County Shadows

Popcorn
It is too young for me and I didn't really like it that much. I don't think I would recommend it, however some (a few) pictures were funny.

Jess

Ghostlines 
This book was quite good, i think it explored how that not everyone does not see things the same way, and i loved the twist with rowan. Also, the writing style reminds me of the shatter me series writing and I felt it showed what was happening inside her brain. This was my second favorite after boy i love.

Zoe

Popcorn
I did not enjoy this book; I felt like the drawings were a bit odd and there was no overall plot, it was just a bunch of random events happening, trying to be funny but just wasn't. This was my least favorite out of all of them, sorry rob.

Zoe

The Boy I Love
I found this book the best out of the all carnegies. I loved how there was so much research put into the book, and the history involved. The only thing is that danny and stephen's romance was a bit....... underdeveloped- it needed a bit more exporing.

Zoe

Not Going To Plan
Not going to plan was one of my most favourite books i have EVER read ! 100% recommend.

Gracie

Chronicles of a Lizard Nobody
I thought this book was a bit young compared to some of the others and also a bit random ,like when he has France on his knee??? 1.5/5 as i didn't really like it.

Elodie

Chronicles of a Lizard Nobody
I didn't like it, I think it is terrible. I did not understand what was going on and I didn't think it was funny whatsoever. It was also extremely random, why is France on his knee?!?!

Jess

Birdie
I LOVE THIS BOOK!!!!!!!! The heartwarming parts of and BIRDIE finding a home, friends, family and most MR DUKE i love JP ROSE put a horse into the book and the writing style which is not used in modern day is VERY GOOD and i would love to see a PART 2 to this book.

Emilie

The Boy I Love
I really enjoyed this book, especially the bits where Danny and him are in the trenches, and have a narrow escape from a crumbling tunnel that has been hit. I think the ending is really satisfying and ties up all the loose ends. I like the way the romance is gradually introduced and then gets stronger and then when he thinks Danny is dead, but actually he's not really scared me and then i felt relief. I also think the way the flashbacks are written is really effective as it's almost like you're there, feeling it with him

Elodie

Wolf Siren
I really enjoyed Wolf Siren as it was different from other books because Red is visually impaired, which made it interesting to see the world from another perspective. I also liked how the author wrote, it was as if I was really there. It was very sad at the end. I rated it a 4.8.

Jess

The Boy I Love
I loved it! The plot and characters were amazing and it made me cry (in a good way).

Olwen

The Boy I Love
From Stephan's Platoon get killed from German attack loosing one ear in the, killing one man and loosing his forbidden love. Danny a new Tommie appears into Stephan's life. Love blossoms from War. ◇This was A book that I could not stop reading i was up at night reading it again and again. This was The first book that made me cry. I love this LGBTQ+ book and I give it 5 stars.

Emilie :)