The Final Year

This was a beautiful book to read, I saw my younger self in much of it, and the illustrations were so pretty. I enjoyed the fact it was in verse, and I think it really added to the story. I thought some plot points were slightly confusing and could've been expanded more, but all in all it was very realistically written and handled more sensitive subjects well.

Madeleine

Bilbo Baggins’ Bookworms

I loved how this book helps you relate to characters and how life can change at any moment. I think the main message is that everyone has a battle there fighting at to not judge a book by its cover as it may surprise you.

Jameela

THS Shadowing

I like the way that this book is written in poems but it is a bit hard to follow.

Ernest

TBGS Readers

It is such a heart warming book. I really loved reading it. I cried for Nate, and laughed for him. My favorite part was when Nat talks about hope for Dylan. It was such a beautiful moment. It actually brought tears to my eyes. My favorite character is obviously Nate. He is amazing and thought it is written in the book, We as readers can feel it. He is genuinely amazing and he has dealt with a lot and it makes me hate Turner! This book is so smart. I couldn't even put it down and I read it as soon as I got it. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Saanvi

Beauchamp Champs 2025

'The final year' follows a 10-year-old boy named Nate as he transitions into his final year of primary school. Nate balances taking care of his siblings, difficulty in his relationships and struggling to keep his own emotions at bay. When his brother, Dylan, is diagnosed with a rare heart condition, Nate finds it difficult not to spiral. I enjoyed reading this book, although I believe it is aimed more towards younger children preparing to switch schools. This book perfectly demonstrates the challenges a primary school student may face, from battling challenging emotions to preparing for the major life change of switching schools. The format of this book perfectly conveys the heartfelt message through poetry, making it an interesting read.

Betsy

Egglescliffe

The Final year is quite a heart warming book which captures the feelings and emotions of a boy named Nate who feels alone due to his circumstances and anger issues, until the people around him ensure him that he is not alone. It is also quite interesting as the book is written in poetry form, which makes it quite impactful to the readers.

Rida

KECHG Shadowers

Nate is having trouble settling down in year 6, because he is struggling to control himself (it's described as a beast within him) as he's in a different class with his best friend Parker Smith. PS is also starting to keep a distance from Nate while hanging out with the bully. Nate's family is struggling with money, and his dad left his mum when he was born. The story has emotional ups and downs, such as when Nate's little brother stopped breathing, and when PS and Nate were friends again. It is written as a poem, with some pictures. It had me crying some bits, and I really felt connected to the characters. The story is set in primary school and has content about SATs and moving to year 7 and this brought back memories as I also read Skellig in Year 6 as the class reading book! I also liked how Nate can express himself through writing poems and how his teacher encouraged him and even gifted him with a diary so he can write down something when inspiration comes! It also has an open ending, when Nate thought he saw his dad, who's always described as looking like Jesus, stepping out into the sunlight calling his name: really happy ending!!

Mila

Beauchamp Champs 2025

A moving and powerful free verse novel about a young boy Nate and the changes and challenges he faces, both at home and in school during the final year in Primary school. Dealing with themes about young carers, bullying, friendships, and family. It was great to see a strong male role model in Nate’s inspirational teacher Mr Joshua and I enjoyed seeing the support he provided Nate and how their relationship developed throughout the story. I loved the references to the book ‘Skellig’ by David Almond and ‘The Final Year’ is certain to become another classic. A must read for both children and adults, perfectly capturing the uncertain transition period many children face from primary to secondary school.

Mrs Mann

Brooke Weston Book Busters

Life for Nate is far from easy- he struggles with the thought of SATs, home life, taking responsibility for his little brothers when his mum is incapable of being a fully performing parent and friendships. There is one more thing though- the beast an emotion so strong that it can never be let out. But when disaster occurs just before Nate leave primary, will he be able to cope? This is an amazing read perfect for anyone who is in need of some reassurance that they are not alone.

Pixie

Book Squad

A brilliant book, I wasn't suspecting it to be in a poem format when I got it but the layout greatly compliments the storyline. The book explores a vary of subjects including illness, exams, friendships and poverty. I would recommend to anyone looking for something different to read.

Venusina

SUAS Shadows

I absolutely adored the final year book, as I already am a huge fan of poetry. The author brilliantly described a young boy’s journey to secondary school with beautifully crafted words in form of poetry. Loved it!

Aadhya

SUAS Shadows

I liked 'The Final Year' because it talks about mental issues and that you don't really know what people are going through and raises awareness for the people who struggle.

Acacia

Nuneaton Academy Shadow Readers

I found this book very interesting, The way the author made the book a poem was nice but sometimes hard to understand at the start but the further you read, the easier it gets. It is a hard and a sad story to read. I liked that it had real life problems and wasn't a happy story throughout the whole book. The author took his time to describe the characters feeling's - each character was given a distinct personality. I found it lovely that the book was narrated as if a diary except as a poem. One character stood out to me and that was Nates wee brother also known as "spideyman". I liked this character as no matter what happened he was able to have fun and find the bright side of things. For a young boy he was quite mature but yet playful. I would definitely read this book again.

Anna

Rebel Readers

I found ‘The Final Year’ an amazing book because I loved the poem verses. I found them really easy to understand and read. The story is about a boy called Nate and his transition into year six . My favourite character was definitely Mr Joshua (Nate’s Teacher) Because he is always smiling, laughing or singing songs. I don't think they needed to add when Nate's younger brother had a heart attack but It definitely was a plot twist that had me grabbing onto the edge of my seat. To truly get the most of this book you have to read ‘Skellig’ by David Almond because the understanding of Skellig makes the book more meaningful and you appreciate the links between them.

Philippa

The John Mason Shadowers

An amazing verse novel. We are introduced to Nate or more accurately Nate introduces himself and his family, single mum and his two brothers: Jaxon who is 2 years younger and Dylan the 'baby' at 4, all 3 boys have different absent fathers. Straightaway we learn that Mum was only 17 when she had Nate and is now 27 and trying to hold things together. Nate is navigating Year 6 with its challenges of changing friendships, school residential trip then the SATS plus his own chaotic home life. In the middle of this Dylan collapses and is diagnosed with a heart condition that then requires surgery. Despite his young age Nate keeps the family together but struggles with his emotions. His teacher Mr Joshua proves to be a great support. We get to the last day of Y6 for Nate and the possibility of seeing his father. Looking forward to the next book!

Mrs. P

Cake a Book Club

I was already a big fan of verse novels but didnt know how much i loved it until reading this book! After going through the final year myself, i can really relate to this book - it made me laugh and cry! i could not put it down and think every year 6 class should read "The Final Year" at some point. 10/10 loved it!

Ava

Book Squad

"The Final Year" is a captivating book with surprises, joy, sadness and most of all a strong message that shows that life will work out. The book drew me in even before I had read the first page, with one look at the poem shaped paragraph I knew that I would enjoy the unique way that the book was written. The novel is about starting a new year and the bumps and obstacles of friendships and family. The book was very calming but also made me excited and determined to find out what happens next. To conclude "The Final Year" is a phenomenal book and a great way to spend your time.

Xanthe

Bilbo Baggins’ Bookworms

I think this book really shows the struggle that people go through with anxiety and how to help control it. It also deals with friendship problems exceedingly realistic and allows people connect with the characters as well as showing how having a family member in hospital affects people at a young age. The books also deals with family issues and the pain and relief of getting back a friend after losing them.

Jess

CSGS Page Turners 25

This book is about a boy called Nate. We experience his final year of school. He goes through many hardships. He loses his best friend to a boy called Turner and nearly loses his younger brother twice to heart problems. He feels he needs to release the anger which he calls the beast, but in the end he overcomes all the problems he faces and re unites with his best friend and brother. He also may have met his dad. Good book.

Pranav Rajan

Ermysted’s

The final year was a surprisingly good book, very interesting and sometimes sad. I loved how it was written and the reference to the Skellig in the front cover. I recommend.

Nancy

Wyedean School

The Final Year is a heartfelt verse novel that captures the emotions of a boy navigating his last year of primary school. The writing is raw and authentic, making the story feel real and relatable. It explores themes of change, loss, and resilience in a natural and honest way. While some parts are predictable and a few characters could be developed more, it’s still a moving and memorable read. I could really relate to the emotions and experiences in the book, which made it even more impactful. I rate this book 4 out of 5

Eeshal

FOFF Girls

My thoughts on The Final Year; I found the book very nice to read. I really enjoyed the book because I am in year 7 and not long ago I was in year 6 and found it hard to transition into a secondary school, also to do SATs plus leaving your friends is also very difficult. I enjoyed that it was a book that doesn’t have too many words on each page so then you can get a break in between because I know some people find it difficult and very tiring reading massive pages. One of my favourite parts of the book was when Dylan was in hospital and Mr Joshua was comforting Nate and making him feel happier even though he is having a hard time with his brother in hospital with his heart condition. One of the parts I felt was really sad was when Nate and his family didn’t know If Dylan was dead or alive. When I was reading that part of the book it gave me goosebumps; I was thinking what’s going to happen next and is Dylan ok. I recommend this book for year 5 or 6 because you could relate to the story of having a really hard time leaving your friends and much more. This is one of my favourite books I have ever read because its all about kindness and about people supporting one another.

A

Larkmead

I have very mixed opinions about this book. The Final Year did an excellent job at creating a gripping storyline and concept from a simple and relatable setting. However, I did not like the fact that the entire story was written in verse, as I believe some elements would have been better in standard prose writing. The book was also very short, and only took me 1 day to read, so in my opinion, using standard prose in some areas could have lengthened the book and elevated the plot further. Overall, I would recommend this book to some people, but not to those who prefer more structured and complex plot-themed books.

Manas

Colchester Royal Grammar School

A fabulous story about the life some people have in the city centre. I loved the style of the writing, it's a book written in verse. I loved how each page was an individual poem, it made me able to see inside the main character's head more easily and made me more emotionally attached to the main character Nate, and his siblings Dylan and Jax. I also really cared about his Mum and his Aunty San, I understood them more as the book went on and felt really sad about what they were going through. The book showed how hard it can be for some kids and how they have to care for their younger siblings because their parents can't. It showed how hard some friendships can be, I know how that feels. Whilst going through an important stage in life, moving to secondary school, catastrophe strikes and Nate's younger brother Dylan gets a heart disease, it showed me it must have been really hard doing your SATS but knowing your brother is in hospital. I think the connections between the siblings are extraordinary. I thought Mr Joshua was a great teacher, he helped Nate in the vital stages of year 6 and understood his circumstances and Nate's personanilty, he really believed in Nate - like any good teacher should. I liked how the book links with Skellig - I enjoyed it so much I read Skellig afterwards. This really is a great book, I highly recommend it. I would rate this book a 10 out of 10. I love this book so much I have read it three times now. It's good out loud too.

Edmund W

Ermysted’s

9.4/10 - I love the form of poetry and the characters making their own poetry in this book, it helps me to understand the characters well in the first few pages where I cannot put the book down, I want to know what happens next. However, I did at one point want to stop reading because of the sad element of the story but then I HAD to see what happened next and it gripped me straight back into the story. The element of school, growing up, friendships are all relatable as a Year 7 :)

Lucas (13)

OAJW Golden Reader Club

The Final Year described in one word that word is Amazing. I liked how the author described his anger and how it was written in a less formal way makes it feel more like it was written by Nate which is a great book in my eyes. The pictures also help in making the situation that is happening clearer to readers. The message of this book is a good message and one everyone needs to read - friendship is valuable to everyone, we shouldn't think of people in any negative ways simply because they are different to us. A great book aimed at the right people - all teenagers should read!

George

The WH shadowers

I don't usually like poetry but this read so easily. The variety of lengths and styles was an asset. I read it in one sitting. The book managed to include a lot of issues of the age group without feeling forced or heavy. The near death experience suggests being grateful for anything less than the worst. Even though they are child issues we face similar through life and the advice of 'every little thing will be alright' is a good philosophy. I was left pondering how the establishment helps people like Nate rise out of their beginnings. A really good read.

Sarah

THS Shadowing

I loved the book and would love for it to win. Its an emotional rollercoaster. Nate is a young boy just living his life when an unexpected thing happens. He must keep a brave face on and be ready for the biggest test of his life all while keeping the beast at bay.

Anastasia

OLSB Shadowers

This book was really good and I loved the bit at the end where he meets his biological dad. Though I found the way he speaks annoying.

noah

TGS Book Group

I really enjoyed the personal feel of the verse style, also I like how it follows Skellig. This is a good book that is, in some way, relatable to yourself. Unusual, but a good read. I would rate it an 8 out of 10

Dylan

TGS Book Group

The book is sometimes sad, sometimes with happy moments .Difficult times for the boy going to big schools. Overall, I recommend the book to anyone who is having difficult times.

Edgar

QEGS Books and Biscuits

I found the book ideal for KS2 readers. In terms of engagement, the allusions to Skellig were brilliant. The way that the text was written gave the book an authenticity that was refreshing.

Julie

OSSMAORATORS

This book was incredible. I loved the characters so much as they actually are quite realistic and I can relate to some of their characteristics. The storyline was really emotional. It had many ups and downs but they came out on top.

Jeevan

Ermysted’s

Hanzalah

Ermysted’s

'The Final Year' by Matt Goodfellow was definitely one of my favourite books on this year's shortlist. I enjoyed the unique style of this book as it was written in prose, and I also felt that the topics that were covered were very different to what is usually written about. The book depicts a young boy struggling with the transition between Year 5 and Year 6 as he deals with friendship troubles, issues at home, and his personal anger issues, all of which collide with each other at the news of his little brother's heart failure. I do not think that the struggles of younger children are depicted often enough, so I thoroughly enjoyed this free-verse novel and would definitely recommend.

Kristina

Brooke Weston Book Busters

"The Final Year" by Matt Goodfellow is a heartwarming book about a boy transitioning into Year 6, where he goes through friendship issues and family problems. The book is written in a poetic form which I thought I wouldn't like but I quite enjoyed it as poetry can be used as a form of expression. It is a lovely story that helped me understand mental health, personal growth and change. I liked how Mr Joshua was with Nate from the start and stayed by his side. This helped the story develop as Mr Joshua supported him as well as his friends. I can't think of anything to criticise about this amazing book. It brings up issues that some people face everyday. I recommend this book.

zainab

Marshland Readers

'The Final Year' is a book about a ten-year-old boy named Nate who lives with his mum and two younger brothers, Jax and Dylan, who think he's Spiderman. Nate also has a best friend called PS. When Nate returns to school in September, he finds himself for the first time, in a different class to PS. Nate feels devastated, especially when PS begins spending time with his rival, the school bully Turner. Yet, Nate's life takes another hit when his youngest brother is suddenly taken to the hospital due to a rare heart condition, making it even more challenging for Nate as he struggles with his feelings. What I really enjoyed about the book was about the structure, which was written in stanzas, which was really interesting and made it stand out from other books. However, I do not like the overuse of slangs, for some readers may find it difficult to enjoy the book. This should be a must-read for all Year 6!

Shahida

Book Squad

I really enjoyed this book. I love the humour of the book mixed with slightly more serious topics, I also liked how I could relate to the book in the aspect that it was the characters final year at school. I loved this book so much I read it all in one go in about 2hr 30min! 9/10

scarlett

The Fitzharrys Shadows

It was an interesting and unique read. I enjoyed some parts of it but I found that the pace was a bit too fast for me. However, it was a nice and easy read because of the poem format. I would recommend this book to 8-11 year olds.

Amelia M

Skipton Shadows

I really enjoyed The Final Year. I read it quite quickly. I loved the brothers' conversations, his teacher Mr Joshua and the illustrations were lovely too. It's a sweet read about family and difficulties with friendships and finishing primary school. I would love to read The First Year when that comes out.

Daisy

Wyedean School

The first thing to say about 'The Final Year' is a comment about its structure. It is a novel in verse form. In this case it is highly effective driving the story on giving it real pace and drive also really helping the narrative voice to emerge. Some reviews on the website are in raptures about this as a form. I first came across this in a modern novel in 'Weight of Water' from 2013. I have seen it countless times since then. It is by no means new and not always effective. Here it helps. You can't help feeling sorry for Nathan and the miserable existence described here of poverty and neglect. In the second half of the novel the family is thrown into crisis but the read up to that point is mostly uncomfortable as the way he is neglected and has to provide care for his siblings is very bleak. All these concerns nip away at him as the story goes on. There are some rays of sunshine in Nathan's life, such as his teacher but he is mostly surrounded by irresponsible and selfish adults.

Mr Hyde

Marshland Readers

The final year was an amazing book, that covered real topics. What happened to the brother was so unexpected and sad, but it all tied together in the end perfectly. The poems were very varied and the writing style flowed very well. The poems showcased a range of a emotions, that capture the final year of primary.

Hannah

Bogle’s Book Worms

it was a very good book loved the language it used and the twist it had with his brother having a heart attack but it being all okay.

ethan v

Ermysted’s

As someone who has never read a book in verses but loves first person point of view books this book was a wonder to read and made me love books in verses. The book was about a boy named Nate who has two younger brothers called Jax and Dylan who live with only their mum. Nate also has a best friend called PS, but as they move up to year six the final year of primary school and get put in different classes their friendship starts to change. But that's not the only thing that's changing in Nate's life, as many exciting, scary and even life threatening events unravel in his life, but how will it all end. I really enjoyed when they went on the residential and Nate and his new friend Caleb have the time of their lives doing all the activities. at first I wished there was more time spent on that subject but now I'm glad they did it the it is as you get to see more of the other events that take place in Nate's life. Something that I did find a little tricky whilst reading the book was all the slang used, but I do think it makes the story feel like it came from a young boy which I do like. I recommend this book to all year six classes and those who sometimes find it hard to find the light in sad and hard times.

Rose

Book Squad

I've read this book and It's an amazing book Based upon a boy leaving primary school And moving to his secondary school He has two brothers and a mother, he is called nate and in this book it tells how he moves on to his secondary school

Manasva

Bookwizards

The front cover of the book the final year could foreshadow the future events and emotions of moving to secondary school. Firstly the wings remind me of David Almond's book Skellig, as well as showcasing the freedom you get from the restrictions of a child to being treat more like an adult as you transition to secondary school. The football and the book could represent the struggle of balancing schoolwork between fun or relaxation. The 3 girls whispering in the background might show the worries of him not fitting in. The wide look/stare in the boys eyes can show the fear of moving to a new school. The one boy by the goal post could represent everyone will feel a bit nervous and lonely, maybe like they dont fit in. My one question still remaining is why is everyone running or out of the shadow and how come the boy is the only one in it? The cover seems to fit the book tittle very well I am definitely putting it on my reading list!

Amelie

Emmanuel Literati

I think this book was quite good. (I read the book before the shortlist was published). I liked the book because I think the "beast" in the book can show the abrupt change of emotions during a school transfer or other difficult moments in people's life. In addition, it shows Nate's transition from a boy to a young adult. However, the reason I didn't like it that much was that I would prefer a student of my age rather than a year 6 pupil. It could also be a bit more descriptive. 8/10

Maxime

4Shadowers

The Final Year This story takes place in the North of England during Nate's (the story's main protagonist) second-to-final year of primary school. One of the main themes in this book is resilience because it shows how Nate perceives through his struggles. This book also teaches children, or even adults, about managing friendships and family. This story is told in first person from Nate's point of view and my favourite style of the book was how the author had made anger seem like a monster and how he made emotions feel real. This book is a mix of action and drama. I think I relate to Caleb because he seems like a calm and gentle friend who is kind and caring, and he seems like the best character in the story. The main suspense (I hope this is not a spoiler) is Dylan (Nate's 4-year-old brother) being sent to the hospital because there is something wrong with his heart. But Mr Joshua helped Nate the most. I would recommend this book to a friend because I think this book is a real treasure to have. After all, it teaches many life lessons and it does make you reflect on your actions.

Rithvik

Bookwizards

I liked this book, as it was quite nice and easy to read due to how it was written like poetry. I also like how it shows how people express themselves in different ways because it lets people see that if maybe they're not so good at drawing then there are other ways to express yourself. One other thing that I enjoyed was how it showed the difference from Nate being at home to at school with him not having the best space at home where his mum struggles and drinks a lot of cider, but at school, Mr Joshua and other teachers are always looking out for him and showing how to express himself.

Robin

Ermysted’s

I thought the final year was a very good book. It isn’t something I would have chosen to read since I am not very into poetry and wasn’t sure how it would work, but after reading this it has changed my mind. It would probably suit slightly younger readers better but it was still a good book nonetheless. The main character Nate was very well described and the idea of the book being made up of his poems worked very well giving the reader a deeper insight to his emotions than a book written in a more standard format. I really liked Mr Joshua as a character. It was very easy to read too. This book is very unique and I would recommend it.

Elouise

GreatB00ks

This book is about a boy gets through a chaotic time at primary school-transitioning from y5 to y6. The Final Year is easy to read as it is set out in the style of a poem. I always wanted to turn the page because it was a real cliff-hanger. Nate (the main character) goes through a tough time with his best friend just leaving him and his brother nearly dying. This really inspires me to keep going no matter how hard life gets. Overall rating:7.5/10

Conor D

Ermysted’s

Its a good book but it is over too quickly the word are structured in a poem and because of that i think its too short to get most of the point through

Patrick H

Ermysted’s

The Final Year was an excellent insight into a completely different perspective of the world to my own. Nate our main character is ten years old and lives in the rougher side of town. He has two younger brothers and none of them live with their fathers but only live with their mother instead. Nate's mother struggles - and this is one of my favorite bits about Nate - he continually looks after his brothers and tries to help his mum. Nate also struggles with his anger and has found that writing poetry helps him to stay calm. At school, Nate is studying Skellig by David Almond and he really loves it as if he can relate to the main characters. Overall, I really enjoyed it but some parts were expected and there wasn't anything unusual in my opinion about the book.

Iona

Logs

This book is slow to get into as it has a very unique poetry style the throughout whole book showing the story. I think this book is very cool with the design ,the way the words are laid out on the page for different scenarios and emotions. This book shows the side of poverty, brotherhood and friendship, Its different to other books and is a good read.

Robson

Kingdown

Nate is 10 and even though he's had some really tough stuff to deal with, everything seems to be going ok - until his best mate gets put in a different class to him for year 6. And then things start going from bad to worse, at home and at school, and Nate has to draw on reserves he didn't know he had, and find help and support in new ways. I found this story profoundly moving - it's really all about love, friendship, dealing with adversity and the power of words. It's written in verse, which makes it a quick read, but which also powerfully represents Nate's voice and his struggles to express his feelings.

Katie

Carnegie@StBede’s

I thought this book was full of different emotions and packed with action.It contrasted feelings in life and was a great read.I would strongly recommend.

John

Fiction Addiction

The Final Year is about how a boy gets through his chaotic final year of primary school. I liked how the book was laid out as it was written like a poem. I had felt sympathy for Nate (the main character). As the book was in the style of a poem it was quick to read. I think that this book was a page turner and I was keen to find out what happened next. I think this book is slightly more for older readers as at some points it was a little emotional. I would give it 9/10.

Mason

The Fitzharrys Shadows

Five out of five stars! "The Final Year" is a captivating read that deserves all the praise. The character development is exceptional, drawing you into their lives and making the story incredibly relatable. The setting is vivid and well-crafted, adding another layer of depth to the narrative. What truly sets this book apart is its brevity. It manages to pack a powerful punch in a short amount of pages, without sacrificing any of the emotional resonance or compelling storyline. The moral compass of the story is clear and engaging, making it thought-provoking and memorable. It's a refreshing change from the often lengthy and sometimes meandering narratives we see so often, creating a truly unique and impactful reading experience. "The Final Year" is one of the best books I've read – highly recommended!

Shanelle

QEGS CARNEGIE BOOK CLUB

Writing an entire book in the format of a poem is a very unique idea. I found it quite hard to understand but I figured it out in the end. I don't really like that 'you' is replaced with 'ya', and the way of talking throughout. Though I have to say, it's rather good. Very interesting.

Matthew

TBGS Readers

The Final Year is an amazing book. It is a great poem book, I love how it talks about the challenges of moving into a new year group (year 6). I like how the author (Matt Goodfellow) adds some other tough experiences that Nate faces and I like how Nate's feelings are described. I give this a 9 out of 10 . I would recommend this book to people that are scared to move into year 6 (especially year 5) and beyond.

Aarav

Bispham Bookworms

I really liked the Final Year as it showed a lovely way of writing about year 6, with illustrations. Like many of the shortlist last year, it was written in poetry but it didn't necessarily have to be poems. It was nice to read about something different because nearly all Carnegie books are about Secondary school, so this made a nice change. Mr Joshua was a great character and seemed realistic while also being an amazing teacher. I will probably read the sequel when it comes out.

Aidan

Ermysted’s

5 stars. I loved the friendships, the poems and the disaster. The drama of the tragedy when they figure out that Dylan had Congenital Heart Defect (CHD).Tragic yet entertaining. The falling out between PS and Nate was very sad because it was relatable.

Amaya

Shhh…We’re Reading!

4.5 stars. Brilliant story-telling and love the poems! The thing I didn't get was that the title of the poem was part of the poem so it took me a while to notice. Other than that, it is really easy to empathise with the character and feel his struggles as the story progresses. Can’t wait for the sequel!

James

Shhh…We’re Reading!

Lionheart25

I really enjoyed this book but it was quit a sad story. I also enjoyed the poetry even though there were quite difficult to understand sometimes. I think this book would be suitable for people of 8+ as it contains relatable things from leaving primary school. I felt really worried when Dylan went to hospital and I also felt a deep level of sympathy for Nate as he loves Dylan so much. I would recommend for people about to leave primary or in year 5 or 4 as it will let them understand the different emotions leaving year 6 may bring. It's a difficult transition to secondary school and one so many of us can relate too which is why I think this is an excellent book.

George

The WH shadowers

The Final Year is a book that you can picture in your mind when reading it. Not only is it written in a satisfying way but you could form a story in your head when looking at a boy with wings on him. Also the story makes you know what life is like for kids in their Final Year of Primary School with a single Mum. I can't wait for The First Year to come out!

Precious A

Larkmead

I loved everything about this book! I loved the story! I loved the iullustrations! I loved the verse! AND it was very refreshing to read something that wasn't full of drugs, sex, swearing and violence!! Well deserving of it place in the shortlist! The friendship issues, feelings and thoughts of Nate is something most young people will recognise and be able to sympathise with. Every kid should be read this book! I am very much looking forward the its sequal! I rate this book 4.5 of of 5

Mrs Allsopp

FOFF Girls

The Final Year was a really good, yet sad story. The best page in my opinion is page 232, one half is a little poem for Nates little brother and the other is a picture of Nate looking at a pair of angel wings flying in the sky its really magical they are glowing. I gave this book a 10/10

summer

Rebel Readers

The book was very emotional and inspiring. The author uses great vocabulary to explain the way the character is feeling and it is very easy to understand. The topics covered in this book are suitable for readers 9+ as it covers what it is like to be in year 6 and the problems and frustrations it brings to a student. Its very relatable. The main character is called Nate and he is facing the challenges of being in his final year at primary school. The year is tough and the book shows us how he overcomes many challenges including: bullying at school, looking after his brothers and supporting his mum. Definitely a book I would recommend.

Rhiyan

The WH shadowers

i personally found the book difficult to read especially due to the poetry like format of it, I believe this could be rectified by adding certain chapters in a original book format to give context and provide some resemblance of a linear story. Although I did find the premise of the story quite compelling and could be developed into a insight into a young persons mind, the author had good intention but it takes a stubborn reader to finish that book.

edward

SHS On The Same Page

I found Nate's story in the last year to be very emotional. I related to Nate when his best friend left him and he felt alone and left behind as I have experienced that a lot in my life. I felt a personal level of connection to Nate in his fight against the Beast and his lonliness in school and the feeling of being lost in his situation. This level of connection I felt with Nate made the book seem more real as I worried for Nate and his family. Nate's little brother Dylan was one of my favorite characters as his sweet innocence at the begining of being a young boy with no real idea of what's going on around him, playing and having fun without a care in the world reminded me of my childhood before my nan was diagnosed with Cancer. Joyfull, carefree and young. This made his hospitalisation hit hard for me. Thank you for reading my review of The last year, in conclusion I loved it.

Abi

OSSMAORATORS

Personally, I thought this book was really well written, especially since I love books that are written in the stanza format. The main character I thought was really dynamic because despite being calm on the surface, he struggles with his 'Beast', on top of all the struggles that come with exams at the end of year six, as well as friendships and family life. Mr Joshua reminded me of my primary school teacher when I was in primary school, and Dylan was so wholesome.

Josie

OSSMAORATORS

I quite enjoyed this book, mainly due to the stanza format, as I have a passionate love for poetry. the story was really relatable according to the other members in my group, however I felt as though it was really wholesome, rather than relatable (just my personal experiences). I felt it was a little slow burning, but regardless it is a really nice, and easy read.

Layla

OSSMAORATORS

The plot and storyline of the book was not only relatable, but emotionally arousing and intriguing. The anticipatory flow of the plot also made the book more interesting and grabbed my attention as a reader too. The story and development of Dylan kept me on my toes, as well as waiting for the 'Beast' to arise in Dylan. Overall, Goodfellow truly captured the attention and sympathy of the reader and if I had the choice, I would read another novel that he has written.

Nicole

OSSMAORATORS

I liked this book as it was an easy read and easy to follow along with. However I think this book would be more suitable for a primary school setting.

lilly-paige

OSSMAORATORS

Very good! I really enjoyed it. The story was very enjoyable and the illustrations really added to it. The twist around the middle of the book really caught me off guard — I almost cried at one point! This is the first book I’ve read for the shadowing but I have a feeling that it’s not going to win. It’s not “out there” enough in my opinion. I would love for it to win but I don’t think it’s going to be the best one shortlisted.

Sofia

Wyedean School

The Final Year Review: Stars= 4.5 Review- I think that this book was amazing; it is written in a poetic style which really helps to emphasise the heartfelt meanings that it conveys. The author uses characters which can be very relatable to students worldwide and the language helps you to understand how they feel in their situation as if they were really there. I also liked the way that the main character (a ten-year-old boy named Nate) finds new friendships and explores old ones, but writes and explains them in his own way by writing in an accent. Overall, I would really recommend this book to anyone looking for a great read which contains many thoughtful themes.

Isabel

Crypt Bookworms

The Final Year is about a boy called Nate who is struggling with being in his final year of primary school and also has friendship issues. Nate copes with these changes by writing poems which is also shown as the book is written in verse. I liked this book because I thought it showed the worries and stress that some people feel when leaving primary school. However I didn't like how the book was written in verse because I found it confusing. Finally I would recommend this book to people who might have worries about secondary school because it is a relatable book.

Eloise

The Fitzharrys Shadows

I liked it because it was easy to read and not boring. It was also quite sad.

Amy S

Herts and Essex

The final year is an amazing book,I loved the way it was written (in poems but tells a story) and how you go through the ups and downs with all of the characters. 3 keywords I thought of were friendships,hardships and school. I think Mr Joshua understands Nate (the main character) the most. I think it would suit people in Year 5 and 6 and definitely if you're in Year 5 and worried about moving to Year 6 but that it will be ok 'cause every little thing gonna be all right ' My rating of the book would be 9.7/10.

Darcey

Bispham Bookworms

I loved this book. It really hit my heart as it reminded it as my personal experience. Loved it would definably read again.

Dora

Wyedean School

After being given a note book by his teacher he finds his passion for poetry. he finds he can show his emotion through poems. He feels in a good position until his Brother drops dead. But that's what he thinks. He is actually alive and has a really big heart condition. During this time he also had problems with his friends but in the end, they made up and everyone is happy. I think this books was better than I thought and I also really liked the way it is written, like ''the crossing'', in a poetry form. I guess writing in poetry form expresses your feelings and emotions a bit more, also emphasizing Nate's love for poetry after discovering that poetry is his thing and hobby.

Charlotte

Rainbeau Readers

In this book, I really like the way that every character progresses through their own story. Also I think that the way it is composed like a poem is excellent because instead of writing it like every other book it is written in the way Nate writes it. A great book some parts could have gone into a bit more detail 8/10

Conor

Rebel Readers

this book really brought me on a rollercoaster of emotions as Nates younger brother Dylan has a heart infection and his best mate PS has abandoned him for some one else. Nate has to try his hardest to keep the Beast inside from all of his swirling emotions. But can he keep it all in.........

Joshua R

Ermysted’s

In a Carnegie filled with prisons, gang violence, drugs and suicide, sometimes it's nice to have a book that sweats the small stuff. The book depicts Nate's rocky transition from a boy to a young man, and Goodfellow does it pretty well too. The poetical structure means the story hits hard enough to leave a mark, and while the language is undoubtedly low-level, in a way that helps to get a bit closer to Nate and his struggles. As Nate's friends, school, family, and his relationship with the Beast change - some for the better, some for the worse - he pours his feelings and his experiences into the book, so we may better understand his final year.

Hanzalah

Ermysted’s

This was a really good book. I really enjoyed reading it. This book was full of different emotions. This was my first long book I ever read but I really loved reading it. The most emotional part was when Natey's brother didn't wake up from his bed and had to go through an operation. At first I found it hard to get used to the word "Summat" which mean "something" from a 10 year old boy's language ,but it shows that it's the way different people write. Even though this was my first time doing Carnegies I really love this. This is one of my favourite book I've ever read. I would rate this a 10/10. I would definitely recommend this.

Hannah S

VISTA Academy

"The Final Year" is a book that I will never forget. I was surprised how much I enjoy this book, especially because this is the first novel in verse I've read. The story follows a boy called Nate, a year six student as he explores a new chapter of his life, and prepares for more yet to come. Nate's take on strong emotions really captured my attention. I love how he addresses his emotions as "The Beast", as sometimes it's hard to accept your own feelings, like anger and sadness. His teacher, Mr Joshua, couldn't have been a better teacher for Nate in his final year. Throughout the book, Mr Joshua helps Nate learn how to accept and control his feelings, and their bond only grows stronger. Another thing I loved about this book was the relationship dynamics between Nate and his two younger brothers. The pressure and maturity that is set on Nate at home isn't easy as the eldest child, but through dark times, or when he's struggling, he will still always find time to spend with his brothers and take care of them. I would recommend this book to all year six pupils, or anyone who wants to read a touching, heartfelt story. Matt Goodfellow really touched me with this novel; never in my life have two blank pages say so much. I would rate this book a 4.5 out of 5; I absolutely loved it.

Seren

Book Squad

It is an innovative book that has lots of ups and downs within. Part way through you think “did that really just happen “. It also shows how people have struggles in there life but they face them.

Evelyn

Edge of the Page

This book is a beautiful thing to read, the poetry is amazing. I love this book as it is relatable to many young people who are going into year 6 from year five so they feel like there not alone.

Iris

Edge of the Page

So interesting on how it all comes together it’s absolutely amazing I couldn’t put it down. Keep writing- Frankie

Frankie

Edge of the Page

I thought this was a really good book about the final year you have at primary school. There are a lot of ups and downs throughout the book and I absolutely love it! Matt Goodfellow did an extremely great job bringing Nate’s character to life and it really shows the struggle of the final year you have in primary school. As a whole I absolutely LOVE this book and would read it again anytime

Luna

Edge of the Page

The Final Year was full of different emotions - the saddest bit about it was when Nate's younger brother did not wake up and he had to have an operation . I LOVE THIS BOOK!!!

Mahek

QEGS CARNEGIE BOOK CLUB

The Final Year by Matt Goodfellow was not what I expected. Seeing as it is a book in verse, I expected it to be a bit boring- it was quite the opposite. If it was not for Carnegie, I would not have picked up this book -as I do not usually read this style of writing- and I am very glad that I did. The story is in the narrator (Nate's) point of view. Nate is a 10-year-old (at the start of the book), young carer who looks after his two younger brothers; Jaxon (8) and Dylan (4). With neither of their fathers, Nate is left to look after his siblings most nights. He has had problems with his anger in the past but has leant to control them. When Year 6 starts, he begins to drift away from his best friend PS. As the year progresses, things begin to get harder for Nate. I won’t spoil anymore. Overall, I would rate this book an 8/10 because its really interesting and draws you in, however it does start to go a little quickly towards the end. I would recommend this book to ages 8+ because I feel like anyone over 8 could really enjoy it.

Ananyaa

SHSK Shadowers

Wow. This book was an absolute emotional rollercoaster, and it really gave me a new outlook on life. Nathan (the protagonist) has to deal his new arising problems of growing up, friendship changes and trying to keep 'the beast' at bay, all while juggling the troubles with his two little brothers. The display of emotions and brotherhood are portrayed so well I could feel them through the page. I absolutely see this going in my top options. Reading this would benefit someone in a way not all books could do, i felt an emotional connection throughout and encountered a new perspective. An absolutely outstanding read.

Ellie

OLSB Shadowers

I would recommend this book to others because it covers very serious topic but it has a very unique writing style that makes the book flow and easier to follow. The storyline is also very interesting and makes you want to keep reading. I also really enjoyed finding out what happened to his brother.

Heidi

Bogle’s Book Worms

This book is a poigent exploration of adolescence filled with raw emotion and an unflinching look at the chasllenges that come with growing up. The protagonist, Nate, allows readers to connect with his vulnerabilities amnd the complexities of his emotional landscape. I rate this book 4.5 out of 5

Maryam

FOFF Girls

I think that this book is reaklly good. I really like the fact that he was introducing himself and his family at the start of the book. At the end, it is so so good! I rate this book 3.5 out of 5

Tasmeia

FOFF Girls

I absolutely loved this book! This book was one of my favourites from the start and I am so glad it got through to the shortlist. A perfect read for Yr6 Primary and I think it's one of those books to stay with the reader forever!

Librarian

QEGS CARNEGIE BOOK CLUB

I enjoyed this book, I like how it was about a boy's life but in the style of poem. It was sad how his brother was in hospital after having a heart disease.

Erin

SHS On The Same Page

This was a very enjoyable read, it was an interesting style of writing but it represented the chaos of year6 very well. It was very well-written and i would recommend it to everyone ages 9-13

Adaml

Ermysted’s

This was a really beautiful and varied book. The easy, flowing style that is vital in a verse novel was enhanced by the use of dialect that made the reader empathise with the characters. It also included some beautiful sections of the poems that the main character writes. Overall, I think this is a really good read for all ages, and I am glad to have had the opportunity to read this book that is able to be read by slightly younger readers.

Eve

St Kaths

The Final Year by Matt Goodfellow is a very good book, which I really enjoyed. This book is about a boy called Nate and he is in his final year of primary school. He gets put in a different class than his best friend Ps, and they grow apart. His younger brother Dylan takes a turn for the worst- he gets diagnosed with an heart condition. At the end of the book Ps and Nate become friends again and they have another friend Caleb and they are all ready to start high school together. I rate this book a 9.5/10.

Ailise

Rebel Readers

it was very good! the poems were very weird/different at first since I never read poetry but i got tuned into it quickly and just read it as a story. The book was very interesting and I was hooked from the first page.

willow

CGS CAKE Club

The Final Year is a brilliant verse novel about a boy called Nate who has started his final year of primary school. However, when Nate and Parker Smith (PS) get put in different classes they drift apart, and PS starts hanging out with Turner, who Nate dislikes. If that’s not bad enough that he’s no longer friends with PS, a disaster occurs to his little brother Dylan. My favourite character is Mr Joshua (Nate’s teacher) because he teaches Nate how to make notes and write poems and gives him a book to write his ideas in. He also helps Nate with all the problems he has. I found this book wonderful because it was written in first person, which meant you could feel the characters emotions. It was as if you were in the book experiencing everything the character was going through within story which felt real. Generally, I loved this book and would rate this book for the ages of 10-13 and an 8/10.

Annabelle

The Fitzharrys Shadows

The Final Year by Matt Goodfellow is an enthralling book about the relationship of Nate and his friends and family, which I could not put down! I found this book very entertaining and it was quite an easy read, and the theme was overall very appealing to me. At first I was a bit confused as to how it was written, but as I read on I enjoyed it more and more. I think that this book could be appreciated by all age categories and I would give this five stars!

Oiver

The Fitzharrys Shadows

The book, about a boy's last year at primary school with his brother being sent to hospital, has a mix between an original story plot and at the same time an interesting story plot. Matt Goddfellow really gripped the difficulty of the situation that he was in, with somewhat relatable characters, strong emotions and believable interactions. The book design was quite different; a mix between poetry and book seems enjoyable to read. A mix between fast-paced action and relaxing detail was pleasant, and the speech was nice. It was written in a Scottish accent, which was instantly noticeable, and though at first I found it confusing and dull, I was hooked.

Lettie

Diary of a Wally Kid

I loved The Final Year. I thought it was convincingly realistic and heart-warming. I can't wait to read The First Year when it comes out in May. As a teacher, the teacher character was everything a good teacher should be: supportive, consistent and kind. This could be the winner!

Lucy

Wyedean School

It was ok but I didn't really like the verse layout. Also, I couldn't really relate to the book that well.

Charlotte

Skipton Shadows

This book is very good. I could barely put it down. This book is for someone who would like a perspective inside someone's head who is not as lucky. This would probably appeal to someone who likes a bit of suspense and emotional and moving books. If you love these genres then this book is definitely for you. Get ready though because by the end you will be in tears.

Jenica

St Catherine’s Carnegies

I really enjoyed The Final Year. Although the verses were slightly hard to read, you get the hang of interpreting it! This book explores multiple themes like family troubles, bullying, new friends, mental health and moving schools.. perfect for children taking the steps into teenagerhood. We follow in the main character's - Nate - footsteps as he makes his journey through life, whilst battling with his inner thoughts and feelings.

Holly

Chiswick Carnegie

It is a book about the struggles and life of a boy in his final year of primary school. I kind of enjoyed this book as I found the way the writer wrote it was very immersive and let you really connect with the characters. However, personally, I am not a fan of slam poetry or the colloquial language used.

Lily

Chiswick Carnegie

The Final Year An interesting read which really gave light to what it is like for people who are less fortunate than most of us. I really loved it and it was super interesting. I met the author in primary school for another award and it was really fascinating to talk to him about how it reflects his childhood as well. The poems were really cool and personally, I'm not a fan of poems but a mix with a story changed my view. In the book, the protagonist, Nate, overcomes bullying, family issues and changing schools which can be hard for us all and on the way, makes new life long friends which he probably wouldn't have if he hadn't have been in the situation he was in which was not a good one. I give this book a 7/10.

Charlotte

Chiswick Carnegie

Being a student this book was perfect for me as sometimes I feel how Nate felt so knowing that he overcame his 'beast' it makes me feel not only very happy for him but really heart warming for me. Thank you so much to the team who let me read this book it helped me so much and will definitely recommend it to my friends and people like Nate.

Sarah

Chiswick Carnegie

This book has taught me a lot. For example, some people have problems but they just need to overcome them. Also, it must have been very hard for the main character to deal with problems at school and also the fact his brother is unwell. This is a great book. It is a great way to show how to deal with friend problems and home problems.

Suheyla

Chiswick Carnegie

I really liked The Final Year. I loved how it was very easy to read as it was a verse novel and how easy it was to get into the characters head as it was in first person. There was a lot of action some of which was good but some of it did make me cry... It was very emotional and I felt like I was there. The way the character Nate was portrayed in my opinion was brilliant as I could really feel his emotions and it was quite easy to follow his journey. It captured me and I felt like I could read it for hours.

Rose

Skipton Shadows

When I first picked up the book, I was slightly sceptical of how enjoyable I would find it because I knew it was written in verse. However, I am very, very glad that I started to read it - I was completely hooked by the end of the first couple of pages! The characters were very realistic and you felt that you were experiencing the highs and lows. At first, I found it difficult to get used to the style of the dialogue, but I got used to it quickly and it was used to enhance the themes and styles of the book. Although the themes weren't relatable to my life, I enjoyed reading about them - I think it helps with understanding what other people I know might be facing or might face in the future. I found it a heartwarming and gripping read and thoroughly recommend it! My favourite book so far!!

Immy

Skipton Shadows

This was a fascinating book that offered an extraordinary insight into the life of the main characters. It helped to show that despite how a person acts and looks, you never really know how they are feeling. It also showed me just how important it is to support your friends when they need help. I would definitely recommend this to another reader and really enjoyed it.

Zack

Crypt Bookworms

‘The Final Year’ is a book about Nate’s final year at primary school. It’s about his journey through friendships, new teachers and his big emotions. I really enjoyed the use of verse because it made it more open to interpretation by the reader and it made it feel really rhythmic. It made me cry in some places, but overall it was a really good book. It personally wasn’t my favourite because I don’t really like books based on real life, I prefer fictional novels. I would recommend it to younger readers, especially those around year 5 or 6 because that’s Nate’s age. I would rate it 6/10.

Hannah

The Fitzharrys Shadows

The final year is a beautiful story riddled with references,twists and shows the rough reality that some people have to face .10/10 i highly recommend this book.

William s

Ermysted’s

The final year was an interesting book that I usually wouldn't chose but ended up quite liking it. I would rate it 6/10

Amelie white

PGHS Shadowers

Are you in your final year of primary school or love poems? If so this book is for you. This books story is told by using poems. This book is about a boy called Nate and his experiences in his final year (year six) such as friendships and poorly family members. He also has a brilliant teacher called Mr Joshua and he supports him the whole way. I would recommend this book to parents who have a child going through their final year of primary school or a child who loves poems. I would totally recommend it; it’s one of the best books I have ever read.

Milo

Larkmead

Such a great book, there was a lot of emotion however, was still relatable. It has everything! Friendship troubles, drama and heart-breaking moments. I also loved the poetry aspect and the promotion of ‘using your voice’. Personally, I think it is a great entry for The Carnegies.

Twalumba

County Shadows

It was a very captivating book. The writing itself was very easy to read and follow along. I really enjoyed it and would definitely read it again!

Emma

Fiction Addiction

Very Good book for change and that you can do anything very enjoyable and took a decent time to read through. very Good. makes you want to read it again. I can tell 100% effort Put in. Love this book.

Noah

The WH shadowers

It is one of the best books I have ever read. This book is about a boy called Nate and his experiences in his final year (year six) such as friendships and poorly family. I would recommend this book to parents who have a child going through their final of primary school or a child who loves poems. I would totally recommend it.

Milo

Larkmead

The final year is a really diverse and interesting book. I love how Nate has to not only face his problems in school, but also take care of his family and especially his brothers Jax and Dylan. The book explores the theme of problem solving and the love of family in a very friendly manner, and losing his best friend is a very big plot point. Overall a 4/5 book.

Jay

Isleworth & Syon

A heart-breaking and emotional read full of hope. It's a very needed story about sibling illness, and children in poverty. Even in the darkest parts of the book, a warm hope shines through.

Alice

Diary of a Wally Kid

The Final Year Was A very interesting book that showed a true experience of what it is like to go through Year 6 and that even though Year 6 is hard with SATS you can get through it. Overall, I enjoyed this book very much and would recommend to Year 5s and above.

Caleb

Colchester Royal Grammar School

This book was, first of all, my favourite so far, Even though it was my first book the first time I've done the Carnegie, it was a beautiful way of telling a story. At first I found it hard to get used to the "ya" 's but it shows that it's the way different people write. I thought at first it was a poem book but the it was written made me think otherwise. It really makes sure you paid attention at the end, as it tells us something that only people who read it would know, "a man who looked like Jesus" tells us that it was his dad as the mum stated that Nate's dad looked like Jesus. I also felt it really show that "Every little thing is gonna be alright" even when we are at our lowest. I would absolutely 100% read this magnificent book again.

Owen Roberts

Ermysted’s

I enjoyed The Final Year although it was aimed at a slightly younger audience than I am used to reading. I thought the verse form worked well for the character and plot. Nate was a great character who it was enjoyable to see grow throughout the novel and who I felt was a good role model - his resilience and ability to see the good in difficult situations, with the help of his teacher, was very inspiring.

Mrs Bean

CGS CAKE Club

I really enjoyed it! At first, the poetry/slang combination is a bit hard to understand, but I got used to it pretty fast, and it made the book nice to read. The dynamic between the brothers is really nice, and the main character's story is very engaging! If I had one criticism it would be that the issues aren't as present as other books, and the outburst towards the end could have had more build-up, but this didn't make the book any less enjoyable. I liked seeing his poems develop over time, and it would be nice to see more of them (perhaps in the next book). I really like the imagery, with the wings and the Beast, and the illustrations are beautiful! Overall I really enjoyed reading it!

Edward L

Ermysted’s

I honestly thought that I wouldn't like this book, as I don't like poetry. But it surprised me at how good it was. Would definitely read again!

Ria

St Kaths

I loved this book as it showed great perspective on moving up the years in primary school. My favourite part was the description of when nates brother had his emergency because the repetition was immensely powerful and descriptive. I really liked this book and would rate it a 10/10.

Cody W

Ermysted’s

I think that this book was excellent. You really bond with the characters, feel the raw emotions, and get a feel of what it is like to be in Nate's shoes. The story line is also really realistic and life-like and I love the way the author describes things from a 10-year-old's point of view e.g. 'The Beast'. An all- round success.

Wilf

St Kaths

This was an intriguing book that I enjoyed very much. I think I will read it again, but I would like to read 'Skellig' first, as it is referred to quite a lot. The formatting was quite strange and felt to be sometimes poetic but sometimes in the format of a poem but not poetic. This was quite an easy read and I would give it a rating of 7.5/10.

Edward M

Ermysted’s

The book 'The Final Year' was a decent book, in my opinion. The storyline was relatively basic and unoriginal. It is the kind of book that I wouldn't even consider picking up at a bookstore but I did find it quite interesting and relatable in some ways. Although, the use of the word 'ya' was extremely excessive! 5/10

William B

Ermysted’s

The Final Year was a book that I wouldn't normally pick up if I saw it in a book shop but when it came to reading it I found it quite interesting. I liked the format of the book as it was quick and engaging to read, although the fact that street language was used throughout the novel made it harder to read. and I would say that was the only down fall to it. The book explores the difficulties children go through, especially in Year 6 when it feels like there is a lot of pressure on you as its your 'Final Year' and when his youngest brother Dylan gets ill it becomes even harder. To summarise I really enjoyed the heartfelt themes this book explores and despite the fact it was a bit harder to read I would definitely recommend this book to children who are approaching Year 6 or are in the middle of it so they can understand what they might feel or that what they have felt was normal.

Isla

PGHS Shadowers

This book explores the difficulties of friendship and is relatable to some. This book was written in street language which I am not used to when reading a book, which made it a little harder to read. But overall it was a quick and easy book to read and I got more engaged in it as the book went on.

Amelia

PGHS Shadowers

I would recommend that a student would read it at the start of year 7 or end of year 6 so they can reflect on their time in primary and see if their school year was similar to Nate's. Overall I though it was a very good book, and I like the style it was written in. I think that if it wasn't written in this style that the book would not be as good.

James W-B

Ermysted’s

Nate is going to start year 6. Unfortunately, his best friend is in the over class with the school bully. Nates teacher is very nice and is called mister Joshua. He tells everyone that year 6 is nothing to worry about. When Nate gets home he always meets his two little brothers (Jax and Dylan). One day he sees his best friend with the school bully and then they both laugh at him. Nate is extremely angry about this but he then makes another new friend Caleb. Caleb likes to draw and Nate loves to write. But when things seem good his brother Dylan has an emergency.

Zakariya

Ermysted’s

The book was really good as it hooked you to the characters and you start to imagine their lives with every poem with their ups and downs. You also feel strongly to anything that happens to them and I love the fact that they made a point that everything was going to be alright and work out in the end which shows that there is always light at the end of the tunnel. My rating for this book is 10/10

Kai

Plumites

I found that it was a fun story. The writing style was new and exciting and the story was good. I could not stop reading it

Anton

Bacon and Eggs Literary Society

it was an excellent book that captured personality and emotion amazingly

Nate E

Ermysted’s

This was an interesting read that started a bit slow. However, near the end, it became engaging yet also quite sad. The style suited it beaautifully.

Livie

St Kaths

A very good book that was interesting and a bit emotional, the poetry was the good as well being a quick read

Leo A

Ermysted’s

I liked it the most when Nate writes poems about different people. The teacher (Mr Joshua) is a teacher that always helps him through life, for example, when he cheered him up even if his youngest brother was in hospital with his heart disease. I love the characters the most in this book because they show the life of actual people.

Michal.M

VISTA Academy

A heartwarming and heart wrenching book. The perfect balance between family, grief and friendship. Would 100% recommend this verse novel.

Eva

KECHG Shadowers

As a big fan of novels told in verse, I already knew I would enjoy it. What I didn't anticipate was that two blank pages would make me ugly cry! The story of Nate is filled with situations a lot of young people find themselves in, pretty much everyone will complete their last year of primary school so this book has a high recognition factor. The friendship issues is something most young people will recognise too. I particularly liked the descriptions of Nates home life and family. There is so much love there and the fact that Nate shoulder quite a lot of responsibility never feels like a hardship or something he resents. This book should be read by all Y6 classes!!

The Scary Librarian

The Scary Librarians Reading Group

I like the illustrations of the Beast and how he overcomes them. I enjoyed the poems and style of which it was written and how short a read it was. The subtle use of his mum being an alcoholic and bingo addict. I think the author perfectly summed up year 6 in the year 5 section of the book.

Alexandra

Norwich High School Bookworms

i found it a bit meh. majority of the book was filled with poetry that did not interest me

mahad.k

Ermysted’s

A poetic book about change, friendship and navigating the "final year" of primary school.

Plum

St Kaths

'The final year' by Matt Goodfellow was a book I was sure I wasn't going to like ; I was wrong. I love the writing style, illustrations and layout of the book: these factors overall made the book more enjoyable to read. I also liked Nate's story and how he overcomes all the challenges and obstacles that come his way, and what he gets as a result.

Sophie

Fiction Addiction

The Final Year was breathtaking in every way. It shows how the transition from primary school to high school can have a massive impact on millions of people with differing backgrounds and personalities, all over the world. My heart stopped when Dylan fell unconscious from his heart disease. Those two pages were probably some of the tensest pages I’ve ever read in my life. Overall, I am glad it was a happy ending and Nate managed to make another friend in the end.

Matthew B

Ermysted’s

A very sad book with lots of cliff hanging moments waiting to see what happens next.

Frederic

Brooke Weston Book Busters

I feel this book is written in an interesting way. It uses rhyming and slang language a lot. It shows how children can suffer from bullying and how friendships matter in life.

raffertyt

Ermysted’s

The Final Year by Matt Goodfellow Rating 10/10 I love this book it is one of the best books I have read The main character is in his last year of primary school and getting ready for his SATS He has a single mum and 2 brothers His mum is a drunk who spends all of her money on bingo That leaves him to look after his younger brothers He lost his only friend to the person who bullies him

Charlie

KSA Book Wolves

Incredible, this is one of those books where it makes you feel really connected with the characters because once you are in the middle of the book you get to know what they are like and feel like they are one of your best friends. I recommend this to anyone.

Eli S

Ermysted’s

The final year is a very moving and emotional book. It is easily my favourite book that I have ever read. The poetry it contains is very creative and fun. It is my favourite carnegie so far.

sethm

Ermysted’s

Good book about a schoolboy experiencing troubles like his best friend playing with someone he doesn't like and his brother getting heart infection, this book shows us that everything will be alright.

Muyang

Ermysted’s

Discovering the final year was as though I had been walking through my local library like a long street on a cold day, windows frosted. Until I wondered upon a brightened window among the darkness, clear in its view. Reading the final year was like looking through this window and in to the perspective of what many people in Britain today experience. It inspires a new sense of compassion and understanding in those who have many luxuries that most cannot afford. It bridges a gap in our minds, taking across new logical steps. The hopeful and relatable story of the final year humanises the people who most of the time are reduced to a percentage of those in the lower poverty brackets. Truly a wonderful experience.

Theo U

VISTA Academy

It was a very good book. I enjoyed the story telling through poems and i thought the pictures suited the style of story very well. i found it to be a very enjoyable read, although it was sad at times, the ending was very good. The only thing i didnt like was how he talked. Overall, 8/10

Elliott.H

Ermysted’s

An emotional roller-coaster with beautiful literature that i would recommend to anyone. My only criticism is that it takes a while to get into the good bit and the language takes a while to get use to.

Henry D

Ermysted’s

Overall I think it is a well written book and I like the rhyming style. The variation of characters is nice. The writer has tried to cram a lot of material into the book and this leads to it being a bit rushed . It also does not feel complete and could have used another chapter. Overall the storyline is engaging with a feel good ending.

Henry S

Ermysted’s

I think this book was absolutely mind blowing and amazing because it connected with the audience It also helped revive past memories I had in year six . I loved reading it and the suspense keeps the book nearly impossible to close without finishing.

Harshitha

Crypt Bookworms

The Final Year, Matt Goodfellow A poignant verse novel about class, identity and family. Genre: verse novel, fiction. Nate is a ten-year old boy who is in his last year of primary school. As he moves into the next year, him and his best friend are put into different classes. The story explores themes of friendship, social class, parent and child relationships and identity. I really enjoyed reading the book; I'm a fan of verse novels and this form linked well with Nate being a keen reader and poet himself. As a teacher I loved the small criticisms in this book about the UK's Y6 SATs exams and the references to David Almond and his famous novel, "Skellig", which I taught in my first year of teaching. I also enjoyed the working class setting of the story and how Nate felt so inspired by his teacher. It is interesting to read about a working class character living in a deprived area without the stereotypical nuclear family. When Nate's brother gets ill I also found it interesting to see how the theme of family was developed. I really recommend this book to everyone in the group as it might allow you to take a glimpse into a world you are unfamiliar with and I think you will warm to the character of Nate very quickly. 6/7 stars.

Laura

Carnegie Literary Circle

The Final Year, Matt Goodfellow A poignant verse novel about class, identity and family. Genre: verse novel, fiction. Nate is a ten-year old boy who is in his last year of primary school. As he moves into the next year, him and his best friend are put into different classes. The story explores themes of friendship, social class, parent and child relationships and identity. I really enjoyed reading the book; I'm a fan of verse novels and this form linked well with Nate being a keen reader and poet himself. As a teacher I loved the small criticisms in this book about the UK's Y6 SATs exams and the references to David Almond and his famous novel, "Skellig", which I taught in my first year of teaching. I also enjoyed the working class setting of the story and how Nate felt so inspired by his teacher. It is interesting to read about a working class character living in a deprived area without the stereotypical nuclear family. When Nate's brother gets ill I also found it interesting to see how the theme of family was developed. I really recommend this book to everyone in the group as it might allow you to take a glimpse into a world you are unfamiliar with and I think you will warm to the character of Nate very quickly. 6/7 stars.

Mrs Copley

Carnegie Literary Circle

The Final Year, Matt Goodfellow A poignant verse novel about class, identity and family. Genre: verse novel, fiction. Nate is a ten-year old boy who is in his last year of primary school. As he moves into the next year, him and his best friend are put into different classes. The story explores themes of friendship, social class, parent and child relationships and identity. I really enjoyed reading the book; I'm a fan of verse novels and this form linked well with Nate being a keen reader and poet himself. As a teacher I loved the small criticisms in this book about the UK's Y6 SATs exams and the references to David Almond and his famous novel, "Skellig", which I taught in my first year of teaching. I also enjoyed the working class setting of the story and how Nate felt so inspired by his teacher. It is interesting to read about a working class character living in a deprived area without the stereotypical nuclear family. When Nate's brother gets ill I also found it interesting to see how the theme of family was developed. I really recommend this book to everyone in the group as it might allow you to take a glimpse into a world you are unfamiliar with and I think you will warm to the character of Nate very quickly. 6/7 stars.

Mrs Copley

Carnegie Literary Circle

I’d probably rate The Final Year a 4/10. While it touches on important themes like family and friendship, I found the story slow and not very engaging. The free verse style didn’t really work for me, and I didn’t connect with Nate as a character. There wasn’t enough action or excitement to keep me interested, so overall, it just wasn’t my kind of book.

Bassit

Ermysted’s

This book is about a boy who doesn't want to go into year 6. After he figures out his best friend is in the other year 6 class he feels useless. He feels even worse when one morning he finds his friend walking to school with the school bully. After being given a note book by his teacher he finds his passion for poetry. he finds he can show his emotion through poems. He feels in a good position until his Brother drops dead. But that's what he thinks. He is actually alive and has a really big heart condition. He is really sad until he starts to get better. Over this period his friend notices how mean he has been and they are now friends again. At the end of the book his brother is well and he has his best friend back.

Billy C

Ermysted’s

This was a lovely book. I really liked it. The concept of the book was alright and it was fun to read. And it was readable. Though I wished they did not leave the book on a cliff-hanger, but overall it is a fantastic book, full of love and emotion.

Afreen

Skipton Shadows

Light-hearted and emotional. Really brings out the struggles some people go through.

Arlo

Crypt Bookworms

This is just a wonderful book which gave me a lump in my throat and ultimately a feeling of hope. Matt Goodfellow manages to capture what it is like when the carpet begins to move uncontrollably beneath your feet, how it can make you react and who might be there to pick you up when you fall. I loved Nate's mum and 'Auntie' San, even with all their flaws, as I felt they were highly relatable to many. The home may be chaotic but it is full of love and this story shows how family isn't always just your blood family. Nate has a best friend, Parker, who he has known since nursery, two brothers and an absent father. In the mix we also have Mr Joshua, a new year 6 teacher, who has taken the time to understand the children entering his classroom. I loved him just because he notices things, but there is so much more too. He plays guitar, he puts on Bob Marley, he writes poetry, the mums all blush and giggle when they see him and, most importantly, he only gets cross when he needs to. I also appreciated the brief appearance of librarian, Karen, who works in the public library where Nate spends a lot of his summer holiday. She, too, is a noticer. She encourages Nate to keep reading and so he spends much of his time in the school library (which is sadly but realistically without a librarian) and starts to enjoy poetry. All these positive interactions help Nate to control what he calls The Beast, the anger that he has worked so hard to control. I won't spoil the book by explaining what causes the beast to return but it is an emotional book which made me cry repeatedly and for many different reasons. Sometimes from sadness, other times from happiness and hope. Since reading this book I have recommended it to anyone who works with children, to parents who are transitioning children to a new school or class, and to children who struggle with anxiety - or not. I think it is a must read.

Donna

St Joseph’s Book Besties