The Carnegies

Tragic and gut-wrenching story that shows you just how powerful the influence of money, praise and adults has on young and vulnerable teens

evelyn
Kesgrave Bookworms

Luke Palmer is an author and poet who makes character-driven, thought-provoking novels and poems with vulnerable themes surrounding masculinity, friendships and elephant-in-the-room topics such as underage drinking and drug-taking. He has been generally commended high for many of his novels, being nominated twice for Carnegies, (in 2024 'Grow') - and rightfully so! His novels have inspired children and teenagers to speak out, changing many readers' minds with his perspective and his talented writing. His fusion of story-telling, hypnotic style and vulnerable topics isn't for everyone, and it's only gone more hard-hitting since Grow (2021), a story about a 15 year old boy lost in his place in the world. 2 years after, in late 2023, he released 'Play'. I was a bit lukewarm on the blurb when I first read it, but I read the first 2 pages, and the intriuging writing dragged me into reading the full novel. It was safe to say that I had no idea what I was expecting when I first dived into this book, which was worrying, yet exciting. Seeing an author try to push away from normal book standards and explanation is something that isn't seen often enough, and I think this is what Luke was trying to push. When I was reading this book, I noticed the core elements of an average story weren't completely gone, though it seemed like that at first glance; you can still see clear structure and relatively clear plotline throughout the entire novel. It made me wonder what age group this was directly for. But still, the push is still clear, masculinity, friendships and LGBT+ themes are much more prominent than in something you'd see in Harry Potter or The Hunger Games. (Unrelated, but the Hunger Games are outstanding.) I haven't read Grow yet so I can't compare Play to that novel yet, but from what I've seen Play seems to have the core elements of Grow, but they're fed in vastly different contexts - this one a 4-boy friendship with realistic character chemistry and Grow more of a one boy relationship, setting in a time where his parents have died. In the first 2 pages you can see that Luke is coming off more abstract and cryptic with more mysterious themes, words popping off the page and bursting with animation! Honestly, this book is full of personality. Luc's life (the 'aggressive' kid who is always pushing forward and loves to compete in sport) is pressurising, yet the pressure seems to fall off him like water. Luc is immediately presented as pushing himself too hard, as being arrogant, and not caring about others, yet he doesn't see that in himself. Luc's perspective presented a more different take than I'd genuinely expect from a sporty person, with an interesting plot line from him, and a character development that seems incredibly realistic. Even from a person who is almost the complete opposite of Luc, I often understood why he was doing the things he was doing, and how who he is affects that. This is my least favourite perspective, though -- sometimes I found him unlikeable, and, while the second half of his POV is great, the first half seemed a bit dull and uninteresting. Overall a great perspective, though. Matt has a very interesting perspective! I love this take on masculinity and pressure for doing well. It's very original, despite, as you may have noticed, using the foundations of school stereotypes. Behind Mark I found his perspective the most interesting one; however, I may be a bit biased because he's probably the one I can relate to the most. I love the way he views the world! To add, everything that happens to him is very realistic and feels exactly what would actually happen if this book was real. You really get attached to this character, man. And that's even better for real life situations as he's LGBT and I think having a character which many people can strongly relate to will re-inforce these rights. Happy Pride month, by the way! Mark. This is the sole focus of the story really, and it's done very well. While I was reading his PoV, I noticed the most atmosphere and literary techniques being used. Mark's story really is based the most around mystery and has the most narrative happening -- I would be inclined to say that Matt's is more focused on emotions, Mark is more on story. I won't spoil what happens but once you begin reading, I can promise you you won't stop on this PoV. It's masterfully done. I also noticed that most of Matt's story really begins towards the second half, the first half is more so short plotlines or preparing for larger plotlines. They're both interesting, but I would like to say that the second half is... more interesting. My favourite chapter is probably the train chapter or the 'untouchable' chapter. Johnny... has one chapter in the whole book. And it's the last one. Probably my favourite one as well; what a lovely high note to be ending one. Throughout the story you're never really sure what Johnny's truly up to, and it all happens at the end! Luke's hypnotic writing style from the beginning appears again, and it feels like you're in a trance. I won't reveal anything though, because I want whoever is reading to experience the same thing I did! ************ Luke's video itself on the Carnegies website is very introspective and thoughtful. It makes me enjoy the book even more, and I think everyone should watch it after you've finished, even if you didn't like the story. But while I did see some negative reviews or neutral opinions on this novel (I wasn't feeling too crazy about the book going into it), I found that most people's reception on this book, from what I've seen, was very positive. The storytelling is great, the design is great, the form is great, the descriptions are great, the chemistry is great, the realism is great, and above all I was looking forward to every PoV after the previous one. I never felt any disappointment, and that's a hard thing to master. Because this book is pretty fantastic, right? It's mind-bending, thoughtful, open and pulls all punches. I love this direction Luke is taking since Grow, and judging by the new poem set that he's released recently, it seems to be going even better! #poetry This seems to be one of the best ones, if not THE best of books that I've read which are on the stranger side. Utterly dynamic, versatile, layered, detailed... I think of a new adjective every time I think of this book. I'm thinking a light 10/10. And to answer the question on the second video, I think a dodecahedron -- it looks complex but it has order. P.S. I know you like only had to write one paragraph, but I just really wanted to give this book justice (and feed my critic brain in department 11). You might see that it's a bit rushed, though.

Luka
Colchester Royal Grammar School

Eliphel
Brentwood Carnegies

Great book with lots of excitement and it shows the dangers of peer pressure and drugs on younger minds

Dex
Winchmore School Carnegie Group 2024/25

This book was amazing and i found it difficult to put down. As the storyline looked into the lives of 4 boys who are growing up together at school. I loved the descriptive language and the way the author wrote about the different people.

Roseanna
SCD Pageturners

Play by Luke Palmer is a gritty narrative of the friendship of a small group of boys, as they navigate the changes from childhood to teens, to adults. All four boys face their own individual challenges throughout the story and face choices which heavily impact their lives. Themes of radicalisation, drug and alcohol culture and toxic masculinity run strongly throughout the book, and the character's responses to these are a good way for teens to safely explore scenarios and hopefully consider what they themselves could do/ do differently if in the same situation. I enjoyed reading this book despite the pretty devastating ending, although I do think that the topics covered make it too mature for a lot of readers.

Mrs Sirrelle
BFS Umbra Readers

Mrs P
Montsaye Librarians

Oh my god! This book was a real rollercoaster. The way that Luke Palmer wrote 'Play' was really overwhelming. Although, I have to say this is one of my favourite books since it was in my comfort zone. The way that there are 4 protagonists written in different perspectives showed you what they were all going through. Johnny is the only one whose perspectives we do not see until the very end. I am really glad I read this, this will definitely be on my favourite books list. I recommend this book to year 8/9/10 people as some people may be able to relate to this. Great book!

Lily
Lost in Pages

I recently read Play by Luke Palmer, and I found it really gripping and emotional. The story follows four teenage boys—Mark, Matt, Luc, and Johnny—who live in a small town and deal with serious issues like friendship, family problems, and growing up. What I liked most was how real the characters felt. Each one had their own way of speaking and acting, and it felt like I was listening to real teenagers. The story is told from all of their points of view, which made it interesting because you get to see how each of them thinks and feels. The book also talks about some dark topics like drugs, violence, and peer pressure, especially when Mark gets caught up in something really dangerous. It made me think about how easily someone can be pulled into a bad situation, even if they don’t mean to. Even though the book is serious, it’s written in a way that’s easy to understand. It made me think about what it means to be a good friend, how hard it can be to ask for help, and how important it is to make the right choices. I would recommend this book to other students in KS3 who like stories that are intense and emotional. It’s not a light read, but it’s definitely powerful and stays with you after you finish it.

Sophie p
Tenbury Page Turners 25

Shocking, heart-breaking and fantastic. Four boys and three different view's. Mark finds himself barricaded in a life of selling drugs. Luc, a rising star rugby player. Matthew a painter with an overwhelming emotion which makes his heart throb with love and Jonny. Just Jonny, a boy neglected by his parents. They all share one thing in common. The society they live in is overshadowed by toxic masculinity. This group of boys is trapped in a world where toxicity flood the streets, drowning you until you can't breath no more. How should I deal with this? Let's play a game! Get alcohol, drugs and let's smoke until we thrown up or pass out. This book was a rollercoaster of emotions. One second I'm disgusted by some character's actions and the next I'm left speechless. I have never felt so broken by an ending until I finished this book. It was truly shocking and left me with my jaw hanging low. I rate this book 5/5 stars. My reason for this it's because of how real it is. What this book communicates to you are real life issues that are still happing now.

Elece
Lost in Pages

Stellan
Novel Talk With Ashcroft

Beau
Novel Talk With Ashcroft

Omg the ending killed me. I had to try not to cry in the middle of english. All of the characters are so well-rounded and likeable, despite their flaws. We see these characters grow and what it does and I love all of that. I also like that Johnny doesn't have any chapters or voice until the very end, and it shows how all the others overshadowed him when they were going through things. I want to see more of these characters!!!

Harriet
SCD Pageturners

Luke Palmer’s Play is a gripping and authentic portrayal of adolescence, focusing on four teenage boys: Matthew, Luc, Johnny, and Mark. Their lives revolve around invented games and scoring points off each other, which I found really interesting. Another thing I found interesting was the way they all interacted with each other. Each character is distinct with clear, separate voices: Matthew retreats into his imagination, Luc tests his physical limits; Johnny remains enigmatic, and Mark, seeking status and excitement, becomes entangled in his older brother’s illicit activities. Mark's descent into the dangerous world of drug operations shows how easily vulnerable youths can be drawn into criminal enterprises. I found it interesting the way he felt he was worthless and doing these jobs got him some sort of worth and made him feel important and useful. Palmer's narrative goes into themes of toxic masculinity, peer pressure, and internalised homophobia. The boys' interactions reflect the expectations placed on them, like Mark with his mother and Luke with his father and Johnny's lack of expectations shows through his character as he is more carefree. The novel doesn't shy away from difficult topics such as drug use and familial neglect, presenting them with honesty and sensitivity. The boys' banter, rivalries, and moments of vulnerability are intensely authentic. Matthew and Mark's longing for each other was done so well and the author showed what kept them from each other really well, making their reunion worth it. I loved the climax that ended with the death of Johnny and with it the truth to everything. I especially loved the ending. The way their lives went after Johnny's death was vague, allowing the reader to choose their reality out of the given scenarios. Altogether, Play is a piece of art. It is worthy of 5 stars.

Eliphel
Brentwood Carnegies

It was well written with an interesting storyline and use of multiple perspectives.

Phoebe
KLB Fiction Fans

This book really exceeded my expectations; I really wasn't anticipating much from reading the blurb, but I found that I enjoyed reading about challenges from a perspective I'd never considered before and that I could understand the characters' choices and views just from how well they were written, despite having a very different opinion myself.

Sophie
Ely College Reading Group

I really loved this book and, despite its slightly confusing start, it got me engaged pretty quickly. The fact that there was a chapter for each character's story and point of view made the book so interesting and quite hard to put down as it makes you always want to know what happens next. The issues portrayed in this book were very realistic and made me realise how there could be people going through difficult situations, like Mark's and Luc's, right in this moment. So even if I'm not usually interested in books with these strong topics (since it's hard to write them in an engaging way) this book was actually successful in grabbing my attention.

Maya
Ely College Reading Group

Play was definitely a hard read. It explored themes like drugs and sexuality and the overall challenges of male friendships. I really enjoyed the character of Matt as he felt the most realistic and I found his struggles with his sexuality really relatable. The book was gritty and intense but still real and a intresting read.

Liam
Horsham BOok HUNTers

Play is a very interesting book that has a lot of element of fun and romance. I really enjoyed reading this book and loved the key elements of romance in this. The book also explores the love for friendship and loyalty of your allies. Overall a 9/10 book

Jay
Isleworth & Syon

‘Play’ by Luke Palmer is an extremely well-thought-out book following four teenage boys (Luc, Mark, Matt and Johnny) and the struggles faced by each of them daily, from drug misuse to toxic masculinity. I appreciate the fact that the perspective of this book changes regularly, and each character has their own font. It really helps you get to know each character on a personal level. The book was much more serious than I was initially expecting with the name ‘Play’, but that does not mean I did not enjoy it. I really liked the fact that this book delves into the ‘taboo’ or ‘wrong.’ Having read other’s reviews, I heard that certain characters, i.e. Matt and Luc, were unlikable or bad, however, I disagree. I feel like the characters were not intended to be role models or good people. This book sickened me in all the right ways. There were points where I had to step away, purely due to the intensity of certain scenes. It may not be appealing to all sorts, but I quite enjoyed that. Normally, I’d write in some complaints I have about this book at the end of my review, but I don’t exactly have any to mention here. I think Palmer really made an interesting, gripping book. One small detail I particularly enjoyed was that the book has the same first and last line. I always enjoy it when books do little things like that. Would I recommend this book? Absolutely. It takes a while to get going, but it is really such a brilliant and rewarding book.

Lily
BFS Umbra Readers

This book is about a group of friends who are just trying to find a game. The themes of this book are friendship and awareness. I loved the story. My favourite part was when the kids ran their first errand as that set the whole story up. I recommend reading this book!!!

Freddie
Sandroyd Bookivores

I thought the way it was written from multiple perspectives was really good and we got different views of masculinity. The portrayal of toxic masculinity was really well written especially in Luc and dad's relationship. I didn't like how focused on drugs and alcohol the book was.

Tilly
Book Looks

Play is a deep story the follows four teenage boys and the different "games" they play at. It is an emotional story that, at times, did feel very heavy and at around halfway I did feel like it was quite overwhelming. However, I did quite like the different perspectives we get from each of the characters and the character development we see in them. I also found the different family dynamics suit the characters and were accurately portrayed, overall I thought the story did fit together quite well. My favourite part was actually the last chapter, I felt like it makes you view the story and Johnny in a whole new way and I thought was a really nice way to end the story. I would rate this book a 6/10

Sofia
BFS Umbra Readers

This was a very enjoyable read with an overall great storyline and I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Max
The High Storrs Shadows

Play is an interesting story exploring the difficulty on men in their youth. The boys all go through struggles in their lives, especially trying to figure out who they are. Play talks about emotional and distressing topics but it is also good for spreading awareness of these topics in boys/teenagers.

Caitlyn
Plymstock School Readers 2025

'Play' was a well written book that demonstrated well the difficulties the 4 boys are all going through. The end was particularly intriguing when the writer gave a glimpse into the boys' futures.

Oliver
Tenbury Page Turners 25

‘Play’ by Luke Palmer is a coming-of-age novel that explores friendship, masculinity, and pressure that young men face growing up. Following four teenage boys: Mark, Matt, Luc, and Johnny - the story shows how loyalty, identity, and fear can spiral into tragedy. Palmer’s writing is emotional, displaying each character with depth and empathy. The novel discusses tough issues like toxic masculinity, abuse, and belonging with honesty and care. Gripping and intriguing, Play is a must-read for anyone interested in the real struggles teenagers face today.

Zoe.G
The Lotus Readers

This book was an adventure from start to finish: it was engaging and relatable as well as staying appropriate and effectively raising awareness to topics such as county lines, drug abuse and suicide. I have read many similar books but they have not handled the topic in such an empathetic and raw way before- this book truly allows the reader to step into the young boys' shoes and understand their individual coping methods and ways they navigate teenhood.

Grace
Plymstock School Readers 2025

I neither loved nor hated "PLAY'. The book covered topics such as drug dealing, homophobia and toxicity. It was based off of four boys as they went through secondary school. The chapters were written from different perspectives of each of the four boys which helped build a stronger and better understanding of them, I found this helped with their character development. I didn't find he story to gripping or exciting and so really didn't enjoy it to much. I found the ending disappointing but overall I'd say it's definitely for more older readers.

Libby A
VISTA Academy

Play is an incredible novel about four boys who face teenage difficulties and how they cope with them; Mark starts selling drugs, Luc pushes himself to make his dad proud, and Matt starts daydreaming. I enjoyed reading this book because it showed me that everyone has different problems they face as teenagers and that we should respect how others feel, as we don't know them or what they are trying to cope with. I also liked that each chapter was told by different boys, as it created suspense each time a chapter ended and made me intrigued about the continuation of the story. Finally, the part that I enjoyed the most was the fact that it showed us that money isn't the most important thing in life and that doing something you love will make you more comfortable rather than doing something just to be rich.

SrishtiHG
4Shadowers

Play was an OK book. It revolves around 4 boys as they go through secondary school. The book tackled important issues like toxic masculinity, drug dealing and homophobia but was very bleak and is definitely for older readers. The chapters were written from different perspectives and really aided the good character development. The book had brilliant symbolism throughout it, with the idea that the boys are always playing some sort of "games." Time moved too quickly throughout the book and the ending was fairly disappointing. Overall, the book itself was good but due to my personal tastes and opinions, I didn't like it.

Emily
HAEC Books and Biscuits Carnegie Shadowers

Four boys grow up together at school, wanting to get out of their town. They play games alot. Matthew slips into his imagination, Luc pushes his body to the limit, and Johnny who knows what Johnny's up to. But when Mark starts running errands for his older brother's mysterious associate, he thinks he's found the best game of all. There's money in his pocket and his friends have started looking at him differently. Then Mark breaks a rule, and quickly realises that the penalties in this game far outweigh the prizes.

Michelle
VISTA Academy

I was a really big fan of ‘Play’, one of the shortlisted novels, and out of the ones I've read would rank it extremely high. The book follows four boys, Matt, Mark, Luc and Johnny, as they go about their lives, playing games, living life and constantly finding themselves in trouble. Mark finds a new game to play, which brings him income, but also gets him into a lot of trouble. Matt struggles with his sexuality, and how his friends deal with it - Luc falls under pressure from his dad about sports, and Johnny, well, who knows what Johnny's doing! I think this book handled current issues really well, but I did find the ending incredibly sad. I think my favourite character was definitely Johnny because he was constantly supporting his friends, and seemed like he brought all the fun to the group! All in all, I really loved this book, and would recommend to others.

Kate
St George’s Dragon Readers

Play, by Luke Palmer, is a gripping book written beautifully through the eyes of four different boys playing games as they grow up, from making dens in the woods, all the way to navigating challenges in the outside world. While the book deals with more adult and difficult themes, it ultimately delivers a powerful message about friendship, choice, and the consequences of our actions. The characters were my favourite part of the story, as Luke Palmer goes into depth about their lives, how their minds work and their relationships with the other characters. The characters developed very well, and it was good to see each of their different personalities get stronger as the story goes on. Play is written from different perspectives for each boy, and whilst in other books this could be confusing, it is easy to understand in Play because Luke Palmer uses a different font for each. The end of play is beautifully written and heart-breaking. As Johnny falls, he remembers what happened to each of the boys, and it’s written in such a vivid way that it sticks with you. The whole scene makes you pause and think, even after you’ve finished. Overall, Play is a book that sticks with you, even after you have finished it, and it is definitely worth reading if you are ready for more difficult themes.

Martha
Norwich School Carnegie Shadowers

PLAY is a powerful, tragic coming-of-age story of four boys exploring masculinity, identity, and dreams. Told through intimate first-person voices, it portrays complex parent-son dynamics and ends with a hopeful, open-ended glimpse into their uncertain futures.

Jola
Beauchamp Champs 2025

The book was told by 4 different friends, who faced different challenges. Johnny only narrated the last chapters (it was the only time where we see things from his view) and told us what happened in the future. Luc was always pushed to the limit by his father, for example making him join an older rugby team when he's underage, causing him to break his arm. Luc's dad also has toxic views on women, causing Luc to feel like he needs to live up to his expectations and be more masculine. I'm disappointed though, that even though he knows he's wrong, he doesn't change. Matt is quiet, and in love with Mark, and Mark started dealing drugs but stopped by repaying his boss. In the end, they all moved on with their lives. It wasn't that gripping for me, so 4/5.

Mila
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Play is a very emotional and intense story about four very different boys who grew up together. It shows the story and perspective of each character, the pressure and challenges they face and the struggles of being a teenager. I enjoyed this book because the writing is realistic and it includes the view of each character. It is a serious book and the characters feel realistic, which can help readers of the same age/situation feel engaged in the story.

Elizabeth
Augustine’s Carnegie Challenge

I did not really enjoy play as much as the other books as I didn't feel it grabbed me. I did think it was a good book though. I also thought at the end it used a really interesting method of showing ways that the other characters could live and what their lives might look like in the future. Overall I thought the book was good but I do prefer some of the other books.

Evie
STAGS Shadowers

Everyone’s setting their socks on fire. Is a rubbish way to begin a book. However, much like the rest of Luke Palmer’s novel, now this line makes perfect sense and it being the final one encapsulates Johnny beautifully. Given Johnny sad ending, I am glad we did not get his perspective – especially because of his unique theories. I believe a story like Johnny’s should not be interpreted into first person narrative as the author would never really understand to the full extent what feelings happen. Johnny’s relations to Mark, Luc, and Matt shined a new light onto teenage male friendships to me as a teenage female reading; and learning about different dynamics, that may form for my peers. The final chapter talking about all the dissimilar realities his friends could end up with; now as much as I am not falling, I still see all the possibilities my friends’ futures entail because I know their faults but them still being up for the game – or learning from the game, whatever the game is to them. Introducing Johnny with the collapsing of dens for the control of the future but not being able to control the present gives depth to the tale and Johnny’s wants in life, foreshadowing the end of the book. Whether it be for the thrills or for the deeper understanding of ‘the map’, Johnny’s joy exudes from the book through the bleak pages of the other’s raw events (yet sadly, as it is for most young deaths, the guy with the smile is the one to go). Linking all the different perspectives and stories is Johnny, he brings his friends closer and the reader closer to them as well. But tragically he is also the end of the story too. I enjoy how straight forward and no-nonsense Johnny would ask his questions whether it be when he is on green or not. Overall, Johnny is a character with great depth and is extremely well written, thus complex. Mark, the Entrepreneur, seems to be a stereo typical teenage boy. But when we find out about his home life being hard as they do not have much money. You grow sympathetic for the young lad, yet I feel that ever reader will not except what his does to earn his money. This draws good attention towards life problems about broke teenage boys getting into terrible situations; which need to be stopped but cannot be without someone talking about it. Palmer’s description of Mark’s longing for a better life is vivid making the book more enjoyable and easier to get into. I liked that although Mark does make out with Matt, his sexuality is not a topic of discussion creating a more inclusive environment. The lesson we learn from Mark is to “never make yourself untouchable”, because you begin by feeling great, you end up losing the game. Also, that trust is something to not use lightly. The next name bothers me, as it is Luc -this is because the author’s name is Luke- and sadly, the most likely to be disliked character is called the other spelling of the author’s name which I think is just petty. Now, as I have grown up with rugby, and sport in general – I understand the competitive drive in Luc and his dad’s attitude towards it because I see the effects of it in a lot of the boys I know (even my dad and some of my friends who are girls). I also believe everyone can relate to Luc being scared to turn out like his dad, when we are kids, we swore we will not be like them, then we turn into them as parents are the biggest influences on youth. Palmer has a gift for making everyone seen and all problems relative. I am glad one of the boys is problematic for girls, so it reflects the truth of the way teenage boys behave because of the influence of others. However, I am happy that Luc (although never perfect with it) tries to get better because someone he loved told him he needed to. Breaking a bone or getting knocked down makes you realise how scorched the ground is so you need to look after the ground before you can run on it. I believe everyone can relate heavily to one character in this novel – for me it is Matt. His coming out story to his friends sounded very similar to mine. This is because I felt the moment get taken away from me too, and from the way my queer friends talk about their experiences with it, they tell similar tales. I have also had complicated relations with people of the same sex after coming out – Matt and Luc’s awkward interactions throughout the book are very close to a regular event for most gay people. Palmer not doing the stereo typical thing of making Matt’s parents do not embrace him for who he is, brings a joy to me as this is very rarely portrayed in media. Yet he still struggles with his sexuality which is heavily realistic. At the beginning of the novel, it is very clear that Matt is gay even before it is stated because of him wanting to ‘fit in’ which is a universal experience (regardless of sexuality). Matt being good with words and decently academic portrays a different side of boys that we do not see in Luc, Mark and Johnny, and so does his close relationship to his parents. Him wanting to take a stand for the environment is cool and I feel that a lot of youth get into stuff like that because it gets forced upon us. The message to take from Matt is to create because someday someone might see themselves in it, like what Luke Palmer has done with this utterly astonishing book.

Freya
KES Bookworms

i enjoyed this book because of its short chapters which made the pool more fast paced and exciting, i also liked the friendships between the boys and how each character was unique. although, i did find this book the hardest to follow out of all but i think it was very cleverly written. 7.5/10

scarlett
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Play is a story that follows 4 teenagers living like any other teenager group until one of them interacts with his brother's friend who shows him something new that changes their lives forever. Play is the best book i have read so far because it gives us perspective from each of the characters and shows consequences of doing drugs.

Artem
Bookwizards

This book was incredibly well written and insightful into the struggles and hardships of teenage boys. I loved the way it progresses through their high school journey and shows that so many things still need to change and be talked about especially in the treatment of girls at the hands of boys. I found it a bit difficult to understand the implications the drug dealers give and slang for the drugs but I don't really understand slang in general!

Emily
Lionheart25

This book was more than just a book. It proved to me that young people will do anything for fun whether it is illegal or not and they would come to the realisation of what they've done far too late. This book showed me the struggle of getting pressured into getting involved with any sort of drugs. I personally liked how we get a different perspective each chapter. The characters' backgrounds felt so real it felt like they were actual living people. The ending was very upsetting but I liked how Johnny felt and saw many things at the end. I loved the fact that the very last line of the book was also at the very start of the book. I really reallllyyyyyyyy liked this book!

Salma
Bellerive Bookies and Cookies

‘Play’ by Luke Palmer is a story centered around 4 boys and their lives. Swapping points of view we see into the minds of 4 very different characters and how they view the world and the circumstances they find themselves thrown into. I felt the short chapters continuously changing perspective between Luc, Matt and Mark kept the book fast paced and interesting, however, I would love to read more from the perspective of Johnny and his views of the world. I enjoyed how the characters did not have a filter, making them seem more realistic and actually present, with flaws and goals. Prevalent throughout the entire book were topics like masculinity, friendship, childhood, human faults with Luke Palmer even recognizing the effect we have on the environment and the consequences in turn that it has on us. Personally, I found the games were often, for me, the most interesting section of the novel as they were an escape for the pressure put on the boys and their way of having fun with a commitment only they could understand. Although the ending was obscure, I felt it was fitting in a way that allowed anything to happen - leaving loose threads that could be interpreted or twisted into the reader's own ending.

Ellie-Anna
Rainbeau Readers

Play was a really nice and enjoyable read overall. I found myself drawn into the lives of the characters—each one felt like a real person with their own voice, struggles, and unique way of dealing with things, which made following their stories really engaging. I especially appreciated how the book explored the different problems each character faced; it wasn’t shallow or rushed, and the author took time to dive into themes like relationships, self-worth, and the pressure of growing up in a way that felt genuine. There were moments that really made me stop and think. That said, I REALLY wish the ending had been different. It’s not that it was bad—it just didn’t feel like an Ending ending. There was some closure, sure, but emotionally it felt a bit unfinished, like it wrapped up just enough to technically end the story but not enough to feel fully resolved. I was hoping for something with more impact or clarity. Still, despite that, I’m glad I read it—the journey was meaningful, and the characters and their stories will stick with me.

Trinity
Augustine’s Carnegie Challenge

Wow, what a read and what a collection of characters! Matt, Luc, Mark and Johnny. It was only afterwards that another member of the group pointed out those were the names of the four Apostles in the Bible. Meeting as young boys building dens the friendship amongst these four friends continues into adolescence and early manhood. The boys have different characters and totally different backgrounds but they all connect. Matt is an artist, Mark falls under the influence of drug dealers as his older brother did and finds himself used as a supplier and a drugs mule, Luc is under the influence of his bullying dad who belittles Luc's mum and who has great sporting dreams for his son until he gets injured, Johnny is a loose cannon but his heart is in the right place and at the end of the day he is the only one with concerns about the other 3. Play is interpreted in different ways: do you play the game or do you not conform, what is at stake? My favourite character was Johnny, mad as a box of frogs and neglected by his wealthy parents but so caring of his friends. The story builds up to a climax one summer night. No spoilers, read it for yourself.

Mrs. P
Cake a Book Club

Wow. What a book! The storyline was so gripping, I couldn’t put it down! ‘Play’ tackles real world problems, and explores events that many deal with, and the way this book was structured was very interesting!

Isabella
CHSG readers

Play is (sadly) my favourite book so far. I genuinely love this book, the characters (although they are stereotypes) act their age to an uncanny degree and I could easily imagine them as real people. They are all flawed to a certain extent: Matt's a pushover, Luc takes after his father in all the wrong ways, Mark is easily swayed by money and Johnny is a chronic risk-taker but they are all decent enough people. The plot points are well paced, things characters do matter and influence their decisions. (Luc's interactions with Sarah being a good example) To top it all off, the themes of toxic masculinity are so naturally baked in you wouldn't even notice you're being preached to. I'm sad this book is so great as the people who need to read it (teenage boys) generally don't read, especially a book this long. You can see the vision so clearly with all the boys being stereotypes as well as being flawed so every person who reads it can find one of them they relate too the most, seeing the flaws in them but knowing they can and do change for the better. But your average "alpha male" couldn't be bothered to read it, it's just infuriating. To sum it up in one sentence: Brilliant, but the people who will actually read it probably won't need it's message.

Alexander
THS Shadowing

Play is a book about 4 teenage boys, all struggling with different aspects of their life. Luc is an athlete, who drives out his problems into sport, Matt struggles with his emotions and feelings for Mark, who has started doing “business” with a friend of his brother; and Johnny is a mystery… I think this book was good as it teaches people about the struggles of boys and teenagers of present day. Something I think was controversial about this book was the ending because even though it was upsetting, I think it was a good and relevant end to the story. I would rate this book a 7-8/10.

Isla
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Play gave me a valuable insight to the lives and struggles of boys my age. I also felt, as a girl the treatment of the female characters was recognisable and resonated with me. The cyclical narrative was carried out very well and felt intriguing and satisfying. I also felt that the family dynamics seemed real and true to life.

Rose Miles
Wyedean School

I really liked this book, it was interesting to see the main characters changing over the years and how that showed their story lines grow. I loved seeing the book being written from four different perspectives as it’s nothing like i’ve read before.

Mireya
SMMA BOOKWORMS

Play is a book about four 16 year olds who are each dealing with different difficult problems. I liked how the 4 perspectives and different stories kept the book exciting and varied. I really enjoyed reading about Mark's involvement with county lines and Matt's struggles with being gay. I didn't like the way Luc treated Mark and Sara badly, especially as he did not apologise. The ending of the book felt inconclusive and rushed. Personally I would have preferred a longer ending that finished the relationship with Matt and Mark, Luc talking to Matt and Mark fully getting out of county lines. I also found some parts of the book confusing such as the 4 perspectives, at the start where they changed years and the ending. Overall I really enjoyed this book and would recommend it to secondary school children but not younger children because it includes drug-taking, drinking, swears, sexual stuff, death, sexism, homophobia, toxic masculinity and neglect.

Sophie
The Fitzharrys Shadows

This book is really good, I'd say it's more for a mature audience as it has some pretty serious topics. It shows really well how people can be different or can be pushed to do things that arent good for them or others because of pressure around them and i really like this book!

Daisy
Thornton Books & Banter

FUNNY BOOK, INTERESTING AND INFORMATIONAL ABOUT LATER LIFE. SHOWS WHAT SOME PEOPLE CAN BE LIKE (HOMOPHOBIA). VERY GOOD BOOK. SOME OF IT KINDA SCARED ME BUT IT WAS ALTOGETHER OK.

GEORGE
Reading’s Readers

This book is very interesting. It talks about 4 different boys with their own problems in their own lives. I recommend this book to early teens and hope readers enjoy this book just as I have.

Hosannah
Kingdown

I thought Play was well written and I did not see the ending coming at all. However I found the beginning a bit confusing, as we passed four years in about three pages, and I kept getting mixed up between the narrators. As the book went on it steadied out a bit and I did get quite invested in the characters, but I thought all the drug taking and drinking got a bit repetitive. My favourite part was definitely Mark's artwork, his drawings and sculptures, and I would have liked to have known what happened to them. I feel that at the end there were lots of loose ends and stories which were never properly explained, which I suppose is unavoidable with so many narrators, but was quite annoying and a bit frustrating.

Mabel
The High Storrs Shadows

Play is a stunning book told from multiple perspectives. It follows the story of four young boys struggling with various challengers. The story explores what happens when one boy ends up in over his head. The focus on relationships among friends is what makes this story super special. I feel it is a book that it is important for every teenager to read.

Emily
TGGS Carnegie Readers

Really good book! Very well thought of characters who had very complex stories however the multiple point perspective was a bit confusing. The end was a little bit rushed but the themes were very well-written and important

Elsie
Eltham Hill Y9 Book Club

I really enjoyed this book! I loved how there were different perspectives and different stories. It brought up difficult topics but it was written in a very clear way and represented some really hard things that people actually go through in real life. I would recommend this book.

Eliza
Eltham Hill Y9 Book Club

I like Play. It is very nice and nostalgic. It makes me think of other stories and films such as Stand By Me and It. A very good book - please read!

Jacob
Montsaye Librarians

This story follows the life of four friends who get up to no good, especially Mark. I enjoyed this book as it allowed people to get a better understanding of how bad drug use is. Although I felt at times there was too much drug use, I liked the concept of each character having their own game. I also liked the fact that each character had their own perspective as this helped to show how different they are and it doesn't matter how diverse they may be as they are all friends as this novel promotes boy friendship. However I disliked the ending due to it being sad but this could highlight the fact that in real life people don't always get happy endings. I recommend this book to people who enjoy darker themes or people of LGBTQ+ plus due to a gay relationship however anyone can read this book. Finally I would rate this book 4/5 stars.

Jessica
Walkden Readers 25

A glorious heart breaking book about friendship between teenage boys, each dealing with their own struggles, such as sexuality, drug dealing, sports, and love. This book also cautions readers about the dangers of drugs, while being a beautiful book of romance, with a twist of humor.

Jennifer
Horsham BOok HUNTers

Play was a very nice book, I would rate it 4.7 out of 5, it was an accurate representation of being a teenager and having issues that are out of hand, and worrying of being an outcast and being different to everyone else, some of the issues even effected the people's performance out on the pitch, but by the end of the book it ended happily. Great book, would recommend to my friends.

Rhoshon
JCA Book Club

play by luke palmer is a coming-of-age story centered on the lives of four boys as they navigate adolescence, friendship, and the pressures of their small town. me personally i found the book very positive, highlighting its realistic depiction of male friendships, relatable characters, and exploration of weighty themes like toxic masculinity and drug use

Irshad
BAS READING CHAMPIONS

This is a compelling and often gripping read. It’s probably the most ‘mature’ of the Carnegie books this year, in terms of subject matter and themes. And the plot deals with some pretty intense, sometimes quite dark topics, like sexuality, drugs, difficult family relationships, sexual violence. The four friends who tell their stories (each chapter is from a different character’s perspective) are in their late teenage years, so the issues they are dealing with are those of a transition to adulthood. The writer, Luke Webster, paints a really convincing picture of male friendship, and an understanding and affection built from years of shared experiences. The four boys are all different though, and as they move towards the end of their teenage years they’re trying to work out their own identities. I think that the book’s title, ‘Play’ represents that sense of pleasure and freedom that characterises the experimentation of late adolescence: soon, they’ll be adults (most of them...) and the time for Play will be over. Now it’s time to explore, to succeed, to discover. Matt, Mark, Luc and Johnny have grown up together and feel like they know each other inside out. Matt is sensitive, artistic, one of the lads but slightly on the outside looking in. He knows he’s gay and is nervous about what his coming out will mean for his relationships. Luc: rugby player, in his own eyes an alpha male and God’s gift to women. His values and behaviour have been shaped by his father’s encouragement and example, but he’s starting to realise that just because his dad (who owns and runs a successful scaffolding business) cares about Luc successfully living up to a rugged male stereotype, it doesn’t mean that his dad really cares about him. He’s not allowed to feel fragile or admit to weakness, even when he’s been seriously hurt at training by a much bigger, older, player, or pushed his body past its limit on a long holiday cycle ride. Johnny: loveable, unpredictable, often unhinged, almost a mascot for the group. Mark: not as academic as Matt, and not a swaggering tough like Luc, struggling to work out what/who he wants to be. Mark starts running secretive errands for a friend of his older brother, errands which take him down a glamorous, but dangerous road. Mark’s story becomes the most gripping one, and the most scary one, even more so because for the most part the drug traffickers who are directing his movements stay menacingly in the shadows. His story is dramatic and potentially explosive; it seems inevitable that it will be central to the novel’s conclusion, which takes place at a drug-fuelled house party with all four friends in attendance. Mark’s story is significant to the ending, but in a shocking and unexpected way that means the book ends on a rather sad, and very moving note. No more ‘play’, the ‘game’ is over. Parents of young readers might be alarmed by the casual way that all of the young characters take recreational drugs in this book. They are a feature of their lives just like their energy drink, ‘Comeup’ (the name itself borrowing from the language of drug-taking). In fact, Webster is drawing a clever link between the ‘addiction’ to the buzz of those socially authorised drinks and the later use of illegal substances. Their complacency leads to recklessness and ultimately the devastating conclusion to events. A great book, only four stars because I think that it’s a bit too mature for younger readers. ****

Mr Hodgson
Ermysted’s

This is a highly compelling and interesting book. I definitely feel like I’ve gotten to know the characters throughout reading this book. Would definitely recommend.

Mary
JGHS Shadowers

I liked Play a lot, it was nice to see the boys over the years and how they changed as their story lines developed. I think it covered an important set of topics and I liked how it ended getting to see some of their futures before they've even happened.

Daisy
Wyedean School

I think that this book was quite long, and I did have to force myself to pick it up. Their lazy, carefree days of summer change as they grow up and the games they play change and become more dangerous. Luc shows toxic masculinity, Mark is trapped, drug dealing, Matt becomes an artist and Johnny.. I mean, it was interesting, buut I personally wouldn't recommend.

Joanna
Townley Book Club

This book was easy to read and very descriptive. I find it interesting that the story is told from four different first person perspectives. I think some people might find this book a little inappropriate, as it talks about drugs, drinking, death, toxic masculinity, abandonement, etc... but I think these topics are important. The four boys all play a lot of 'games' like "Everyone's setting their socks on fire", and throughout the book the games become even more dangerous, especially for Mark. I love the ending when Johnny thinks about his friends' and his sister's futures as one final game, with all their different choices and outcomes.

Camille
4Shadowers

A very well written book. Its story is well thought out and nicely weaved. However, it is a bit predictable at times and some plot twists were easy to see coming. Other than that, it is a great story showing raw emotions and bringing up some real issues from our world. For a more basic rating, I'd give 'Play' an 8.5/10

Anonymous
St George’s Dragon Readers

‘Play’ by Luke Palmer ‘Play’ is a book based on masculinity, where four boys go through their life playing games to challenge each other and proving their manliness. The book is about a group of boys who each have a different concept of the “male” in society. One would be a strong male who is good at sports, big and strong. Another is part of the LGBTQ+ community facing the reality of his gender, afraid to talk about it to the other boys. The next is a carefree boy whose dream is to be able to live a carefree and peaceful life. The last is the main character, a boy with high interests in money, named Mark. The story is written to show how young boys can go through tough phases and how males in society are not always the stereotypically strong and manly kind. I find the book to be intriguing, entertaining and relatable. The first few chapters introduce the characters but as the book goes on, Mark’s actions cause all his friends to face their deepest fears. The book is highly recommended for young boys going through their teenage life before becoming a man and I rate this book a 7/10.

Xavier
The Lotus Readers

I really liked the book "play" and how it swichted in between characters in each chapter. I also loved how they all had different personalities and views. Mark encounters a really hard situation which could help the readers understand the reality of life, it shows that there are really fun times but also difficult and dangerous times.Overall, the book really made me interested and I would recommend it to other pupils!

Alice
The Bentley Woodlanders

Something about this book became special to me when i was reading it, maybe it was because of how the book is easy to relate to, or how it talks about real struggles that a lot of teens (especialy boys) go through, there are a lot of reasons why someone might like this book, and for me its because of all of those reasons it has a good message behind it and is relatible and almost felt comforting to read, and that is what makes it special to me. if i was to give this book a rating, i would give it 5 stars.

Larry
Orpington Library Older Teens

This was a gripping read. I was fully immersed in the characters' young lives, which were everything you probably wouldn't want your teenage son's to be - drug-taking, hanging around the streets, 'making out' with a string of girls, failing at school, negative male influences. Phew! This is an insight into the modern lives of streetwise teens and not for the fainthearted. The author is a secondary school teacher so I'm sure this is a realistic portrayal of some teenage boys experiences. The story keeps switching from boy to boy, written in the first person and that can be confusing - you need to keep a straight idea in your head about which is which, but this becomes easier once you get into the plot. Although each boy is very different, their bonds of friendship are very strong. My favourite character was Matt, who is gay, and the least rebellious of the four. Particularly convincing as a character was the father of Mark - a narcissist of a dad and the ongoing damage done to his son though his expectations and bullying was tough to read. This book is not appropriate for younger teens and although a satisfying read, certainly not an uplifting one. Beautifully written and well worth reading though. I found it almost unputdownable.

Mrs M
Blake Book Buddies

6/7 I really liked the style and pace of the the writing in this book since I think it gave me a chance to really get to know the characters well and understand how different the lives of the boys were. The book moves through several years of the boys' lives which I think made me feel a bit disconnected with the characters at moments but also emphasised the different challenges they came to face with as they grew up. Overall I would recommend this book because I think there are many important messages as you understand each other the boy's lives and what affected them as they grew up.

Bianca
Carnegie Literary Circle

Play was an engaging story of drug misuse and toxic masculinity, among other things. It was narrated through the perspective of four boys who each have a lot of character development. My favourite character was Johnny because he was the most intricate character. My favourite narrative, though, was Matt's, as his was the most interesting to read from. The extremely heavy drug usage and Luc's narrative really brought this book down, as I did not find either realistic or interesting, though the morals rang clear. The twist ending was slightly confusing (with Johnny pushing the needle) but still just as heart warming/breaking.

Elijah
VISTA Academy

Play by Luke Palmer follows four boys—Johnny, Luc, Matt, and their friend—as they grow up in a small town, pushing boundaries and searching for excitement. They play games, take risks, and test their limits, but when one of them breaks a rule, the consequences become real. The novel explores friendship, masculinity, and the dangers of wanting to escape boredom, making it a tense and emotional read. For me personally the ending was very tragic as at the end of Play, Johnny’s reckless behavior leads to his tragic death after a dangerous climbing stunt and drug use. His loss shakes the group, forcing the others to reevaluate their choices. Mark, caught in a dangerous world of crime, struggles to free himself from the trouble he unknowingly stepped into. Luc, shaped by his father’s influence, continues to push his limits, testing himself in ways that could become risky. Matt, the more introspective one, processes everything that has happened, grappling with the emotional weight of losing a friend and the uncertain future ahead. The novel leaves their stories open-ended, making readers wonder where life will take them next.I really enjoyed reading this book but i didnt like how it ended .

Yumna
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Play by Luke Palmer is a powerful and emotional book about four boys growing up and trying to figure out who they are, and what it really means to be a man. Each of the boys has a unique personality, and some even have their own font, which makes it easier to tell them apart and understand their point of view. The story is often sad and deeply emotional, as it explores their dreams and the pressures teenage boys face. The characters aren’t perfect — they make mistakes and bad choices — but that just makes them feel more realistic, like people you might actually know in real life. The ending shows that even after everything they’ve been through, there’s still a chance for change and growth. It reminds us that there is always hope for the future.

Chantelle
Rainbeau Readers

Luke Palmer’s “Play” is a well written and powerful book that helps readers understand how difficult life can be for people from different backgrounds and social situations. Even though the story deals with some serious issues, it stays enjoyable and doesn’t focus too heavily on the negatives. The book follows four very different boys as they go through school and become close friends. To keep themselves entertained and escape their everyday lives, they create games to “play” during school and on their holidays. At first, these games are fun and innocent, giving them something to look forward to. But as the boys grow older, their games become more daring and a little riskier. One of the boys, Matt, starts off as a kind and innocent character. Over time, though, he begins to make poor choices. He falls in with the wrong crowd and starts running drugs, thinking it’s just a bit of fun and adventure. Eventually, things take a dark turn when he is kidnapped by men involved in the drug world. They warn him that one more mistake could cost him everything. This moment is a huge contrast to the friendly way the man who first brought him into the business treated him, showing how dangerous and fake that kindness really was.

Oscar
Bookwizards

I really enjoyed this book but the ending was a bit confusing to work out what was happening. But I loved how the writing was set out and I enjoyed the story line. The author did a really good job for making a book where you don’t want to put it down. I would rate it a 8/10.

Sarah
Carnegievores

I thought it was a great book that had a clear plot while still going into lots of detail of the struggles that teenage boys can go through. The elements of drugs creates a sense of fear and an feeling of imminent danger as well as evoking sympathy for the characters. Overall, an amazing read.

Noah
DauntseysShadowTeam

Play is a very well-constructed book. It is about a group of friends who describe their lives in quite some detail. The reader is drawn into the book right from the start. I enjoyed Play, but found it did take me quite some time to read it.

Rehan
QEGS CARNEGIE BOOK CLUB

This book is so funny and thought provoking! I like the fact that the characters that we follow are all a stereotypes and that we see parts of each in ourselves. It really makes you think about the consequences of your actions and how that can affect others as well. Seeing different experiences of the same situation really adds to the book as well because it shows you how the world is perceived by different people and how people's thought processes vary. This book emphasises the need for empathy and understanding even when it is hard to do so - a valuable lesson which everybody at this point in the world needs.

Bella
Balla Bookworms

It is quite an intersting story, showing the growth and life of highschool boys and the dangers of teenage lives.

Sawyer
Tenbury Page Turners 25

I found Play an engaging read, right from the start, I haven't stopped talking about it! The four main characters are brought together in realistic, messy, silly, powerful, loving friendships. As a reader it was fascinating to move from one character's voice to another (thanks for the different fonts!) to follow their interweaving storylines, as their relationships with one another move apart and together. No spoilers here - be prepared for an emotional rollercoaster! You will recognise these boys - you know them or are them! Enjoy their story, it is superb!

Mrs P
Montsaye Librarians

Play is a very good book, in my opinion. It is about four boys who are all very good friends. At the start of the book the boys mainly focus on building dens, coming up with new games and this promotes the theme of play which runs throughout the story. One of the boys - Luc - shows the toxic masculinity than men and boys can suffer from. Mark gets caught up in drug dealing. Matt becomes an artist. Jonny though... Well, I will give no spoilers! 4 stars out of 5!

Edith
Montsaye Librarians

Play is an eye-opening book telling the lives of four friends in alternating chapters. They play games at school, games out of school, each with their own rules. But some games don't always end happily. I enjoyed reading Play, its a story that feels like it could happen any time in real life. My favourite parts were the end of the chapters - the last sentences almost always spoke the feelings of each character and how the felt about themselves, or what they were doing. The story also kept me turning the pages right till the end - the building of tension was spread throughout the whole book. However, there was one main thing that I didn't like about Play. It felt like the ending could have been explained a lot more than it did, and through the voices of all the characters - how their lives turned out for each of them, narrated by themselves. But overall, this book was really good, and it makes us think of the realistic challenges any of us could one day face. I would recommend it to all young adult readers!

Emma M
VISTA Academy

‘Play’ is a novel by Luke Palmer about the four friends Mark, Johnny, Luc and Matt, who are in secondary school. The author tells the story by alternating the perspectives between the boys, which helps the reader to understand the point of view of each character better. The book explains well how easily one mistake can be made and result in the wrong path. What initially starts as ‘a game’ for Mark, what seems to be ‘harmless’, leads to a serious crime: drug dealing. The choices you make in life always have consequences is a lesson these teenagers need to learn. (The book is in many ways very similar to last year’s ‘Crossing The Line’.) The last chapter is told from Johny’s perspective and it’s kind of a peek into the future, where/how the (now grown up) friends end up. The story is very realistic and tragic and in my opinion, only suitable from 14+. I didn’t enjoy reading this book, especially the end. I felt like there is a huge gap in the end since a devastating incident happens while they are Year 9 students but then from there it straight goes to when they are adults.

Eric
Beauchamp Champs 2025

This book was my last read and definitely my favourite. However the names were too similar. I think it would have been easier to understand if Matt and Mark's names were a bit different. Despite this, Play was the best Carnegies I've read this year!

Livie
St Kaths

The book ‘play’ is a very fun book to read with lots of wonder and adventure inside of it. I particularly liked it when at the start of the book Mark was talking about his best den he made which was in the shape of an L. Also this book talks about the friendship of four friends and shows how friends are always needed to face challenges together and it won’t always be easy for one another but overall I think this book is amazing and definitely one to read.

Hayden
TTS Readers

This book was really good and touched on some difficult topics really well. Although I'm not a boy, I can definitely see some of the boys at my primary school in the characters. Overall, I think the book was really good despite fizzling out at the end!

Greta
Newstead Wood Carnegie Shadowers

Emotional and interesting.

Jasmine
Newstead Wood Carnegie Shadowers

The story is about when four friends grow up together at school , playing games , anything to keep there minds busy until they all slip into their own imagination . I liked reading this book because it helped explain how different peoples mind sets work in the same situation . One main feature in the book is repetition which had a strong effect on the storyline which i liked .

Isabelle
OLSB Shadowers

Darker than expected, but still hooked me in. Covered topics that are typically considered taboo to talk or write of, such as drugs. Nice to read a book that covered these topics and taught me some of the reasons behind drug usage, drug selling and more. Would recommend to friends, though would warn them of the swears inside.

Alex
Carnegie Club

Play by Luke Palmer was an emotional roller coaster to say the least. Matt and Johnny were both good characters who deserved more time in the book. Marks chapters were all the same: running drugs for various strangers. Luc was my least favourite character. I found the way he treated Sara absolutely awful. This book tried to tackle too many issues at once, leading to a jumble of bad topics. Is it really too much to ask for the characters to be happy and have a good life?

Astrid
Larkmead

This book can be summarised in 4 words: "Okay book, terrible endings." "Play" is a book that explores themes of toxic masculinity and some teenage friendships. Its plot is similar to the plot of Crossing the Line with more advanced themes and a much more difficult read (it's not a verse-novel). I didn't like it much because while the characters do develop, its more of just snapshots of what the characters do - like an AI-generated video - where it's too still and quite bland. The ending is horrible... a lot of really interesting stuff happens in the last 50 pages just for it to... end. Nothing interesting happens. It just ends, with a bunch of loose ties. It isn't a proper ending, there's too much that happens that isn't explained. There's stuff in the book that is really interesting but unfortunately I won't type about that as it would spoil parts of the plot; but it doesn't explain some stuff that would be nice to know. 3/10; it's ok apart from the ending... which, as I've said, just... ends.

Thomas
Carnegievores

I really enjoyed this book. In the first chapter I found it hard to get into, but that completely changed! I got completely immersed in it after the first chapter. The multiple perspectives were very good as they all tied into each other and were very vivid. I thought you could really tell what they were thinking and feeling. I thought this was an extremely well written book and I loved it all the way through.

Iris
Skipton Shadows

I just want to start by saying I absolutely loved this book. I love how it covered many subjects often not discussed and what a boy in that situation might feel. I also liked how this book showed the dangers of drugs and what they can do.

maya k
Herts and Essex

I really enjoyed reading 'Play'. The dual narrative kept me very intrigued with the plot, and I was constantly thinking ‘what would happen next?’ and couldn’t put the book down. Though I found it a bit confusing at times, I really enjoyed the ending; the way it was structured made it very captivating for me. I would recommend this book to others, but probably to people of a slightly higher age group.

Natalie
TPS Carnegie Collective

I like this book as it: - Explored different people's perspectives on the story - Was a somewhat accurate description of school - Alerts people to the danger of drugs - Features good dialouge - Captures you and builds tension

yusuf
TPS Carnegie Collective

I enjoyed reading 'Play' and I like how it focused on all of the boys and how different their lives were. I adored the subplot of Matt and Mark crushing on each other, and the characters felt very real. However, at some points I felt like the author wasn't showing that the plot was about Johnny and how he was struggling. We didn't hear about him for pages while one of the other boys would go on about a game of theirs, and I found some of the book to be slow moving. If the author had focused in on Johnny a bit more and made him more of a main character, then the ending would have worked better. It was also easy to predict the ending, and it felt quite rushed, and there was no build up to the end. I did like, however, the last chapter with Johnny reflecting on everything and showing us the future of the other boys, but I felt like the plot was a bit messy at points. Besides this, I enjoyed reading Play and the author was really good at showing what it's like to be a teenager.

Ela
KES Bookworms

Play by Luke Palmer is a serious book about teenage friendship and growing up in a small town. The book shows the lives of four boys - Matt, Mark, Luc, and Johnny - and how they deal with matters that most adults encounter, such as finding who they are, peer pressure, and the choice of doing bad things. Palmer's text is real and realistic in depicting how adolescent boys talk and act. All the characters are elaborated, with unique personalities, problems, and motivations, and are easy to relate to. The novel shows the tough topics of drug addiction and harmful attitudes toward being a man, and does so realistically, showing the real problems young people are faced with. The text is also reviewed for focusing on male friendships, the influence (or absence) of the fathers, as well as pressures from others. It further provides insight into the ways the boys adapt to living conditions and into the challenging decisions they take that often have worse consequences. Some readers find that the tale slows at certain points, but the book is worthwhile because of its characters, emotional messages, and positive messages. The ending is dramatic and piques my interest. Overall, Play is a novel that offers a close-up view of the lives of teenage boys. It's best read by mature teens , especially those who are interested in the subjects of masculinity, friendship, and the teen struggle.

Shaurjesh
MTS Northwood

this is an amazing book showing each characters feelings of eachother and a view of each character per chapter.4 friends who go to school together but they also have different perspectives of eachother. At first they all make and destroy dens such as the “L” den and many more but as they grow older they make more dangerous games such running jobs and tasks for criminals like Mark has done as a show of respect for his older brother but it gets out of hand . during the middle of the book a guy called Tom who is Marks older brothers friend asks about a package which has something to due with drugs and Mark is acting so confused and tom tells him to hide it under his shirt. this is one of the few main reasons why Marks old friends are mad at him . they feel left out because Mark is hanging out with his older borther, they feel betrayed and worried as Mark is doing something risky and illegal for his older brother. i think Mark is finally feeling proud and excited that his older brother finally sees him as he is worth something and Mark is not facing the truth that his older brother is using him for something illegal and mark wont see that because he thinks he is finally “hanging out” with his older brother . even though this has a bunch of swear words i think its still a really good book and is one of my favs right now.

khadija
BAS READING CHAMPIONS

“Play” by Luke Palmer was quite engaging and thought-provoking for me and I enjoyed learning about the different lives, and friendships, of the four teenage boys – Matthew, Mark, Luc, and Johnny – who all like to mess around and participate in reckless activities. The book explores toxic masculinity, friendship, drug use and peer pressure. I especially enjoyed Luc’s unique perspective because he had to deal with expectations, sometimes set by his dad, to prove himself by doing dangerous things. Later, he becomes more self-aware and realises that the choices he made were maybe not the best and tries to improve himself, for example, by mending broken friendships, primarily with Matthew. All four boys have a ‘game’ that they play, and Mark gets involved with one that seems to be fulfilling and rewarding but then switches to a dangerous and manipulative situation – where he becomes trapped. I found that the friendships between the boys changed as the challenges being faced became more apparent in their lives and I think that the different personas of the boys were very effective. I also think that the use of short chapters kept me invested in the plot, but I do wish that Johnny was included more in the book as I think that there could have been a deeper understanding of his life, leading up to the tragic plot twist at the end. I would recommend this book to people in Year 9 and above. Overall, this was a great read, and I rate it 8/10 stars.

Hannah
Augustine’s Carnegie Challenge

3 stars This book reminds of ‘We Were Liars’ by e.lockhart. Although it obviously does not have the same plot nor writing style, they both have the same sense of sadness. I think this book describes male life in a way I saw it sometimes. It emphasises that boys have struggles too and I like how it shows their different perspectives and personalities since they are in total opposites but have lots of similarities too. This book is the perfect example of ‘not everything is a game’ and shows the consequences of actions that you make. I believe more teenagers should read this book and books like this, it explores the dangers of illegal drugs and alcohol. As wells as this, it teaches minors the consequences of dealing drugs and interacting with dangerous people. Lastly on pages 264-265, Matt states a powerful speech that is so true about the world. It may seem pessimistic or ignorant when you first read it but to be fair, it’s realistic. We need to act on issues instead of just having the role of acting and reassuring people we will do things so they don’t have to worry about it. Overall, I rated this book 3 stars because it is quite slow-paced with long chapters and I did not have the urgency to read it. It definitely gave a great message though. I loved how Luc was described as an athlete, Mark an entrepreneur and Matt an artist. They also had different fonts for everyone speaking.

Zoe
Herts and Essex

I found the book "Play" by Luc Palmer enjoyable, I found in some parts it was gripping and emotional. With this book I had to expect the unexpected because I could never tell what was coming next. It's about four friends that live different lives but all care about each other, it does show some behaviour as normal whereas it shouldn't, but I still thought this book was amazing, and I didn't expect the plot twists that were ahead, when I was reading, considering I didn't know anything about the book until I started reading, I would definitely suggest this this book to anyone looking to read something outside of their comfort zone.

Isabelle
Marshland Readers

This book was not what I expected at all. The language, the tone, the realism and everything in between, was good. The way it was written with Johnny as the main character and Mark, Matt and Luc's perspective, was an interesting concept that was well done, but I sometimes felt we weren't focusing on Johnny that much. We often go through whole chapter's without a sense of him and I felt that really made him less relevant and that ultimately led to his suicide and therefore his point of view at the start and end is less impactful than it should have been. If we had a chapter that was a page or two long where he describes everyone setting their socks on fire and something else, maybe his eventual suicide would have been sadder. I am not saying it was not sad when he died, as it certainly was. While I did predict it, I didn't think it would be as bad as it was. I honestly felt Matt should have been the main character. He had a more interesting personality with his artwork and his crush on Mark. Also Mark, Luc and Johnnie's parents made my blood boil. Luc's dad was way too rude and aggressive, Mark's Mum only pays attention to him when he does something bad and Giles' and Johnnie's mums were awful. Matt's parents were great though. I like how they are the voice of reason among this book's horrible weak parenting, them calling out how bad Luc's Dad and Johnnie's mum are. Overall, while I do think this book has problems, I still liked it. Good job Luke, you did well, but there is room to explore the complexities.

Thomas
Rebel Readers

Play is a book about sadness, but it does take a little bit of time to adjust to the book. Before you will like the book, you might want to start reading some other Carnegie books, for example The Final Year and Little Bang.

Muhammad H
QEGS CARNEGIE BOOK CLUB

A well writen book where the author brings the teenage characters to life in an amazing way. It has some flaws, like the repetitive presence of alcohol or drugs.

Benjamin H
4Shadowers

‘Play’ by Luke Palmer was definitely outside my usual reading genre, but I found it a gripping and eye-opening read. The way it explores male friendships, masculinity, and the struggles a boy can face was both insightful and heartbreaking. I found myself unexpectedly invested in their journeys, even when their choices frustrated me. While it’s not the kind of book I would have normally picked up, I’m glad I did - I may not pick another one of this type, but I enjoyed it. It gave me a new perspective on the pressures and challenges young men experience. Luke Palmer definitely highlights the pressures of masculinity and the power of friendship . I would recommend this book to anyone who is ok with 'Young Adult' themes like drugs and gangs, and who likes a thrilling and eye opening story.

Reya
Brentwood Carnegies

play is a thrilling collection of several people all intertwined in one epic tale. It is also a cautionary book which shows the consequences of alcohol and drugs as it it shows what they could have done with their lives when Johnny dies. I feel it is a near perfect book (the start being a bit slow ). It is a fun way to get the consequences of drugs and alcohol across to the reader whist still being a page turner and in my opinion the best book I have read so far.

hugo lan
Bookwizards

The book had great literature and the writing was amazing and also the depth of character and growth was good. The overall story was just not for me. I didn't really enjoy the whole point of the story and some of the interactions and things the characters did. I also did not really enjoy the guy and his interactions with the characters. The ending of the book I thought was quite good and powerful especially talking about the pyramid and the little rooms inside. Overall it wasn't my favourite book but did have some good qualities to it.

Kyriacos
The Broxbourne Readers

Play was an interesting book it was not my favourite since I thought the plot was not very clear. There were some parts I enjoyed like the tense scenes where mark is dealing. In addition Luc’s love life is quite interesting. Despite this though I found the ending a little anticlimactic.

Raf
Horsham BOok HUNTers

Personally, I really enjoyed the book Play by Luke Palmer, you get to see the character development in each of the 4 boys and how things can change throughout a teenagers life, all 4 boys show different life experiences and backgrounds, creating representation for so many different young people allowing readers to connect with the characters but also be able to put the situations into a real life perspective. However in my opinion at the beginning the time jumps in the earlier years could have been explored more before the boys reached year 11. Overall I found the book very enjoyable and captivating, having the views of all the boys really allowed me to be able to have an insight on different subjects that I wouldn’t have had before reading. I would definitely recommend this book to other students.

Ella
LatLit

"Play" was very interesting book to read that had me enticed the whole way through. The characterisation is done amazingly and every character is different to another. I would recommend "Play" to anyone who is OK with dark subjects including drugs as well as swears. The blurb is a bit misleading but everyone I know who has read it agrees with me that this is a heavy but captivating read.

Thomas
Carnegie Club

Lovely book idea and really enjoyed even after first few pages. Astounded by complexity too!👍👍

William
St George’s Dragon Readers

I would definitely recommend this book to anybody who doesn't mind large amount of drugs and other such content. this is a really good book with a very important message, and I think a lot of teenagers can relate to some of the characters. I think that that the story is really well done, and his writing style is perfect for this type of book. 8.5/10

Matthew
Woodruffians

'Play' follows four boys as they grow older and face the challenges that come with it, we get to see each one of the boys as they face their challenges in their own unique ways. the book hopes to tackle problems teenagers face and gives perspective on teenagers and the pitfalls that may happen to them. the novel is realistic in their approach and doesn't hold back its punches when it comes to depicting trauma. the book's realism approach doesn't personally appeal to me however I can still see how someone would like this book. Overall i would give this book a 7/10

Ceejay
King James Reading Royalty

There are some parts in the book that might trigger some people but this depends upon their past, but I thing that this book should have a warning as it can bring back some old upsetting memories. Having said that, I loved it but some people may not agree as there are some upsetting parts, but overall I enjoyed it. I would recommend this book to a friend if they wanted to read something a bit dramatic. 4 * from me.

Fay
BCS Book Squad

Play is about 4 boys who grow up together and are best friends until some of them begin to start acting differently and some strange things start happening to them. I really enjoyed this novel as I can relate to the boys a lot especially johnny as I feel that he didn't change as much and I feel that I experienced a situation quite similar to his in my old school and he is in a friendship that seems quite familiar to me. I thought that Luke Palmer wrote it really well and that's why I found it so fast and easy to read. I think this book is quite a true story as the events that occur in the book are in fact everyday occurrences in the real life of a teenage boy. Overall, I thought this book was really enjoyable and I think I will recommend it to a friend.

Nico
Ardingly Carnegie Book Group

This book explored many themes that are present in a teenagers life and goes through many of the struggles that a teenager might have. It has a good moral, and meaning. Showing the problems of naivety and why trusting someone is so important as well as who you surround yourself with. The book also presents the hard choices one has to make and the consequences that actions might have. Overall I really enjoyed this book and would recommend it to people who like a thrilling story

Peter
Ardingly Carnegie Book Group

"Play" by Luke Palmer is a book that generates a lot of feelings, though not all were positive for me. On one hand Palmer's writing is undeniably alluring and thought - provoking, and there are moments were the story really shines, particularly in the emotionally raw moments of each character. I definitely think the exploration of deep themes like drugs, toxic masculinity, homophobia etc. was quite insightful. The observations made about relationships in this text show that time was taken to execute the story in a sensitive way. However I found the pacing can be irregular and at some points difficult to connect with especially right at the very end. Overall its a sophisticated and reflective read and can 100% be enjoyed depending on your reading style.

Mila
Kesgrave Bookworms

Play is a tense and timely novel that delves into the dark world of online radicalization and manipulation. Centred on a teenage boy who becomes entangled in a mysterious alternate reality game, the story offers a compelling look at how easily young people can be drawn into dangerous ideologies under the guise of entertainment and belonging. I like this book because Palmer’s writing is sharp and empathetic, balancing suspense with thoughtful character development. It’s a powerful, thought-provoking read that raises important questions about digital influence and identity in the modern world. My favourite part was when the boys begin to question the true purpose of the game he's involved in. This moment of realization, where the excitement of the game turns into a chilling awareness of manipulation, is powerful.

Meghna
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Luke Palmer’s novel is emotionally gripping and depicts realistic circumstances that teenage boys experience in this modern world. He explores ideas of toxic masculinity, sexual assault, drug use and county lines; all essential topics to be explored given that many young men currently face them. Through changing first person perspective, the reader has the opportunity to fully understand and explore the feelings of the characters. Emotive and engaging language also enables the reader to fully connect with the characters and the challenging experiences they were facing; this was particularly beneficial as I am not part of this demographic but could still empathise with their situations. I admit that it was initially challenging ‘to get into’ and reading it felt more of a chore at first, than a joy, however after a couple of chapters, I was hooked and I found the novel a quick, easy, albeit powerful and emotional read. Be prepared, the ending is definitely a tearjerker and you’re left with thoughts of an existential nature and the endless possibilities that life can bring. The book would appeal to anyone in Year 9 or above, however you may want to give it a miss if you are currently dealing with unresolved trauma as some of the content may be difficult to read. Additionally, I feel this would be useful to parents of, or those working with teenage boys if they want to gain an insight into the complex minds of them and understand the possible reasonings behind some of their decisions.

Florence
HHS

I loved the different points of views of the four boys because it sort of helps us to know how certain things are to them as individuals I would definitely recommend this book to my friends mostly because of the way its written. I think it is beautifully written. My favourite character was Johnny, he was always a good friend, he was supportive and happy no matter what was happening amongst his friends I was sad about Johnny but there was still something beautiful about the way the scene was written. Poetic

Chukwufumnanya
The SBSJs

This might be a good book. However, I do not like this book since it does not fit the type of story I find interesting.

Kaleb
Readerraptors

This book review is about Play by Luke Palmer. Multi layered and gripping. The book follows four boys friendships we see their lives play out right in front of our eyes. From building dens in woods in their youth to navigating tough challenges in later life trying to find themselves and trying to do what's right but sometimes making mistakes. There are strong themes of boyhood, male friendship and modern day masculinity. The author shows you how each of them deal with any pressure they face and coping with what's happening around them. The author goes into detail of the real meaning of friendships. For me personally I could not put down this book and out of all the Carnegie books 2025 I think this is the most addictive, compelling and best book.

Hugo
Bookwizards

I found Play by Luke Palmer quite disappointing. The story was difficult to follow, and the characters didn’t feel believable or relatable. It seemed like the book was trying to say something important, but the message got lost in the confusing plot and writing style. I was hoping for something more engaging and meaningful, but unfortunately, it wasn't my cup of tea. I rate this 1 out of 5

Eeshal
FOFF Girls

I liked this book but I found it quite confusing at the end and I didn't like some of the characters.

hasan i
Ermysted’s

‘Play’ is about four boys who grow up together, until they start to act differently and notice strange things happening to each other, then they play a game, which results in some bad news. When reading, I liked the fact that there were three different perspectives from the three different boys on how they view the world and each other. I also liked the different styles of writing. However, I think the novel may have benefitted from the use of pictures, to help visualize some of the key moments of the story better. Overall, I thought it was an amazing book and I liked it. **** (out of five stars).

Nadirah
Rockwood Reads

Great book, loved how each chapter was a different person and it started when they were young. It also highlighted the very bad aspects of drugs which I think was very important because of these things I give it a 8/10

Katherine Jurd
Herts and Essex

This book was very interesting but it made me feel a bit uncomfortable when the boys did idiotic things. I think the best part was the end because it shows what they have made with themselves after Johnny’s death RIP 🪦. The book shows that actions have consequences and I think that the character Mark felt it and probably feels guilty that he is responsible. I also feel sorry for the character Anna and I would really like to know what her parents felt after Johnny’s death. I don’t like the character Luc as he is selfish and only looks out for himself. This book is full of emotions and life and has a great message to the reader. I rate it 3.5/5 due to how it made me feel as a reader

Saanvi
Beauchamp Champs 2025

This was a very enjoyable book and whilst I was reading it I was hooked; the fast paced drama of it all made it a real page turner. However, the themes could be a bit repetitive and sometimes felt like the story was going nowhere. All in all I think it was beautifully constructed and was an amazing read.

Arnold
TBGS Readers

Play by Luke Palmer is a novel following the story of Matt, Mark, Luke and Johnny, four boys who have formed together to make an odd friend group, all itching to have fun and get up to mischief. While Matt gets imaginative, Luke pushes himself, and Johnny, with his wild imagination, gets up to who knows what; Mark starts to work for a friend of his brothers and begins to pocket money; however, after making a mistake, he starts to question whether he's doing the right thing even though he might already be in too deep. Although, in this book, there are a lot of rocky bits throughout the four boys' relationships and personal lives, and the theme of drug usage is exaggerated a bit dramatically, it is truly riveting, with themes of boyhood, male friendship, modern-day masculinity and the loss of innocence all beautifully intertwined. From looking at all four boys' perspectives in the book, you can see from each chapter the pressures they face and each of their individual takes on what's happening as things change over time and their dynamic becomes different than it was when they were younger. What is especially great about this book is that, even though Matt, Mark and Luke's friendships have their ups and downs, Johnny (whose mind is something no one will ever come to understand) is almost the glue holding them all together, and how Palmer has designed Johnny and all the characters for that fact to have such interesting and individualistic personalities is a marvel. Finally, although the book's ending is somewhat unexpected and shocking, it is a great read , with the winding story and use of language that is able to paint a picture in your mind so vivid it might as well be real.

Beatrice
Europa Champs

The book Play explores the importance of communication in young people’s relationships, the influence of drugs, and the pressures of different social expectations. It does a great job of showing the dangers of getting involved in drug trafficking, similar to Crossing the Line, which won last year’s Carnegie Shadowers’ Choice Medal for Writing. What I really liked about Play was the ending—it shows how life could have been completely different if the characters had made other choices, which is a theme in some of the other books on this year’s shortlist too. One thing that really struck me was the way time is used at the end—it genuinely surprised me. The ‘games’ the characters play also change over time, showing how people grow from childhood into their teenage years. The risks they’re willing to take to get what they want also change, which highlights some of the key themes in the book. However, I didn’t fully enjoy it because some parts made me feel uncomfortable. Still, it’s a powerful story and a good book for understanding the consequences of drugs.

Hayden
Rainbeau Readers

I didn't really like the book because it explores themes that I don't really appreciate such as drug-taking or sexual abuse. However, the book is beautifully written. Overall, the writing style is good but the topics are a bit harsh. If you are not into these topics please do not read. 3/10

Maxime
4Shadowers

Play is an interesting book because it talks us through 4 teenage boys who are best friends. They are dealing with a lot of problems mostly drug dealing and sexuality. I really enjoyed this book because it speaks about probems which are topical nowadays. Palmer employs a distinctive narrative technique by presenting the story through the alternating perspectives of the four teenagers.This approach provides readers with an intimate understanding of their thoughts and emotions. I highly reccomend this book because you can relate to some of the issues faced by the characters who are the same age as me.

Bathgate jules HG
4Shadowers

I have mixed feeling about 'Play' by Luke Palmer. As a long time participant in the Carnegie Wards, and even longer as a Librarian and English teacher, I have seen many of the elements of this novel before in other books. Last year Tia Fisher's wonderful 'Crossing the Line' revealed the dangers of 'county lines' and I found myself being reminded of that book which was quote rightly voted as winner of the readers' choice awards. That book was superior to this. Oh, and the element of different narrative voices for each chapter. I have lost count of how many time I have seen this now. It's now nearly as common as writing in verse form. However, I think this was done far more effectively in 'The Light in Everything' from the 2023 awards where the different points of view are used most effectively when describing the same specific incidents in an entirely different way because of attitudes and preconceptions. So the narrative voice was more defined there. That book was superior to this. I do not wish to be wholly negative about this book as it does have some merit but I do not feel sympathetic to any of the characters amidst their misogyny and drug abuse depicted as entirely normal and regular rites - of - passage. I will say that I did really enjoy Luke Palmers' previous novel 'Grow'. That book was superior to this.

Mr Hyde
Marshland Readers

Overall , play wasn’t really my kind of book . I found a lot of the parts very confusing and the use of drugs was very heavy and almost took up all of the book . Descriptions of the book say it is mainly about friendship however , I didn’t really see a lot of that in the book . One good thing was that I think that Luc’s part was well written and engaging . Overall I would give this book a 3/5

Holly H
VISTA Academy

I liked the way the characters were written and how the story was told from different points of view. I didn't like how long it took to get into one of the characters main plot. I would recommend.

Reka
Pittville School

Aurelia
Europa Champs

Play is a book about 4 teenage boys who grow up together and after a while of playing together they start to hang around the wrong kind of people. Luc loves rugby but his dad keeps pushing him to his limit. Johnny's just a bit crazy really, he loves to build dens that are designed to collapse and then collapses them. Matt realises he's gay and that he is in love with Mark. Mark's older brother knows a drug dealer known as the Guy. Before long Mark is a drug dealer too, doing jobs for the Guy. They have wild parties with their friends from school (which involve lots of drugs). Bearing in mind none of these boys are over 18, this book really highlights the dangers of young people being left alone regularly. For example, Johnny's parents are nice people but they go on holiday without him so he found other ways to entertain himself, even though they were illegal. Even though it pays very well, Mark wants to stop selling drugs but the guy won't let him showing that it's not completely the child's fault and that they need support from trust-worthy adults I really loved this book because it raises awareness of important issues though at the same time it's an interesting and engaging story. I would be interested to know if it was deliberate that the characters had the same name as the four gospel writers in the bible.

Tristan
Europa Champs

I found the book 'Play' to be one of my favourite books. It had some unexpected twists, which made the book even more fun to read. When Johnny died, it was so unexpected. For example, in Treacle Town, I kind of expected Trig to die, but not Johnny. The author described the characters really well and I found the book to be very enjoyable. 9.5/10

William B
Ermysted’s

I found this book really interesting . I love how it provides different viewpoints as it shows that there are multiple sides of the story. Each character has their own way of speaking which is represented by the font and what language they use and I like how some of the words they use and their personalities change along the way. The story lines are amazing in this book. We can slowly see how just doing favours for a friend can escalate into serious things like drug dealing. Which is important because it helps the younger generation know what they could be getting themselves into.

Phoebe C
Herts and Essex

I really enjoyed this book, the beginning hooks you in by describing the setting but doesn't give any information away about the plot of the book so it allows you to imagine what you think the book is going to be about. I like how throughout the book it changes between each of the characters perspectives so you can see what's going on through their eyes. The book felt very authentic, I feel like people could relate to some of the characters, and the language they use is very modern day and uses slang so you can understand the characters better. All of the characters are very different and have different personalities which gives the reader an idea of the different types of people and their experiences. The book was very engaging and made me feel like I was part of the story the writer captured the struggles that teenagers may experience really well. Overall I rate this book a 10/10

Cece
MSJ Shadowers

I think the book is a very good book as it goes deep into characters thoughts and feelings. It tokes a while to get started. It was more enjoyable than I thought it would be. It was very realistic and made you think and understand different types of people.

Tallulah
MSJ Shadowers

"Play" is a heart-wrenching novel with authentic and strong friendships. I enjoyed watching the boys' relationships grow and evolve alongside them. The story explores grief and loss in an impactful way. The characters' bonds are deep and meaningful, making this an emotional read. While some parts tackled mature themes, overall, it was a really good, engaging, thought-provoking and heart-breaking book (especially at the end).

Lily
TPS Carnegie Collective

Play is a fantastic book about four boys- Mark, Luc, Matt and Johnny- growing up together playing games and having fun. My favourite character was Johnny because even from the start he always seemed happy and cheerful. At the start, I found this book a bit confusing because it was told by more than 2 people but when I got used to it, it was an amazing book to read, and I couldn’t put it down. The end really surprised me, and I wasn’t expecting what had come next to happen next. Overall, I liked this novel and would recommend it for people who like reading about friendship and adventure. I would rate it an 8/10.

Annabelle
The Fitzharrys Shadows

This book is a gripping exploration of masculinity, friendship, and the harsh realities of growing up, making it a book that truly resonated with me. I wholeheartedly recommend Play for its powerful themes and emotional depth—it’s a book that lingers in your mind long after the final page.

Farishta
KECHG Shadowers

'Play' by Luke Palmer is a brilliant book that gives points of view from four boys as they go through secondary school. I think it has an amazing story and once you start reading it you can’t put it down. It covers some difficult topics, but it is written in a good way. I love the adventurous side of the story and you can really relate to the characters as they are just like so many boys that age and you can laugh along with their games and jokes as if you are friends with all of them. All in all, I highly recommend this book to anyone.

Jonny
St George’s Dragon Readers

I really enjoyed this book because I could relate as a teenager towards the group, the ending was absolutely brilliant in my opinion capturing Johnny's voice perfectly. Although, yes, it was clearly written by a man and not a young boy, I found it really interesting how the author conveyed the main character's narrative - no spoilers - but like ‘’Come up” and “Green” to describe things ever present in the teenager's lives. At first it was hard to get into, but as soon as I did I was hooked until very end. Overall, a great read and my favourite Carnegie book this year.

Cecile
St George’s Dragon Readers

'Play' by Luke Palmer is an amazing book that follows the story of four boys through their journey through school. The book was so captivating as we get to see how the story progresses through each person's perspective and their own personal and unique struggles. It also explores peer pressure and how each try to fit in into the group. There are so much going on and I absolutely love the way the book is written!

Cynthia
RGS Junior Book Club

A brilliant book that evokes thoughts of childhood, outlining how easy it is to fall into the world of drug dealing and how you need to be careful about who you associate with.

Ben
St George’s Dragon Readers

I thought this book was really good, it has been the first Carnegie book I have read this year with a consistent, engaging story. 5/5

Lucian
Ermysted’s

I thoroughly enjoyed Play, I found it addictive, and disturbing both at the same time. The plot followed four friends through their time at school. The book also has an intersting structure in that, it is told from each boys perspective. But in a way that is easy to follow because it is a different font for each boy. I found myself relating to many of the character's in many ways. I found it relatable and a very true depiction of growing up and growing apart as a young person. It has earned five stars!

Alice
Diary of a Wally Kid

I struggled with the start of this book and might have given up if I hadn't been reading it as part of this. There was something about the group activities that I found bewildering. There is a chance that this is because I'm an adult or is it my gender? I think it is unlikely to be the latter as I was a 'tom boy'. However getting beyond that and into the book I became engrossed in the way that being dragged into the drug world could be seen as a 'game' and develop from what had gone before. Having had conversations with students recently about how they think they are too savvy to be groomed I think it is a book that should be read widely. The following repercussions appear too common in life. I liked the variation in narrators changing the viewpoint of how the story develops. There were quite a lot of other life experiences thrown in and I'm not sure they didn't get drowned out. I wanted to know more about some of the women in the background but that was probably an intention that their stories/experiences were secondary. Better than I thought it would be.

Sarah
THS Shadowing

Play was a great book. I can clearly see why Luke Palmer and this book were nominated for this award, pulling on themes of struggling to fit in in a changing world . Each of the characters try to in different ways: Luc - through toxic masculinity, Mark - through drug dealing, Johnny trying to earn respect from his friends by doing outrageous things, and Matt also wanting to fit in with his friends but still pursue his academic interests. I would say that the ending was the best part, containing - and I won't spoil it too much - a look forward to all of the character's lives and how they continue on after the story ends. Lets just say it doesn't end well for all of them. 9/10 would read again! (It even rhymes)

Rory
KES Bookworms

Play is a book that follows the lives of 4 young boys through parts of secondary school and lots of things happen. These include romances, ruined friendships and lots of sadness. The plot twist at the end was very strange, and very sad. Overall, I would give this book a 9/10.

Estlin
Ermysted’s

Play was such an interesting book with incredibly interesting characters, and I enjoyed reading each characters perspectives as they each had such different/ unique struggles and stories to illustrate. The ending was unlike many other books I've read and it definitely did not disappoint!

Maryam
LPGS Readers

Play is a gripping and poignant novel which explores themes of growing up, peer pressure, and the struggles of adolescence. It is very thought provoking and insightful as to the lives of four teenage boys from a point of view which leads the reader to connect and empathise with the characters on an emotional level. Overall, this is an excellent book.

Ruqayya
KECHG Shadowers

Play was a very hard hitting and compelling read, evoking many emotions throughout the story. It is not my favourite but was still a great book. There were a few stand out parts of Play that really carried it; my favourite being the switching of character for each new chapter. This helped me to connect with each of the boys and provided a variety of viewpoints instead of just one which made the book all the more interesting. The other good part was just the characters in general because I found they were solid and contradicted each other well to create a smoother flowing story. I felt that the main message behind this book about the dangers of drug dealing was very sharply conveyed in a very direct manner. The downside was the plot being slightly dragged out as I thought it took a little too long to get to the very shocking end which I was not at all expecting. I liked the ending because it was dramatic and was left open only describing a little of what happened to the remaining boys afterwards which left it mostly open to interpretation. Overall, it was a very direct and powerful book with great characters and a clear message as well as a climatic ending. Score: Plot:6/10 Characters:10/10 Setting:5/10 Originality:5/10 Total:26/40

Sevan
Ermysted’s

This is an amazing book with a great ending (I am not going to give a spoiler though - read it for yourself). I thought that Matt was the best character until the end when it suddenly changed to the "quietest" character (again no spoiler) . A definite winner in my book. I would not change it in any way.

Franklin
The High Storrs Shadows

This literally sent chills through my body when I read it! The story of each of the boys’ lives and backstory was very interesting, including how different they are from each other. The wording was incredible, too! It was pretty hard to get into, though, and (in my opinion) a little slow. The ending left me feeling refreshed, and thinking about how the others’ lives must have gone. There’s a lot of lessons you could learn from this book. Would recommend! 8/10

Vanya
TPS Carnegie Collective

"Play" by Luke Palmer is a captivating exploration of creativity and the human experience. Palmer's writing is both engaging and thought-provoking, seamlessly blending humour with profound insights. The characters are well-developed and relatable, drawing readers into their journeys and challenges. The narrative flows effortlessly, making it difficult to put the book down. Palmer's unique perspective on the importance of play in our lives serves as a refreshing reminder to embrace joy. Overall, "Play" is a delightful read that inspires and entertains me, making it a great read for anyone looking to reconnect with their playful sides.

Harrison
TPS Carnegie Collective

Overall,I thoroughly enjoyed the book despite the topics being slightly more aimed at older children. I believe the message in this book is important and hence everyone should one day get to read this,if not something similar. Furthermore,I particularly enjoyed the cyclical structure and the way and emotional connection was built with the character as it really impacted the strength of the resolution. I will however admit that I am reather uncertain as to why the male characters are named after males in the bible and there isn't a section in the story or and authors note that explains the decision,even tho they seem to play a big role in the story line.

Candice
Bogle’s Book Worms

Play is a good book and I felt that the characters were real and that I could connect with them. I liked how it had dual narrative as it means you can see it from different people's point of view. I also liked how each character had a different font as it helped you to remember who was who, and so you could see that each character is different and yet just as important. The last chapter confused me a bit, but I liked how the book ended with the same line it started with. Altogether I would rate it an 8/10 because I liked the creativity and the story. I would recommend it to 10-14 year olds.

Amelia M
Skipton Shadows

I personally did not like this book. I did not like the drugs, the implied sex, the violence, etc. The writing style is good but the topics are a bit harsh. If you are not into these topics please do not read. 4 out of 10

Aurelia
Europa Champs

Play by Luke Palmer is a book about teenage boys and how they deal with friendship and the temptation of danger. It follows four best friends — Mark, Johnny, Luc and Matt — who are all struggling with different personal issues. Whether it's the pressure to fit in, problems at home, or figuring out their own identity, the story shows how growing up affects everyone in different ways. One of the characters even gets involved in a county lines drug operation, which shows how easy it can be to get caught up in dangerous situations. I found it really interesting how the author managed to cover so many different challenges teenagers face. He does a great job of showing the struggles young people go through, especially when it comes to friendships and identity. I also liked how the group has a different game they play as they get older — I think it's a clever way to show how they are growing up, while still reminding us of the innocence they're slowly leaving behind.

Elizabeth
Rainbeau Readers

Play is a interesting book by luke palmer set in 4 teenage boy's neighborhood. The style of narration is semi omniscient as we get to see from the point of view of each character apart from one. This causes us to have a bond with each character and not just one protagonist. It also causes a sense of mystery as we wonder what is the fourth boy doing. Play is about boy's who venture into the dangerous world of dealing drugs. We watch Mark start dealing drugs, something he consideres a game but then we see him realinzing the consequences of even the slightest mistake which causes him to want to stop but the problem is he is already beyond saving.We can see this when Mark is kidnapped in a van where his abductors threaten him, claiming this is his last chance; this was most definitely traumatic for Mark and it caused me to worry for him. Luke Palmer is trying to warn us of the consequences of taking and dealing drugs and the difficulties teenagers may experience. I personally was uncomfortable at some points but overall it was an interesting read that has a clear message.

MuzzammilHG
4Shadowers

This book follows 4 boys' struggles through school, hardship and addiction all under the guise of a "game". I feel that this book encapsulates the modern life of teenage boys and the pressures of society and friends. I thoroughly enjoyed this book from start to finish. It's tone and pacing made the storytelling of the book enjoyable as well as who in which chapter was speaking, which allowed the story to flow freely. However, the chapters' layout is confusing at first but each boy is written in their own unique font which makes it easier to tell who is who. Another thing is the multiple time skips at the start that confused, so I didn't know which year group they we in until halfway through the book. 10/10

Katherine
KES Bookworms

I really enjoyed this book. I just didn’t like how much swearing there was. I like how it is told from different perspectives from four different people and they describe a situation differently, but I didn’t see Johnny’s perspective a lot but when I did, it was really interesting. There is a really shocking plot twist at the end and it really shook up the story as the boys had to learn how to cope with it. I think this is a really great submission for the award but I am not entirely sure whether it should win.

Genevieve
Beauchamp Champs 2025

In a village in the south of England, four boys grow up together, thinking of new games to play - some of them more dangerous than others. Matt is great at art, with supportive parents, but struggles with his sexuality; Luc is a brilliant athlete, but his father pushes him too hard; Johnny is neglected by his parents; and Mark’s older brother introduces him into someone who starts pushing him into drug dealing. The boys themselves also take drugs - they talk about this quite matter-of-factly, which is a bit unsettling. One thing that was intresting in this book was how the boys were all seeing what was happening differently - so something that was really important - even life-changing - for one of them would be completely insignificant for another - mentioned, but irrelevant. I would give this book 7 out of 10 as it was really interesting (I think people over 12 should read it, because it talks about some important things, like homophobia and toxic masculinity) but I made quite slow progress as it was very slow-paced at times - it wasn’t really unputdownable.

Zosia
Europa Champs

This is a really beautiful book that examines the influence of drugs and societal toxic masculinity on 4 boys' lives, with the repetition of seeing life as a 'game'. Whilst it starts quite light-heartedly, as the novel progresses it shows how fast peoples lives can change for the worse and how peoples' personality and whole mentality is truly down to nurture, not nature. For one of the characters in particular, it also shows the reasons some young people begin to deal drugs, and how difficult it is to escape. The detailed internal monologues of each character are really crucial to the book too, as they feel unable to share any of their struggles with each other due to a culture of toxic masculinity. Overall, I would definitely recommend as I really enjoyed.

Eve
St Kaths

I loved reading Play by Luke Palmer, not only because it is wonderfully crafted, but because Luke Palmer explores many relevant ideas such as great friendships, art, the devastating results of drugs, climate change and more. We feel concerned for the future as the challenges faced by the characters in Play are still relevant in our world. I think most stunning aspect of Play is the shocking reality and emotion of the book . Overall, I really enjoyed reading this book and would give it 8/10

Sophia
Bilbo Baggins’ Bookworms

I really enjoyed the book and I could not put it down! The author has a unique way of putting all the emotions felt throughout the story on paper. This book is about how four boys - Matt, Lucas, Mark and Johnny grow and become men, with different ideas of what 'being a man' is. This represents the different ways that 'masculinity' can be described. They also play games to get themselves through school and when Mark thinks he has found the best game, the other boys must save him. This book shows the dangers of drugs and ends in a heartbreaking but beautiful way. I recommend this book. I did not initially believe this book would capture my interest but it did>

Anya
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Play I found this book really interesting and engaging. I liked how the group of boys in this group were all friends but all very different from one another. I also found it clever how every other chapter was written in the viewpoint of one of the boys in the group because it felt like you were being told multiple stories at once. For the majority of the book you are being told the viewpoints of Luc, Matt and Mark but the fourth friend Johnny doesn't tell his story until the last several chapters. In the last few chapters Johnny is falling from a lamp post he climbed and he was high, as he is falling he imagines what the future will be like for his friends. When he's falling throughout the final pages of the book he sees an upside down pyramid and in each block of the pyramid he sees what the future will lead to for his friends, how it will work out for them and he sees them at his funeral too. This book isn't the sort of book I would usually read but I found it eye opening and educational. I give it 5/5 !

Rachel
TGS Book Group

Anya
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Play-review I really enjoyed this book because all the characters were so different with different skills and weaknesses but all loved to play their games. It represented what different personalities thought 'being a man' was with Lucas thinking it was about strength, Matt about imagination, Johnny about having fun and Mark is in his own world. This book ends in a really beautiful but heartbreaking way and the way the author manages to put so many emotions onto the pages is spectacular. It was written really well and describes growing up and the dangers of drugs like no other author. As well as this, the author shows the stories from each of the characters' points of view so each chapter is written with a different style. Overall, I loved this book!

Anya
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Although this book is not my cup of tea due to the topics it addresses, I commend the writer for successfully capturing the essence of 4 boys in one book. Written from 4 different points of view, Play shows the growth of Matt, Mark, Johnny and Luc as they go through high school, strengthening their friendship and inventing games. Living in an environment where underaged drinking and illegal drugs are the norm ,the four, especially Matt, find themselves in a difficult situation as Matt’s drug dealing gets out of hand and turns out to no longer be 'a simple game'. What I like about this book is that throughout, we only get the points of view of Mark, Matt and Luc as they navigate through personal affairs; Johnny’s is saved for the absolute end and told in an extremely unique way that connects the reader with the characters.

Aarna CI
4Shadowers

The story is about four boys playing games, scoring points against each other, but as the boys grow up, the games become more dangerous when Mark starts running errands for his older brother. What I liked about this book is the bits of poetry and the bits about family. The book made me laugh in places and was emotional in places. I honestly thought there were no bad bits in this book – it was fantastic. It had some really heart-breaking moments. Overall, I thought it was amazing and would give it five stars (out of five) *****

Subhan
Rockwood Reads

I loved the characters Matt and Mark who were really believable. I really liked how the story went, it was full of action and the boys interactions were incredible. The ending was sad but really credible.

Gracie
Flegg Heads

This book is about a group of friends travelling through life until mark starts doing a job for his older brother’s friend. In the end of this Johnny dies. Good book. Would recommend to older people

Pranav rajan
Ermysted’s

Play is a truthful, convincing novel that follows the friendship of four boys. It has short chapters and is easy to read which keeps the reader motivated. Each boy has their own complicated story and their own hard choices to make but the reader feels like they have been on the journey with them.

Sienna
Diary of a Wally Kid

This was a well written book by an author new to me. Overall, it exceeded the expectations I had at the start. It was a compelling read from start to finish. The ending was dark yet very understandable.

Joby
CSGS Page Turners 25

Overall I enjoyed this book and would recommend it. The characters story's were connected while still separate and distinct, though I did enjoy some more than others. The themes and topics in book are very important and are covered well. I did find the time jumps in the beginning quite confusing and the way the ending was written I found annoyingly vague and complicated. But it was still a great book and I can see why it was nominated.

Ellen
Diary of a Wally Kid

I really enjoyed the book, I think it uses the multiple perspectives very well and offers a good insight into the realities of growing up. I liked how each character was written and seeing how they view themselves compared to how others see them. Also, I do like how the story was able to balance being chaotic and eventful but also insightful on life. I would definitely recommend this book.

Kirsten
Winchmore School Carnegie Group 2024/25

This book had a great story line and a very descriptive element but it had lots of swearing involved and when they switched perspectives it was hard to keep track of who they were talking about. I would recommend this more for my older friends however I wouldn't recommend it for younger ones due to the language included. Thank you for letting me read this book.

Sarah
Chiswick Carnegie

When I picked up this book, I immediately knew that I was going to enjoy this book by looking at the illustration of the book cover. When I started to read the first page, I was hooked into it. Reading further into the book, I couldn't put it down. It showed the different perspectives of the characters in the book and the difficulties that they faced and meeting girls. I highly recommend this book!!

Casey
SPS Book Clubbers

To be honest I got a bit bored reading this. The early chapters that just went through their time in that school year, was repetitive and a little bland. I enjoyed the male friendships developing but even this felt unfinished. It was very true to life regarding Mark's deepening involvement in drug dealing- how he was lured in with it being a game and how the reader could see it for what it was but it took him until late in the book to realise. Didn't like his mum being aware of it and ignoring it as he had money for bread and milk. I did like the lack of prejudice regarding sexual orientation. An ok read about male friendships forming from early years but towards end felt all about one character and drugs.

Deborah
Ousedale Olney

I didn't find this book interesting.

hasan i
Ermysted’s

This book was the first book I ever read that had been written from a young school boys POV! The details were amazing and the story just added more flavour to the pot of amazing things I can say about this book I rate it 8/10

Dylan
Kingdown

I loved this novel so much! In a lot of books, the description in between the dialogue doesn't feel like it has much of meaning, but in Play everything felt significant - every moment was powerful. I thought it was so clever how each of the characters had their own distinctive narrative voices and personalities, because they each had their own vulnerabilities that were explored throughout the book. The writing style felt really natural and fluid - beautiful and raw at times, held-back and quieter at others - and the handling of themes such as toxic masculinity, drug misuse, friendship and love was done in a really emotive way. The last chapter sort of blew my mind. Overall, I really loved it and would recommend it to anyone looking to read something unlike anything else they'd read before.

Eva
Sutton Shadows

I think it is a good book to do with the dangers of being a teenager in secondary school. I liked the book because you do not really know what comes next until you read the next part of the book with interesting parts overall it is a very good book.

Arthur
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Play is an enjoyable, thought-provoking, and ultimately heart-breaking tale of four teenage boys: Mark, Matt, Luc, and Johnny. Luke Palmer manages to vividly encapture the struggles of young men in today's society, especially so in reference to toxic masculinity and drugs. I particularly appreciated the alternating viewpoint, as it managed to portray what each character was going through and the struggles they overcame. The book started when the boys were young, building dens and playing in the woods, Play took the reader on a journey from their childish innocence to the harsh realities of the world. I really liked this book and would definitely recommend it.

Bee
KES Bookworms

I think that 'Play' is an amazing book. The use of realistic dialogue, serious yet normal scenarios and the occasional comedy makes it enjoyable to read, and the characters are understandable, and even relatable, in some scenes. The subject that the book seems to follow is the serious issue of county lines and drug usage, and the many consequences it can lead to. This means that the book can become serious, with the usage of swearing making it clear that this book is covering a dark topic, and the ending, while tragic, is a grim reminder of the consequences of our actions. Overall, this is a must-read for those who are searching for a serious book, which 'Play' excels at.

Elliott
Saltash Sprightly Scholars

Play is the co-written story of four boys each struggling with problems they try to face alone as they also struggle with school, life and growing up. I found Play to have a compelling narrative as each boy shared his struggles and pain with only himself. I quite liked this book, but I found that some of the topics discussed were of a more mature nature than past and present Carnegie books. Overall, I would say that this book is an acquired taste, but I would read it again so if you like multiple person books then I highly recommend this one.

Emily
Larkmead

I thought that that this book was really interesting and nostalgic. It reminds me of my old primary school where i thought I knew my friends really well but it turns out that I didn't. This book had many ups and downs which i enjoyed, especially when we could see them change personally, but some parts were boring and needed improving. I would give it an 8/10 as I enjoyed the plot and overall gist.

An
Ermysted’s

I can't even find the words to begin to tell everyone how amazing this book is . So, before I start, I will tell you a little about it. This young adult fiction is about a friendship group of four boys in their final year at school,. Told in the point of view of three of them, we get to know each boy: Mark, Matt and Luc. And through them we also learn about Johnny. They are individuals with different backgrounds and personalities but there is simple acceptance of one another, just the way they are, which I thought was great. But then Mark starts running errands for this guy…what will happen? I recommend this book for anyone who is looking for a good read between the age of 11 - 17 ……and I give it ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Jemima
Sandroyd Bookivores

Play was an eye - opening book with male friendship at its center. The book is written in a very creative way, and I really liked how the characters and their games grew up throughout the book. The book focuses on four main perspectives which are the ones of four boys: Mark, Matt, Luc and Johnny. This feature then adds a unique dimension to the book. I felt that all the boys seemed to belong to stereotypes. Luc is the classic handsome boy, good at sport box whereas Matt is in the smart and focused box. Jonny is in the not present and drug - addicted bracket and Mark is in the pressured drug dealer bracket. However, I did feel that they all had one thing that was different from those stereotypes, and this then shaped the friendships that they have with each other. We see them change and evolve throughout the book and it all comes to a shocking conclusion when somebody takes it too far... The ending serves as a warning that some games turn dark. The ending is very well written as we find out the characters futures through a person's thoughts. I would recommend Play to anyone who enjoys books that have a lot of different perspectives.

Lucy
The Maynard School

Great book for teenage boys to understand life and growing up, shows how good friends can work together and get through life together

Ashley
MHHS Shadowers

This was a very adventurous book, exploring the do's and don'ts of childhood. Going from making friends and building dens, to selling drugs and meeting shady people

jack
Ermysted’s

Heartbreaking, heartwarming and hard-hitting, this book perfectly captures the lives of the main characters in the book. The characters are perfectly developed and extremely consistent all through the story, with the speech and actions perfectly mirroring their surroundings and personalities. I found it hard to understand the fact that more than one person was narrating, but the different fonts really helped with that and I quickly got used to it. Definitely worth a read, though some of the themes are very adult.

Immy
Skipton Shadows

Unnecessarily long and too much filler.

mahad.k
Ermysted’s

I didn't really enjoy this book as it wasn't very emotive and didn't have a particularly interesting storyline. The best part about it was it was educating us about the dangers of drugs in modern day society.

Ned
Bookwizards

Play is a gripping novel that explores the lives of four teenage boys as they navigate the challenges of growing up in a small town. The story delves into themes of friendship, identity and issues like drug use, toxic masculinity and the search for belonging. Each chapter offers a different character's perspective, providing a deep understanding of their individual struggles and choices. I loved how each character had different font writings, expressing their personalities and actions(e.g. bold or neat). I recommend Play to KS4 students who are interested in realistic stories which tackle complex social issues.

Yagmur
Fiction Addiction

An interesting and insightful story on the lives of four boys and what happens as they struggle and grow and the problems they face.

Plum
St Kaths

‘Play’ by Luke Palmer is a complicated yet pleasing book about the reality of growing up into manhood and how hard it can be. One of my favourite things about this book is that you get a huge impression of who Johnny (one of the four main characters) is without hearing from his point of view except from the very start and the end and the way he can’t pay attention in class but is extremely perceptive of all his friends and noticing things others didn’t. Although it was subtle, I also loved the way Luke changed fonts for each different character as it made it easier to remember whose perspective it was. Overall I love the realism of the book and I would give it a 8.5/10.

Violet
The John Mason Shadowers

Really interesting book and definitely had a huge influence on the way I view drugs and alcohol etc. I was constantly on the edge of my seat for each characters storyline.

Seren
Box Books

'Play' is about 4 boys who are each struggling with their own personal challenges. I found the way the author presented each of them in a slightly different way really fascinating and it was an interesting read but I found it difficult to relate to the characters. The last scene was confusing and dragged on for too long and overall it was quite depressing. I'm glad I read it as I like to try out different genres but it wasn't my cup of tea.

Evelyn
BCS Book Squad

This book is a fiction story with Mark, Luc, Matthew and Johnny as the main characters. This book was the kind that you cant stop reading and could spend hours on without realizing. It was a bit difficult at the start, with the four different perspectives, but got easier with the more you read it. This is a good book for teens for it involves Marks point of view on how he is being pulled into county lines without realizing. Overall a good quality book that I would read again.

Pola
The Fitzharrys Shadows

I think this is a really good book because it deals with mature themes and real-life issues that could affect anyone, like drug dealing, alcohol abuse, and how some people see masculinity. These topics make the book feel serious and powerful. It really connects with the reader by showing the characters' emotions and the reasons behind their actions, and it also helps us learn from what the characters go through.

Charlotte
Rainbeau Readers

I enjoyed all of the plot, and I think it had very good ideas, and the book was written very well so you could empathise with the characters. Even though I didn't particularly enjoy the writing style, I thought it suited the book very well. However, because of all of the separate plot lines, I think they all were tackled a bit mediocrely and I would've preferred all of them to be a bit fuller and fleshed out. Ignoring this I did enjoy the book and will be creating a more satisfying ending in my mind.

Madeleine
Bilbo Baggins’ Bookworms

This book really highlights the dangers of getting drawn into things that you know you aren't meant to do. The book was about drug use and the ending was very emotional. I really loved the character Johnny he was really innocent and he tried to do the right thing, I really connected with him. It was clever how the boys in the book normalised drug use but the writer made it clear it wasn't right. I loved this book because I really loved the character developments, it was a powerful read.

Eben
THS Shadowing

Play is about four boys who are close friends. The story switches between each of their perspectives, giving us a look into what’s going on in their individual lives. Luc pushes himself to the limit to win his father’s approval, Mark gets caught up in drug dealing and starts drifting away from his friends, Matt escapes into his imagination, and Johnny just wants to feel free. This is a very mature book that explores serious themes like drugs, love, masculinity, and alcohol abuse. Although the switching perspectives were a bit confusing at times, I still found the book really gripping and powerful. I would recommend it to readers aged 13 and over because of the mature content. It’s a thought-provoking story that shows how different people deal with pressure in their own ways.

Isabella
Rainbeau Readers

This is an incredible book. I love how relatable it is in the world we are a part of, drugs are a problem that need to be addressed and I love how the author approaches them in this book. The cyclical nature of the book creates a lovely ending and leaves you feeling satisfied and fully engaged. I could not put this down, It was just TOO good. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone interested, I also think this would be a good book to read in school as maybe a year 9 or 10 group read. This book, although very tragic, does outline quite a few key topics of discussion that most students are either passionate about or struggle to talk about.

Amelia
KECHG Shadowers

The split narrative between the friends meant you got to see the thoughts and feelings of every single character in depth and added a whole other layer to the ending. However, the book focused mainly on Mark which made it feel like Luc had no proper character development and Matt's narrative only really started at the very end of the book and was basically cut short.

Afrin
FGCS Carnegies 2025

‘Play’ is an excellent representation of teenage life, especially how easily young people can be pulled into risky behaviours like drug use and alcohol. I was shocked by how quickly characters like Mark were pulled into dangerous situations—something that feels all too real in today’s world. Luke Palmer’s wordplay stood out from the first page; his writing is emotional, and immersive. This book made me think about how “peer pressure” shapes who you are as a person. I’d highly recommend it to other readers looking for something raw and powerful. 9/10.

Sebastian
Ermysted’s

Miroslava
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Luke Palmer's 'Play' is about friendship and growing up, and how people change when they get older and have to make choices in life. It shows how hard it can be to figure out your place in the world and in your relationships. The ending, where a character talks about life after death, made me think a lot about my own life. However, the story has some mature content, like sex and drugs, that made me feel uncomfortable. Because of this, I think it's better for older readers. It's a powerful story, but it's also very intense.

Miroslava
Beauchamp Champs 2025

Play by Luke Palmer is a book that really resonated with me, as it dives into the ups and downs of adolescence in a way that's both relatable and emotional. The characters feel real, each dealing with their own struggles, which made it easy for me to connect with them on a personal level. The way the author captures the feeling of uncertainty and self-discovery during the teenage years really stood out to me. While some parts of the plot felt a little predictable, I found myself hooked by the fast-paced writing and the balance of humor with deeper, more serious moments. The book made me reflect on my own experiences growing up, and I think it would be a great read for anyone who enjoys stories about personal growth and overcoming life's challenges. Overall, Play is a meaningful and entertaining read that left a lasting impression on me.

Omar
Beauchamp Champs 2025

The Play is a fantastic book, featuring 4 protagonists, Johnny, Luc, Matt and Mark, who are best friends growing up each with their own unique perspectives during their adolescence. I particularly enjoyed the aspect of them having their own fonts, further capturing the essence of their distinctive ideas of masculinity. The book was really interesting and I would definitely recommend it.

Abihanoor
KECHG Shadowers

Play is a book about the challenges of growing up, and the stories that result. We journey with 4 friends, hearing each of their opinions about the events that are happening, in detail. In my opinion, the opening few chapters could be elaborated on, as they gloss over several years in a very short space of time. In addition to this, in this section, the visual description is quite underdone, meaning that readers may struggle to picture some of the scenes. In the middle of the book, many themes are carefully explored, which is a huge credit to the book, but it does fall into a repetitive cycle of silly decisions followed by consequences, which leads to quite a long read. The ending is superb, however, a beautiful sting in the tail, which successfully and concisely wraps up the preceding events extremely well. Overall: a book that is well written and structured, exploring a wide variety of difficult topics, but could be expanded in places. 8/10

Benjamin
TBGS Readers

Amelia
Nuneaton Academy Shadow Readers

Personally, this book isn’t like what I normally read. This made it exciting and different. Although it wasn’t my favourite book, I still enjoyed it and was able to escape into the world of Johnny, Mark, Matt and Luc. I enjoyed the different perspectives of each character and how references were made throughout the book to the start or something previously said. This made the plot believable and consistent; also making me want to continue reading. Additionally, ‘Play’ covers some darker topics that I don’t usually see in books, therefore creating awareness and understanding about these themes. The ending of the book was very deep and left me thinking about time and the different paths you take in life, it also nearly had me in tears because of what happened to Johnny. Overall, I found ‘Play’ to be enjoyable and was easily immersed into unfamiliar perspectives and experiences.

Betty
Skipton Shadows

This book is about four boys and how their friendship grows and changes over time. It explores important themes like friendship, masculinity, and loyalty. The short chapters help keep the story fast-paced and gripping, but the main message is never lost. It doesn’t shy away from serious issues and shows how the characters’ decisions have a big impact on their lives. I found it honest and intense, and it really made me think about how even small choices can affect not just you, but the people around you too.

ethan
Rainbeau Readers

Personally, I believe that this book tells the truth about how easy it is to take things to far and to ruin your lives. The book follows four boys who are starting year nine at school and are constantly in search of a new 'game'. When Mark gets involved with his brothers shady friend, he thinks that he's found the best game of all. As Mark grows apart from the others, he starts spending his money from selling drugs to everyone. As everyone starts taking more and more drugs from Mark, it all goes wrong for the foursome at a house party when Johnny dies. I think that the cover of the book fits the story as it shows a scene from the book that could be interpreted as Johnny's suicide or as them at the river.

Liam
Bookwizards

This book, personally, was not for me. it switches from different perspectives during the book.

Isabelle
OLSB Shadowers

Play was a really nice book, I enjoyed the multiple perspectives and the writing style.

Nancy
Wyedean School

An amazing book on masculinity told through multiple perspectives entirely different to each other, and an unexpected ending entirely. Thoroughly enjoyed.

Elsie
St Kaths

PLAY: This intriguing book is about the negatives of drugs on people. The book switches perspectives from 4 different friends: -Luc- who we see as a sporty sixth former pushing his body to the limit -Mark- a person who got himself tangled in the drug business -Matthew- a person who got himself addicted to drugs -Johnny- a helpful and vengeful friend who was heading for disaster. These boys had their lives spoiled by drugs and Johnny even died after consuming too much...

Aarnav
Bookwizards

8/10 - I thought the book was amazing with the characters diverse situations but their collective friendship with the main theme having fun and 'playing' together with the world wide shared experience of childhood friendship. Their collective childhood of growing up together was a very important part which I really enjoyed and the drug usage showing ideas of corruption of youth yet all the characters still choose to stay friends ignoring their lives to stay together and continue to have fun right until the end. The ending was indeed bittersweet but I felt that it sent a message to say how important it is to be aware of issues like drug use and county lines but also with personal development and overcoming internalised issues within yourself and despite each others flaws and disputes, remaining together through thick and thin was a vital and very important message sent to readers.

Jade
TGS Book Group

This is my favourite book so far. I really liked it because it switched round who was narrating the book. I would recommend this book to my siblings and friends if they asked for a good book. I liked how at the end of most chapters there was cliff-hangers, which made you want to keep reading to continue from their position.

James W-B
Ermysted’s

I really liked 'Play' because the first person point of view really let the story go into more depth with emotions and thoughts, while still continuing the story. I especially liked that the ending was fast but not rushed (and that it made me cry a little). I thought all the characters were really well developed, however, the start of the story seemed to have something happen, then jump forward in time, making it quite hard to follow (despite adding a believable backstory to their friendships). Overall, I give 'Play' a solid 9½ out of 10 because I really loved the story and the way it covered the core issues.

Arthur
Plumites

I really liked Play. At the start I wasn't really aware what exactly was going on, but as the story progressed I started to get a grip of what was happening. I also liked how there was a different font for every boy's perspective chapter which kind of displayed them as a person, however as Matt and Johnny's fonts were the same I couldn't really tell whose chapter it was; although from the characters and experiences and other things mentioned I could sort of tell. Speaking of Johnny, I really liked his quirky, impulsive demeanour and I wished he had more chapters instead of just the starting and ending one. Overall, a 8/10.

Holly
Chiswick Carnegie

This was an excellent read that really showed just how difficult it is for drug traffickers to stop trafficking drugs, among other things. It really allowed me to feel the character’s point of view, and it was an astounding book.

Zack
Crypt Bookworms

Hanzalah
Ermysted’s

'Play' is a terrifying, exhilarating, award-worthy book that shows the development of the lives of 4 young boys as they navigate through some of life's worst issues for teenagers: exams, home issues (abuse, neglect and absence of parents), drug-selling and addiction. As we follow their journey through the chapters showcasing each individual's thoughts and feelings, we get to see their thoughts and interests showing through more clearly, not just going with what 'the group' is saying. It was really interesting to see such diverse outcomes at the end of the book when they all started with the same opinions, and it was nice to learn that they all remained friends even into adulthood. I personally found this book more difficult to read as it dealt with trickier topics, however I still appreciated it being on the shortlist because these things need to be discussed more among younger and more vulnerable members of society.

Kristina
Brooke Weston Book Busters

I liked this book because it showed how much people change as they grow up. The book is about a group of boys who go to school together but begin to grow apart. One of them gets in with the wrong crowd while another becomes very good at rugby. The story is quite enlightening but has some older content so I would recommend this book for Year 8 or above.

Henry
SGS Eclipse

Play is a book about 4 different boys. The book shows how the pure and playful child is quickly changed to care about social status and wealth. while getting dragged into a hell consisting of drug dealing.

Ming
Ermysted’s

I so enjoyed this book. The four characters were well drawn and the issues they had to deal with were very 'real life' (sadly!). Their individual stories and the way they intersected over a number of years made for a sometimes complex plot, but very readable. As I got towards the end of the book, I was intrigued as to how it might finish, and I did not see the ending coming - it was a fabulous ending, different in tone from the rest of the book, but utterly compelling and overwhelmingly moving. My favourite so far...

Ros
Balla Bookworms

There's one thing which simply wows me. The story is written from every boys' perspective. This really makes you feel like you know these characters, letting you really immerse yourself in the story. I feel like the swears are a bit piled on, but a really solid storyline and plot. The ending kept me confused for ages! Highly recommend it.

Matthew
TBGS Readers

It's a good book. Mild swearing but overall very interesting. I love the ending of the book. I recommend reading it by yourself as it can get intense.

Sophia
BAS READING CHAMPIONS

Play by Luke Palmer was a thoroughly enjoyable read. Not only was the plot interesting and not overdramatic but the characters were also described thoughtfully and their backstories were really impactful. The 4 main characters, Matt, Mark, Luc and Johnny were completely different and allowed many different perspectives of the events that unfolded during the book and there was a real sense of friendship between them especially when there was tension. The plot was very engaging as well as sad as it dealt with difficult topics such as drugs and showed the complex emotions of the characters going through these times. I also thought that the journey from innocent childhood to a more mature understanding of the world was created beautifully. I think the most shocking part of the book was the end. It was very unexpected and had a different tone underlying it but for me it didn't impact the sincerity of the story or my love for it. A definite 10/10!

Jemimah
KES Bookworms

In my opinion, this book was quite good. The ending was a bit confusing but other than that I really like how the four boys grew and developed as they aged throughout their school years. I definitely rate this 13+ but I think it was a good book.

Naomi T
Herts and Essex

I thought this book was amazing! I would highly recommend it as it is an insight into the struggles that many young people face and the lack of help they are given. It has many emotional ups and downs, and had me completely hooked into the character's stories. Luke Palmer makes you feel like you know the characters and the emotions it draws out are intense and strong. I love how the story switches between three of the characters ( plus the twist in events at the end!) and you can see the journey the four characters face. This highlights problems in society that we need to face and shows how many young people find their way into the endless cycle and trap of drugs. It is a really powerful story which I definitely recommend! It also highlights the struggles of LGBTQ+ and the struggle young people face in showing their personality.

Ryan
SHS On The Same Page

I really enjoyed this book. I enjoyed the unique style of writing where it switches from character to character. I also like the end where we are able to see "Johnny's" perspective on the situation. Overall good book

Hasan
Desborough Reading & Biscuit Club

Play is a book highlighting the friendship between four boys: Johnny, Mark, Matt and Luc, following them throughout their path through secondary school, starting at year eight going all the way up to year eleven. It follows the boys separately from each chapter, taking up a different character every time, giving the reader insight into the feelings, emotions and motives of what they do. As you follow the book, you watch as things spiral out of control for the boys, having you on the edge of your seat and waiting to see what will happen to them, hoping they will be able to fix what they have done before it is too late. I liked this book very much because it had me on the edge of my seat, waiting to see what would happen next, keeping me guessing for what would happen to them, knowing inevitably that something would have to go wrong and that they would all get dragged down with each other. I liked how it was intricately written, letting you follow each boy's story; while also letting you follow the story as a whole, seeing from everybody's eyes as it happened before them. I don't have anything negative to say on the book, except how at the beginning I was confused on the different perspectives, getting to know the new characters, but other than that it was a brilliant read. Overall, I would recommend it to someone looking to follow an interweaving story, looking for a book with a dramatic ending.

Rowan
The Fitzharrys Shadows

I loved it but some parts just didn't feel real, and some parts made me cry.

Dora
Wyedean School

'Play' by Luke Palmer is an excellent interpretation of the mindsets of modern teenage boys growing up together and exploring the changes between being just innocent boys and what the real world is like. It perfectly handles challenging themes that many young people experience in the world and helps to convey these points of view to readers in a powerful, yet sensitive, way. I also like how the story goes through many years of these friends' lives and shows just how much they change in them. However, I also think that sometimes having four main characters with their own individual stories can make it quite challenging to remember what previously happened to them, as it flits a lot between each of them in chapters. I also think that sometimes the language and references to other mature themes is a bit too much. I also sometimes find it hard to connect with the characters, and I struggle to see their thoughts and opinions on certain matters discussed in the book, but I think that maybe other readers will be able to understand these characters further than me. But I find the story very interesting, and I do like how each of the four friends is able to express their thoughts and feelings in each of the chapters on certain matters that have taken place. The ending is also very creative, and it leaves the reader with lots of different ideas on what could've happened to each of the characters in the coming future, which is a very interesting thing to think and reflect on after finishing reading this book.

Tess
LGGS Shadow Questers

The book “Play” by Luke Palmer is a beautiful book written in different perspectives from the point of view of four very different boys. They strike an unusual friendship and try to help each other as their school life goes on. With many twists and turns along the way, they face different challenges and struggle with who they actually are rather than what is expected of them. The use of first person in this novel really brings the characters alive and all their views and opinions are brought through clearly to the reader. This book was gripping right till the very end and had amazing characters. They were believable, full of emotion and the interactions with each other were also great. The only thing that was slightly bad about the book was the ending. Although it was a clever move to have the plot twist at the end, the bit that came after was slightly unusual and definitely not a particularly credible ending. It was a nice touch but perhaps too much for the ending of the book.

Alice
Diary of a Wally Kid

It was really good, I loved the book, and I would recommend it to a friend.

Fay
BCS Book Squad

I thought the book play was undeniably amazing. I loved how the POVs alternated to each of the characters stream of consciousness. The ending surprised me more than I can express. I do think the middle of the book was hard to read as it was quite slow paced but overall I think it was a great book and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it.

Sophie
Marshland Readers

‘Play’ is a book about 4 teenage boys’ experience through secondary school. They play games, scoring points against each other but, eventually, these games turn into much more. I really like the poetic feel to it because although it wasn’t poetry, it was very rhythmic and had some repetitive elements. It personally wasn’t my favourite book because I struggled with some of the choices the main characters made. I also didn’t really enjoy the themes; drugs, toxic masculinity and sexuality. This is because they’re not really my style however if you’re into novels about teenage experiences- this is probably for you. It reminded me of some Josh Silver novels like ‘Happy Head’. I would recommend it for ages 13+.

Hannah
The Fitzharrys Shadows

Nice book. I liked the way the four main characters developed through the book. Some of it had quite a lot of things happening at once. The changing of perspective through the book was interesting because it was like four different stories connecting in one book. It also shows the pollution of the landscape and the effect of dealing drugs on someone's life. The ending was interesting and complex, and I enjoyed it. I would recommend this book to others.

Jakub B
Ermysted’s

It was a really good book that reflected the stories of several boys in a highly effective way. It reflects on real life issues: drugs and pollution. The words are used in such a way that I am able to picture everything in my head. I also like how each different perspective allows me to understand a different exciting point of view. Play should be chosen for the Carnegie award because it is an amazing book that excited me from the beginning right through to the end.

Iris
Crypt Bookworms

The thing that made this book exciting was that every chapter or every few chapters there would be a change in pov

Connor R
Ermysted’s

Play was a very interesting book. I felt the constant switching between different characters could often be confusing and remembering all the different side characters and their relationships was very difficult. However, the story was quite compelling and ,after I had gotten used to the structure, the book became a very enjoyable read. The characters seemed immensely convincing and had very complex motives that were conveyed by the writer very well. The ending of the book was.... unusual. It ended in a way that was unexpected yet helped tie up most of the plots as well as leaving the story "unfinished". Overall, an interesting read that was more complex in story and pacing than other Carnegie books.

benjaminr
Ermysted’s

I've always found the concept of masculinity (and gender as a whole) strange, with twisting, turning, confusing mazes that seem to be full of rules; utterly impossible to navigate. I really enjoy how this book tackles these issues, and that each character who 'plays' the game of life and has a result due to their own choices. The alternating POV's can be normally jarring to follow, but this book allowed them to flow well together and shows the thought and skill behind them being cohesive, especially in the final chapters! It clearly communicated the struggle the each boy was going through in their own way. Personally, I found the attitudes of the protagonists relatable and the transition from the lack of maturity to the facing of consequences is awe-inspiring and bitter sweet. I loved reading play! I give it 3.5 out of 5! My only critique is the dialogue does try to hard...

Connie
OAJW Golden Reader Club

The book was very effective in tackling the themes it wished to discuss, highlighting how and why characters acted as they did with the different perspectives being very recognisable from each other due to the unique tones of the characters which is often hard to accomplish with multiple POVs. The pacing and ambiguity in parts did make it quite confusing to follow even though it was an intentional writing decision to reflect the story so its definitely a book where the reader really has to focus to be able to fully understand the progression of the plot. The ending was equally beautifully written and strange, being completely different to the vibe of the rest of the book but made sense in the context. Overall 8.5/10 stars

Mariya
Sutton Shadows

This was a very interesting book that highlighted many issues facing us today, particularly those of some younger people. For example, its comments on toxic masculinity were sensitively well put. I also enjoyed the different perspectives throughout the book, as it allowed different opinions and situations to be heard, therefore avoiding one sidedness. However, I found the ending to be quite difficult and perhaps to end on a slightly more hopeful note would have enhanced the messages in the book.

Milly
The Maynard School

Play is a book about 4 different boys, namely Matt, Mark, Johnny and Luc. The book shows how innocence in childhood is quickly lost, and about how social status, wealth and all other categorising factors cannot stop the fatal impact of drug dealing, drug abuse and, possibly even fatalities. The story is written in 4 perspectives to shine a light on how different the lives of 4 individuals were. It is a great and moving read, and shows that life is not all that simple.

Tejas
Colchester Royal Grammar School

I would say this book can be likened to a key. For me, it opened a door that I never knew existed, revealing, simply, the many possibilities of life. All a person’s life experiences are just one path they could have chosen; this book lyrically and wittily explores the finer points of it. Each character within Play is unique, shaped by their families and life journeys, but the four also have much in common, making this story relatable and individual. Towards the finale, I have never read a deeper, purer description of Time itself, or even of life, but it truly moved me, and, I think, will resonate with me forevermore. Only a sage could have brought such wisdom to words.

Molly
PGS Library

Play – Luke Palmer The book is a little bit slow, and I struggled to read it, but it did have nice fleshed-out characters that I missed after reading. Unfortunately, the characters were one of the only good things about the book that I picked out as it was slightly boring. More easily persuaded readers could easily get the wrong ideas from this book as the more negative effects of one of the main boy’s actions are only portrayed as a bad decision in the last 10 pages. 4/10

Jake
KSA Book Wolves

A good book! I found it to be sometimes quite hard to read, as some of the events in the book were quite disturbing, but they were handled in a good way. I think the characters were interesting and had distinct personalities, making the writing from their respective viewpoints very interesting! The ending was amazing, ending on a more positive note yet still really getting the point across! Overall, I think Play was a powerful and well written book!

Edward L
Ermysted’s

This book was fun to read, and did an excellent job of exploring the lives of different boys, with different life experiences and social statuses, which contrasted their characteristics in the book. The book gives a good idea about the dangers of drug abuse and dangers associated with drugs. My only issue with the book is that the ending was quite cryptic and felt a bit jarring, not quite fitting in with the remainder of the book.

Manas
Colchester Royal Grammar School

A really good book exploring how devastating drugs are for children. Great read that made you always want to read on.

Finn
St Kaths

I loved this book as it took me out my comfort zone making me try new books. It was really enjoyable as I learnt about different peoples perspective, when usually it is only one person writing and how they develop as characters. It focuses on drugs, sexuality and friendships. I would rate this book 5 stars as the writing was nice and I couldn't put it down.

Isabella B
VISTA Academy

I only read the start and I stopped because it didn’t grip me and was a little confusing due to the perspectives which usually I can deal with in books

Emma
SHSCC_Readers!

It is very good and has a lot of meaning behind it while still being suitable for tweens or teens.

Ellie-mai
SHSCC_Readers!

'Play' by Luke Palmer was a book I did not expect to like but am glad I do. I really enjoyed the stories this book follows however, I was not a big fan of Mark. I found the writing style to be quite fun to read ; I also enjoyed how every protagonist got their at least one chapter from their point of view. My favourite bit was the beginning because of how all the characters were introduced. Overall I really enjoyed the book and I am sad it is finished.

Sophie
Fiction Addiction

The book was very scary at first. I liked it because Matt came out as gay and wasn't ashamed. But I felt very sorry for Matt as he was taking drugs and being threatened by his brother's mysterious friend who uses and exploits kids on social media.

Abigail
St Cath’s Shadowing

Very gritty and realistic to the life of a modern day male teenager. I would recommend reading.

Frederic
Brooke Weston Book Busters

I’d rate Play by Luke Palmer an 8/10. The plot was good and kept me interested, but the ending was a bit weird. One of the things I really liked was how the book switched between different characters' points of view—it made the story more dynamic and gave a deeper understanding of what was happening. Overall, it was an enjoyable read, even if the ending wasn’t what I expected.

Bassit
Ermysted’s

The actions of four boys spin a complex and chaotic web of consequence and effect. As Johnny calls them in his high final moments, this web opens the possibility of many 'rooms', many possible futures that are made by these crucial decisions in the teenage years of Mark, Matt, and Luc - yet Johnny severs any parts of the web leading to his 'rooms' with a drug-clouded decision of his own. While it may seem at the start like too much is going on, all these strands come together in the end for a big finish nobody expected less than me. Busy? Yes. Messy? Most likely. But in the end, it is a story about four boys growing up the hard way, pressured by the world and the decisions that they made, and the way their futures will be affected - a story indeed written messily, but still written very well.

Hanzalah A
Ermysted’s

This book touched my soul, it was a rollercoaster of emotions. I deeply connected with all the characters, they felt so real and now forever will have a special place in my heart.

Lyra
Pittville School

Play

Luke Palmer

Submit Review

Submit Artwork

Luke Palmer

Shadowers' reviews and artwork