories are pushed away by both narrators and they only resurface in strong emotional moments like at the end of chapters. The author did a good job of fleshing out the motivations and fears of each characters so I understood them and cared about them. The novel reminds me of Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe because behind the well-rounded characters there is a philosophical message about the power of friendships. I would recommend this book to readers who like to care about the characters they read about. It's good escapism because it creates a well-rounded reality for these boys and their friendships.

Ms Čechová
NA Book Club

This was a heartfelt book about love and friendship. I felt this was very emotional and well written. The dual narrative worked very well, but I felt first person present would have given an even better insight into their feelings, and third person present tense was a little clunky to me. Still, that didn't stop this from being an amazing book which really highlights what family means and the character development is great. This was an insightful and emotional read.

Iris
Skipton Shadows

This book made me feel more emotions than I thought was possible . I felt happy , sad , confused , excited , angry , you name it , I felt it . While the topics were very deep I also couldn’t put this book down . The relationships that were developed were also very moving . However , if there was one thing I would change about this book , it would be how it was written in the the 3rd person . Overall , I would give it a 4/5 .

Holly H
VISTA Academy

I loved this book, it was filled with emotion and everyday I looked forward to reading it. I would definitely recommend this book to my friends (and I already have.)

Sophie
Cake a Book Club

A hopeful, thought provoking novel which spotlights the hope and love that shines throughout a touching coming of age story. The characters are filled with life and their suffering and pain is intertwined with the ways they can still find love and joy amongst all they have been through. I especially love the relationships that make the whole book shine with hope, especially Akash and Finlay. This amazing book will defiantly be one I reread over and over again.

Isla
Cake a Book Club

This is a thought-provoking story of Finlay and Banjo and their intertwined lives in the Scottish care system. I loved the depth of character and the relationships they form (especially Finlay and Akash). More importantly, I think are the friendships and the message that, with the right people, things will get better. 10/10

Nancy
Cake a Book Club

This was an extremely interesting read and it really showed how the two characters, Finlay and Banjo, were feeling throughout the book. It also seemed to have a couple of hidden morals.

Zack
Crypt Bookworms

through out the time that i read the Glasgow boys i found that i could not catch on to the plotline of this story, i personally did not enjoy the fact that this book has to be read with a bit of an accent ,however i found the power of identity striking and i enjoyed the humour of the characters and liked how relatable the characters are.

eva
OSSMAORATORS

during the time I read Glasgow boys I enjoyed the book as the style matched the perspective of what the them and time period the use of mixed classes in the boys form one of a foster background and one from a lower class point of view. the book explores the point of view through Finlay and banjo the point of identity of the world around them.

holly
OSSMAORATORS

Personally, I don't believe that this was a good book. I struggled to understand the plot and I didn't find it engaging.

Faith
OSSMAORATORS

A tough read in places but what a terrific book! It's an uncompromising look at the impact that being in the care system can have, and Banjo and Finlay's experiences really draw the reader in. An empathetic and engrossing read.

Ms Darbyshire
STAGS Shadowers

I feel this book could win Carnegie and would deserve to because it raises awareness of difficulties of care kids after they leave and have no safety net. It also represents the friendship between Finlay and banjo really well and i enjoyed it a lot!

Alice
Herts and Essex

Glasgow Boys is a book about the lives of two boys: Finley and Banjo, who live in Glasgow and have come out of the foster care system. The book describes how they are doing, and follows Finley's career path through university, while also following Banjo’s last year of Secondary school while giving flashbacks into their past. As you get deeper into the book, you begin to understand why they act the way they do and delve into their history. I liked the way Margaret McDonald slowly gives flashbacks throughout the book, revealing secrets and uncovering the past of the two boys, letting you understand them deeper and what has happened to them, giving spectacular plot twists as you come to understand what they have been through. I found the start of the book uninteresting as nothing was happening to them that was exciting, but as I came to the end it was page turning, wanting to know what happened to them in the past, and how things are going to turn out. Overall, I would recommend this book to a reader who enjoys a romance but also someone who likes the plot twists and trying to figure out what has happened before it is revealed.

Rowan
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Glasgow Boys is a book that helps readers to truly empathise, whether with themselves, the characters in the book, or other people in their lives. It helps people do this by displaying a grounded and realistic story, with situations that slightly older readers of around university or college age will find very empathetic. However, even younger or older readers will still find ways to empathise with the book’s message that contact between us (whether physical or verbal) is an important part to all of us.

James
Southmoor Storywriters

Glasgow Boys is a book based around love, friendship, family and growing up. It is told from the viewpoint of two teenage boys- Finley and Banjo. Whilst Finley has just aged out of care and has left to go to Glasgow University without any support, Banjo is trying to settle in with his new foster family during his final year of high school. At the start of the book, my favourite character was Finley since I was interested in how his story would play out as he goes through university but towards the end of the book my favourite character changed to Banjo since he had quite a bit of character development as well as more of an insight into his past. One thing I didn't like about the book was the ending since I felt like it was a bit rushed and sudden with a lot happening in a short span of time. I would recommend this book to anyone who likes coming of age stories. Personally, I really liked Glasgow Boys and since I've never read a book told from two perspectives, I found that they intertwined nicely and would give it a rating of 4/5.

Tilly
The Fitzharrys Shadows

The story was very good. The writing from two perspectives was done well. I think the message of finding and embracing yourself was conveyed effectively.

Anton
Bacon and Eggs Literary Society

I absolutely loved this book. The two main characters had such deep personas and their story and relationships were developed so well. The Scottish was written so well I could hear the Scottish in my head when I was reading it. This is the best one I have read so far!!

Willow
Ely College Reading Group

Glasgow boys is an AMAZING book. The plot twists are so interesting. The romance keeps the book exciting and has me hooked! Banjo and Finlay are amazing characters! At first I was struggling to get into the book as I didn’t think it was my cup of tea! But after a few chapters, I couldn’t get enough of it!

Alice S
Herts and Essex

I loved this book - it really told a fantastic story. I will remember it forever. 10 out of 10 from me.

kianna
QEGS CARNEGIE BOOK CLUB

I loved this book. It was so moving, so heart-breaking, but so, so, so, good

Wilf
St Kaths

I enjoyed this book. I liked how the book showed Finlay and Banjo from two different perspectives. I think it was certainly an original idea. Also, I think Banjo's accent really made it seem more realistic, but it seemed like he threw the f word left, right and centre. You couldn't go a page without having Banjo screaming atrocities. 7/10

William B
Ermysted’s

This is my favourite book so far, it is heartfelt and I really enjoyed the book. I thought that the Scottish dialect was interesting and made it seem more realistic. I also liked the dual narrative and how you read from both the perspectives. It wasn't really the style of book I normally read, but I'm glad Idid because I loved it.

Mia
Skipton Shadows

It was a heartwarming book and was filled with great descriptions. I really enjoyed following the characters journey throughout the book and enjoyed the ending greatly. The book is quite easy to read and the Scottish dialect is quite cool and it make the book feel real. The original idea was amazing and I think that the author did a great job in coming up with the idea. I would recommend this book to 12+ because there is a bit of bad language in there. Altogether I really liked it.

Amelia M
Skipton Shadows

Gurman
Lionheart25

The characters in this book were crafted to perfection with the complexity and realism in every action and behaviour they exhibited. the elusion of the hard facts of their traumas till near the end of the book rather than knowing every detail from the beginning works effectively as it put the focus on viewing and understanding the characters as real people as if the reader is coming into contact with them in real life . the emotional complexity acts a lesson in empathy and representation for how people are affected by their experiences. there were many thought-provoking, beautiful sentences which managed to be moving without feeling disjointed from the personal perspectives. overall 10/10

Mariya
Sutton Shadows

The book 'Glasgow Boys' is a nice story that portrays the problems plaguing society like suicide, anxiety attacks and others. Each problem is shown in a way the character has it like Finley. After attempting suicide it gives a perspective that makes us imagine how he would feel. I think the individual character storylines for Banjo and Finley were amazing, but as a whole it was quite dry. I would suggest this book to anyone who likes multiple perspectives and individual character's showing their own story in a vivid way

Ehinomhen
Bacon and Eggs Literary Society

Simrah
Lionheart25

I did enjoy this book, I read it quickly and it kept my attention. I liked the concept and Margaret McDonald is a good writer! Okay, just had to say that because my book reviews tend to come off quite negatively. My biggest criticism of this book is that it can't seem to decide whether it's in second person or in a diary format. Let me explain: each perspective is in third person, "he"; "Finlay"; "Banjo"; but then, occasionally, like this example from early in the book, it'll suddenly shift to being like a diary in a dork diaries kind of way: "What. What. Finlay did not just imply he literally swallowed his own vomit." This is from page 57, and when I read it it really broke my immersion within the story because for the rest of the time, the narrator is impartial and is just relaying the story, so why did it get /embarrassed/ and feel the need to tell everyone it was embarrassing? Instead of that, McDonald could've written "Finlay flushed with embarrassment. He regretted implying he'd swallowed his own vomit.". That probably isn't great, but it doesn't break my immersion. In conclusion, these occasional breaks were distracting and disruptive to my experience reading this book. I found both characters compelling, but it bothered me that Banjo seemed to get a lot more pages than Finlay. The amount of pages both of them got are probably realistically similar but Banjo's perspective always bored me just a bit more so it just feels like Finlay had a lot less pages. As i was reading it, some lines just felt like they were written to be intentionally profound, and because of that it reminded me of TikTok poetry. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but it made me cringe a little bit. Here's a few of my favourite quotes: "It's such a beautiful thing to hold somebody" Finlay "What an experience to have a body. This thing that needs watered and fed and rested, is yanked around all day to various places and into various poses. This unreality of it all overwhelms him sometimes: that it's only a collection of cells and tissues and electrical synapses. /I don't exist/, the waves would come. He wanted to run out into the street and shout to anyone /please just touch me, tell me i'm alive, make sure I exist/." Finlay "Finlay realises he's resented everybody who hasn't experienced his very specific pain." Finlay

Ellie
Presdales Carnegies Reading Group

This book was an uplifting tale of two boys who couldn't be more different to one another, learning to overcome their pasts and hope for a better future. I thought that this was expertly written, in a way that had me rooting for the characters from the start, the sheer amount of personality present in even the minor characters being a highlight that made this a very compelling, and overall satisfying read.

Eleni O
VISTA Academy

Three years ago, Finlay and Banjo were like brothers, sharing a room in their children's home and, despite their differences, looking out for each other and understanding one another in a way they had never previously experienced in their troubled lives. Then something happened to drive a wedge between the boys, and they have not spoken since. This book explores what is happening in their current lives alongside flashbacks to the event that drove them apart. The dual narrative works well, with each boy experiencing their own set of challenges alongside a shared grief at the seemingly irretrievable loss of their friendship. You will root for both boys and long for a reconciliation, but will they find each other again?

Mrs J.
The Maynard School

At first, Glasgow boys seemed very unusually structured - frequent flashbacks and changes in character perspectives. However, I found that as I got more used to the structure I began to appreciate the intricate writing and story that made this book a memorable read. What I enjoyed most about this book is that how throughout there is the constant feeling of - this situation could improve - a sense of optimism that leads perfectly into the book's end. Overall, a memorable but gritty read.

benjaminr
Ermysted’s

It was a book that perfectly explains some of the problems that kids and teenagers go through.9/10

Connor R
Ermysted’s

'Glasgow Boys' is the story of two boys, Banjo and Finlay as they traverse through their life in the city of Glasgow. On the one hand I enjoyed the complexity and layers that all the characters had. The relationship that Banjo and Finlay had was very unique and I don't read many books with characters like them. However, on the other hand, I must admit that the writing felt a little unversed.

Frankie
OP No Shelf Control

We read this book for the North Herts Schools Book Awards and it won, so obviously enjoyed by lots of readers in North Herts Schools!

Catherine
Books & Biscuits

It is very good and I like how it is very diverse and multi-cultural. I also like how they both become friends again even though they stopped being friends before.

Ellie-mai
SHSCC_Readers!

It was very good I absolutely loved it. LGBTQ+ is very important to me and including a gay character is always a big yes for me

Meredith
SHSCC_Readers!

On one side, you have Finlay. Shy and introvertive. On the other side, Banjo, violent and impulsive. Both have demons and shadows they need to fight with. Look past the language barrier, the strong words and heavy Scots, and you have a warm story that is pretty well written and not too hard on the mind. The emotional rollercoaster as the Glasgow Boys bond, then break, then bond to break again, then finally bond ever stronger than before. The story expresses a soft and hearty message behind a gruff facade - not too unlike Banjo - that friendships can be not unlike family, transcending distance, difference and destruction. Probably gonna have my vote. Plus, the Scots dictionary had me splitting my side.

Hanzalah
Ermysted’s

This book annoyed me at the start because of the dialect that I had to read ALOUD to understand. However, I liked it because the boys even though they had a hard start in life didn't dwell on it for long and moved on to making friends and a new family.

Abigail
St Cath’s Shadowing

Glasgow boys, by Margaret McDonald, is a great book about two boys one called Banjo the other called Finlay. Banjo is living with his new foster family. He finds it tough at school as Kyle and his group of friends start making up names and bullying him. Until one day he gets a job at the café and meets a girl called Alena. Finlay has started studying for his nursing degree at Glasgow university and becomes friends with Derya and Jun. He meets on old friend from his past called Akash who at first, he can’t remember but then all the memories of Akash come streaming back to him. My favourite character is Alena because she was always kind to Banjo and made him smile even if he was having a tough time. Alena was even happy and cheerful when she didn’t feel decent but she didn’t take her anger out on people and just accepted it for what it was. I liked the fact that it was written about two different people, and it was one chapter on Banjo then one on Finlay because you weren’t just hearing about one person the whole way through, and it was nice to hear about their different lives. I also liked, how it would go back in time because we heard about their pasts’ and what it was like for them growing up. Overall, I would rate this book for the ages of 13+ and 10/10.

Annabelle
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Breathtakingly brilliant

Laia
The Ryecroft Bookworms

I quite liked this book as it depicted real problems. Very good book but a bit depressing.

hasan i
Ermysted’s

I quite liked this book as its not unrealistic and features real problems. Very good book but it was a bit depressing.

hasan i
Ermysted’s

Glasgow Boys

Margaret McDonald

Submit Review

Submit Artwork

Margaret McDonald

Shadowers' reviews and artwork