The Carnegies

Alice
JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

It is a good book with pretty realistic characters and somewhat realistic senarios. It shows what to look out for and what not and to do.

Toby
LatLit

An excellent book! Somewhat unrealistic at times (for example the speed at which Marnie gets a group of close friends) but really likable, engaging characters and an enjoyable structure, hearing from two perspectives. For a while, I was concerned that I’d need to do some PSHCE about it (with my own children as well as my Carnegie group) but towards the end, Marnie’s Mum said what I’d been thinking – phew! A valuable read.

Miss Heath
Bassingbourn Readers

I found Not Going To Plan really interesting because it shines a light on difficult topics and helps readers start a conversation. It's really important to know what to do when someone is pretending to wear a condom and the aftermath. Though it is fiction it's still incredibly important to learn about.

Alex
Ross Readers

Not Going to Plan is a powerful and emotional novel told in verse that explores friendship, consent, and unplanned pregnancy. The story follows Marnie and Zed, two very different teenagers who form an unlikely friendship while dealing with the pressures of school and personal challenges. The characters feel realistic and relatable, making it easy to connect with them. The verse format keeps the story fast-paced and adds to the emotional impact. Overall, it is a thought-provoking and memorable book that handles difficult topics with honesty and sensitivity, and I would highly recommend it. I give this book ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Anisa
WSFG Carnegies Shadowers

As Summer begins, Noah decides to make the most of every day - instead of wasting it. He wakes up, learns new skills, spends time with his friends and challenges himself to try things he has never done before. When reading this book, I found the story to be interesting and it kept me wanting more. I liked the characters and wanted to see what happened to them - I also really liked the message of the story. However, I did find some parts to be a bit slow and not very exciting, with some parts taking too long to get back to the main events. Overall, I thought it was a good book and I would recommend it. **** (4 stars out of 5).

Saim
Rockwood Reads

Not going to plan had a different but easy to read verse layout that shows the story through 2 viewpoints which is more interesting than the average layout. This shows everyone has their own rights and you need others to agree if you want to do something. It lacked places which would have made it more exciting. Though not my favourite, it’s not bad. But some words I didn’t understand and would recommend for older people; approximately for year 10.

William
The Perse Carnegians

Not Going to Plan was a very interesting book and I enjoyed it a lot. It was a story about a girl who gets kicked out of her private school and has sex with a boy from her new state school who only pretends to wear a condom and as a result she gets an unwanted pregnancy. Afterwards she has a tricky decision to make; should she abort or not. In the end she decides to abort but experiences some backlash from one of her friends. I think this story really highlights the importance of being careful in teenage years in relation to sex as when Marnie was pregnant it practically ruined her life as she received lots of online abuse which shows how dangerous a place social media can be for teenagers.

Alex
The Perse Carnegians

I think the moral of the story being don't do something you will regret and true friends mean the world really make it an excellent book and so i rate this book a 4/5 ->The moral being so true and heart grabbing the pain she went through ->I love how each person has their own side of the page ->How Marnie changes because of her getting pregnant ->It is a book that makes you want to read every page ->One thing I didn't like so much is that there wasn't much detail about her old school before she got kicked out ->I think that her having a friend helping her out is really good

Arya
The Perse Carnegians

‘Not Going To Plan’ is a strong and unique story that captures readers by how different it is. Whole pages are turned into pictures by shaping the words themselves into an artwork. The dual perspectives of Marnie and Zed –two polar opposites- gives a refreshingly new description of the same place with every chapter. The author has decided to tackle a complicated with no clear ‘right answer’, and this adds deep, impactful dialogue that makes the reader question their own views in the process. I especially love that the characters are made to represent the sides in the ongoing problem this book covers.

Leo
The Perse Carnegians

I really enjoyed this book despite being skeptical of it at first due to the plot. This book tackled hard problems in a deep and interesting way and in the end I felt like I really cared and understood the characters despite them being quite different to myself.l also felt like now I understand the pain and consequences of the themes of the book. I liked the way the book was layed out as it made the book seem really interesting and the relationship between Zed and Marnie was well-written(if bit unplausible at times). My favourite character was Luca as he was a nice and friendly person. Overall, I really liked this book and think it has a real chance to win.

Elsie
The Perse Carnegians

The themes of this book were definitely aimed at an older age range, revolving around teenage love, pregnancy, lies and teenage pressure. I didn't really like the verse novel style that the book was written in and I found it harder to read when the words turned upside down or started creating weird shapes. However, I quite liked the language the author wrote in, balancing description with simplicity. The book's storyline was an interesting idea, but if I was the author, I would have stretched Marnie's pregnancy stress procrastination for longer-around 70 pages-and I would have put Harry coincidentally running into Marnie after her GCSE art exhibition and them having an awkward conversation with Marnie mainly angrily shouting. Then Jessica comes and the two girls completely deflate Harry's ego. Overall, this book should be aimed at 14-18 years old and I would rate it a 7/10 because I like the authors language, just not the themes or verse style.

Felix
The Perse Carnegians

My favourite of the Carnegie shortlisted, this book had a lot of interesting themes which I haven't read much about before. It managed to keep a realistic plotline while also being unique and not at all cliche, with a definite build-up, obstacle, and eventual satisfying ending. My favourite part of the book was the style in which it was written; one character's thoughts and actions down the left hand side, the other's down the right. I've never read a book like that before and it makes it a lot more exciting than a huge block of text on one side.

Sophie
The Perse Carnegians

I Personally think that Not going To Plan is an extremely strong contender this year. From the real and relatable themes of not fitting in or being mistreated for your differences, to the statistics, facts, and logos inserted into the book to help people struggling through a similar situations; Not Going to Plan is a highly relatable novel that encapsulates teenage life and the struggles with teenage pregnancy. I also enjoyed the fact that, despite their obvious differences, Zed and Marnie really bounce off of one another and compliment each other very well. I also loved their banter between each other and how, through the verse style, you can see each characters point of view. I found the verse style of writing extremely interesting and also the word art allowed me to visualise the situation Zed and Marnie were in and their opinion. Overall, I loved this book, the readability of it, and also the content!

Finnley
Tenbury Page Turners 26

I really enjoyed not going to plan its was a very sad but interesting book and the way the writing was laid out really intrigued me as I have never seen a piece of text shown like that! I would rate it a 9.5/10!!!

Tallulah
Kingdown Wilts

Rose
Kingdown Wilts

Not Going to Plan by Tia Fisher delivers a story that is realistic fiction and makes points on an important subject. The book follows the school life of Marnie, who gets into unwanted and unexpected trouble, but through her friends she sees the light in it. I would recommend this book to anyone who likes realistic fiction as it delivers two points of view which lets the reader think and make questions and assumptions of what would happen and the course of events. This book is different from others on the longlist as it has different topics and the readers have to think more.

Orleta
LC Best Books

Not going to plan by Tia Fisher is a book that explores very strong themes and tell us the story of a girl called Marnie who gets expelled from her school right before her GCSE's. She moves to a new school where she sits next to Zed and they both agree to help each other with their studies, but they become a lot closer than study partners. I particularly liked the structure because the short lines make the book feel fast paced and make me want to read on more and more as the plot of the story also gets more intriguing. Overall I would rate this book a 8/10 and recommend it to people ages 14-17.

Hisham N
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This is an amazing book! Not Going to Plan explores the challenges and realities of teenage pregnancy. The story follows Marnie, a teenage girl who unexpectedly finds herself pregnant and must navigate this difficult situation with the support of her friend, Zed. This is a very fast-paced and engaging read. It highlights girls' right to choose and introduces readers to different perspectives on abortion and teenage pregnancy. Thought-provoking and enjoyable, this is a book that encourages important conversations while remaining an entertaining read.

Charley
Rainbeau Readers

I loved this book so much as i found it very interesting and i liked the way that it was layed out. I liked the way that the characters were all different and their range of believes and the way that it influenced their actions. I also loved the fact that they were listening to kpop whilst ice skating! 10/10

Amelia
GreatB00ks

I really enjoyed Not Going To Plan, and, in fact, have since sought out one of Tia Fisher’s other books-Crossing The Line, which I also loved. I think this was the best of the Carnegies as the message was conveyed, in a way, more powerfully due to the fact it was written in verse. I enjoyed the writing style as it helps to lift the mood on an extremely hard topic to talk about. It was thought provoking and urged you to think deeper about consent and abortion. It questioned why people shame abortion and cheered on women’s rights. Overall, I found this an extremely thought provoking and enjoyable read with a powerful message that, no-doubt, speaks to the heart, not just the head.

Nina
The Perse Carnegians

Not Going to Plan is the best book in the Carnegie. It's one of the only books that makes its serious topic enjoyable to read and the character development in all of the characters was good. The main problem of the book is how it was set out. I don't see any need to have it like a poem especially when there's only one character and they use too much slang like preggers. Some of these words feel like a old man trying to fit in with the youth but over all great book. Probably the best and most enjoyable even though some scenes don't play well or don't fit. 7/10 good plot bad structure and bad vocab.

patrick h
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

yuding
The Perse Carnegians

I found this book interesting and fun to read, especially with the writing style and layout.

Moeez
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I enjoyed reading 'Not Going to Plan' because it felt realistic and dealt with issues that teenagers can face in real life. The story follows Marnie and Zed, who become friends even though they are very different. I liked how their friendship developed throughout the book. The book is written in verse, which made it quite quick and easy to read. Some parts were emotional and made me think about the choices the characters made. However, I found a few sections a bit slow, but I still wanted to keep reading. Overall, I would give this book 4 out of 5 stars and would recommend it to older teenagers.

Harry
FCC Book Group

I found Not Going To Plan to be good in some places but lacking in others. One of the main reasons why I thought this book was good was the relationship between Marnie and Zed. I liked it because it progressed really nicely throughout the story and it showed how people with different interests can still get along. However, the other characters - such as Luca and Rakel - were not developed at all which led to conversations with them to be a bit dry. I also disliked the way in which the words were laid out on the page as it made it very difficult to track where the next sentence was and didn't really add much to the visualisation of the book. The main storyline focused on an unplanned pregnancy, and this is where opinions may vary. The book presented one particular perspective quite strongly, and didn't look at many other viewpoints in much depth. Because of this, people may feel that the topic isn’t examined as fully as it could be. I also felt that there wasn’t a huge amount of character growth by the end of the story. Few of them changed because of the decisions they made which, once again, made them feel a bit dry. I did like the ending though, as it was a good representation on what was being described in the book. Overall, Not Going To Plan was an ok book with some good characters, some bad characters and a decent plot that followed only one opinion. Plot:6/10 Characters:4/10 Setting:4/10 Style:3/10

Sevan C
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I did not think at first I would like this book, however I was absolutely astonished as this may be the best book I have ever read, without exaggeration. I would recommend this to anyone, as for young girls it’s an important lesson of their rights, for LGBT teens it is an important piece of representation, especially those under the aroace spectrum with Zed. A lot of things that are annoying in other books are pulled off excellently here- it doesn’t force an unrealistic plot by touching on the fact most victims of SA (which what Harry did falls under) do not report it, and the ending would usually be annoying as it is a cliffhanger however I cannot think of a better ending for this book, as it stays realistic throughout it. What I like is the book touches on taboo topics that many are afraid to touch on, because these topics are very important. The characters are also great representation for many groups and easy to relate to. In conclusion, 10/10. Would recommend to anyone over the age of 11.

Erin
Lost in Pages

I really liked how the book used shape poems to get across what the character was feeling or to show what the poem was about and how it took turns between two characters without getting too boring and repetitive.

Zoë
Skipton Shadows

Not Going To Plan is a masterpiece. Tia Fisher definitely struck the nail on the head with this one. I love this story because I feel it explains so many complex emotions in the form of angsty teens and pregnancy of all things. My favourite moment of the whole novel has to be when Luka takes Zed to a pride club and when Zed decides to leave he tells Luka that he doesn't know what or who he is yet and he doesn't like the idea of being restrained by society's labels. I feel that Tia really got the idea of society and people having to put labels on everything and everything's variations across extremely well. That just made me think a lot about everyone's rules and restraints and labels, so I just felt really enlightened and amazing after reading that part. I feel Not Going To Plan is a really riveting and absorbing story that I would love to read over and over. The layout and writing of this book if great and I just love the way that the text is the different characters' thoughts on each side of the page. I also liked the way the text sometimes looped into shapes and shadows to enhance the feelings and emphasis of the story. I think this book is perfect for understanding feelings about choices, consent and who you are. I would recommend it to teens and young adults looking for something deep and phenomenal like this.

Daniel
Ross Readers

Not Going To Plan by Tia Fisher is a book about a student called Marnie who discovers the truth of consent and teenage pregnancy the hard way and about a student called Zed who helps her through her struggles. The main themes are consent, friendship and Identity. I enjoyed the style of writing in verse as it isn’t a very common way of writing YA fiction, and it is interesting seeing the different thoughts and opinions of the characters at the same time. In my opinion, there could have been an epilogue or extended ending for this book as the ending was quite abrupt. Overall, I loved reading this book and would rate it 5/5. I would recommend this for 13/14+ readers as there is mature content.

Sofia
CSGS Page Turners 26

This book which is written sort of like a poem is creative yet totally realistic. the main character of the story is entirely relatable and the storyline is gripping, emotional and heart-breaking all at the same time. Zed is the perfect friend in this and we all need at least one friend like him. I couldn't put this book down and it is definitely a 9/10⭐

Nia
Court Fields Bookworms

I enjoyed the book and found it easy to read, the story is written very well, and you can feel sympathy for most characters. I think the book tells important stories and does it well, and i like how it's a verse novel so it's interesting to read. Marnie's story is very important to be told considering how the world is at the moment, and Zeds character is interesting because it's quite complex.

Martha
Next Page Adventurers

I read Not going to plan. I found it very graphic, but I do think people should be educated and realise the reality of teenage pregnancies. I thought that the friendship between Marnie and Zed was very sweet and i thought that including both Zed's and Marnie's perspectives really helped me understand the story better. Overall, i had mixed feelings about this book, so i would rate it a 3/5.

Norah
Dauntsey’s Carnegie Shadowing

i found not going to plan a relating book for some people, not me but it educated me and people could learn from Marnie's mistakes. i think that everyone should have a friend like Zed and that people should be more carefully. the structure of the pages was a bit jarring. probably recommend for people older than 13 as it is a bit graphic.

Issy
Dauntsey’s Carnegie Shadowing

I found it an interesting book, that worked with some interesting topics. I found it very hard to read at the start, but towards the end it god a bit better, i would not recommend to anyone bellow the age of 16. I thought it covered some topics that needed to be covered and i thought it did it in a good way, but i just didn't love the book personally. I would rate it 5/5 because i think someone else might like it.

Annabelle
Dauntsey’s Carnegie Shadowing

Tia Fisher’s Not Going to Plan is such a powerful read — written as a verse novel, it doesn’t shy away from tough topics like consent, friendship, abortion, gender identity, and making your own choices. What I loved most is how balanced and honest it feels; Fisher lays everything out clearly and fairly, so you get to think things through for yourself instead of being told exactly what to believe. The story centres on Marnie, who tends to leap before she looks, and Zed — the total opposite: super organised, focused on his studies, and always thinking ahead. It’s an unlikely friendship at first, but watching it grow is one of the warmest parts of the book. Their differences make for some really funny moments too, but they also show just how much two very different people can lean on each other when life gets hard. I was really impressed with how Fisher handles Marnie’s unplanned pregnancy. It never feels like she’s saying abortion is either the “easy way out” or something to be ashamed of — instead, she shows all the layers. Marnie has to weigh up her future, her family, her education, and what she truly wants for herself. Other characters have their own views too, and every single one is treated with respect. It feels real, and it makes you stop and think about how complicated these decisions really are. The way it’s written adds so much too. Being in verse, with short, snappy lines, it perfectly captures that jumbled, anxious, overwhelming feeling Marnie goes through. Sometimes there’s just one word on a whole line — it makes you pause and really feel what she’s feeling. It’s amazing how such simple language can say so much. There are some lines that really stick with you, too. When Marnie says life is “not going to plan,” it sums up the whole heart of the story: things rarely turn out how you expect, and you can’t control everything — but you can choose how you deal with it. Both Marnie and Zed learn that lesson as the story goes on. I also appreciated that there’s no “bad guy” here. Even when people make mistakes or say the wrong thing, they feel like real people, not just characters written to be hated. That makes the whole story feel so much more believable and helps you understand why everyone acts the way they do. All in all, Not Going to Plan is engaging, thoughtful, and feels so genuine. It tackles tricky subjects with real care, the characters feel like people you might know, and the verse style makes it both quick to read and deeply moving. I’d recommend it to older teens who enjoy realistic stories that make you think, so, 5/5 stars

Mia
BUCS Library Book Club

Going to Plan is an enjoyable book with an interesting story and relatable characters. It teaches important lessons about adapting when things don't go as expected. I would recommend it to other readers.

Shalini
Lostock High Readers

A compelling and heart- breaking YA verse novel 'not going to plan' is definitely one of the books that I would recommend. The thoughtful and unique idea of the poetic verse structure beautifully and accurately mirrors the fragmented and unpredictable nature of the book's title, Not Going to Plan; it also, in a way, mimics the life of the main characters and visually interacts with the reader: satisfying the eye. The chaotic life of Marnie and her risky adventure entertained me and the unpredictable element of this book kept me hooked.

Devi
HGS Book Club

Not Going To Plan by Tia Fisher is a beautiful heartfelt book about teen pregnancy and making your own choices. It is a verse novel about a young girl who is doing her GCSEs when she gets pregnant and has to rely on her friend Zed, a science mastermind! The story is about over coming obstacles and standing against societal stigmas involving teen pregnancies and abortions. I would recommend this book for anyone over the age of 13. I would give this book 5 stars out of 5!

Isla
Weald of Kent Grammar (Sevenoaks)

Not going to plan is about Marnie moving to a new school after she got kicked out of her old one. She has a passion for art and does it as a GCSE. She met a boy called Zed who helps her a lot . At Harry's party Marnie was drunk at a party and accidentally got pregnant. She decided to have an abortion with the support of her Mum, Luca, Zed and Rakel. I generally love this book because it shows strong friendship and how some friends are always there for you.

Vista Academy Littleport

Although I thought the character concepts and interpretations were rather trite (yet another "nerdy", science-obsessed boy in a friendship with a academically failing, artistic girl), I really enjoyed the themes at play. The abortion debate was not shown as black and white, and neither was Marnie's relationship with her friends, such as her anti-choice friend Rakel, and Zed's journey with the LGBT community. I found myself identifying with Zed a lot, especially with the way Marnie sees him. The representation of the school experience was also accurate and not romanticized at all. 9/10

george number one book reader book man
ShadowBookers

I think that the book is very good, I especially liked how the characters were developed. I also think that it's a very good book for teens as some may also be going through similar things and might relate to the book. I love how it was written and think it was really easy to read.

Sophie
Tenbury Page Turners 26

I liked this book, I found it interesting how it was written in verse, I think the structure of the text really added to the chaos of the storyline. Having the book written from both Marnie and Zed's point of view really helped bring their story to life. I would recommend this book to teenagers.

Elizabeth
Academic Readers

I didn't like this book very much. I thought that the characters were very basic and not very interesting. The book loses half of the plot with the GCSEs being overshadowed completely. The ending was unfulfilling and did not resolve anything in the book

Yusuf K
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed this book, it was my favourite from the Carnegies. I enjoy the secondary school setting, it's not relatable as such but it's familiar. It's a very important issue that it covers, especially among teenagers

Felix L
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Not Going to Plan is a really good book about growing up and learning responsibility. The main character goes through some tough situations and has to make important choices. I liked how realistic the story felt, and it showed how challenges can help someone become more mature. Overall, I really enjoyed it.

Lucas
Bookwizards

I don't think there is a single person my age who shouldn't read this book! I really enjoyed this book because I felt it dealt with some of the hardest topics in today's society with honesty and empathy, which is something young people really engage with. I really appreciated the way different points of view were portrayed in the book. For example, one of the main subjects of the book was abortion and the author chose to have two opposing beliefs surrounding abortion e.g. a Christian belief that abortion isn't acceptable contrasting with the main character's belief that no one should be shamed for what they choose to do with their own body. However, despite these contrasting opinions, by the end of the book one of the characters understands that, despite her own beliefs, it isn't her place to tell someone else what to do with their body. This book had a big impact on me as it taught me things that I feel the education system has failed to teach me. I also really enjoyed how the book was written in verse because this made it even more accessible for people in my age group.

Maeve
Thomas Tallis Reads

I found this book extremely powerful and beautifully written. I loved how it did not try to hide the fact that an abortion is painful. I loved the simplicity of the writing and how easy it was to understand the storyline. I would 100% recommend this book to a friend and rate it a 5/5!

Olivia
CSGS Page Turners 26

I thought this was a great book. I think it explored both serious matters but also contained humor as well, I really enjoyed reading it and would definitely recommend it to friends. It moved at a good pace and I liked how it was written, especially the verse. Although I didn’t like reading about the topic of teenage pregnancy,I think for someone who was interested in that topic, it would be very informative. I would recommend this for ages 12-16 but for advanced 11 year olds as well.

Elsa
Helkats & Hardbacks

Not going to plan is told from the narratives of Marnie and Zed. Marnie is a bit of a troubled kid who is really good at art and Spanish but bad at maths, while Zed is the opposite. This is stereotypical. Other than that it's a pretty good book about school pressure and pregnancy. I didn't like it much, but could not put my finger on it.

Lucas
Hope Valley Literati

This book wasn't my favourite, though it did discuss some important topics. One of the main reason why I didn't like this book that much was because I found the format of it a bit confusing at times, especially when the writing was in a spiral pattern. However, I did like how it showed the events of the book from both Marnie and Zed's points of view. Before I read this book, I didn't know what stealthing was, and it does a good job of showing how damaging it can be to someone's life. I would give this book a 6/10.

Alfie S
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Sofia
JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

I thought this was a good book - but I didn't really enjoy it. When I was reading it, I tried to appreciate that it was written very well, and the plot moved at a good pace so it didn't feel too slow and dragging or too quick. I found this was quite hard to do because I don't want to read on themes like teen pregnancy, especially when there are plenty of other books that are also written well that are far more enjoyable. I wouldn't recommend this to someone else, unless they asked for recommendations on that topic.

Edward M
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I enjoyed this book because it was interesting, educational and informative. It taught me important life lessons in a friendly, safe environment without any dangers or risks. I also enjoyed the style in which it was written and how it depicted both sides of the story and how every story has two sides. I would recommend this book because it fundamental to know, engaging to read and reader friendly but many need adult to understand the principal and messages of the book.

Jonathan
Bookwizards

This book is about a rebellious girl named Marnie who gets expelled from her private school and has to move to a normal one. She has to sit next to Zed, a maths nerd who hates being touched, and they reluctantly agree to tutor each other. They become unlikely friends, but everything goes wrong when Marnie is tricked at a party and gets pregnant, which is VERY stressful. I rather enjoyed this book because it handles real teenage struggles that makes it good for older readers.

Lucas
The Fitzharrys Shadows

I really enjoyed this book and I think it was my favourite out of all those short listed.I enjoyed the authors writing style and how she presented each character.I would definitely read this book again.

Neve
Sir Roger Manwood’s School Book Club

I loved this book! It is really well written super interesting. I 100% will recommend this book but the topic is for around 11+ as it does cover some sensitive topics. Overall probably one of my favourite books I've ever read and I will probably read it again. I rate it a 10/10: it covered a topic which I think is important and it really interested me. It was a great story and I loved reading about the characters' feelings.

thea
Sir Roger Manwood’s School Book Club

I think the book really well shows both the expectations and stigmas attached to sex but it also really well portrays the nature of teenagers and how they make mistakes. It also shows how teenagers can be very independent from their parents not wanting to tell them things and shows the importance of relationships with your parents as a child because of this.

Grace
LSST Library Shadowers

I enjoyed reading Not Going to Plan. The story was interesting and showed that things do not always happen the way we expect. I liked the characters and how they solved problems when their plans changed. The book was fun and easy to read. I would recommend this book because it is enjoyable and teaches an important lesson about being flexible and positive.

Arshdeep
Sale High Readers

Not Going to Plan is an engaging story that shows how life does not always work out as expected. The characters are relatable, and their challenges feel realistic. The plot is interesting and keeps readers wanting to know what happens next. Overall, it is an enjoyable book with a positive message about adapting to change.

Ishaan
MTS Northwood

The book ‘not going to plan’ by Tia Fisher is a 14+ thoughtful and engaging explanation of what happens when life refuses to follow the script we have written for it. Through a mix of relatable characters, unexpected twist and honest reflections. The story follows a girl named Marnie how she meets a guy named Zed and they go to a party, and she ends up doing something she is not supposed to do. The story highlights the reality that success and happiness are often found in unplanned moments rather carefully designed ones. One of the books greatest strengths is its realism. Tia captures the frustration, disappointment and uncertainty that accompany setbacks while also showing how these experiences can lead to growth and self-discovery. The writing style is accessible and reflective, balancing humour with emotional depth also the way its layout helps with the reading because sometimes books that are usually with lots of words on the page makes it very overwhelming and seems like it is a long book even when it like only 100 pages. A particularly memorable aspect of the book it is emphasis on resilience. Rather than presenting failure as something to be feared it encourages readers to view obstacles as opportunities to learn. This message feels both timely and inspiring in a world where many people feel pressure to have everything figured out. Overall, I rate this book 8.5 out of ten because I think this book is telling you to be careful and don’t let people take advantage of you.

scarlet
Larkmead

Abby
JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

Not going to plan was a compelling, heart warming read on a subject that really doesn’t get enough attention. I really warmed to the characters in this book and I really liked the contrast that they provided each other. I enjoyed the way the book was written (in verse) as I thought it was really clever. However I did feel at some points it became unnecessary. Overall, this was a 4/5 read and I really enjoyed the ending in particular as u thought it was a nice way to finish the book off!

Alice
JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

I really like not going to plan. I loved the way it was written because it was really fun to read and didn’t t fit with the normal formatting of a book. I loved all the characters and how the book explored loads of different themes like feminism, consent, friendship’s , and identity as well as having LGBTQ+ characters. I thought the characters were really well written and I liked how different Zed and Marnie were but they still managed to get along.

Hannah
Tractors

it seemed interesting. i liked how the text was in the book . but unfortunately i couldn't follow the story because it was boring. zed was too obnoxious. marnie was an annoying brat and i hated her . she gave up on a great oppurtunity just because she thought she was cool

Evie
Stratton shadowers

I didn't really like this book. The pages had almost no words on them and I couldn't really tell who was talking. I think this book was a bit inappropriate so I would recommend for 14+. I think it was an alright book.

henry
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This story was ultimately about friendships and loyalty. But also about the important message of CONSENT. The talking script style made this a fun and easy read. I really enjoyed Marnie's sassy character and although Zed is the absolute opposite to her they spark an everlasting friendship that stands the test of time. The story also highlights the need to have the courage to speak out to trusting adults when something in life is too difficult to navigate on your own.

Anon
SHS Book Club

This was a truly unique book. It opened my eyes to the difficulties faced by pregnant teenagers, and deeply moved me. The verse format worked really well to bring the message home even more vividly. I rate this book 10/10.

Maddie
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

This is a book for older students, maybe Year 10 upwards. I like that it is in verse. It is an important book.

Luka
Coombe Critica

Not Going To Plan is a beautiful blend of narratives that combine to make one of the most interesting YA books I've ever read. The themes were fascinatingly relevant, especially for those approaching adulthood, and it provided a really captivating and realistic outlook on topics like teen pregnancy and abortion. The use of character allows multiple opinions to be discussed; I really enjoyed how balanced it was as a whole. The plot, I think, is really well thought out as well— and, combined with the visual, poetry-like style of writing, it made for a wonderfully unique book. I also thought the individual characters were brilliant– especially the use of character foils (Zed and Marnie– as you'll see!). Overall, Not Going To Plan is a fantastic book– and I highly recommend it, especially for those who enjoy visual novels!

Ayanna
LC Best Books

Not going to plan is the story of a teenage girl, Marnie, who accidentally gets pregnant at a party. On her first day at her new school, she gets sat next to Zed, a total nerd wo has zero tolerance for mistakes. They are polar opposites in personality, yet they start to form a friendship over revision for GCSEs. But when her world collapses, can she rely on Zed to help her fix it? My favourite character was Marnie as some of the things she did to get in trouble were so funny, they made me laugh out loud. My favourite part was when Marnie and Zed first met. It felt very real due to the way it was written. Overall, I liked this book more than expected. I wouldn’t have picked this book out if it were just at the library, but since it was part of the Carnegies I read it and actually enjoyed it! Would definitely recommend!

Gwen
Vista Academy Littleport

Not Going To Plan has a very significant strength which is that it focuses on very real and serious issues with a very good style of writing that makes it feel true. However, the main problem that I didn’t like about the book was the setting that it was in. I think having a book about consent and teenage pregnancy set in a school, especially in the GCSE year, is quite unrealistic. Aside from that, I really liked how Zed and Marnie’s relationship grew because that was a very credible way for a friendship to form, if not a little cliché, but it was very well written in that aspect. The only thing that I would change (apart from what is said above) is having just one main character. Even though it means there are less issues to talk about, it means it is more understandable for the reader particularly as it is already written in verse (which is another thing I liked about the book). Overall I would rate it a 7/10.

Siddharthan
The Perse Carnegians

I think 'Not Going To Plan' is a well written book and although normally I don't like reading books written in verses I enjoyed this book. I like how we can hear from both characters' perspective and how the characters and relationships develop throughout the story. It's quite realistic and I often felt empathy for Marnie and Zed. Also, the topics and themes are addressed very well.

Anita
St George’s Dragon Readers

Despite not actually being a huge fan of books that seem to follow a poetry-like format, I hugely enjoyed this book and loved the storyline throughout! When I first picked up the book, I had doubts (as quite a picky reader), but I was quickly sucked into the lives of Zed and Marnie, sympathising with both of their situations at different points in the book. Despite Marnie's abortion being the main storyline, I really liked Zed's subplot line, and his struggles with his sexuality, and how he felt. As a girl myself, I thought the main subject of abortion and non fully-consensual sex to be a very interesting and important one, as they can often be seen as very taboo subjects that should really be discussed more often (in my view). Not only the plot, but the way it was presented purely through words really captured my attention, almost creating pictures and words with symbolism - emphasising particular things. Altogether, I loved this book, and would be incredibly supportive of it being chosen as the Carnegie Winner!

Kate
St George’s Dragon Readers

Shadower's challenge: “In the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit.” “I seek forgiveness from Allah.” “Allah?” “Uhh… yeah?” “ALLAH?!” “What’s your point?” “You’re praying to… that… in a Christian neighbourhood.” “Look, I really do not get the problem here.” “Get out.” “Excuse me?” “Get. Out.” “No. Not until I get an explanation.” “You’re praying to that… thing… while we’re rightfully praying to our Father.” “You do know my Allah is based upon your God, right? My religion is based on yours.” “I’m just trying to save you trouble.” “Oh, is that what you call this… accusation?” “You know, a human being must always obey his conscience.” “…I give up arguing. Whatever you say.” “I’m just trying to help.”

Jake
The White Harts Book Club

This was my favourite Carnegie! First of all, I likes the characters, they felt believable, and both Marnie and Zed had well thought out problems they both solved, and didn't detract from each other. I really enjoyed seeing them and other characters progress throughout the story! I also appreciated that Zed's entire personality was not solely "Nerd", and had some nuance, as sometimes can be a problem. My only minor criticism was that the style of writing could get a little confusing in parts, but I think this was worth it, as it brought a lot to the story both with the words themselves, and creatively the structure of the words. It covered multiple deep issues, such as teenage pregnancy, abortion, sexuality and pressure, but I felt that each one was handled well without feeling forced or rushed. The book also taught me something new, both the term of "stealthing", quite how horrible it can be, that it is a form of rape, and I really think it is important to raise awareness of issues such as this. Abortion, the major topic discussed is also very important, both the ethical side and raising awareness on how to do it safely. I also thought it was really interesting how the book included a person opposed to abortion, yet showed how they could remain friends, promoting a society where different opinions can co-exist peacefully. Finally, I really liked the conclusion, and I felt it was a really clever way to tie everything together with an art piece about the themes of the book!

Edward L
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Initially, I thought the cover was asthetic, but it did not really give an idea of the events of the book. It took me around 2 weeks to read the book. The book was about two teenagers who are very different people trying to help each other move through issues at home and in school. The main themes are identity, womens rights, queer identities, and peer groups for teenagers. I think this book is for ages 16+, I think the book is more targeted towards women, but I do think it would resonate well with queer individuals also, regardless of gender. I liked that I think it was a realistic depiction of this type of event, it was not sensationalised, or over dramatic, it feels like something people would genuanly experaicne in real life. However, I felt that the conflict between Marnie and Rakel was resolved to easily. The disagreement between them was realistic, but it seemed that Rakel changed her opinion on abortion for the sake of driving the narrative, it was not realistic for her charcter given her highly religous backround. The most memorable moment was Zed researching various perspectives on the abortion debate in order to reach a logical perstive, and subsequently realising that this particular issue should not be considered in a logical sense, as much as an emotional one. I would rate this book an 8/10, I would recommend it to others, and I think it deserves to win a Carnegie medal.

Erin
Gibraltar Carnegie Scholars

“Not Going to Plan” is such a well-crafted read that properly addresses the taboos around teenage pregnancy and consent, whilst telling it through such likeable characters. I genuinely loved getting to know each character’s personality and quirks (the Pikachu earmuffs!) and I think that since it was written in verse, it felt fast paced and easy to read, whilst still having that emotional appeal. Fisher said, ‘it was written as a conversation between Marnie and Zed’ and I think that was one of the most compelling elements for me: being able to watch the story unravel through two contrasting characters that both feel so necessary to fully tell the story, whilst the layout mimicked their chaotic, internal anxieties. At certain points, it felt like it was trying too hard to teach a lesson, rather than actually being plot essential. However, I feel that it was completely overshadowed by the humour of the dialogue and the raw, emotional depth of the characters and their dynamics. Fisher has written a powerful and realistic read about big societal issues through characters you inevitably fall in love with. One of the best reads and my favourite in Carnegie this year.

Cianna
The Narrative Navigators

A book about consent and the struggles of female figures when dealing with abortion and having friends you can trust.

Bruno
The Fitzharrys Shadows

“Not going to plan”- the main theme of this book is in the title! The story is told from two sides- Marnie, a girl who has been expelled from her old school and is bad at numbers , and Zed, an introvert who is good at numbers but not languages (Marnie’s strong suit). However, when some condom-free sex takes place, the two have to work out what to do when things really don’t go to plan. Overall, this was a great story about consent. It really highlights the issues that can come from not following it. I also loved the way the story was written- the verse makes it look more powerful and when the words form pictures it looks fantastic. If you’re okay with strong language and hard topics, then definitely give this book a read!

Sandy
Larkmead

Not going to plan is a great book for teens who are learning about consent and how to deal with friendships and identity. I loved how the main character (Marnie) was displayed and how Zed helped her out by protecting her. I also love the way the text was presented and I wish more books were like this. I would recommend this book to people who like books that are quite easy to get through without having to read massive chapters.

Sienna
Lost in Pages

Excellent book, well written and fast-paced!

Greg
Desborough Books & Biscuit Club

It was a different book to what I'm used to but I enjoyed it as it was quite an odd experience compared to what I usually read.

Joe
Plumites

I really, really enjoyed reading this book as it was unlike anything I have ever really read in many ways. The layout of the book was very clever and unusual, and I do think it related to the theme of the book in many ways. I enjoyed how it explored topics other writers wouldn't, the array of characters and the beliefs they held. At first, it was very unusual (because of the poem styled lay-out) helped with getting the emotions across. The characters felt like real people and a real group of friends going through a tough time. Marnie and Zed becoming friends was a happy surprise, however I did not understand how Luca and Rakel came into the friendship group. The book overall was a very enjoyable read that I would recommend to the higher end of KS3- not year 7.

Nell
Willow Book Whispers

I loved this book the twists and turns had me on the edge of my seat. The book felt so amazingly addictive and at some points I really struggled to put it down. I liked how it was a verse novel as it felt like the words flowed off the page into my brain which created the pictures like it was a comic. I liked the ending - which I won't spoil but oh if you haven't read it you are in for a treat. I read it as part of the Carnegie challenge and so far it is my favourite book. I liked how there were two sides and it was written in two views and people but it gives a nice contrast and it felt like I saw it in different views. So, I believe this book was written to show the struggle of teenage pregnancies and how important a relationship with your mum. This book is a 14+ but I read it when I was 12 and I really enjoyed it.

Emilia
Team Car Park

Not Going to Plan is about Marnie who is expelled from her previous boarding school and at the beginning of the book is shown to be arriving at a new school. The new school has let her in to take her GCSEs so she is in Year 11. At her new school she meets Zed, a nerdy kid who loves physics and maths as opposed to Marnie who likes Spanish and Art. They form a close bond as they start revising together. One day, Harry, a popular kid, invites Marnie to his party and they accidentally have sex with each other as he pretended to wear a condom so now Marnie is really anxious about telling her parents. I liked the themes of this book about choices and accidental pregnancy and how things can go wrong as it gives readers a deeper insight on how the world can work for some people. I feel like the writing style made it a bit hard to understand as it wasn’t the regular prose style I was used to. This is a good book for teenagers about accidental pregnancy and choices!

Leopold
The Perse Carnegians

I absolutely loved this book. However Before I read the book I was worried that reading in verse would be difficult and I wouldn’t enjoy it but it rose above my expectations massively. Not only was it entertaining in the storyline but how the words where placed and sometimes shaped kept me hooked the whole time I loved how the characters all had there different opinions and how they developed as the book went on as well as the satisfaction of Marnie getting back at Harry at the end became it was so empowering and the message put out there so important I will definitely be reading her other books !

Bonnie
Tractors

I like the storyline a bit as it shows the un sugarcoated truth of teenage pregnancy and how they handled an abortion emotionally but what really set me off was the poetic format as I was used to book written in that format to rhyme but either ways its was a solid read. I'd give it a 5.5\10

LAKSH L
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Finally! A book about teenage pregnancy where the main characters aren't romantically inclined! I have been waiting for a book like this for ages. I was so surprised when I found out that Zed did not like Marnie romantically, but he was her friend. I have always wanted to see this kind of representation, where the characters are not driven apart by shame and fright. Marnie and Zeb were really interesting characters. And I loved how deep they were. They had fears and secrets, and they felt like real people. I loved this book so much, and it was also a really easy read because of the text structure.

Zebedee
Mansell Library Reviewers

The book “not going to plan” is quite an interesting and amazing book to read. It is an ideal book for teens and young adults of this year and age. It explains a lot about what young adults aged from 15 to 16 years old. It teaches a lot about life, friendship and responsibility. The book was written by Tia Fisher and has a very good storyline. One of the main characters is Marine. She is written as a typical 16 year old. She is disobedient, kicks off, vapes and is into art. She is a young girl that doesn’t really fancy going to school. She got expelled from her last school and her last chance to go to a school to finish up her GCSEs. She gets into contact with her former rival from primary school. She starts to regret her options but can’t really do anything bout it. Marine meets and makes new friends that helped her through her journey in her last year in high school. I loved all the characters in this book, at first the book seemed boring, and the structure of the novel was quite unique and weird at first but I got used to it. I love the way she made her friends and how they stuck by her even after all the hardships she faced. The themes includes friendship, courage, responsibility, family, relationship, judgement, social pressure and a sense or taste of freedom. Another main theme is teenage pregnancy. I would recommend the book to any Year 9s to 11s. This is a must read book that portrays the results of some actions that teens do without thinking. Overall this book is inspiring and teaches or rather portrays the life of a basic teenager. This is a 5 out of 5 stars.

Ore
Westleigh book Club

I really liked this book and found it really easy to read. I think that it is better for orlder people. aged 16+ but overall it was really engaging.

Olivia
Epsomians

Tia Fisher’s Not going to plan is a powerful verse novel that talks about sensitive topics that most wouldn’t dare to. There are so many good things that I can say about this book. The characters are one of those good things because they express their emotions in an honest and understandable way, which makes me feel more immersed in their world and their story. I love the bond between Marnie and Zed because it just makes the book feel more realistic. Marnie and Zed go through things that would crush a lot of people, and they work through it together. The story is a very big part of why I like this book so much. The story is always moving. I love the pacing because it is at the perfect pace for anyone to understand. As important as the beginning of the book is the end also very important and the ending of this book just made me warm because it’s so heartfelt and beautiful. To conclude I want to state one last point. I adore the way this was written. Tia Fisher uses her words to create stunning imagery which is a wonderful addition to the book and allows me to fully understand her words. She writes about what Marnie and Zed went through together in a simple but intense way. She uses a range of unique methods which elevates her writing. I enjoy her dual perspective style allowing me to understand both characters in a different view.

Matilda
BUCS Library Book Club

Tia Fisher's Not Going to Plan is a powerful verse novel that explores the concept of choices. The story tackles difficulties though throughout the story it remains hopeful and engaging showing the importance of support and understanding during challenging moments One of the novels most important features is the bond between Marnie and Zed. Marnie is a creative, confident and independent student while Zed prefers routine logic and structure. Despite their differences they develop a genuine friendship through their shared experiences. This makes their bond feel like a more realistic demonstration of a friendship. The novel follows Marnie after she has an experience at the party that would change the rest of her school year. Tia handles the sensitive topics with care focusing on the emotional journey rather than including dramatic plot twists. The story explores difficult decisions she must make and the challenges she faces while also highlighting resilience and personal growth. Tia’s use of formatting is very effective - the different poem styles reflect the personalities of the two protagonists. Marnie’s sections tend to feel more creative and expressive with Zed’s opportunity more structure. The story uses verse novel format effectively adding in some more emotional impact

Philip
BUCS Library Book Club

Not Going to Plan by Tia Fisher is an excellent and gripping read for teenagers. When Marnie arrives at a new school she is placed next to Zed her exact opposite. Marnie is a rebelling girl who vapes and is great at Spanish but sucks at Physics. Zed is a geek who loathes the smell of vapes and loves Physics however he hates Spanish. When both find themselves sat next to each other in lessons they decide to revise together. Marnie helping Zed in Spanish and Zed helping Marnie with her Physics, these two soon find themselves acquaintances. Tia Fisher is an excellent author who fuses poetry and story telling into incredible narrative poetry piece. I love how she had two fonts for her two very different characters. For Marnie a more extreme squigglly font which demonstrates her personality with her love of parties and desire to create amazing artwork where Zed has a smart font. What a great read!!!!

Manon
Tractors

Not going to plan - Tia fisher I think not going to plan was a very good story, but how it was written in verse amazed me. I think the way the tex was written an shaped made the story so much better by showing you what it ment, not by describing it in loads of detail. The characters were very well thought out and I think Marnie and Zed being completely opposite but still being best friends was a really good idea. Zed is a typical 'nerd' studying instead of going to parties and would much rather be at home by himself then going out with friends. But Marnie? She was the rebellious girl who got expelled from her old private school for vaping and had to moved to Zeds school. This book explores themes of consequences of teenagers choices. And shows you can get out of bad places by talking o the people you trust.

sophie
Tractors

This book shows genuine problems and issues with today as a whole . It makes people aware of pressing issues and how many things can change lives for the worse . I think this was a very good book and I enjoyed reading it .

Conor
Bramcote College Library

Harper
BFS Umbra

This book is one of my favourites this year. The format it is in makes it much easier to read as well as the story being written in the perspectives of the 2 main characters. I felt like the story was very heartfelt and the characters were quite likeable.

Henry W-R
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Honestly, this book intrigued me from the very first word. Narrated entirely in verse, I devoured this book in the span of barely five days or so. Although the use of verse was initially challenging to get my head around, the story drew me in almost instantly with the highly interesting double meanings and word art/shape poems. The use of rhyme and rhythm drives the pacing forward really well, making it very easy to read and comprehend. Though some of the wordplay took me a few rereads to catch on to, it was so interesting to see how the hidden metaphors linked the book even more. Throughout the book, Tia Fisher handles the main themes of the story extremely well - addressing teen pregnancies, consent, abortion and the views surrounding it, women's rights and societal labels. She presents to us a very active story concerning very real-world issues, and shows us the debate surrounding these topics through the contrasting lens of a rebellious, artsy girl and a rule-loving, closed-off boy. Whilst the main theme of the book is abortion, it also spins out to many other different problems teenagers also face in modern times. The topic of LGBTQ+ rights shown through Luca, and how he wants a life where he doesn't have to fight for his sexuality. The idea of religion and double standards surrounding women represented by Rakel, and her own viewpoint on abortion. One line that really stood out to me in the book, really highlighting these double standards was: "We're damned if we do/ We're damned if we don't". The juxtaposing viewpoints of Marnie and Zed really stood out to me: both with single parents, both facing societal pressures yet so very different in their approach to the world. Throughout the book, I really enjoyed as both of them changed each other and evolved in the way they view others. Marnie, initially rebellious and angry, mellowed out and warmed up to other people, interacting and being really supportive. She also stopped vaping, which made me so, so happy! Zed, on the other hand, finally came to terms with being unlabeled by society and accepted that not everything has to be absolutely perfect. He begins to bend the rules a little and learns to flow, instead of being stuck to the strict laws of societal acceptance. I also really loved their friendship. Much like the relationships presented in 24 Seconds From Now, it felt earned and realistic, with the way it slowly built up from a mutual acquaintance to a strong, supportive, close connection between the two. The only critique I would have for the book is that it tries to juggle too much at once. Although the main themes presented were delved into really well, I would have liked to see some more explorations of LGBTQ+ rights and double standards. Maybe it would have helped to just slightly cut down on the myriad of issues presented, since the pacing was already really good. However, I did enjoy how Tia Fisher included topics that are not talked about enough in modern, young adult fiction. In conclusion, I think this book was a really well-linked story addressing real-world issues and giving young people voices through art and creation. Overall, an extremely intriguing read!

Roosha
The Perse Carnegians

Personally, this was one of my favorite books because of how realistic the plot was. It also makes you realize that lots of young people struggle with teen pregnancy and abortion. The detail and the layout was a definite 10/10. Altogether, the book was amazing and I would read it again!

Skye
Vista Academy Littleport

This book is about a girl, Marnie who gets kicked out of her prestigious all girl school and now joins another to finish her GCSE's. When she first joins she is sat next to a math and physics nerd, Zed, who eventually becomes Marnie's tutor and she helps him with his Spanish. However when they get invited to a party is all goes bad... Overall, I think that Tia Fisher wrote this book which was very appealing as it was set in a modern time and used a lot of current day language and abbreviations which made it easy to read and more compelling to a young adult audience. It covered some serious topics like teenage pregnancy and different sexualities. I liked this book and I think that it is good for 14+ to read as it is mature enough to cover serious topics all while being funny and interesting; I like how it was a verse novel which made it seem as though you aren't really reading a book and easily get lost.

dainton
Vista Academy Littleport

I really enjoyed reading this book- it’s one of my favourites this year. I originally wasn’t sure if the fact it was a verse novel would affect my experience, but it actually made the book much easier to read. The characters were engaging and the story was really wonderful and heartfelt.

Isabel
Crypt Bookworms

'Not Going to Plan' is a fantastic book. Written in Tia Fisher's iconic verse, the story follows two main characters: Marnie Staedler, a 'bad girl' with a disrespect for the rules of society, and Zebedee Donovan, a nerd who has an amazing talent for physics. Marnie (terrible at science but great at art and languages) and Zed (amazing at science but awful at languages) don't like each other, but they need each other to pass their GCSEs. But at Marnie's first ever house party, she has s*x with someone who only pretended to wear a condom, resulting in her getting pregnant. As the story unfolds, Marnie and Zed end up becoming friends, with a side storyline involving Zed coming out as queer. It is told from both characters' perspectives, helping us understand them more, and in parts, the verse forms pictures to convey emotions better. Riveting, irreverent and heartwarming, 'Not Going to Plan' is easily a 10/10 from me.

Evan
The Leopards, Skinners’

I think Not Going To Plan is a really good book because it touches on subjects people try to avoid, but they really aren't something you can just avoid. One of the subjects is teen pregnancy, which for every 1000 births, 13.6 of them are teen pregnancies (aged 15-19). It also talks about abortions and how many people view them, like Marnie's friend Rakel believes abortion is wrong because of her faith. I think the fact that the author wasn't scared to write about these subjects shows how great of a writer she is.

Alessandra
Kingdown Wilts

I thought the way the book was set out was really interesting, and I liked that the story had 2 different perspectives. I liked the characters and the way they were presented. However, I think the verse made the story a bit tricky to follow in some places as the story moves quite quickly, and the ending didn't feel very satisfying as a result, as it finishes abruptly.

Eleanor
The High Storrs Shadows

– Before reading the book I must admit, I didn’t think I would enjoy it much but as I started reading through, I was surprised by how much I liked it. I’ve never been one for poetry and had this book not been part of the Carnegies, I don’t think I would have read it. However, I feel like the poetry and the way it was written overall was really nice for a change and I liked how so much story and emotions could be conveyed with such a short number of words. I liked both the characters of Zed and Marnie, and all of their friend, I feel like all the characters were written really well and Jessica had a nice redemption. I wasn’t a fan of the storyline in general but that might just be me, as I’m not personally the biggest fan of teen pregnancy stories. However I really did feel for Marnie and I did feel proud for her at the end of the book. Quite a fun book, maybe like a 7.5/10

Sofia
BFS Umbra

THIS BOOK WAS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! The cover immediately grabbed my attention with its unique style and interesting title name. When I saw the strange layout I thought that this book couldn't be that good, it seemed like the a typical book about some girl who hates her new school. However. THE PLOT AND MESSAGE OF THIS BOOK WAS EXTREMLY THRILLING. With the topic about women empowerment and the ability to have rights over their own body intrigued me even more into the book. With the topics relating to real life teens I feel that the writer definitely used this book as a way to show the audience her viewpoints on these controversial topics and help teens or anybody feel better about themselves if any of these events have happened to them. Its an absolute wonder to read and I suggest every body to read it.

Alimah
FGCS Bibliophiles 2026

Not Going To Plan has a very significant strength which is that it focuses on very real and serious issues with a very good style of writing that makes it feel true. However, the main problem that I didn’t like about the book was the setting that it was in. I think having a book about teenage pregnancy set in a school, especially in the GCSE year, is quite unrealistic. Aside from that, I really liked how Zed and Marnie’s relationship grew because that was a very credible way for a friendship to form, if not a little cliché, but it was very well written in that aspect. The only thing that I would change (apart from what is said above) is having just one main character. Even though it means there are less issues to talk about, it means it is more understandable for the reader particularly as it is already written in verse (which is another thing I liked about the book). Overall I would rate it a 7/10.

Siddharthan
The Perse Carnegians

Not going to plan is a unique book wrote in verses. This structure took a while to grow on but I came to realise the structure of the book allowed for a quick and easy read. Alongside this I believe the complex and mature themes in the book could be better displayed through this format. Overall I enjoyed this book and found the plot engaging throughout.

Jeevan
MTS Northwood

I really liked "Not going to plan" because it shows how Marnie grows up and deals with MAJOR problems teenagers can sometimes go through. I liked how an unlikely friendship is born with the nerdy boy and the snarky* girl. *I couldn't find an adjective to describe Marnie. She really is unique.

Elijah
KES Reader

Let me describe this book. It's like searching through a landfill site and genuinely finding something that still useable and in decent condition. This book is like the best of the worst. This book, 24 seconds from now and Lizard Nobody are what has been convincing me to continue reading these disgraces and I hope my next read, Ghostlines, will not make me want to fall asleep.

Mahad.K
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I believe that the book was cleverly written but the scructure was a bite distracting , it was a very unique thing to do but I personally didn't care for it . The content of the book was interesting at the start but I did lose interest as the plot carried on.

Elizabeth
LatLit

Not Going To Plan is a book about Marnie going through messy relationships and school drama while her best friend Zed is exploring sexuality. I like the way this book was structured showing both Zed and Marnie's point of views throughout the book I loved how easy the characters were to connect with and how relative they were. I would recommend this book to any teenager struggling with identity, sexuality or teenage drama

Ava
Glossopdale Readers

not going to plan is a fantastic book it can be a little bit to graghic at times it tells us about an unlikely friend ship forming and that friend rising up and helping up marine through a tough time one thing i noted is that a people who do read this book they should remember they can stop at any time.

harper
BFS Umbra

I think it is really good because it shows how the girl feels and also teaches girls some moral lessons.

Chidumaga Aimee
The SBSJs

This book "Not going to plan" centers on two main characters Marnie and Zen who are starkly different in nature. Marnie being a troublesome teenager and Zen being a smart, studious person. Marnie ends up in a situation (becoming pregnant) where she needs Zen's help to make a very important philosophical decision still being argued by philosophers today. The themes were discussed well, and I enjoyed the verse novel type. Despite this, this book was not for me for a number of reasons. The issue with this book is that the author oversimplified the situation. The central conflict (pregnancy) is treated more of a inconvenience rather than the ethical question involved. It felt one sided and does not engage with the mistakes the main character made. Tia Fisher does not reflect on any mistakes, drinking, personal boundaries and the ultimate mistake Marnie chose to make. which I did not like. Drinking and vaping at 16 is illegal and this was not reflected in a bad way but more as a choice. Her pregnancy was also her fault for making those decisions'. To conclude, this is a verse novel discussing serious and complex topics but in my opinion could have been presented in a more 2 sided, reflective way.

Atharva
MTS Northwood

Not Going To Plan by Tia Fisher is a mature book written in verses rather than paragraphs. At first I was put off by verse writing but the story itself is exciting and engaging although occasionally hard to follow. Not Going To Plan follows Marnie and Zed, as Marnie finds she is pregnant and knows she would rather go to art college rather than have a baby. I would recommend this book to 13+ as it is an emotional book full of teenage struggles including parties, GCSEs and hard decisions.

Annabelle
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Roosha
The Perse Carnegians

I really enjoyed this book! I thought the way the story was written in verse was very effective and eye-catching and allowed for quite a fast paced book. I felt like the two main protagonists, Marnie and Zed, were really well written and felt like very real characters and I really liked seeing how their unexpected friendship developed. I thought that the different views shared by different characters in the book regarding abortion were well presented and showed why abortion is such a debated topic. It also highlighted the problems with the stigma of abortion and teenage pregnancy in society and the fear of judgement, seen when Marnie doesn't even want to discuss her pregnancy with her mum. I really enjoyed this book and thought that its overall messages and themes were expressed and handled really well.

Tim
St George’s Dragon Readers

Not going to plan is a book based around two people called Marnie and Zed who have to face the difficulties of high school and the stress of GCSEs. I enjoyed this book and would definitely recommend this book to someone likes reading YA based on possible real life.

poppy
Vista Academy Littleport

To me, this book shows a sensitive yet important topic very well. Consent is very important, and this book teaches you the struggles caused by a lack of it. As well as this, this book is informative on what you should do if such things happen. However, I did not really like the style and almost poetry like aspect of this book, as well as sort of pictures within the words sending messages to the reader. I thought so because, to me, this style of writing was very confusing, as having 2 main characters isn't really what I prefer. While I see why other people may love this book, personally I don't think this deserves to be my winner, even if it is very informative.

Bowen
The Perse Carnegians

This was a good book for me because of the views of teen pregnancy and LGBT+. It conveys important messages around this which can almost educate children/teens that read this.

Jennifer
GreatB00ks

Not going to plan, by Tia Fisher, is a brilliant book. It mainly follows Marnie and Zed as they get ready for their GCSEs. However, when Marnie gets pregnant, she needs Zed’s help even though they are opposites. I enjoyed how the book is written in verse but reads like prose, and how you get Marnies perspective and also Zeds. However, I feel like the book is too centred in Marnie. Overall, it is a great book for older readers.

Zach
MTS Northwood

this book is about a girl named Marnie dealing with the messy realities of relationships, drama from her school, and growing up as a teen.

Hasini
BAS Reading Champions

I really enjoyed this book. It was different to anything I've read before. It explores quite grown up themes but in a way that is appropriate for a YA audience. I learnt lots from it and found it very educational but in an interesting way. I liked the hints about one of the characters being neurodivergent, as I'm neurodivergent myself, and I always appreciate seeing neurodivergence represented in books. It is also written in verse and plays with words visually on the page - I was a bit sceptical at first but quickly got into it and this ended up being one of my favourite things about the book.

Hannah
SDG Reads

Not going to plan was one of my favourite books that I read for the shadowing, and I really enjoyed reading a book with such an interesting structure. (the word-pictures) I think that it was really interesting the way that in its own way, Marnie’s GCSE solved many problems for the group. I particularly enjoyed finding out that the decorated numbers for the chapters were a sort of gift to Zed, and I thought that that symbolised how he had influenced her year and GCSE. My favourite character in the book was Naomi, and I thought that she was a sort of fairy godmother in a way to Marnie, guiding her through the year and helping her to grow and improve.

Iris
The Perse Carnegians

This book was a good way to show how consent and making sure you are prepared is an important thing. This story follows two people, different lives at home and how they meet. The formatting of the text was sometimes a little annoying, on one page you would have the format and the it would suddenly switch and the font was fading but it corresponded to what the characters were saying so I get why the author did this. It wasn’t a favourite read but overall I enjoyed it

Natalia
Horsham BOok HUNTers

I think 'not going to plan' is probably my favourite book I have read so far. It takes you on rollercoasters of relatable themes to real life, as Marnie tackles life changing events all at the same time. This book showed me true friendship between Marnie and Zed and how one small change in her decision could have changed her life forever and that you should always choose the right decision for you and, in Marnie’s situation, not just because of someone else thinks that abortion is murder just because of their religion and what they believe in. I think having two different perspectives in this story really makes it different to other books and really stuck out to me. Overall, this book highlights the theme of freedom to be yourself and make your own decisions-no matter what anyone else says. 9/10

Violetta
SDG Reads

This book is wonderful to say the least; for one the presentation is unique and brilliant making every single line different from the rest. The depth is another point that makes the book amazing, as it shows that people need to help and be helped by other people to get along in life and friendship is key. It made me feel incredibly sad for Marnie and angry at Harry for abusing her trust and lying about everything. It is overall a book that preaches freedom to be yourself - no matter how you are.

toby
The Wondrous Book & Biscuit Club

I really enjoyed this book, and was definitely my favourite out of the Carnegie writing novels. Firstly, I liked how it was a verse novel- this definitely helped as some of the other books were quite long with small font (no disrespect to those of course!), so it broke those other books up quite nicely. Secondly, I loved so many of the characters in this book, and, somehow, I could find little parts of them that I could relate to. I can also relate to the theme of GCSE stress that we see through some characters- especially Marnie- and I can also relate to the theme of pressure in general throughout the novel. I also thought the use of speech was extremely effective and was definitely used at the right time, but also how we can see 2 perspectives- Marnie and Zed's inner monologues. I can see this being a stage production someday, or maybe a film, the book was that good. Would recommend to an older, more mature age group though (i.e. older teens, young adults).

Bella
TGGS Carnegie Readers

I really loved this book it was the best Carnegie book I have read so far. The writing style was just so good and it just made it easier and quicker to read. Some of my favourite parts had to be when Marine and Zed were saying the same thing at the same time with just a few different words. There were parts of the book where I just couldn't stop reading I was so engrossed in the story. You really never could know what was coming next. My only advice to the author is to make a sequel it is much needed to know about what happens after their GCSE's, does Zed go to college? Does Marine pursue her art dreams?

Harry
The Wondrous Book & Biscuit Club

Stephen
The SBSJs

Melisa & Phoebe
The SBSJs

I think 'Not Going to Plan' was written well, it was an interestingly structured book. It took you through the details of teenage pregnancy but I like the support Zed gave towards Marnie, showing true friendship. However, if I'm honest, I just didn't really like the topic that much and some parts I found a bit boring. It was an okay read but I wouldn't it again. 7/10

Sophia
KES Readers

I thought 'Not Going To Plan' was a really good book. At first, I thought the format of writing would annoy me but it suprisingly didn't. I liked how it was in perspective of two people, as this made it easier to understand the characters. I think the subject of abortion and teenage pregnancy was approached really well. However, I did find the ending was a bit predictable and didn't have much closure. Overall, I thought it was a good book and would rate it a 7/10.

Amelia
KES Readers

Not Going to Plan is a book to read for three important reasons: awareness, identity, and a different way of writing. A must read for all ages in high school, 5/5.

Ted
TMHS:PageTurners

This is definitely one of the books I most enjoyed this year because it was aimed at older readers. The characters were engaging and original, and I loved how the friendships evolved and changed. I am quite specific about which verse novels I like because they can quickly become confusing or overly concise, but I thought this one was done very well. However I would say the plot and themes are definitely very unoriginal and overdone in teen/YA books. I also liked the almost parallel story of their GCSEs, which coincided with the main story in a very clever and sophisticatedly managed way. Overall I would definitely recommend this book as a good enjoyable read, although it is one of many teen pregnancy narratives now.

Mabel
The High Storrs Shadows

Not Going to Plan is a relatable coming-of-age story about friendships, family, and things not working out the way you expect. I liked how it balanced humour with more emotional moments, which made it feel quite real and easy to connect with. The characters felt believable, like people you might actually know. Overall, it’s an enjoyable and honest story about life not going how you planned.

Sebastian
St George’s Dragon Readers

Not Going to Plan is an amazing book, though it is done in verse and explores big themes in teenage lives. It is a very good book. Some of the shape poetry was good.

Zoe
SDG Reads

Although Not Going to Plan tackles with some important themes accurately, I didn’t find the writing style or story to be compelling or inspiring, even for someone who has had the same experiences as the main character. It followed two of the character’s inner monologue’s, but sadly, I didn’t find them descriptive or interesting in any way. I also don’t think this book teaches you much more about the reality of teenage pregnancy and abortion than you’d already know, which doesn’t support the general audience of the book or make it worth reading for most people.

Dexter
Horsham BOok HUNTers

I really enjoyed reading this book as the verse structure was different and really submerged the reader into the book, especially as it switches between two perspectives. I thought it had a good message and also was funny in parts. It was lovely watching friendships grow and relationships change throughout the book, which made it such an enjoyable book to read.

Louisa
St George’s Dragon Readers

I absolutely loved not going to plan. It was really interesting and I loved the way the characters sometimes thought about the same things; if there was a bit more detail I think their would be more of a flow to the writing however it was still over all very good.

Josie
Chiswick Carnegie

Really amazing book you are such a good author and really capture what happens in the real world (unlikely friendships). Well done Tia! My favourite part is when Marnie first enters her classroom and doesn't know who's side to be on! Congratulations on getting nominated, good luck!

Annabel
St John’s Book Groups

I see this book in many ways, its written in a way which lets you switch between many perspectives quickly and seamlessly, and it carries a message that appears to be controversial, the relationships between the characters interest me the most, as while Harry was in a relationship, he cheats on her in favor of someone he barely knew. Zed has an interesting character arc, this is because he appears first as a priveliged academic, that looks down on others judgementally, but we follow him as he accepts marine and then later attending a youth group with Luca, willing to help marnie with hiding what she needs hidden, by essentially cancelling his dreams to help her. The ending is one i adore, this is because it shows both sides of the situation, shows how people tend to limit the exposure of controversial material in favor of the safer option of hiding it, then taking credit once positively revealed. It handles topics with care and its why i enjoy this book

Poppy
Stratton shadowers

Challenge Activity The Blooming Between Us Backstory Kadie: Kadie is 15 and goes to Charleston Prep (school for girls) and is quite smart, a top student and unusually courageous, you can usually find her in the library nose deep in her book. Kadie doesn't have many friends (though the ones she has are amazing) but she doesn't need them because she has her pen notepad and most importantly her books. Carlos: Carlos is 15 and goes to Charleston High (school for boys), he is loud, obnoxious and loves football. His crowd is the popular crowd, he is Captain of the football team. School is the last thing on his mind . At home he is messy and hates doing what he’s told. In theory he is the definition of a “teenage bad-boy”. In the Summer term when the two schools decide to collaborate for the first time in years . A boy and a girl from each school are partnered up to look at different aspects of the “ Green Horizons “ project. A campaign to teach young people (ages 5-16) about the amazing ecosystem we call our earth and how to keep it healthy (because of the increasing effects of climate change). The pairs are decided at random. So when Kadie and Carlos get paired lets say things don’t seem to be going well. Chapter 8 Carlos (speaking): “So… you’re really gonna read that whole book before we even start?” Carlos (thinking): She’s so quiet it’s loud. Why does she look like she already knows I didn’t do the homework? Kadie (speaking): “Knowledge helps the project run smoothly. You should try it sometime.” Kadie (thinking): Why did that come out sharp? He’s impossible. Loud, messy, distracting… and somehow still staring at me like I’m the strange one. Carlos (speaking): “Hey, I try. Just… not with books.” Carlos (thinking): Why am I explaining myself? Since when do I care what a girl with ink on her fingers thinks of me? Kadie (speaking): “Well, the soil samples won’t analyse themselves. Could you pass me the pH strips?” Kadie (thinking): Please don’t drop them. Please don’t— Carlos (speaking): “These? Relax, I’m not a total disaster.” Carlos (thinking): Okay, maybe I am. But she doesn’t have to look so worried. I can handle a piece of paper, right? Kadie (speaking): “Thank you.” Kadie (thinking): He didn’t drop them. Huh. Maybe miracles do happen. Carlos (speaking): “So… why do you care so much about this project? It’s just school stuff.” Carlos (thinking): I shouldn’t ask. But I want to know. She looks at the world like it’s a puzzle she’s already halfway solved. Kadie (speaking): “Because it matters. Because the planet is changing and someone has to teach the younger ones how to protect what’s left.” Kadie (thinking): And because caring is easier than talking to you. Or… it was. Before you started asking real questions. Carlos (speaking): “You talk like you’re older than fifteen.” Carlos (thinking): And smarter. And braver. And… why am I noticing this? Kadie (speaking): “Someone has to.” Kadie (thinking): Why does he suddenly look serious? It’s unsettling. He’s supposed to joke, not listen. Carlos (speaking): “Well… maybe you can teach me too.” Carlos (thinking): Did I really just say that? Great. Now she thinks I’m trying to impress her. …am I? Kadie (speaking): “Maybe I can.” Kadie (thinking): Oh no. Why did I smile? He definitely saw that. And he’s definitely going to make it weird. Carlos (speaking): “Cool.” Carlos (thinking): She smiled. And it wasn’t at a book. I’m in trouble.

Willow
Atlantic Awesome Readers

I really liked how this book's composition read like a poem; it flowed and switched from two perspectives but it didn't feel jumpy or like we were missing out on anything. The overall story of the book was really interesting, I liked the friendship group formed and the way they were mostly supportive of her when she got pregnant and made her decision, although Raquel initially opposed it she came round and supported her friend. I loved how her friend tried to support her despite knowing so little about pregnancy or abortion The big art show reveal was also very satisfying at the end.

Florence
Carnegie Shadow Judges MEAC

Not Going To Plan is to me a very good book. I loved the different styles of writing in the book, like the different points of view for the different characters, the in verse story, and the words that formed pictures. I felt that Not Going To Plan covers a sensitive topic very well, and manages to create an informative yet interesting book that is a fun read. Overall, Not Going To Plan is written very well and thoughtfully, creating a 'don't put me down' style read that is associated with great books. I would recommend this to everyone 12 or up.

Benjamin
The Perse Carnegians

'Not going to plan' by Tia Fisher is a great book that I enjoyed to read and became completely engulfed in the book by the first chapter, it follows Marnie and Zed through a series of challenges. As the book goes on, their bond of friendship becomes bigger and by the end you would barely be able to part them.

Delilah
CSGS Page Turners 26

I enjoyed how it focused on the consequences rather then the actions and how it exposed a side of romance you don't normally see in romance books for kids.

Ezra
ShadowBookers

Edith
Montsaye Shadow Readers

Zed and his friend Marnie find out she is pregnant after a boy lied about wearing a condom. I liked how this book was written in verse and poems instead of being written left to right like a normal book. This is my favourite book so far! 5 stars!

Edith
Montsaye Shadow Readers

Marnie - a troublesome girl and Zed - a shy nerd, form an unlikely friendship, but then Marnie gets pregnant... I really loved reading this book. It explores the female right to choose what they do with their body, and difficult themes like blackmail and rape. It also leaves you on a really good cliff-hanger at the end... 4 out of 5 stars!

Olivia
Montsaye Shadow Readers

This is about Marnie and Zed and how Marnie got tricked into thinking a boy was using protection when they had sex. In my opinion, I think it's a great book and I love how it has both Zed and Marnie's point of view and how they evolve into who they are. 4 out of 5 stars!

Zara
Montsaye Shadow Readers

I really enjoyed this book. The writing and chapters were set out in a brillant way to ensure an easy read. Marnie was a great character who really grew throughout the book which was really inspiring. I also like how they showed the pressure that was put on Zed and how he overcame it. I love how the book aproached the pregnancy as it taught about how you don't have to go through anything alone. I really enjoyed the and would definetly recommend .

Emmy
GreatB00ks

Having read Tia Fisher's finalist book Crossing The Line last year, I was very excited to read Not Going to Plan. Although I am not an automatic fan of reading books in verse, I have found Fisher's writing to be incredibly accessible, and I love the way she uses shapes and direction in her work to reflect the context. While stories of teen pregnancy is definitely not original in YA literature, the way it is approached in Not Going to Plan is a refreshing new take. The story covers some very difficult topics (such as stealthing and abortion) with great sensitivity, and conversations between characters are raw and honest. As friends clash in their beliefs and actions, the conversations around them are poignant and well considered, showing that people can disagree and still demonstrate respect for each other and promotes a strong sense of empathy in the reader. The way that art and creativity is used as an outlet for protagonist Marnie is a great way to remind readers that there are positive ways to channel difficult feelings and emotions, that can still be recognised and seen by others. While this isn't a book for younger readers, I would absolutely recommend it to older students.

Mrs Sirrelle
BFS Umbra

One of the best verse books, I've read. It was a first time to read these type of books!

Mikaela
The SBSJs

It think that not going to plan was an interesting read, because of the way it dealt with controversial themes like abortion and teenage pregnancy. I think that it also teaches readers about stealthing, but while also having a good plot. I also enjoyed how it showed you should be support of others decisions. I really liked reading this book. I would recommend to anyone wondering about teenage pregnancy and abortion.

LeoL
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed this book, I found the different culture it was set in refreshing and really interesting. I like the structuring of the book as it goes back in time through Neon's life

Felix L
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Not Going to Plan is a book with adult themes such as abortion and stealthing. I would recommend it to 13+

Theo B
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I believe that this was a great book because it shows signs of growing friendship between Marina and Zed when at the start it was all hate and disgust but then they became the best of friends which shows that there is all ways a light at the end of the tunnel and it is nice to read the transition as well.

Charlie
Bookwizards

The beginning of the novel sets up how vulnerable Erik is after he moves to a school. Fisher shows us how Erik is under a lot of stress because of school being alone and problems at home. This makes Erik easy to manipulate. The first part of the book is important because it shows how people like Erik want to belong and have money and how bad people can use this against them. As the story goes on things start to happen faster. Erik loses control of his life. Gets into the bad world of selling drugs. The way the words are written, with sentences and lots of space makes us feel like Erik is really scared and trapped. At first Erik thinks he is in charge. Really he is not. The last part of the book is about how bad things can get when people are treated unfairly by the law. Erik has to deal with being scared hurt and watched all the time. He is trying to make a life for himself. This part of the book also talks about how the system's supposed to help kids like Erik but it does not always work that way. Fisher wrote the book in a way using verse. This makes the book more than a story for young people. The way the words are on the page with a lot of space makes us feel the weight of Erik being alone. The author did not use a lot of words so we can understand the hard topics like law and social issues. The book Crossing the Line is an example of writing today. It should be on the list, for the Carnegie Medal. It is a story and it teaches us something. Fisher does not give us answers but instead shows us how strong Erik is and how we should understand why some teenagers get into trouble. We should look deeper. See what is really going on.

Binyamin
BAS Reading Champions

Not going to plan is a unique book about a normal GCSE student called Marnie, who goes through teenage pregnancy. The story mainly focuses on how the protagonist goes through her hardships with the help of Zed, Luca, and Naomi, even after witnessing the backbites and negative comments on social media. My favorite part of the book was when Marnie’s friends were covering her up when people were mocking her because of her pregnancy, since it showed me the friendship between Marnie and her friends.

Jayden
The Lotus Readers

This book had me begging for just 'one more chapter' every day before bed, which soon turned to 2, 3 and countless more: It is really just that compelling. It is a powerful and engaging verse novel that challenges the taboo of sensitive topics like pregnancy and abortion. It all starts with our main characters Marnie and Zed being forced to sit next to each other in class, and it soon takes off from there. They talk, and through situations, they become friends, despite being the complete opposites of each other. Both Marnie and Zed have their own problems: Marnie being in a situation where she accidentally gets pregnant, and Zed being in a somewhat identity crisis, which hits hard and is relatable to teenagers, especially those in school. It also has its own fresh, creative and effective writing style, where each line is carefully crafted to create a vivid image on what goes on in Marnie's and Zed's head. However, despite each word changing shape to create new ones, it can sometimes get a bit confusing to read, but once you get it, it evokes strong emotions in readers. I believe it would really strike a chord with teens and people who love books that talk about real life issues, as it focuses on important themes such as consent, responsibility and support. It shows that despite life feeling like it's falling apart or "not going to plan", there are still people who care and will support you, which makes it both reassuring and empowering for people to read.

Azizah
FGCS Bibliophiles 2026

This book was not that bad because it showed two very different people's views on each other and how they come to be friends and how Zed is taken out of his comfort zone by Marnie. I didn't enjoy how Marnie got used by someone and got called names by that person, which shows the harsh reality of the world.

Akmal
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really liked the use of contrast in this book, it was really interesting seeing the different sides between Zed and Marnie and how they gradually end up in the same circumstance even though Marnie really dragged Zed into it. It was a really interesting read and I was in shock that the author chose for Marnie to actually have an abortion as every single other book doesn't. I think this book should win for the writing award.

Muyang
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Coming into this book I expected it to be a depressing book about abortion and things going wrong in Marnie's life. However it was wholesome at the end, especially with Marnie's development of her character and how she made up with Jessica (I think her name was). I didn't really like Zed, and I found him to be a bit annoying and I don't think he really developed as a character. Other than that I very much enjoyed this book and I give it a 8/10

Elliott.H
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I like this book because it shows different perspectives from a boy and a girl in different challenging situations. I think that this book would be great for anyone who wants to learn about other peoples perspectives in life and how to persevere in life through the challenges in life.

Eunice
BFS Umbra

Not going to plan a short novel that has 2 view points from different perspectives of the main characters: Marnie Staedler and Zebedee Donnovan. The characters have just entered their IGCSE phase and have many challenges throughout the book. The author, Tia Fisher has used dual perspectives to contrast their characters and personalities as well as the actions of the main characters. The book highlights teen relationships,pregnancy, abortions and the dangers of stealthing. In the book the author also uses the main characters to showcase their voices and ideas using people's view points.What I enjoyed about this book was how it explored serious topics like relationships and teen pregnancy in a powerful and honest way. The story felt emotional and realistic, the book and the topics felt more emotional . I also think that Tia Fisher portrayed the characters as weak, fragile and then made the characters more powerful in their own way. I would recommend this book to young adults who like realistic and romantic fiction, and people who are interested in the topics of unexpected pregnancy and raw friendship.

Kimika
The Lotus Readers

Not Going to Plan is an extremely powerful novel on the topic of teenage pregnancy, stealthing and abortion, told in a very creative and engaging fashion. It follows two main characters, Marnie and Zed, who each have their own worries and problems that they need to deal with. The book makes fantastic use of shape poetry to engross the readers into the minds of Marnie and Zed and their ideas and mindset. Marnie is portrayed as a more creative, free-thinking individual with a distaste for the rules, while Zed is portrayed as more of a logical person. The creative, poem-style writing creates an enthralling back-and-forth between the characters, their ideas, and how their different ideologies blend together when supporting each other. The book leans hard into the value of friendship, the idea of life, and the importance of understanding choices and feelings held by others. Tia Fisher reaches out to all who are facing alienation or unexpected events and comforts them through this work of art.

Junior
The Lotus Readers

‘NOT GOING TO PLAN’ is the kind of book that you can read once, as it also came with the split views of two best friends (Zed & Marnie) and how they cope with a problem together. Given the fact that the both of them experience life in very different ways, shows us what a strong bonded friendship is like. The book is mainly based on the perspective of a girl who comes into conflict just before coming so close to joining an art college she had dreamt of. Themes involved are identity, mature themes, mental-abuse and relationships, so I recommend this book to age 14 and up. I really enjoyed reading ‘NOT GOING TO PLAN’, because of how the book includes the perspective of two friends from the moment they first meet, until the end of book.

Panathara (Eine)
The Lotus Readers

Honestly I was obsessed with this book. The way it was written was so creative and I loved how the words looked on the page. Every page I turned brought something new and showed me a style of writing that I didn't think existed in most book writing. The story felt very relatable, very in your face (in a good way) and very realistic like this could be happening to someone. The book itself is a great way to bring awareness to pregnancy associated with teenagers and kept me entertained all the way through.

Lakshake
HGS Book Club

An incredibly good book; the creativity in how the verses were set out is like nothing I've ever seen and I loved it.

Elizabeth
Sir Roger Manwood’s School Book Club

Marnie really messed up this time around – she gets kicked out and has to move to a different school, where the only available seat is right next to Zed, a nerd with no errors for mistakes. Marnie (talented in art and Spanish, bad at maths) who just wants to loose something and Zed (a genius in maths and physics, hates languages) who hates people even tapping him. They have absolutely nothing in common, except that they both need high grades in subjects they hate. Their tutoring sessions begin to develop into an unexpected friendship, it becomes important when Marnie sleeps with a boy lying about not using a something. I didn’t really like this book but I would recommend this book to young adults who love romance.

natalia
Vista Academy Littleport

Not going to plan is an interesting book exploring the ideas of abortion and teen pregnancy. The story follows Marnie and Zed travelling through life around their GCSEs. At her first party after leaving her posh private school, Marnie becomes pregnant and the trouble begins. With rumours and secrets everywhere, can Marnie and Zed survive the horrors of secondary school?

Estlin K
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

At first it seems like she is a normal rebellious kid, but when she transferred schools that's when the drama started. It's also a really good awareness for teens. It also has a very good plot to it. It's easy to get into as well.

Francesca
Redhill Reviewers

I love Tia Fisher's style of writing. This book handled the sensitive subject of teenage pregnancy with brutal honesty and raw emotion.

Mrs H
LGA Page Turners

Not Going To Plan is an enlightening book showing the good and bad of teenage life from friendships romance and fierce loyalty. Zed and Marnie's relationship is an amazing show of how even if you don't have compatible personalities a wonderful friendship can blossom. I found this book gripping through the layout of the book which made it easy and quick to read. I would read another book by this author because I love the layout that Fisher uses. It has been one of my favourite books that I have read and I think it is a very good candidate for the Carnegie Medal.

Kyla
The Wells Readers

I feel that the characters in this book are probably this book's strong suit and with them, the way that they and their emotions develop and are portrayed is very good. The fact that the two main characters are almost polar opposites inn personality adds to the interest of the book. The plot could be better, however it still isn't bad and everything else is decent or good. Overall, this book was good, but not the best.

Theo dP
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

'Not going to plan' by Tia Fisher is a novel in verse about teenage pregnancy, women's rights and friendship. It starts with Marnie, the main character, joining a school and making some friends. At some point there is a party and she basically has sex with this guy at a party who "said" he was wearing a condom. Marnie and her friends are basically just dealing with that for the rest of the book. This brings me onto my first point: I think that two thirds of the main 'bits' happened at the start of the book which come as a bit of a surprise. It does get cleared up at the end, even though it's a bit confusing in the middle. Some of the sentences are written in quite a strange way, making them quite difficult to understand. The only thing that really stops me from giving it a higher rating is that she vapes. It ruins the whole thing! I also have a problem with the fact that at one point Marnie says she will stop vaping (with fingers crossed) to Zed to get him to help her and then she promises again but I'm pretty sure it doesn't say anywhere if she actually did stop after that. I suppose it was an alright read so I would give it a 5/10.

Tom
Hope Valley Literati

This book was absolutely amazing. The way the author spoke about really taboo subjects so openly was really lovely and created a safe environment within the book. You could really understand what the characters were feeling and the author did an amazing job of creating that space for empathy and emotional connection with the characters. I really loved how no character was left out, their storylines were all thoroughly explored in an interesting and engaging way. I liked how Zed exploration of his sexuality wasn’t his main characteristic and plot line, really highlighting that sexuality doesn’t define us, but it also perfectly illustrated the struggle of labels and pressure to come out and know who and what you are. I loved how Jessica and Marnie almost bonded over the fact they had both been treated awfully by Jessica’s boyfriend. It really made that point clear ‘you are not alone’. The authors use of pacing was incredible and I loved the fact that the story was written from both Marnie and Zeds perspective, so you could get the full story. Sometimes when a book is written like that, it can get really confusing and you start to loose what is going on but I found that this book perfectly balanced the different characters perspectives. It is absolutely incredible.

Lyla
Balla Bookworms

I really enjoyed this book I think the author handled difficult topics that don't get talked about often enough in a really good and clever way that meant it was easy to understand but also didn't offend anyone or take away their personal opinion. I also really appreciated the care and time taken at the end of the book to come up with discussion points for book clubs and links to resources if people do need it. If she were to release another book in that series I would happily read a sequel of them at sixth form or universities and I would also quite like to know what results they got I know some people enjoy it being left as an open book but personally I don't. Finally I am left with one question that wasn't entirely clear in the book obviously Zed is part of the LGBTQ+ community but I'm not sure if he is also autistic maybe.

Amelie
FAB(C)

I found this book to be a really enjoyable and emotive read. The characters were intricate and detailed allowing for very realistic storytelling. I’ve always loved books in verse and I thought this was an intresting use, very fitting for the different perspectives. I’d definitely recommend on account for its drama and relatability. :)

Willow
Central Teen Reading Group

I loved the book Birdy because it was very adventurous.

Rosie
The Barty Book Bunch

This book gave me an insight on topics I had little to no knowledge of, such as stealthing. It included themes common to the young adult genre such as sex, inclusion and finding yourself. The perspectives were far from my reality and I liked that to a certain degree as it allowed me to understand an alternate lifestyle from mine, however the events that occurred made me slightly uncomfortable, as I was not mentally prepared. As a piece of educational fiction, I would rate it a 4/5 however as a book for entertainment/relaxation, it would personally be a 2/5 for me.

Aba
Reading Heroes

The story is about a young girl, Marnie, who gets herself expelled from school and moves to a new one. Once there, she gets paired with a boy who's completely opposite to her; yet they need to help each other to revise for their GCSEs. However, another boy gets her pregnant and she relies on Zed for help. I really enjoyed how this book conveys a message to children in secondary school to always be careful with people you don't fully trust. I also liked the structure of the paragraphs and how they convey how Marnie feels and what she is going through. Overall, I think this is a story that is more aimed at Year 10 and 11 students (rather than Year 7-9), as they will be experiencing similar events to the characters - such as going through exams - and may be more likely to experience things like these. But I did enjoy the book and would read it again. ***** (5 stars).

Aleena
Rockwood Reads

I enjoyed this book as it tackled themes of consent and abortion as well as identity very maturely. The story was quite good and I would recommend to others over the age of 14. My only complaint was that there were no real consequences to because of what happened which made the ending a bit bland.

Hasan I
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed this book because it was funny on a serious topic making younger children feel better about topics like this not to be afraid to be worried about telling someone this an issue in your life

Arwa
Rad readers

I’ve loved this book. I think it talks about very important topics well, and is really well written.

Lina
Rad readers

Very easy read and an interesting plot line.

Bryony
Rad readers

My initial thoughts about the book was on how the author was going to tell a meaning story. It took me only a few days to read the book. The main plot was 16-year-old Marnie trying to navigate her way through conflict. The main themes were sexuality, teen pregnancy and consent. The book handled the topic of teenaged pregnancy well by emphasising the effect it had on the protagonist. We see the extent of her mental distress when she finds out she’s pregnant, and the fear of her mother finding out. I feel like this is a realistic portrayal of what a teenager would genuinely do, and how we should empathise and support pregnant teens, rather than judging them. Another aspect of the book that is intriguing is how it’s written in verse form. The verse form makes it unique from other books, and is a great way of expressing the character’s emotions and feelings to the reader. The book would consistently switch between the characters, and would provide insight into their personalities. I felt like this was very effective in portraying the characters’ personalities, as the readers were able to see how exactly they would think. I did not like how the dialogue at times sounds like an adult trying to write how they assume teenagers talk. It sounds juvenile and uncharacteristic of what a teenager would actually talk like. The most memorable moment of the book was when the protagonist finally told her mother about her abortion. The book would be suitable for ages 15+, due to its mature themes such as sexuality, teenage pregnancy and exploitation in the form of stealthing. It would be most suitable for teens, as the protagonists are teenagers themselves, and allows the reader to relate to them in some way. The book tackles serious topics, and enables teenagers to fully understand the impact of said topics. I would rate it a 7/10. I would recommend it to others and I think it deserves a Carnegie Medal.

Gabriela
Gibraltar Carnegie Scholars

This was honestly THE BEST BOOK I'VE EVER READ EVER!!!!!!! I absolutely adored this book so much so that I accidentally whizzed through it within just over 24 hours of having it. I loved the style the book was written and it made reading this book so interesting as it was a new format of reading for me. I loved the fact that Tia fisher wasn't subtle about anything- she explained everything in full detail from the very start to the very end. I also really liked the fact that she included different perceptions of pregnancy and abortions through different characters in the book as it helped us understand that you can have your own views and opinions on something, especially if its a sensitive topic to do with pregnancy, sex and abortions. ect... I do believe that the messages and the sexual language used in this book may not be appropriate for some younger readers so I think 14+ is the right move to make, but I 100% think that everyone should read this AMAZING book at least once in their life as its educating, enjoyable, page-turning and so so much more. I would definitely read this again and I'm planning on buying this book and her other book "crossing the line" as soon as possible!!

Jemima
Tractors

If I am completely honest, I was not looking forward to reading this because of the subjects I was told would be in the book. I was also sceptical because I assumed the 14+ would be quite inappropriate and I felt out of my comfort zone being persuaded to give it a go. Despite this, and the challenge of how it was written - in verse- I have grown to love ‘Not Going To Plan’ and my opinion has completely changed. I really love how different it is to other books, spreading awareness and compassion. It also added perspective by being written in verse and helped me to learn how to accept and read things that are slightly outside the box. I think so much of the book is about being different and spreading your message. I also think that it highlights how important it is to learn from mistakes and dealing with the consequences of your actions. I also liked how realistic and relatable it was like stressing about exams and dealing with things at school. I think the target audience is 13- 17 year olds because it feels so relatable and truthful at those ages where you could struggle with so many of the things in this teenage book.

Anthea
Larkmead

I really enjoyed Not Going To Plan. I felt the story was very intriguing and the format brought a new edge to the book.

emily
Carnegivores

At first, although I was sceptical to pick up the book as it was written in verse, I did find myself becoming quickly absorbed with the characters, their relationship dynamics, and their values. Zed and Marnie's friendship was a real, accurate portrayal of teen friendship wedged in exam stress and caution but beautiful in its own way. However, the layout of the book did prove difficult to overcome as random size increments and swirly text made it less accesible. I do wish Fisher went more into depth about the ethical issues regarding abortion but her execution on the theme of consent was perfect. Overall, it was quite a quick, satisfactory read that adressed relevant issues within schools or during adolescence.

Edlin
Reading Wizards

This book was amazing!!! It was a beautiful story of consent and it's such an important story. I read this book super quickly because it was written in a way that was fast to read. It was written really nicely and clearly. I would highly recommend this book.

Emma
Ousedale Shadow Chasers

I liked the concept of this book and how it dealt with mature themes in such a way that your were almost warned by the book but also got to enjoy the plot . I especially enjoyed the friendships throughout and how each character supported one and other . I found that this book was great in the way it descriped each moment and especially in the way Fisher wrote . I loved the style of her writing as it made the book and the words on the page fun to read . I would recommend this book to anyone who is familiar with the themes presented within it .

Layla
The Tiffin Girls’ Shadows

"not Going To Plan" by Tia Fisher is a YA novel about two very different people that were 'forced' together on their first day of school and formed an unlikely friendship. It's also about how a boy pretended to wear protection and a girl became pregnant because of it. There were many messages in this book and many characters that told them, but I think my favourite was Marnie's mum because she was so calm and understanding of Marnie's situation - having been through it herself - and really empowered her voice at the end where many parents may have discouraged their children from speaking up about what happened. I think it's amazing books like this get on the shortlist where so many young people can read them and become aware of their message, definitely recommend!

Kristina
The Laureate League

I loved this book! Marnie was an amazingly crafted character, along with Zed which made this book so fun to read! I think that the theme of the book was extremely empowering and the opinions expressed through it I couldn't agree with more. Although this is aimed at older audiences I still found this book gripping and couldn't really put it down! The way the pages are laid out also gives it a certain flair and I loved the way we got both Zed's and Marnie's perspectives in the plotline. In conclusion I absolutely loved this book and will definitely read it again in the near future!

Cassia
Diary of a Wally Kid

It is a great book and would rate it 10 out of 10. it shows you should make up with your friends.

Skye
Court Fields Bookworms

Not Going to Plan is an amazing book which I really enjoyed reading. It was interesting to see Marnie deal with all her struggles whilst at the same time trying not to upset her friends and family with her decisions. I liked how the book discussed certain controversial topics which reflected modern day society and conflict between morals and religion. This book really drew me in, and I would rate it a definite 5/5.

Nourin
Herschel Shadows

I couldn't stop reading this book and I loved the ending. A short summary: Marnie goes to a party and has a one-night-stand with a boy who deceives her into thinking he used protection. She gets pregnant. Her friends find out and help her and she has an abortion. Then she tells her mum who is supportive and helps Marnie resolve the situation. Marnie takes her GCSEs. The main characters include: Marnie, who's good at Spanish and Art but bad at Physics; Zed, who's bad at Spanish but good at Physics and Maths; Jessica, a bully, and Jessica's boyfriend, Harry. I feel like the themes in this book are about freedom and bravery. It educates the reader about their sexual rights. The ending was euphoric and a real release of tension. I would give this book 5 stars out of 5.

Kewe
Harris Academy Purley: Loan Stars

I liked multiple things about this book. I liked the way it was structured, with the way the shape poems were, and the rapid succession between the perspectives of Marnie and Zed. I liked the way it tackled sensitive topics through many character’s eyes, and the clear way it portrayed issues in the world. The characterisations were great as well.

Xayat
Herschel Shadows

Not Going to Plan is a poignant story about two individuals navigating IGCSEs and high school. It zooms in on Marnie and Zed, two people with completely different ideas for their future. The story goes through a whirlpool of teenage pregnancy, stealthing, opinions on abortion, and stress. Although the topics were very sensitive, the author approached them in a very interactive and thought-provoking way through people having different opinions on abortion, relationships with family and friends, and working through conflicts. I especially enjoyed the way the author, Tia Fisher, wrote the book as a poem. The different ways she displayed the text made the book that much more engaging and interesting.

Angela
The Lotus Readers

Freya
Esher High

This book was a 10/10 for me . I absolutely loved the poem style and dual narrative and could not get enough of Marnie and her quirky way of showing her creativity . I also could really relate to Zed being viewed as weird by others but not caring and still forming such meaningful relationships with his friends . The only thing that I would change was the fact that you didn’t end up knowing their GCSE results . But the two characters with such different personalities makes this book relatable to everyone in at least one way. Incredible read

Freya
Esher High

Alyss
Ousedale Shadow Chasers

I really enjoyed reading this book, the layout of the verses was really easy to read. The relationship between the characters was heartwarming and also shows a divide in students between their interests and beliefs on different topics. It can show real life issues and school problems between friends and foes. It can show teenage themes and problems that come with it. Overall it was a really good book to read with real life situations and how the characters over come them and can also show people who might be struggling or afraid of any of the themes that the book contains, that they it can be overcome.

Jorja
Tenbury Page Turners 26

I thoroughly enjoyed this book .It explores many intriguing teenage themes and ways to conquer complex life situations . I like the structure of the writing and how its laid out as it makes it engaging and draws you in to keep reading more .I believe the idea in the book is excellently explored. The inclusion of the contrast between the beginning and end of the book and the developing relationship with Marnie and her mother is rather heartwarming.

Annie
Tenbury Page Turners 26

Not going to plan was one of my most favourite books i have EVER read ! 100% recommend.

Gracie
County Shadows

I liked this book a lot, the plot, the way it was written, everything, really. I especially liked how when the perspective changed, it changed sides on the page.

Josiah
Hunt for Excellence

14+ Not Going To Plan Nourishing literature Open book Thrilling novel Grown up content Opposite of boring Intricate Nerd called Zed Genuine book Teaches some important, complex topics Originally written Plucky girl called Marnie Lucky to read it Abortion Not going to stop reading A captivating novel that shows the complex realities of growing up and showing the impact of teenage decisions at a party. I really enjoyed this book as it taught me some very important lessons. I would only recommend this book to over 14s who appreciate good literature. Overall I would rate this book a 6.5/10.

Milo T
Larkmead

I really loved this book! It was relatable, empathetic, funny, beautiful and powerful. Firstly, I thought this book approached the difficult and complex problem of abortion with honesty and empathy. Through Zed, Marnie and their friends, Tia Fisher showed a variety of opinions and ways of dealing with difficult situations with understanding- making this book relatable to many people. She kept the tone of the novel light and funny without taking away from the gravity of the situation. Not Going To Plan is not a miserable book, and that makes it all the more empowering. I also enjoyed that she focused on the relationship between Zed and Marnie, developing their connection without resorting to romance as many YA books do. I also liked the general message of this book, a feminist rebellion but also showing that each person has their own path, not defined by their past mistakes or background. This also links to the open-ended ending. It was a wise choice not to show their GCSE results - sometimes things go to plan, sometimes they don’t, but that doesn’t undo the personal growth accomplished throughout the story. Each character grew and changed throughout this story - but gradually. This book was realistic as it was optimistic, no fairytale quick-fixes for their lives. Finally I can’t not mention the writing style! The verse was beautifully executed, slipping seamlessly between distinct characters. I like how Tia Fisher used concrete poetry techniques to show Marnie’s voice - her thoughts picturesque like her art. Overall, this book is a wonderful creation, and I hope many more young people read it, enjoy it and learn from it as I did!

Matilda
WSFG Carnegies Shadowers

I thought that this book was really good however I feel as if something else should have happened before Marine got pregnant. Whether Marine had a past enemy that she met at Downham or something else to happen. But other than that I feel this book was really touching and the topic was really important.

Taylor
Bramcote College Library

Viki
Montsaye Shadow Readers

Marnie and Zed are complete opposites and need help with GCSEs. When Marnie gets pregnant accidentally, she turns to Zed for help. I think this book was really good and there were many moments when I shut the book to think about it! The beginning was really intriguing and I'm glad about how it ended. I love how the book looks and the writing style. 4 out of 5 stars.

Viki
Montsaye Shadow Readers

I really enjoyed reading this book because it addresses some really important issues like consent and abortion. This story of empowerment is really good as an example of choosing your own path.

Freya
Redhill Reviewers

Marnie got kicked out of Wynford College and had to go to Downham School to complete her GCSEs. Zed has always been at Downham, but he wants to go to a super selective scientific sixth form, then onto Oxford University. This was a really good book, with a really annoying ending! Tia should have told us their results! This story is a good way to support people in a relaxed way without judging others because of their past mistakes.

Ava
Montsaye Shadow Readers

Marnie is expelled from her old boarding school and is sent to a new school for her GCSEs. There, she meets a boy called Zed and they’re basically the opposite. What Marnie’s good at, Zed’s bad at and what Zed’s good at, Marnie’s bad at. Also Zed is nerdy and Marnie is more impulsive. They start having revision sessions and they start becoming friends. Marnie also meets a boy called Harry who invites her to his party. At the party, they get close to each other and Harry only pretends to be wearing a condom. This is a book about choices and consent. I like how the author was writing from her experience so she knows more making it feel more real. I didn’t like how the book was written in verse as it made it really fast paced and I couldn’t get information from it sometimes. In summary, this is a verse novel about choices, consent and navigating teen life!

Leopold
The Perse Carnegians

This book is lovely. Two oppisite people becoming great friends. This story is written like a conversation between Zed and Marnie and so written in verses so I think this writing is really new to the writing industry. I couldn’t put this book down when I started reading and it. Please read!

Blaise
Bookwizards

Personally, I disliked the book, however I am not the age of the target audience. I found it hard to identify with the characters, or with almost of the situations they were facing. I understand that it is a great book about friendship and overcoming life's difficulties, and a great book for older years.

Ben
TBGS READERS

This book explores some important topics, but are discussed in a way that is easily understood. It is so important for this book to be read, and is a book written extremely well for this generation. The use of verse and different perspectives really compliment how the story is told. Overall, the message is very powerful and is a 10/10 read.

Annabel
Floydians

This book was powerful, educational, and a very important read. The subject matter was very serious and heavy, but the author tackled it in a way which felt realistic to teen experience. It was also written well, and I liked the use of creative formatting in some places however the fact it was written in verse felt slightly unnecessary at points. My main criticism would be that while the messaging and themes were extremely valuable, the actual pacing and plot fell off a bit. However I still think everybody should read it and it was important and I think people could learn things from it!

Maddy
JGHS Carnegie Reading Group

I really liked this book especially when tia fisher explained that a lot of teenagers go through abortion and there’s no stories like that. I really liked how it was written as well it took me a second to understand it but after that I understood why she wrote it like that so it could be marnie or zed and their opinion compared to others. Overall this was a great book and I would love to read the next one.

Summer
Tractors

I really loved this book and would read again. It was interesting and educational whilst still being enjoyable. It explored serious and very real themes but also different relationships such as friendship, family and romantic bonds. It was sad but also heartwarming and had a very wholesome end.

Sophie
Cake a Book Club

This book has quite a few deep topics, and I think it really shed light on some of the problems that teenagers may face when tricked into giving consent. Overall I think it is a very important book to read as a young person living in today's society

Annabel
Cake a Book Club

This one surprised me. Within the first 50 pages, I knew this was a unique book I had to finish. Thee are real stakes in this novel. All the characters grow from caricature-esque stereotypes into deeply human people with different outlooks on the complex moral issues displayed in the plot. The pacing was so fast it was hard to put down, and paired with its amazingly one-of-a-kind word art format, I loved it. I think the only problem here is that the ending feels slightly forced and at times (especially at the end) its tight plot got lost in trying to make its message clear. Otherwise, excellent.

Matthew
Talking Books

Not Going To Plan is a bold and inspirational book that shows the consequences of adolescent pregnancy and the importance of consent. When I started reading this book, I found the concept of a verse novel hard to understand; but as the story continued, it seemed correct to make the novel in that format because I actually got to see the story from two sides, literally. To start off, Marnie and Zed are like two opposite people, but as each of them have skills that the other direly needs, their partnership turns into a strong friendship. This book highlights teenage pregnancy and I agree with it's age rating of 14+. Personally, if I were to rate this book, I would give it an 8/10. This is probably one of the strongest and most powerful books out of the entire shortlist.

Jacob
Larkmead

Not going to plan was a powerful novel which portrayed a serious topic by telling to story in a more poetic way with creative imagery too. However it was really well done and I worth a read.I found it a good story when understanding the message that the author was trying to show for a 13 yr old girl.

Taha
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

In the book Not Going to plan by Tia Fisher, there is a girl called Marnie and she messes up at school again but this time it got her expelled. At her new school, the only empty seat is next to zed, a nerd with 0 tolerance for mistakes The 2 couldn’t be less alike.All the same, Marnie (amazing at art and spanish but definitely not numbers) and Zed (marvellous at maths and physics but definitely not languages) need each other's help to get their GCSE’s, and their revision sessions turn into a fragile friendship. But when Marnie has sex with a boy who pretended to have a condom, she has to count on Zed’s help.

Ethan
Glossopdale Readers

It's good for inspiring people to be themselves and take on challenges brought on by their different personality traits. It wasn't that interesting/exciting which is the genre I would go towards with adventure, thrills, etc., but I understand why people would enjoy it. It made me question people's views and made me curious what would happen from a social/emotional perspective rather than an action, thrill seeking viewpoint. The story was motivational in making people stand up and take ownership of themselves and don't be afraid to say no and respond to others' harmful actions.

Jasmine
Cake a Book Club

I think the book started off really strong, and I found the first half of the book really engaging. The characters and storyline were interesting, and it kept me wanting to read more. However, the second half became a bit boring because it seemed to go off topic quite a lot, which made the story lose some of its focus and excitement. Overall, it was still an enjoyable read, but I think the ending could have been more connected to the main plot.

tabs
Plumites

Chronicles of a Lizard Nobody is a middle grade humorous fantasy school story that follows Zeke, a Hall monitor monitor lizard who (mostly) wants to keep a low profile, survive school, and stay out of trouble, however, his plans are thrown away when Pelicarnassus, a pelican who rules the school, develops a grudge that quickly gets out of hand. What I particularly like about this book is its ability to blend humor with more mature themes and issues, making it a quick and lighthearted read while still taking away a hard hitting message. Zeke shows major character growth while being relatable and still within reach, allowing readers to draw inspiration from him. Overall, Chronicles of a Lizard Nobody is a fun and easy read that I would recommend to people of all ages who are fans of comedy and adventure.

Quinn
The Lotus Readers

Not Going To Plan is a YA novel told in verses and stanzas that delves into the viewpoint of 16 year old Marnie Staedler. It unfolds into a double narrative including Zebedee Donovan, or Zed for short; both fighting their own unique challenges. The writer, Tia Fisher, uses the concept of a concrete or shape poetry to cultivate the imagery of the context, instead of pure text. She also presents two characters in the same context, which I find magically poetic. What I enjoyed most about is the heavier topics like stealthing and teenage pregnancy being themes of the novel, which is a very interesting difference in plot as other YA novels focus on lighter topics like school life; with rational, tangible solutions like contraceptives and abortion with the clash with religion and judgement. Overall, Not Going To Plan is an innovative “double-narrative” that hits readers hard and fast with the speed of problems. It shows an unbiased and brutally honest description of love and consent, and I would strongly recommend this to teenage readers that need answers on pregnancy and strong relationships.

Daniel
The Lotus Readers

'Not Going To Plan' is a young adult verse novel written by Tia Fisher. Its quick pacing and use of concrete poetry means the book is very visual and engaging to read, making it accessible for even people who don't enjoy reading. The main characters are likeable and realistic, which makes them easy to get invested in from their introduction into the story and the characters' experiences with exams and school life is relatable to the target audience. The book covers the topics of teen pregnancy, sexual consent and abortion. Specifically it covers the legal repercussions and moral wrongness of stealthing, lying about using a condom, as well as different secular and religious views about the morality of abortion. Overall, I enjoyed the book for its characters, the way it addressed topics that can be difficult and its less common structure.

Ava
Reading Wizards

Relevant, topical issues for today's adolescents dealt with in an interesting way. I enjoyed this book although it is definitely not a lighthearted read, there were some humorous elements to it. I think many teenagers will think of it favouably and it will educate them on both what not and what to do when things quite spectacularly don't go as you want them to. My first read of a verse novel. 4/5 stars

Sadia Sahi
Herschel Shadows

After getting expelled, Marnie meets Zed who is completely different from her. They end up being friends after Marnie makes a mistake and gets pregnant. She has to break taboos. I think that this book is interesting and that people don’t have to be ashamed and that you should break taboos. I think that the book is good and aimed at young adults and adults.

Owen
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Not going to plan is a hooking, stressful and powerful story about mistakes, teenage love and freedom from the expectations of school life and society. With it's easy, fun-to-read text layout and incredible, meaningful story, I didn't want to stop reading. Truly one of the best books I have read in a long time.

Jude
Carnegivores

Not going to plan is a book which explores mature themes like abortion that can be distressing, but Tia explores them in a way which reinforces their importance. I like the way Marnie's and Zed's relationship changes and think that both charecters were complex whilst also being relatable. I like how Marnie uses her GCSE Art coursework to express her freedom which is quite inspiring for students to think about to take their GCSE's this way. I think the book wrapped up quite nicely and was a good read. The way of writing was engaging and unique and I always like having more than one perspective on a book. 3.7 stars

Emaan
Carnegie Shadow Judges MEAC

Not Going To Plan is a really good book. I loved the friendship between the characters and how they all had contrasting opinions and viewpoints. The way Tia Fisher cleverly wrote about the issues of teenage pregnancies was really interesting to read. I would definitely recommend this book to my friends!

Emily
The Broxbourne Readers

I loved Not Going To Plan, this beautiful verse book is so relevant with the discussions about abortion happening in the world right now, however it is definitely a book for older, more mature readers. I didn't expect to feel so much connection to Marnie, but the book immerses you into her world and feelings. I love the way that Zed is presented as a queer person and his discovery of who he is resonates with me as someone who is part of that community. This book manages to discuss a difficult and often avoided topic in a safe and understanding way. It emphasises the point that it is the woman's body, the woman's life and the woman's choice, it covers being taken advantage of and opens the doors to so many important discussions.

Lou
BLURB

This book is a very powerful book that explores stigmatised themes such and teen pregnancies and abortion. I found it very interesting to read about how it would feel for someone experiencing that. Furthermore, there are strong themes of friendship and how good friends will always be there for you. I found this very eye opening and it helped me understand the concept of teen pregnancy and abortion and how it might feel for someone experiencing this.

Deshna
The Tiffin Girls’ Shadows

Not Going to Plan is a powerful and emotional novel that explores issues many teenagers can relate to, including relationships, identity, consent, and the pressure of growing up too quickly. Marnie breaks conventions because she is not presented as a “perfect” teenage girl instead, she feels realistic, flawed, and vulnerable. Throughout the story, she navigates difficult situations while trying to understand herself and the people around her. I found this especially impactful because it showed how easily trust can be broken and how confusing teenage relationships can become. What stayed with me most was how honest the story felt. It does not glamorise teenage struggles but instead encourages empathy and reflection, making it an important and memorable read for young people today.

Ananya
The Lotus Readers

Not going to plan is an emotional and engaging YA novel , that explores friendship and though decisions in a realistic way . The verse format makes the story quick to read while still show in strong emotions and characters development. I liked this book because of the two sides of the people and it was easy to read. I found the story interesting and would recommend to older teenagers.

Therrin
Vista Academy Littleport

I really enjoyed Not Going To Plan by Tia Fisher because I love how engaging it is - partly because of the storyline and the way it is written. Basically, how she illustrates the words or describes them - like the tone she's saying them in and how Marnie’s friends supports her after what she finds out. It is a believable story but I would have liked it if there was more description. It did feel quite rushed and I believe there could have been more written about what could happen next to make it more lengthy.

Apolonia
WSFG Carnegies Shadowers

I really liked this book. The way all the characters were portrayed was really nice with all of them having flaws and likes about them. Despite only having two people narrating, all of them are well developed. Like Jessica Bates who initially is a mean girl who bullies Marnie, but we then learn that she is also taken advantage of. As well as this, I particularly liked how Zed is shown with his queer identity. As a queer person myself, I found that his struggle with figuring out his identity is very realistic and resonates with me. Overall, I thought this book had a very nice message and is my favourite of the books (that I've read so far).

Lara
WSFG Carnegies Shadowers

Not going to plan – By Tia fisher This book most certainly does what it says on the cover as Marnie and Zed’s lives are definitely NOT going to plan! These teens could not be more different but in an unlikely meeting, the nerdy boy with Pikachu earmuffs and the rebellious girl getting expelled form a deep and powerful friendship. Written in verse, the novel conveys the pairs friendship whilst also diving into deeper issues like consent, harassment and respect. With all the drama and buzz at Downham high will Marnie and Zed find their place and finally get things going to plan?

Amy
Helkats & Hardbacks

My first impression of this book was quite similar to what happens at the end, I did miss some details compared to the ending but it was worth reading it! The switch of 2 perspectives is so similar to Malorie Blackman's style and also the emotions are really clear when you put the 2 perspectives in different situations. It's one of those stories where it might relate to other teenagers or even introduce these themes to teenagers. It's quite realistic with today's views and society.

kayla
MSJ Shadowers

This book was very good. The concept of a teenage pregnancy is a very real thing to many people, and Not Going to Plan did a very good job of describing the process leading up to it in an understandable way. While the main characters did seem a bit cliche, the rebellious bad girl and the nerdy boy, they overall helped to create the atmosphere of a toxic school.

Hafiz
MTS Northwood

Tia Fisher’s novel ‘Not Going to Plan’ is a powerful story that explores themes of consent, teenage pregnancy, abortion, and what to do when something doesn’t go according to plan. The language that Tia Fisher uses in this book is words/phrases that the younger generation tends to use, making it seem as if it’s a friend telling a story, allowing me to empathise more with the characters in this book. The way the author displayed all the words was unique, and something I’ve never seen a writer do before, especially when she filled an entire page with “Why me?” with a big question mark in the middle, which emphasized the character’s fear after just finding out she’s pregnant. It also highlights the importance of family and friends, especially in overwhelming situations, which was mainly seen when the main character’s mother chooses to offer support to her rather than scolding her. This novel has strong messages for teenagers about consent and protecting yourself in situations like what the main character, Marnie experienced, and I think it can have a lasting impact on every teenager who reads this book. Overall, ‘Not Going to Plan’ was one of the best books I’ve ever read and I highly recommend this book especially for teenagers.

Gianna
The Lotus Readers

Tia Fisher’s young adult fiction “Not Going to Plan” is a touching yet impactful story. It explores themes of abortion, teen pregnancy and friendship. Its unique way of displaying the words onto the book, the realistic and somewhat relatable characters for teenagers makes it even more enjoyable when reading. The book breaks the shame around abortion whilst also standing up for people who chose not to be sexually active and just want to live their life. Perhaps the most important part is the friendships and bonds in the book, comforting readers that they are not alone and can depend on friends or family whenever they need help. Overall, Fisher’s book is one of the best books I’ve ever read, it is funny, creative and something I really enjoyed reading.

Hoai Anh
The Lotus Readers

Not going to plan is a story dealing with teenage pregnancy learning how to move forward when life changes unexpectedly. I enjoyed the split perspective between two characters as it was really fun to see how different two characters think in the same situation. We learn about two main characters, Marine and Zed, seeing how they change throughout the book and how they overcome and deal with unexpected problems. The book's theme mainly focused on friendship, social pressures and consent and coercion. The writer depicts the dark sides of teenage relationships and how social pressures can affect different situations. Overall, I enjoyed reading this book and I hope others will enjoy this book too.

Lucy
The Lotus Readers

Tia Fisher's ‘Not Going to Plan’ is about a year 11 student called Marnie. At the start, she transfers into a new school, where she meets her best friend, Zed. She then goes on to meet Rakel and Luca. I am disappointed with the relationship statuses at the end because I feel as if the book was building up to something that didn’t happen. This book's main topics are unlikely friendships, control, peer pressure, and sexual consent. I found this book quite interesting, not only because of the context, but also because of the unusual layout. For me, every page told its own story, which made the book very interesting and alluring. Overall, I think this book was a very good read, and I would recommend it to mature readers.

Luci
The Lotus Readers

Not Going To Plan is a verse novel that looks at the perspectives of 16 year old Marnie and the people around her in school. It focuses on Marnie, a defiant student who deals with the result of a sexual ‘accident’. What stood out to me from this novel was the structure as it clearly showed how each character thought. Tia Fisher uses a different style as to the ‘standard’ book and I enjoyed how sometimes the words were structured as images. She really highlights the internal thoughts of the characters and it was interesting to see how Marnie had reacted in that situation. Overall, Not Going To Plan is a novel that discusses and brings attention to many issues that are going on in our current society. Tia Fisher points out the sexual challenges a teenager could deal with and the dangerous situations, not just teenagers could be in, but also adults.

Theresa
The Lotus Readers

Not Going To Plan is a captivating YA contemporary novel that follows 16 year old Marnie, a rebellious student who has to face impossible decisions and consequences of a sexual encounter. Tia Fisher beautifully weaves in themes of deception, breaking taboos, and friendship. What I enjoyed about this book is its realistic depiction of teen life rather than the romanticised version many other YA books fall into. Marnie’s road to growth is complicated and challenging, reminding readers that despite the journey not being easy, everything will work out in the end. Overall, Not Going To Plan is a meaningful and deep read which leaves a lasting impact. It is an un-sugar-coated approach to the challenges of growing up that I would recommend to those interested in teen relationships and fans of verse novels.

Quinn
The Lotus Readers

The book "Not going to plan" is an eye-catcher, With a bright orange front cover I was instantly drawn over to read it. The words are written in verse, stretched out or moved in some form which makes it interesting and different to the other Carnegie books. It is about a girl called Marine who struggles with teenage pregnancy and abortion. To me it felt very realistic and full of emotion, really showing me how bad the situation actually is. It gave me food for thought as to what I woul do if it was me or a friend with a similar problem. I found this a nice quick read and one of my favourites. I do not believe this is a book for children as it is a very touchy, personal subject. So I woul recommend it for readers who are over 13.

Philippa
The Shady Bookhounds

I thought the book had some mature parts in it with strong language but I would suggest this book because it is very good to read

Ella
St Kaths

This book was eye catching by the cover even when on a shelf with many other books. The concept and blurb were interesting and intriguing, creating a desire to explore the story. The poetry layout was unique. However, the change in sizes and the variation in reading direction was frustrating as someone with dyslexia, I would have loved to keep reading but this unfortunately prevented me from doing so. Overall, interesting and eye catching but not accessible for someone with dyslexia.

phoebe
Reading Wizards

This book is written in an interesting way; the lettering is twisted and tugged in various directions, forming shapes that are relevant to the writing itself. However, this means it is quite difficult to read without constantly turning the book. Overall, while I love the storyline, I am not as keen on the shapes made of words.

Molly
The Book Explorers

A fairly book about teenage pregnancy and abortion but I do have doubts about the relationship between Marnie and Zed. Would they really have connected? And the story line was a bit thin all the way through. I enjoyed the book and finished it quickly but that is because it is in verse form.

Mrs Symons
Plumites

The pages are printed in verse which adds interest, especially with the cleverly crafted pictures. The story itself is emotional, fun and quite a roller-coaster ending with the social down fall of the nasty male character.

jess
TMHS:PageTurners

This was one of the most intriguing books I've read in a while. When I saw the concept for the other books I was revolted. Same with this one. however it has been a pleasant surprise being one of my most addictive reads in a while. The fact that the book references real life scenarios (not about the main issue but a little detail that reminded me it was in the present) made me laugh and it feels like the author really cares. My first thought when I got this was "Oh great I've got the worst book here" however reading it has made me realise that this book was completely worth reading and definitely deserves a reward.

Oscar
Plumites

Not Going to Plan by Tia Fisher is a powerful and critically acclaimed young adult verse novel that tackles heavy themes like sexual consent, unplanned pregnancy, and social stigma. Shortlisted for the Carnegie Medal for Writing 2026, it has been widely praised for its accessibility and emotional impact.

lamar m
Lionheart2026

The book was good, but I wouldn’t say it’s one of the best books I’ve read. It is definitely more suitable for older readers because some parts are quite traumatising. One thing I really liked was the layout of the book, which looked really nice and made it enjoyable to read. I would recommend this book to people over 15 who enjoy this type of drama. It’s not really my kind of book, but I know lots of people who would probably love it. I also liked that it didn’t have long, boring sections that dragged on. Overall, it wasn’t a bad book - it just wasn’t to my taste. I would give it a 6/10.

Ksenya
Rainbeau Readers

'Not Going to Plan' was an odd book I struggled with the writing style and didn't particularly enjoy the story... but I was hooked. I couldn't put it down. The prose worked for some parts but didn't work for others. the author clearly thought the story needed a happy ending -I disagree- so some of the ending parts feel unrealistic especially her making up with Jessica. I really liked the addition of a highly religious character added to the story enormously but I found zeds cluelessness annoying at points. An okay book 6/10

Grace
KES Readers

'Not Going to Plan' - Initially I found the main character infuriating, she came across as rebellious and ungrateful to her mother who had put all her power into giving the opportunity for her daughter to attend a higher-class school. However, the more I read the more I became fond of Marnie, I understood her, her school was restricting her freedom in her art and her identity had been lost in the beige of students whose personality and differences had been sucked out of them. Zed bis a complicated character, in some scenes he is supportive or misunderstood and i feel for him, in some he allows his friends to be betrayed and insulted. The writing style was difficult and felt childish, but I think this writing style would help more readers find the message of this book more interesting and take more from it, just a personal thing. The story was relevant and spreads awareness well that abortion is healthcare, and it should not be something to be ashamed of. This book talks of consent and the effect of bullying and carries these messages well to the right audience. Wrapping up, the novel felt incomplete after Marnie had done brilliantly well to stand out and not follow the crowd in her GCSE art, I wished the story hadn’t had been left on a cliffhanger and let down the book. All in all I would rate this book a 7.5/10 would recommend but wouldn’t re-read

Jess
KES Readers

I thought this book had quite a good ending but was otherwise not a very good read. The main character Marnie annoyed me in some parts of the book which could be frustrating to read. The topics which this book explored were not very nice to read but I think the author balanced it enough so that it wasn't an uncomfortable topic.

Nadia
St Kaths

Not Going To Plan I think is a brilliant book for teenage readers. Tia Fisher educates readers on the reality and scariness of teenage pregnancy. This book proves that the people around you are some of the most important people and will help you in the times that you need them. When Marnie decides she wants an abortion, her friends are by her side through it all. Despite their beliefs, in the end the decision was accepted by everyone. Marnie helped a girl who was stuck in a controlling relationship without realising it and spread awareness to girls like her around the world through her art. Not Going To Plan is a brilliant book to spread awareness about manipulation and how deeply you actions can affect somebody else's life.

jess
Diary of a Wally Kid

Not Going to Plan, written by Tia Fisher, is an extremely informative and moving novel. The book covers a variety of sensitive topics that will resonate with readers of all ages. One of the highlights of Fisher’s writing is her effective use of a dual perspective, which allows the reader to deeply connect with the narrative. At its heart, the novel explores the many struggles students face within the school environment. Set in Downham High School, the story follows the unlikely friendship between Marny and Zed. The plot focuses on Marny, who becomes pregnant while still in school following a deceitful encounter with a crush. As the story unfolds, it tackles the sensitive topic of abortion and raises awareness about gaslighting in relationships—even among younger couples. One of the most powerful moments in the book is how Marny uses her GCSE Art presentation to spread awareness about these experiences. I highly recommend this novel because it informs readers about the complexities of sexual encounters and emphasizes that, in many difficult situations, you may not be at fault. It also underscores the vital importance of opening up to friends and peers rather than bottling emotions up. Ultimately, this story may change the way you view both the school system and modern relationships.

Sydney
The Book Explorers

Not going to plan is a book about Marnie, a girl coming up to doing her GCSEs. She makes a mistake and gets too drunk at a party after moving schools, and is impregnated by a boy who pretended to wear a condom. She also meets a boy called Zed who is a bit of a nerd and completely opposite to her. I like that the author made the two main characters complete antithesis to each other because it allowed her to show that even those boundaries didn't stop them being friends, and they could help each other revise. The book is laid out in mini poems/paragraphs mostly about four lines and Zed always talks from one side of the page, and Marnie from the other. This was good because it meant that at some bits, they could say contrasting lines at the same time to show their oppositeness. However, this was flawed when the other characters spoke with them as they messed up the system a little bit and swapped sides from time to time. I also felt like the start was a bit rushed, and the end dragged out, because the 'problem' was two days into the storyline, and then the end was like a month after the resolution. This book has strong themes of pregnancy and abortion, as well as feminist abuse and LGBTQ so I can definitely see why it is aimed at older teenagers or adults. I would rate this book 2.5/5

Felix C
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Tia Fisher’s Not Going to Plan is a highly-rated YA novel in verse (2025) exploring teenage pregnancy, consent, and social taboos. Reviews highlight its "essential" handling of complex, sensitive themes, praising its character-driven approach that addresses issues like stealthing, abortion, and social stigma through an honest lens, making it an insightful read for young adults.

lamar m
Lionheart2026

I really liked this book for many reasons. The characters were great and I loved the way it was written. All the inclusivity was amazing, the LGBTQ+ Group, Teen mothers, Womens rights, and many more. My faveourite character was probbaly Zed, since he was finding himself throught the book, like his sexuality and mother, and all the new challenges he had to face. One detail I loved was that the fact each character had their own font. All in all, 10/10 I absolutely loved it.

Hen
SWA Readers

The novel Not Going to Plan by Tia Fisher certainly is a curious read. At first, upon looking at the words, Fisher ingeniously displays them in a way rarely used: poetry. Moreover, the emotions conveyed are subtly foreshadowed through word art and changes in font. Indeed, this book is a thrilling read, with a whole array and cast of lovable, almost lifelike characters, ranging and diverse in every way possible. Furthermore, it explores themes such as teenage pregnancy, teenage love, and romance in general. I would rate this book very highly due to Fisher’s immense imagination displayed here.

Ryan
The Perse Carnegians

At first, I didn't enjoy the style that the book was written it but it grew on me as I liked the way that it showed two different perspectives. This book is not one that I would normally read but I still found this book empowering and well written. The characters were all well thought out and the plot had a very good shape. I liked the way Zed, Lukka and Rakel supported Marnie throughout her struggles with her pregnancy. I think the way that Tia Fisher thought out the ending with the art project was very creative and how at the end even though Jessica was mean to Marnie they got along at the end. Overall I would give this book a 4/5.

Lukshmi
CSGS Page Turners 26

I really enjoyed reading Not Going To Plan, it was a really fun and engaging read. I loved that some of the lines were shapes, that it was written in two different perspectives and that the text was only written on one side of the page with made you want to read more. I especially liked the ending of the book when Marnie presents her art piece about freedom. I think it was important to show that everyone should have their own rights and make their own choices.

Iona
Tractors

i really enjoyed this book i love how it shows a really big issue in our society

zakir
Cleeve Carnegie

I absolutely loved this book, it was such a good read I struggled to put it down. I think its a really good balance between it being enjoyable and educating. I loved the fact its written in verse and a dual narrative perspective. I also love the way Fisher literally mapped out the story with the text in parts of the book. I think the characters are all quite different so you can see what is happening through multiple viewpoints which can also help you to learn that different people have different views and none have to be right. I like the way Fisher presents Marnie's pregnancy not in a shameful way but as a learning curve and an opportunity. Over all I think this book was fantastic and I have already recommended it to multiple friends. The only thing I would say to check first as it covers mature themes but I think most people would enjoy it.

Isabella
Cleeve Carnegie

i really enjoyed this book because i thought it was very educational and it was also interesting to read because i liked the contrast between Marnie and Zed as it shows two different perspectives. It was really interesting to read a book that talked about more mature themes although i do feel that the whole pregnancy plot was a bit pushed down in some way.

Sophie
Cleeve Carnegie

I like how this book sheds light on teen pregnancy and how it's usually unexpected but you can get through it anyway

Tamera
Dunraven

At first, I didn't like how the book was formated, but then I started to like it because it showed the two different perspectives nicely, I also liked how the words sometimes drew images and showed the different emotions of the characters. Zed being willing to change his ways to help Marnie even though it was a struggle for him, was nice as it showed his strong bond with Marnie. I enjoyed how in the story it showed different topics that people can go through- homophobia, assault and racism. I thought that when the mum comforted Marnie even after her secret abortion was nice because it showed that her mum was there for her no matter what, The open book ending was a good addition, it represented the fact that their futures after secondary had many different possibility's.

Nissi
SMMA BOOKWORMS

The book was written by Tia Fisher. It tells a story of a young girl who has moved schools. She gets invited to a party but she makes the mistake of trusting someone who says they have done something- but they haven't. She ends up finding out that she is pregnant and has an abortion. I definitely recommend adding this book to your collection as it is very intriguing...

Mia
The Book Explorers

Not Going To Plan is a good book. I honestly wouldn’t have picked it up off the shelf just out of choice- but I’m glad I read it. It’s about a year 11 girl who has sex with a boy who pretends to wear a condom. She then gets pregnant, and all of her dreams disappear if she has this baby. She goes through the nerve-racking process of making life decisions no 16 year old girl should have to make and then has to face the fear and pain of abortion. I liked this book because it presents themes of friendship, freedom and determination. I would recommend this book to readers 15+ only because Not Going To Plan does have quite a few adult themes in it as well as the ones previously stated.

Molly
Chiswick Carnegie

I loved this book a lot. To begin with, I felt like Tia Fisher was trying to make us feel sympathy towards Marnie, relating to not only her school situation, but home as well, which I don’t think is represented enough in literature today. I think the fact that her mum works nightly and can only spend a certain amount of money is so realistic for a lot of people who live in the UK right now, especially in today’s society with inflation, difficulties with work and other negative economic phenomena that really aren’t being discussed as much as they should, specifically in England. In addition to that, I think that it’s very hard to hate any of Fisher’s characters, even if they have negative traits sometimes, for example Zed: some people might think he’s annoying or robotic or he doesn’t listen as much as he should, specifically to Marnie, (as well as having a worryingly fastidious mother?) but it wouldn’t be appropriate for him to go along with things and be lovely all the time - without attitude, without flaws, without fear or insecurity or selfishness, the book would be a drag, no? It’s the same with Rakel, I think. She’s so kind, lovely and obviously caring but she still has her own beliefs that could come off as offensive to others, but it’s clear she works on them throughout the ending and I think that represents a lot of difficult character development on her part, as well as assuming it would be hard as her parents would have obvious qualms about Marnie’s decision. As for Marnie, I really liked the fact that she was the same as the typical girls from her school - the vaping, the rough British colloquialism and the attitude - but she was so much deeper than that; she has views that probably no person, girl or boy, would even bother to think about at her age, as well as having her hair painted like a rainbow (something which the typical ‘popular girl’ would probably avoid). I think that this makes her character so much more complex, not so necessarily hard to understand, but hard for a typical non-sensitive person to truly see through, I think that’s why Zed and her had an awkward start to their friendship as well, however as they really got to know each other, their bond became a lot stronger, rather than Marnie and Rakel who I think got along straight away because of Marnie’s façade. In relation to the actual topic I think it's good that it acts as the main topic since most books or tv shows have it as a sub-plot between side characters. But that isn’t the only difference as many Carnegie books have already done that; Tia Fisher makes it feel more real, and less like pregnancy acts as a ‘punishment’, or a ‘sin’, which I get the feeling is already implied in a lot of media, even today. Another character I really loved was Lukka, who I thought was one of the more level-headed ones, and when it came to helping Marnie, he was there with Zed as well. I really loved the fact that Marnie didn’t need to explain her decisions like she did with Zed and Rakel; he just understood her actions, and immediately supported her, and I think in this book he’s a very underrated character, along with Rakel. All in all I really loved this book and I can already tell that it will be my favourite out of all of them.

Pearl
Hope Valley Literati

I have never read a book like it and I really enjoyed it. When I picked it up I thought it wouldn't be something I would finish but it was a great plot and ending. I also think that the contrast between Marnie and Zed was amazing and well thought through!

Oskar
St Kaths

It’s a powerful book about gritty real-life issues, which are often shunned in society, so it’s intriguing and new. I enjoyed it, and would recommend it to people who are passionate about the subjects or seasoned readers.

Amelia
Horsham BOok HUNTers

I found this book really funny, and I really enjoyed the story. I like how it talks about two people, from their perspective of the story, and their thoughts / opinions. I also like how it’s based on a similar story.

Ella
Horsham BOok HUNTers

This book felt like three things at once: A book on pregnancy, like Little Bang from last year. A book about breaking the norm in secondary school. A book trying to explore complex themes. So the pregnancy part is overshadowed by the secondary school part, really being only 50 pages long - short for a verse-novel. The characters felt really stereotypical: one is really good at art and languages but awful at maths, the other is really good at maths and physics but awful at languages and art, and the way that the pregnancy part is handled is quite stereotypical. The themes are just there (I don't care much about themes). The ending is atrocious. They do a great big build up in the last 50 pages (I stayed up to 00:15 reading this on a Saturday night) and it just ends in the least satisfying way possible. 4/10 (and me thinking it was a good read in the first 100 pages...)

Thomas
Hope Valley Literati

Not going to plan, a novel written by Tia Fisher, portrays a realistic high school environment, addressing the fundamental issues in it such as underage drinking and teenage pregnancy in the modern world. Throughout the book, the readers can observe the powerful relationship forming between Zed and Marnie in their academic journey, highlighting both the emotional shifts and challenges during adolescence. I enjoyed reading this novel very much, especially moved by the scene where Marnie reaches out for help for her abortion; watching Marnie’s characteristics develop from a timid and rebellious girl to a passionate, confrontational adult provoked a sense of proudness and inspired me to make braver choices in my life as well. Additionally, I found the structure of the novel’s concrete poetry and typography very unique and visually appealing, similar to other works like Punching the air, contributing to the flow and presentation of the book. In conclusion, this book considering the mature content and profound purpose, is a good and suitable read for students over the age of 14.

JiAn
The Lotus Readers

I enjoyed this book. The way it was written in verse and how the author used that to (literally) shape what was happening was really enjoyable at some bits, although I did find it a bit annoying at times to have to turn the book or my head round to see what was written. In terms of the story, there are some fairly mature themes included but it was generally enjoyable and I would probably recommend it.

Sophie
KECHG Shadowers

Not Going to Plan is about a teenage girl,called Dylan, whose life suddenly changes after an unexpected event,forcing her to face difficult choices /consequences and grow up quickly.The story is written in short ,poetic lines,which makes it feel real and emotional ,like you're inside her thoughts ,wich is the reason to why l really enjoyed reading it. The book explores themes like responsability and relationships.Moreover,the book is written: with a unique writing style which makes the words stand out, and a meaningful morale that shows that even when life goes wrong there is still hope.

Indira
4Shadowers

Not Going To Plan by Tia Fisher is a novel written in verse about two very different teenagers, Marnie and Zed. Marnie is rebellious, and Zed is quiet and focused on sciences. Despite their differences, they become friends and help each other in difficult moments.Furhtermore, I really liked how the novel is told from two different points of view, as it gives more depth to the story. Overall this was a great read and I definitely recommend it !

Louise
4Shadowers

What if you were starting a new school where you know no one but slowly make friends however your actions prove a problem driving a wedge between you and your friends. This book is interesting from two different perspectives. If you like romantic teen books where things go wrong then this book is for you.

Arthur
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Rock Bottom Is a Beginning, Not the End Give this book your all—and it just might give you everything back. ‘Not going to plan’ by Tia Fisher is a fast-paced highly visual novel that really gives its characters a voice. It’s a powerful read consulting sexual consent, unplanned pregnancy and the breaking of taboos. Yes, it does consult these themes boldly, but there is an intentional sincerity sandwiched between the lines of the novel. This strikes the perfect balance between the stark realism of the plot and the meaningful message that has to be transmitted. The plot follows Marnie and Zed, two total opposites struggling to pass their GCSEs, who form an unlikely bond when Marnie moves to a new school. Their lives are upended when Marnie becomes pregnant after an act of “stealthing” by her classmate Harry, forcing her-with Zed’s support-, to navigate the legal and emotional fallout of a non-consensual encounter while facing their final exams. What struck me most was how unexpectedly relatable this book felt. My life is nothing like Marnie’s, or any other character’s, yet I still found myself connecting deeply with the atmosphere and feeling as though I was living alongside them. The novel is written with a level of humanity that many books seem to lack. It is something simple, yet often misunderstood. Humanity is not built on perfection or constant excitement. It is shaped by ups and downs, and by individuals who are always learning, growing, and changing. The immersive setting in ‘Not Going to Plan’ adds depth and realism to the story. I’ve been living in the UK for a few years now and sometimes it feels like living in your own peculiar bubble. The book creates a comfortable, realistic setting that reflects that, hooking the reader into the story even more. Although personally the setting felt very tactile, it might not have its full impact on non-Brittish readers who aren’t accustomed to the book’s setting and subjects, such as the concept of GCSE’s. It is written in verses, where the two protagonists take turns expressing both monologues and dialogues. This structure feels very intentional: not only does it guide the reader through the story more fluidly, but it also gives each character space to be heard. It highlights their individuality and encourages a sense of honesty and bravery in how they express themselves. In Not Going to Plan, there is a subtle feeling of the relentless struggle to reach perfection, much like in real life. This is explored in several ways throughout the novel. It wasn’t exactly Marnie’s pregnancy that gave the punch, it was quite expected, but rather the whole backstory created behind each and every character, which was stunning and captivating. Every character begins from somewhere, and they all strive for their own version of perfection. Along the way, they encounter problems, some bigger than others, but still obstacles that obscure their perfect reality. I can’t find anything more humane or better reflective of the nature of living. It’s a primordial instinct, a call that isn’t very often resonated. I believe that authors can choose how to communicate their story and their ideas. It can be through an action-packed plot or through simple thoughts and reflections that appeal to our emotions. For me, this is what sets apart paper with words from a true book. A book, in my opinion, encourages the reader to reflect on deeper, more personal thoughts, and sometimes even act on them in real life. An action-packed story can be exciting, but so can a film. Books, however, offer something more lasting. They stay with you, shaping the way you think and feel long after you’ve finished them. That’s what makes them so powerful. ‘Not going to Plan’ is a book. I felt very drawn to it as I never thought I would. It was comforting to feel absorbed by the humanity of it; to know that everyone has their ups and downs, but we all make it out of the pit somehow. When I flipped the last page of this book, I knew it was only the end of the beginning.

Noemi-Grace
Euro Champs

Not Going To Plan is about a girl named Marnie who is a victim of stealthing. She is pregnant, and relies on her best friend, Zed, to help her get through this, even though they are completely opposite. She finds help in her friends but has to make the ultimate decision- to keep the baby, or not, by herself. This book is very mature, and I found that I did not like the book that much. However, I found that it was a change to a normal novel as it was written in verse, specifically, shape poetry, which is easy to learn, but hard to perfect. The author made her writing style look like a picture book, which was both amazing but also annoying as I had to frequently turn the page around. Overall, I think this book was very good and I did enjoy reading it, although I do find it is appealing to only a select group of readers.

Kai
The Lotus Readers

This novel felt very real. I thought it was a well written novel about the convoluted and messy process of abortion, the complexities of friendships, and how to live with differences of opinion. I liked the interactions between Zed and his mother the most, and how they ended up dedicating time to reflect and talk to each other so they wouldn't just get stuck in their own thoughts. (spoilers here sorry!) Zed was my favourite character. Even though he had dedicated himself completely to the physics marathon, he ended up messing it up trying to help out Marnie. In the moment, it was excrutiating for him being in that exam hall and unable to concentrate. But after, he was able to make the best of his situation, knowing that he had been able to help his friend through a really difficult situation. His sense of justice made him an immensely likeable character, and unlike the way autistic boys often used to be portrayed, as apathic and heartless.

Zoë
The High Storrs Shadows

Not Going To Plan is a really gripping story with an amazing plot. However, the book layout isn't the greatest and there are some mature themes but overall the book is a really good one to read. I would definitely recommend!

Carys
The Mockingjays

The story is about a girl called Marnie, who is kicked out of school because of a 'relationship' she has with a boy called Zed and she ends up becoming pregnant. The story follows the actions Marnie takes in dealing with this news. My favorite part of the book was when Zed dances like he is from the 1980s, I found this part to be hilarious. I was not too fond of the character of Jessica, who was bullying Zed and attacks Marnie. I think this was a decent book, and quite hilarious in parts - I would recommend it to other students (***** out of five).

Subhan
Rockwood Reads

This is the best book I have read yet (and I am not exaggerating!). It is a short, simple read where you can stop at any point if needed. It shares a story for 2 prospective which really intrigued me. Also, it is very relatable to British children in public school with accurate, updated information such as SLT. Over all it's a 10/10 and if is doesn't win the award, I would be shocked!

Olivia
The Book Voya’s

I really liked this book as I had never read a book with this type of formatting, which I think is called shape poems? The book covers mature themes that are important to talk about and it kept me engaged. Also the fact that there were multiple short poems made it a quick easy read for when I am travelling to just open up the book and start a new poem. I enjoyed this book and gave it a 9/10!

Lishane
MTS Northwood

I loved the conclusion of the book, with the wildly different perspectives of four young characters all intertwining together in a bid for respect and understanding. The dual narrative technique and the arrangement of the text felt dynamic. A powerful read full of important topics.

Sophie
Horsham BOok HUNTers

Tia Fisher blends an incredibly serious topic in her latest book with loveable and relatable characters. It has raw and genuine emotions mixed with a comedic flare that not only is a joy to experience but also respectful of the subject matter.

Jack
Fullbrook Bookworms

Having read Tia Fishers previous novel, Crossing the Line, I knew I would not be disappointed with her newest novel Not Going to Plan. Marnie and Zed are sat next to each other in class. Marnie has just been expelled from her grammar school, after some interesting arrangement of flowers in the school garden and must sit her GCSEs at a local school. Zed is a top student who is not great at Spanish, Physics being his strongest and Marnie’s weakest they decide to help each other out. But after a party at another student's house, some questionable dance moves and decisions make one go down a path they didn’t expect and the other to get caught up in it. The two at first do not get on, but when Marnie needs Zed near the end of the novel he is there for her. I really enjoyed the flow of the story and the way the words were laid out to empathise what was going on. I loved watching the friendship between Marnie and Zed grow. I also thought that the subject matter of the novel, Teenage Pregnancy and the options that Marnie has, is one that needs to be spoken about more openly.

Jess
Orpington Library Older Teens Group

Not going to plan was a really nice, short, easy read due to its poem-like style of writing. I really liked it because at times, it was very tense and extreme but towards the end, slowed down a bit and ended quite nicely, which was the part I really enjoyed. In a way, Marnie felt very relatable about her grades were going down but she still succeeded which I feel many young people these days could relate to. Because of the parts that some people might not like and it whad a good explanation of the consequences which some teenagers might not be aware of. Although Marnie maybe did not do things she should have done in the past, she learnt from her mistakes and moved on and never looked back. She was not afraid to say what had happened to her and Jessica Bates but the fact they could look past all their previous problems and move on.

Charlotte
Chiswick Carnegie

Very informative book based on the termination of pregnancies. It provides statistics and the thoughts of a young girl going through this personal option. I think it's deeply important in the media that more girls know they aren't alone when terminating pregnancy and this book just proves that whatever option you choose, it's yours to make and whether you keep the pregnancy is up to you or not. It was funny and informative at the same time. I would recommend this to anyone who would read it.

Bethany
Henry’s Shadowers

In my opinion "Not Going to Plan" was a beautifully written book, the author's use of prose and concrete poetry helped both bring the words alive and reinforce the books central themes. Whilst the book did delve into some darker more complex themes it didn't feel too heavy or daunting a read, rather the author explored them with respect in a way that made it understandable for all readers without taking away from the severity of the issues. My one critique of the book is that at points it did feel a little unrealistic and the plot felt similar to other YA books I have read. But it's key focus on abortion, a complex ethical issue for many, did help set it apart and overall I would give the book an 8/10.

Eve
KES Readers

This is a great book which covers a really important topic: teen pregnancy and abortion. The verse format makes it highly visual and engaging and complements the author's message. I would definitely recommend to all.

Anya
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

I really enjoyed reading Not Going To Plan and think Tia Fisher is an amazing author. I especially liked the format in which it was written as well as the fact that it was a reasonably fast read. Before each page turn I was dying to know what happened next, and I thought the plot was amazingly gripping. This book is a 10 out of 10 from me and I highly recommend it.

Martha
CSGS Page Turners 26

I feel Not going to plan would make reading feel more accessable and less damanding to people who dont read often because of how it is set out on the page and i feel this is a strength, plus the storyline also carries through well and you get to know the characters extremely early on thanks to each viewpoint being extremely distinct - something not found in all books. I feel the plot was good though i think some of the themes were extremely rushed and not explored to the extent that they could've alongside the storyline such as sexuality and identity

Izzy
Sidmouth Insiders

I really enjoyed this book, as it is written in verse, the message was really powerful. It touched on really mature topics and was extremely enlightening. I couldn't put it down, and once I finished it, I read it all again!

Chloe
CSGS Page Turners 26

This book uses a very interesting style of verse, immersing you within the story. It covers great topics and how to deal with them and I like how at the end of the book there are lots of links to support anyone going through these issues, showing how considerate the author is!

Josh
Tenbury Page Turners 26

I really enjoyed this book. It deals with the important topic of teenage pregnancy and how this affects so many young women and girls, which I feel like is not often spoken about. Although I found some parts of the book a bit too mature for me, I still enjoyed it and just wanted to keep reading. I don't usually choose verse novels but I really liked this one.

Indi
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

I am a massive fan of books in verse, so I may be slightly biased, however I was hooked to this book from the first page. I love how the author challenged these ideas and social expectations as it proved a very educating read. Another thing I like was the structure, especially the moments where the poetry was shape poetry - I just thought it was so intelligent and well done. I really liked the two perspectives of Marnie and Zed and the writers creative decisions were excellent. Overall, a great read and I would definitely recommend!

Cecile
St George’s Dragon Readers

I really enjoyed this book. It is a serious read approached in such a way that is not overwhelming. The main character Marnie faces huge challenges that she tries to fix for herself. One of the main themes in the book is my body, my life, my choice. I found this was really important and a topic that should be discussed more often. Marnie's art topic of freedom changes across the book, which I think represents how she grows as a character. All of the characters are represented very well and feel real because they face real problems. Overall this was an amazing read and I would recommend it to anyone.

Olivia
The Wondrous Book & Biscuit Club

I thought this was a good book talking about some mature themes and talking about female empowerment and racism, I especially loved the dual POV as i felt like this was a fun way of reading a book. The themes are Verse, Empathy, Consent, Identity, Teenage pregnancy, Stealthing and Friendship

Freida
Thomas Tallis Reads

I'm not going to talk about the plot of the book, because the plot of the book was one I've seen a million times. Instead, I want to talk about the book's structure. Poem books don't usually cinch it for me, but the way Fisher used words to make pictures or pictures to tell words was interesting and honestly intriguing. While the story wasn't one I found myself able to move through easily, the way text and placement was structured and utilised was done very well, and I put the book down confident Tia Fisher has a very good way with words.

Hanzalah
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Not Going to Plan is a moving and enjoyable read, addressing topics like teenage pregnancy, stealthing and abortion. I found the layout of the book interesting, it is more like a script than a book. Marnie is expelled from her school and heading to a new one just before her GCSEs. She struggles with mathematics and physics and needs some help to pass. Zed is excellent at maths and physics, but not languages. Revision sessions turn into a fragile friendship between the two. When Marnie gets pregnant by another boy, her friends are there to support her. Not Going to Plan made me feel angry at how easily something like this can happen. It made me think about consent and trust in relationships. I would recommend this book to 15-16 year olds.

Oliver
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Elspeth
Montsaye Shadow Readers

Not Going To Plan is brilliant! Being the first verse novel I have ever read, I found it a little difficult to read at first, however it got much easier as I got deeper into the book. The main character is a very relatable, determined and bold person who struggles to make the right decision for herself after getting pregnant. I love that although her friends have different opinions about what she should do and what is right and wrong, they all come together and support her with her decision. The book is very cleverly written, with words that form images and I also liked the different pictures for each chapter number.

Lyla
Walkden Readers 26

I really enjoyed this read, it explored some great topics quite well. The writing style and structure also added an interesting and different touch.

Noor
Talking Books

An interesting novel in verse format, it has you feeling like Tia Fisher’s Marnie and Zed are talking to you. The story follows two teens in their final year of GCSEs, navigating through the ups and downs of Year 11. Zed, a physics genius and loner, meets Marnie, an art enthusiast and Spanish whizz. Both need help with the subject they hate, and it just so happens that they both excel at each other's weaknesses. A mere tutoring agreement becomes an unexpected friendship, and Marnie relies on Zed during the most difficult decision of her life. The contrast in personalities between Marnie and Zed keeps the story interesting, and the realistic issues of teenage life make the story more relatable and engaging. I would highly recommend this book as it feels mostly realistic and can be relatable for many teens.

Ameerah
The Book Explorers

Not Going To Plan was a powerful and inspiring book about making your own choice without the worry of who will judge you.

Hannah
St John’s Book Groups

Not Going To Plan was a powerful and inspiring book about making your own choice without the worry of who will judge you.

Hannah
St John’s Book Groups

Not Going To Plan by Tia Fisher is a book written in a creative verse format that explores themes of consent, breaking taboos, teen pregnancy and abortion. The story is about Marnie Staedler, a rebellious and brash “scholarship girl” who is expelled from her posh all-girls private school for constant troublemaking. At her new school, she meets Zed, the class nerd who cannot stand hugs or the smell of Marnie’s vapes. At a party, Marnie sleeps with a boy (Harry) who was only pretending to wear a condom (and who only did it with her to make his girlfriend jealous!) Eventually, she finds out that she is pregnant, and needs Zed to help her decide what to do. This book was really enjoyable. The poem format makes the story better paced without having to worry about making the sentences too detailed, and interesting pictures and shapes were also made from the words on the page. I liked the subplots in the story such as Luca and Zed’s situation, which made the characters feel really real and consistent. I really enjoyed the development of friendships and characters – it felt relatively realistic when Marnie and Jessica teamed up on Harry whilst not becoming sudden best friends like in kids films. My favourite character was probably Luca because of his easygoing nature and how he supported Marnie during the abortion. The book covers challenging and tabooed themes but it was written just right: neither treated as an unspeakable topic nor as something to be joked about or glossed over.

yuding
The Perse Carnegians

Bold, Beautiful and Brave. I loved this book - it has a wonderful representation of text and an exceptionally arty, proud and relatable main character Marnie. I like the contrast between her and Zed, the less artful and more science-based character. Both of them have expectations given to them. I thought the plot was really in depth and vibrant, showing life isn't easy and that quite a lot of the time it doesn't go your way. Again the text really shows the readers exactly what is going on and makes it a lot nicer to read. This book is also really nice because it makes the reader feel more aware and understanding to situations that they would probably think "that could never happen to me" and through the characters it also shows that you shouldn't assume anyone's story and people can change, eg. Jessica. Overall, I thought it was absolutely amazing. I would highly recommend it. It is a truly beautiful piece of artwork that stands proud, reminding others to be brave.

Ellie
WSFG Carnegies Shadowers

I really enjoyed this book! It spoke about the important topic of teenage pregnancy and how this affects so many young women and girls, which I feel is not often spoken about. Although I found some parts of the book a bit too old for me I still enjoyed it and just wanted to keep reading! I love how the book is written in verses which is something I don’t usually choose to read but I actually found enjoyable.

Indi
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

I enjoyed this book very much as most of the books from previous years seemed a bit too kiddish, but this one was more grown up and teenager appropriate which made me enjoy this the most. The way the book was written like a role play made it easier to read and understand what all the characters are experiencing and the choice of the school being the main setting really made me enjoy the book more as a reader. This might be my favourite even though I haven't read all of the other books yet and I enjoyed it a lot. 5 out of 5 from me!

Mariia
HAEC Books and Biscuits Carnegie Shadowers

I think 'Not Going to Plan' is a really good book. I enjoyed the plot and I felt that you could really feel sympathy for Marnie once you had gotten to know her better. I loved it and recommend it for others to read. I would rate it 5 out of 5 stars!

Callie
Montsaye Shadow Readers

This book is a realistic and interesting story about a girl who moves schools and finds herself in a tricky situation. The story is told from two perspectives focusing on Marnie who’s artistic and navigating school issues, and Zed a smart student who excels in physics but struggles with social life and languages. This proves anyone can be friends if you get to know each other. I would recommend this book to teens who like books about real school life.i would rate this ⅗ because i prefer books with more action.

Henry c
Glossopdale Readers

'Not Going To Plan' was my first verse novel ever, and to be fully honest, it has completely succeeded past my expectations. Picking up the book, I wasn't sure I'd enjoy it, but after reading the blurb and getting past a few pages, I couldn't get my eyes of the book. Tia Fisher has really peaked my interest for verse novels, and I will definitely be looking into her other books! Excluding the format of the book, the plot and the characters really kept me engaged. Marnie and Zed were beautifully written, and their dynamic truly made me smile whilst reading. I actually got emotional during some parts of the book, and it really comes to show how amazing Tia Fisher is when it comes to writing. I would totally read again! I look forward to more of her books having a chance at being awarded the Carnegie Award. Just so i could have an excuse to read it and smile again!

Melisa
The SBSJs

Overall I thought that Not Going to Plan was a good book. I think that my view changed quite quickly because I thought it would be quite unrealistic that something like that would happen. But I do like how the characters developed throughout the story and Zed and Marnie's friendship grew stronger.

jack
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Not Going to Plan is a novel in verse, with two narrators. I'm not a poetry person, but the book is easy to read, with likeable characters and a very relevant message. The story is aimed at young adults, but is sensitively written for younger readers. A very satisfying read, which made someone I know laugh out loud!

MrsMidge
Balcony Bookworms 2026

I did not like the format nor the story in general but I like the message it teaches. I would rate it, i would rate it a 4/10.

Gracious
Baxter Booklighters

Not Going to Plan is a book about a girl called Marnie who falls pregnant due to a one night stand and her friend Zed who is helping her make the right choice. I believe that this book is very thought provoking since it puts into perspective how something like this story can happen and it highlights the realism of the novel. I also really enjoyed Zed and Marnie’s friendship developing into one where they could trust each other and stand by each other even when a serious challenge faces them. I would recommend this book to young teenagers since I did really enjoy this book. Also I would rate this book a 5/5 since I was never bored of reading it and the story was really intriguing.

Skye B
Glossopdale Readers

I really enjoyed this book. The way it is written means that you can follow the story in a concise way without being overwhelmed by all of the 'outside noise'. The way setting and characters were developed through short sharp sections of text was great. The storyline was harsh but necessary and again the fact there wasn't a love story made this a powerful read. I love the character Zed and the fact that he is shown to struggle with the idea of not fitting into a label of sexuality and that that is OK. For me as a reader I was able to look at this perspective in a supportive and positive light. Fantastically powerful, great character focus and loved the style of writing. Big fan.

Fiona
The Carnegie Coast Readers

This book was really good and I enjoyed it a lot. I loved the formatting of the book and the way it switched between perspectives, highlighting the comparisons well. I also found the message empowering and leaving the ending open to interpretation was a great touch. Overall, I'd give it an 8.5/10.

Linn
KECHG Shadowers

I found this book very interesting and it was written in a fascinating way with the dual perspective verses. I felt as though it carried important messages about abortion and teenage pregnancy. If I had to criticise, I would say that it was perhaps a little fast paced but otherwise I really enjoyed this book, would definitely recommend!

Rowan
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Not Going to Plan was an interesting book. It’s about a 16-year-old girl called Marnie who is always getting into trouble and is eventually sent from her boarding school, to a public school to finish her GCSE course and do the exam there. Then she goes to a party and gets pregnant after a boy pretended to wear protection. It also shows her relationship with Zed, a smart, and careful boy that helps her through her entire journey of pregnancy even when she decides to have an abortion and focus on her GCSEs. I liked this book because it showed lots of friendships and struggles between the characters and Tia Fisher really conveyed lots of emotion between them, however I also disliked this book as it was very fast paced at some points and some points you couldn’t see the development of a relationship, just the product of it. I quite like it 6.5/10.

Sebastian H
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The book’s message is that even when your life feels like a mess, you can get through it with honesty and a true friend. It shows that things don’t always go to plan, but having someone like Zed to support you makes you brave enough to start over. It’s a hopeful story about being yourself and finding strength when things get difficult.

Lojine
Lionheart2026

I really enjoyed this book. The important topic it deals with is teenage pregnancy and how it affects so many young women and girls. I feel this is a topic we all need to speak about more openly and more often. Although I found some parts of the book a bit too mature for me I still enjoyed it and just wanted to keep reading. I don't normally read verse novels but I really couldn't stop reading this one.

Indi
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

Not Going to Plan is a book about teenage pregnancy and is told in verse. I liked how it has lots of themes which kept the story interesting. I enjoyed that the story was written in verse as that made it interesting. I also liked reading about Marnies' emotions. The only thing I didn't like was that the ending felt a bit incomplete and I would have liked to see a longer ending. Overall I really enjoyed this book and would recommend it to young adult readers.

Sophie
The Fitzharrys Shadows

I loved reading this book, the author has effectively captured teenage emotions through the struggles, challenges and recoveries of the 2 main characters. I also really enjoyed the verse-style presentation and how often throughout the book the writer used inventive ways of using words to make images. I like how the author used the idea of standing up for what you believe in as the key element behind this book. Would definitely recommend.

Liam
LSST Library Shadowers

Not Going to Plan is a refreshing and uplifting read. It gently reminds us that life doesn’t need to follow a perfect script to be meaningful. The author tells a story that feels very human. They blend humor, vulnerability, and insight in a way that grabs your attention from the very first page. Instead of viewing setbacks as failures, the book presents them as unexpected chances for growth, discovery, and even joy. What stands out most is how relatable the shared experiences are. Whether dealing with missed chances, sudden changes, or moments of self-doubt, the author tackles each situation with honesty and warmth. This approach makes it easy for readers to see parts of their own lives in the story. The writing style is engaging yet comforting, balancing thoughtful reflection with lighthearted optimism. Another strength of the book is its key message: uncertainty can drive transformation. Rather than promoting strict control, it celebrates adaptability and resilience. By the end, readers find a renewed sense of hope and a reminder that sometimes the best moments arise from plans that fall apart. Overall, Not Going to Plan is an inspiring and uplifting book. It encourages readers to welcome life’s unpredictability. It’s a great choice for anyone seeking reassurance that even when things don’t go as expected, something meaningful and beautiful can still come to light.

Alex
Bookwizards

Like a book I've read recently, the story is presented in an extremely interesting and unique fashion because its organised in a way that allows all perspectives to be witnessed which ensures that the readers ending idea upon the book is fairly varied. And although that is only one statement I overall really enjoyed the book.

Rafa
Chiswick Carnegie

I really liked how fast-paced the book was, I didn't ever get bored, always wanting to read more. I didn't like some of the choices that Marnie made, but that was more of just me and not an actual problem. This is a book I would 100% recommend this book to friends and family.

Aurelia
TPS Carnegie Collective

I thought the book was truly amazing I loved the characters and their special talent. Such a powerful story for teenage girls a book I won't forget!

Phoebe
St John’s Book Groups

Really powerful story!

Mathilde
St John’s Book Groups

Not Going To Plan is an amazing book. I loved every last sentence. The themes explored were sensitive yet handled in the best way possible - I liked how the book explored different views on 'taboo' topics and how nothing was shied away from. The poem format, the writing, and especially the metaphors guarantee I'll be reading more of this authors work in the future! 10/10 book for me!

Rida
HGS Book Club

I found this book really captivating. It is written in verse and is extremely clever in how the layout of the text reflects what is happening/being said in the book. It was quite unlike any book I have ever read. The sensitive theme was approached with subtlety and maturity. I also enjoyed the way the story was told from the perspectives of two opposing personalities, with their individual thoughts on the same incidents at the same time. The age rating was appropriate too, as I think one needs to be 14+ for this story. I found each and every character easy to relate to. Overall, the book is a delightful, engaging and poignant read.

Alexandra
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

Not Going To Plan was a really informative read. It educated me on abortion and what is really involved, something that needs to be more widely discussed. The book is also written in verse which explores different ways to communicate the story. Throughout the book, verse or the word placement (both in sentences and on the page) were used to add pace or slow it down, create visuals to further the story, emphasise certain words and create an interactive read. I would recommend this book to mature teenagers, as it deals with mature topics such as pregnancy and abortion. Additionally, it would resonate with teens due to the focus on GCSE’s and the stress inducing environment around those. Furthermore, the book was really insightful and accurate about teenage life, making it a relatable read. This is particularly shown through the dual narration between Zed (an intelligent boy who is struggling with the social obstacles teenage years present) and Marnie (a problematic girl who goes on a journey of values and self development). Overall, I found this read inspiring, educating and engaging.

Abi
Diary of a Wally Kid

Initially, I wasn’t a fan of the layout as it made it hard to focus on the main theme of the story and I couldn’t get into the book. However as I kept reading, the brilliant concept of two teenage worlds that were so fantastically different yet so similar was refreshing and great to read. Such a beautiful book, would recommend.

Bethan
Horsham BOok HUNTers

I really enjoyed this book. I like how the author wrote the relationships between the characters and how they wrote the plot I didn’t really like the format of the text I found it unique but I found it was unnecessary and made reading the book a bit frustrating other than that I think the front cover is creative and demonstrates what the book is about. Overall I did enjoy the story

Vikki
Horsham BOok HUNTers

This book was really heartwarming and connected with the themes incredibly well. Pros: the style of writing really grabs your attentions and makes you feel as if you are in the characters shoes, the themes are explored really well with multiple different opinions displayed in the book cons: I don't think this book has any cons

Ernest
TBGS READERS

This verse novel was so so so good! It was so well paced and intriguing, I read it in only two days! The characters were so well written and loveable. The storyline was so believable and relevant to modern day as well as being interesting and engaging. The topics dealt with in the book were approached with sensitivity and maturity. I hope to read more verse novels in the future because I enjoyed this one so much. If you're looking for a quick, easy read then this is definitely the book for you!!!

Roseanna
SCD Pageturners

everI enjoyed Not Going to Plan, and it was a great read. I like the contrast between Marnie and Zed, but I think zed was potentially not needed and didn't really do much. However, the abortion was very climatic and very interesting. Also I really like the poem format. 6/10

Toby
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I really enjoyed Not Going To Plan. I loved the way the book was set out. Its full of heart-felt moments where you feel connected to the characters. When I first picked up this book I thought I wouldn't enjoy it, but I was definitely proved wrong!

Ava
Kingdown Wilts

I really enjoyed reading this book as it was such an emotional and moving story. I really liked the way the text was placed like how on some pages the text would be in a swirl or upside down and it would always surprise me where the text was. If I was to rate this book I would rate it 5 stars as it was really fun to read!

Matilda
Kingdown Wilts

I think this was a great book, I really enjoyed the text format as it was very creative. I also loved the fact that the author hasn't shied away from subjects such as abortion

leon
Kingdown Wilts

I thoroughly enjoyed this book, with its impactful message and relatable topics. I found it very meaningful and memorable, and it affected me emotionally, letting me understand people in Marnie's position and realise the hardship they go through. It has opened me up to these things, and I will never forget this book. It is extraordinary; I have learnt a lot from it. The plot line is amazing. In particular, I really enjoyed the way the text was laid out, making it an engaging and unusual read.

Rose
Kingdown Wilts

I enjoyed Not Going To Plan. This was the second time I've read this book and I felt it was much better this time round. I really like books written in verse, and this was no different, with its unique and interesting structure that was a conversation between the two principle characters, Zed and Marnie. It was also very thought provoking and I love Marnie's GCSE art project. My only criticisms are that I didn't understand what 'screen printing' was (although that just might be because I'm not very good at art 😅) and I think it would have been even more interesting & challenging if we had heard the arguments for and against abortion equally compelling and thoroughly. Overall, this is a good read and I would give it 7/10

Ilsa
The High Storrs Shadows

Plot ; I thought that the plot was really well written ,I liked that it reflected themes of Feminism, Standing up to Homophobia and Teenage Pregnancy. I loved the fact that this book was based on empowerment and that this story is personal to the author. I enjoyed the fact that this novel highlighted the struggles and pressures of teenagers, through a personal and meaningful approach. The fact that it was written in verse also made it special and the switching between POVs allowed each character to reflect on the situation and how it affected them deeply. To me, I was deeply hooked from start to finish and read this book in one sitting! One thing I wanted to know was their GCSE scores! Did Zed get a 9 in Spanish? Overall, I rate it 4.5/5!

Zayna
Mansell Library Reviewers

This book is about teenage pregnancy, consent and abortion. I liked this book as it tells the story of Marnie getting pregnant without her consent, and does everything she can to try and abort the foetus.

Tarja
GreatB00ks

I like this book because it is very bold

Amelia
Stratton shadowers

Not Going to Plan was a book about abortion and the struggles that come with it. The book was set in poem form even though it was not a poem in any way, because of this you could read the book very fast. The book was boring at times but was ok.

Joshua R
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I thoroughly enjoyed ‘Not Going to Plan’. The narrative voice is really unique, and the plot is incredibly detailed and enjoyable. The characters are all really diverse and interesting, and I like the way that Tia Fisher can mix small moments of comedy into what might otherwise be a very serious book. This is a wonderful and enlightening read for young people.

Eleanor
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

Not going to plan was an amazing read - it is filled with heartfelt moments where you truly feel connected to the characters. I personally enjoyed the use of dual narrative as it gave me a version of the story from two very different characters' view points showing me how dissimilar the two characters are. I believe that the book sends a great message to its reader of their self worth and independence. Overall it was a great read and I would definitely recommend it.

Charlotte
Skipton Shadows

'Not going to plan' was a book that took upon itself to comment on a difficult topic. Abortion is one of the great ethical questions of the modern day, and I thought that this book explored either side of the debate rather well. However, I wasn't such a fan of the plot, it seemed to be one of the three or four standard YA storylines, much the same story as other books. I wasn't a huge fan of the poetry, this being only the second book I've read in verse. I really disliked the fact that some words and phrases were placed in different fonts and orientations on the page. That I thought took away from the imagination and serious aspects of the book. Overall I'd give it a 6/10, good, but not one I'd read again.

Rory
KES Readers

I really enjoyed the writing style of this book and how the verses were from both the perspectives of Zed and marnie as it really showed the contrast between their characters. The many serious important topics in this book were really well presented without being too upsetting. I especially liked how marnie used her art to bring up, and overcome some issues.

Jessica
THS Book Crew

This book is an amazing ,creative and insperational book that shows children in high school to speack up and how to be safe out of school. This book is a quick read and captivated me in minutes of reading the book. The way the verses are written are amzing as i have never read a book with verses before. Tia Fisher did a magnificent job on this book and definetly pulled this off.

lily
THS Book Crew

Good book from two different peoples point of view. I love the layout and it was my 1st ever verse novel book.

Charlotte
Fullbrook Bookworms

"Not Going To Plan" is a book written as a novel in verse, which gives the whole book a unique feel. The book includes many powerful themes, such as; teenage pregnancy, empathy, consent and identity. It includes two characters who help each other throughout the story. Overall, the story is very empowering, but doesn't feel as smooth as some of Tia Fisher's other works. 8/10

Elliott
Hope Valley Literati

This is an easy-to-read book based around a complex topic I feel strongly about. Marnie finds herself pregnant after a disastrous party. Unable to speak to the adults in her life, she turns to her friends, old and new, for support and help. By adding dialogue to the classic verse novel format we can understand multiple perspectives and viewpoints, so our own prejudices are challenged and gaps in our knowledge filled.

Bibliophile
Angmering Book Lovers 4 Life

Not going to plan by Tia Fisher is a book about a teenage girl facing difficult decisions in life. She needs to learn who to trust and who to turn to for support and ultimately to have the confidence to choose for herself. Marnie is doing her GCSEs when she gets kicked out of her private school and must go to a local public school where she meets Zed. Zed is brilliant at physics so makes a deal with Marnie to teach her physics if she teaches him Spanish. When an unlikely friendship forms, Marnie convinces Zed to go to Harry’s party. She ends up having sex with Harry, who assures her he is wearing a condom. This turns out to be not true and Marnie ends up pregnant. She now faces a difficult choice and finds out who will be by her side whatever happens. This book covers difficult themes including abortion, consent and a person’s right to make decisions for themselves about their own body. There is also true friendship and the unquestioning love of a mother. The book is written in verse and the first-person changes from Zed to Marnie showing their different views on what is happening. I liked this style of writing, and it helped me to understand the characters better. I found some of the themes challenging but I enjoyed reading the book. I would recommend this book to teenagers who want to consider these issues.

Greta
Helkats & Hardbacks

When I first picked up this book, I thought that I wouldn’t enjoy it, but I have been proved very wrong! This book is a must read for all young adults. It contains extremely important subjects like teenage pregnancy, consent and friendship. I love Marnie and Zeds friendships; they are so different but still the perfect match! I also love the fact that this was a verse novel, I know I sometimes feel bored of the words going across the page and this book changed that! The playing of words and visual reading was so engaging and I loved it!

Jana
The Perse Carnegians

I felt this book was a powerful and moving piece of text. While the verse structure was confusing at first I soon got used to it. However, I felt it skimmed over too much details on some bits like the LBTQ+ club and the relationship between zed and Lucas. But I felt this book covered some really important topics and shouldn't be overlooked as a moving drama.

Thomas
Forest Hill Library

I really enjoyed the verse layout of this novel, which meant the books character was altered. The characters felt feasable yet interesting. I think the novel's plot had quite a few interesting path as well. I have'nt read multiple 'teenage pregnancy' books (only little bang) but I felt this story explored themes of poverty and social life as well.

Ernest
Team Car Park

It was an amazing book and I loved how it represented a type of assault people don’t usually recognise as rape. Although, I felt that some parts of the story were a little unfinished. We never got to see how Harry’s reputation was affected, or his reaction to what Jessica and Marnie said in front of everyone, or his family’s reaction. We also never really got to see the end of what happened with Luca and Zed — when Luca said “Maybe I just wasn’t the right one for you.” Zed thought in his head that nobody could be more right for him than Luca, but then nothing else significant happened between them. Zed just stayed unlabelled and what he’d thought about nobody being righter than Luca was not addressed again. I think that they should have either actually got together or Zed shouldn’t have thought that about Luca, because now it feels like that part of the story was accidentally forgotten about and dropped rather than completed with the rest of the book.

Lorin
Carnegivores

the book is quite good and quite a lot of plot twists and i like the end how they faced their problem and got what the people deserve.

Ian
HAEC Books and Biscuits Carnegie Shadowers

🚨TW: Teenage pregnancy, Stealthing and Abortion Marnie attends Wynfird College for Girls on a full scholarship, or she did before she was managed moved to the local Comprehensive because her behaviour was so poor and she made some bad decisions. What the school didn’t see was how she was treated by the other students because she was from a single parent working class home who on occasion has to utilise food banks, classism at its finest. At her new school she hasn’t very long before it’s her GCSE’s so the plan is head down, don’t stand out, get to the end of school. This quickly goes wrong when entering her form room a girl from her old primary school, who doesn’t like her, notices Marnie make her way to her seat and so does this girls boyfriend. Zeb just wants to be left alone, who wants to do well in school and excel in Physics so why has the teacher put the new girl next to him. A friendship eventually forms between Marnie and Zeb when he realises she could help him pass Spanish and she knows for certain he could help her with Physics. Zeb is the one who is there for her when she eventually messes up again and gets herself involved in a drunken fumble with the off limits boyfriend and how mistakes are are a great way to learn and taboo subjects are not something to be ashamed of. A great YA book and my first Novel in Verse. It’s so current and relevant. An empowering book for teen girls to read and because it’s written in verse makes it’s so much easier to read and keeps the pace moving, excellent for those who struggle to read or dislike reading. 4 ⭐

Mrs Ellis
AB Everyone Reading

I really enjoyed this book because its about Marnie and how she messed up at school again and this time she's gotten expelled. At her new school she's sitting next to a nerd called Zed. Then eventually they ended up bonding together.

Musa
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Not Going to Plan was a really interesting book. I enjoyed the format, as it is a verse novel, which makes it a quick read. I liked how it frequently swapped perspectives between Zed and Marnie, allowing you to see both of their viewpoints at the same time. I would definitely recommend this book, and if I had to rate it, I would give it 5/5, as it was a very fun read. My favourite character was Zed because he remains loyal to Marnie throughout and is a very kind character.

Fleur
Rainbeau Readers

I liked Not Going To Plan because it's a funny and easy way to inform people about of the power of consent.

Marwa
Dunraven

Not Going To Plan was a very good book, not only does it educate the reader on challenging topics, but it is also humorous and uplifting. I found that the verse and the fact the book was written with both the stories of the same page was hugely refreshing compared to the over-done different chapter, different character narrative. The book being written in this way also helped create linkage between the two characters’ lives, which could have been missed if read in another format. The sometimes-creative layout of the pages helped to explain the story further, without being tedious or distracting. The plot of the book was heart-felt and pure and also realistic, showing conflicting feelings on certain decisions by friends and family, rather than a romanticised literary version. Overall, I found this book to be powerful and raw. I would hugely recommend and have and will continue to re-read. 10/10

Lulu
KES Readers

'Not Going to Plan' was the first book I read out of the shortlist, and I was pleasantly surprised by the poem-like format. I think it was effective to convey the thought processes of Marnie and Zed in a realistic way, and I thought the use of typography was unique and engaging. It covered mature and controversial themes, namely teenage pregnancy and abortion, which I found to be quite interesting and perhaps a bit heavy, but interesting nonetheless. I felt that Marnie and Zed's connection grew well throughout the book and that their friendship developed quite naturally. Although this wasn't a book that I would pick up myself, it was a fresh and uniquely written perspective towards these themes, and I would definitely recommend it to others.

Yuvi
KECHG Shadowers

I really enjoyed reading "Not going to plan". I really loved the way Tia Fisher cleverly used writing in dual-perspective to convey the feeling of each character in the given scenario and I really enjoyed her play on words as she wrote in verse to further suggest their feelings. This book has many powerful messages. I think it teaches the reader a lot about consent and also how hard it is for some people as they experience a lot of bullying from many things. I believe it also reinforces the need for strong friends and a strong bond with parents as they can help you through the hardest times. It also encourages the reader to think about what they would do if they were faced with the many problems the main character, Marnie, experiences. The story is extremely moving as we go through this journey with her. However, I would have liked the book to have a slightly better ending. For example, it could have explained what the characters did next or even what grades they achieved as we have been with them for so long, I personally wanted to know a bit more about their endings.

Annabel
The Maynard School

When Marnie gets expelled by her independent school and sent to Downham College, she was put to sit next to a boy named Zed, a nerd who does not accept mistakes. The two of them require help from one another. Marnie, who is good at Spanish and art but not at Physics, and Zed, brilliant at maths and Physics but not Spanish, need to help the other to get their GCSEs. But when Marnie has sex with a boy at a party who pretended to wear a condom, she needs Zed’s help to overcome her problem. I like this book because it broadens about how you can rely on others to help overcome your problems and fears, instead of hiding it and making the problem worse. My favourite character in that book would be Luca, who is a friend of Zed’s, because he is funny and understanding about Marnie’s issues. However, I would recommend it to people from Year 10 upwards because it includes some strong language (etc. swear words) and topics that you would cover at a later age, such as consent. In conclusion, this book is a good book to read if you are looking to understand teenagers.

Ibsan
The Perse Carnegians

The book was powerful and informative in such an engaging way. I have not read verse novels before so it was quite unusual to me, and yet it was a very interesting way. It definitely highlights the emotional weight of abortion and dealing with pregnancy, giving quite an accurate idea of teenage culture as well. The cliff hanger it is left on, creates suspense, leaving me wanting read more!

Hannah
KECHG Shadowers

This book was actually my first choice when I saw the books. I read the first chapter or so but felt I had to put it back. After I read a few others I thought I’d give it a try and now I realise how wrong I was to put it down. This book was absolutely fantastic and sometimes I didn’t understand the older themes in the book but understood the story. This has encouraged me to read more young adult books and inspire others to do so as well. I’d like to thank the author for making me step out of my comfort zone of fiction to a kind of in between. Thanks for your time.

Seren
The SBSJs

When I first picked up this book, I was quite skeptical- it was written in free verse, and I generally don't enjoy reading these types of books because I feel like it interrupts the story's flow. However, for this book, it didn't feel like this at all- it matched the storyline quite well and was effective in portraying the dual perspective's of Marnie and Zed. I do feel like there could've been more depth and time spent on the moment before Marnie's big decision, as I feel like the time in which she decided was quite brief. I loved the friendships between the characters and Jessica Bates' showdown at the end😂. Overall, this book was quite gripping and I give it an 8.5 out of 10.

Francesca
Orpington Library Older Teens Group

This is a verse novel, which in a simple giant poem making people read fast. The story follows a girl named Marnie who’s life is basically falling apart. Her grades are slipping, her friends are acting weird, and then she finds out she’s pregnant. I thought the way the author showed Marnie's panic was so realistic. You can really feel her stress through the way the words are laid out on the page, sometimes they even zig-zag or drop down to show how she’s feeling. One of my favourite parts was the relationship between Marnie and her mom. It felt very "real life" and not like a fake movie. Even though the book deals with some heavy stuff, it still felt hopeful. It makes sense that this book was shortlisted for the 2026 Carnegies Medal for Writing because the writing is just so unique. If you liked Tia Fisher's other book, Crossing the Line, you will definately love this one too. I give it 5 stars! Its a great read for anyone who likes stories about real teenagers facing tough choices.

Peace
Vista Academy Littleport

Although I don't usually read books written in verse, after a recommendation from a couple of my friends I loved it: I thought the format of this book made it more impactful and I especially liked the creative ways the words were shown. This was the kind of book where every moment you're not reading it, you're thinking about and wishing you were reading it. It was powerful and interesting and empowering and it really made me think about the important issues raised in the book. It all felt really real and honest and I would really recommend it, even if it's a bit different from what you'd normally read!

Evelyn
BCS Book Squad

Not Going to Plan is an amazing book based on friendship, consent and trust. Tia Fisher connected with her readers through an exhilarating account about a girl who becomes a teen mom whilst struggling through her GCSEs. Tia later tells us, in the author's note, that she wrote this book to raise awareness about consent. However I don't believe that was all she was trying to convey, I feel like she was trying to tell us that when things are hard being with people you love and support you is so important. Overall I think Not Going to Plan is a spectacular book. 8/10

Sara
Chiswick Carnegie

Not Going To Plan is definitely not a book I would take off a shelf in a library, however, when I started to read it, I began to appreciate how it stood up for the right of abortion, and highlights how girls can carry things that wasn’t their fault, and take all the blame. Luckily, Marnie had Zebedee (cool name) by her side. They are complete opposites, but need each other’s help and they go through different things together, like finding boundaries and identity. It is a brilliant book, although it may cause controversy, I definitely agree with it. Consent and choosing what to do with your own body is very important.

Kirsty
Vista Academy Littleport

This personally isnt my favourite book, but i do like the characters Zed and Marnie, and how they are complete opposites!!

Emma
Dunraven

I think not going to plan by Tia fisher was a very good book . its about a boy called zed and a girl called marine who recently got kicked out of the private school she used to go to right before her GCSEs . when she arrived to her new school sat next to zed . later on went to a party and after got pregnant . the story is about her dealing with her GCSEs while tyring to deal with the facts she's pregnant at 15. I would recommend it to teenagers or anyone who likes romance teen drama or love.

Aine
9y4

I really liked this book. Although the themes were mature the writer wrote them really well and definitely did their research for this book. The characters contrasted really well with each other and their friendship was entertaining. The ending was great and it really makes you think and feel for people in the same situation as Marnie. Overall a really good book.

Freya
LGGS Shadow Questers

I found "Not Going to Plan" very interesting and captivating, specifically for the older audiences (15+) as it does contain a lot of mature content, and even I as the reader had to really pause to take what I had read in. But overall, really good book, as it also teaches that accidents do happen, and it's good to have people there to support you!!

Angel
KAEP Lions

Of all my initial expectations for Not Going to Plan what I hadn't anticipated was the book to make me laugh! With such a serious subject matter I was apprehensive that it would be a tough read and students might feel a bit overwhelmed; but Tia Fisher has created a truthful, genuine story that lots of young people will recognise and hopefully find strength from. I am a huge fan of Crossing the Line and once again her verse is sublime with some beautiful imagery captured. My only criticism would be consistency - that some parts felt more compromised than others. I can only imagine how challenging it is to write in verse, and to do so to a deadline must put necessity before beauty on occasion. Perhaps we've been spoilt by the treasure trove of Crossing the Line? The dual narrative was done so well with both characters having distinct voices. I'm looking forward to hearing the response of my shadowing group!

Ms Devine
Booky Wookies

I thought that this was a well written book that explores some topics that are otherwise not widely talked about. It had strong characters and a powerful message.

Maya
St Kaths

I was prepared to not like Not Going to Plan by Tia Fisher as not really being a lover of books written in verse, but I was very surprised as I loved it. It is an honest, engaging novel that really connects with young readers. It follows Marnie, who is suddenly expelled from her prestigious boarding school just before her GCSEs and forced to rebuild her life somewhere new. In her new school, she finds herself sitting next to Zed—quiet, highly intelligent, and seemingly her complete opposite. Marnie shines in creative subjects like art and Spanish, while Zed excels in maths and science, but they quickly realise they share the same determination to succeed. What starts as a practical study arrangement gradually grows into something more meaningful, forming a bond neither of them expected. One of the novel’s biggest strengths is how real the characters feel. Marnie isn’t portrayed as perfect, which makes her relatable, and her struggles with emotions, school pressure, and relationships give the story real depth. Her connection with Zed is especially compelling, and when their friendship is tested by an unfair and painful situation, it adds a powerful emotional layer to the story. The book explores a range of important themes, including mental health, trust, growing up, and facing consequences. It also highlights how important support systems—friends and family—can be during difficult times. Despite tackling serious issues, the writing remains approachable, with moments of humour that balance the heavier topics. Overall, it’s a thoughtful and memorable read that feels genuine and relevant, offering meaningful insights into choices, resilience, and what it means to grow up.

Mrs Ward
BCS Book Squad

This was the first book that I read out of the eight shortlisted and it was really good. I thought the plot was creative and I liked that it was dual narrative. When I first started I was a bit apprehensive as it was in verse format but I found that later on it made it better and more engaging. I thought that the unlikely friendship was good and the group of friends were all different and happy to express themselves. I would recommend this to 14-16 year olds, purely because of some of the themes. I would rate it a 8.5/10 as it had a good plot and was really enjoyable. When reading this book I struggled to put it down and kept on wanting to read one more page as it was so captivating.

Amelia M
Skipton Shadows

This was an amazing book - one of my favourites! I loved the characters and plot and I think spreading awareness about Stealthing is really important - as no one really addresses that it's a form of rape. This was such a compelling read; as soon as I started reading it I couldn't put it down. The book was written in verse and the layout was unique and creative, though as someone who struggles with eyesight I did sometimes find the words and sentences difficult to follow across gaps. I would give this book a 9.5/10 :)

Klara
The Wondrous Book & Biscuit Club

Not going to plan by Tia Fisher It is a realistic fiction genre book about teen pregnancies and exam stress while along the way also touching on subjects such as disappointment, expectations and many more subjects that lots of teens my age and older who are or in the future will struggle with. The main character is a girl called Marnie who is lied to in sex and tricked into thinking the boy had protection while she is under the influence of alcohol. She then seeks help from a boy called Zed who she sits next to in her classes about what to do with the pregnancy, how they deal with it and what comes off it is for you to find out by reading the book. A lovely extra that really made the book go from good to excellent for me was the format in which it was written and how words were emphasised by being printed in different patterns, shapes and fonts. Overall a lovely book that I couldn't recommend more to any teen aged 13-18 who loves a good realistic and relatable book.

Eleanor
Euro Champs

Megan
4Shadowers

Amaury
4Shadowers

Sia
4Shadowers

An incredibly well made book on the topics of consent and identity. I really enjoyed this book and the typography enhanced the feel of the story. Would definitely recommend however I was disappointed by the fact that Zed and Lucas' story never progressed any further in the book.

Trinity
FAB(C)

Not going to plan: Tia Fisher Not going to plan is a powerful young adult book written in verse and focuses on serious teenage issues but in a very clear and appropriate way. The story focuses on Marnie, a girl who is forced to leave her private school due to her rebellious personality. She stars afresh at a new school and meets Zed. A complete opposite of Marnie; he is clever and sensible. They begin to help each other with school work but after a party, everything changes for Marnie. She is left alone to deal with her consequences. Or is she? No she isn’t. Zed and her friends help her through tough times and sad times. The book is filled with different topics such as relationships and responsibility. Overall, Not Going to Plan is an engaging and important read, especially for older teens. It raises awareness of serious issues while still telling a compelling story about friendship and growing up. This book left me with the message that great friends will always be there to help no matter the circumstances.

Maggie
Helkats & Hardbacks

This book helped me understand further teen pregnancies and abortion. It was well written and I liked the style of the layout and how it was written. By writing it from the characters' points of view it helped me understand how they were feeling and what they thought meaning it was a very captivating read. It was a quite emotional read and overall it was very well written and a good read.

Rose
Skipton Shadows

I really enjoyed this book. It was nice to have a story with two people’s perspectives and it was quite funny and wholesome too! It helped me learn about consent and I had a great time reading it.

Justin
4Shadowers

This is probably one of my favourite Carnegie books so far, I really enjoyed it. I was anticipating for the book itself to be quite a long read, taking me a week or so, but I finished this in a few days. If you want a quick read, this may be for you. The story focuses on two main characters; Marnie and Zed. Marnie is a new student, who's just been expelled from her previous school, hoping to find good in her new school. Zed is a smart, charismatic character, hoping to use his knowledge of Physics to help him. Both students have their GCSE's coming up, but when Marnie gets pregnant, it wasn't going to plan. The story shows her mental and physical health, and the pressure weighing on Zed. It also shows, empathy, consent and teenage pregnancy. The plot was understandable and easy to follow at time. I also loved the style of the story using the words themselves as illustrations, I found it fascinating. I highly recommend this book to Year 9+, it was such a good read!

Isla
Ousedale Shadow Chasers

I was skeptical at first but it got really interesting quite quickly. I think it gave a new perspective on teenage pregnancy and i enjoyed the story and the way it moved. The art in it was very creative and i like when books have a deserving ending and all the protagonists are happy.

Melissa
GreatB00ks

I thought that this book was very interesting because it was something I had never read something like it before. I thought that the main characters were interesting because they weren't your natural idea of heroes or heroines. I thought that Marnie was a very believable character but I think that becoming pregnant with a boy you know nothing about is not a life- like situation. I think that she goes through the whole story in a good way because she asks for help from people, which not everyone would do because they can be too scared to tell the truth to people. I like that Zed overcomes his fear of people to help Marnie through everything. The character of Zed's mother is a bit unbelievable because she is so pressurising and she doesn't add a lot to the story apart from not being very supporting to Zed and Marnie. In the end, I liked that Marnie and Jessica joined forces to get back at Jessica's boyfriend, who made Marnie pregnant in the first place. The end part, where Marnie and Jessica speak together is an exciting time and my overall favourite part of the book. Overall, I think that this book is very good and I would definitely go back to read it again.

Ruby
The Perse Carnegians

Great book, epic story really engaging and relatable (not the getting pregnant part) but I found the print style very hard to follow and IT DIDNT END

Flic
Ink & Insight

This book was very good and i thought that marnie was a great character.

Tiana
Dunraven

I enjoyed the book and found the format very interesting, as I hadn't encountered the style of writing before reading the book. I think that all of the characters were written well, and that they all played important roles in the plot. None were featured just for the sake of it. I think the book faced bold topics in a way that was light-hearted, not too heavy, but also rather sophisticated. Overall, I liked the book found it engaging as it built up tension well and followed a clear plot line. However, it was slightly frustrating that we didn't get to see their GCSE results, as it seemed rather crucial.

Rosey
Elms Shadowing 2026

I thought this book was amazing, A really good story while being sensitively informative.

Group Leader
SuAS Shadows

I enjoyed reading the book because I liked how the story followed the lives of 2 completely opposite people. This helped to emphasize exactly how different they are, but also how they needed each other in the most dire moments of their lives. I also enjoyed the format of the book because I found it easier to read. Furthermore, I found the book very informative and it has a very strong and powerful message about abortion and choices, which I think is very helpful to this generation. Lastly, I liked the character development of Marnie because she started off being immature and aloof, but as the story went on she made impactful decisions and managed to use her artwork to reinforce it.

Aleeza
Elms Shadowing 2026

Personally, I slightly enjoyed this book. I found the dialogue and expressions uncomedic, but regardless it was still a fairly good read. The author's interpretation of the issue of pregnancy at such a young age is remarkable and very well written. I especially enjoyed how she used it as art project at the end.

Cole
Elms Shadowing 2026

This book is written in verse, a form which I have previously enjoyed but struggled with this time. The book moved between two different characters point of view and I think this made it harder to connect with them. However, I also think this is in important book with an important topic - abortion and how it is very hard for the person going through it. I think other readers will enjoy reading the book more than me.

Edmund
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I found the book to fall short of my expectations of what seemed like a promising idea for a book. The general theme of the book surrounds the mishaps of teenage life, and deals primarily with facing the consequences of bad decisions. Overall, I think the premise was laid out excellently. However, I think the “moral of the story” was drilled far too much throughout the novel, and I felt it preferred a clear instruction style of “don’t do that, that’s bad” as opposed to the spirit of Carnegie books historically, which present solutions and morals through cleverer methods. For instance [spoiler], Zed ends his conclusion of whether he believes Marnie’s abortion is moral or not as “her body, her choice”, which although is a powerful line used across debates about this, feels very cliche. I feel there was too hard a line between “good characters” and “bad characters”, where the good characters all were politically correct even if they had no real journeys nor motivations to be politically correct. This ties in to my second and biggest criticism, which is that the author throughout the novel describes the characters holding opinions other than those she clearly puts across as “correct” as less intelligent or inferior. She portrays a religious character who is against abortion as being self-centric and uncaring about the feelings of Marnie when discussing her pregnancy, being shown to be dismissive and careless. This is one of the weakest methods in my opinion to convey how one side of an argument is bad: by making the holders of the other side unintelligent and clearly the “bad guys”. Moreover, the characters rarely had personalities that didn’t directly tie into their plot points. Zed, one of the main characters, never ventured out of his nerdy comfort zone, instead staying, throughout the book, static and unchanging, as many other characters seem to do too. The LGBTQ+ character rarely ever talked about anything else other than his sexual orientation, which is a disappointment, as frankly it does no justice to any of the minority groups the author attempted to portray. Overall, with a bit more thought, this book could’ve been a fantastic read, however, I must say it is a downgrade from Fisher’s “Crossing the Line”.

Muadh
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

i read the book "not going to plan" and to be honest, it wasn't my favourite book. It was well written, very easily readable and extremely unique. This book was written in verse which I liked and it was presented uniquely. I think i would have enjoyed it more if it was less detailed in the pregnancy bit, but I understand why the author has included it. In a way, it was good that people get disgusted by underage pregnancy, because it may stop them from doing it.

Srishti
HGS Book Club

An amazing book, I think it really embodies pressure on teens especially with Zed (his A level programme) and questions values asking important questions to the reader and making them stir. It shines light from different angles on serious mature topics. It is only amplified by verse which causes the book to almost flow and make you think differently especially as words are changed into shapes. Something else is Zed questioning his sexual orientation like saying he doesn’t know what he is. It is really uncommon for representation for people who aren’t totally sure where they fit in to which (at least from what I’ve seen) is quite uncommon. However I do think there is a large realistic element which I believe is important to see every once in a while. I know people who have experienced these same academic pressures. I really liked this book, and if you are ok with potentially triggering mature topics this is very definitely a recommendation of mine.

Drupta
HGS Book Club

I think this book is a bit too realistic for my taste.

Marcus
The Broxbourne Readers

I quite enjoyed the plot line as it can be very relatable for children in the late teens, because it includes representation of consent, alcohol, vaping etc. I really liked the way it had been written in verse as it came across as very impactful and the contrast between the two characters was very interesting.

Ivy
Beacon Thursday Book Club

I really enjoyed this book and personally think it is the best one this year. I loved how Zed and Jessica really worked together, despite their completely different backgrounds and aims in life. I also liked how the author used some swear words since it brought out the true emotions of the characters. My only criticism is why didn't she reveal their GCSE results? However other than that I believe it was a very good book.

Seb
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I thought that the book is quite sad and has mature topics but it can help people learn and understand about teen pregnancy

cece
Cake a Book Club

'Not Going To Plan' is a book about empathy, consent and accidental teenage pregnancy. It is about a young lady at 16 years old named Marnie who was expelled from her old school and has to go to a new one. One night at a party a terrible scene occurs where she has sexual intercourse with a young man called Harry. Harry pretends to wear a condom, but doesn't, and Marnie gets pregnant.The author explores ideas about abortion and tries to explain the differing opinions on the controversial topic. I liked the poem format of this book and how it wasn't actually a poem. I also love how the story had different perspectives on the two main characters. I enjoyed the book.

Conor D
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I liked this book. I liked how in chapter 1 it brings up typical teenage actions e.g.. vaping, alcohol and doing piercings and tattoo's by yourself. I liked how in chapter 7 you learn about Marnie's mum and Zed and Jessica's backstory. One of my main issues however is the layout of the book and the format it is written in. I found it amusing, I was in hysterics and it entertained me for hours. I found the party very confusing, I didn't know where everyone was and I also thought that when Zed and Luca kissed I thought it should be more of a thing across the book towards the beginning. I loved how Marnie's friends supported her. I loved when Jessica and Marnie put Harry to justice for his actions. I loved the ending but i would like to of seen the GCSE's results and saw the expression of happiness if they got good GCSE's. I would like to know more about Naomi's backstory.

Lilah
Ousedale Olney

This is an extraordinary book. From the contrasts between Zed and Marnie to realism of it all, everything seemed to fit perfectly. I would definitely recommend this to another reader.

Zack
Crypt Bookworms

I was looking forward to reading Not Going to Plan and was not let down – the book is written in verse brilliantly and I enjoyed it from cover to cover. The story is about the serious and often distressing topic of teenage pregnancy, but is entwined with other topics such as feminism, LGBTQ+ rights and many more. It was a very enjoyable read, and Tia Fisher has created a fantastic book where you feel as if you are in the characters' shoes. I believe that this book could also be very helpful to people struggling with similar situations. Overall, Not Going to Plan was an amazing read and I would definitely recommend it.

Louis
The Fitzharrys Shadows

"Not Going To Plan" is a thought-provoking book which tackles difficult and relevant topics such as abortion and sexual consent. I really enjoyed how the style of the verse helped demonstrate each character's feelings at that specific moment. I found the characters to be extremely life-like, and their decisions felt very real. Overall a very impactful and well-written book. Would definitely recommend.

Benjamin R
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I overall really liked the story and the characters, but I wasn't a fan of how the book was written with the text being aligned to one side of the page to resemble a character, for me, I find it difficult to read like that. However, the plot was brilliant and, if it was presented in a way that I personally preferred, then it would be even better.

Alexis
LSST Library Shadowers

In the book 'not Going To Plan' by Tia Fisher, the story explores serious topics such as sexual consent and abortion. The book is set in the present time in a secondary school from the perspective of a girl called Marnie and a boy called Zed. I personally loved this book and would definitely read it again. The book transported me to another world and allowed me to see through the eyes of Zed and Marnie. I would definitely recommend this book.

Issy
Diary of a Wally Kid

The book is fantastic and it had a lot of parts about GCSEs . This was a big deal for me because reading a book at this time is all about running away from all the exams I have in less than 3 weeks. However, this book was a constant reminder which also got me a little stressed as to whether I'm giving it my all. It really didn't hit it for me as i usually expect books to be some sort of escapism. Nevertheless, I 100% recommend it because if it had caught me at a different time , it would have been one of my greatest reads.

Vongai
Folkestone Academy Readers

A great book. I loved the verse style of writing and the way that the story shifted between the points of view of two very different characters. I think the mix of metaphors and cold hard facts makes the book very interesting and enjoyable to read. The theme in this book is also very important and something that is communicated through characters who develop naturally over the course of the story. This is probably my favourite book out of the ones I have read so far.

Philippa
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

Not Going To Plan was a really interesting book. I loved how the author showcased the narration with verse-like format for accessible reading and for a quick pace. This also helped with the awareness of these types of situations and clearly portrayed these well. During some parts of the book, there was a lot of depth and information dropped in all at once. However, some parts lacked this depth and made it a little confusing for events. And some of the characters were left a little stereotyped and not really enough characterization built up for them. Overall, this was a really great read and a good boost of awareness for these real-life situations, and such a heartfelt ending!

Afreen
Skipton Shadows

I really apreciated reading the book Not Going To Plan because i found the writing structure poetic and unique.The theme of friendship was presented in a unsual way showing that even if you're nothing like someone in particular you can still build a strong and reliable relationship.The characters were suprisingly memorable and endearing making the story captivating.

Lucie
4Shadowers

Not Going to plan is the perfect twist on a romantic novel. Instead of showing the love and desire you usually expect; it highlights the things that can go wrong and how to face the difficult consequences of teenage pregnancy. Moreover, we can see different perspectives on the situation primarily from the two friends (Marnie and Zed) but also their peers. Finally, I found the character developpement really impactful. Marnie's clear and oriented mind and her desire to be independent help her make impossible decisions. But the way Zed manages to appreciate Marnie and understand her despite their differences; to the extent of helping her in her most vulnerable moment truly showcases his emotional capcities.

Sia
4Shadowers

Not Going to Plan is a powerful and honest novel that feels very real for young readers. It tells the story of Marnie, who is expelled from her expensive boarding school just before her GCSEs and has to start again somewhere new. There, she ends up sitting next to Zed, a brilliant but very reserved student who seems completely different from her. While Marnie is talented in subjects like art and Spanish and Zed is much stronger in maths and science, they both share the same goal: they want strong results in school. What begins as a simple academic arrangement slowly develops into an unexpected bond. What makes the book so engaging is that the characters feel believable. Marnie is not perfect, which makes her easy to understand, and her struggles with sadness, school, and relationships make her story even more touching. The connection between her and Zed adds even more depth to the novel, especially when their growing friendship is shaken by a painful and unfair event that changes everything. The novel does not only focus on one issue. It also looks at mental health, trust, adolescence, and learning to deal with consequences. It shows how essential friends and family can be when life becomes overwhelming. Even though the subjects are serious, the writing stays accessible, emotional, and sometimes humorous, which makes the story easier to connect with. It is a meaningful and memorable read for teenagers, with important messages about choice, support, and growing up.

Yasmine
4Shadowers

Not Going To Plan by Tia Fisher is a book written about teenage pregnancy and the controversy surrounding it. It describes important issues with society and is written in verse, making it an even more entertaining read. I really enjoyed it although the topic felt somewhat inappropriate for younger readers, however extremely relevant for older teenagers and young adults, who may be going through similar problems in the country. The book provides information and many opinions in the subject and is overall an enjoyable read. I would rate it for future readers a 6/10.

Oliver
The Fitzharrys Shadows

'Not going to plan' by Tia Fisher is an awesome book for teenagers, especially for teenage girls since our body (the menstrual cycle is starting...)is changing and our mindset is developping ; there may be accidents such as pregnancy that aren't wanted at this young age but that can happen, so this book allows us to imagine being in the same situation as Marnie and making us feeling what she is living and feeling what she is going through. Moreover, reading this book tells you what you can do if this situation happens and the different ways to get out of it. This story makes you realize how important your parents and friends are, to support you in bad situations like this one. As a teenager reader, we can "relate" to Marnie which makes us even more interested to know what will be her decision and how will her friends help her. The young pregnancy isn't the only relatable part; the fact that Marnie fell into depression at her all-girls boarding school, that led her to drink alcohol and smoke, is something many teenagers today can relate to. Marnie's story helps the teenagers that are in a similar situations, to feel less alone. Even for girls that haven't sombered in that depression it will warn them about it. This book doesn't only talk about the theme of teenage pregnancy and abortion but also about friendship,self-identity and responsability, globalizing everything a teenager can live. The book treats difficult and explicit topics which can be unpleasant to read about, but Tia Fisher wrote it in an easy-to-understand,emotional yet funny way. Overall, it's an incredible book to read !

Kiara
4Shadowers

This was the sort of book that I would never usually pick up , as the plot was quite grown-up but I'm so glad I did because I really enjoyed it. I love verse novels as they are always quite quick, easy reads so I was really excited for this one. I think the layout of the words was very clever, emphasising intense feelings and making it such an interesting and exciting read. I also really liked the alternating perspectives, displaying Zed and Marnie's contradicting personalities but also how they truly cared about one another , creating a relationship with such depth and sweetness. Also, I found this quite an educational read , as I hadn't read or discussed the subjects of abortion and young pregnancy before. Although, I didn't find these subjects too heavy as they were carefully handled to just the right level. One slight critique is that I wish we could have had a slight hint as to what Marnie and Zed's futures would be like and what they would go on to do. In conclusion I really enjoyed this! Thank you!

Lyla
The Maynard School

The book "not Going to Plan" is, in one word, amazing. It is a fictional book yet the social realism, the matter-of-fact story and Tia Fishers writing style make it feel like this book is a non-fiction, that the book is real. It is written in verses, which makes it extremely fun to read, a breath of fresh air if you will, and also a quick read. Engaging, highly realistic, wonderful plot, this book is a gem and a must read!

Namish
4Shadowers

Although some traits of the characters felt slightly exaggerated, they were well developed. They had strong personal backgrounds and distinct personalities. This book is written in verse and for me the first time reading such a narrative style and structure. Initially, I was a bit sceptical. However, as the story progressed, I appreciated the author's creativity and how she used the style to convey emotions' more powerfully. The story explores the different challenges, successes, and perspectives of the two main characters, Zed and Marnie, in an honest and insightful manner, which was satisfying and engaging to follow.

Viktoria
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

I read this whole book very quickly - in a day! It kept me hooked throughout because I always wanted to know what would happen next. It was a very empowering read, too. Although it is not of the theme/genre that I would usually read, I really enjoyed it. I think that the representation of the text in a sort-of poetry style was a very interesting choice. Overall, I would most certainly recommend for all older readers.

Lucia
Carnegie Shadow Judges MEAC

This was a fun and interesting book, that I really enjoyed reading.

Jalen
Carnegie Shadow Judges MEAC

This book was really good. I loved how it also used events which could happen to anyone. I also relate to Zed not wanting to label his sexuality nowadays everything has a label so I like how he says 'We all assume that everyone's got to be something. We all have to be neatly boxed, with tags to define us but what if none of those tags applies to me? What if I am neither this nor that nor the other one.'

Aurora DT
Larkmead

A book that describes problems with society very well, with many people's different views and the togetherness in the ending. However, I didn't like the way the book was structured, as I felt like I hindered me from actually focusing more on the plot. More like me figuring out how to actually read the book. Despite this, the book also serves to be very informational and helpful to those in struggling.

Alisha (O)
LSST Library Shadowers

'Not going to plan' is an amazing book that shows real world problems and that there isn't always a simple solution. Moving to a new school was never going to be easy, but it's a whole lot harder than anything she could have predicted. When Marnie accidentally gets pregnant, she faces a lot of backlash once people find out, she gets told "You aren't seriously considering keeping the baby, that's so wrong" but also "You musn't get an abortion, that's so wrong". She has to make the decision, knowing she'll be hated no matter what she picks. All because of one mistake.

Jackie
DGS Carnegie Shadows

This is one I have mixed feelings about. I can see what Tia Fisher is trying to do in Not Going to Plan, and there are definitely parts that work well. The writing is very accessible and the verse format makes it a quick, engaging read. It’s the kind of book that’s easy to get into, even if you’re not usually a big reader. The friendship between Marnie and Zed is probably the strongest part of the book. They are very different, but their relationship develops in a believable and supportive way. I also liked the inclusion of art as a form of self-expression, and the resources at the end are helpful and clearly included with care. However, I did find that the book lacks depth in places. Some of the characters feel quite stereotypical rather than fully developed, which made it harder to connect with them on a deeper level. The main storyline focuses on an unplanned pregnancy, and this is where opinions may vary. The book presents one particular perspective quite strongly, and doesn’t explore a wide range of viewpoints in much depth. Because of this, some readers may feel that the topic isn’t examined as fully or as thoughtfully as it could be. I also felt that there wasn’t a huge amount of character growth by the end of the story. Some of the decisions and behaviours earlier in the book aren’t really reflected on in a meaningful way, which made the overall journey feel a bit incomplete. Overall, this is a well-written and easy-to-read book with a strong friendship at its core, but one that may not work for everyone. I would recommend it for older students (16+), and it’s definitely one that could lead to interesting discussions depending on your perspective. 2★

Mrs Naden
Lostock High Readers

I love the fun writing style of this book. I had yet to read a book with the theme of teenage pregnancy but I throughly enjoyed it.

Sage
Lit Legends of Swavesey

This was a good book but definitely is for upper years. however the structure of the book was so weird and i think i still have trauma from that weird structure of that book. but i also got to learn that having an abortion is not that hard but also really painful - well, that's a plus . :)

Kenul
Folkestone Academy Readers

A very empowering and amazing book! This was so fun to read especially since it was a verse novel, and funny at some moments. It highlights how people should not be ashamed of abortion and how your friends and family can support you if you are going through hard moments. Definitely one of my favourites out of the books I've read so far

Miguel M.C
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

It's a very powerful book written in verse, which makes it quick to read and shows the main character’s thoughts really clearly. The structure makes important moments stand out, and the character feels realistic because of her decisions and emotion, which makes parts of the story very enjoyable, I’d recommend it—8/10

Stanley
Reading Wizards

Not Going to Plan by Tia Fisher is a book I found both gripping and quite eye-opening. I really liked Marnie as a character because she feels believable and human—she starts off quite sure of herself and in control, but then has to deal with something that completely knocks her off balance. I also liked Zed, who at first comes across as quite closed off and awkward, but over time you see him become someone she can actually rely on. What stood out most to me was how the book handles serious issues in a very honest way. The part about stealthing was especially informative for me, as I didn’t fully understand what it is before reading the book. It didn’t feel like it was there just to shock the reader either—it felt real, and it made me properly think about consent and how easily boundaries can be crossed.

Jackie
The Perse Carnegians

'Not Going To Plan' is a book about empathy, consent and accidental teenage pregnancy. It is about a young lady at 16 years old named Marnie who was expelled from her old school and has to go to a new one. At her new school she sits down next to a boy named Zed who is great at physics and maths while Marnie strengths are art and Spanish. They both need each other's help to get through their GCSEs but one night at a party a terrible scene occurs where she has sexual intercourse with a young man called Harry. Harry pretends to wear a condom, but doesn't, and Marnie gets pregnant. Marnie and Zed need each other to get through this. I liked the poem format of this book and how it wasn't actually a poem. I also love how the story had different perspectives on the two main characters. I enjoyed the book. 8/10.

Sylvan C
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Not Going to Plan is a book that explores serious and sometimes ‘hushed’ topics like abortion, and it tries to show the bigger picture by including different opinions. I really liked the different points of view from Zed and Marnie, because it adds more depth and makes the story more interesting than if it was told by just one person. I also found it really engaging, as so much happens in a short amount of time for each character.

Amelia
Rainbeau Readers

I particularly enjoyed reading this novel as I found that the writing style was different but impactful. I have not read a verse novel before this and found the style and easy and fast paced read. I liked the plot of the book and found it perfect for age ratings of 14+ as it captures accurate themes of specifically GCSE exams and had the small details (such as how long the art exam was) and I felt that has made the book more relatable to people around that age range as a whole. It explored deeper themes such a teenage pregnancy and it was impactful as a reader because it shows how different growing up can be for so many different people. I also enjoyed the vast range of character as they were all different and lived contrasting lives as some characters live a good life whilst others may have financial strugglesv- like Marnie and Zed, and even Jessica. However, at times the pacing of the book almost felt too fast and slightly rushed at points, but on the whole I thoroughly enjoyed this read and would recommend it to people my age that would like to get into reading and that may want something th`t they could relate to in some way.

Seren
Brombil Book Critics

I thought the writing style was very very creative it made reading just that bit more entertaining. At first I thought it was odd and would be irritating but after getting into the book I started to like it. The language and word choice was very thought out it captured how each person would think feel and react to the things happening. I really enjoyed the story it was a great representation of going to school and the troubles of the people and situations in and out stop school. I would recommend this book to people in Year 9 or older and especially to people who like to get deep into a book and star to empathise and understand the characters and how they feel. Overall, I thought the book was entertaining not only in the story but also regarding how you read the book definitely a 8 or 9 out of 10.

Lucas
Forest Hill Library

It was really good, I love it when Marnie kind of liked Harry but then realised he was not nice and to me there was some kind of twist, because if you read the blurb, when she and Zed become friends and help each other you have that feeling when you think they’re going to kiss or something. Anyway, I LOVE the book, my favorite character was definitely Marnie, it made me sad when she didn’t want the baby and had an abortion. I give this book five stars for its creativity, romance and a little bit of humor. I recommend this book to teens who love romance and friendship.

Charlotte
Euro Champs

Not Going To Plan is an enlightening book which is written in a fascinating format of verses where you are able to read from the perspective of different characters and how they may view a situation differently to another. It tackles societal expectations and stigmas, tough situations and the realities of life as a teenager. The book is incredibly moving whilst being entertaining and fun to read as it keeps you guessing what might happen next. Reading the events unfold is a brilliant experience and Tia Fisher did a great job at realistically capturing the characters' emotions and struggles.

Iris
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

I think that the plot was great but I found it hard to read because of how instead of being written in paragraphs filling the width of the page the words were used to make shapes which I found hard to read but the characters had strong emotions and made it clear what they were thinking.

Henry
St Kaths

Not Going to Plan follows the story of Marnie and Zed, two complete opposites who end up becoming friends over revision sessions. I thought this book was very powerful in terms of its themes and the message it put across about teen pregnancy, abortion and consent. It portrayed lots of characters with lots of different backgrounds, and showed how everyone has the right to say no and make their own decisions. My favourite character was Marnie, while she was quite a difficult student at the start of the story I liked the way she followed her own path and developed as a character throughout the book. Verse novels aren't my favourite but I liked the way it was written with both Zed and Marnie's point of view. Overall I enjoyed this book, it tells us an important message in many ways and I would recommend it to lots of young adult readers.

Emma
Vista Academy Littleport

This book was not a good book for me because it had a lot of rude and swear words in it. What I liked about this book is that if one person was good in a subject the other one isn't so they helped each other. I liked how they worked together. This actually went pretty well when I read it and I really enjoyed these parts.

Adidev
The Fitzharrys Shadows

I enjoyed this book very much, I enjoy reading verse and found this one just as good and the storyline was satisfying. I feel it dealt on some very controversial issue quite nicely while still getting across the author's point of view. However, I feel like Zed's character didn't need to have his own section of writing.

Willow
CGS CAKE Club

When I first read the blurb for this book I wasn't very excited and I didn't expect it to be very good, however I was shocked about the way that you bond with the characters and really feel for them throughout the book. I loved the way Zed was portrayed but I wish there was more about the physics test he did because I feel like I wanted to know more about it. Marnie was my favourite character as I loved the way that she acted throughout the book. I really wish there was a second book as it's a bit sad saying goodbye to the characters

Lucy
Rainbeau Readers

Not going to plan was a really interesting read that I enjoyed a lot. I thought it was written in a sensitive way though covering such a serious but important to cover topic. I loved the relationship between Zed and Marnie as they are both such different characters but also loved reading how they helped each other throughout the story. I liked it being a verse novel and it having 2 perspectives so I overall really enjoyed this book and would definitely recommend.

Annie
The Maynard School

Personally, I like the verse style layout of the book and the dual narrative that occurs alongside each other rather than chapters changing for each character. I also like the pictures created from the words that relate to its action and/or the character’s fears. I think that this book shows a wide range of issues that some teens may face such as homophobia, not ‘fitting in’, judging for beliefs and the possibility of teen pregnancy and the decisions that come with it. However, I do believe this book occasionally followed classic tropes such as the friend group consisting of the problematic one, someone part of LGBTQ+, the smart one and the other one who contradicts and/or sporty – this isn’t a bad thing it’s just a basis that many authors follow. I also agree with what Marnie and Rakel were saying about ‘We’re damned if we do/damned if we don’t,’ because within society women/girls are judged for wanting or not wanting intimacy and/or sexual engagement and for the expectation to be both pure and not ‘frigid’. Typically, men/boys aren’t as criticised within the same category for their own choice. Obviously, the topic of abortion is a large part of this story and I believe it shows a range of viewpoints such as Rakel’s religious viewpoint, the protests we’re told are outside the clinic and Zed’s logical thoughts on it as abortion can go against moral and/or religious conscience and it’s hard to determine what counts as ‘murder’ when it comes to that, but ultimately, in my opinion, it relies on the choice of the mother and her capability at that time to be able to look after a baby and hopefully she has the support of family and friends.

Iyesha
Cottingham High School

Verse novels aren’t really my style, however I felt the plot and character development was exceptional in this novel, and did really well in highlighting serious issues.

Elly
Rad readers

NOT going to plan is a very well written book written from two peoples perspectives Marnie and Zed. They are sort of like no rhyming poems. It takes a good look at the subject of abortion in our society and the need for it to be talked about. In the book, Marnie feels alone and afraid to tell her mother that she is pregnant. Her best friend calls her a murderer and only Zed stands up for her. They order the abortion pack and Marnie takes the pills. Afterwards in her art GCSE she records a video about her experiences. I would rate this 9/10 as it is thought provoking read and was very interesting

Sophia
The Shady Bookhounds

I've really liked all the shortlisted books I've read so far, and this was no exception! I felt that the verse suited the characters and pace, and helped it feel more immediate and impactful. I think this was very realistic in its portrayal of the issues it covered, and all the characters felt well developed and like they could be very real. I found this quite immersive and it was paced very well, and covered very important topics in a way that felt easy to read and realistic.

Iris
Skipton Shadows

I really liked this book because it was from a very interesting perspective. I felt like it had a great plot and was a very gripping read. I liked the sense of friendship conveyed across the whole book which was very good and I would definitely recommend it.

Fleur
Rainbeau Readers

Not Going To Plan showed me the irreversible consequences of actions. It highlights that you need to be careful during sexual activities and that not everyone should be trusted. I also have learnt about stealthing, i didn't know what that was before i read this book and now i know that it's illegal and can have serious consequences. This book is very influential and educational and many people can learn from this. People who have experienced this can also be relieved to know that someone has written about it and know that it happens to many people not only girls but boys too. People now can understand the trauma of people actions and how even though it wasn't their decision it can affect them more than the perpetrator.

lily
PHS Book Explorers

Not going to Plan is a good book. It's about school with a girl getting pregnant at 16 and doing her GCSEs and she needs her best friend to help her. 4/10

Max D
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Not going to plan is a great book filled with emotion and charm. It is really creatively written, from the actual story itself to just how the pages are laid out. It is heart-breaking and uplifting how the main character handles her problems. I did not expect to like it but I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book.

Aiden
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

I think this book is really good and definitely worth reading. I don’t usually like verse novels, but this one is really interesting and keeps you hooked all the way through. I would recommend it for Year 8 and above because it includes some sensitive topics and a bit of mild swearing. However, it isn’t too strong, and the censored parts are very short and only last for a couple of pages. The chapters are about 5–8 pages long, which makes it an easy and enjoyable read. I would give this book 4.3 out of 5 stars.

Arya
Rainbeau Readers

This book was a really good read - I enjoyed how it was laid out in short paragraphs across the page. I liked how it dealt with some difficult themes and I really enjoyed reading it as a whole.

Bronte
Crypt Bookworms

I thought it was a brilliant, imersive and creative book. I haven't read anything like it before. Loved it!

Hollie
St Kaths

Not Going to Plan explored an often overlooked topic that is gaining prominence in literature - abortion. However, I liked how it doesn't focus on just abortion - it also focuses on identity and the struggles of teenagers. The contrasting characters and viewpoints of Zed and Marnie brought depth to the story and plot. I thought the verse format didn't add too much, and in some places (e.g. the heartbeat) made it a bit of a nuisance, but it made the book a bit more unique and interesting. Overall, it explored a complex topic well, displaying different viewpoints through the characters, while still keeping the book grounded with the approach of GCSEs. 8/10.

Aashaz Z.
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Brilliant book, demonstrating how opposites can be the best of friends, while also giving people awareness of malicious people who fake wearing protection. It shows you shouldn't be scared to call out wrong actions or to show your personal opinion on a situation.

Julia
Reepham Reads

I loved this book. I loved the poem set out and the switching between the characters. 9/10

Connor R
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Having previously read and LOVED Crossing the Line I was ready for her verse written style. Just as before I was unenamoured to start but soon drawn in by Zed and Marnie and the alternate telling. Another funny and moving, realistic tale of friendship, making mistakes and how, where and when to seek help. The book doesn't shy away from YA issues and, more importantly, doesn't give you the answers. Felt all the art stuff at the end was a bit much and I don't think she needed to change her display last minute. Overall a great read.

Debbie
Ousedale Olney

I found this book really interesting because it made me think about issues I never thought before, and it was presented in a really nice way to understand. It had characters I could understand in an environment I go to nearly everyday, meaning I could feel how the characters felt and why. My favourite character was Zed as he was really nice and smart. :)

Ethan
Rainbeau Readers

I found 'Not Going to Plan ' by Tia Fisher a really honest and emotional novel about two teens whose lives mess up after something goes seriously wrong, and I found it surprisingly easy to connect with both of them. Tia's writing style doesn’t shy away from tough topics like consent and the pressure of growing up, but she writes about them in a way that feels real , The writing style makes it quick to read, but it still hits hard, and the friendship that develops between Marnie and Zed feels messy and awkward at start .

RaqeebG
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

The book "Not going to plan" was unique. It follows the story of Marnie a school girl who finds herself getting into some troubles at school which results in her moving schools to sit her GCSEs. There, at her new school, she meets Zed a boy in her tutor class who was very different from Marnie. The book was a verse novel and a short, easy read which I enjoyed. I thought the topics were explained really well whilst not being "too heavy" they seemed more subtle but known. To begin I was not to sure on what I thought, however, as I read more I grew to enjoy the book. Review by Libby

Vista Academy Littleport

Not going to plan is an incredible book that discusses a sensitive topic with lots of maturity but also makes it entertaining for the reader. I love how in the back of this book, the author has included extra material for people experiencing similar situations to find comfort, support and help. To me, this book is really important as it talks about something that may be considered shameful so it isn’t spoken about enough. I love how the characters Marnie and Zed are so completely different and yet they still become best friends. I think that Tia Fisher is an inspiring author and her style of writing is amazing!

Jess
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

Honestly speaking, “Not Going to Plan” is an amazingly written book and (though the pictures were a bit awkward in school) I have had a great time reading it. I love the book’s layout and how both characters are dealing with their own problems, particularly Zed with “labelling” himself. I also like how, though a side character, Naomi has such a strong personality and supports Marnie with her personal ideas. I strongly recommend, and already begged my friends to read it! P.S. They said maybe after Carnegie!!

Pola
The Fitzharrys Shadows

"Not Going to Plan" by Tia Fisher is a fascinating and powerful book. The story focuses on friendship, problems and decisions! I found it really interesting that Tia Fisher wrote the book in verse and not in just long paragraphs. My favourite part is how she wrote the book using two perspectives, this gave me an insight on what both characters felt! However, at the start of every verse the line is bold, this made me feel a bit confused, as I did not know whether the author was trying to make me focus on something. Overall I think "Not going to plan" was a fantastic read. Tia Fisher has made a very realistic book in my opinion, and I would 100% recommend it! Rating: 8.5/10

Lilly
Euro Champs

Pola
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Coming into this book I expected another book warning about teen/YA sex, ending in abortion. But this book defied my expectations. I wasn't expecting it to be a verse novel, though, and the perspective of the mother and Rakel were enlightening, and I thought really brought something to the book. It follows Zed and Marnie as they explore their sexuality and love lives. While the author still covered abortion, it was from an objective perspective and was tactful in explaining it. Overall I didn't hate this book but didn't love it enough for me to want to reread it. 6/10

Elijah
Vista Academy Littleport

I quite liked this book and found that it explored very controversial and complex topics really well and in a poetry format that made it easy to read. I liked the contrast of how Marnie and Zed looked at the world built their relationship and their story. I thought that how the book showed abortion and fear to tell people was really good with characters like Rakel having different opinions on it but in the end showing that people can do what they want. My main complaint was how the book didn't use speech marks and instead used italics which made it quite confusing when actual italics were used and I think it would have been better just to use speech marks. I would recommend this to probably ages 13+ as it explores controversial topics that require more thinking and the main concepts wouldn't be suitable for younger readers. Overall I give it 8/10.

Robin.O
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Not Going To Plan is a brilliantly descriptive and engaging verse novel told from the perspectives of two characters, Zed and Marnie. The characters are admittedly very different but the dialogue they share together is very believable and interesting. There are some topics that I had not encountered before reading this book but by the end, I felt that they were explained in a quite subtle yet completely informative way so that you were not left feeling confused about them. I would definitely read this again and recommend it to a friend.

Flora
St Kaths

It was good and I liked how it has multiple POVs. It portrayed issues like teenage pregnancy and stealthing very well, albeit I wasn't a fan of the writing style very much, I still found the storyline very easy to follow. I quite liked how the way the words were set out on the page changed to keep the experience engaging and interesting.

Laila
Next Page Adventurers

I really liked this book it is worth reading ,although it does have mature things which is a bit terrifying but if you are 14 it is alright . I really enjoyed reading this and some parts are funny. Some parts do have a big shock and will blow your mind away .Overall if you love a bit of gossip and drama this book is definitely for you !!!

Gabriella
Next Page Adventurers

An amazing and different book in comparison to the other 7 texts. By being in a verse-novel form, it acts as a shorter read for all people to understand about pregnancy and the consequences in a school environment. Although the language becomes stronger as the text goes on, it works in order to show the divide between the victim and the classmates. It is a shorter book as a result, so it can become a quick read if you are a fast reader. I've personally found it quite boring for the first half as it is not very paced, but the pace quickly increases at the text continues.

Kaleb
Folkestone Academy Readers

Not Going to Plan is a book about a young girl called Marnie who is just about to take her GSCE’s. She joins the school late – she doesn’t know anyone. But Harry Borman invites her to a party, and how can Marnie refuse? But when she is deceived, can she trust the nerd who sits next to her to help fix things? My favourite character was Marnie because she was quite kind, and willing to make friends and adapt to a new environment. I can relate to her emotions at the beginning of the book because when I started year 7, I felt the same way. My favourite part of the book was when Marnie went to Zed for help, because it was when Marnie and Zed finally realized their friendship. There were some emotional scenes, and they felt very real. There wasn’t really anything I didn’t like about the book. I really liked it. I think that older children would like this book because there are some grown-up topics, but overall I think it is a very good book!

Catelyn P
Vista Academy Littleport

If I had to use one word to describe this book it would be WOW! The personality change and journey is unfathomable to me and how well worded it was. This book was so well written it should be up in the Louvre.

Charlotte
St Kaths

I really enjoyed the writing style of this book. It started off like a slow moving steam train but developed into a bullet train half way through. I think it would be easy for teenagers to relate to the emotions and indecision that permeates every chapter. I would definitely encourage our upper year students to read the book. The end left me feeling oddly emotional. A really good read.

Mrs Muller
Folkestone Academy Readers

Not Going To Plan is a book about abortion. At first, I found it really similar to Little Bang so when I found out that Kelly McCaughrain supported Tia Fisher in writing this book, I wasn't too surprised. I thought the characterisation was good, and that most of it felt like it could really happen. One small hole in the plot was that Zed and Marnie were working on the same spreadsheet where Marnie admits who the father is, Zed later says he can only guess who the father is. Two years ago, I read Crossing The Line and I definitely prefer Not Going To Plan because it felt more uplifting. I also appreciated the poetry and wordart more this time as two years ago half the books were written in poetry. It probably didn't need to be in poetry, but it definitely worked. The ending was good, although I wish she hadn't ended it on a cliffhanger...

Aidan
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

This book was excellent! I believe a good writer is one who conveys their message in such a way that it is both authentic and effective. This is exactly what Tia Fisher did. She taught me something new, allowing me as a reader to connect deeply with the story and understand the emotional reality behind it. I have read Tia’s work before and like the way her novels are written in verse. It helps the reader connect to the story in an intensely emotional way because the language is concise and therefore more hard-hitting. I felt as though I was in Marnie’s thoughts. I admire how Tia has handled such a sensitive topic with honesty and care, never romanticising the situation but instead showing the true challenges and consequences the characters face. This made the story feel powerful. The characters were also very well developed and both Marnie and Zed’s journeys felt genuine. This book is moving and leaves a lasting impression. I would highly recommend it.

Priyanshi
Shelf Indulgence by JCG

This was my first read of this year's Yoto Carnegies and it did not disappoint me! The verse novel made the story flow at a really good pace, plus the dual narrative gave me a feel of the perspective of each character. The informal tone added to the connection between the reader and the characters, and I loved the way that some of the pages were set out with the words in the shape of an image, or in different positions on the page - like illustrations out of letters - and it really gave me an insight into what the narrators are thinking and feeling. I felt like I was inside their heads and experiencing the story as Zed and Marnie. I loved it.

Immy
Skipton Shadows

Very good book that addresses issues that teenagers face in today's world. Including discrimination, abortion and teenage pregnancy.

ADAM
Reepham Reads

Not Going to Plan by Tia Fisher is an important read for young people navigating the trials and tribulations of senior school and in particular the ups and downs of friendships and relationships. It explores the themes of online bullying, identity and consent. Marnie is an intelligent, feisty teen who has talents, dreams and immense potential but who has made a series of questionable choices. Expelled from one school she enrols at a tough, local comprehensive school but quickly finds friendship in the form of STEM genius Zed and an inspiring staff member who helps her channel her rebellious streak into artistic self expression. I particularly liked the depiction of her male friends and the way they supported and lifted Marnie up in her darkest hour. Written in free verse and sensitively tackling the realities of life for many young people in today's digital world. This book is both accessible and relatable.

Mrs Clarkson
Epsomian Shortlist Shadowers

Not going to plan was a book that followed Marnie - a rebellious teenager and Zed - a quiet kid who does not like to talk to people . I think the book did well in getting across the general point of abortion rights , teen pregnancy etc and also showed people how their not alone . As it is a coming of age book it did well in portraying people working through differences and exploring different options and viewpoints of life , however I felt the way the friendship between Marnie and Zed grew so quickly was a bit unrealistic . They are polar opposites and seemed to form a friendship overnight which wouldn't really happen in real life .This book wasn't my genre of choice but it was a quick easy read and I felt the dual narrative helped with the flow and movement of the book . It conveyed emotion and did encourage me to think more about abortion rights which shows that the point was made well and clearly . Overall I would give this book 4/5 stars .

Holly H
Vista Academy Littleport

Overall, I found this book to be quite entertaining with an interesting storyline that I enjoyed. However, I have 2 primary criticisms of the book: its predictability and a couple of unrealistic events. The friendship developed in the book seemed to me quite unrealistic, like the friendships you only really see in sappy, quite frankly, movies. The idea of someone like Zed and someone like Marnie, considering previous history of the 2 characters, would be very unlikely in the real world. While I would believe it if the author portrayed the two on amicable terms, that too would not make it a very good book. Therefore, I don't really think people like Zed and Marnie are very compatible in the real world, which should be reflected in the book. My other problem with the book was its predictability: simply just reading the blurb already gave me a very good idea of what the book was about, and not to my surprise, all my predictions were true. There was only one event when you actually had to guess as to what would happen. As well as this, I don't really like some of the character portrayals. For example, I didn't like how Marnie drags Zed into her own problems against his own will, when in reality she could've faced the shame of fessing up to her mother and instead acquiring her help. In spite of this, I don't only have negative comments of the book: in fact, there's a lot I could complement on the book. I found it to be a very powerful storyline, and as I mentioned before, I enjoyed it quite thoroughly. I also liked how it explored taboo topics which many other authors would be too afraid to write of. Overall, I found it to be a very enjoyable book, regardless of its flaws. I would rate it an 8/10

William B
Ermysted’s Carnegie Shadowing Group

Not Going To Plan has amazing characters and an excellent dual narrative keeping the reader in suspense. Loved the way Tia Fisher used words and stanzas to convey emotion and setting and it's a brilliant portrayal of wider themes. Absolutely would recommend.

Elsie
St Kaths

Going into this book, it definitely wasn't my preferred genre, but I didn't dislike it as much as I thought I would. It is a verse novel that follows the stories of Marnie and Zed, Marnie being a rebellious teenager who recently got manage moved from her all girls boarding school, whereas Zed is a quiet boy in the back of the class, seated at the only desk that has a spare seat, so there they befriend each other due to needing help in their respective weak subjects - maths and physics for Marnie and Spanish for Zed. I think the way the book is laid out is very effective in showing the juxtaposing characters of Marnie and Zed, how despite being very contrasting personalities, they still managed to become friends. It was also a quick read, yet still covered all the grounds it needed to in order to get the overall message across. However, personally I thought the chapters leading up to the ending were quite dragged out, and there were numerous times I thought 'that should be the end' when it wasn't, just for the actual ending to be quite abrupt. As well as this, there were many moments throughout where I got quite a bit of second-hand embarrassment, but I feel like that's inevitable in a young adult novel, especially one handing such taboo topics. Overall, it wasn't my favourite read, but I was relatively impressed by how it surpassed my expectations.

Lyra
Vista Academy Littleport

Not Going To Plan by Tia Fisher is a coming-of-age story in which Marnie discovers she's pregnant and the struggles she has to go through. We follow Marnie's journey through school, dealing with friendships and the bullies. She transitions from someone who makes mistakes to someone who has to deal with a lot and grow up fast. I liked that it was written in verse with shape poems, it made it an interesting read, you could see the difference in Marnie's voice and her friend Zed. The overall message is that you don't need to copy others or give in to peer pressure if you don't want to. You can be yourself and it's important to understand that. Marnie does stand up for herself and although I know she will be all right, it's left me thinking what she did with her life after she left school.

Asia
The Next Chapter

I absolutely loved this book! I love the immediacy of verse novels and how Tia Fisher uses this to create a gripping, harrowing story. By the end of the book, I felt so emotionally connected with the individual characters yet also totally angered and appalled at some of the wider themes (e.g. stealthing, abortion). She thus creates a beautiful story within the context of wider political themes, evoking empathy in the reader. I also loved this was set in a modern landscape (2025) as it highlights how these themes are still prominent in everyday life, even if UK laws have changed. Please read this book to provide a new perspective on themes of abortion, teenage pregnancy and relationships!

Eve
St Kaths

I liked that it was in verse/poetry - it made it a quick read. I wish there were more development of the characters that you get in regular books

Laura
HGCSC Library

Not Going To Plan

Tia Fisher

Author Interview

Shadowers’ Challenge

Submit Review

Submit Artwork

Tia Fisher

Shadowers' reviews and artwork